VIII .
An Experimental Inquiry concerning Animal Impregnation .
By John Haighton , M. D. Communicated by Maxwell Garthshore , M. D. F. R. S. Read February 2 , 1797 .
DIFFICILLIMUM aggredior laborem , et exitum vix promitto qui lectori satisfaciat .
This was the sentiment of the justly celebrated Baron HALLER , when he first directed his attention to this subject , when he attempted to produceorder and regularity out of chaos , and to show " How the dim speck of entity , began " T ' extend its recent form , and stretch to man .
" GARTH .
The difficulties which discouraged so able a philosopher , are but ill calculated to inspire me with -confidence ; but the disappointment from failure will be attended with this solacing reflection , that if I have miscarried , it is in a great undertaking .
The multitude of physiologists who have sought for laurels in this field , can best bear witness to the difficulty of the pursuit ; and the penetrating genius of a HARVEY , though adequate to a full exposition of the circulation of the blood , toils in vain in the mysterious researches of generation .
His philosophic mode of scrutiny by experiment , when pointed to one object , conferred immortality on his name ; but when directed to another , reduced him to a level with contemporary reputation .
Others , perhaps from possessing a greater propensity to the subject , have laboured with more success : they have penetrated into the interior recesses of nature , and thence brought to view what preceding investigators had deemed inaccessible to research .
On this view of the subject , our acknowledgments are particularly due to the labours of STENO , DE GRAAF , HALLER , and others .
To STENO and DUE GRAAF we are indebted for some important facts on the structure of the ovaries The supposed analogy to the male 's testes is disproved , and the vesicular structure , together with a connexion with the ova , or rudiments of the new formed animal , fullyestablished From the experiments of DE GRAAF on rabbits , we learn , First .
That the ovaries are the seat of conception .
Secondly .
That one or more of their vesicles become changed .
Thirdly .
That the .
alteration consists in an -enlargement of them , together with a loss of transparency in their contained fluid , and a change of it to an opaque and reddish hue .
Fourthly .
That the number of vesicles thus altered , corresponds with the number of foetuses , and from these are formed the true ova .
Fifthly .
That these changed vesicles , at a certain period after they have received the stimulus of the male , discharge a substance , ,which being laid hold of by the fimbriated extremity of the fallopian tube , and conveyed into the uterus , soon as , , sumes a visible vesicular form , and is called an ovum .
Sixthly .
That these rudiments of the new animal , which for a time manifested no arrangement of parts , afterwards begin to elaborate and evolve the different organs of which the new animal is ; composed To these facts we may add , that the calyx or capsula which formed the parietes of the vesicles thickens , by which the cavity is diminished .
This cavity together with the opening through which the foetal rudiments escaped becomes obliterated , and from the parietes of these vesicles having acquired a yellowish hue , they are called corpora lutea .
But though some important facts are clearly ascertained , there are others still problematical .
Physiologists are by noo means agreed concerning the immediate cause of conception .
All admit the necessity of sexual intercourse .
They acknowledge too , the necessity of some part of the female being affected by the direct contact of a fecundating-fluid , :but what the pre &gt; cise part is which must receive the stimulus has hitherto been involved in mystery anddoubt .
Nor are they more unanimous respecting the state or condition of the substance that passes from the ovaries ; whether at the time of its expulsion it has a circumscribed vesicular-character , or whether it .
has no determined figure .
DE GRAAF and MALPIGHI , in the last century , and some respectable physiologists of the present day , adopt the firstopinion ; HALLER and some others favour the last .
The subject of conception Iolves other problematical points not less interesting ; the discussion of which I purposewaving at present , iit order the better to direct my attention more closely to the preceding questions. .
The intention then-of this ; - ; essay is to explore the proxiate cause of the impregnation of animals , andto trace with more accuracy the visible effects of k from their first appearance , until : the rudiments of the foetus are lodged in the uterus and have assumed the proper characters of an ovum .
As soon as these rudiments manifest that opaque spot , or " dim speck of " entity , " which is known to evolve the foetus by regular and progressive steps ; another stage of the inquiry then commences , viz. to trace the visible formation of the new animal through its whole course ; but as this belongs rather to the oeconomy of the foetus than the mother , it is not intended to form any part of this paper .
I perceive , however , that I cannot investigate the question of the proximate cause of impregnation in a satisfactory way without first determining what are the evidences or proofs that impregnation has taken place : this then necessarily becomes a preliminary question .
I therefore restrict my inquiry to the three following subjects .
First .
What are the evidences of impregnation &gt; Second .
What is the proximate cause of impregnation ?
And , third .
Under what form do the rudiments of the fetus pass from the ovary to the uterus ?
SECTION I. What are the Evidences of Impregnation ?
The investigation of every complicated subject of inquiry comprehends within its range a more or less extended recital of facts , depending in a greater or less degree on each other , but primarily arising from some fundamental proposition .
As this proposition is generally the basis on which this superstructure is raised , or the trunk from which the various ramifications of inquiry proceed , it is essential , to the establishment of the ultimate conclusions , that the antecedent question be rightly decided .
: It becomes then indisputably necessary to us in the present subject , to determine what is the criterion of impregnation .
That a female isimpregnated when a foetus is sensibly formed , is so obvious to reason that no argument can be necessary to convince us of its truth .
But it is important to some conclusions in the sequel of this paper to prove , that a female has conceived before there are any vestiges of a new animal .
The test of this condition must then be sought for in there ovaries ; and the well conducted experiments of DE GRAAF , in the last century , and of Baron ' HALLER and others , in the present , bear so forcibly on this point , -that the necessity of further investigation is in a great measure precluded .
But , in order that I might bear evidence of its truth I examined with great attention the ovaries of some ; ftll grown virgin rabbits , and Dfound , as -DE_ GRAAF has represented , that there entered into their composition a series of cells:containing a transparent colourless , fluid .
It was indispensably-necessar hereto be certain , that these rabbits had never been admitted to the male , lest thei remains of former impregnations should be confounded with virgin appearances .
