VII .
Experiments and Observations , made with t Yew f ascertaining the Nature of the Gaz produced by passing Electric Discharges through Water .
By George Pearson , MD. DF .
R.S Read February 2 , I797 . ?
to IN the )7ournal de Physique for the month of November , 1789 , were published the very curious and interesting experiments of Messrs. PAETS VAN TRoosTrWYK and .
DEIMAN ; which were .
made with the assistance of Mr. CUTHBERTSON ; on the apparent decomposition'of water by electric discharges .
The apparatus employed was a tube i2 inches In length , and its bore was -f of an inch in diameter , English measure ; which was hermetically sealed at one end , but before it was sealed , 1 inch of gold or platina wire was introduced within the tube , and fixed into the closed end by melting the glass around the extremity of the wire .
Another wire of platina , or of gold with platina wire at its extremity , immersed in quicksilver , was introduced at the open end of the tube , which extended to within 58 of an inch of the upper wire , which , as was just said ; was fixed into the sealed extrmxity .
; The tube was filled with distilled water , which had been freed from air by means of CUTHBERTSON 's last improved air pump , of the greatest rarefying power .
As the open end of the tube was immersed in quicksilver , a little common air was let up into the convex part of the cured end of the tube , with the view of preventing fracture from the electrical discharge .
The wire which passed through the sealed extremity was set in contact with a brass insulated ball ; and this insulated ball was placed at a little distance from the prime conductor of the electrical machine .
The wire of the lower or open extreimity , immersed in quicksilver , communicated by a wire or chain with the exterior coated surface of a Leyden jar , which contained about a square foot of coating ; and the ball of the jar was in contact with the prime conductor .
The electrical machine consisted of two plates of 31 inches in diameter , and was similar to that of TEYLER .
It had the power of causing the jar to discharge itself 25 times in i5 revolutions .
When the brass ball and that of the prime conductor were in contact , no air or gaz was disengaged from the water by the Electrical discharges ; but on gradually increasing their distance from one another , the position was found in which gaz was disengaged ; and which ascended immediately to the top of the tube .
By continuing the discharges , gaz was discharged till it reached to nearly the lower extremity of the upper wire , and then adischarge occasioned the whole of the gaz to disappear , a small portion excepted , and its place was consequently supplied by water. .
From my own experience I should venture to affirm , that a more particular and more accurate account than that published , is requisite , to enable the student , or even the proficient , to Institute the above experiment with success .
Hence , during the six or seven years which have elapsed since its publication , no confirmation has been published , ; ecept the experiment re- , peated by Mr. .
CUTHBERTSON for my satisfaction , as related in my work on the Chemical Nomenclature ; although I have heard of many persons , and some of them experienced electricians and chemists , who have made the attempt .
But by labouring with Mr. CUThBERTSON , since he came to reside in London , I have learned the circumstances on which the success of the experiment depends ; and I have received from him effectual aid in continuing a process , with the objects I had in view , the tediousness and even difficulties of which can only be conceived by those who have been engaged in the same pursuit .
In the course of my experiments on this subject , Mr. CUTHBERTSON invented a new method-of disengaging gaz from water , by means of the electrical discharges , namely , by means of uninterrupted or complete discharges ; whereas the method of Mr. VAN TROOSTWYK was by interrupted discharges .
The rationale of the process according to these two methods , I apprehend , cannot be understood without an explanation ; for I find books on electricity do not contain the necessary information .
In the experiment of Mr. VAN T.RoOSTWYK , it must be con.i sidered , that if in place of water the tubes be filled with air , the whole of the charge of the Leyden jar will pass , at each explosion , from the upper to the under wire , and no interruption in the discharge will happen ; but if they are filled with water , then an interrupted discharge may be caused : by which is meant , that a part of the charge only passes at each explosion through the water from wire to wire , and with much diminished velocity .
The residuary electricity in the Leyden jar is nearly one half , as may be accurately demonstrated .
