XVI .
The Longitudes of Dunkirk and Paris from Greenwich , deduced from the Triangular Measurement in 1787 , 1788 , supposing the Earth to be an Ellipsoid .
By Mr. Isaac Dalby ; communicated by Charles Blagden , M. D. Sec. R. S. Read May 19 , 1791 .
IN the account of the Trigonometrical Operation in 1787 , 1788 , which is given in the Philosophical Transactions , Vol. LXXX .
after the distance of Dunkirk from the meridian of Greenwich has been determined on a parallel to the perpendicular at Greenwich , its longitude is found by spherical computation , on a supposition , that the surface of a sphere nearly coincides with that of the earth in an east and west direction , where the operation was performed ; and the magnitude of this sphere , or which amounts to the same thing , the value in parts of a degree , &amp;c. of a measured arc on its surface ( for as such the arc between the meridians of Botley Hill and Goudhurst may be considered ) has been determined by actual observation at two stations nearly in the latitude of Dunkirk ; and this independent of any hypothesis which can sensibly affect the conclusion .
The principles , though not strictly geometrical , admit of little objection ; and therefore , as much care was taken in observing the angles at these stations , upon which the directions of the meridians depend , the longitude of Dunkirk ( and consequently that of Paris ) as given in the Table , Vol. LXXX .
456 12 p. 232 .
must be nearly true , whatever may be the real figure of the earth .
But , it may be said , that the arc between the meridians of Botley Hill and Goudhurst ( 17'1/ 3 ) is too short to infer from observation the value of the arc between the meridians of Greenwich and Dunkirk ( amounting to near a degree and a half ) , sufficiently accurate for finding the longitude to great precision ; because it has been remarked in the Appendix to the same Volume , that an error of 1 ' ' , in either of the horizontal angles at the above stations , would cause a variation of near 6 ' ' of a degree in the longitude of Dunkirk or Paris .
M. BOUGUER'S spheroid agreeing nearly with the meridional measurements , it was adopted for the purposes of latitude .
But the degree perpendicular to the meridian in latitude 51o 6 ' 53 ' ' is found to be 61248 fathoms ( Vol. LXXX .
p. 215 .
) which falls short of M. BOUGUER'S degree about 22 fathoms ; therefore , supposing the directions of the meridians to have been very accurately determined , the earth cannot be this spheroid , notwithstanding the ingenious hypothesis respecting the curve of the meridian .
But it is also well known , that the measured degrees of latitude in different places are inconsistent with an elliptical meridian : for , suppose an ellipsoid to be determined with the degrees found at the equator and polar circle , the computed degrees in middle latitudes will be much longer than the measured ones , as it is well known ; and the whole meridional arc between Greenwich and Paris will , on such an ellipsoid , exceed the measured arc by a quantity answering to about 21 ' ' of latitude .
It is evident , however , that if we suppose small errors to have taken place in determining the celestial arcs , or differences of latitude in some of the operations ( for there is little doubt but the terrestrial mensurations in general have been made exact enough ) , it will be easy to reconcile most of the results to an ellipsoid .
The following computations of the longitude are made on a supposition , that the earth is an ellipsoid , for the purpose of comparing the conclusions with what has been inferred from observation .
It will be seen , that the ratio of the axes comes out very near the ratio assigned by Sir ISAAC NEWTON , or 229 to 230 .
It is determined of such a magnitude , by adhering nearly to the measured arc of the meridian between Greenwich and Paris , deduced from the late operation , that the computed meridional degrees differ but little from the measured ones in five different places in middle latitudes ; but the defects at the equator and polar circle are supposed to be nearly equal to each other .
This will be seen better by the following comparative view of the measured and computed degrees in the same latitudes .
According to Lat. Measured .
ComExcess or deputed .
fact in meao ' Fath .
Fath .
sured arc .
M. CONDAMINE , &amp;c. 00 60481 60344 + 137 MASON and DIXON , 39 12 60628 60682 54 BOSCOVICH , &amp;c. 43 0 60725 60738 13 CASSINI , &amp;c. 45 0 60778 60768 + 10 LIESGANIG* , 48 43 60839 60823 + 16 Arc from latitude French and English 48o 50 ' 14 ' ' to 160656 160662 6 51o 28 ' 40 ' ' MAUPERTUIS , &amp;c. 66 20 61194 61057 + 137 In the five comparisons , from latitude 39o 12 ' to Greenwich , the greatest error ( 54 fathoms ) answers to about 3 ' ' of the celestial arc : neither of the other four differences amounts * From the late Gen. ROY'S Paper in the Phil. Trans. 1787 .
to 1 ' ' .
