XIII .
Farther Experiments relating to the Decomposition of dephlogisticated and inflammable Air .
By Joseph Priestley , LL. D. F. R. S. Read April 7 , 1791 .
THE doctrine of phlogiston , and that of the decomposition of water , have long engaged the attention of philosophical chemists , and experiments have sometimes seemed to favour one conclusion , and sometimes an opposite one .
I have myself been very differently inclined at different times , as appears in my publications on the subject ; and I am hardly sensible of a wish which way this important controversy , as it may be called , be decided , notwithstanding the part that I have taken in it .
I cannot help thinking , however , that the experiments , an account of which I shall now lay before the Society , are decisive in favour of the composition of an acid from dephlogisticated and inflammable air ; and , therefore , that the opinion of these two kinds of air necessarily composing water cannot be well founded .
It is , indeed , sufficiently evident , that the same elements likewise compose fixed air , and therefore it is the less extraordinary that they should compose another acid .
The doctrine of phlogiston I would , however , observe , will not be , affected by the most decisive proof of the composition of water from dephlogisticated and inflammable air ; since this would only prove , that phlogiston is one constituent part of water ; which is an opinion that I have advanced , and mentioned on several occasions ; and it is the less extraordinary , as water resembles metals in the remarkable property of being a pretty good conductor of electricity .
What I shall now allege , however , will make it very doubtful , whether pure water be ever formed by the union of dephlogisticated and inflammable air ; and perhaps make it more probable , that water , as I have lately advanced , is only the basis of those kinds of air , as well as of every other kind .
It was objected to my former experiments on the decomposition of dephlogisticated and inflammable air , by firing them together in a copper vessel , which always produced an acid liquor , that this acid came from the phlogisticated air with which the dephlogisticated air that I made use of was necessarily more or less diluted ; or from that which I could not wholly exclude , as a part of atmospherical air , when I exhausted the copper vessel by means of an air-pump .
To obviate this objection , I then observed , that I not only constantly found that the more phlogisticated air was contained in the two other kinds of air ( mixed in the proportion of two measures of inflammable air to one of dephlogisticated ) the less acid I got ; but that , when I purposely mixed any given quantity of phlogisticated air with them , it appeared not to have been at all affected by the process , but remained the very same , in quantity and quality , as before .
Still , however , because Mr. CAVENDISH , though in a very different process , had found nitrous acid to result from the decomposition of phlogisticated and dephlogisticated air ; and because M. LAVOISIER and his friends had found nothing but pure water after the slow burning of dephlogisticated and inflammable air ; it was maintained by the favourers of their system , that the water only in the liquor which I procured came from the union of the two kinds of air , and the acid from the phlogisticated air which I had not been able to exclude .
But let any person only consider the very small quantity of nitrous acid which was procured by Mr. CAVENDISH from the certain decomposition of 3194 grain measures of atmospherical air , amounting to more than 61/ 2 ounce measures in one case , and of 2710 grain measures , amounting to 51/ 2 ounce measures in another case ( Phil. Trans. Vol. LXXVIII .
p. 264 .
268 .
) , three-fourths of which was phlogisticated air ; and the vastly greater quantity which I procured ( Ibid. p. 324 .
) , when it could not be proved , that a particle of phlogisticated air was decomposed , and think whether it was at all probable , that the acid came from this kind of air , and not from the union of the dephlogisticated and inflammable air , which evidently disappeared in very great quantities .
This circumstance alone might have satisfied those who interest themselves in this question ; but it does not seem to have been attended to .
I have now , however , effectually removed the objection above mentioned , by entirely excluding all phlogisticated air from the process ; the dephlogisticated air which I at present use being so pure , that it contains no sensible quantity of phlogisticated air .
I also make use of no air-pump , but first fill the copper vessel with water , and then displace it by the mixture of the two kinds of air ; yet , in these circumstances , in which all phlogisticated air is excluded , I procure even a stronger acid than before .
The paper that I send along with this article contains the dry residuum of the turbid green liquor , produced by a single explosion of a mixture of two parts inflammable and something thing more than one part of dephlogisticated air , in a copper vessel which holds thirty-seven ounces of water ; and a little more must have have remained in the vessel , which I could not get out by draining or shaking it .
It is most evident , therefore , that the acid necessary to dissolve so much copper must have come from the union of the dephlogisticated and inflammable air , because there was nothing else in the vessel .
The inflammable air was procured from iron by means of steam .
