IV .
On Nebulous Stars , properly so called .
By William Herschel , LL. D. F. R. S. Read February 10 , 1791 .
IN one of my late examinations of a space in the heavens , which I had not reviewed before , I discovered a star of about the 8th magnitude , surrounded with a faintly luminous atmosphere , of a considerable extent .
The phenomenon was so striking that I could not help reflecting upon the circumstances that attended it , which appeared to me to be of a very instructive nature , and such as may lead to inferences which will throw a considerable light on some points relating to the construction of the heavens .
Cloudy or nebulous stars have been mentioned by several astronomers ; but this name ought not to be applied to the objects which they have pointed out as such ; for , on examination , they proved to be either mere clusters of stars , plainly to be distinguished with my large instruments , or such nebulous appearances as might be reasonably supposed to be occasioned by a multitude of stars at a vast distance .
The milky way itself , as I have shown in some former Papers , consists entirely of stars , and by imperceptible degrees I have been led on from the most evident congeries of stars to other groups in which the lucid points were smaller , but still very plainly to be seen ; and from them to such wherein they could but barely be suspected , till I arrived at last to spots in which no trace of a star was to be discerned .
But then the gradations to these latter were by such well-connected steps as left no room for doubt but that all these phenomenon were equally occasioned by stars , variously dispersed in the immense expanse of the universe .
When I pursued these researches , I was in the situation of a natural philosopher who follows the various species of animals and insects from the height of their perfection down to the lowest ebb of life ; when , arriving at the vegetable kingdom , he can scarcely point out to us the precise boundary where the animal ceases and the plant begins ; and may even go so far as to suspect them not to be essentially different .
But recollecting himself , he compares , for instance , one of the human species to a tree , and all doubt upon the subject vanishes before him .
In the same manner we pass through gentle steps from a coarse cluster of stars , such as the Pleiades , the Praesepe , the milky way , the cluster in the Crab , the nebula in Hercules , that near the preceding hip of Boots ( a ) , the 17th , 38th , 41st of the 7th class of my Catalogues ( b ) , the 10th , 20th , 35th of the 6th class ( c ) , the 33d , 48th , 213th of the 1st ( d ) , the 12th , ( a ) RA .
13 h. 27 ' 40 ' ' .
PD. 60o 2 ' .
The places of all the objects mentioned in this Paper are not brought to the present time , but given as they were calculated from the best observations I have made of them ; the change in their situation arising from the lapse of a few years is too trifling to be any hindrance to our finding them very easily .
h. ' ' ' o ' ( b ) VII .
17 .
RA .
79 45 .
PD. 114 34 .
38 .
6 53 16 .
88 37 .
41 .
22 20 20 .
38 47 .
( c ) VI .
10 .
16 14 22 .
115 32 .
20 .
0 42 4 .
117 46 .
35 .
0 19 44 .
29 41 .
( d ) I. 33 .
11 57 26 .
78 25 .
48 .
17 10 46 .
107 36 .
213 .
12 17 59 .
44 45 .
150th , 756th of the 2d ( a ) , and the 18th , 140th , 725th of the 3d ( b ) , without any hesitation , till we find ourselves brought to an object such as the nebula in Orion , where we are still inclined to remain in the once adopted idea , of stars exceedingly remote , and inconceivable crowded , as being the occasion of that remarkable appearance .
It seems , therefore , to require a more dissimilar object to set us right again .
A glance like that of the naturalist , who casts his eye from the perfect animal to the perfect vegetable , is wanting to remove the veil from the mind of the astronomer .
The object I have mentioned above , is the phenomenon that was wanting for this purpose .
View , for instance , the 19th cluster of my 6th class ( c ) , and afterwards cast your eye on this cloudy star ( d ) , and the result will be no less decisive than that of the naturalist we have alluded to .
Our judgement , I may venture to say , will be , that the nebulosity about the star is not of a starry nature .
But , that we may not be too precipitate in these new decisions , let us enter more at large into the various grounds which induced us formerly to surmise , that every visible object , in the extended and distant heavens , was of the starry kind , and collate them with those which now offer themselves for the contrary opinion .
h. ' ' ' o ' ' ( a ) II .
12 .
RA .
12 32 37 .
PD. 72 23 .
150 .
14 19 53 .
81 43 .
756 .
14 51 42 .
35 22 .