The reason of these differences must be assigned from the ; difference in point of density , elasticity , and conducting power , of the medium of water and of air .
It must be added , that although water in large quantity is a good conductor , and air is not , yet water being here in very small quantity it proves a bad conductor ; as is the case with the very best conductors .
A cubic foot of water is only just capable of -receiving , or letting pass through it , a full discharge from a jar of -one foot of coated surface- ; and the quantity of water employed in this experiment not being iO part of a cubic foot it is a very imperfect conductor ; so that an anterrupted discharge only can pass through the tube , without dispersing the whole of the water .
But if , the discharge be not seemingly as strong as the tube can bear without breaking , the gaz is not produced from it ; and on this point hinges this extremely delicate process .
The situation of the different parts of the apparatus for the interrupted discharge is shown by Tab. III .
fig. 5 .
To succeed by the method of the Complete or uninterrupted discharge , the apparatus now to bedescribed must be used , and the following -rules must be observed .
i. A~tube , fig. 6 .
is employed about fouror five inches in length , and its bore one-fifth or one-sixth of an .
inch in diameter .
One end is mounted with a Qbrass tube , fi g. 7 .
and the_ : other end is sealed at the lamp with a wire , about o of an inch in thickness , fixed into it , as above described which extends into the brass tube , so as to be almost in contact where the explosion is made .
If the wire touches the brass tube , there will be no gaz produced .
The tube being filled with water , and set in a cup of water , the discharge may be made into it , as in the above described process of Mr. VAN TROOSTWYK , ; but here the insulated ball must be placed at a greater distance from the prine conductor , and"a Leyden jar with only fiy square inches of coating will answer the purpose .
In this way of making ; the experit mentf gaz is produced by each discharge , in the brass tube ; and in much greater quantity , and with much less frequent accidents , and less trouble , than in the former method with the interrupted discharge .
But the gaz obtained with .
this appa , ratus always contains a large proportion of atmospherical air , on account of the quantity of water and more immediate and extensive communication ' of it with the atmosphere .
By repeated discharges there is an impression made.in the brass tubbe , in the part where the discharge passes through it , and atlast a small hole is made in that part .
On this account the same mounted tube Cannot serve for producing a large quantity of gaz .
S. The other sort of apparatus , invented by Mr. CUTHBERTSON , is representedby fig.8 .
At first it consisted of a glass tube half an inch wide , .
and about five inches in length , mounted at one end with ma brass funnel , and inverted in a brass dish ; but afterwards the tube was blovns funnel-wise at the end , as shown by fig. 9 .
The other end must have a wire , about o of an inch thick , sealed into it at the lamp ; which wire extends to nearly the bottom of the brass dish in which the tube stands .
The exact distance between the end of the wire and brass dish must be found by trials ; that which generally answered in my experiments was about 2x0 of an inch .
If it be properly arranged , gaz will ' be produced at each discharge .
The Leyden jar used with this , apparatus , : , must contain about i5o square inches of coating .
The distance between the insulated ball , and the prime cone " ductor , att which the experiment succeeded , -was.commonly about half an inch .
If experiments be proposed , in which electric discharges must be passed through water , or other fluids , for even a much longer time than was consumed in perforiming those referred to , or related in this paper ; it may be an object to employ the wind , or perh~aps the power of a horse , to turn the electrical machines ; the expense of labourers being considerable . ? ?
2 .
EXPERIMENTS .
From my journal of the , numerous experiments , made during the course of nearly two years , I shall select those which will serve to explain the nature of the process , and show the power of the plateelectrical machines ; and I shall particularly relate those experiments which afforded the most useful results concerning the nature of the gaz obtained .
i. With interrupted Discharges .
Experiment A. About i Goo of these discares , by means of a. thirty-four inch single plate electrical machine , in nearly three hours , produced , from New River water taken from the cistern , and which had not been freed from air by the air pump or boiling , a column of gaz two-thirds of an inch in length and one-ninth of an inch wide .