This very pure dephlogisticated air I first imagined could only be got by the process in which I observed ( Experiments on Air , Vol. II .
p. 170 .
) that I once before procured it , though I then supposed the extraordinary result to be accidental ; because in other circumstances I have sometimes had it very pure when I could not succeed in a second attempt of the same kind .
It was by heating the yellow product of the solution of mercury in spirit of nitre , without suffering the red precipitate into which it is converted by heat to come into contact with the external air , from which I thought it probable that it might attract some phlogiston .
Afterwards , however , I found that this circumstance makes no difference whatever ; and that the air so procured appeared to be purer , arose from the greater purity of the nitrous air which I made use of as a test , and which I got from mercury , and not from copper , the nitrous air from which I find to be much less pure .
For trying the dephlogisticated air yielded by some red precipitate which had been prepared many months by the nitrous air from mercury , it appeared to be as pure as that which was procured in the manner above described .
That the dephlogisticated air which I now made use of was sufficiently pure for my purpose , appeared from mixing one measure of it with two of nitrous air , when the whole quan1 tity tity was reduced to less than four hundredth parts of one measure ; so that it is probable that , by a more accurate proportion of the two kinds of air , and greater address in mixing them , they might have almost entirely disappeared .
There is besides some reason to think , from the great variety in nitrous air , that the greater part of this very small residuum comes from the nitrous air , and not from the dephlogisticated .
It will be said , how is it possible to reconcile the result of this experiment with that of M. LAVOISIER and his friends ?
which I was by no means disposed to question after the publication of the Extract from the Register of the Academy of Sciences for August 28 , 1790 , in the seventh volume of the Annals de Chimie , in which a distinct account is given of a large quantity of very pure water procured from the slow combustion of the two kinds of air above mentioned : for before this it was acknowledged , that some little acid was always found in the water so procured .
But my late experiments , besides ascertaining the fact of the production of nitrous acid from the decomposition of dephlogisticated and inflammable air , throw some farther light on the subject , and may in some measure explain their result ; for I am now able to procure , in my own process , either nitrous acid or pure water , from the same materials .
I constantly observe , that if there be a surplus of dephlogisticated air , the result of the explosion is always the acid liquor ; but that if there be a surplus of inflammable air , the result is simply water .
That phlogisticated air is not in all cases affected by this process , I completely ascertained , by admitting a little common air into that mixture of the two kinds of air which always produced water , and finding nothing but water in the result .
I find , however , that , agreeably to the experiments of Mr. CAVENDISH , phlogisticated air is decomposed in this process , when there is not enough of inflammable air to saturate the dephlogisticated air ; though when there is a redundancy of inflammable air , there is even a production of phlogisticated air .
Putting 0.5 oz. m. of phlogisticated air to a mixture of two ounce measures of inflammable air and 1.5 oz. m. of dephlogisticated air , the whole was reduced by explosion to 1.05 oz. m. of the standard of 1.1 , with two measures of dephlogisticated air , which appears by computation to contain no more than 0.388 oz. m. of phlogisticated air ; so that 0.112 oz. m. had been decomposed in the process .
When there is a sufficient quantity of inflammable air , the phlogisticated air always remains unaffected in this process , as appears by mixing any quantity of it with the two kinds of air to be exploded , and finding the very same quantity , as I have repeatedly done , in the residuum .
That when there was a sufficiency of inflammable air for the purpose , phlogisticated air is even produced in this process , was evident from my never being able to diminish any quantity of dephlogisticated air by inflammable air so far as by good nitrous air , and the residuum always containing phlogisticated air .
Having exploded two measures of inflammable air with one of dephlogisticated air , which by a mixture of two measures of nitrous air was reduced to 0.04 , there was a residuum of 0.1 , of the standard of 1.3 , which appears by computation to contain 0.0767 oz. m. of phlogisticated air .
The reason why , in my former experiments , I always procured more or less acid , must have been that , without any intention , or suspecting that any thing depended upon it , I must have had some surplus of dephlogisticated air .
M. LAVOISIER I also perceive to have taken it for granted , as I did , that after either of our processes , any surplus of either of the two kinds of air would only have remained unsaturated , and have been found unchanged in the residuum .
I claim no merit whatever in this observation .
It was in consequence of accidentally finding pure water in what I then imagined to be the same circumstances in which I had always before found acid , and which surprised me not a little at the time , that I was led to vary the proportions of the two kinds of air , till at length I succeeded in ascertaining the circumstances on which this remarkable difference in the result depends ; but I am by no means able to assign any reason for this difference .