( b ) III .
18 .
12 41 7 .
84 51 .
140 .
15 8 .
92 0 .
725 .
12 6 57 .
43 14 .
( c ) VI .
19 .
15 5 2 .
110 14 .
( d ) 3 56 48 .
59 50 .
It has been observed , on a former occasion , that all the smaller parts of other great systems , such as the planets , their rings and satellites , the comets , and such other bodies of the like nature as may belong to them , can never be perceived by us , on account of the faintness of light reflected from small , opaque objects ; in my present remarks , therefore , all these are to be entirely set aside .
A well connected series of objects , such as we have mentioned above , has led us to infer , that all nebulae consist of stars .
This being admitted , we were authorized to extend our analogical way of reasoning a little farther .
Many of the nebulae had no other appearance than that whitish cloudiness , on the blue ground upon which they seemed to be projected ; and why the same cause should not be assigned to explain the most extensive nebulosities , as well as those that amounted only to a few minutes of a degree in size , did not appear .
It could not be inconsistent to call up a telescopic milky way , at an immense distance , to account for such phenomenon ; and if any part of the nebulosity seemed detached from the rest , or contained a visible star or two , the probability of seeing a few near stars , apparently scattered over the far distant regions of myriads of sidereal collections , rendered nebulous by their distance , would also clear up these singularities .
In order to be more easily understood in my remarks on the comparative disposition of the heavenly bodies , I shall mention some of the particulars which introduced the ideas of connection and disjunction : for these , being properly founded upon an examination of objects that may be reviewed at any time , will be of considerable importance to the validity of what we may advance with regard to my lately discovered nebulous stars .
On June the 27th , 1786 , I saw a beautiful cluster of very small stars of various sizes , about 15~ in diameter , and very rich of stars ( a ) .
On viewing this object , it is impossible to withhold our assent to the idea which occurs , that these stars are connected so far one with another as to be gathered together , within a certain space , of little extent , when compared to the vast expanse of the heavens .
As this phenomenon has been repeatedly seen in a thousand cases , I may justly lay great stress on the idea of such stars being connected .
In the year 1779 , the 9th of September , I discovered a very small star near ~ Bootis ( b ) .
The question here occurring , whether it had any connection with ~ or not , was determined in the negative ; for , considering the number of stars scattered in a variety of places , it is very far from being uncommon , that a star at a great distance should happen to be nearly in a line drawn from the sun through ~ , and thus constitute the observed double star .
The 7th of September , 1782 , when I first saw the planetary nebula near ~ Aquarii ( c ) , I pronounced it to be a system whose parts were connected together .
Without entering into any kind of calculation , it is evident , that a certain equal degree of light within a very small space , joined to the particular shape this object presents to us , which is nearly round , and even in its deviation consistent with regularity , being a little elliptical , ought naturally to give us the idea of a conjunction in the things that produce it .
And a considerable addition to this argument may be derived from a repetition of the same phenomenon , in nine or ten more of a similar construction .
( a ) RA .
18h .
20~ 2~ .
PD. 107~ 3~ .
( b ) Phil. Trans. Vol. LXXII .
p. 115 .
Catalogue of Double Stars , I. 1 .
( c ) RA .
20 h. 52~ 36~ .
PD. 102~ 12~ .
When I examined the cluster of stars , following the head of the great dog ( a ) , I found on the 19th of March , 1786 , that there was within this cluster a round , resolvable nebula , of about two minutes in diameter , and nearly of an equal degree of light throughout ( b ) .
Here , considering that the cluster was free from nebulosity in other parts , and that many such clusters , as well as many such nebulae , exist in divers parts of the heavens , it appeared to me very probable , that the nebula was unconnected with the cluster ; and that a similar reason would as easily account for this appearance as it had resolved the phenomenon of the double star near ~ Bootis ; that is , a casual situation of our sun and the two other objects nearly in a line .
And though it may be rather more remarkable , that this should happen with two compound systems , which are not by far so numerous as single stars , we have , to make up for this singularity , a much larger space in which it may take place , the cluster being of a very considerable extent .
On the 15th of February , 1786 , I discovered that one of my planetary nebulae ( c ) , had a spot in the center , which was more luminous than the rest , and with long attention , a very bright , round , well defined center became visible .
I remained not a single moment in doubt , but that the bright center was connected with the rest of the apparent disk .
