XXIII .
A Second Paper on Hygrometry .
By J. A. De Luc , Esq. F. R. S. Read July 14 , 1791 .
PART II .
IN the first part of this Paper *I have treated of the fundamental principles of hygrometry , and of some hygroscopic phenomenon ; and this will relate to a particular application of those premises .
62 .
Since the publication of my first hygrometer , many others have been invented , two of which are now principally in use ; the hair hygrometer of M. DE SAUSSURE , and my hygrometer made of a slip of whalebone .
If the comparative points of those instruments could be determined in the whole extent of their scales , the only inconvenience of their being both used would be , the necessity of reducing to one of them , the observations made with the other ; but from 70 to 100 of mine , which space includes the most important period of moisture , their correspondent indications are as different from one another , and as variable , as if they were the effects of two very different causes .
Therefore it is important to decide which of them should remain our only measure of moisture , till , if possible , a better one is found .
The following pages , I hope , will lead to that decision .
* See Page 1 .
of this Volume .
63 .
The fundamental process of M. DE SAUSSURE , with the view of discovering the effects of moisture on the hair hygrometer , was this .
He repeatedly caused successive known quantities of water to evaporate into a close glass vessel , previously reduced to extreme dryness , and containing that hygrometer and a manometer ; he observed the correspondent changes of those instruments , and , by combining the results of his experiments , he reduced to regular series the correspondent motions of the two instruments by equal quantities of evaporated water .
Having confined himself to that only class of experiments , which , from causes that I shall explain , could not discover to him the difficulties of his attempt , he thought himself warranted to draw from them the following conclusions .
1st , That the degrees of moisture in the enclosed medium , were nearly proportional to the quantities of water evaporated in the vessel ; and that , consequently , the ratio observed between those quantities and the march of his hygrometer , could be considered as giving immediately the march of the instrument correspondent to moisture itself ; which , according to our common opinion , is a certain quantity of aqueous vapours spread in the medium .
2dly , That when no more water could evaporate in the vessel , the enclosed medium was arrived at extreme moisture ; and that , consequently , the point indicated at that time on his hygrometer , was to be the limit of its scale on that side .
3dly , That having , from those experiments , a probable determination of the expansions of the hair by successive equal quantities of moisture , in beginning from the point were this is null , and ending at its extreme , his instrument could not differ essentially from an absolute hygrometer .
64 .
These conclusions were very natural in the state of M. DE SAUSSURE'S experiments ; but before their publication I had gone over a great field of hygroscopic phenomenon , in which the hair , and a close vessel , had a share ; and thereby , seeing the objects in another light than M. DE SAUSSURE , I doubted of his conclusions , and I procured three of his hygrometers , in order to examine them on some particular points .
It was after that immediate verification of my conjectures concerning his instrument , that I settled the following conclusions , very different from those above .
1 st , That MOISTURE , or the quantity of vapour spread in the medium itself , does not increase in an enclosed space in proportion to the quantity of water evaporated in it ; because of an increasing , but undetermined , part of that water being deposited on the sides of the vessel ; and that , consequently , Mr. DE SAUSSURE'S experiments could not afford the determination of a real hygroscopic-scale .
2dly , That the circumstance considered by him as a sure sign of extreme moisture existing in the enclosed medium , namely , the maximum of evaporation in the space , has only that effect when the temperature is very little above 32o ; but that , by successive increases of heat from that point , moisture recedes farther and farther from its extreme ; or from the point where no more vapour can be introduced in the medium without an immediate precipitation ; though at the same time , there are successive increases in the quantity of vapour , and thereby a constant maximum of evaporation correspondent with the actual temperature .
3dly , That , in approaching to extreme moisture , the hair hygrometer becomes stationary , and afterwards a little retrograde , in which march the unavoidable irregularities of every hygroscopic substance produce frequent anomalies ; from which cause it was very difficult for M. DE SAUSSURE , considering the form of his experiments , to discover the hygroscopic law expressed by the second conclusion ; and with the unknown existence of that law , to suspect the march of his hygrometer : which accidental complication I shall explain hereafter .
65 .
When I published those results of my experiments and observations , M. DE SAUSSURE rejected them ; not from having made new experiments that had confirmed his opinions ; but because he conjectured inversely , that my theory resulted from a fallacious march of my hygrometer : and the well-earned reputation of that celebrated philosopher engaged me to undertake every experiment that could help me to detect on which side was the error .
I have related , in the first part of this Paper , some of those experiments ; and now , for their application , as well as for giving an account of some others , I shall follow more particularly M. DE SAUSSURE'S process .
66 .
In a large glass vessel , containing ( as I have mentioned above ) a manometer and his hair-hygrometer , which vessel he had previously reduced to a known small distance from extreme dryness , M. DE SAUSSURE introduced from time to time a piece of wet cloth , which he weighed both before he put it into the vessel , and when he took it out .
The successive increases in the quantity of vapour resulting from that process were indicated ; on the manometer , by successive increases in the quantity of the enclosed elastic fluids , which caused the quicksilver to ascend more and more in that instrument ; and on the hygrometer , by successive expansions of the hair .
The maximum of evaporation was clearly indicated by the manometer ; for , during every lasting temperature , the quicksilver , after having ascended to a certain point , remained fixed at that point , notwithstanding a longer stay of the wet cloth ; and by repeating that operation at different temperatures , M. DE SAUSSURE determined the quantities of evaporated water that , in a given space , and by a given temperature , produced the maximum of evaporation .
That single determination , from its great consequences not yet generally attended to , would be sufficient to fix the celebrity of its author , as I have already expressed many times in other works .
67 .
But with respect to a different conclusion from the same experiments , no less important to natural philosophy , I have also said , that M. DE SAUSSURE'S hygrometer may have misled him .
We have seen , that the manometer indicated , by an indubitable symptom , the maximum of evaporation ; for here the immediate cause is clearly known , namely , the quantity of elastic fluids ; and it is evident , that the quicksilver must ascend in the instrument in proportion to that quantity , and stop when it ceases to increase .
