XIII .
A Third Catalogue of the comparative Brightness of the Stars ; with an introductory Account of an Index to Mr. FLAMSTEED'S Observations of the fixed Stars contained in the second Volume of the Historia Coelestis .
To which are added , several useful Results derived from that Index .
By William Herschel , LL. D. F. RI S. Read May 18 , 1797 , IN my earliest reviews of the heavens , I was much surprised to find many of the stars of the British catalogue missing .
Taking it for granted that this catalogue was faultless , I supposed them to be lost .
The deviation of many stars from the magnitude assigned to them in that catalogue , for the same reason , I looked upon as changes in the lustre of the stars .
Soon after , however , I perceived that these conclusions had been premature , and wished it were possible to find some method that might serve to direct us from the stars in the British catalogue , to the original observations which have served as a foundation to it .
The labour and time required for making a proper index , withheld me continually from undertaking the construction of it : but when I began to put the method of comparative brightness in practice , with a view to form a general catalogue , Ifound the indispensable necessity of having this index recur so forcibly , that I recommended it to my Sister to undertake the arduous task .
At my request , and according to a plan which I laid down , she began the work about twenty months ago , and has lately finished it .
, The index has been made in the following manner .
Every observation upon the fixed stars contained in the second volume of the Historia Cwlestis was examined first , by casting up again all the numbers of the screws , in order to detect any error that might have been committed in reading off the zenith-distance by diagonal lines .
The result of the computation being then corrected by the quantity given at the head of the column , and refraction being allowed for , was next compared with the column of the correct zenith-distance as a check .
Every star was now computed by a known preceding or following star ; and its place according to the result of the computation laid down in the .
Atlas Cwlestis , by means of proportional compasses .
This was necessary , in order to ascertain the observed star : for the observations contain but little information on the subject ; most of the small stars being without names , letters , or descriptions The many errors in the names of the constellations affixed to the stars , and in the letters by which they are denoted , also demanded a more scrupulous attention so that only their relative situation , examined by calculation , could ascertain , what the stars really were which had been observed .
Every observed star being now ascertained , its number in the British catalogue was added in the margin at theend of the line of the observation ; and a book with all the constellations and number of the stars of the same catalogue , with large blank spaces to each of them , being provided , an entry of the page where FLAMSTEED'S observation is to be found , was made in its proper place .
If the star observed was not in the British catalogue , it was marked as such in the margin of the observations ; and being provided with another book of constellations and numbers , it was entered into the blank space belonging to some known preceding or following star , by which its place had been settled .
The Greek and English letters used by FLAMSTEED , whether they were such as had been introduced before , or which he thought it expedient to add to them at the time of observation , were also entered into their proper places ; and to complete the whole , the magnitude affixed to the stars was likewise joined to the entry made in the blank spaces of the index .
I have been so far particular in giving the method by which the index has been constructed that it may appear what con-s fidence ought to be given to the conclusions which will be , drawn from its report .
About three or four examples of its use , will : completely show how the results , which will be mentioned , have been obtained .
Suppose I wish to be informed of the particulars relating to the i3th Arietis .
Then by the index I am referred , in the column allotted for that star , to 77 observations ; and find that FLAMSTEED used the letter a 7 ' times , and that in two places he calls it a star of the 2d magnitude ; the rest of the observations being without any estimation of its brightness .
If it be required to know FLAMSTEED5s observations upon the 34th Tauri , which star is supposed to have been the Georgian planet , mistaken by FLAMSTEED for a small fixed star ; * we find in our index , that on page 86 , December 13 , 1690 , a star of the 6th magnitude was observed , which answers to the place of the 84th Tauri ` in the British catalogue ; and that no other observation of the same star occurs in the second volume .
In my catalogue of comparative brightness , the 34th Tauri is put down among the lost stars , it being no longer to be seen in the place where it was observed byFLAMSTEED .
If in my review of the heavens I cannot find 38 Leonis , and examine this index , I am , at once informed that FLAMSTEED never observed such a star ; and that of consequence it has been inserted in the British catalogue by some mistake or other .
In many cases , these mistakes may be easily traced , as has been shown with regard to this star in my second catalogue of comparative brightness .
See the note to 38 Leonis .
When we wish to examine go Ceti in the heavens , and cannot find it , we are informed by our index , that go Ceti is the same star with 1 Eridani ; and that , consequently we are not to look out for two different stars .
We may now proceed to give some general results that are to be obtained from an inspection of our index .
They are as follows .
IIX Stars inserted in the British catalogue have never been observed by FLAMSTEED .
This will explain why so many stars in the heavens seem to have been lost .
There are 89 stars in the same catalogue that want considerable corrections in right-ascension or polar-distance .
In many it amounts to several degrees .
+ stars more , besides them3 that are taken from the erroneous stars in the catalogue , want corrections in the Atlas Celestis ; several of them also of many degrees .