In the year 1785 , the 6th of October , I found a very bright , round nebula , of about 11/ 2 minute in diameter ( d ) .
It has a large , bright nucleus in the middle , which is undoubtedly h. ~~~~ ( a ) RA .
7 32 1 .
PD. 104 18 .
( b ) 7 32 5 .
104 15 .
( c ) 17 58 25 .
23 22 .
( d ) 3 30 35 .
109 15 .
connected with the luminous parts about it .
And though we must confess , that if this phenomenon , and many more of the same nature , recorded in my catalogues of nebulae , consist of clustering stars , we find ourselves involved in some difficulty to account for the extraordinary condensation of them about the center ; yet the idea of a connection between the outward parts and these very condensed ones within is by no means lessened on that account .
There is a telescopic milky way , which I have traced out in the heavens in many sweeps made from the year 1783 to 1789 ( a ) .
It takes up a space of more than 60 square degrees of the heavens , and there are thousands of stars scattered over it : among others , four that form a trapezium , and are situated in the well known nebula of Orion , which is included in the above extent .
All these stars , as well as the four I have mentioned , I take to be entirely unconnected with the nebulosity which involves them in appearance .
Among them is also d Orionis , a cloudy star , improperly so called by former astronomers ; but it does not seem to be connected with the milkiness any more than the rest .
I come now to some other phenomenon , that , from their singularity , merit undoubtedly a very full discussion .
Among the reasons which induced us to embrace the opinion , that all very faint milky nebulosity ought to be ascribed to an assemblage of stars is , that we could not easily assign any other cause of sufficient importance for such luminous appearances , to reach us at the immense distance we must suppose ourselves to be from them .
But if an argument of considerable force should now be brought forward , to show the existence of a luminous matter , in a state of modification very different from the con(a ) RA .
from 5h .
15 ' 8 ' ' to 5h .
39 ' 1 ' .
PD. from 87o 46 ' to 98o 10 ' .
struction of a sun or star , all objections , drawn from our incapacity of accounting for new phenomenon upon old principles , will lose their validity .
Hitherto I have been showing , by various instances in objects whose places are given , in what manner we may form the ideas of connection and its contrary by an attentive inspection of them only : I will now relate a series of observations , with remarks upon them as they are delivered , from which I shall afterwards draw a few simple conclusions , that seem to be of considerable importance .
To distinguish the observations from the remarks , the former are given in italics , and the date annexed is that on which the objects were discovered ; but the descriptions are extracted from all the observations that have been made upon them .
October 16 , 1784 .
A star of about the 9th magnitude , surrounded by a milky nebulosity , or chevelure , of about 3 minutes in diameter .
The nebulosity is very faint , and a little extended or elliptical , the extent being not sar from the meridian , or a little from north preceding to south following .
The chevelure involves a small star , which is about 1 1/ 2 minute north of the cloudy star ; other stars of equal magnitude are perfectly free from this appearance ( a ) .
My present judgement concerning this remarkable object is , that the nebulosity belongs to the star which is situated in its center .
The small one , on the contrary , which is mentioned as involved , being one of many that are profusely scattered over this rich neighbourhood , I suppose to be quite unconnected with this phenomenon .
A circle of three minutes in diameter is sufficiently large to admit another small star , without any bias to the judgement I form concerning the one in question .
( a ) RA .
5h .
57 ' 4 ' ' .
PD. 96o 22 ' .
It must appear singular , that such an object should not have immediately suggested all the remarks contained in this Paper ; but about things that appear new we ought not to form opinions too hastily , and my observations on the construction of the heavens were then but entered upon .
In this case , therefore , it was the safest way to lay down a rule not to reason upon the phenomenon that might offer themselves , till I should be in possession of a sufficient stock of materials to guide my researches .
October 16 , 1784 .
A small star of about the 11th or 12th magnitude , very faintly affected with milky nebulosity ; other stars of the same magnitude are perfectly free from this appearance .
Another observation mentions 5 or 6 small stars within the space of 3 or 4 ' , all very faintly affected in the same manner , and the nebulosity suspected to be a little stronger about each star .
But a third observation rather opposes this increase of the faintly luminous appearance ( a ) .
Here the connection between the stars and the nebulosity is not so evident as to amount to conviction ; for which reason we shall pass on to the next .