I therefore observed with care not only the appearance on the surface of these bodies , but likewise examined ; with great minuteness the interior parts- ; yet in none of them could I see any of those circumscribed substances , which , from their yellow colour , are called corpora lutea .
But -whensimilar observations were made on rabbits that had been impregnated at different periods , ,and .
the traces of those.corpora lutea were more or less evident , :-accord.ing to the interval of time that had elapsed ; I may then saly that no corpora lutea exist in virgin animals , and that whenY2 ever they are found , they furnish incontestible proof , that*impregnation either does exist , or has preceded .
: But adproper distinction between past and existing imprenation can be made only by tracing the phenomena of : recent fecundation progressively , and noting the appearances in the different stages .
I was therefore under the necessity of repeating with care several of DE GRAAF 's experiments , in order that I might bear testimony to the truth of them , at least as far as the results coincided with my own , EXPERIMENT .
Having therefore procured several virgin rabbits in a fit state for impregnation , I admitted one of them to the male .
Twelve hours afterwards it was killed , and on examining the ovaries several of the vesicles evidently projected ; they had lost their transparency , and were become .
opaque and red .
When punctured , a fluid of the same colour escaped .
I made sections through some of them ; but at this early period the corpora lutea , which are formed by : the thickening of the parietes of the vesicles , were not very evident .
I therefore determined to examine them in a more advanced state .
EXPERIMENT .
Another rbbit being admitted to the male I examined it twenty-four hours afterwards .
The colour of the fluid contained in the vesicles was similar to that of the last experiment .
The vesicles projected more evidently , and their thickened parietes manifesting the commencement of corpora lutea were become more apparent EXPERI MEANT .
I inspected the , ovaries of another rabbit forty-eight hours post coitum .
At this period the vesicles seemed to be in the very act of bursting , and a semitransparent substance , : of -a mucus-like consistence , was beginning to ; protrude from some of them ; others indeed were less advanced .
The fimbriated extremities of the fallopian tubes were preparing to receive their contents , ; as appeared byhaving quitted their usual pow sition , and embraced the ovaries- ; int such a degree , that only a small portion could be seen until the ; tubes were taken away .
Sections .
, being made into the thickened vesicles , the formationof corpora lutea , appeared to have made further advances .
From the appearance of an , incipient rupture of the vesicles in this experiment , it was but reasonable to expect that their contents would soon have escaped ; but as my views were directed to the formation of a corpus luteum , I deferred the next. .
examination to a more distant time .
EXPERIMENT .
In two days and twelve hours after coition , I examined the ovaries of another rabbit .
The foetal rudiments had escaped ; bit the cavity of the ovarian vesicles had suffered but little diminution .
Bristles were easily introduced by the ruptured orifices .
In .
this experiment the advances towards the formation of a perfect corpus luteum were such as the period of examination would naturally lead us to expect .
The contents of the vesicles having escaped , it was but reasonable now to look forward to a speedy obliteration of the cavity .
I therefore examined these parts under similar circumstances on the third , fourth , and fifth day .
In the last experiment there was but little vestige of cavity , consequently the corpora lutea might be considered as perfectlyfformed .
I think it not improper to remark here , that though in the relation of the above experiments I have constantly kept in view the formation of corpora lutea ; yet I did not altogether neglect the opportunity of making other observations , which in this early stage of the inquiry it would be premature to relate .
Besides which , several other rabbits were examined atimoredisetant periods , as well with a view of tracing their progress with accuracy , as to afford further evidence of their connexion with impregnation .
But as ' it would be tedious to state in detail the several experiments made on this single question , by reason of the great similarity of result , I decline trespassing on your patience , and therefore lay before you only the conclusion which is , that in the great variety of experiments on brute animals which my physiological'iinquiries have led me to conduct , as well as in the extensive opportunities I have had of observing the ovaries in the human subject , I have never seen a recently formed corpus luteum unattended with*some circumstance or other connecting it very evidently with impregnation ; I have more thanonce seen a recently formed ; corpus luteum in the human subject without a foetus .
Nay , even in a subject where there has been a kind of hymen : but the uterus in these cases has ' borne the ma'rks of an early and'trecent abortion .
SECTION II .
W~hant -is theproximate Cause of Impregnation ?
The preliminary question concerning the criterion of fecundation being now answered , we are led by a natural transition to show by what means this test has been produced .
Waving all comment on the peculiar circumstances of sexual intercourse , as being both irrelevant and indelicate , we -shall note only one important effect of it , the passage of the fecundating fluid of the male into the generative organs of the female , as being an indispensable requisite in the human female , and in such animals as bear an affinity to it .
As this effect of sexual communication is so important , it cannot be indifferent to the design of nature , to what part of the uterine system the semen should be conveyed .
It admits of no doubt that it either remains in the vagina , passes into the uterus , or else extends its course -along the fallopian tubes to be applied to the surface of the , ovaries , which .
it stimulates , and from which the new animal derives its existence ; , but whether it be one or other of these , has given 'birth to more physiological controversy , than perhaps any other operation of a living animal .
Those who have entered the lists have ranged .
themselves either on the side of application of the semen to the , ovaries by means of the tubes ; or on that of the inutility of this process .
These latter contend for an , aborption'of this fluid by .
the vagina , a peculiar excitement of the whole frame as a consequence , of which excitement the changes produced on the ovaries are to be considered the local effects.:But though : the question has been disputed on .
both sides with all the zeal , of argument and controversy , the arbiters of science have not yet acknowledged a victor on either side .
The advocates for the first opinion allege , that the semen has been seen both in the uterus and tubes , and quote as their authority the observations of Mo1RGAGNI for the former , and RUYSCH for the latter .
When seen in this last situation , some have thought that it was conveyed thither by the muscular power of these parts : in the manner of a peristaltic motion , beginning at the uterus and ending at the fimbriated termination of the tube ; and when at this last , it was supposed that the semen was applied to the surface of the ovaries , and impregnated them by actual contact .
" Though I shall prove that this hypothesis is altogether visionary , yet prima facie it is far from carrying with it the characters of absurdity .
There is nothing repugnant to reason in contending for what analogy seems to favour , particularly when the subject is thought beyond the reach of demonstration or proof .
