XX .
Experiments and Observations on the Dissolution of Metals in Acids , and their Precipitations ; with an Account of a new compound acid Menstruum , useful in some technical Operations of parting Metals .
By James Keir , Esq. F. R. S. Read May 20 , 1790 .
IN the following Paper , I intend to relate two sets of experiments ; one , showing the effects of compounding the vitriolic and nitrous acids in dissolving metals ; and the other , describing some curious appearances which occur in the precipitation of silver from its solution in nitrous acid by iron , and by some other substances .
In a subsequent Paper I hope to continue the subject of metallic dissolution * and precipitation , first , by adding some experiments on the quantities and kinds of gas produced by dissolving different metals in different acids , under various circumstances ; secondly , by submitting certain general propositions , * The English word solution has two significations in chemistry ; one , expressive of the act of dissolving , as when we say , that ` ` solution is a chemical operation ; ' ' and the other , denoting the substance dissolved in its solvent , as a solution of silver in nitrous acid .
' ' The French language is equally equivocal , as the word ` ` dissolution ' ' is used in both the above-mentioned senses .
In treating on this subject , in which both meanings were very frequently required , sometimes in the same sentence , I could not but be sensible of confusion in the style , and I have therefore confined the word solution to express the substance dissolved together with its solvent , and the word dissolution to denote the act of dissolving .
which seem deducible from the facts related ; and , lastly , by concluding with some reflexions relative to the theory of metallic dissolution and precipitation .
PART 1 .
On the effects of compounding the vitriolic and nitrous acids , under various circumstances , upon the dissolution of metals .
SECTIONFIRS T. On the mixture of oil of vitriol and nitre .
1 .
The properties of the several acids , in their separate states , have been investigated with considerable industry and success ; and those of one compound , aqua regis , are well known on account of its frequent use in dissolving gold : yet not only various other combinations of different acids remain to be examined ; but also the changes of properties to which these mixed acids are subject , from the difference of circumstances , especially those of concentration , temperature~ and of that quality which is called , properly or improperly , phlogistication , are subjects still open for enquiry .
2 .
As I shall have frequent occasion to speak of the phlogistication and dephlogistication of acids , I with to premise , that by these terms I mean only certain states or qualities of those bodies , but without any theoretical reference .
Thus vitriolic acid may be said to be phlogisticated by addition of sulphur or other inflammable matter , by which it is converted into sulphureous acid , without determining whether this change be caused by the addition of the supposed principle phlogiston , as one set of philosophers believe , or by the action of the added inflammable substance in drawing from the acid a portion of its aerial principle , by which the sulphur , its other element , is made to predominate , as others have lately maintained .
It were much to be wished , that we had words totally unconnected with theory ; that chemists , who differ from each other in some speculative points , may yet speak the same language , and may relate their facts and observations , without having our attention continually drawn aside from these to the different modes of explanation which have been imagined .
But at present we have only the choice of terms between words derived from the ancient theory , and those which have been lately proposed by the opposers of that theory .
In this dilemma I have preferred the use of the former , not that I wish to show any predilection to either theory , but because that system , having long been generally adopted , is understood by all parties ; and principally because , by using the words of the old theory , I am at liberty to define them , and to give significations expressive merely of facts , and of the actual state of bodies ; whereas the language and theory of the antiphlogistic chemists being interwoven and adapted to each other , the former cannot be divested of its theoretical reference , and therefore seems inapplicable to the mere exposition of facts , but ought to be reserved solely for the explanation of the doctrines from which this language is derived .
Thus by the definition which I have mentioned of phlogistication , this word expresses not the presence or existence of an hypothetical principle of inflammability ; but a certain well-known quality of acids and of other bodies , communicated to them by the addition of many actual inflammable substances .
Thus nitrous acid acquires a phloVOL .
LXXX .
Bbb gisticated gisticated quality by addition of a little spirit of wine , or by distillation with any inflammable substance .
3 .