January the 6th , 1785 .
A bright star with a considerable milky chevelure ; a little extended , 4 or 5 ' in length , and near 4 ' broad ; it loses itself insensibly .
Other stars of equal magnitude are perfectly free from this chevelure ( b ) .
The connection between the star and the chevelure cannot be doubted , from the insensible gradation of its luminous appearance , decreasing as it receded from the center .
h. ' ' ' o ' ( a ) RA .
60 33 .
PD. 96 13 .
( b ) 5 30 53 .
92 21 .
January 31 , 1785 .
A pretty considerable star , with a very faint , and very small , irregular , milky chevelure ; other stars of the same size are perfectly free from such appearance ( a ) .
I can have no doubt of the connection between the star and its chevelure .
October 5 , 1785 .
A star with a strong bur all around .
A second observation calls it a very bright nucleus , with a milky nebulosity , of no great extent .
A third suspects the milkiness to belong to more of the same , which is diffused over the whole sweep in that place ; but a fourth says , that the milky nebulosity is much stronger than what the nebulous ground , on which the star is placed , entitles it to ( b ) .
The connection , therefore , between the nebulosity and the star is evident .
January 1 , 1786 .
A star surrounded with milky chevelure ; the star is not central .
A second observation calls it affected with a very faint , and extensive , milky chevelure .
A third only mentions a star affected with milky chevelure ( c ) .
As by the word chevelure I always denoted something relating to a center , the connection cannot be doubted .
February 24 , 1786 .
A considerable star , very faintly affected with milky chevelure .
A second observation , much the same ( d ) .
November 28 , 1786 .
A star involved in milky chevelure ( e ) .
h. ' ' ' o ' ( a ) RA .
6 54 27 .
PD. 100 53 .
( b ) 5 25 57 .
96 52 .
( c ) 5 35 56 .
89 50 .
( d ) 5 59 4 .
96 19 .
( e ) 5 57 4 .
96 15 .
January 17 , 1787 .
A star with a pretty strong milky nebulosity , equally dispersed all around ; the star is of about the 9th magnitude .
A memorandum to the observation says , that , having but just begun , I suspected the glass to be covered with damp , or the eye out of order ; but yet a star of the 10th or 11th magnitude , just north of it , was free from the same appearance .
A second observation calls it one of the most remarkable phenomenon I ever have seen , and like my northern planetary nebula in its growing state ( a ) .
The connection between the star and the milky nebulosity is without all doubt .
November 3 , 1787 .
A bright star with faint nebulosity .
A second observation mentions the star to be of the 9th magnitude , and the faint nebulosity of very little extent ( b ) .
June 11 , 1787 .
Suspected , stellar .
By a second observation it is verified , and called a very small star involved in extremely saint nebulosity ( c ) .
November 25 , 1788 .
A star of about the 9th magnitude , surrounded with very saint milky nebulosity ; other stars of the same size are perfectly free from that appearance .
Less than 1 ' in diameter .
The star is either not round or double ( d ) .
March 23 , 1789 .
A bright , considerably well defined nucleus , with a very faint , small , round chevelure ( e ) .
The connection admits of no doubt ; but the object is not perhaps of the same nature with those which I call cloudy stars .
h. ''o ' ( a ) RA .
7 16 28 .
PD. 68 39 .
( b ) 23 11 26 .
30 0 .
( c ) 17 1 51 .
47 26 .
( d ) 01 57 .
18 41 .
( e ) 11 12 25 .
50 17 .
April 14 , 1789 .
A considerable , bright , round nebula ; having a large place in the middle of nearly an equal brightness , but less bright towards the margin ( a ) .
This seems rather to approach to the planetary sort .
March 5 , 1790 .
A pretty considerable star of the 9th or 10th magnitude , visibly affected with very faint nebulosity of little extent , all around .
A power of 300 showed the nebulosity of greater extent ( b ) .
The connection is not to be doubted .
March 19 , 1970 .
A very bright nucleus , with a small , very faint chevelure , exactly round .
In a low situation , where the chevelure could hardly be seen , this object would put on the appearance of an ill-desined , planetary nebula , of 6 , 8 , or 10 ' ' diameter ( c ) .
November 13 , 1790 .
A most singular phenomenon !
A star of about the 8th magnitude , with a faint luminous atmosphere , of a circular form , and of about 3 ' in diameter .