On passing through this gaz between the two wires of the tube in which it was produced , a single electric spark , its bulk was instantly diminished to two-thirds .
In other experiments the bulk of gaz was -only diminished to about one half .
And the result was the same with distilled water .
B. The:experiment A being repeated several times , with distilled and New River water , freed from air by the air pump or loing boiling , thequantity of gaz just mentioned Was obtained in about four hours .
On passing an electric spark through this gazp in the situation above'mentioned , its bulk was instantly diminished , din some cases 44 , and in others 44 .
C. i6oo interrupted 'discharges , by means of a thirty-two inch plate machine , produced , from New River water and distilled water freed from their air by the air pump , a column of gaz about three-fourths of an inch in length , and one-ninth of an inch in diameter , in the space of three hours .
It was reduced in bulk 44 by passing through it a single electric spark .
D 50oo revolutions of the thirty-two inch plate machine , in three quarters of an hour , produced 60o interrupted discharges in river water , freed ' from air by the air pump , by which 'Ia column of gaz , half an inch in Iength and one-tenth of an ' inch in diameter , was obtained .
It was diminished , as usual , by an electric spark , 44 of its bulk .
E. Nearly four days incessant labour , with the thirty-two inch plate machine , produced only 56,5488 cubes of gaz , of one-tenth of an inch each ; on account of the usual : accidents during the process .
The air had 'been exhausted , by setting the water under the'-receiver of the air pump .
F. It was found that Goo interrupted discharges produced about three inches in length of gaz , measured in a tube &amp; -Lof an inch in width , from water out of which its air had been drawn by the air pump .
G. It appeared , from many experiments , that the'same unboiled water , or water from which the air had not been exhausted by the air pump , which had repeatedly yielded gaz by passing through it electric discharges , always left a residue of gaze , which the electric spark did not diminish ; and this residue was in nearly the same quantity , after six or seven -experiments , each of which afforded a column of gz , half an inch in length , and one-ninth of an inch in diameter , as was left on passing the electric spark through the gaz , afforded by the third or fourth experiment .
Hence it seems , that water is decompounded by the electric discharge , before the whole of the -common or atmospherical air is detached from the water , by merely the impulse of each discharge .
Yet I think it probable that , after the discharges have been passed through the same water for a certain time , the whole of the air contained ; in water will be expelled , and no gaz be produced , but that compounded by means of the electric fire from water ; in which case , supposing the gaz -so produced to be at last merely hydrogen and oxygen gaz , it will totally disappear on passing through it an electric spark .
-But I have never been able to determine this point ; because the tubes were always broken after obtainingax few products , or long before it could reasonably be ; supposed the whole of the air of the water-was expelled from it .
H. To the gaz obtained in the experiment E was added , over water , an equal bulk of almost pure nitrous gaz .
Fumes of nitrous acid appeared and the gaz examined was reduced almost one-third of its bulk .
A small bubble more of nitrous gaz being let up no further diminution took place .
To this residue was added half its bulk of oxygen gaz , obtained from oxymuriate of potash.:this mixture , of gazes having stood several days over well burnt lime and boiled quicksilver , an electric spark was passed through the mixture , over quicksilver ; by which its bulk was instantly diminished one-fourth .
But -no moisture could be perceived upon the sides of the tube , or on the quicksilver .
Thefailure of the appearance of moisture was imputed to a bit of lime accidentally left in the Dtube , which was burst by the explosion and dispersed through the tube ; or else the quantity of water produced was so small , comparatively with the residuary gaz , that the water was dissolved by it in the moment of its composition .
For supposing water to have been compounded , it could not amount to the NO part of a grain ; and the residuary gaz was at least two thousand times this bulk .
That a quantity of water can be compounded , under the same circumstances as in this experiment , and be apparently dissolved in air , so as to escape observation , even with a lens , was proved by passing an electric spark through a mixture of hydrogen and oxygen gaz , well dried by standing over lime .
2 .