But it is not the same as to the indications of the hygrometer in respect of moisture : M. DE SAUSSURE found himself that they were far from proportional to the intensities of their cause ; and in the last stage of his experiments , though these indications did not vary much by the different maxima of evaporation , they however varied in the space of 1 or 2 degrees .
But as those small differences on the point where the hygrometer stopped in different experiments , did not follow apparently any law conformable to the temperature , M. DE SAUSSURE considered them as small anomalies , unavoidable in hygroscopic substances , and of little consequence on a scale of 100 degrees ; therefore , laying aside that circumstance , he could have no doubt , that , in every temperature , the maximum of evaporation in a close space was synonymous with the maximum of moisture in that space ; while , from my experiments , these two supposed identical expressions may differ 1/ 5 , and sometimes 1/ 4 , of the real scale of moisture , which is the case in the temperature of only 75o or 80o .
68 .
Let us now suppose for a moment , that the above hygroscopic law , and the march that I attribute to the hair hygrometer , are real .
In that case , if , during a constant maximum of evaporation , the temperature varies from 32o to 80o , moisture will diminish 1/ 5 and even 1/ 4 of the whole ; or , in other words , the state of the medium will be distant by so much from that in which a new introduction of vapour would be followed by a precipitation .
But at the same time , in the whole of that period of moisture , the hair hygrometer is supposed to move only 1 or 2 degrees backwards and forwards , with frequent irregularities .
Therefore , in the hypothesis , such a great change of moisture would be hardly suspected from those small deviations of the hair hygrometer , in which at first nothing appears to be regular ; and thereby it is evident , that , by confining himself to those experiments , M. DE SAUSSURE could not discover those two important laws of hygrology and hygrometry , of which I have here only supposed the existence .
69 .
Let us suppose again , that the hair hygrometer had not existed before a certain number of other experiments ; and that M. DE SAUSSURE , in his attempt to produce an instrument of that kind , had fixed on any of the slips made of fibrous vegetable or animal substances cut across the fibres , of which many hygroscopes had been made before in a coarser manner ; and that , in every other respect , he had proceeded as he has done with the hair .
In that case , having placed his hygrometer and the manometer in the same vessel , with a quantity of water sufficient for producing the maximum of evaporation in every common temperature , and observed also the points where both instruments stopped in different lasting temperatures , he then would have found ; that the hygrometer indicated less and less moisture , at the same time that the manometer , by ascending more and more as the evaporation increased by more heat , indicated that increase in the quantity of vapour , distinct from the expansions of the fluids ; and that each of those instruments remained also fixed in that state of opposite changes , by every sufficiently durable change of temperature .
The first observation of that phenomenon would have surprised him , as it did me , and it would have induced him also to try some other of those slips ; and by finding the same phenomenon with every one of them , he would have been convinced , that it was a real law of moisture .
Lastly , if he had known Mr. JAMES WATT'S observations on the great dryness of the steam of boiling water , as long as it remains in a space as warm as the water that produces it ( a condition always understood when the general laws of evaporation are the object of inquiry ) ; admitting with me , as it follows from his own theory , that such steam is no other than the same kind of vapour thus far mentioned , only rendered capable of a greater density by more heat ; he would then have seen the importance of that hygroscopic law from its great extent .
I have hardly any doubt , that extreme dryness would reign in a close place similar to PAPIN'S digestor , if there were a sufficient space above the water and a red heat ; though that space would be filled with vapour to the maximum .
This relates only to the hygroscopic law here in view , on which , in the supposed case , I do not think we could have had any controversy .
70 .
Lastly , let us suppose , that in order to try the effect of moisture on the substance he had first chosen , or on some other of the same kind of substances , but taken lengthwise , M. DE SAUSSURE had happened to try first one of those which , used in that manner , have a great retrogradation , as goose-quill and deal ; and that , after having previously observed it in the open air , he had enclosed it in the moist vessel , at a time when the place where it stood before had the degree of moisture corresponding with the stationary state of that hygroscope , he would then have observed a phenomenon as little expected as the former : for after that instrument had been enclosed in the moist vessel , it would have moved , by that increase of moisture , in the same direction as it had done in the open dry air when there was on the contrary an increase of dryness .
Surprised no doubt at that phenomenon , M. DE SAUSSURE would have submitted his new instrument to more experiments ; he would also have tried other threads , in which he would have found the same sort of march , only at various degrees ; and if , in the course of those trials , he had submitted the hair to the same experiments , the smallness of its motions backwards and forwards , and their irregularities , would not have prevented him from discovering in it the same sort of march as he had then been used to see in other threads ; and thereby , he would have abandoned the whole tribe of threads as unfit for the hygrometer .
71 .
The whole of that supposed course of experiments with slips and threads , is that which I have followed from the time I had abandoned the construction of my first hygrometer ; which I did especially with the view of being able to try many substances .
Therefore my theory was formed in consequence of the two above conclusions , which appear to me immediate , and such as M. DE SAUSSURE could not have drawn differently , if he had followed the same necessary steps : and now I will prove , moreover , that if it had not been for accidental circumstances in his own process , the hair alone would have engaged him by degrees to undertake the same experiments .
72 .
M. DE SAUSSURE'S first hygrometers , having their index at the top of the frame , could be plunged into water ; and he tried that method for fixing their point of extreme moisture , as I had done for my first hygrometers .
But in those trials he observed , that while his instruments stood in water , their indications remained undetermined within a space of four or five degrees ; and attributing that irregularity to a friction of the hair with water , he thought it necessary to change my method , to that of placing the instrument in a moist medium , which he produced by means of a glass jar , wet on the inside , and inverted over water .
In this method , the situation of the index became indifferent ; and , for some particular reason , he placed it at the bottom of his new hygrometers , which then could not be plunged into water .
This last circumstance was merely accidental ; however , we shall see how much it has influenced his opinions in respect of extreme moisture .