9 , stars are put down , which must be reduced to 2 ; each going by two names in different constellations .
i71 stars , completely observed both in right-ascension and zenith-distance , have been totally overlooked .
35 more , which have onleof the two , either right-ascension or polar-distance doubtful , have been omitted .
86 with only the polar-distance , and i3 with only the rightascension , have also been unnoticed , About 50 more that -are pointed out by pretty clear descriptions , are likewise neglected ; so that upon the whole between five and six hundred stars observed by FLAMSTEED , have been overlooked when the British catalogue was framed .
These additional stars will make a considerable catalogue , which is .
already drawn up and nearly finished by Miss HERSCHEL , who , is-int hopes that it may prove a valuable acquisition to astronomers .
Neither the index to FLAMSTEED 's observations , nor the catalogue of omitted stars , were finished when my former two catalogues of -comparativebrightness were given ; I shall therefore now select a , few notes to be added t6o those which are at the end of these catalogues .
They will contain such additional light as I have been enabled to gather from this newly aqui red assistance .
Additional Notes to the Stars in the First Catalogue of the : comparative Brightness of the Stars .
Aquarius .
25 Is the same star with 6 Pegasi .
There are but'two observations upon it .
The first is on page 5t ; FLAMSTEED calls it " in constellations Pegasi sub capite .
" The second , on page 71 , is described " in constellatione Aquarii trianguli in capite " lprxcedens et borealis."P Here we see that the double insertion in the catalogue is owing to the star 's having been called by different names in the observations .
See also Mr. WOLF .
LASTON'S catalogue , zone 88 ' . ?
7 Is the same with 1i Pegasis There are three observaq .
tions : the first places the star in the constellation of Pegasus , the two latter in that of Aquarius .
See also Mr. WOLLASTON'S catalogue for this star , and others of the same kind .
65 Has not been observed by FLAMSTEED ; notwithstanding which we find it inserted in my first catalogue , 'Where -its rela tive brightness is given .
It should be considered that , in the first place , several stars of which there are no observations in the second volume of FLAMSTEED'S works , and which are , net vertheless , inserted in the British:catalogue , such for instance as 0 and , Draconis , are well known to exist in the heavens .
Now whether they were put into the catalogue from observations that are not in the second volume , or taken from other catalogues , it so happens that observations of them cannot be found .
Therefore the want of a former observation by FLAMSTEED , is not sufficient to prove that a star doles not exist .
In the next place it should be recollected , that the method used to ascertain the stars in estimating their brightness , is not so accurate , as to point out with great precision the absolute situation of a star ; and that , consequently , another star which happens to be not far from the place where the catalogue points out the star we look for , may be taken for it ; especially when there are no neighbouring stars of : , theBritish catalogue that may induce us to exert uncommon attention in ascertaining the identity of such a star .
MAYER , however , has an observation of 65 Aquarii in his zodiacal catalogue , No. 932 which puts the existence of the star out of doubt .
72 As the star neither was observed by FLAMSTEED , nor does exist , we cannot admit the remark which Mr. WOLLASTON in his catalogue , zone g9 , has upon MAYER'S 939 star ; Where he supposes an error in declination of 3 degrees to have been committed , on a supposition of its being FLAMSTEED 's 72 .
8o Requires + 2 ' in time in RA , and therefore is not the star I have given , which requires i535".104 Which is without RA in the British catalogue , has three complete observations , page 8 , 70 , and 331 Aquila .
la9 Is without RA .
There is but one observation of FLAME STEED , page 53 , which has no time .
The RA is given by M. DE LA LAND , in Mr. BODE S Jahr-Buch for 1796 , page 163 .
3 and 34 Which do not exist , , were probably inserted by a mistake of one hour in the time of one of the observations on the two stars 68 and 69 .
In the zenith-distance , page 71 of FLAMSTEED'S observation of 69 Aquilax , for 530 read , o- .
40 and 43 Which do not exist , were probably also inserted by the same mistake of one hour in the RA of 70 and 71 .
Capricornus .
1 and 2 Should be ' , .
FLAMSTEED calls them so in his observations , and MAYER has also adopted the same letters in his catalogue , No. 821 and 822 .
-cygnus .
5 Is without RA in the British catalogue ; but the star has not been observed by FLAMSTEED .
9 Is without RA ; FLAMSTEED , however , has a complete observation of it , page 67 .
24 Has no RA .
The time observed by FLAMSTEED is only doubtful in the seconds .
Its RA has been given in Mr. BODE'S Jlhr-Bucl for 1797 , page 163 .
q Has no RA .
FLAMSTEED never observed this star ; but it is 3 Cephei Hevelii .
38 Has no RA in the British catalogue ; but as the defective and only observation of FLAMSTEED on page 75 , which might be supposed to -belong to 38 will agree better with 43 , it follows that he never observed 38 .