No two substances are more frequently in the hands of chemists and artists than vitriolic acid and nitre , yet I have found , that a mere mixture of these , when much concentrated , possesses properties which neither the vitriolic acid nor the nitrous , of the same degree of concentration , have singly , and which could not easily be deduced , a priori , by reasoning from our present knowledge of the theory of chemistry .
4 .
Having found by some previous trials that a mixture composed of nitre dissolved in oil of vitriol was capable of dissolving silver easily and copiously , while it did not affect copper , iron , lead , regulus of cobalt , gold , and platina , I conceived , that it might be useful in some cases of the parting of silver from copper and the other metals above mentioned ; and having also observed , that the dissolving powers of the mixture of vitriolic and nitrous acids varied greatly in different degrees of concentration and phlogistication , I thought that an investigation of these effects might be a subject fit for philosophical chemistry , and might tend to illustrate the theory of the dissolution of metals in acids .
With these views I made the following experiments .
5 .
I put into a long necked retort , the contents of which , including the neck , were 1400 grain measures , 100 grain measures of oil of vitriol of the usual density at which it is prepared in England , that is , whose specific gravity is to that of water as 1,844 to 1 , and 100 grains of pure and clean nitre , which was then dissolved in the acid by the heat of a water-bath .
To this mixture 100 grains of standard silver were added ; the retort was set in a water bath , in which the water was made to boil , and a pneumatic apparatus was applied to catch any air or gas which might be extricated .
The silver began to dissolve , and the solution became of a purple or violet colour .
No air was thrown into the inverted jar , excepting a little of the common air of the retort , by means of the expansion which it suffered from the heat of the water-bath , and from some nitrous fumes which appeared in the retort , and which having afterwards condensed , occasioned the water to rise along the neck of the retort , and mix with the solution .
The remaining silver was then separated and weighed , and it was found that 39 grains had been dissolved ; but probably more would have been dissolved if the operation had not been interrupted by the water rushing into the retort .
6 .
In the same apparatus 200 grains of standard silver were added to a mixture of 100 grains of nitre previously dissolved in 200 grain-measures of oil of vitriol ; and in this solvent 92 grains of the silver were dissolved , without any production of air or gas .
The solution , which was of a violet colour , having been poured out of the retort while warm ( for with so large a proportion of nitre , such mixtures , especially after having dissolved silver , are apt to congeal with small degrees of cold ) , in order to separate the undissolved silver from it , and having been returned into the retort without this silver , I poured 200 grains of water into the retort , upon which a strong effervescence took place between the solution and the water , and 3100 grain-measures of nitrous gas were thrown into the inverted jar .
Upon pouring 200 grains more of water into the retort , 600 grain-measures of the same gas were expelled .
Further additions of water yielded no more gas ; neither did the silver , when afterwards added to this diluted solution , give any sensible effervescence , or suffer a greater loss of weight than two grains .
7 .
In the same apparatus 100 grains of standard silver were exposed to a mixture of 30 grains of nitre dissolved in 200 grain-measures of oil of vitriol ; and in this operation , 80 grains of silver were dissolved , while at the same time 4500 grain-measures of nitrous gas were thrown into the inverted jar .
When the undissolved silver was removed , 200 grains of water were added to the solution , which was of a violet colour , and upon the mixture of the two fluids an effervescence happened ; but only a few bubbles of nitrous gas were then expelled .
8 .
In the same apparatus 100 grains of standard silver were exposed to a mixture of 200 grain-measures of oil of vitriol , 200 grains of nitre , and 200 grains of water ; and in this operation 20 grains of the silver were dissolved without any sensible emission of air or gas .
9 .
In these experiments , the copper contained in the standard silver gave a reddish colour to the saline mass which was formed in the solution , and seemed to be a calx of copper interspersed through the salt of silver .
I perceived no other difference between the effects of pure and standard silver dissolved in this acid .
10 .
I then exposed tin to the same mixture of oil of vitriol and nitre , in the same apparatus , and in the same circumstances , taking care always to add more metal than could be dissolved , that , by weighing the remainder , the quantity capable of being dissolved might be found , as I had done with the experiments on silver : and the results were as follow .