73 .
In the first account of his experiments , M. DE SAUSSURE did not enter into those particulars ; but they are in his answer to me : and when I there saw , that he gave as a reason for having abandoned the immersion in water , that a strong adhesion of the hair to that liquid impeded the freeness of its motions , I found it more natural to assign to the instrument itself the unsteadiness of its index which he attributed to that cause .
Indeed , in those first hygrometers , one end of the axis passed through a hole for the purpose of carrying the index outwards , which was a cause of much friction : that axis besides was loaded with the weight of pretty large pincers , holding the hair , and that weight was counterpoised on the other side .
Lastly , the connexion of the hair with the index was produced by a silver lamina , which , though very thin , opposed some resistance in bending round the axis .
Those are defects that M. DE SAUSSURE corrected afterwards ; but they existed in the instruments which he plunged into water , and a weight of only 3 grains was not sufficient to keep their index steady , either in water or any where ; and this he observed himself .
74 .
Notwithstanding that natural explanation of the unsteadiness of M. DE SAUSSURE'S first hygrometer when in water , I thought it necessary to try , in the same circumstance , some well-constructed hair hygrometer ; therefore I made two , similar to the last of M. DE SAUSSURE'S in every respect , except that of having their index at the top ; and for the connection of the hair with the axis , I used a kind of pincers , not above half a grain in weight , with a hair-like bit of hemp , which I know does not alter in any sensible manner the march of the instrument .
Now , these hair hygrometers , with their weight of only 3 grains , being put into water , follow in it their own laws , arrive and remain fixed at their once settled point , as well as any of my other hygrometers .
This M. DE SAUSSURE would have also found , if in the improvement of his instrument the axis had remained at the top .
75 .
Before I explain the influence which that accidental circumstance of the place of his index has had on his opinions with respect to extreme moisture , I must mention another of the same kind which has contributed to the same effect .
It is evident , both from theory and from M. DE SAUSSURE'S own experiments related above ( ~ 66 .
) , that a sufficient quantity of water in any part of a close vessel is the only requisite for producing in it the maximum of evaporation ; but , with a view of accelerating that effect for the common purpose of fixing the point of extreme moisture on his hygrometer , he prescribes wetting the inside of the vessel , besides inverting it over water .
He did not ( and indeed he could not ) foresee the consequence of that alteration in his first process ; but in fact it was such as to prevent him from discovering , even with time , in those operations , what he would have seen immediately if his last hygrometers could have been plunged into water .
76 .
After the improvement of his hygrometers , their index was no more subject to that unsteadiness observed in the first ; consequently they remained fixed under the moist vessel ; but they did not fix at the same point every time ; and it happened accidentally , from causes of irregularity in the vessel itself , that in some of the cases , when the hair was the longest , a precipitation of water happened ( by some partial cooling ) on some part of that vessel ; and he took that appearance for a sure sign that there was a superfluous quantity of water in the enclosed air .
From that accidental connexion of circumstances he concluded , that his hygrometer indicated two different states of the medium in respect of extreme moisture ; one , correspondent to about 98 on that instrument , which he considered as real extreme moisture , or that state of the medium in which no more vapour could be introduced into it without a precipitation ; the other , when such a precipitation took place , which he made correspondent to 100 , or to the greatest length of the hair .
Prepossessed afterwards with that opinion , when I published my comparative experiments of his hygrometer and mine , in which the latter stood sometimes at 80 when the former was at 98 , he concluded from that circumstance , that while his hygrometer moved only 2 degrees by the utmost effect of a supersaturation of the medium , mine had 20 of those insignificant degrees .
In this centers the whole of our disagreement , and I am now going to trace its cause in the accidental circumstances above described .
77 .
When I plunge my hair hygrometers into water , where , as I have said , they come to a fixed point , that point does not indicate the greatest length of the hair ; for , on the contrary , that thread is then shorter than it is most times under the moist vessel .
This M. DE SAUSSURE would have seen , if he had not been prevented , by the situation of the index in his improved hygrometer , from trying again the effect of water on the hair ; and that phenomenon alone would surely have given a different course to his ideas ; especially he would not have supposed , that the hair lengthens 2 degrees more , by a super-saturation of the medium , or by the immediate contact of concrete water .
78 .
If , also , when he settled the manner of determining the point of extreme moisture on his hygrometers , M. DE SAUSSURE had retained the simplicity of the process he had used for his fundamental experiments , in which a piece of wet cloth had been sufficient for producing the maximum of evaporation in his large vessel ; and , in consequence , had contented himself with inverting his glass jar over water , without wetting it on the inside , he would have avoided a great cause of deception which I am going to explain .
In my first experiments on the comparative marches of our hygrometers , in which I followed M. DE SAUSSURE'S prescription for the moist vessel , I found some anomalies which puzzled me .
M. DE SAUSSURE himself took notice of them in the account I gave of those experiments , and attributed them to my instrument .
I did not agree with him in that respect ; but it was long before I could discover the real cause of those anomalies .
The first step towards that discovery , was the reflecting on the uselessness of wetting the vessel on the inside , for the only purpose of producing in it the maximum of evaporation .
That consideration engaged me to undertake a new course of the same experiments , with a glass jar merely inverted over water ; and by that means , the greatest part of the real anomalies being removed , I observed clearly in the march of the hair , the combined effects of its own property , and of the hygroscopic law respecting evaporation which was known to me from other phenomenon .
79 .
As for the cause of those anomalies which had been removed by the change of the process , the following phenomenon led me to discover it .
I observed frequently , at times when my hygrometer , placed under the jar , stood at a considerable distance from its point of extreme moisture , that a very small diminution of heat was sufficient to cause , on the lower part of the vessel , the formation of a tarnished rim , extending one or two inches above the surface of the water , with a thin vanishing edge .