68 Has no RA .
There is a complete observation by FLAMTL STEED , page 75 .
78 Has no time in FLAMSTEED'S observations .
It is No. 146 in DE LA CAILLE'S catalogue .
7 , Has no RA .
FLAMSTEED has but one observation , which is without time .
Mr. BoDE gives it in his zfalr-Buch for 1797 , page 163 .
Hercules .
24 Is the same with are Serpentis .
28 Is the same with ii Ophiuchi .
54 There is no observation of this star .
The zenith-distance of 55 was taken twice April 8 , 17o3 ( instances of which we find in several other stars ) , which occasioned its being inserted as two stars , 6,3 There is no observation of this star , nor does it exist .
The star of which the brightness is given in my catalogue , is at some distance from the place assigned in the British catan logue .
FLAMSTEED observed a star , page , which will be No. 269 in Miss LHERSCHEL'S manuscript catalogue .
This , with an error in the calculation of the PD , probably occasioned the insertion of 63 .
And if this be the star , the PD of the British catalogue must be corrected + af .
71 Has never been observed by FLAMSTEED , nor does it exist .
A small error in the calculation of one of the four observations of 7o , may have produced it .
8o and 81 Were never observed .
The two stars v 24 and 25 Draconis , miscalled i in FLAMSTEED5s observations , page 55 and 1,75 , with an error of PD , accounts for the insertion of these stars .
See Mr. BODE'S Iahr-Buch for 1787 , ,page 194 .
93 The PD is marked : : ( doubtful ) , in the British catalogue but the observation of FLAMSTEED , page 520 , is complete .
Pegasus .
6-Is the same starwith 25 Aquarii .
11 Is the same star with 27 Aquarii .
Additional Notes to the Stars in the Second Catalogue of the comparative Brightness of the Stars .
Aries .
i There is an observation of a star by FLAMSTEED , which being calculated with an error of 1o ' of time in RA , would produce i Arietis ; we may therefore correct the British cataR r 2 logue RA + lo ' , and the star will be found to exist .
In Miss HERSCHEL'S manuscript catalogue it is No. 143 .
2 Is the same star with 107 Piscium .
38 is the same star with 88 Ceti .
In three observations , page 85 , 285 , and 485 , FLAM5TEED has called it Arietis ; and on page 481 he has called it Ceti .
See also Mr. BoDE'S .
ahrBuch for 1793 , page 200 .
so By FLAMSTEED'S observation , page 273 , the catalogue , requires -11 in time of RA .
C(assiopea .
3 The place in the catalogue by two observations of FLAMSTEED requires + 515 of time in RA , and + 7 ' of PD. 8 Is marked : : but has four complete observations on page 140 , 144 , 145 , and 1447. .
29 There is an observation of FLANMSTEED on page 144 which has produced this star , but the time of it requires a correction of + 6 ' ; and it will then belong to 32 .
That this correction should be used , will appear when we compare this observation with another on page 213 .
In1 both places a star , which is not inserted in the British catalogue , but which is No. 384 of Miss HERSCHEL'S manuscript catalogue , was taken at the same time .
On page 144 it is " d Duarum iinfra y , versus polum , borealis .
Simul fere .
transit , austrea ; " and on page 213 we have " post transitum .
" for the new star .
and " cum priore " for 32 ; and in both places the zenith-distance perfectly shows that they were the same stars : the 32cd and a star south of it .
And they are now , both in the places where FLAMSTEED has observed them , 30 FLAMSTEED has no observation of this star .
It is c 21 Cassiopeae Heveiji .
33 FLAMSTEED observed no RA of this star .
It is 0 23 Case slopead HeveiXi .
34 Is wrong in the catalogue .
By two observations of FLAMSTEED , page 144 and i,5 it requires a mean correction of9 of time " in RA .
In this case my double star III .
23 will no longer be p 34 Cassiopeae , but a star 9 ' of time preceding a ; for it exists in the place where 34 is put in Atlas , according to the erroneous catalogue , and is rather larger than FLAMSTEED'S star p.,35 The RA is marked : : The single observation , page 207 , has the time marked circiter , being probably set down to the nearest minute only ; and by the same observation the ' PD requires + 20o ' .
47 Is also marked : : but has one complete observation , page 149 .
ST The observation of FLAMSTEEi which produced this star should be corrected +1 hour .
This makes -it 37Cassiopeo HeveliI .
52 and 53 By FLAMSTEED 'S observation page 208 , should be the reverse in PD of what they are .
Cetus .
14 If we correct the British catalogue + 5 ' in PD , it N7ill become a star observed by FLAMSTEED , which is No. 312 in Miss HERSCHEL'S manuscript catalogue .
26 FLAMSTEED has no observation of this star ; rbut we find it in DE LA CAILLE'S zodiacal catalogue , No. 10 .
5I Is the same with io6 Piscium .