And the analogy favourable to this opinion has probably been taken from the impregnation of frogs and toads , in which process we are told , on the authority of RoESEL , SWAM MERDAM , and SPALLANZANI ' , the ova are impregnated by the male as they are passing from the body of the female ; and that in water newts the ova are impregnated even without copulation .
Now here is an appearance of contact between the fecundating fluid and the ova .
Again , on the other hand , the contact of semen with the ovaries has been thought improbable , from ' an analogy drawn from the vegetable kingdom ; for admitting the Linnzean doctrine to be true , which contends for a necessity of sexual intercourse in vegetables , it would be difficult to demonstrate to the satisfaction of stern philosophers , that the pollen pervades the pistillum , and stimulates the contents of the pericarpiumby contact , to the evolution of the germ Such would deny the contact of semen , The advocates for either opinion then may avail themselves of analogies suited to their owhrmode ofdthinking .
It may be said , however , and with some colour of truth , that the latter analogy , as being more remote than the former , and as being founded on a principle which some have suspected to be gratuitous , should be received with caution and distrust , Before any deduction can be made from analogy concerning the means by which any important end is to be effected , we cannot examine the instruments performing such actions with an attention too nice or too minute .
If we find nature employing different instruments , in different animals , to -produce the same ultimate effect , I think it -but fair to conclude , that the means used are essentially different ; but the closer the resemblance in the instruments or organs , the nearer will the means approach .
On this principle no conclusions can be drawn respecting the human species , from observations either on vegetables , or even on frogs , toads , and newts .
Birds , as being impregnated by semen conveyed into the body , resemble .
human impregnation more than the former ; but they differ so obviously in the mode of perfecting the foetus Sfrom the ovum that I scarcely dare to rest any thing on their general analogy .
There is , however , a curious fact respecting them not altogether inapposite to this question , which is , the permanent effect of one-coitus .
-I have read in the Abb &amp; SPALLANZANI'S dissertation , and elsewhere , ' that all the , eggs which a hen will lay in twenty days will be impregnated at ' , one coitus : and Mr. CLINE tells me , that in Norfolk this matter is reduced to a certainty with respect to turkeys ; and that even to a greater , extent There ; ifs certaily some difficulty in reconciling these facts to impregnation by contact of semen ; but from the very obvious , difference between oviparous and viviparous animals , I shall not press this argument farther .
Indeed it should alwaysbe iimpressed on the recollection of those who are labouring in the pursuit of truth , that arguments drawn from analogies , tunless from those of the nearest relation , are better adapted to the purpose of illustration than of proof : and though they frequently find advocates in confident closet philosophers , their are received with deserved distrust by the more cautious Lpractical physiologists. .
Those who cannot admit the passage of semen by the tubes , do not neglect to take the advantage of some difficulties , which their opponents have overlooked .
They say , implicit confidence is not due to the observations of MORGAGNI and RuYSCH , and that what appeared to them to be semen in the uterus and tubes , was nothing more than the mucus of the parts .
They further invalidate the force of this argument by contrqsting ' these solitary observations , with ' a numerous train of counterfacts ; for in all the experiments made by HARVEY , DE GRAAF , HALLER , and others , it does not appear that semen was found bee yond the vagina , except in one of Baron HALLER's:experiments in a sheep , in which he saw semen in the uterus forty-five minutes after coition .
But this fact standsalmost alone .
; and when placed in opposition to the many experiments attended with a contrary result will weigh but little in the balance of impartial decision .
Yet , however , he rested much upon this one fact , and adduced it in support of his opinion , that when , ever impregnation happened , the semenfipassed into the uterus , and was retained ; but when it returned from the vagina , then the animal remained unimpregnated .
In this latter case , he supposes the semen had never passed beyond the vagina for if it had , he says it would have been retained .
This argument he thinks is unanswerable .
The insufficiency of this reasoning did not escape the penetration of his opponents and the immense mass of counterfacts poured out against him , like an irresistible torrent , bore away the very foundation of his doctrine .
This brings the advocates for the necessity of the contact of semen with the ovaries into a dilemma , from which they attempt to extricate themselves by contending , that fecundation does not require the application of semen to the ovaries in a palpable form ; but that there is exhaled .
from it a subtle , fluid in a vaporific state , called aura seminalis , and that the : contact of this vapour is fully sufficient to impart.to the ovaries their due quantity of stimulus .
But the.opinion , even thus qualified , has not passed without animadversion .
There are some who cannot comprehendhow the tubes should perform two motions in contrary directions which they must do , 'if they first convey the aura seminalis to the surface of .
the ovaries , and afterwards return the rudiments of the foetus into the uterus .
-..Such a double action they think is repugnant to , the oeconomy of the part , but assign no reason for their opinion .
They might with equal propriety deny the possibility of , a peristaltic and inverted peristalticmotion of the intestines , or the opposite actions .
in the oesophagus of ruminant animals , though I am persuaded very few would acquiesce.in their incredulity:.but as minute discussion of this particular question would be rather extraneous to my irivestigation , I must decline any further disquisition .
The difficulties which were opposed to the conveyance of the semen by the tubes , were , as .
we should suspect , intended to prepare the way for a different explanation ; a therefore physiologists , by a very natural transition of thought , were led to suppose that the presence of semen in the vagina alone was sufficient to account for impregnation .
In order to give support to this opinion , cases were adduced , in which , from some anatomicalpeculiarities it seemed almost impossible that the fecundating fluid could be conveyed into the uterus ; and yet in several of these cases impregnation had really taken place .
It would be digressing too much to state the facts in detail , seeing that in this inquiry I deduce nothing from them ; nor would such statement solve the problem before us .
The facts are already in the possession of physiologists , but are not admitted as satisfactory proofs .
Those -who hold the contrary opinion , either cavil at the accuracy of the statement , or draw a different conclusion ; therefore to attempt conviction by these materials would be to engage in the service of forlorn hope .
It remains then to : try whetherby a : patientexperimental investigation , we can make such an accession of new facts to our present stock of knowledge as will enable us to unloose this Gordian knc:t .