Having reflected on that phenomenon , from the mechanism I assign to the operation of fire in the very act of evaporation I concluded , that in such a stagnant air every evaporating surface had an atmosphere of extreme moisture , which extended as indicated by the tarnished rim ; and that it was only beyond that limit that reigned the other law , of a decreasing moisture , correspondent to the increasing maxima of evaporation by an increasing heat .
That new law of evaporation offered evidently an adequate cause for explaining the anomalies observed in the wet vessel ; for glass retains concrete water very imperfectly , and it runs down very soon from many of the places which had retained it .
Consequently , under such a partially wet vessel , and differently so at different times , the instruments must be variously affected by ~ scattered atmospheres of extreme moisture .
80 .
However , before I could trust that explanation , I wanted to submit it to some direct experiment ; and I succeeded by a means which at the same time realized what M. DE SAUSSURE thought he had obtained , namely , to produce extreme moisture in a close space , during any common temperature , without any precipitation of water from the medium .
This I have produced by means of a wire cage , 4 inches in diameter , covered with cotton cloth , having at the top a reservoir , by which the cloth is kept thoroughly wet for a long time ; which cage besides is enclosed in the glass jar inverted over water .
In that apparatus , though in summer-time , every hygrometer , either thread or slip , moves and fixes itself , not so speedily , but else exactly as if it was plunged into water , without any supersaturation of the enclosed medium , or precipitation of water on the hygroscopic substance .
81 .
We may see now that the idea of two sorts of extreme moisture is without any foundation .
In order to enforce the necessity of taking the point of extreme moisture in the air brought to that state , and not in water , M. DE SAUSSURE says , That the hygrometer is not to measure the moisture of water , but that of the air .
' ' This at first appears plausible ; however , in reality , moisture is no more to be considered in water itself , than heat in the fluid called fire .
Water is the cause of moisture , as fire is the cause of heat ; but those effects are not produced on their causes ; it is on other substances .
Therefore , if some hygroscopic substances are placed in a medium which has attained extreme moisture , and , in proportion as they take water from it , the loss of that water be constantly repaired by a new evaporation , they will receive by degrees in such a medium , without any precipitation , as much water as if they were plunged in water itself ; for the limit is their capacity , which I have explained in ~ 19 .
This is the same theory that I had expressed in my first Paper on Hygrometry ; and it is completely confirmed by the above experiment , with the discovery of this new hygroscopic law : ` ` That in a stagnant air , every evaporating surface has an atmosphere of extreme moisture , which extends in a space of few inches , diminishes rapidly , and does not interfere beyond that limit with the other laws of moisture .
' ' 82 .
I shall now explain , by an example , what is the fundamental deviation of an hair hygrometer , introducing in it , for a moment , those two singular points 98 and 100 , which , in M. DE SAUSSURE'S experiments , were a very natural cause of mistake .
A hair hygrometer and mine , being in a close vessel , at a time when the temperature , sensibly constant , shall be but little above 32 ; if moisture is first introduced into that vessel , so as to bring the hair hygrometer , by a very slow direct motion , to 98 , my hygrometer will stop between 70 and 75 ; and both instruments will be fixed , if moisture and heat remain the same .
Let moisture then be made to increase very slowly , till the hair hygrometer has attained its point 100 ; mine will have arrived at 80 ; and they again will remain at those points as long as , with the same temperature , the same quantity of vapour shall remain in the vessel .
Lastly , let a sufficient or superfluous quantity of water be introduced into the vessel , the hair hygrometer will retrograde to 98 , and mine proceed to 100 , at which points they will stop , whatever be the quantity of water ; and they will remain fixed , as long as the heat shall not increase .
This explains the riddle of the singular point 98 , or of a certain point , various in different hair hygrometers , various even , at different times , in the same individual , at which that instrument stands with very different degrees of moisture ; consequently , its little motions round that point may create great deception , especially from the nature of organized substances , on which now I shall add a few words .
83 .
The above is the fundamental march of the hair hygrometer , such as it is on the whole , and as it would be conG gg2 stantly , stantly , if no other cause interfered ; but it is subject to disturbing anomalies , which become worthy of attention within that small critical space which I have described .
The texture of organized hygroscopic substances occasions a friction between their parts , when , by the changes of moisture and heat combined with their elasticity , they undergo changes in their respective positions ; whereby they hardly can completely return to the very same arrangement , though with the same external circumstances ; even at extreme moisture , when , there being less friction between their particles , the greatest part of the disturbances produced in their former motions are restored .
To that general cause of irregularity is added a particular cause , when those substances are in the state of hygrometers ; this is the influence of two opposite forces acting constantly on them ; one , the tendency of their component parts to remain united ; the other , a weight or spring which tends to separate them .
Certain accidental arrangements of their component parts give them more power to resist the action which tends to separate them ; and those arrangements are very changeable , by the alternate introduction and expulsion of moisture , by a long stay within a small compass of variations , and by more or less heat .
This is a large field of facts and speculations , not uninteresting in itself , but on which I must not dwell : what I have said or those causes is sufficient to account for the anomalies to which , more or less , every hygrometer is subject .
But whereas in the slips , those anomalies create only some irregularities in the observations , without any deceiving consequence in respect of the laws of moisture , they may deceive when they happen to interfere in the critical part of the march of some threads ; for instance , if , by a certain accidental arrangement of the constituent parts in a slip of whalebone , there happens to be some tenths of a degree difference , from one experiment to another , on its point of extreme moisture , that anomaly cannot be of any consequence on the determination of what must be considered as that state in the medium ; but if it happens to the hair , which , in approaching extreme moisture , has but very small motions , it may reverse those which it had had naturally ( as I have observed it sometimes ) and become a cause of deception .
84 .
I have now explained , how mere accidental circumstances have been the cause of a difference in the ideas that M. DE SAUSSURE and I had formed on what is to be understood by extreme moisture in every case ; and I am going to illustrate the whole of that subject by a singular fact .