FLAMSTEED has 23 b.1 servations of the star , and has-always called it.v , except once on page 482 , where it is without letter , and where the:constellation is marked Aquarii ; now , as there was : immediatecly folowing an observation of 54 Ceti , and Aquarius was evidently wrong , the star has been put in Cetus .
58 Bcy FLAMSTEED S observation , page 358 , the RA in the British catalogue requires a correction of-3 in time .
74 FLAMSTEED has no observation of this star , nor can !
I find it in any other catalogue .
The place of it is so distant from other stars of the British catalogue , that my estimation of brightness may belong to some star not far:from the situation assigned , and that the star of the British catalogue maynot exist .
88 Is the same with 38 Arietis .
See Mr. BODE'S Jahr'-Bucb for 1793 , page 200 .
Eridanus .
44 In the British catalogue is marked : : The single observation of FLAMSTEED , page 153 , is perfect , all but a difference of at between the zenith-distance by the diagonal lines and by the screw .
, 45 Marked : : has a complete observation , page 153 .
68 Marked : : has a complete observation , page 146 .
Gemini .
So There is -no observation on this star .
The star I have given is at a considerable distance from the place assigned by the British catalogue , so that in fact the star of the catalogue does not exist .
It has been inserted in the British catalogue by a mistake in the calculation of a star which ig about 1o49 ' more south .
This will be No. i 39 in Miss , HERSCHEL'S manuscript catalogue , and it is probably the , real intended 5 of FLAMsTEED .
' The expression of its brightness:41,50 of my catalogue will do very well for it .
70 and 71 By FLAMSTEED'5 observations should ; be called &amp; ' , and 5 .
Tyc Ho and HEVELIUS also call 71 r. 72 and 73 Have been inserted by a mistake in 64 and 6j .
See Mr. BODE'S yahr-Buch for 1788 , page 175 .
76 FLAMSTEED has no observation of this star .
It is , however , MAYER'S NO .
310 .
8o Is not X , but according to FLAMSTEED'S observatio n qua sequitur i ; and has no letter .
Leo .
1o Is the same with i Sextantis .
25 This star does not exist in the place where the British catalogue gives it ; but if we admit that it has been inserted by a mistake in the calculation of 1o Sextantis , it may be taken into the constellation of Leo , as a star inserted in two constellations ; and it will then be " 25 is the same with 1o Sextantis .
" 26 In FLAMSTEED'S observations , page 299 , the strias cochlea give 26 ' less than the lineas diagonales .
The former are right ; therefore the British catalogue must be corrected PD -26 .
28 FLAMSTEED has no observation of this star .
It was probably inserted by a mistake in calculating an imperfect observation of li Sextantis .
If this be allowed , we then must say " 28 is the same with iX Sextantis .
" 66 FLAMSTEED has no observation of this star .
There is a small star near the place where the British catalogue has given it , of which I have expressed the brightness ; but as its situation is not exactly where it ought to be , my catalogue should have , " s does not exist .
" 67 Is the same with 53 Leonis minoris .
71 May have been inserted by a mistake in one of the three observations of 73 ; putting the star north of 8 instead of south .
III .
Catalogue of the comparative Brzghtness of the Stars .
Lustre of the stars in Andromeda .
1 I ?
13-4 1 -15 I6 21 6 ' 43|6 8 .
3 41 6 2,146,6 5/ 6 1hT 5 61 16.7 4,6 81 67 7-8,1i 8.3 97 6 lo .
9 101 16.7 13 10.9 2l1.9 t6 18 , " T95 -121 j --6 15.12,913 '31= 6j 12,13-10 14 _ 6_ ? ?
14,15 51 j6 14,15.12 i6 |A|4 |16i7 1 -16 177 / 4 16 -1i7,19 19 T17 _8 6 20 .
18 '9 !
141 17,19-20 19T 17 20 4 Is 5.61 19-20 20-2 22-209.1i8 -22-20-23 21 21 2,81 8 Pegasi 2143 21 -43 W~~ ~.11 4,..1,1 , 43 _ 43'f 22 95 22 20 23 !
i6 20 -23 , -26 24/ 0 4.5925,24-27 25101 5 J25 , 24 26 6f 3,26 28/ 1 161 29-28 32..8 T0 Lustre of the stars in Andromeda .
291 X4.51 30 .
2928 29 , 35 30 |J4 37-30 .
29 SL 1gISI4 Trianguli = 31- , 2 Trianguli 321 6 135 -32.28 32 39 33 i NAb .
is a Nebula 341 4 135 , , 4,38 351 |14 J29,35-32 35,34 35-48 50,35,53 36 6 38,36 371 4 ' 134 *37-S3 37-50 381 w 14.534,38-,36 39 6 32 39 40j 6 !
28T40 41j d5 f4241 45 42J P15 154 ; 42-,41 43 ?