With complete or uninterrupted Discharges .
The gaz obtained by the first described kind of apparatus , for the uninterrupted discharges , p. 145 , and fig. 6 and 7 , always left a residue of at least one-fourth of its bulk on passing through it the electric spark ; even when water was used , which had been freed from air by boiling , or the air pump .
Nor will this result appear surprising , when it is considered how liable the water in this apparatus 'is to mix and absorb air during the experiment .
However , this method would have been extremely valuable if the next other method had not been discovered ; for gaz may be obtained by it with fewer accidents , and much more rapidly , than with the interrupted discharges .
The apparatus is also much more easily fitted up , and is more simple .
But I think it unnecessary to particularly relate any experiments , as they afforded the same results as those already described , and as those next to be related .
The following experiments were made with the apparatus described p. 146 , and shown by fig. 8 , 9 , and 10 .
Experiment i. At 0h 40 ' P. M. began to produce discharges with a double plate twenty-four inch machine , in water taken from the cistern : and at 12h 6 ' P. M. of the same day there had been written down 10200 discharges , each of which occasioned air to ascend from the bottom of the wire and brass cup .
The quantity of air obtained was now apparently about one-fourth of a cubical inch , and it occupied nearly half of the tube ; the water in which was by this time very muddy .
After standing till the day following at noon , when the process was again commenced , it did not appear that any of the gaz had been absorbed by the water over which it stood .
At 3h 35 P. M. began to produce discharges , and at 8h P. M. had passed 6636 ; which , together with those of the preceding day , amounted to 16836 .
The tube was now 5full of gaz , and there seemed to be almost half a cubical inch ; for it was , o.served , that the gaz was this day yielded at double the rate it had been the day before .
This was accounted for from thediminished pressure upon the electric fire , by the tube containing gaz instead of water .
At this time , namely , at 8h P. M. I was surprised , on the passing of a discharge , by a vivid illumination of the whole tube , and a violent commotion within it ; with , at the same fime , the rushing up of water , instantly to occupy rather more tan Iof the space which had been .
occupied by gaz .
The residue of gaz was not diminished further by an electric spark ; and to the test of .
nitrous gaz it appeared to be rather worse than atmospherical air , as it consisted of rather less than one part of oxygen , and three parts of nitrogen or -azotic gaz .
It seemed as if the electrical discharge had kindled the oxygen and hydrogen gaz of the decompounded water , by flying from the bottom of the wire to the brass funnel ; so that the fire returned into the tube where it passed through the gaz .
Or the combustion might be occasioned by a chain of bubbles , reaching from the brass dish to the surface of the water in the tube , which was set on firein its ascent , and thus produced combustion of the whole of the gaz of decompounded water .
That this phenomenon was from the combustion here supposed , was in some degree proved by finding that the mixture of hydrogen gaz and atmospherical air , under the same circumstances , was kindled in the same manner .
Experiment ii .
With a double plate electrical machine , 24 inches in diameter , and a similar apparatus to that in the last experiment , 1 4600 discharges produced , at least , one-third of a cubical inch of gaz .
While I was measuring with a pair of compasses the quantity of gaz produced , the points of them being in contact with the part of the tube occupied by gaz , I was again surprised , on the passing of a discharge , by an illumination of the whole tube , and the rushing up , with considerable commotion , of water , to occupy about two-thirds of the space filled by gaz .
The residuary air was found , as in the former experiment , to be rather worse than atmospherical air .
It was concluded that the points of the compasses had attracted electrical fire from the wire to the sides of the glass , and thereby kindled the hydrogen and oxygen gaz of decompounded water .
But to determine this question , I introduced into the same tube a mixture of one measure of oxygen and two measures of hydrogen gaz , to occupy nearly the same space in the tube as the gaz had occupied : then passing an electrical discharge fthroughXit 'no combustion was excited , ; but on passing a discharge while the compasses were in contact with the tube , as just mentioned , an illumination and violent commotion were produced , with the rushing up of water , to leave only 8 of the gaz as a residue .