An hygrometer made with a box thread , or a thin fascicle of the fibres of that wood , being placed in open air , next to a hair hygrometer , or to most of the other instruments of that sort , moves in a contrary way from them ; but we may lay aside that circumstance , by supposing , that the numbers , marked on the dial of the first , are increasing in the opposite direction from those of the other instruments .
Let us then suppose , that some experimental philosopher had chosen the box thread for his hygrometer ; with him I should have fallen into no controversy on the point of extreme moisture ; for , either under the moist vessel , or in any other case approaching extreme moisture , his hygrometer would have moved like mine .
But the box thread , at approaching extreme dryness , first relents much its pace , then becomes stationary , and afterwards retrograde ; by which property , with the concourse of some accidental circumstances as have happened in M. DE SAUSSURE 's experiments , the very same questions that I have examined with so much labour in respect of extreme moisture , only because of the hair hygrometer , would have been transported to the point of extreme treme dryness ; which , however , till now , has created no doubt .
85 .
That singular thread illustrates also another point , closely connected with the retrogradation of its tribe , but not to be confounded with it ; I mean the recoil .
The common cause of both phenomenon is , two opposite effects produced by changes of moisture , on the length of threads .
The retrogradation in the march , comparatively to that of moisture , is produced by one of the effects , which before was surpassed by the other , becoming predominant ; and the recoil , or a returning back a part of a first stride when moisture changes suddenly , is produced , by one of the effects , that on the fibres themselves , being performed sooner than that on the sort of reticle formed by the fibres .
Now , the box thread having its retrogradation at approaching extreme dryness , there also the recoil becomes sensible : it appears in the first modifications of that thread when placed in my dry vessel , by motions backwards and forwards , as it happens to some other threads , when taken out of water , or exposed to any other sudden change of moisture .
The box thread having a slow motion , no recoil is clearly distinguishable in its common march ; whereas the hair and the quill-thread , which , in appearance , are very quick , have generally a very disturbed motion when moisture changes suddenly .
I have seen them , when in a free air , and happening to be in their stationary state , moving quickly one way in a space of 1 or 2 degrees , and then recoiling flower , sometimes to the same point where they were before , while my hygrometer underwent a steady change , which was in the first direction of theirs .
This phenomenon , of a complete recoil in the stationary state of quick threads , is similar to the recoil of the index in those glass frames that I have described in ~ 59 .
of this Paper , which have a compensation for the changes of heat by a thin a brass lamina : this being sooner affected than the glass rods , by sudden changes of heat , the index moves first one way ; then it recoils completely , by the change being operated later in the glass rods .
86 .
The experiments briefly related in this Paper will , I hope , be sufficient to answer the following question , which has been made to me by some observers of the two principal hygrometers here compared : ` ` Why does the hair hygrometer , when exposed to the open air in day time , come so often near its point of extreme moisture , while the whalebone hygrometer almost never comes within 30 degrees distance of that point in summer , and very seldom within 20 in winter , even in rainy weather ( if preserved from rain ) ?
' ' The answer , according to the results of these experiments , is this : ` ` The general march of the hair hygrometer is much decreasing , comparatively to equal increases of moisture ; that march sorwards , ends in a stationary state , and is followed by a small retrogradation ; while the whalebone hygrometer has constantly a march , if not proportional , at least constantly similar to that of moisture itself .
' ' 87 .
There remains an object of inquiry , which is , a determination of those ratios here generally expressed .
I have explained , in the first part of this Paper , the difficulties of that object , and what help may be found in comparing the marches of hygrometers with the acquisitions of weight of their substances , of which process I gave some examples ; and here I shall relate similar experiments on hair , whalebone , box , and aloes-pitta .
But as I have already described the whole process , and the manner of calculation of that class of experiments , I shall only give here the results of these last .
88 .
I must , however , first explain another reduction that I have added to the former .
In the first TABLE which I have given of those experiments , I followed the immediate division of my instruments , in which o corresponds to extreme dryness , and 100 to extreme moisture .
But first , under that form , the point called 100 by M. DE SAUSSURE would not appear in its true light , as it means the greatest length of the hair ; while the point 100 of my scale designs the state of that thread in water , where it has a little retrogradation .
Under that form also most part of the terms in the observation on the box thread would be negative , since it moves very long in a contrary direction to the other hygroscopes .
For these reasons , instead of calling o the point of extreme dryness , and that of extreme moisture 100 , I have , in the following TABLES , applied the first of those denominations to the smallest length of each substance , and the last to their greatest length .
That reduction produces no difference in the proportions between the terms , and none in the terms themselves in respect to slips ; as in these , the greatest length is always observed by extreme moisture , and the smallest by extreme dryness .
II .
TABLE of comparative changes in the weight and in the length of the same substances , by the same increases of moisture , correspondent to the march of the slip of whalebone from 5 to 5 of its degrees .
WHALEBONE .
HAIR .
ALOES-PITTA .
Increases of March of Increases of March of Increases of March the weight the slip .
the weight the hair .
the weight of the in shavings .
in a mass of in a mass of thread hair .
pitta .
of pitta .
Extr .
dryness 0.0 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 6.0 5 4.8 15.7 6.0 20.6 11.8 10 8.8 29.0 11.8 35.1 17.3 15 12.5 40.0 17.3 51.6 22.2 20 15.9 50.4 22.2 57.6 26.8 25 19.1 59.7 26.8 75.6 31.2 30 22.2 67.5 31.2 71.9 35.2 35 26.6 74.4 35.2 76.3 39.7 40 29.0 79.3 39.7 83.0 44.0 45 32.0 83.3 44.0 86.6 48.1 50 35.0 88.0 48.1 93.6 52.1 55 38.2 90.0 52.1 96.5 57.1 60 43.3 92.8 57.1 94.7 61.7 65 49.8 94.1 61.7 98.2 66.3 70 55.3 95.4 66.3 100.0 71.9 75 61.9 97.0 71.9 99.2 77.6 80 68.7 100.0 77.6 98.2 * 83.2 85 * 76.0 99.5 * 83.2 96.8 * 88 8 90 * 84.0 99.2 * 88.8 94.1 * 94.4 95 * 92.0 98.6 * 94.4 91.9 In water *100.0 100 *100.0 97.7 *100.0 88.3 89 .