2 2 1 , 43 57 2 1,43 ; 57 21 43,57 43 X 13 Ari 4313 Ari 43 = , 57 44 1i6 145 .
44 4 !
5.6 141 .
45 44 45 47 47 ~6 14547 481 5 ~35..489,46 49 !
0 5 146,49 so-1uI1 6.5 37 -50 -35 5sl1 5 51s-1 521X16 T53 , 52 .
55 53 5135,53,52 58,5~-6 5.3 , 60 J56 ] 6 53-6.59 6o , 56 Lustre of the stars in Andromeda .
57 r 2.3 43 .
57 57 ; l3 Arietis 43 ; 57 43 57 43 , 57 _8j 6 18i 53 59L1 6 56 .
59 6o b6 53 , 6o , 56 6111 6 J63,61 66,61 62j c6 J65,62 361 j6 j64 .
63,61 6 Persei , 63 64_ 6 [ 6564.6,1 651 5 16564 65,62 6 , , 6 Persei 66 16.7 166 ; 61 Lustre of the stars in Bootes .
6 j7,1 6-1,2 21 61 2,210 , t 16 1"1 .
41 14 15T4-G6 5uj4 |5T 4 30 5,35 6 5.6 6 , 7 4671 7 16,7,1 7-26 81 3I 1827 79 Virgilis 88 -27 , 36 8 9g 5 128 ; 1 9 -l1 313 6 11 -24 '41 16 118 , l4,15 15j 6 1'4 , 'S 16 11 16-3Lyrae Lustre of the stars in Boots .
18 61 2 , 18 , 14 191 I. 19 .
23 .
201 5 , 2 o , 8 20 ; 22 21 f4 123,21.17 22 ft5f 20 ; 22 2CSf 0f4 J19 .
23,21 241 g 6.7 1 13-24 25 |I4 125-Si 26 ' 177 26 34 --2 2~~7'1 V , 13 I8,27-49 27-,49 8-27 2742 28 aJ , 51 -28 28 ; 12 29 4 ? ?
13 t5 129 30f 3 30 - , 5 3g1 II 5S I 35 , -31-32 32 26 I31-32 33 1 hs 6I 39 .
33 3-38 341 6 34-26 35 0 ? ?
4 S5 5 1,1.S.29 37 * 35 31,361 ; 13 SCoron 36 8 371M 4 37 35 3,8 I hbz 63 3338 391 6 147 39 39 .
33 40 ?
I 6.7 47-4 40 4115 145 ; 41-46 41,48 41 .
50 4203 49,42 42T49 27-,42.49 42 49 43 L[5 [ 43-45 441 16 144 47 451 C5s 3-45 ; 41 46T b7V 6 141-46 48,4647 k5 I44 47 39 47 40 481 5:41,48,46 Lustre of the stars in Boots .
49 1 ? ?
3 127- ) 49 42 - , 49 42 49 42 , 49 I _I_1 42549 97-49 5 ?
05 41 S 5._ 28 .
51 4 5p--51.2 4 Corome 51 , 7 Corona- : 52 v_ 53 __ _2 , 54 53 v6 53 ; 52 541 161 52,54 Lustre of the stars in Cancer .
&lt; 1 16 15 .
21| w'j 16 9,2,4 14,2,4 , L 6 16 3 , 5 83,1 4a 1 J6 1 2,4.13 56 3 , 5 &gt; ' 6GX 5 16-14 6-15 6T18 78[ 9,7 81 16 __8-3 K9 I7 109,2 9 , 7 I10,2 5 J10 -9 eLW1ll 16 1 4 , 11 15 126 j3,12 13 41 6.7 1 4.13 14 _41 42 6 -14,11 51631 $I 614l3..16- , lo J C. .
43i6 ?
- , 317 li 431'7T47 17,48 81 x6 61 , 18,23 '91 x6 19 -30 , 28 201 d ' 6| 3 1 , 20 , 25 211 i6 37,21,34 29-21 Lustre of the stars in Cancer .
221q 6.7)1 23 , 22 23 ) j6 118 23 , 22 24 61 32.24 25 d1 6 20o,25 26 p s_6 Does not exist .
27j j6 127 ; 29 28 I V6.7130 , 28 , 32 29 667 27 ; 29-21 30 V6 119-30,28 31 ) 0 16.5 31,20 31 33 321 1 17.8128,32.24 331 v 6.7 131 33 34i T6 121,34.36 351 17 142 3538 .
36 C16 134 .
36 371 c % 6f 9-37,21 38 a8 142 ; -38 .
40 35.38 391 161 39,41 401 6 138 .
40 41 17 39 , 41.42 42JcJ7.8J41.42 ; 38 402 ; 35 431 i 14 )4.G16 47-,43 441 6 120---44 4--44 45 1 A " 61 76 , 45 .