In this state of my experiments I concluded , that nitrous acid , though consisting of the same elements with pure water , contains a greater proportion of dephlogisticated air ; and in the last edition of my Observations on Air , Vol. III .
p. 543 .
I observed , that ` ` substances , possessed of very different properties , may be composed of the same elements , in different proportions , and different modes of combination .
It cannot therefore be said to be absolutely impossible , but that water may be composed of these elements , ' ' viz. dephlogisticated and inflammable air .
When I first prepared an account of my late experiments for the Royal Society , I entertained this idea ; but I now consider it as at least uncertain , because when I mix the two kinds of air in such proportions as to produce water , I find in the residuum much more phlogisticated air than I do when acid is produced , which affords a suspicion that , in this case , the principle of acidity goes wholly into the phlogisticated air , which , as my former experiments show , actually contains it , though it is not easy to ascertain in what proportion .
Having exploded three ounce measures of a mixture of something more than two parts inflammable air , and one of dephlogisticated , and another equal quantity in which the inflammable air bore a less proportion to the dephlogisticated , the former of which I knew would yield water , and the latter acid , I found the residuum of the former to be 0.57 oz. m. not affected by nitrous air , and weakly inflammable ; and in order to find how much phlogisticated air it contained , I mixed different proportions of phlogisticated and inflammable air , and concluded , from the manner of firing them , and this residuum , that it could not consist of less than one-third of phlogisticated air , viz. 0.19 oz. m. But the residuum of the mixture which would have produced acid was 0.62 oz. m. of the standard of 1.0 , which I find by computation to contain not more than 0.062 oz. m. of phlogisticated air .
I repeated this experiment very many times , and never failed to have a similar result ; so that it is very possible that the pure water we find may be nothing more than the basis of the two kinds of air ; and the principle of acidity in the dephlogisticated air , and the phlogiston in the inflammable air , may combine to form a superfluous acid in the one case , and the phlogisticated air in the other .
This supposition is strengthened by finding that whether the produce be acid , or pure water , the two kinds of air unite in nearly the same proportions .
But since water has an affinity to almost every substance in nature , and a peculiarly strong one to the acid and alkaline principles , it may be impossible that it should be wholly free from them ; and if they be in proper proportions to saturate one another , and in the same quantities , their presence may never appear .
As the reason why , in my former experiments , I always produced an acid liquor , and never pure water , was my using too great a proportion of dephlogisticated air ; so the reason why M. LAVOISIER and his friends generally produced but little acid , and at last not at all , must have been , that the slow combustion which they made use of gave the principle of acidity in the dephlogisticated air , and the phlogiston in the inflammable air , a better opportunity of escaping , and forming the phlogisticated air in their residuum , of which they have not published any satisfactory account * ; and it is probable , that the weight of these elements compared with that of the water which forms the basis of the two kinds of air , may be very small .
That excellent philosopher M. DE LUC supposes that they have even no weight at all .
M. LAVOISIER himself , I observe , lays particular stress , ( p. 262 .
) on the slowness of the combustion , as if he suspected it to be necessary to his result .
This circumstance may also account for my want of success in the attempts that I made to repeat his experiment : for whenever I made a stream of inflammable air to burn in a vessel of dephlogisticated air ( which I contrived to do by means of a less expensive , but I own a less accurate , apparatus than his ) I always got some acid , though less than in my own process ; but I made a larger and stronger flame than I imagine M. LAVOISIER chose to produce .
In the course of these experiments , I found , that when the inflammable air I made use of was from turnings of cast iron , there was always a considerable quantity of fixed air in the residuum , not less than one-tenth of a measure , after the explosion of two * Since this was written , Mess .
FOURCROY , VAUQUELIN , and SEGUIN , have published a very particular account of their experiment ; from which it appears , that , after the combustion of the two kinds of air , there was a pretty large residuum of phlogisticated air , more than was contained in the airs before combustion .
See Annals de Chimic , for April 1791 , P. 35 .
measures of inflammable air and one of dephlogisticated ; whereas there was either no fixed air at all , or the slightest appearance of it imaginable , when I made use of inflammable air from malleable iron , extracted either by means of steam or acids .
The principal of these experiments , as well as those in my former Papers on this subject , will be found to confirm the similar ones of Mr. CAVENDISH ; but they prove the source of the acid in the results not to be what he imagined , viz. phlogisticated air , but the union of the dephlogisticated and inflammable air ; and they also make it at least doubtful , whether these two kinds of air compose pure water .