11 .
No tin was dissolved nor calcined by the mixtures in the proportion of 200 grain-measures of oil of vitriol to 200 grains of nitre ; nor by another mixture in the proportion of 200 grain-measures of oil of vitriol to 150 grains of nitre , and consequently no gas was produced in either instance .
12 .
With a mixture in the proportion of 200 grain-measures of oil of vitriol and 100 grains of nitre , the tin began soon to be acted on , and to be diffused through the liquor ; but no extrication of gas appeared until the digestion had been continued two hours in boiling water ; and then it took place , and gave a frothy appearance to the mixture , which was of an opaque white colour , from the powder of tin diffused among it .
In this experiment the quantity of tin thus calcined was 73 grains , and the quantity of nitrous gas extricated during this action on the tin was 8500 grain-measures .
Then , upon pouring 200 grains of water into the retort , a fresh effervescence took place between the water and the white opaque mass , and 4600 grain-measures of nitrous gas were thrown into the inverted receiver .
13 .
With a mixture in the proportion of 100 grain-measures of oil of vitriol to 30 grains of nitre , 30 grains of tin were dissolved or calcined , and the nitrous gas , which began to be extricated much sooner than in the last mentioned experiment with a larger proportion of nitre , amounted to 6300 grainmeasures .
Water , added to this solution of tin , did not produce any effervescence .
14 .
With a mixture in the proportion of 200 grain-measures of oil of vitriol , 200 grains of nitre , and 200 grains of water , 133 grains of tin were acted on with an effervescence , which took place violently , and produced 6500 grain-measures of nitrous gas .
15 .
The several mixtures above mentioned , in different proportions of nitre and oil of vitriol , did , by the help of the heat of the water-bath , calcine mercury into a white or greyish powder .
Nickel was also partly calcined and partly dissolved by these mixtures .
I did not perceive that any other metal was affected by them , excepting that the surfaces of some of them were tarnished .
16 .
These mixtures of oil of vitriol and nitre were apt to congeal by cold , those especially which had a large proportion of nitre .
Thus , a mixture of 1000 grain-measures of oil of vitriol and 480 grains of nitre , after having kept fluid several days , in a phial not so accurately stopped as to prevent altogether the escape of some white fumes , congealed at the temperature of 55~ of FAHRENHEIT'S thermometer ; whereas some of the same liquid , having been mixed with equal parts of oil of vitriol , did not congeal with a less cold than 45~ .
The congelation is promoted by exposure to air , by which white fumes rise , and moisture may be absorbed , or by any other mode of slight dilution with water .
17 .
Dilution of this compound acid , with more or less water , alters considerably its properties , with regard to its action on metals .
Thus it has been observed , that in its concentrated state it does not act on iron ; but , by adding water , it acquires a power of acting on that metal , and with different effect , according to the proportion of the water added .
Thus , by adding to two measures of the compound acid one measure of water , the liquor is rendered capable of calcining iron , and forming with it a white powder , but without effervescence .
With an equal measure of water effervescence was produced .
With a larger proportion of water the iron gave also a brown colour to the liquor , such as phlogisticated nitrous acid acquires from iron , or communicates to a solution of martial vitriol in water .
18 .
Dilution with water renders this compound acid capable of dissolving copper and zinc , and probably those other metals which are subject to the action of the dilute vitriolic or nitrous acids .
SECTIONSECON D. An account of a new process for separating silver from copper .
19 .
The properties of this liquor , in dissolving silver easily without acting on copper , have rendered it capable of a very useful application in the arts .
Among the manufactures at Birmingham , that of making vessels of silver plated on copper is a very considerable one .
In cutting out the rolled plated metal into pieces of the required forms and sizes , there are many shreds , or scraps as they are called , unfit for any purpose but the recovery of the metals by separating them from each other .
The easiest and most aeconomical method of parting these two metals , so as not to lose either of them , is an object of some consequence to the manufacturers .