On repeating this experiment with one measure of atmospherical .
air and two of hydrogen gaz , combustion could not be excited ; nor with two measures of atmospherical air and one of hydrogen ; nor with two measures of hydrogen gaz and.one of atmospherical air ; but on addi ptg to this last mixture one measure of oxygen gaz , the electric ischarge produced the phanomena of combustion just mentioned , with the rushing upof water , to occupy about two-thirds of the space which was occupied by the gazes .
Experiment iii .
Having passed 10ooo discharges .
through water , with the apparatus of the preceding experiment , and thereby obtained only one-fifth of a cubical inch of gaz ; and having observed that the quantity of gaz was not greater than it was when only 80oo discharges had beenpassed , and yet bubbles had been seen to be produced on each .
discharge as copiously , or more so , by the last 3 or 4000 discharges as before ; I began to suspect that part of the gaz had been destroyed during the process , or had been absorbed .
While I was considering how to account for thisdisappearance of gaz , and was at the same time looking at the tube through which the discharges were passing , I observed one of them to be atended with a diminution , instantly , 'of about one-fifth of the gaz produced , and with a slight commotion .
I wwas now sure , from this phaxnomenon , and from the unequal augmentation of the bulk of the , gaz at given times during the process , that combustion had been excited several times before ; not only in the present experiment , but perhaps in the former ones , without observing it .
I conceived that a gradual combustion also , very probably , took place in this process , by the kindling of bubbles of gaz in their ascent through the water .
I now perceived that the discharges ought to be produced more slowly , or the tubes to be wider , to allow the bubbles to pass quite through the water , in order to avoid the accension of gaz during the process .
My calculation also , that 35 to oo0o discharges were requisite to produce one cubical inch of gaz from water , containing its usual quantity of common air , was rendered much more vague by this accenSion , so often liable to be occasioned .
To the gaz which remained in the tube in this experiment was added an equal bulk of nitrous gaz ; the mixture diminished to 1,5 ; and on adding to the residue half its bulk of oxygen gaz , and passing through it the electrical spark , no accension or diminution of bulk was produced .
Hence all the hydrogen gaz and oxygen gaz , produced by the decomposition of the water , had been burnt during the process ; the oxygen gaz thus detected being considered to be only that expelled from the water .
Experiment io By means of electrical discharges , with the apparatus used in the preceding experiment , I obtained gaz froam New River water ; letting it up into a reservoir as soon as about ir of a cubic inch was produced , till I had collected I of a cubic inch .
To this was added an equal bulk of nitrous gaz ; on which the mixture diminished to 1,2 ; and on the addition of a little more -nitrous gaz , no further di.minution took place .
To this residue half its bulk of oxygen gaz was added , and this mixture of gazes being well dried by standing over lime and boiled quicksilver , an electric spark was passed through it , by which a diminution of 6L of its bulk took place .
A little dew was then seen , upon the sides of the tube where the quicksilver had risen ; and , with the aid of a lens , the same appearance was perceived on the part of the tube containing the residue of gaz .
It may now be expected , that I should have made the experiments with this apparatus on distilled water freed from its air , not only by long boiling , or the air pump , but by passing through it several hundred electrical discharges .
It would also have been , to some persons , more satisfactory , if the experiments had been made upon a larger scale , so as to have produced the combustion of a much larger quantity of gaz , and consequently have produced a greater quantity of water .
As , however I apprehend , the experiments contained in this paper , when well considered , by competent judges , will be found to explain the nature of the gaz procured from water by electrical discharges ; and as another very important subject demands my attention , the honour of more splendid and convincing experiments must be reserved for other inquirers .
If the same sacrifices -be made by them , which have been nmde in performing the present experiments , I think it is scarcely possible but that still further light concerning the composition of water should be obtained , as well as concerning oils , alcohol , acids , &amp;c. ; to the investigation of the composition of which , the mode of analysis and synthesis here indicated , may be applied . ? ?