60 461 16 55 ; 46 .
61 ... 47 1A a kI4 1 17 47-,43 65 * 47--76 48 , 47 48 1 ' 117,48,47 48--58 49 bi6 14937.oj Al 6 |6c , 50 51 .
T1 61 5.64 52 II 5452 Lustre of the stars in Cancer .
53 6 53 53 54117 6-,54-5 8 ?
,48 S5S jI 1 58-55 ; 53 67 .
55 , 70 57 5.5 46 56 g6j Does not exist .
571,1I.6I8 ; 57 -55 57,97 2 58 gf 6 48-58-55 58 , 75 58 ; 57 599 5j 5.6 64 .
59 .
-66 601 o ' 4.5 45 .
60 , " 50 6i 16 146.61 62j 116 j63.62-,54 63J o2 6 163.62 64 3 '6 j1.64 .
59 65 J141 65 .
47 66 aJ 6 J59 .
66 671 167167 .
55 687 6181 -68 71 68 .
78 68 ; 8o 69 J 6 ; 169 77_ 7o ' 16.7 1 55 , 70 71L 7 j68,7 ' 78,71 721 16.715772'73 6j Does not exist .
74 116 Does not exist .
75 17 6758875 76 ?
LLK 4 45 -7 76 , 45 771 5 15.6 69 777 79 786T6V 8.78 , j~71 83,78 I 8078,71 79iT8 77 79 ~7~ 8o !
7 i o-83 68 ; 80 78 811 sw I7 154,81 81-68 81,83 821 6,82,54 83 j6 181 , 83 80 83 , 78 Lustre of the stars in Centaurus .
2J g 14 5 5-2 31 k| 4.5 1 4,3 .
4h 45 49 3| Wl 2.3 '.5- .
Lustre of the stars in Cepheus .
KT1 | 15 1.17 2015 13-,2 3K 413 32,3-,2 21 3301 4A _6 16-4.7 S1I35 -,37 Cygni 5 .
37 Cassiopea 71 6 14*7 r |*S 8 Lustre of the stars in Cepheus .
25 17 126- , 25 26 .
6 130-,26-,25 2-7 ) I 15132,207 27.23 21-27-23 21 T2 28 ) 6 )28-29 291 e)6 )28-29 30 61 --30-,26 31 ) 6 3_431 32 ) ?
)4 f8-,32.3 32i3 33)i ) 5 117,33 34 1 j,5 34 -31 35 ) VI 3s-,8 Lustre of the stars in Corona Borealis .
91o1 6 12 12 fl 151 2--1 3P14 )8 ; 3-13 4 ) 0 4.5 13 ; 4-1o 4,7 .
2 123 155 OpIiuchi , S 536 Bootis 6K &lt; _ 11-6 , 94 )4,7,1O 81 vI4 18 ; 3 9 ) 75 6,9 12,9 g !
4 4-io 7,10 " 1 5 iI-6 12 |A5 12 , 9 14 -6 | 14 19 .
15)e 6)1 7- , 15 6-6 ) '6 116-17 171 o6 1617 17 , 15 181 u6 119- , 18 Lustre of the stars in Corona Borealis .
'91 ~I5 j14 i9-,1i820 f ' 5j20 ~'21 _21 50 21 Lustre of the stars in Lacerta .
Ij51 7 , 1 , 8 i , 1 Hevelii .
6 21 15 17T2,5,3S1 14AS514.3,9 41 1 5Is 4*3 5l 14.517-5 2,5 .
4 61 s1 7-6 , 11 i Hevelii .
_6 71 17 I-s 7T2 7-6 7,1 6 li,8.ilo 91 6 K3,9 1'0 6 18 .
10,12 -111 5 6,11 05 121 6 I10 , 12 13 16 J1 5.1 , 1 43 14 14( I6 13 , 14.16 15 I5 11,15-.13 i~j 6 j1.16 Lustre or the stars in Lepus .
XI 97 71 lo .
1 .
12 2 [ E 4 5 , 2 , 13 3 , |5 3 .
6 71 v1 56 16,4 7 7 , Lustre of the stars in Lepus .
91 bJ 114-19,15 17 I_6 lo .
1 111 04f 1617-9 121 61 7.12 it ___[4 2 GG1 laa~15-1 141 4 5 , 14 1 2 ) 4j 152 , 10 '16'w 641 4 , 1618 _17_i 6 1I .
127-,19 18 6.4J 14-6-i8 , W1 161719_ Lustre of the stars in Navis .
I6 1 , " la686 De a Caille 22j6j 1-2 11,3 4.5 13 114 1 , 3Cnsm .
i-13 Cism.__ '44 6 141 96-,6 s 36 15 , Cas 1 6bj 1 .
f 11.61 16-19 8 5 .
1S6 l o18.91 4 14 9S 6 .