This attempt naturally leads us to review the two points of the question viz. Is the passage of the semen by the tubes to the ovaries , essential to -impregnation ?
If not , what other means are employed . ?
If it be true that the fecundating fluid must pass:by the tubes to the ovaries before impregnation can take place , ought it not to follow , as a consequence , that if , from any cause , both these tubes be obliterated , the animal so affected would be barren ?
or if the animal be multiparous , would not an obliteration on one side prevent conception in the corresponding ovary ?
Now I had some distant apprehensions , even before Imade this experiment , that dividing both tubes would produce effects equivalent to an extirpation of both ovaries , which experience has since proved to be well founded ; for it not only destroys the power of conception , but even the disposition for using the means .
EXPERIMENT .
Having procured a full grown virgin rabbit , which had betrayed signs of disposition for the male , I made an incision into the posterior part of each flank , -exactly upon the part where the tubes are situated .
By means of my finger and -a bent probe , I drew out a very small portion of the middle of the tube , and cut out about -8 of an inch .
The two ends were returned into their former situation , and the wound closed by what-surgeons call the quill suture .
The same operation -was performed on the opposite side , and in a few days both wounds were healed .
As soon as this rabbit appeared in health , it was admitted to the male , but the venereal appetite seemed to be entirely lost .
Thinking it possible that its , health was not perfectly restored , .
I kept it a month longer in a state of high feeding , and admitted it to the male a second time , but the same reluctance continued .
I began now to suspect that the venereal appetite was irreco-* verably gone : 'but as the season was cold , and of course unfavourable , it appeared proper to persevere in .
this plan until the genial influence of returning spring had produced its effect ; but instead of discovering signs of the restoration of the female character , it was evidently more averse .
It was now killed and examined , the tubes adhered firmly to the loins -at the part where they were divided , and at that part their canal was obliterated , so that neither quicksilver nor air could be made to pass .
The ovaries were much smaller than they usually are in breeding rabbits ; they appeared to have degenerated from their proper character , a circumstance probably the conse-quence of that destruction of the harmony of action in these parts , which subsists in the healthy state , which is essential to the views and intentions of nature , and for want of which harmony , the sexual indifference , approaching to aversion , was in this instance so remarkable .
In the relation of this experiment , it must be remembered , that a small portion of each tube was cut out , in order to obliterate the canal with greater certainty It is not altogether indifferent to the present subject to know , whether this apathy depended on the removal of that portion , or whether it would have happened had there bee nothing more than a mere division .
Nor is it extraneous to inquire , whether a simple division of the tube is sufficient to obliterate it , because.less violence is ofered to the part , , Xand of course the connection will be less disturbed .
EXPERI MEANT .
Being furnished with another rabbit , in high breeding condition , I repeated:the experiment , by making only a division of the tubes ; in other respects -every thing was conducted as before .
The venereal appeti-te declined as evidently in this as in the former , and notwithstanding many solicitations from a very animated male , during the space of -three months , it could never be excited .
On dissection , it appeared that the tubes were as completely obliterated , in , this experiment as .
in the last , and .
the ovaries had equally degenerated..n the two preceding experiments neither of the rabbits had given any active proofs- , of fecundity , though .
they had marks of the venereal heat upon .
them .
I therefore changed my subject .
for one .
that had , had young ones .
EXPERI MEANT .
A. healthy ' rabbit , which had lately been.separated from her first litter , was made .
the subject of a repetition..of the experiment. .
1_'took .
the opportunity of -feeling .
for the ovaries , , in order to have better:evidence respecting their.b~ulk , and by-that means to .
form a juster comparison.s The disposition to propagation declinedas evidently in this animalIas .
in the ... two for.mer ; and dissection equally evinced a change .
of theovaries ; for at the expiration of three .
months,.they had lost .
nearlyhalf their size .
Feeling , but little encouragement " to persevere in a repetition of these.experiments , I:determined to change the mode of inquiry , and totry the effect of a division of one tube .
only .
From , reasoning I was led to -think , that if .
a. division " of both tubes -destroyed the harmony of the generative system , a , division of one only might permit that harmony to continue in some degree .
I wished likewise , if possible , to have this point determined ona virgin : rabbit , the better to guard against any deception which the remains of a former impregnation might occasion .
EXPERI MEANT .
A full grown virgin rabbit had one of the tubes divided at a little distance from the extremity of the cornu uteri .
-:The wound soon healed up , and its health was soon restored , but it betrayed no disposition for the male .
I attributed it in part to the coldness of the season , for it was in the middle of December , 1794 ; but the effects of its inclemency were much moderated by having a fire in the room during the day .
I kept her until the first of May ; during this interval the male was frequently offered to her , but shealways refused , except once in February : it however was unproductive .
From examination after death , it appeared that the divided tube was completely obliterated , but the--other was sound : both ovaries were evidently shrunk , 'proving , in addition to my previous observations , that their actions had been languid .
The result of this experiment disappointed me much ; for no reasoning a priori had led me to entertain - the smallest suspicion that a mutilation of one side only could destroy ' the harmony of the whole uterine system .
But my disappointment originated chiefly from the apprehension that this effect would be uniform , that it was the result of a determined law of the part ; and if so , it fdrmned an insuperable obstacle to my research .
Its importance to my project was too great to be discouraged from a. single obstacle ; therefore in justice to my undertaking , I Was in some measure compelled to pushthe inquiry to -such an .
extent , as should enable me to say with precision , Whether it is possible to impregnate an animal in the situation just described .
EXPERI MEANT .
Two other rabbits full grown and perfectly healthy were made the subject of a repetition of the last experiment .
The male was offered to them several'times during the space of three months .
They generally refused him , yet received him twice or three times each during this interval ; but neither were impregnated .
As the signs of degeneracy from their proper sexual character became daily more evident , they were devoted to anatomical inspection , and exhibited appearances in the ovaries like the former , but somewhat less in degree .
The rabbit keeper informing me that those which had already had a litter were more certain of breeding than those which had not ; I determined to make a trial of one of this description , with a view to compensate for my former disap..m pointment .