For this purpose two modes were practised ; one , by melting the whole of the mixed metals with lead , and separating them by eliquation and testing ; and the second , by dissolving both metals in oil of vitriol , with the help of heat , and by separating the vitriol of copper , by dissolving it in water , from the vitriol of silver , which is afterwards to be reduced and purified .
In the first of these methods , there is a considerable waste of lead and copper ; and in the second , the quantity of vitriolic acid employed is very great , as much more is dissipated in the form of volatile vitriolic , or sulphureous acid , than remains in the composition of the two vitriols .
Some years ago , I communicated to an artist the method of effecting the separation of silver and copper by means of the above-mentioned compound of vitriolic acid and nitre ; and , as I am informed , that it is now commonly practised by the manufacturers in Birmingham , I have no doubt but it is much more aeconomical , and it is certainly much more easily executed than any of the other methods : for nothing more is required than to put the pieces of plated metal into an earthen glazed pan ; to pour upon them some of the acid liquor , which may be in the proportion of eight or ten pounds of oil of vitriol to one pound of nitre ; to stir them about , that the surfaces may be frequently exposed to fresh liquor , and to assist the action by a gentle heat from 100o to 200o of FAHRENHEIT'S scale .
When the liquor is nearly saturated , the silver is to be precipitated from it by common salt , which forms a luna cornea , easily reducible by melting it in a crucible with a sufficient quantity of pot-ash ; and , lastly , by refining the melted silver , if necessary , with a little nitre thrown upon it .
In this manner the silver will be obtained sufficiently pure , and the copper will remain unchanged .
Otherwise , the silver may be precipitated in its metallic state , by adding to the solution of silver a few of the pieces of copper , and a sufficient quantity of water to enable the liquor to act upon the copper .
The property which this acid mixture possesses of dissolving silver with great facility , and in considerable quantity , will probably render it an useful menstruum in the separation of silver from other metals ; and as the alchemists have distinguished the peculiar solvent of gold under the title of aqua regis , a name sufficiently distinctive , though founded on a fanciful allusion ; so , if they had been acquainted with the properties of this compound , they would probably have bestowed on it the appellation of aqua reginae .
SECTIONTHIR D. The change of properties communicated to the mixture of vitriolic and nitrous acids by phlogistication .
20 .
The above-described compound acid may be phlogisticated in different methods , of which I shall mention three .
1st , By digesting the compound acid with sulphur by means of the heat of a water-bath , the liquor dissolves the sulphur with effervescence , loses its property of yielding white fumes ; and if the quantity of sulphur be sufficient , and if the heat applied be long enough continued , it exhibits red nitrous vapours , and assumes a violet colour .
2dly , If , instead of dissolving nitre in concentrated vitriolic acid , this acid be impregnated with nitrous gas , or with nitrous vapour , by making this gas or vapour pass into the acid , this compound will be phlogisticated , as it contains not the entire nitrous acid , but only its phlogisticated part , or element , the nitrous gas , without the proportion of pure air necessary to constitute an acid .
This impregnation of oil of vitriol with nitrous gas or nitrous vapour was first described , and some of the properties of the impregnated liquor noticed , by Dr. PRIESTLEY .
See Experiments and Observations on Air , Vol. III .
p. 129 and 217 .
3dly , By substituting nitrous ammoniac instead of nitre in the mixture with oil of vitriol .
21 .
The compound prepared by any of these methods , but especially by the first and second , differs considerably in its properties with regard to its action on metals from the acid described in the first section .
It has been observed , that the latter compound has little action on any metals but silver , tin , mercury , and nickel .
On the other hand , the phlogisticated compound not only acts on these , but also on several others .
It forms with iron a beautiful rose-coloured solution , without application of any artificial heat ; and in time a rose-coloured saline precipitate is deposited , which is soluble in water with considerable effervescence .
It dissolves copper , and acquires from this metal , and also from regulus of cobalt , zinc , and lead , pretty deep violet tinges .
Bismuth and regulus of antimony were also attacked by this phlogisticated acid .
To ascertain more exactly the effects of this phlogisticated acid on some metals , I made the following experiments , with a liquor prepared by making nitrous gas pass through oil of vitriol during a considerable time .