In the above , and in the following experiments , the operation of successively introducing moisture into the vessel was stopped , when the slip of whalebone was at 80 , as beyond that term the smallest difference in the temperature between the parts of the apparatus creates great anomalies ; therefore the folVOL .
LXXXI .
Hhh lowing lowing terms in the three columns of weights , which are marked with an * , have only been added ( as I have explained for the former Table ) with the view of having a common modulum between the changes of weight and the marches of the other instruments .
But the observed terms remain in their original proportions , and from these we may see , that the march of the slip of whalebone does not differ much from the successive increase of weight in its own substance ; and that when taken out of the apparatus , and immediately plunged into water , it proceeds in the same direction as before , till it has attained its fixed point , while the hair takes , comparatively with the increase of weight of its own substance , great strides in the beginning of its march , and very small steps in the latter part of it , before 100 ; and then retrogrades a little , when taken out of the apparatus , and plunged into water .
We see besides in that TABLE , that the thread of aloes-pitta , which at first takes still greater strides than the hair , has , after a longer stationary or undetermined state , a determined beginning of retrogradation at the same time that its own substance continues to acquire weight in the apparatus , and continues that retrograde march when , being taken out of the vessel , it is plunged into water .
90 .
The following TABLE will farther illustrate these characteristic differences of slips and threads , the ascertaining of which was so essential to hygrometry .
III .
TABLE of experiments on the comparative changes in the weight and the length of the same substance by increase of moisture .
BO X. Slip of March of Increases of March of whalebone .
the slip .
the weight the thread .
in shavings .
Extr .
dryness 0 0.0 0.0 72.8 5 4.5 7.3 87.2 10 9.5 12.8 93.2 15 14.5 17.8 97.8 20 20.0 22.6 100.0 25 25.7 27.3 95.9 30 31.5 31.8 92.7 35 38.0 38.5 88.6 40 45.5 44.5 79.9 45 51.5 49.7 70.3 50 56.5 54.8 63.9 55 61.2 59.1 57 3 60 65.7 63.1 51.0 65 69.7 66.4 47.5 70 73.7 69.6 40.9 75 77.7 76.6 31.4 80 81.5 80.0 21.7 85 85.9 * 85.0 16.0 90 90.5 * 90.0 10.4 95 95.5 * 95.0 5.1 In Water 100 100.0 *100.0 0.0 We see in this TABLE the slip of box following , in its increases of length , the increase of weight in the shavings of the same wood , nearly in the same manner as the slips of whalebone , quill , and deal , follow those of their own shavings ; while the thread of box , after having gained some length by decreasing steps , begins soon to shorten , at the same time that its substance continues to imbibe water ; being thus the shortest , when it cannot receive any more water in its pores .
That excess of the hygroscopic phenomenon of threads cannot but throw a full light on the nature of those hygroscopes .
91 .
I am now going to assemble , in two TABLES , the comparative marches of all the threads , and of all the slips , which I have hitherto submitted to that regular course of experiments , laying aside many more of each class , the marches of which I only know from common observations .
The next TABLE shall contain the experiments on threads ; in the number of which are two thin natural bodies , which in that respect are similar to the hair ; one , an animal substance , is a very thin porcupine quill ; the other , a vegetable , is a thin stem of gramen .
TABLE of the correspondent marches , by the same increases of moisture , of different THREADS or vegetable and animal substances taken lengthwise .
Porcupine WhaleHair .
Gut .
AloesGooseDeal .
Gramen .
Box .
Slip of quill .
bone .
pitta .
quill .
wh.bone .
Ext. dryness 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 72.8 0 18.0 12.0 15.6 9.7 20.6 37.0 33.2 26.8 87.4 5 34.0 29.9 29.4 19.2 35.1 66.6 54.8 48.4 93.2 10 48.8 39.9 40.9 26.8 51.6 78.7 ~ 74.9 67.1 97.8 15 62.3 50.8 50.5 37.0 57.6 88.0 84.6 ~ 76.6 *100.0 20 73.3 58.8 59.2 47.1 75.6 ~ 93.4 89.8 83.9 95.9 25 81.0 65.3 68.8 57.3 71.9 97.2 93.8 90.5 92.7 30 86.8 70.8 73.0 67.4 76.3 99.0 96.9 95.1 88.6 35 90.8 76.1 78.3 75.6 83.0 94.4 94.3 98.6 79.9 40 93.0 81.4 82.1 82.9 ~ 86.6 96.2 97.7 * 100.0 ~ 70.3 45 95.0 85.4 86.1 87.8 93.6 99.0 * 100.0 98.8 63.9 50 94.5 88.4 88.8 ~ 91.6 96.5 95.3 94.6 98.0 57.3 55 97.0 90.8 91.6 94.7 94.7 97.2 97.0 97.2 51.0 60 96.5 92.8 93.8 96.3 98.2 98.2 94.6 96.2 45.7 65 96.5 95.1 95.6 97.8 * 100.0 * 100.0 93.0 94.8 40.9 70 95.0 97.1 97.2 98.7 99.2 99.0 91.4 92.6 31.4 75 97.0 98.1 ~ 98.0 * 100.0 98.2 98.2 89.0 89.8 21.7 80 98.0 99.1 100.0 98.7 96.8 97.2 86.9 86.5 16.0 85 98.6 ~ 99.6 * 100.0 96.8 94.1 95.8 84.6 84.0 10.4 90 99.1 * 100.0 99.3 94.5 91.5 94.4 81.9 80.9 5.1 95 In water 100.0 99.5 98.3 91.8 88.3 92.5 79.0 77.0 0.0 100 92 .
There the porcupine quill shows no retrogradation ; however , consistent with its tribe , it had some in other experiments .
