VI .
Observations on certain horny Excrescences of the Human Body .
By Everard Home , Esq. F. R. S. Read February 17 , 1791 .
THE history of diseases belongs not properly to the province of the naturalist or philosopher ; it is intimately connected with the inquiries of the physician and anatomist ; but when disease becomes a cause of the formation of parts similar to others existing in nature , but rendered uncommon by novelty of situation , or produced in animals to which they are not naturally appropriated , it may be considered as having instituted a monstrous variety , highly deserving of attention from the naturalist .
To describe such varieties is indeed more fully the office of natural history than of medicine ; but the investigation of diseases which are found to subvert the ordinary laws of nature respecting the situation or production of parts in an animal body , undoubtedly belongs to the medical practitioner .
By these considerations I have been induced to lay before the Royal Society the following account of a disease which occurs sometimes in the human body , very remarkable in its effects , but very little understood as to its cause ; namely , the production of an excrescence similar to a horn .
So curious a phenomenon has naturally attracted the attention of the ignorant as well as the philosopher ; and the individuals who have had the misfortune to be subject to this disease have been considered as monsters .
Horny excrescences arising from the human head have not only occurred in this country , but have been met with in se1 veral veral other parts of Europe ; and the horns themselves have been deposited as valuable curiosities in the first collections in Europe .
In giving the history of a disease so rare in its occurrence , and in its effects so remarkable as almost to exceed belief , it might be thought right to take some pains in bringing proofs to ascertain that such a disease does really exist : I consider the doing so as less necessary at present , there being two women now alive , and residing in England , who are affected by the complaint .
I shall , however , in the course of this Paper , bring other evidence from the testimony of the most respectable authors who have considered this subject .
The two following cases contain a very accurate and distinct history of the progress of the disease through its different stages , and make any further detail of the symptoms entirely unnecessary .
Mrs. LONSDALE , a woman 56 years old , a native of Horncastle in Lincolnshire , fourteen years ago , observed a moveable tumor on the left side of her head , about two inches above the upper arch of the left ear , which gradually increased in the course of four or five years to the size of a pullet 's egg , when it burst , and for a week continued to discharge a thick , gritty fluid .
In the center of the tumor , after the fluid was discharged , she perceived a small soft substance , of the size of a pea , and of a reddish colour on the top , which at that time she took for proud flesh .
It gradually increased in length and thickness , and continued pliable for about three months , when it first began to put on a horny appearance .
In two years and three months from its first formation , made desperate by the increased violence of the pain , she attempted to tear it from her head ; and with much difficulty , and many efforts , at length broke it in the middle , and afterwards tore the root from her head , leaving a considerable depression which still remains in the part where it grew .
Its length altogether is about five inches , and its circumference at the two ends about one inch ; but in the middle rather less .
It is curled like a ram 's horn contorted , and in colour much resembling isinglass .
From the lower edge of the depression another horn is now growing , of the same colour with the former , in length about three inches , and nearly the thickness of a small goose quill ; it is less contorted , and lies close upon the head .
A third horn , situated about the upper part of the lambdoidal suture , is much curved , above an inch in length , and more in circumference at its root : its direction is backwards , with some elevation from the head .
At this place two or three successive horns have been produced , which she has constantly torn away ; but , as fresh ones have speedily followed , she leaves the present one unmolested in hopes of its dropping off .
Besides these horny excrescences , there are two tumors , each the size of a large cockle ; one upon the upper part , the other about the middle of the left side of the head ; both of them admit of considerable motion , and seem to contain fluids of unequal consistence ; the upper one affording an obscure fluctuation , the other a very evident one .
The four horns were all preceded by the same kind of incysted tumours , and the fluid in all of them was gritty ; the openings from which the matter issued were very small , the cysts collapsed and dried up , leaving the substance from which the horn proceeded distinguishable at the bottom .
These cysts gave little pain till the horns began to shoot , and then became very distressing , and continued with short intervals till they were removed .
This case is drawn up by the surgeon who attended the woman for many years , which gave him frequent opportunities of seeing the disease in its different stages , and acquiring an accurate history of its symptoms .
Mrs. ALLEN , a middle-aged woman , resident in Leicestershire , had an incysted tumor upon her head , immediately under the scalp , very moveable , and evidently containing a fluid .
It gave no pain unless pressed upon , and grew to the size of a small hen 's egg .
A few years ago it burst , and discharged a fluid ; this diminished in quantity , and in a short time a horny excrescence , similar to those above mentioned , grew out from the orifice , which has continued to increase in size ; and in the month of November 1790 , the time I saw it , was about five inches long , and a little more than an inch in circumference at its base .
It was a good deal contorted , and the surface very irregular , having a laminated appearance .
It moved readily with the scalp , and seemed to give no pain upon motion ; but , when much handled , the surrounding skin became inflamed .
This woman came to London , and exhibited herself as a show for money ; and it is highly probable , that so rare an occurrence would have sufficiently excited the public attention to have made it answer her expectations in point of emolument , had not the circumstance been made known to her neighbours in the country , who were much dissatisfied with the measure , and by their importunity obliged her husband to take her into the country .