EXPERIMENT .
Being furnished with one of this kind , and from which the young had been taken away three weeks at the age of ten weeks , which , together with the month of gestation , amounted in the whole to four months from the last conception , I made this the subject of the experiment .
Now , at this distance of time , it is not very probable that the ovaries should retain very evident vestiges of the preceding conception : but as it was a point of too much importance to be left in doubt , I determined to satisfy myself by ocular examination , which , by a little management , was effected .
The traces of corpora lutea were farfrom being evident , so that there was no danger of con.founding them with any recent mark that might happen .
The tube on one side was cut through as before , but to my unspeakable mortification this rabbit was as barren as the former , though tried several times during the space of three months .
The generative organs were examined after death , and the appearances corresponded with those of former ext periments .
In this case , as well as in a former , I had an opportunity of comparing the shrunk state of the ovaries after death , with the plump and healthy condition before the mutilation ; and it affords an additional proof of that sympathetic connexion , or consent , between one part of the generative organs and another ; and shows that in the production of a new animal , the co-operation of different parts is necessary ; and further , that if the assistance of one part is wanting , the others , as if governed by a principle of intelligence , cease to continue their important work .
But I was still in a state of suspense with regard to the end for which these experiments were instituted ; and such an uninterrupted succession of failures on a point so essential to my present inquiries , I confess tended but little to animate me in the pursuit .
I was beginning to suspect that the barrenness consequent to the division of only one of the tubes , was as determined a law in the oeconomy of these parts , as it seemed to be in those cases where both tubes were cut through ; and that nothing could prevent this sterility ; but my contemplations were directed into another channel by the following experiment .
EXPERI MEANT .
Having procured another rabbit , nearly unddr the same circumstances as the last , I operated precisely in the same mode , and had equal evidence too concerning the condition of the ovary .
The result of this experiment was successful ; for on admitting the male to her about one month from the operation , she betrayed no reluctance , and became impregnated .
Ten days afterwards she was killed , and opened .
Both ovaries retained their primitive plumpness , and manifested the evidences of impregnation .
These evidences are the presence of corpora lutea , bearing the same precise characters as I have demonstrated in the former part of this essay .
Those seated in the ovary of the mutilated side did not differ in any respect from the same bodies on the perfect side : but they were unattended with foetuses whereas in the perfect side , there were as many foetuses as corpora lutea As this experiment had succeeded , I examined the divided tube with attention , to satisfy myself whether its canal was obliterated ; and of this I had the clearest proof ; for it would not allow quicksilver , nor even air to pervade it .
Now here is matter for reasoning .
Both ovaries , it seemss , bear unequivocal proofs of impregnation , but foetuses are found only on one side .
Now , on what principle shall we explain these phoenomena ?
It is certain that neither semen nor the aura seminalis could have touched the left ovary , and yet it bears the most unequivocal marks of recent impregnation .
It must depend on some other cause than the actual contact of semen .
But an important subject for investigation here presents Aa 9 itself .
Why were there no foetuses on the mutilated side ; but only the corpora lutea ?
Is the application of the semen to the vagina or uterus sufficient to stimulate the ovaries to perform their first procreative operations , without enabling them to achieve any thing more ?
and does it require the permanent and active energies of this fluid , operating by direct contact on the surface of the ovaries , to produce the full measure of their effects ?
But as these are queries which cannot be answered from the mere reflexions of the closet , I must engage anew in the business of experimental inquiry .
But the first step that ought to be taken in the management of this question , is to give full confirmation to the above fact , by a repetition of the experiment ; I therefore engaged a keeper of rabbits to procure me six in high breeding condition , as soon as possible .
EXPERI MEANT .
Within the space of a month , I cut through the fallopian tube on one side in six rabbits .
The season was warm , and consequently favourable for breeding .
As soon as they recovered they were admitted to the male : but out of this number two only were impregnated ; and the keeper assured me that one of them had never been impregnated before .
When the success in these experiments is compared with that of the former , there was no cause for complaint .
Of these two which succeeded , one had three corpora lutea and three foetuses in the perfect side , with two corpora lutea and no foetuses on the imperfect side .
The other , which was the virgin rabbit , had two corpora lutea and two foetuses on the perfect side , with one corpus luteum and no foetus on the mutilated side .
Having now three indisputable proofs of this important fact , I consider it a full answer to any objection that can be urged on the ground of accidental appearance ; and that what has been stated above , must , under the circumstances described , be considered as a law of the part ; viz. That the ovaries can be affected by the stimulus of impregnation , without the contact either of palpable semen , or of thde aura seminalis .
But I cannot expect that any physiologist , prepossessed with the common notion of the contact of semen , will yield assent to my position , without subjecting it to a severe scrutiny , and exposing every possible objection to which it is liable .
It certainly would not be unphilosophic to ask , why foetuses were not found either in the ovarium , or in the tube between it and the obliterated part , agreeably to the assertion of NuCK , if , as I contend , the ovary was affected by impregnation ?
Again , a tenacious opponent might further avail himself of this apparent difficulty , by alleging that if the tube had not been obliterated until after coition , the semen or its powers might have affected the ovary by actual contact ; and the product of conception might have been more complete .
And in support of this idea , he might adduce the result of an experiment said to have been made by NucK , in which he made an extra-uterine case ink a bitch , by tying one of the tubes three days after coition .
These objections have at least speciousness to recommend them to our notice ; but it is from experiment alone that we can determine whether they have any solidity .
To the first difficulty I reply , that my experiments were not made under the same circumstances that Nucx 's is said to have been ; therefore , giving him full credit for what he has advanced , a similarity of result cannot be expected .
But it is painful to me to differ from any writer of character in the statement of a fact , where the truth is equally accessible to us both ; and note withstanding the respect I willingly bear towards a name that has both acquired and deserved considerable reputation , I must confess that it appears to me highly problematical , whether this celebrated experiment be a reality , or only an ingenious device .
But some facts , which it will soon be in order to relate , will show ( I think very clearly ) that I rest my suspicion upon fair grounds .