The determination of M. BECCARIA is not brought into the comparison , because his measured degree in latitude 44o 44 ' is longer than the measured one in latitude 45o .
The longitude of Dunkirk on this ellipsoid is found to be 9 m. 29.8 s. in time ; and consequently that of Paris 9 m. 201/ 3 S. , which is about 11/ 2 S. more than that inferred from the value of the measured arc between Goudhurst and the meridian of Botley Hill ; and therefore the sum of the two horizontal angles at these stations would , on this ellipsoid , be only about 4 ' ' less than those found by actual observation .
Method of computation .
On an ellipsoid , where the degrees of the meridian at the equator and polar circle are 60481 and 61194 fathoms respectively , the degree in latitude 50o 9'1/ 2 ( the middle latitude between Greenwich and Paris ) will be 60981 fathoms , exceeding the measured degree by 140 fathoms ( Vol. LXXX .
p. 225 .
) ; therefore , if each of the former degrees was about 140 fathoms less , the computed and measured arcs in latitude 50o 9'1/ 2 would be nearly the same .
But , that they also may nearly agree in latitude 45o , let the degrees at the equator , and in latitude 50o 9'1/ 2 , be taken 60344 and 60844 ; then , from these two degrees , the ratio of the axes will be found as the tangents of the arcs 50o 9'1/ 2 and 50o 1 ' 35'1/ 2 ; and the semi-axes 3489932 and 3473656 fathoms * .
The * Determined thus : If right lines are drawn perpendicular to the curve of a conic section to meet the axis , it is known , that the radii of curvature at the points in the curve from whence these lines are drawn , will be as the cubes of these lines .
Hence , if PC , GB , EC ( Tab. VII .
fig. 1 .
) , are perpendicular to the curve , the radii of curvature The length of the whole meridional arc between Greenwich and Paris on this ellipsoid is six fathoms greater than the measured arc ; the degree in latitude 48o 43 ' , 16 fathoms less ; in latitude 45o , 10 fathoms less ; in 43o , 13 fathoms greater ; and that in latitude 39o 12 ' , 54 fathoms greater .
The degrees at the equator and polar circle are considerably less than the measured ones , conformable to the hypothesis .
Suppose CE , CP ( fig. 1 .
) , are the greater and less semiaxes of the ellipsoid ; G Greenwich ; PGE its meridian ; PD the meridian of Dunkirk ; and let GBA be perpendicular to the curve of the meridian at G ; then GA will be the shorter axis of the elliptical section which is the perpendicular to the at P , G , E , will be as PC3 , GB3 , and PC2/ CE~3 , because at the point E ( or equator ) the line so drawn will become the radius of curvature itself , or PC2/ CE .
Therefore GB3 : PC2/ CE~3 : : rad .
curv .
at G : rad .
curv .
at E : : length of a deg. in the lat. of G : length of a deg. at E , the equator .
Let the arc ERL be described with the radius CE ; draw CR parallel to GB , RS parallel to PC , and join CK ; then , by the nature of the ellipse , CR ( CE ) : CK : : GB : half the parameter , or CP2/ CE ; therefore CE3 : CK3 : : GB3 : CP2/ CE~3 : : 60844 : 60344 ( supposing the lat. of the point G to be 50o 9'1/ 2 ) , or CE ( CR ) : CK : : 60844~1/ 3 : 60344~1/ 3 ; but CR : CK : : sine SKC : sine KRC ( co-lat .
) ; therefore , 60844/ 60344~1/ 3 X cosine lat. = sine SKC ; hence the angle SCK is given ( 50o 1 ' 35''1/ 2 ) ; therefore , as tang .
SCK : tang .
lat. ( SCR ) : : SK : SR : : lesser semi-axis CP : greater CE .
And putting d=57.295779 , &amp;c. the degrees in the circular arc which is equal to the radius ) we have tang .
lat/ tang .
SCK~2 X 60344d = 3489932 fathoms the longer semi-axis ; and tang .
lat./ tang .