9 17J | 16 2 .
lo , 8e47= 11 12 i. 16 11 12 3 , 1 1665S De la Caille. .
121 61 1-12 11-5,121 138 4 13 1:3 , Canis miti .
S-I als minl._ 4N14 16 16 6-14 16-,114 }|3 ogC1 Cat-iis lmai .
' 516 5i i , .
i6 14 16 - , 14 ... 1~7 6 20 17 - , 1 ~~~~~ _ 2 Lustre of the stars in Navis .
8J _-61 20,18- , 22 19 41 14.51 19 , 20 201 15.6 I19,20-21 19,20,18 20-,21 2O-17 21 6 20 21 20- , 21 221 61 8-,22 Lustre of the stars in Orion .
21 14 I'-3 2 -8 2I1 r'1 4 1l3-g7 31 14 -[1-,3 8,3--2 3,9 4 !
ox 4.5J 9~-4 11,94,15 4 --9GlaIuri I___ I___ -____ 4 , 97 _lauri .
5I 6 I10-,5 6 gI 6 17-6,14 lu7 l 216 1 2-7-6 8 !
z41 -8 , 8.0-o 11 _Y 1 12 6 Does not exist .
1b16 I16i 18-113 14 1Z151 6 , 14 ; 16 51 Y !
5 I4 1535 16 !
hb 6 114 ; 16-13 16 .
18 17 1114.5 15 2S1721 18j 16 .
116 .
1813 9A1 19 T lo Canis thin .
19 = ; 87 Tauri | |_ | 19- , lo Canis min. 201 rl 4 120 , 29 8 -20= 29 21 16 117 --21 221 5 22 , 27 22.31 22 11 MonOCerOtis Lustre of the stars in Orion .
231rn| 6 |3o,23 , 38 241 j2 112 fauri- , 24-46 24- , 46 25.V1 225,17 47 25 .
30 26 6D oes not exist .
271 I6 122,27 31,27 28 113 144_28,48 28-20 29 e5 120,29,36 20 29 ; 53 30o I52 25 .
30 23 31j j6 122.31,27 32f Aji j32,47,33 n6 i38 33 34 &amp; 2 i50o-34 ; 53 50-,34 5334 35 6 15 535 361 v4 29,36 49 371 I5 140-937 61 , 37 98J 6 123,38,33 39 |14 I39-40 401 &amp; 5I 39-40-37 40,61_ 411'O'I 6 143.43 42 ] c1 5 142,4.5 431 1T 41 41.43 441 ' f3.4 4428 45 J c ' 5 j42 , 45 461 ej2 j464 -034 24-46 46 -l0o ydrx II1 46_ 50 24- , 46 471 15 132,47,25 48 1T 14 48 49 jd1 36-49 495S5 s5o S2 50 24 Gemi 46 , 50o 34 46 -5o _34 j , _50 ; 1 24 Gemi 5 .
I 5 " ; 51 sj ; 5 2 Lustre of the stars in Orion .
J52J 6 1S1 ; 52,6o,531 I3I 1 ' 3I S45 ; 53 S 29 ; 53 o Hyd-.53 53 34 54 2Xi 5 S4---s7 54-62 551 6 j49s 56f 6 f56 ; ,5i 57 IXI S1 54--57 68,57,58 1 58.io Canis min. 58 -87 Tauri 8- , 10 Canis min. 58 .
_______________ 591 6 60 - , 59 6of 6 1s2 , )6o,59 -6 )14 J40,61,37 62H 6 15 4-62-64 63 16 166.63 66 : ; 63 64 ( Xz 6 ( 622-64 65 1 Xj J.6_j Does not exist .
66 116 166.Gj 66 ; 63 671 V t4.5 67 ; 70 67,70 68 i6 71768,57 69171 16 , 70 -69.-72 , -70 ~ 4.5 67 ; 70 - , )74 70 -75 67 , 70 69 71 f1 6 I71,68 72ff 6 169 72 73f kP i6 f74 ; 73 74j kl i6 70- , 74 ; 73 75 s74 .
76I 16D notexst 76 16 Does not exist .
77 6 77 78 7-8 Notes to Andromeda .
1 By three observations of FLAMSTEED , page 130 , 138 , and 140 , the polar-distance in the edition .
of 17295 requires + go .
40 Is the same with 69 Piscium. .
FLAMSTEED observed , it five times ; twice among the stars , of the constellation Pisces , and three times among those of Andromeda .
See page 14 , 134 , 139 , 149 , and 210 .
6i M. DE LA LAND says is lost. .
See Mr. BODE .
S farBucIa for 1794 , page 97 ; but as the star is now in its place , it may perhaps be changeable , and ought to be looked after .
Nvotes to .
Boots .
47 The RA in the British catalogue is only given to the nearest degree , and Mr. BODE and Mr. WOLLASTON , in their catalogues , have left it out ; but FLAMSTEED has .
four complete observations of it , on page 166 , 168 , 414 , and 415 , and the star is called k in all of then .