In the meantime I feel it incumbent on me to reply to the general principle of the objection , and to determine by experiment how far it is deserving attention .
Now , if there be any validity in the objection , it should necessarily follow , that if an opportunity was given for the semen to pass by the tubes to the ovaries ; we might , by opening an animal at a proper time after coition , detect some disposition in the fimbriated extremities of the tubes to apply the semen , by first approaching , and afterwards embracing the ovaries ; and this action ought , according to the common theory , to take place before the usual sign of conception is at all evident on those bodies , which in the rabbit is somewhat apparent in six hours , but unequivocally marked in twelve .
Again , admitting the probability of it , we are led to inquire by what power the semen can be conveyed to such a distant part .
It must be either by the male , vi jaculationis , or by muscular power in the tubes , analogous to a peristaltic motion .
If it were by the first mode , the conveyance would be instantaneous ; but in the latter , some little time seems necessary to allow the tubes to be affected by the stimulus preparatory to ; their peristaltic action .
Perhaps this question may receive some light from the sacrifice of a few animals , at different periods between the coitus and the first visible effects of impregnation ; and I considered it by no means inapposite to the subject , to determine whether these conjectures were authorized by any visible changes , either.in the condition or situation of the tubes .
But the fruits of this inquiry will appear by the following exv periments .
EXPERIMENTS .
A female rabbit in high season was admitted to the male , and in a few minutes afterwards the ovaries and tubes were brought into view ; but the fimbrix were in their natural situation .
As soon as proper rabbits could be procured , I repeated this experiment on two others , with precisely the same consequence .
These facts militate strongly against the possibility of the conveyance of the semen to this part vi jaculationis , and demonstrably prove , as far as three facts can go , that if the moving power inheres in the female , it is not instantaneously exerted .
But are the powers of the fecundating fluid conveyed at any time by the tubes ?
This simple question betrayed me into the prosecution of experiments to a greater extent than I at first expected ; for the result of several of them was unsatisfactory : but being once engaged in the question , I felt myself compelled to prosecute it , by examining these parts at different periods from the coitus to the manifestation of its effects .
But I found from a regular series of observations made on different rabbits , at every hour between the first and the ninth , that the fimbrix remained nearly in their usual situation ; and the only difference I perceived in the last hours , was a greater turgescency of vessels , as if preparatory to some important action .
I desisted from -this ' inquiry at the ninth hour , because the ovaries now bore very evident marks of impregnation ; and there appeared to have been no action in the tubes by which the semen could have been conveyed to them .
The impression which these experiments at first made on my mind , was , I must confess , not altogether incongenial to my wish , in as much as they seemed to furnish a satisfactory answer to the question ; but reflexions when more at leisure abated my confidence , and in the end convinced me that my proofs did not exceed probability , so that there was still room for the suggestions of scepticism : and indeed it might be said with great propriety , that the tubes might have inclined towards the ovaries in the intervals of the hours above mentioned , and have returned to their former situation , and thus have eluded my research .
I think it but candid to acknowledge , that these last experiments do not prepare me to meet that objection .
These reflexions suggested to me the expediency of constructing a plan of inquiry more apposite to the sllject ; and attended with experiments bearing more directly on the point at issue .
Under this impression I determined to obliterate one of the tubes at different periods post coiturn , and after the lapse of a sufficient length of time , to notice the effect .
My particular view its this was to allow sufficient time for the ; arrival of the semen at the ovaries supposing it to take place ; so that if they were stimulated by an affusion of that fluid , either in a palpable or insensible form , here would be time allowed suffi " cient to produce its effect ; and if in this mode foetuses could be formed , while by obliterating the tube ante coitum nothing more than corpora lutea were seen , it furnished an argument of no inconsiderable force in favour of impregnation by immediate contact ; but if on the contrary , corpora lutea ONLY were found , then such experiments would give additional force to the arguments stated in a former part of this section .
EXPERI MEANT .
One of the tubes of a rabbit was divided half an hour post coitum , and the wound closed as before .
She was kept a fortnight , that I might know the result ; but there were no marks of impregnation on either side .
Though a failure of impregnation has been very common in experiments connected with the mutilation of these parts , I apprehended that the derangement in the present instance proceeded from some disturbance given to the procreative operations in their commencement , and therefore determined in the next trial to wait a few hours , the better to avoid this .
EXPERI MEANT .
I repeated the operation on two other rabbits , in one at four , and in the other at six hours after coition .
On inspecting the parts at the end of a fortnight , the first was not impregnated , but the last was .
In this there were four corpora lutea in the right side , answering to the same number of foetuses in the cornu uteri of that side ; but on the left or imperfect side , there were three corpora lutea without foetuses .
The corpora lutea on both sides were cut open , but not the slightest difference could be detected .
Now , if the contact of the semenwith the ovaries in any form be essential to impregnation , here has been an opportunity for such contact during the space of six hours ; but it has not been sufficient to advance the procreative operations further than happened in those experiments where the tube had been divided before coition .
Let us then for a moment suppose that the interval be lengthened , in order to allow a better opportunity for producing the full effects of impregnation , by exposing the ovary a longer time to the stimulus of the semen .
EXPERI MEANT .
I cut through the left tube of another rabbit twelve hours post coitum , and examined the parts on the fifteenth day .
There were four corpora lutea with the same number of foetuses on the right side , and three corpora lutea without fotuses on the left ; so that twelve hours supposed exposure to semen , had made no sensible advances in the procreative operations on the mutilated side .
EXPERIMENT .
The same operation was repeated twenty-four hours post coitum .
Corpora lutea were found in both ovaries , but foetuses only on the perfect side .
Now I observed in one of the experiments related in the former part of this essay , that the vesicles of the ovaries when examined forty-eight hours post coitum , were extremely prominent ; they appeared as if going to burst : it is but reasonable then to admit , , that at this time they must have received their full measure of stimulus ; and if one of the tubes was divided in this state of things , the result would be more decisive .
EXPERIMENT .
The operation was repeated under the circumstances just described , and in fourteen days the result was ascertained , viz. three corpora lutea and as many foetuses on the perfect side , and two corpora lutea without foetuses on the imperfect one .