SCK X 60344d=3473656 , the shorter .
meridian at Greenwich , and the angle EBG will be the latitude of Greenwich , or 51o 28 ' 40 ' ' .
Let HO ( parallel to GA ) be the section of the parallel to that perpendicular , passing through Dunkirk .
Then by the Table , p. 232 .
( Vol. LXXX .
) the arc GH is 152549 feet ; but this arc exceeds the real distance of the parallels GA , HO , not more than a fathom ; therefore this distance may be taken = 25424 fathoms .
Now the sections GA , HO , of the ellipsoid being similar , from the known properties of the figure , we shall get HO the shorter axis of the section of the parallel = 6959396 , its longer axis =6979374 , and HW = 3531757 fathoms , W being the point where HO cuts the axis PI of the ellipsoid .
Hence , if D be Dunkirk , and the arc HD the measured arc of the parallel , we have given the length of this arc , or 547058 feet ( Table , p. 232 .
) = 91176 fathoms , and also the point W in the lesser axis of the section HO , to determine the angle HWD in the plane of this section .
But reverting the series which exhibits the length of an elliptical arc in terms of the absciss and ordinate , will be of little use in the present case , where the arc and its chord are very near of the same length : For , let HKOL ( fig. 2 .
) be the section of the parallel , where HO = 6959396 , and KL = 6979374 , are the axes ; and HW = 3531757 , as in fig. 1 .
; also , suppose HS is the radius of curvature at H , or at the middle of HD ; then , if we conceive the arc HD to be a right line , or described with the radius HW , or with HS ( 3499700 ) and thence determine the angle SWD from the two sides SD , SW , and the included angle ( the supplement of HSD ) ; in either case we get the angle HWD the same , or 1o 28 ' 44'',8 to within 1 ' ' .
This angle being obtained , the inclination of the planes PHW , PDW ( the planes of the meridians of Greenwich and Dunkirk , fig. 1 .
) , or the longitude of the point D , will be found by the common proportion which in a rightangled spherical triangle determines an angle when the legs are given : this will be obvious by conceiving a sphere ( of any magnitude ) to be described about W as a center .
Hence , as rad .
: cotang .
angle HWD ( 1o 28 ' 44''.8 ) : : sine angle HWP ( 38o 31 ' 20 ' ' ) : cotang .
2o 22 ' 26''1/ 2 , the inclination of the planes of the meridians PH , PD , or longitude of Dunkirk on this ellipsoid .
And as the difference of meridians of Paris and Dunkirk is 2 ' 21''.9 ( for this will not be materially affected by different hypotheses ) the longitude of Paris will be 9 m. 201/ 3 S. in time .
The longitude of Dunkirk from Paris ( 2 ' 21''.9 ) is the mean longitude deduced at p. 223 .
( Vol. LXXX .
) , which is only 1''.1 less than that given in the Connoissance des Temps , 1788 .
The method of computing the latitude of the point D ( was it necessary ) is thus : as rad .
: cosine DWH : : cosine HWP : cosine DWP ; and since the point W in the axis PW is given , and also the angle DWP in the plane of the meridian PD ( by the foregoing proportion ) , the point D will be determined by the properties of the ellipse ; which in fact is nothing more than finding the inclination of the vertical at the point D with the given line DW , which inclination added to the angle DWP , gives the co-latitude of the point D. And hence may be evinced the truth of what is advanced at p. 199 .
( Vol. LXXX .
) , that if the value of an arc on a spheroid , considered as an arc of a great circle perpendicular to the meridian , be given , the longitude may be found by spherical computation , but not the latitude .
For conceive the arc HD to be perpendicular to the meridian at H , then the angle HWP would be the co-latitude of the point H ; and the former proportion would give the longitude of D , whether the figure was a sphere or spheroid ; and the angle DWP ( found by the latter proportion ) would be the co-latitude of D supposing it a sphere , in which case the point W becomes the center ; but this will not hold in a spheroid , because DW would not be perpendicular to the meridian at D. The forgoing method of computing the longitude from the measured arc of a parallel on a given ellipsoid ( though evidently the direct one ) , will be tedious , especially when the lengths of the measured arcs ( GH , HD ) are very considerable .
But when the latitude of the point H is determined from the measured arc GH ( on the known meridian ) , and the extent of the other arc ( HD ) , or rather the angle HWD , is not more than two or three degrees , the same conclusions , extremely near , may be obtained in the following manner , which is nearly the same as the method used in computing the longitudes in the Table of General results , p. 232 .
