II .
Observations on horizontal Refractions whichb afect the Appearance of terrestrial Ojects , and the Dip , orDepression of the Horizon of the Sea .
By Joseph Huddart , Esq. F. R. S. Read November 24 , 1796 .
TIHE variation and uncertainty of thedip , in different states of the air , taken at the same altitude above the level of the sea , , was the occasion of my turning my thoughts to this subject ; as it renders the latitude observed incorrect , by givingan erroneous zenith distance of a celestial object .
I have often observed that low lands and the extremity of head lands or points , forming an acute angle with the horizon of the sea , and viewed from a distance beyond it , appear elevated above it , with an open space between the land and the , sea .
The most remarkable instance of this appearance of the land I observed at Macao , forseveral daysprevious to a typhoon , in which the Locko lost her-topmasts in Macao foads ; the points of the islands and low lands appearing the highest , and the spaces between them and the sea the largest , I ever saw .
I believe it arises , and is proportional to the evaporation going on from the sea ; and in reflecting upon this pharnomenon , I am convinced that those appearances must arise from refraction , and that instead of the density of the atmosphere increasing to .
the surface of the sea , it must decrease from some space above it , ; and that evaporation is ' the principal cause which prevents the uniformity of density and refraction being continued , by the general law , down to the surface of the earth:1.and I am inclined to believe , though I mention it here asa conjecture , that the difference of specific gravity in the particles of the atmosphere may be a principal agent in evaporation ; .for the.corpuscles of air , from their affinity with water , being -combined at the surface of the fluid from expansion , _form air specifically lighter than the drier atmosphere ; and therefore float , or rise , from that principle , .
as steam from water ; and in their rising ( the surrounding corpusc^les from the same cause imbibing a part of the moisture ) , become continually drier as Xthey ascend , yet continue ascending until they become equally dense with the air.* However , these conjectures I shall leave , and proceed to the following observations upon refractions .
In the year 1793 , when at Allonby , in Cumberland , I made some remarks on the appearance of the Abbey Head , in Galloway , which in -distance from Allonby is aboutseven leagues ; and from my window , at fifty feet above the level of the sea at that time of tide , I observed.:the appearance of the land about the Head as represented in TFab .
I. fig. 1i .
There was a dry sand , ry , called Robin Rigg , between me and the Head , at the distance from my house of between three and our miles over which I saw the horizon of the sea , H-0 ; the sand at this time was about three or four feet above the level of the sea .
The hummock d is a part of the head land , but appeared insulated or detached from the rest , and considerably elevated above the sea , with an open space -between .
I then came -down about twenty-five feet , when I had the dry sand of Robin Rigg , x y , in the apparent horizon , and lost all that floating appearance seen from above , and the Abbey Head appeared every where distinct to the surface of the sand ; this being in the afternoon , the wet or moisture on the sand would in a great measure be dried up .
I have reason , therefore , to I conclude that evaporation is the cause of a less refraction near the surface of the sea ; and when so much so as to make an object appear elevated wholly above the horizon , ( as at d in fig. i. ) there will from every point of this object issue two pencils of rays of light , whichenter the eye of the observer ; and that below the dotted line AB ( parallel to the horizon of the sea H 0 ) , the objects on theland will appear inverted .
Tro explain this phenomenon,.I shall propose the following theory , and compare it with the observations which I have made .
Suppose H 0 , fig. 2 .
to represent the horizontal surface of the sea , and the parallel lines above it , the lamina or strata of corpuscles , which next the fluid are most expanded , or the rarest ; and every lamina upwards increasing in density till it arrive at a maximum ( and which I shall in future call the maximum of density ) at the line D C , above which it again decreases in density ad infinitum .
Though this in reality may be the case , I do not wish to extend the meaning of the word density farther , than to be taken for the refractive power of the atmosphere ; that is , a ray of light entering obliquely a denser lamina to be refracted towards a perpendicular to its surface ; and in entering a rarer lamina , the contrary ; which laminae being taken at infinitely small distances the ray of light will form a curve , agreeable to the laws of dioptrics .
In order to establish this principle in horizontalrefractions , I traced over various parts of this shore at different times , when those appearances seemed favourable , with a good telescope , and found objects sufficient to confirm it ; though it be difficult at that distance of the land to get terrestrial objects well defined so near the horizon , as will afterwards appear .
One day observing the land elevated , and seeing a small vessel at about eight miles distance , I from my window directed my telescope to her , and thought her a fitter object than any other I had seen for thepurpose of explaining the phamo-n mena of these refractions .
The telescope was forty feet above the level of the sea .
The boat 's mast about thirty-five feet , she being about twenty to thirty tons burden .
The barometer at 29,7 inches , and FAHRENHEIT'S thermometer at 54 .