22 .
To 200 grain-measures of the oil of vitriol impregnated with nitrous gas , put into a retort with a long neck , the capacity of which , including the neck , was 1150 grain-measures , I added 144 grains of standard silver , and immersed the mouth of the retort in water , under an inverted jar filled with water , to catch the gas which might be extricated .
The acid began to dissolve the silver with effervescence by application of heat ; the solution became of a violet colour , and the quantity of nitrous gas received in the inverted jar was 14700 grain-measures .
Upon weighing the silver remaining , the quantity which had been dissolved was found to be 70 grains .
When water was added to the solution , an effervescence appeared , but only a very small quantity of gas was extricated .
By means of the water , a white saline powder of silver , soluble in a larger quantity of water , was precipitated from the solution .
The solution of silver , when saturated and undiluted , congeals readily in cool temperatures , and , when diluted to a certain degree with water , gives foliated crystals .
23 .
In the same apparatus , and in the same manner , 100 grain-measures of this impregnated oil of vitriol were applied to iron .
An effervescence appeared without application of heat , the surface of the iron acquired a beautiful rose colour or redness mixed with purple : and this colour gradually pervaded the whole liquor , but disappeared on keeping the retort some time in hot water .
Notwithstanding a considerable apparent effervescence , the quantity of air expelled into the inverted jar was only 400 grain-measures , of which 1/ 4 was nitrous , and the rest phlogisticated .
The solution was then poured out of the retort , and the iron was found to have lost only two grains in weight .
The solution was returned into the retort , without the iron , and 200 grains of water were added to it ; upon which a white powder was immediately precipitated , which re-dissolved with great effervescence .
When 2000 grain-measures of nitrous gas had been expelled into the inverted jar , without application of heat , the retort was placed in the waterbath , the heat of which rendered the effervescence so strong , that the liquor boiled over the neck of the retort , so that the quantity of gas extricated could not be ascertained .
24 .
In the same manner 11 grains of copper were dissolved in 100 grain-measures of impregnated oil of vitriol .
The solution was of a deep violet colour , and at last was turbid .
The quantity of nitrous gas expelled into the inverted jar during the operation was 4700 grain-measures .
When the copper was removed , and 200 grains of water were added to the solution , an effervescence took place , 1700 grain-measures of nitrous gas were expelled , and the solution then acquired a blue colour .
25 .
In the same apparatus and manner , 100 grain-measures of the impregnated oil of vitriol were applied to tin , which was thereby diminished in weight 16 grains , while the liquor acquired a violet colour , became turbid by the suspension of the calx of tin , and a quantity of nitrous gas was thrown into the inverted receiver equal to 4100 grain-measures , without application of heat , and another quantity equal to 4900 grainmeasures , after the retort was put into the water-bath .
26 .
Mercury added to the impregnated oil of vitriol formed a thick white turbid liquor , which was rendered clear by addition of unimpregnated oil of vitriol .
In a little time this mixture continuing to act on the remaining mercury acquired a purple colour .
The mercury acted upon sunk to the bottom of the glass in the form of a white powder , and the purple liquor , when mixed with a solution of common salt in water , gave no appearance of its containing any mercury in a dissolved state .
27 .
The nitrous gas with which the oil of vitriol is impregnated shows no disposition to quit the acid by exposure to air ; but , on adding water to the impregnated acid , the gas is expelled suddenly with great effervescence , and with red fumes , in consequence of its mixture with the atmospherical air .
Upon adding 240 grains of water to 60 grain-measures of impregnated oil of vitriol , 2300 grains of nitrous gas were thrown into the receiver ; but as the action of the two liquors is instantaneous , the quantity of gas expelled from the retort before its neck could be immersed in water , and placed under the receiver , must have been considerable .
The whole of the gas , however , was not extricated by means of the water , for the remaining liquor dissolved 5 grains of copper , while 800 measures of nitrous gas were thrown into the retort .
28 .
The following facts principally are established by the preceding experiments .
1 .