Its last steps have the unsteadiness of the stationary state , and thereby are subject to anomalies .
From the same cause , none of the other threads have exactly the same steps in any two experiments , though on the whole their march remains essentially the same .
The march here given of the hair hygrometer comparatively with mine , is the mean result of three experiments , with three different sets of instruments ; one of the hair hygrometers that I have employed was sent to me by Mr. PAUL , of Geneva , and its point of extreme moisture was determined in a fog .
The small and changeable retrogradation of the thread of whalebone and of hair might have been overlooked , were it not for other threads in which the retrogradation begins before that period where the state of moisture is difficult to ascertain ; but from these threads , that phenomenon is placed in a clear light , which is reflected on the others .
I have marked with an * the greatest elongation of each of them , and with a~a point near which their elongation begins , and to which they return at last .
These signs will guide the eye in the above TABLE , which shows clearly , that no thread can be trusted to for the HYGROMETER .
TABLE of the correspondent marches of SLIPS , or of fibrous vegetable and animal substances taken across the fibres , and of such as have no sensible fibres .
Goose Porcupine Slip of Box .
Deal .
Ivory .
Ivory TortoiseHorn Horn quill .
quill .
wh.bone .
breadthwise .
lengthwise .
shell .
breadthwise .
lengthwise .
Ext. dryness 0.0 0.0 0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 4.8 4.8 5 4.5 5.4 6.1 8.3 11.0 9.5 13.8 9.7 8.8 10 9.5 11.2 12.7 16.6 21.5 18.5 26.8 14.4 12.0 15 14.5 16.5 18.7 24.6 31.5 27.5 38.8 19.2 17.0 20 20.0 21.9 24.9 31.5 38.5 37.0 48.8 23.9 23.4 25 25.7 27.2 30.4 37.6 45.4 46.5 58.0 28.5 29.4 30 31.5 32.7 35.4 43,6 51.9 54.5 64.6 33.3 36.0 35 38,0 38.3 41.9 49.7 58.3 62.1 71.0 38.3 41.4 40 45.5 43.7 47.4 56.3 63.8 68.7 75.5 42.9 45.4 45 51.4 49.2 53.5 62.4 69.0 72.3 78 5 47.4 49.8 50 56.5 54.6 58.5 67.4 72.8 77.0 82.2 52.4 54.8 55 61.2 59.9 63.5 71.6 76.4 79.7 86.2 56.9 59.7 60 65.7 64.9 68.0 76.1 79.4 84.3 89.6 61.9 64.4 65 69.7 69.7 72.1 79.1 82.4 86.4 92.4 67.2 68.5 70 73.7 74.5 76.1 82.9 84.9 88.4 93.4 72.2 73.5 75 77.7 79.0 80.1 86.7 88.2 90.2 94.4 77.8 78.9 80 81.5 83.5 84.5 90.4 91.2 92.0 95.4 82.8 83.9 85 85.9 87.5 87.8 92.4 93.8 94.0 96.6 88.2 88.9 90 90.5 92.0 92.0 94.5 96.2 96.1 97.8 94.0 94.4 95 95.3 96.0 96.0 97.5 98.6 98.1 99.0 In water 100.0 100.0 100 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 100.0 93 .
This last TABLE is the most important , as it contains a class of hygroscopes which posses in common the following first requisites for an hygrometer ; 1st , that they may indicate , without any illusion , both extreme dryness and extreme moisture ; 2dly , that they move constantly in the same direction as moisture itself ; 3dly , that they move always when moisture changes .
It should seem as if the march of the slip of horn taken lengthwise , from its very decreasing progression , came very near that of the thin porcupine quill ; but , as I have said , among the steps of the latter there are accidental retrogradations , and it sometimes has a final one ; and I have never observed that disposition in the former , which , in its last small steps , follows constantly the motions of every other slip .
94 .
The agreement of all the slips in this last respect is a very essential circumstance in hygrometry , as it assures us , that we cannot mistake the cases when moisture is extreme in the atmosphere ; a very important point for discovering the nature of many meteorological phenomenon .
No slip will create deception in that respect ; while , on the contrary , every thread may deceive in dubious cases , and even create great error , if , unknown to the observer , it happened to be in the beginning of its elongation .
There was , however , a question to be decided in that respect , namely , whether or not a great moisture in the medium was a cause of alteration in the march of any hygroscope , by producing in its substance a sudden irregular lengthening .
That accidental question is answered in the negative by all the hygroscopes of both classes : for , in respect of the threads , instead of lengthening suddenly in that period of moisture , they have then a retrograde motion , either continuing or only beginning ; and as for the slips , they , by lengthening in the same period , only follow their former laws : the slips which , comparatively to that of whalebone , have at first small steps , and which consequently move in an increasing progression , continue only to follow that progression ; and those which at first have greater steps , and consequently a decreasing march , have then small steps conformable to their individual law ; therefore , none of those hygroscopes of both classes have any sudden start , produced by any degree of moisture in the medium , or by the application of concrete water ; each of them follows , from one end to the other of its scale , it own progression ; and in respect of slips , moisture is never extreme in the ambient medium , as long as , in their respective progressions , they have not attained their greatest length .
95 .
Our common hygrometer must then be made of one of the slips ; but with that great dissimilarity observed in their marches , which of them shall we choose as indicating the real march of moisture ?
None as yet from that consideration , which I do not even think a primary one .
It is true , that if we trust to the increases of weight in those substances , as being a means of ascertaining the real progress of moisture in the ambient medium , the mean rate of six experiments of that kind related in this Paper , give the preference to the slip of whalebone ; but this I do not yet consider as decisive , farther than in what relates to the comparative marches of slips and threads ; however , as my reasons of doubt on a more absolute conclusion cannot be expressed in a transitory manner , I must lay them aside for the present .
96 .
But , as I have said before , this is not what ought to determine our choice on the substance of a common hygrometer , since the observations themselves are distinct from the consequences to be drawn from them .