The appearance of the vessl , asmagnified in the telescope , was as represented in fig. 3 , and from the mast head to the boom was well defined .
I pretty distinctly saw the head and shoulders of the man at the helm ; but the hull of the vessel was contracted , confused , and ill defined the inverted image began to be well defined at the boom ( for I could not clearly perceive the man at the helm inverted ) , and from the boom to the horizon of the sea the sails were well defined , and I could see a small opening above the horizon of the sea , in the angle made by the gaff and mast ; and had the -mast been shorter by ten feet ( to the height of y ) , the whole would have been elevatedabove the horizon of the sea , and from y to d an open space .
This drawing was taken from a sketch I took at the time , and represents the proportion of the inverted to the erect object , as near as I could take it by the eye , the former being about two-thirds of the latter in height , and the same breadth respectively ; though at one time during my obserzation , which I continued for about an hour , I thought the 'inverted nearly as tall as the erect object .
The day was fine and clear , with a very light air of wind , and I found very little tremor or oscillationin viewing her through the telescope .
I have laid down fig. 4 .
for the explanation of the above phenomenon , in which A represents the window I viewed B the vessel from ; H0 , the curved , surface of the 'sea ; CD parallel to H 0 .
the height of the maximum of density of the atmosphere ; the lines marked with the small letters a a , b b , c c , d d , the pencils of rays under their various refractions from the vessel to the eye , or object glass of the telescope .
The pencil of rays a a , from a point near the head of the mainsail , is wholly refracted in a curve convex upwards , being every where above the maximum of density ; , and the pencil of rays d d , which issues from the same point in tho-sail , and passes near the horizon of the sea at -x , is convex upwards from the sail to W where it passes the line of maximum of density , which is the point of inflection ; there it becomes convex downwards , passing near the horizon at x to y , where it is again inflected , and becomes convex upwards from thence to the eye .
The pencil of rays b b , from the end of the boom , passing nearly parallel to the horizon , and near the maximum of density , suffers very little deviation from a right line in the first part ; but in ascending ( from the curvature of the sea ) will be convex upwards to the eye .
The pencil of rays c c , from the same point in the boom , may have the small part to c convex upwards , from c to z it will be convex downwards , and from z to the eye convex upwards .
From this investigation it appears , that two pencils of rays cannot pass from the same point , and enter the eye , from the law of refraction , except one pencil .
pass through a medium which the other has not entered ; and -therefore the maximum of density was below the boom , and could not exceed ten feet of height above the surface of the sea at the time these observations were made .
Respecting the hull of the vessel being confused , and ill defined in the telescope , as by fig. A , it arises from the blending of the rays , from the different parts of the object , refracted through the two mediums ; some parts of the hull appearing erect , and some inverted .
Suppose the dotted line ii , fig. , an indefinite pencil of rays , passing from between the inverted and erect parts of the object , or the upper part of the hull of the vessel , to the eye , ( for the lower part of the hull could not be observed ) : the objects cannot appear inverted , except the angles at the eye aAc and and , exceed the angle aAi ; for the intermediate space could only be contracted by the secondary pencils of rays .
The lengths of the inverted , compared with the erect image of the sail , is as the sines of the angles at the eye aAi to iAd ; and the angle at the eye and , made by the two pencils of rays from the same point near the head of the sail must be double the angle a Ai , when the inverted image is as tall as the erect .
In this case , the sines of the angles aAb , a Ac , a Ad fig. 4 , are proportional to the altitudes 4b , a c , a di in the magnified view of the vessel , fig. A. Under this consideration no inverted image of the sail will be formed , until the angle at the eye , made by the two refracted pencils of rays aa and d d , exceed the angle made by a a , and b b , the apparent height of the sail of the vessel ; for were thoseangles equal , the inverted sail would only be contracted -into the parallel of altitude of the boom b , and render the appearance confused , as in the hull of the vessel : .
Respecting the existence of two pencils of rays7 entering the eye from every point of an object not more elevated than a , or less than i , fig. A , in this state of the atmosphere , I cannot bring a stronger proof than that of the strength of a light when the rays pass near the horizon of the sea , proved by the following observations .
Going down Channel about five years ago in the Trinity yacht , with several of the elder brethren , to inspect the lighthouses &amp;c. I was told by some of the gentlemen , who had been on a former survey , that the lower light of Portland was not so strong as the upper light , at near distances , but that at greater distances itwas much stronger .
I suspected that this difference arose from the lower light being at or near the horizon of the sea , and mentioned it at the time ; but afterwards had a good opportupity of making the observation .
We passed the Bill of Portland in the evening , steering towards the Start , a fresh breeze from the northward andclear night ; when we had run-about five leagues from the lights , during which time the upper light was universally allowed to be the stronger , several gentlemen keeping watch to make observations thereon , the lower light , drawing near the horizon , suddenly shone with double lustre .