That the cases which I have related may not be considered as peculiar instances from which no conclusions can be drawn , it may not be amiss to take notice of some of the most remarkable histories of this kind , mentioned by authors , and see how far they agree with those I have stated , in the general characters that are sufficiently obvious to strike a common observer ; for the vague and indefinite terms in which authors express themselves selves on this subject show plainly , that they did not understand the nature of the disease , and their accounts of it are not very satisfactory to their readers .
In the Ephemerides Academiae Naturae Curiosorum there are two cases of horns growing from the human body .
One of these instances was a German woman * , who had several swellings , or ganglions , upon different parts of her head , from one of which a horn grew .
The other was a nobleman ~ , who had a small tumor , about the size of a nut , growing upon the parts covering the two last or lowermost vertebrae of the back .
It continued for ten years , without undergoing any apparent change ; but afterwards enlarged in size , and a horny excrescence grew out from it .
In the History of the Royal Society of Medicine ~ , there is an account of a woman , 97 years old , who had several tumors on her head , which had been 14 years in growing to the state they were in at that time : she had also a horn which had originated from a similar tumor .
The horn was very moveable , being attached to the scalp , without any adhesion to the scull .
It was sawn off , but grew again , and although the operation was repeated several times , the horn always returned .
BARTHOLINE , in his Epistles ~ , takes notice of a woman who had a tumor under the scalp , covering the temporal muscle .
This gradually enlarged , and a horn grew from it , which had become twelve inches long in the year 1646 , the time he saw it .
He gives us a representation of it , which bears a very accurate resemblance to that which I have mentioned to have seen in November 1790 .
No tumor or swelling is * Ephem .
Acad. Not .
Cur .
Dec. iii .
An. V. Append .
p. 148 .
~ Ibid. Dec. i. An. I. Observat .
30 .
~ Histoire de la Societe Royale de Medecine , 1776 , p. 316 .
~ Epistol .
THOM .
BARTHOL .
expressed in the figure ; but the horn is coming directly out from the surface of the skin .
In the Natural History of Cheshire * , a woman is mentioned to have lived in the year 1668 , who had a tumor or wen upon her head for 32 years , which afterwards enlarged , and two horns grew out of it ; she was then 72 years old .
There is a horny excrescence in the British Museum , which is eleven inches long , and two inches and a half in circumference at the base , or thickest part .
The following account of this horn I have been favoured with by Dr. GRAY , taken from the records of the Museum .
A woman , named FRENCH , who lived near Tenterden , had a tumor or wen upon her head , which increased to the size of a walnut ; and in the 48th year of her age this horn began to grow , and in four years arrived at its present size ~ .
There are many similar histories of these horny excrescences in the authors I have quoted , and in several others ; but those mentioned above are the most accurate and particular with respect to their growth , and in all of them we find the origin was from a tumor , as in the two cases I have related ; and although the nature of the tumor is not particularly mentioned , there can be no doubt of its being of the incysted kind , since in its * LEE'S Natural History of Lancashire and Cheshire .
~ The following extract is taken from the Minutes of the Royal Society , Feb. 14 , 1704-5 .
A Letter was read from Dr. CHARIERE , at Barnstaple , concerning a horn , seven inches long , cut off the second vertebra of the neck of a woman in that neighbourhood .
Dr. GREGORY said , that one of seven inches long , and of a dark brown colour , was cut off from a woman 's temple at Edinburgh .
Dr. NORRIS said , that two horns had been cut off from a woman 's head in Cheshire .
progress it exactly resembled them , remaining stationary for a long time , and then coming forwards to the skin ; and the horn being much smaller than the tumor previously to the formation of the horn , is a proof that the tumor must have burst , and discharged its contents .
From the foregoing account it must appear evident , that these horny excrescences are not to be ranked among the appearances called lusus naturae : nor are they altogether the product of disease , although undoubtedly the consequence of a local disease having previously existed ; they are , more properly speaking , the result of certain operations in the part for its own restoration ; but the actions of the animal oeconomy being unable to bring them back to their original state , this species of excrescence is formed as a substitute for the natural cuticular covering .
To explain the manner in which these horns are formed , it will be necessary to consider the nature of incysted tumors a little more fully ; and in doing so we shall find , that this particular species does not differ in its principle , nor materially in its effects , from many others which are not uncommonly met with in the human body , as well as in those of many other animals , which , as they are more frequent in their occurrence , are also much better understood .
Incysted tumors differ exceedingly among themselves , both in the nature of their contents , and in their progress towards the external surface of the body .
Many of them have no reference to our present purpose ; it is only the more indolent kind to which I mean now to advert : some of these , when examined , are not found to contain a fluid , but a small quantity of thick , curd-like matter , mixed with cuticle broken down into small parts , and upon exposing the internal surface of the cyst , it is found to have an uniform cuticular covering adhering to it , similar to that of the cutis on the surface of the body , from which it only differs in being thinner , and more delicate , bearing a greater resemblance to that which covers the lips .