Notes to Cancer.26 Wasnot observed by FLAMSTEED .
An observation on , page 297 has occasioned the insertion , of this star ; but by correcting .
the time 1 ' , it will agree with two other observations of 22 Cancri on page 21 and 26 .
See , Mr. BODE 's Yahr-Biichb for 1788 , .
page 172 .
56 This star has notbeen observed by FLAMSTEED , nor does it exist .
Page 25 FLAMSTEED observed j5 Cancri with a me-morandum , SC Hac habet comitem sequentem ad austrum ; " which has probably occasioned the insertion of this star ; but he had not then observed all the B 's , and might possibly mean .
to point out e 5 ; which he afterwards observed on page 27 .
The stars are so near together that he might easily mistake sequens for pracedens ad austrum .
FLAMSTEED in his observations calls 58 3d a , 67 4th q , and 70 5th a ; this shows that there is no authority for six a 's .
See Mr. BODE'S account of the same star in his yahr-Buch for 1788 , page 171 .
71 " April 5 , 1796 .
71 Cancri is 1i ' nearer to 78 and 1i ?
" farther from 68 than it is placed in Atlas .
" 73 and 74 Have not been observed by FLAMSTEED , nor do they exist .
How they came to be inserted , does not appear to be satisfactorily accounted for by Mr. BODE in his yahr-Buch for 1788 , page 172 .
He gives us four observations of 62 and 63 Cancri ; but FLAMSTEED has thirteen , and they are all perfect except the last on page 564 .
Notes to Cepheus .
15 cc October 25 , 1796 .
15 Cephei consists of two stars .
" c Both taken together for one , by the naked eye , give 14 .
15 c ' In the telescope they are 1o4- , 1515.,18 Has no time in FLAMSTEED'S observations .
" March 26 , CC 1797 .
18 is a very little preceding 19 .
It is 12 degree from " 9 17 .
The stars 18 , 20 and 19 are in a line which bends a " little at 18 towards the preceding side .
" Notes to Corona Borealis .
21 In the British catalogue requires a correction of -28 ' 21 " in time of RA and 14 ' 55 " in PD. In the place where it is marked in Atlas according to the erroneous catalogue , is no star ; but very unaccountably it is also marked in its right place in the same Atlas .
FLAMSTEED has four complete obser- .
vations of it on page 167 , 445 , 477 , and 478 .
Mr. WOLLASTON not being acquainted with the existence of 21 Coronae in its right place , supposes zone 550 , that I have made a mistake in calling my double star VI .
18 , very unequal ; but in his corrections he gives us the place of a star , as hecalls it 'I near v , which is the real second v of FLAMSTEED ; who very particularly describes it on page 167 , " Duarum ad v sequens et clarior ; " and this is the double star I have given in my catalogue as 21 Coronae .
Notes to Navis .
i There is no observation of this star ; but in Miss HER_SCHEL'S manuscript catalogue , No. 92 , is a star s0 more south , which has probably been calculated wrong , and has given occasion for its insertion ; correcting , therefore , the PD of i Navis + 2 ' , the expression of its brightness is as I have given it .
17 There is no observation of this star ; but if we correct the PD + 30 , it will then agree with No. 238 in Miss HERSCHEL'S manuscript catalogue .
21 By FLAMSTEED'S observation page 431 , the PD of the British catalogue requires + 18 ' .
Notes to Orion .
12 FLAMSTEED never observed this star .
It does not appear how it came to be inserted in the British catalogue .
26 FLAMSTEED never observed this star .
An error of 20 ' in PD in the calculation of one of the four observations of 25 Orionis , may have occasioned the insertion of it .
35 Is marked in the British catalogue ; but FLAMSTEED has seven completeobservations of this star ; therefore the marks : : should be out .
63 There is no observation of this star ; but supposing an error of + 2 ' 14 " of time in RA , and of + '0 ' 22 " in PD , it will then agree with No. 33 of Miss HERSCHEL'S manuscript catalogue .
I have taken the comparative brightness of that star , supposing it to be 63 .
64 and 65 Have no observation by FLAMSTEED ; but their insertion has been accounted for by Mr. BODE in his Jabr .
Buch for 1793 , page 195 .
He mentions FLAMSTEED'S two observations on page 17 and 94 .
There is a third on page 292 , which confirms what Mr. BODE says .
The 64 of which I give the brightness , is not far from the place assigned to it in the British catalogue .
It is No. 1 in Miss HERSCHEL'S manuscript tatalogue .
76 There is no observation of thisstar .
A mistake of 1 ' in PD in calculating.one of the four observations of 8 Monocerotis , might occasion its insertion .
WM .
HERSCHEL .
Slough , near Windsor , April lz , 1797 .