Mr. STRACHAN , whose sight is weak , had for some time beforelost sight of both lights , , but could then clearly perceive the lower light .
I then went aloft , ( as well as others , ) but before I got half mast up , the lower light was weaker than the upper one ; on coming down upon deck , I found it again as strong as before.:We proceeded on , and soon lost the lower light from the deck ; andupon drawing the upper light near the horizon , it like the I former shone exceeding bright .
I again went aloft , when it diminished in brightness ; but from the masts head I could then see the lower light near the horizon as strong as before .
This is in consequence of the double quantity of light entering the eye by the two pencils of rays from every point .
To illustrate which , we compare the , vessel , fig. 4 , to a : lighthouse built upon the shore , and A the place of the observer ; and having brought down the light so low as to view it in the .
direction a a , another light would appear in the horizon at x from the pencil d d , ; and had the vessel been still enough to have observed it at this time with a good glass , I doubt not but the two images might have been distinctly seen : as the light dropped , ( by increasing the distance ) the two images would appear continually to approach each other , till blended with double light in one , and disappear at the altitude i , above the apparent horizon of the sea .
But , as explained before , if the strength of evaporation did not separate by refraction the pencils aa and d-d to a greater angle than double the angle that the lamps and reflectors appear under , the two images would be blended , and the strong appearance of light would be of shorter duration .
The distance run from the lights , during the time each of the lights shone bright , ,^would have been useful , but this did not occur at the time , nor have I had the like opportunity since .
However , I recommend to the mariner to station people at different heights in looking out for a light , in order to get sight of it -near the horizon , when it is always strongest .
Respecting the appearance of the Abbey Head before mentioned , fig. i , the dotted line AB represents the limit , or the lowest points of the land that can be seen over the sea ; for , as above stated , all the objects appearing below this line , are the land above it inverted ; and where the land is low , as at d and m , it must appear elevated above the horizon of the sea .
In fig. S. let H0 represent the curve of the ocean , and d the extreme top of the mount visible at A by the help of refraction ; the dotted pencil of rays cc passing from d to the'eye in some part a , little below the maximum of density , where inversion begins ; therefore no land lower than this can be seen ; , for any pencil from a point in the land lower than this , must in the refraction have a contrary flexure in the curve , and therefore pass above the , observer .
Let AD be a tangent to the curve at A , then the object d will appear to be elevated by refraction to D ; also let Av be a tangent to the pencil Ax Iat A , then the angle DAx will appear to be an open space , or between D and the horizon of the sea .
Suppose a star should appear very near and over the mount d , as at a , two pencils would issue from every point of it , and form a star below as well as above the hummock d. There are always confused or-ill defined images of the objects at the height of the dotted line , fig. i , above the level of the sea , as before mentioned ; and instead of the points of d ending sharp in that line , they appear blunted , and the Abbey Head is frequently insulated at the neck m. .
I have viewed , from an elevated situation , a point -or head land at a distance beyond the horizon of the sea , forming , as in fig. 6 .
a straight line A B , making an acute angle BA0 with the horizon of the sea .
Seeing the extreme point blunted and elevated , I descended ; and though in descending the horizon cut the land higher , as atH 0 , H 0 , yet the point had always the same appearance as a , a , a , fig. , 6 , though the land is known to continue in the direction of the straight line AB to beneath the horizon , or nearly so , as viewed from the height above .
If then from a low situation we view this head land through a telescope , the inclination of the surface AB to the horizon being known to be a straight line , it will appear as in fig. 7 .
the dotted line ( at the height of the point -where a perpendcular xy would touch the extreme of the land ) being at the limit or lowest point of erect vision .
And if a tangent to the curved appearance of the land a b , is drawn parallel to the inclined surface of the land A B , fig. 6 , touching it at C , the point C will show the height of the maximum of density , where the pencil of the rays of light , from thence to the eye , approachnearest the sea ; for pencils of rays from this land , taken at small distances from C , will form paralel curvs , nearly , through the refracting mediums , and C will be thepoint of greatest refraction ; for above C as at B the refraction somewhat decreasing , will appearbelow the line a b , or the parallel to the surface of the land , and the refractions decrease below the point C ; for had they increased uniformly down , to the surface of the sea , it would render the apparent angle of the point ; of land z more acute than , the angle Ca 0 , contrary to all observations .
Thius I have endeavoured to explain the phenomena of sthe distorted appearance of the landa near the horizon of the sea , when the evaporation is great ; and whel at the least , I never found the land quite free from it when , I useda telescope , ; and from thence infer , that .
wecannot have any expectation to ifind a true correction forte effect of terrestrial refraction , by taking any certain part 'of the contained arc ; for the points zC B , fig. 7 , will have various refractions , though they are at nearly the same distance from the observer .