The star is perfectly in the center , and the atmosphere is so diluted , faint , and equal throughout , that there can be no surmise of its consisting of stars ; nor can there be a doubt of the evident connection between the atmosphere and the star .
Another star not much less in brightness , and in the same field with the above , was perfectly free from any such appearance ( d ) .
This last object is so decisive in every particular , that we need not hesitate to admit it as a pattern , from which we are anthorized to draw the following important consequences .
h. ' ' ' o ' ( a ) RA .
11 45 12 .
PD. 33 43 .
( b ) 6 58 40 .
91 29 .
( c ) 9 27 22 .
30 11 .
( d ) 3 56 48 .
59 50 .
Supposing the connection between the star and its surrounding nebulosity to be allowed , we argue , that one of the two following cases must necessarily be admitted .
In the first place , if the nebulosity consist of stars that are very remote , which appear nebulous on account of the small angles their mutual distances subtend at the eye , whereby they will not only , as it were , run into one another , but also appear extremely faint and diluted ; then , what must be the enormous size of the central point , which outshines all the rest in so superlative a degree as to admit of no comparison ?
In the next place , if the star be no bigger than common , how very small and compressed must be those other luminous points that are the occasion of the nebulosity which surrounds the central one ?
As , by the former supposition , the luminous central point must far exceed the standard of what we call a star , so , in the latter , the shining matter about the center will be much too small to come under the same denomination ; we therefore either have a central body which is not a star , or have a star which is involved in a shining fluid , of a nature totally unknown to us .
I can adopt no other sentiment than the latter , since the probability is certainly not for the existence of so enormous a body as would be required to shine like a star of the 8th magnitude , at a distance sufficiently great to cause a vast system of stars to put on the appearance of a very diluted , milky nebulosity .
But what a field of novelty is here opened to our conceptions !
A shining fluid , of a brightness sufficient to reach us from the remote regions of a star of the 8th , 9th , 10th , 11th , or 12th magnitude , and of an extent so considerable as to take up 3 , 4 , 5 , or 6 minutes in diameter !
Can we compare it to the coruscations of the electrical fluid in the aurora borealis ?
Or to the more magnificent cone of the zodiacal light as we see it in spring or autumn ?
The latter , notwithstanding I have observed it to reach at least 90 degrees from the sun , is yet of so little extent and brightness as probably not to be perceived even by the inhabitants of Saturn or the Georgian planet , and must be utterly invisible at the remoteness of the nearest fixed star .
More extensive views may be derived from this proof of the existence of a shining matter .
Perhaps it has been too hastily surmised that all milky nebulosity , of which there is so much in the heavens , is owing to starlight only .
These nebulous stars may serve as a clue to unravel other mysterious phenomenon .
If the shining fluid that surrounds them is not so essentially connected with these nebulous stars but that it can also exist without them , which seems to be sufficiently probable , and will be examined hereafter , we may with great facility explain that very extensive , telescopic nebulosity , which , as I mentioned before , is expanded over more than sixty degrees of the heavens , about the constellation of Orion ; a luminous matter accounting much better for it than clustering stars at a distance .
In this case we may also pretty nearly guess at its situation , which must commence somewhere about the range of the stars of the 7th magnitude , or a little farther from us , and extend unequally in some places perhaps to the regions of those of the 9th , 10th , 11th , and 12th .
The foundation for this surmise is , that , not unlikely , some of the stars that happen to be situated in a more condensed part of it , or that perhaps by their own attraction draw together some quantity of this fluid greater than what they are entitled to by their situation in it , will , of course , assume the appearance of cloudy stars ; and many of those I have named are either in this stratum of luminous matter , or very near it .
We have said above , that in nebulous stars the existence of the shining fluid does not seem to be so essentially connected with the central points that it might not also exist without them .
For this opinion we may assign several reasons .
One of them is the great resemblance between the chevelure of these stars and the diffused extensive nebulosity mentioned before , which renders it highly probable that they are of the same nature .
Now , if this be admitted , the separate existence of the luminous matter , or its independence on a central star , is fully proved .
We may also judge , very confidently , that the light of this shining fluid is no kind of reflection from the star in the center ; for , as we have already observed , reflected light could never reach us at the great distance we are from such objects .
Besides , how impenetrable would be an atmosphere of a sufficient density to reflect so great a quantity of light ?