Others of this kind , instead of having cuticle for their contents , are filled with hair mixed with a curdled substance , or hair without any admixture whatever , and have a similar kind of hair growing upon their internal surface , which is likewise covered with a cuticle .
These cuticular incysted tumors were , I believe , first accurately examined by Mr. HUNTER , to whom we are likewise indebted for an explanation of the mode in which the parts acquire this particular structure .
Mr. HUNTER considers the internal surface of the cyst to be so circumstanced respecting the body , as to lose the stimulus of being an internal part , and receive the same impression from its contents , either from their nature , or the length of application , as the surface of the skin does from its external situation .
It therefore takes on actions suited to such stimuli , undergoes a change in its structure , and acquires a disposition similar to the cutis , and is consequently possessed of the power of producing cuticle and hair .
What the mode of action is , by which this change is brought about , is not easily determined ; but from the indolence of these complaints , it most probably requires a considerable length of time to produce it .
That the lining of the cyst really does posses powers similar to cutis , is proved by the following circumstances : that it has a power of forming a succession of cuticles like the common skin ; and what is thrown off in this way is found in the cavity of the cyst .
It has a similar power respecting hair , and sometimes the cavity is filled with it , so great a quantity has been shed by the internal surface .
Besides these circumstances , the hair found in the cyst corresponds in appearance with that which grows upon the body of the animal ; and when incysted tumors of this kind form in sheep , they contain wool .
What is still more curious , when such cysts are laid open , the internal surface undergoes no change from exposure , the cut edges cicatrize , and the bottom of the bag remains ever after an external surface .
Different specimens , illustrative of the above-mentioned circumstances , are preserved in Mr. HUNTER'S collection of diseases .
The cysts that produce horny excrescences ( which are only another modification of cuticle ) are very improperly considered as giving rise to horns ; for if we examine the mode in which this substance grows , we shall find it the same with the human nails , coming directly out from the surface of the cutis .
It differs from the nails in not being set upon the skin by a thin edge , but by a surface of some breadth , with a hollow in the middle , exactly in the same manner as the horn of the rhinoceros * ; at least this is evidently the case in the specimen preserved in the British Museum , and in one which grew out from the tip of a sheep 's ear ; they are also solid , or nearly so , in their substance .
This mode of growth is very different from that of horns , which are all formed upon a core , either of bone or soft parts , by which means they have a cavity in them ; a structure peculiar to this kind of cuticular substance .
Incysted tumors in different animals would appear , from these observations , to be confined in their production to the * The horn of the Rhinoceros is a cuticular appendage to the skin , similar to nails and other cuticular excrescences , being in no respect allied to horns but in the external appearance .
cuticular substance proper to the animal in which they take place ; for , although cuticle , hair , nail , hoof , and horn , are equally productions of animal substance , only differing in trivial circumstances from each other , we do not find in the human subject any instance of an incysted tumor containing a substance different from the cuticle , hair , and nails of the human body , to which last the horny excrescences , the subject of the present Paper , are certainly very closely allied , both in growth , structure , and external appearance ; and when of some length , they are found to be so brittle as to break in two , upon being roughly handled , which could not happen either to hoof or horn .
In the sheep they produce wool instead of hair ; and in one instance in that animal , where they gave rise to an horny excrescence , it was less compact in its texture , and less brittle than similar appearances in the human subject ; upon being divided longitudinally , the cut surface had more the appearance of hoof , and was more varied in its colour than nail .
Incysted tumors being capable of producing horns , upon the principle we have laid down , is contrary to the usual operations of nature ; for horns are not a production from the cutis , and although not always formed upon a bony core , but frequently upon a soft pulp , that substance differs from common cutis in its appearance , and extends a consideraway into the horn : it is probable , that this pulp requires a particular process for its formation * .
*A sheep , about four years old , had a large horn , three feet long , growing upon its flank .
It had no connection with bone , and appeared to be only attached to the external skin .
It dropped off in consequence of its weight having produced ulceration in the soft parts to which it adhered .
Upon examining it there was a fleshy substance , seven inches long , of a fibrous texture filling up its cavity upon which the horn had been formed .
I shall conclude this Paper by observing , that the cases of horns , as they are commonly termed , upon the human head , are no more than cuticular productions arising from a cyst , which in its nature is a variety of those tumors described by Mr. HUNTER under the general name of cuticular incysted tumors * .
These incysted tumors , when considered as varieties of the same disease , form a very complete and beautiful series of the different modes by which the powers of the animal oeconomy produce a substitute for the common cuticle upon parts which have been so much affected by disease as to be unable to restore themselves to a natural state .
* The principle upon which the production of these excrescences depends being once explained , the modes of preventing their formation , and removing them when formed , will be readily understood , the destruction of the cyst being all that is required for that purpose .
This may be done before the tumor opens externally , or even after the excrescence has begun to shoot out , and will be better effected by dissection than escharotics , since the success of the operation depends upon the whole of the bag being removed .