An~d if the observations are made wholly over land , if the ground rises to within a small distance ; of the raays of light in their passage from the object to theeye , as well as at the situation of the object and observer , the refractions will be subject to be influenced by the ; evaporation of rains , dews , &amp;c. which is sufficiently proved by the observations of Colonel WILLIAMS , Captain .
MUDGE , andMr .
DALBY , Phil. Trans. 1795 , $ p. 583 .
The appearances mentioned by Colonel WILLIAMS , Captain MUDGE , and Mr. DALBY , ( Phil. Trans. 179 , p. 586 , 587 , ) cannot be demonstrated upon general principles as they arise from evaporation producing partial refractions .
In those general principles , it is supposed that the same lamina of density is every where at an equal distance from the surface of the-sea , at least as far as the eye can reach a terrestrial object ; but in the partial refractions , the lamina of the expanded or rarefied medium may be of various figures according to circumstances , which will refract according to the incidence of the rays , and affect the appearance of the land accordingly , which I have ' often seen to a surprising degree .
But my principal view is to show the uncertainty of the dip of the sea , and that the effect of evaporation tends to depress the apparent horizon at x , when the eye is not above the maximum of density ; and from hence the difficulty of laying down any correct formula for these refractions , whilst the law of evaporation is so little understood , which indeed seems a task not easy to surmount , The effect indicated by the barometer and the mometer is insufficient : and should the hygrometer be improved to fix a standard for moisture in the atmosphere , and show the variations near the surface of the ocean , which certainly must be taken into the account , ( evaporation going on quicker in : a dry than a moist atmosphere , ) the theory might still be incomplete for correcting the tables of the dip .
I shall therefore conclude this paper , by showing a method I used in practice , in order to obviate this error , in low latitudes .
When I was desirous to attain more accurately the latitude of any head land , &amp;c. in sight , I frequently observed the an- , gular distances of the sun 's nearest limb from the horizons , upon the meridian both north and south , beginning a few minutes before noon , and taking alternately the observations each way , from the poop , or some convenient part of the ship , where the s'un and the horizon both north and south were not intercepted ; and having found the greatest and least distances from the respective horizons , which was at the sun 's passing the meridian , and corrected both for refraction , by subtracting from the least , and adding to the greatest altitude , the quantity given by the table ; and also having corrected for the error of the instrument , and the sun s semidiameter ; the sum of these two angular distances , reduced as above , iSo , is equal to double the dip , as by the following EXAMPLE. .
The sun 's declination 3 ' so " north , and its semidiaiueter ~ ' 58 ' took the following observation : The meridian distance of the sun 's nearest limb from the South .
North- .
horizon of the sea _ 78 ? ?
36 ' S3o0"= lo t- ' sr , Refractionper table _o 1= 4 .
o 1t Distances corr .
for refraction = 78 36 19 0lot1 1 31 .
Error of the sextant +1+1 Xg Sun 's semidiameter +58+ 15 58 78 49 101 19 1 diffi orthe dip found -6 S 78 53 49 Altitudereduced = 78 47 24 io 12 50 Zenith distance =1s 36 ISO Diff. 12 50 The sun 's declination N. =4 32 S36 S2 Dip .
Latitude of the ship N. = ' 4.5 o6 I regret that I cannot in this paper insert the dip which I have found in my observations ; for I only retained the latitude of the ship determined thereby , as is usual at sea ; I generally rejected the error of the instrument , the dip , and semidiameter , as they affect both observations with the same signs , and reduced the observation by the following method : South : North .
Sun 's dist. as before 780 36 ' 3o0 1010 1 ' 20"I Refraction it +0 11 Dis.corr.forrefraction 78 36 19 101 1 31 1010 1 ' 31l + 78 36 19 Sum ofS .
diam. dip , and Sum " 79 37 So refraction = diff. + 115 i8 + II 5 78 47 24 Diff. 22 10 11 5 10l 12 36 90 90 The I dist. as before ii , 112 36 2D .
= 11 12 36 It may be observed , that neither the dip , semidiameter , or index error , can affect the zenith distance of the sun 's centre ; and the refraction being small near the zenith , the result must be true if the angles are accurately taken ; and it is only necessary to observe , that when the sum of the distances is less than 1800 , the half difference must be added to the distances , as by the last reduction .
There is a difficulty in making this observa. .
tion when the sun passes the meridian very near the zenith , as the change in azimuth from east to west is too quick to allow sufficient time ; nor can it be obtained by the sextant when the sun passes the meridian more than 3o degrees from the zenith ; for I never could adjust the back observation of the HADLEY'S quadrant with sufficient accuracy to be-depended upon .