And yet we observe , that the outward parts of the chevelure are nearly as bright as those that are close to the star ; so that this supposed atmosphere ought to give no obstruction to the passage of the central rays .
If , therefore , this matter is self-luminous , it seems more fit to produce a star by its condensation than to depend on the star for its existence .
Many other diffused nebulosities , besides that about the constellation of Orion , have been observed or suspected ; but some of them are probably very distant , and run out far into space .
For instance , about 5 minutes in time preceding ~ Cygni , I suspect as much of it as covers near four square degrees ; and much about the same quantity 44 ' preceding the 125 Tauri .
A space of almost 8 square degrees , 6 ' preceding ~ Trianguli , seems to be tinged with milky nebulosity .
Three minutes preceding the 46 Eridani , strong , milky nebulosity is expanded over more than two square degrees .
54 ' preceding the 13th Canum venaticorum , and again 48 ' preceding the same star , I found the field of view affected with whitish nebulosity throughout the whole breadth of the sweep , which was 2o 39 ' .
4 ' following the 57 Cygni , a considerable space is filled with faint , milky nebulosity , which is pretty bright in some places , and contains the 37th nebula of my Vth class , in the brightest part of it .
In the neighbourhood of the 44th Piscium , very faint nebulosity appears to be diffused over more than 9 square degrees of the heavens .
Now , all these phenomenon , as we have already seen , will admit of a much easier explanation by a luminous fluid than by stars at an immense distance .
The nature of planetary nebulae , which has hitherto been involved in much darkness , may now be explained with some degree of satisfaction , since the uniform and very considerable brightness of their apparent disk accords remarkably well with a much condensed , luminous fluid ; whereas to suppose them to consist of clustering stars will not so completely account for the milkiness or soft tint of their light , to produce which it would be required that the condensation of the stars should be carried to an almost inconceivable degree of accumulation .
The surmise of the regeneration of stars , by means of planetary nebulae , expressed in a former Paper , will become more probable , as all the luminous matter contained in one of them , when gathered together into a body of the size of a star , would have nearly such a quantity of light as we find the planetary nebulae to give .
To prove this experimentally , we may view them with a telescope that does not magnify sufficiently to show their extent , by which means we shall gather all their light together into a point , when they will be found to assume the appearance of small stars ; that is , of stars at the distance of those which we call of the 8th , 9th , or 10th magnitude .
Indeed this idea is greatly supported by the discovery of a well defined , lucid point , resembling a star , in the center of one of them : for the argument which has been used , in the case of nebulous stars , to show the probability of the existence of a luminous matter , which rested upon the disparity between a bright point and its surrounding shining fluid , may here be alleged with equal justice .
If the point be a generating star , the further accumulation of the already much condensed , luminous matter , may complete it in time .
How far the light that is perpetually emitted from millions of suns may be concerned in this shining fluid , it might be presumptuous to attempt to determine ; but , notwithstanding the unconceivable subtilty of the particles of light , when the number of the emitting bodies is almost infinitely great , and the time of the continual emission indefinitely long , the quantity of emitted particles may well become adequate to the constitution of a shining fluid , or luminous matter , provided a cause can be found that may retain them from flying off , or reunite them .
But such a cause cannot be difficult to guess at , when we know that light is so easily reflected , refracted , inflected , and deflected ; and that , in the immense range of its course , it must pass through innumerable systems , where it cannot but frequently meet with many obstacles to its rectilinear progression .
Not to mention the great counteraction of the united attractive force of whole sidereal systems , which must be continually exerting their power upon the particles while they are endeavouring to fly off .
However , we shall lay no stress upon a surmise of this kind , as the means of veri1 fying fying it are wanting : nor is it of any immediate consequence to us to know the origin of the luminous matter .
Let it suffice , that its existence is rendered evident , by means of nebulous stars .
I hope it will be found , that in what has been said I have not launched out into hypothetical reasonings ; and that facts have all along been kept sufficiently in view .
But , in order to give every one a fair opportunity to follow me in the reflections I have been led into , the place of every object from which I have argued has been purposely added , that the validity of what I have advanced might be put to the proof by those who are inclined , and furnished , with the necessary instruments to undertake an attentive and repeated inspection of the same phenomenon .
W. HERSCHEL .
Slough , Jan. 1 , 1791 .