Let us suppose the case ( which I do not give up ) that , with time and researches , some process be found by which known quantities of moisture may be successively produced in the medium itself .
The use of that process for hygrometry will be , as M. DE SAUSSURE has begun to do it , to observe , on some hygrometer , the successive effects of those known quantities of moisture , from which may be formed a table of the correspondence between the equal degrees of the scale of the chosen instrument , and the real quantities of moisture in the medium ; and that table will serve to correct as well past as future observations made with that instrument .
Therefore it matters not what that hygrometer shall be , provided it is convenient in other respects .
Let us then examine which of the slips possesses the most essential properties of an hygrometer , such as should be in common use for comparative observations , and to which consequently future discoveries in respect of the real proportions between the quantities of moisture itself would be applied .
97 .
Steadiness is surely a first requisite for such an instrument ; and in that respect no slip comes in competition with that of whalebone .
That property was the first motive of my choice ; and as an instance of it I shall only mention , that I have just now plunged into water an instrument of that sort , of above ten years standing , which is come to its point of extreme moisture as if it had been fixed yesterday ; for , without regard to the distance of observations , there may be between them a difference of some tenths of a degree .
Some other slips may be brought to a certain degree of steadiness by studying what is the degree of stretch which they may bear ; but that attention is not necessary for the slip of whalebone : if , for instance , when its point of extreme moisture has been fixed while it was stretched to a certain degree , that stretch is much increased , it will acquire some absolute length ; but it will be steady again for a new point taken the in water .
98 .
Another property of the slip of whalebone , which at first should seem contradictory to the former , is its great expansibility , in which also it surpasses all the substances which I have tried .
Such a slip lengthens above one-eight of itself from extreme dryness to extreme moisture , which produces many advantages in the construction and observation of that instrument .
In respect to observation , when it is exposed to the wind , the difference between the chords of the arches of its bends and its real length is so small , comparatively with its hygroscopic variations , that the indetermination of its index will remain confined in a space of one or two degrees , when it becomes impossible to observe hygrometers whose substance has but little expansion .
Lastly , of all the substances which I have reduced to slips , none is so easily made thin and narrow as whalebone .
I have found means for producing easily such slips of it as , with a length of eight inches , weigh only about 1/ 1 6 th of a grain , and are thereby as quick as is convenient in other respects .
All those distinctive properties of the slip of whalebone seem to point out an hygroscopic substance fit for our common hygrometer .
Description of the whalebone hygrometer .
99 .
I have now only to describe the construction of that instrument as I have fixed it after a long experience .
The fig. 1 .
( Tab. IX .
) shows its form for common use .
Some of those instruments are of the same size as the figure , and they may easily be made smaller , but commonly they are half as large again in every dimension .
Their frame will sufficiently be known from the figure , therefore I shall confine myself to the description of some particulars .
The slip of whalebone is represented by a , b ; and at its end a is seen a sort of pincers , made only of a flattened bent wire , tapering in the part that holds the slip , and pressed by a sliding ring .
The end b is fixed to a moveable bar c , which is moved by a screw for adjusting at first the index .
The end a of the slip is hooked to a thin brass wire ; to the other end of which is also hooked a very thin silver gilt lamina , that has at that end pincers similar to those of the slip , and which is fixed by the other end to the axis by a pin in a proper hole .
The spring d , by which the slip is stretched , is made of silver gilt wire ; it acts on the slip as a weight of about 12 grains , and with this advantage over a weight ( besides the avoiding some other inconveniences of this ) that , in proportion as the slip is weakened , in its lengthening by the penetration of moisture , the spring , by unbending at the same time , loses a part of its power .
The axis has very small pivots , the shoulders of which are prevented from coming against the frame , by their ends being confined , though freely , between the flat bearing of the heads of two screws , the front one of which is seen near f. The section of that axis , of the size that belongs to a slip of about 8 inches , is represented in fig. 2 .
; the slip acts on the diameter a , a , and the spring on the smaller diameter b , b. 100 .
Another construction of the same instrument is represented , of half its dimensions , by fig. 3 .
( Tab. X. ) The essential parts of that hygrometer are the same as in the other ; therefore I shall only mention the differences adapted to the use of fixing it out of a window .
The figure represents the manner in which it is fixed , with its dial turned half-way towards the observer , by a proper head of the hooks which hold it at the top and the bottom .
The steady part of the instrument is represented by fig. 4 .
; it is partly an half tube , cut longitudinally through the axis , and having sidewise two vertical rows of large holes .
A whole tube goes over that half one ; for which purpose the piece a , a , is taken off by unscrewing the female screw b which belongs to the part d ; this last is a small open tube , cut outside in screw .
The large external tube has also two vertical rows of holes , at such a distance from one another , that , when one of them corresponds to one of the rows of the half tube , the other is in front .
The two opposite positions that tube can be brought to are in order that the instrument may be placed either side of a window , and each of those positions is determined by one end of a cut at the bottom of the tube in a , fig. 3 .
which then holds against the steady pin c , fig. 4 .
The rows of holes of the tube are to be turned towards the room , to prevent the rain from falling on the slip ; and the dial being enclosed in a box with a glass in front , no rain can get into the instrument .
It must also be fixed in a place not much exposed to the sun , or be screened from it without preventing the circulation of the air .
The communication of the slip with the external air through the rows of holes and the open bottom d , fig. 4 .
is sufficient for that class of observations .
By the manner of its being hooked , it may be easily taken off for carrying elsewhere ; and , if a quick observation is wanted , the tube also may easily be taken off .
I have the honour of presenting one of those instruments to the Royal Society ; and , as it is very desirable that some hygrometer be added to the other meteorological instruments usually observed , I wish this may deserve a place in their Observatory Fig. 1 .
50 40 60 Fig. 2 .
~~ a b 20 80 b a 10 90 ~ 100 ~M a d ~ Fig. 3 .
Fig. 4 .
a d aa b