That a mixture of the vitriolic and nitrous acids in a concentrated state has a peculiar faculty of dissolving silver copiously .
2 .
That it acts upon , and principally calcines , tin , mercury , and nickel ; the latter of which , however , it dissolves in small quantity , and that it has little or no action on other metals .
3 .
That the quantity of gas produced while the metal is dissolving is greater , relatively to the quantity of metal dissolved , when the proportion of nitre to the vitriolic acid is small than when it is large ; and that when the metals are dissolved by mixtures containing much nitre , and with a small production of gas , the solution itself , or the metallic salt formed in it , yields abundance of gas when mixed with water .
4 .
That dilution with water renders the concentrated mixture less capable of dissolving silver , but more capable of acting on other metals .
5 .
That this mixture of highly concentrated vitriolic and nitrous acids acquires a purple or violet colour when phlogisticated , either by addition of inflammable substances as sulphur , or by its action on metals , or by very strong impregnation of oil of vitriol with nitrous gas * .
* Dr. PRIESTLEY has noticed this colour communicated to oil of vitriol by impregnation with nitrous gas or vapour , and also the effervescence produced by adding water to this impregnated liquor .
See Experiments and Observations , Vol. III .
p. 129 and 217 .
6 .
That this phlogistication was found to communicate to the mixture the power of dissolving , though in small quantities , copper , iron , zinc , and regulus of cobalt .
7 .
That water expels from a highly phlogisticated mixture of concentrated vitriolic and nitrous acids , or of oil of vitriol impregnated with nitrous gas , a great part of its contained gas ; and that therefore this gas is not capable of being retained in such quantity by dilute as by concentrated acids .
Water unites with the mixture of oil of vitriol and nitre , without any considerable effervescence .
29 .
To these observations I shall subjoin one other fact , namely , that , when to the mixture of oil of vitriol with nitre a saturated solution of common salt in water is added , a powerful aqua regis is produced , capable of dissolving gold and platina ; and this aqua regis , though composed of liquors perfectly colourless and free from all metallic matter , acquires at once a bright and deep yellow colour .
The addition of dry common salt to the concentrated mixtures of vitriolic and nitrous acids produces an effervescence , but not the yellow colour ; for the production of which therefore a certain proportion of water seems to be necessary .
PART II .
On the precipitation of silver from nitrous acid by iron .
SECTION 1 .
1 .
BERGMAN relates , that upon adding iron to a solution of silver in the nitrous acid no precipitation ensued * ; although * Dissert .
de Phlog .
quantitate in Metallis .
the affinity of iron to acids in general is known to be much stronger than that of silver ; and although , even with regard to the nitrous acid , other experiments evince the superior affinity of iron : for as iron precipitates copper from this acid , and as copper precipitates silver , we must infer the greater affinity of iron than of silver .
In the course of his experiments , however , some instances of precipitation occurred , which he attributed to the peculiar quality of the irons which he then employed * .
I was desirous of discovering the circumstances , * BERGMAN tried many different kinds of iron , and he thought he found two which were capable of precipitating silver .
But as he did not discover the circumstances according to which this precipitation sometimes does , and at other times does not happen , he may have been mistaken with regard to the peculiar quality of these two kinds of iron .
At least the several kinds which I have tried always precipitated silver in certain circumstances , and always failed to precipitate in certain other circumstances .
I do not know any other author who has mentioned this subject , excepting Mr. KIRWAN ; who , in the conclusion of his valuable Papers on the Attractive Powers of Mineral Acids , says , ` ` I have always found silver to be easily precipitated from its solution in the nitrous acid by iron .
The sum of the quiescent affinities being 625 , and that of the divellent 746 .
Yet Mr. BERGMAN observed , that a very saturated solution of silver was very difficultly precipitated , and only by some sorts of iron , even though the solution was diluted , and an excess of acid added to it .
The reason of this curious phenomenon appears to me deducible from a circumstance first observed by SCHEELE , in dissolving mercury , namely , that the nitrous acid when saturated with it will take up more of it in its metallic form .