Now , what mode of reasoning ought we to adopt here ?
Has the mutilating process suspencdd the effect of that stimulus which impregnation had begun ?
and are those appearances in the ovaries , any thing more than , incipient relapses into evanescence ?
Such really appears to be the state of things , and seems to mark in a decided manner , a sympathetic connexion between one part of the uterine system and another .
And were I to adopt the language of a late celebrated physiologist , I should say " ; that the ovary on the imperfect side , " ; feeling the inability of the tube to transmit its contents to " the uterus , the proper receptacle , had suspended the usual " operations of these parts , from a consciousness of their inutility .
This reasoning will probably appear not perfectly consentaneous to certain well established facts on the subject of extra-uterine foetuses ; for dissection has fully evinced the possibility of a foetus being perfectly evolved , and of acquiring considerable bulk , either in the ovary , abdomen , or tube .
I do not hesitate to acknowledge the full force of these facts ; but I cannot admit that they subvert the principle I wish to establish from experiment ; because I conceive there is anr essential difference whether nature sponItaneously dispenses with her usual modes , and attempts to effect her ultimate purpose by irregular means ; or whether , proceeding in B b the ordinary course of her operations , she .
suffers an impedi ' Inent which a physiologist may have produced to thwart her designs .
In the first case , she may be provided with an expedient ; in the last , she will probably be left without resource .
Here again we may notice the experiment mentioned by NUCK , which , though under similar circumstances , was attended with a different result .
Some who feel themselves disposed to venerate his authority , will probably oppose his experiment to mine , and think it incumbent on me to account satisfactorily for the difference .
I can by no means acknowledge such an obligation ; for to confer validity on experiment by reasoning , is to invert the order of inquiry , and support facts by conjectures .
It is sufficient for my credit to be able to adduce evidence of the truth of what I advance , and forthis evidence I rely on my preparations .
The train of reasoning which I have lately pursued , led me toextend my inquiries into this particular question stillfurther ; and as in the last experiments the vesicles were known to be just on the point of bursting before the tube was cut through ; the next step in the inquiry appeared to be , to determine the consequences of dividing the tube a short time after the rudiments of the foetus had passed .
Will the procreative operations be suspended , if the tube be cut through after the ovum is deposited in the uterus ' ?
EXPERIMENT. .
I repeated the operation on two rabbits , one of which had received the male two days and eighteen hours , the other two days and twelve hours .
I knew from my own experiments , as well as those of De GRASA , that the vesicles had discharged their contents before either of these periods .
The examination of these at the usual time , proved that the actions of these parts suffer no interruption by a division of the tube made after the rudiments of the foetus have been conveyed into the uterus ; for there were corporea lutea in : both ovaries , and foetuses in both cornua uteri .
These experiments I think overturn ( as far as experiment can ) every argument which has hitherto been adduced to support the hypothesis , that the affusion of the semen on the ovaries , either in a sensible form or in that of aura seminalis is essential to impregnation : for if the ovaries were susceptible of their proper excitement only by the contact of semen , by what accident has it happened that the effects of that excitement are not more obvious and further advanced in those experiments , where nothing was done to intercept its course for forty-eight hours , than in those where all communication between the uterus and ovary had been cut off before the means for impregnation had been employed ?
We should exipect in the one case to find the full effects of impregnation , and in the other no traces of it would be seen ; instead of which , the procreative actions are no further advanced where there has been an opportunity for the passage , of the semen , than , in those cases where the passage has been impossible .
But if we defer the mutilation until the ovary has perfected its work , which it does in a rabbit in something more than fifty hours from the approach of the male , then the generative process isnot disturbed , and the evolution of the foetus , goes on in the usual manner ; for now all the different parts of theuterine system being in a condition to act , each performs its peculiar office .
First .
The semen by its presence stimulates either the van gina , os uteri , cavity of the uterus , or all of them .
Secondly .
The impression made on these is propagated to the ovaries by consent of parts .
Thirdly .
One or more of the ovarian vesicles enlarges , projects , bursts , and discharges its contents .
Fourthly .
During this process in theovary , the tube is uni dergoing a state of preparation for the purpose of embracing the ovary , and receiving the rudiments of the foetus .
Ffithly .
This preparation consists in part of an increased turgescence of its vessels , and a consequent enlargement of its fimbriated extremity .
When thus prepared , it approaches the ovary .
Sixthly .
After the tube has performed its office by a peristaltic motion , commencing at the fimbriae , and terminating in the uterus , it gradually returns to its former situation and condition .
Seventbly .
While these different actions are going on in the appendages of the uterus , others not less important to the design of nature are instituted in the uterus itself : for the tunica decidua , where it is obvious , is formed ready to secure firmness of connexion between the tender ovum and internal surface of the uterus , until a proper attachment by means of placenta can be effected .
Eightdly .
By way of guarding with additional security against a premature escape of the ovum , an apparatus , seated in the neck and mouth of the womb , now begins to develope its real structure , and perform its proper action , consisting in the secretion of a mucus-like substance , .
sufficient in quantity to fill completely the whole length of the neck , and by that means to seal up the communication between the cavity of the uterus and vagina .
Ninthly .
Nor does the care of nature for the preservation of the new animal terminate here ; for while she is by various means forming and perfecting her work , at least as far as comes within the province of the uterine system , she is at the same time making preparation for its nourishment after birth , by instituting the proper secretion of the breasts .
When we take a reflected survey of these successive opera .
tions , I think it must appear , , on tracing nature 's steps through the different stages of this work , that they are the product of that law in the constitution which is called SYMPATHY , or consent of parts .
That the semen first stimulates the vagina , os uteri , cavity of the uterus , or all of them .
By sympathy the ovarian vesicles enlarge , project , and burst .
By sympathy the tubes incline to the ovaries , and having embraced them , convey the rudiments of the foetus into the uterus .
By sympathy the uterus makes the necessary preparation for perfecting the formation and growth of the foetus .
And , By sympathoy the breasts furnish milk for its support after birth .