3 .
The following conclusions appear to me obvious and incon-I trovertible .
The mere concussion by the electric discharges seems to extricate not only the air dissolved in water , which can be separated from it by boiling and the air pump , but also that which remains in water , notwithstanding these means of extricating it have been employed .
The quantity of this air varies in the same and in different waters , according to circumstances .
New River water from the cistern yielded one-fifth of its bulk of air , when placed under the receiver of Mr. CUTHBERTSON'S most powerful air pump ; but , in the same situation , New River water taken from a tub exposed to ' the atmosphere for a long time yielded its own bulk of air .
-Hence the gaz produced by the first one , two , or even three hundred explosions in water , containing its natural quantity of air , is diminished very little -by an electrical spark .
The gaz or air , thus separable from water , like atmospherical air , consists of oxygen and nitrogen or azotic gaz ; which .
may be in exactly the same proportions as in atmospherical air , for the water may retain one kind of gaz more tenaciously than the other ; and on this account the air separated may be better or worse than atmospherical air , in different periods of the process for extricating it .
The nature of the gaz , which instantly disappears on passing through it an electric spark , is shown by ( a ) This very property of thus diminishing ; and by the following properties ; ( b ) A certain quantity of nitrous gaz instantlydiappeared , apparently composing nitrous acid , on being added the gaz ( a ) p. i+9j , H. ; iS4 , Exp. IV .
; oxygen gaz being added to the residue after saturation with nitrous gaz , and an electric spark being applied to the mixture of gazes , well dried , a considerable diminution immediately took place , and water was produced ; p. 154 , EXp .
IV .
( c ) Combustion from hydrogen and oxygen gaz took place , when the tube was about three-fourths full of gaz , R.152 , Exp. I. which was confirmed by passing an electrical discharge , under the same circumstances , through a mixture of hydrogen and oxygen gaz , P. 152 , Exp. i. ( d ) Combustion from hydrogen and oxygen gaz took place , when the points of the compasses .
were accidentally applied to the .
part of the tube containing gaz , p. 152 , Exp. ii .
; which was , confirmed by passing a discharge , under the same circumstances , through a mixture of hydrogen and oxygen gaz , while the points of the compasses were applied to the .
' tube .
, ; p. i5j , Exp. II .
( e ) The observations made of the kindling of ' gaz in .
small quantities , from time to time , during the Iprocess of obtaining it , particularly while it was ascending in chains of bubbles , or was adhering to .
the funnel .
, of the tube , p. i 'j .
, Exp. Ill. confirm the evidence in favour of this gaz being hydrogen and oxygen gaz .
The -evidence contained under the heads ( a)-(e ) , considered .
singly and conjunctively , I apprehend , must be admitted by the most rigorous reasoner , to be demonstrative that hydrogen and oxygen gaz were produced by passing electric discharges through %water .
With regard to the origin and mode of production of these two gazes , our present observations and experiments do not afford complete demonstrative evidence ; but , although some hypotheses must be admitted , I conceive that the body of evidence we possess can afford a satisfactory interpretation of the phenomena .
EXPLANATION OF THE PLATE ( Tab. ILL .
) Fig. i , 2 , 3 , 4 .
represent the tubes used in producing gaz from water by the interrupted electric discharges .
Fig. A. represents the situation of the above tubes during the process of producing gaz from water .
Fig. 6 , 7 .
represent the tubes employed in producing gaz from ' water by the first method , with uninterrupted electric discharges .
Fig. 8 .
shows the figure of the tube mounted with a brass funnel , 'used in the second method of producing gaz from water by uninterrupted electric discharges .
Fig. 9 .
represents the tube blown funnel-wise at the end , instead of being mounted with a brass funnel , as in fig. 8 .
Fig. 8 .
represents the situation of the tubes fig. 8 .
and 9 .
during the process of producing gaz by the uninterrupted electric discharges .