The same thing happens in dissolving silver in the nitrous acid in a strong heat ; for , as I before remarked , the last portions of silver thrown in afford no air , and consequently are not dephlogisticated .
Now this compound of calx of silver , and silver in its metallic form , may well be unprecipitable by iron , the silver in its metallic form preventing the calx from coming into contact with the iron , and extracting phlogiston from it .
' ' In this Paper I shall not enter into the explanation of these appearances ; but I thought it necessary to premise what so eminent a chemist as Mr. KIRWAN has suggested on the subject , that the reader may see at once the present state of the question .
I shall only remark , that the above explanation , stances , and of investigating the cause , if I should be able , of this irregularity and exception to the generally received laws of affinity .
2 .
I digested a piece of fine silver in pure and pale nitrous acid , and while the dissolution was going on , and before the saturation was completed , I poured a portion of the solution upon pieces of clean and newly-scraped iron wire into a wine glass , and observed a sudden and copious precipitation of silver .
The precipitate was at first black , then it assumed the appearance of silver , and was five or six times larger in diameter than the piece of iron wire which it enveloped .
The action of the acid on the iron continued some little time , and then it ceased ; the silver re-dissolved , the liquor became clear , and the iron remained bright and undisturbed in the solution at the bottom of the wine glass , where it continued during several weeks , without suffering any change , or effecting any precipitation of the silver .
3 .
When the solution of silver was completely saturated , it was no longer affected by iron , according to BERGMAN'S observation .
4 .
Having found that the solution acted on the iron , and was thereby precipitated , before it had been saturated , and not afterwards , I was desirous of knowing , whether the saturation was the circumstance which prevented the action and precipitation .
For this purpose , I added to a portion of the saturated solution some of the same nitrous acid , of which a part had been employed to dissolve the silver ; and into this mixture , tion , not being founded on any peculiarity in the nature of iron , seems to suppose , that the silver is also incapable of being precipitated , from such solutions as iron cannot act upon , by any other metal .
But this is not the case : copper and zinc readily precipitate silver from these solutions .
abounding with a superfluous acid , I threw a piece of iron , but no precipitation occurred .
It was thence evident , that the saturation of the acid was not the only circumstance which prevented the precipitation .
5 .
To another portion of the saturated solution of silver I added some red smoking nitrous acid ; and I found , upon trial , that iron precipitated the silver from this mixture , and that the same appearances were exhibited as had been observed with the solution previously to its saturation .
6 .
The same effects were produced when vitriolic acid was added to the saturated solution of silver , and iron afterwards applied .
7 .
To some of the same nitrous acid , of which a part had been employed to dissolve the silver , I added a piece of iron ; and , while the iron was dissolving , I poured into the liquor some of the saturated solution of silver ; upon which a precipitation of silver took place instantly ; although , when the same acid had been previously mixed with the solution of silver , and the iron was then added to the mixture , no precipitation had ensued .
8 .
The quantity of vitriolic acid , or of the red suming nitrous acid , necessary to communicate to the saturated solution of silver the property of being acted on by iron , varies according to the concentration , and to the degree of phlogistication of the acids added ; so that a less quantity than is sufficient does not produce any apparent effect .
Nevertheless , when the solution of silver is by addition of these acids brought nearly to a precipitable state , the addition of spirit of wine will , in a little time , render it capable of acting on iron .
9 .
It appears then , that a solution of silver is not precipitated by iron in cold , unless it have a superabundance of phlogisticated acid* .
10 .
Heat affects the action of a solution of silver on iron : for if iron be digested with heat , in a perfectly saturated solution of silver , such as a solution of crystals of nitre of silver in water , the silver will be deposited in its bright metallic state on different parts of the iron , and the iron which has been acted on by the solution appears in form of a yellow ochre .
11 .
BERGMAN relates , that he has sometimes observed beautiful crystallizations or vegetations of metallic silver formed on pieces of iron immersed long in a solution of silver .
I have found that no time is able to effect this deposition , unless the solution be in a state nearly sufficiently phlogisticated to admit of a precipitation by iron , but not completely phlogisticated enough to effect that purpose immediately .