Having now investigated this intricate question , I hope with some regularity the design of this essay next leads me to consider the state or form of that substance which passes from the ovaries in consequence of impregnation .
SECTION III .
What is the Form of that Substance which passes from the Ovaries in consequence of Impregnation ?
No sooner had the researches of the physiologists retraced the existence of the new-born animal to the ovaries , than their curiosity was excited to discover the form it assumed while resident in these bodies , and especially at that particular time when the foetal primordia are about to escape from them .
The analogous phenomena of oviparous animals , and the structure of the ovaries as described by DE GRAAF , concurred to favour an opinion , that in viviparous animals there existed ova in these bodies , and indeed from this very circumstance they received their name .
But though several physiologists have concurred in this opinion , there has not been any strict coincidence respecting their state while in the ovary .
Some have thought that the vesicles described by DE GRAAF were the true ova , and that these are the bodies that are expelled by impregnation .
Others , with greater probability , have considered these vesicles as the apparatus destined by nature , under the influence of the proper ' stimulus , to form the ovum : and though at all times they contain a glairy kind of fluid , from the stimulus of impregnation this fluid becomes a small vesicle or ovum seated within the larger vesicle , which now becoming thickened , and acquiring a yellow colour , is called the corpus lu.cum : from this body the interior vesicle or ovum is protruded .
Others again refuse assent to both these opinions , and contend that the substance extruded from the corpora lutea has no vesicular appearance and though by some it has been called an ovum , yet that name is not applicable to it from any resemblance of figure , but rather from its agreement with an egg in being the substance in which the rudiments .
of the future animal are contained , DE GRAAF contended that the primordia foetus while in the ovary is vesicular , as appears in his work ; in which , after describing the enlargement of the proper vesicles usually connected with his name , he says , " I praterea aliquot post coitum cdiebus tenuiori substantia proediti sunt , et in sui medio " limpidum liquorem membrana inclusum continent , quo una " cum membranaA foras propulso , exigua solum in iis capacitas " superest .
" He is therefore decidedly of opinion , that as soon as the product of conception becomes the subject of notice , it has a vesicular form , and this he thinks takes place at the end of the third day , though the substance passes from the ovaries several hours before this time .
He seems rather to assert , that it passes in a vesicular form , than to prove it ; for in fifty-two hours after the approach of the male , he found the ovarian vesicles were empty , though he could not now find the new vesicles either in the uterus or the tubes .
But in seventy-two hours they were so evident , that he could distinguish with ease the two membranes of which they are formed , viz. the chorion and amnios ; so that they cannot be very small at this time .
Hence it would follow , that if on a repetition of this experiment on the third day no vesicles should , happen to be found , it would not-be from minuteness that they would escape observation ; therefore should any one be disposed to search for them , he need not bend his sight , as if looking at microscopical objects .
VALISNERI on the contrary searched for these eggs with great industry , accompanied with an ardent wish to find them ; but though his experiments appear to have been judiciousy -conducted , he never succeeded .
HALLER .
also maintains , from a regular series of expe-riments made on sheep ( whose term of utero-gestation is five months ) , that some days e apse between the -escape of the substance from the ovaries , and the appearance of a circumscribed body in utero , which can properly be called ovum : and that this does not happen until seventeen days from impre gnation .
In the mean time , nothing but irregular masses of mucus are found .
The circumscribed form at this time acquired seems to depend on the formation of the foetal membranes now bounding the contained miucus-like substance .
This apparently homogeneous mass , on the nineteenth day un dergoes a change of character an opaque spot is seen within it , which subsequent observations prove to be the first evident marks of the evolution or formation of the foetus .
From this dim speck of animal existence we may observe a series of regular advances , from an iinorganiized mucus-like mass to the most beautiful and complicated machine in nature .
But to trace her progressive steps through this important work , forms no part of the design of this dissertation .
The chief difference between 'DE GRAAF and LIALLER on this subject , consists in their opinions respecting the form of the substance that is passing from the ovaries , whether it is vesicular at this time or not ; for in the subsequent processes they differ but little .
No solution can be given of this question by force of reasoning ; it is from experiment alone that we can receive conviction , notwithstanding the two contrary opinions that prevail .
All that can be expected from an individual in such -a case , is to add the result of his own labours to one side or the other , so that in the end te preponderance must depend on the weight of evidence .
The experiments I have made on this simple question do not allow me to incline to the side of DE GRAAF -for in the rabbit I have never found any thing in the uterus which had a regular circumscribed form earlier than the sixth day , and even then the substance was bounded by a covering so very tender , that it scarcely had firmness sufficient to support the figure .
Before the sixth day , I have never seen any thing but irregular mucus-like masses in the uterus ; but after this ti-me the substance has firmness sufficient to admit of preservation in spirits , a specimen of which I have in my collection of preparations .
This acquisition of figure does not depend so much on a difference of consistence , as on the formation of membranes enclosing this substance .
These membranes when in a more advanced state of formation , are known by the names of chorion and amnios .
The product of conception being arrived at thisstage , may with some propriety be called an ovum , as it has acquired a determined figure ; but the different constituent parts of it are not apparent at this early period ; on the tenth day , in the rabbit , an opaque spot is seen in this ovum , which increasing daily in its bulk , progressively manifests the formation of the foetus .
It is a little remarkable that in the rabbit , where the term of utero-gestation does not exceed thirty days , a third part of that time should be required to make that opaque spot obvious to the sight , whilst the remaining two-thirds should suffice to complete the formation of the foetus .
It appears as if it required a more elaborate exertion of the formative powers of these parts to produce what might figuratively be called the nucleus of a foetus , than to go on and complete the work .
But this remark applies only to the rabbit for in the human female , abortions at the third month clearly prove that the evolution of the foetus has been perfected some time before .
Such an obvious , difference cannot fail to impress our minds with doubts and distrust , whenever we are drawing inferences from analogical reasonings : but to trace the formative process of nature through this work , and to compare her progres- .
sive advances in the different periods of utero-gestation , are foreign to the design of this essay .
It remains then for me to beg pardon for having so long trespassed on the patience of this Society .