( Vol. LXXX .
) .
Suppose G and D ( fig. 1 .
) to be Greenwich and Dunkirk ; PH , PD , their meridians , as before ; and let HD ( instead of its being a parallel to the perpendicular at Greenwich ) be an arc of an ellipse cutting the meridian of Greenwich at right angles , suppose in the point H. Then the arc GH being = 152549 + 50 feet nearly ( because the ellipse which passes through D , and is at right angles to the meridian PG , will fall about 50 feet to the south of the point cut by the parallel ) , therefore the value of the arc GH , or 25433 fathoms , will , on this ellipsoid , be 25 ' 4''.4 , and consequently the angle PWH , or the co-latitude of H , is 38o 56 ' 24''.4 .
Now , the radius of curvature of this perpendicular ellipse at H , the extremity of its lesser axis , will be 3499798 fathoms * , which , divided by 57.295779 , &amp;c. ( the degrees in the circular arc which is equal to the radius ) , gives 61083 fathoms for a degree on this ellipse , considered as a great circle perpendicular to the meridian at the point H on the ellipsoid ; and since the length of this arc ( HD ) will be nearly the same as that of the parallel , or 91176 fathoms , its value will be 1o 29 ' 33''.6 ( the arc DH , or rather the angle DWH ) .
Hence , as rad .
: cotang .
1o 29 ' 33''.6 ( HWD ) : : sine 38o 56 ' 24''.4 ( HWP ) : cotang .
2o 22 ' 26''.8 , the longitude of D , or Dunkirk , the same as before , very near ; hence the longitude of Paris will be 2o 20 ' 4''.9 .
But the same may be obtained from the mean distance of the meridians of Greenwich and Paris , or 537950 feet .
See p. 599 .
in the Appendix to Vol. LXXX .
It appears from the foregoing hypothesis , that the measured degrees of the meridian in middle latitudes will answer nearly on an ellipsoid whose axes are in the ratio assigned by Sir ISAAC NEWTON .
But this will receive further confirmation from the fifth ellipsoid in the second Table , p. 232 .
( Vol. LXXX .
) , where the near agreement between the computed and measured arc of the meridian between Greenwich and Perpignan ( differing but about 52 fathoms in the extent of 8o 46 ' 44 ' ' ) would be somewhat extraordinary , were we certain that the latitude of Perpignan ( 42o 41 ' 56 ' ' ) is correct ; but this is suspected by M. DE LA * It is not necessary to determine the axes of this ellipse , because when HW is perpendicular to the curve of the meridian , it will ( by the nature of the figure ) be the radius of curvature of the arc HD at the point H. Hence , if we put v for the cotang .
and c for the cosine of the latitude of the point H , and let a denote the sine of an arc whose tang , is CE/ CP x v ; then a/ c x CE=HW , by the properties of the ellipse .
E DH G SKR B IWCPL O Fig.1 .
A HD KL Fig.2 .
S W O CAILLE .
See Mem. de l ' Acad. 1758 .
The computed arc , however , between Greenwich and Paris is 19 fathoms longer than the measured arc , which answers to a little more than 1~ of latitude .
The longitude of Paris on this ellipsoid is 9 m. 20 4/ 10 S. If it be contended , that the operations at the equator and polar circle were as correct as those executed for the like purpose in middle latitudes ; and that a kind of mean between the extreme results ought to be preferred ; we shall still get an ellipsoid , whose axes are nearly as 229 to 230 , by taking the degrees at the equator and polar circle each 70 fathoms less , and that in latitude 50~ 9~ 1/ 2 as much greater than the measured ones ; and the longitude of Paris will be found 9 m. 19 7/ 10 S. But the computed meridional arc between Greenwich and Paris will exceed the measured one by a quantity answering to about 11~ of latitude .
It is almost needless to observe , that the longitude of Paris ( 9 m. 20 s. ) deduced by Dr. MASKELYNE from the different results found by astronomical observations ( Phil. Trans. 1787 ) agrees to less than half a second with either of the above determinations .
N. B. In the Table of General Results , p. 232 .
Vol. LXXX .
read 18~ 46~ for the longitude of Wrotham Hill ; this should have been corrected in the Appendix .