12 .
Dilution with a great deal of water seemed to dispose the solutions of silver to be precipitated by iron more easily .
* It was said , at ~ 4 .
that the addition of dephlogisticated nitrous acid to a saturated solution of silver did not render this solution precipitable by iron .
Nevertheless , as this acid dissolves iron , such a quantity may be added , as to overcome the counteracting quality of the solution of silver , so that the acid shall be able to act on the iron ; and while this metal is dissolving , it phlogisticates the mixture , which then becomes capable of being precipitated , and is in fact reduced to the same circumstances as are described at ~ 7 .
The limits of the quantities which produce changes cannot be ascertained , because they depend on the degrees of concentration and phlogistication of the substances employed ; and therefore , whenever a change is said to be produced by a certain substance , it means that it may be produced by some proportion , but does not imply by every proportion , of that substance .
Without attending to these considerations , persons trying to repeat the experiments mentioned in this Paper will be liable to be deceived .
A solution of silver , which did not act on iron , upon being very much diluted , and having a piece of iron immersed in it , during several hours , gave a precipitate of silver in the form of a black powder .
SECTION II .
On the alterations which iron or its surface undergoes by the action of a solution of silver in nitrous acid , or of a pure concentrated nitrous acid .
13 .
It has been said , that when iron is exposed to the action of a phlogisticated solution of silver , it instantly precipitates the silver , is itself acted upon or dissolved by the acid solution during a certain time , longer or shorter , according to the degree of phlogistication , quantity of superabundant acid , and other circumstances , and that at length the solution of the iron ceases ; the silver precipitate is re-dissoved , if there is superfluous acid ; the liquor becomes clear again , but only rendered a little browner by its having dissolved some iron ; while the piece of iron remains bright and undisturbed at the bottom of the liquor , where it is no longer able to affect the solution of silver .
14 .
I poured a part of the phlogisticated solution of silver which had passed through these changes , and which had ceased to act upon the piece of iron , into another glass , and dropped another piece of fresh iron wire into the liquor ; upon which I observed a precipitation of silver , a solution of part of the iron , a redissolution of the precipitated silver , and a cessation of all these phenomenon , with the iron remaining bright and quiet at the bottom of the liquor , as before .
It appeared then , that the liquor had not lost its power of acting on fresh iron , although it ceased to act on that piece which had been exposed to it .
15 .
To one of the pieces of iron which had been employed in the precipitation of a solution of silver , and from which the solution , no longer capable of acting upon it , had been poured off , I added some phlogisticated solution of silver which had never been exposed to the action of iron , but no precipitation happened .
It appeared then , that the iron itself , by having been once employed to precipitate a solution of silver , was rendered incapable of any further action on any solution of silver .
And it is to be observed , that this alteration was produced without the least diminution of its metallic splendour , or change of colour .
The alteration , however , was only superficial , as may be supposed ; for by scraping off its altered coat , it was again rendered capable of acting on a solution of silver .
To avoid circumlocution , I shall call iron thus affected , altered iron ; and iron which is clean , and has not been altered , fresh iron .
16 .
To a phlogisticated solution of silver , in which a piece of bright altered iron lay , without action , I added a piece of fresh iron , which was instantly enveloped with a mass of precipitated silver , and acted on as usual ; but what is very remarkable , in about a quarter of a minute , or less , the altered iron suddenly was covered with another coat of precipitated silver , and was now acted on by the acid solution like the fresh piece .
In a little time the silver precipitate was re-dissolved , as usual , and the two pieces of iron were reduced to an altered state .
When a fresh piece of iron was then held in the liquor , so as not to touch the two pieces of altered iron , they were nevertheless soon acted upon by the acid solution , and suddenly covered with silver precipitate as before ; and these phenomenon may be repeated with the same solution of silver , until the superfluous acid of the solution becomes saturated by the iron , and then the re-dissolution of the precipitated silver must cease .
17 .
I poured some dephlogisticated nitrous acid on a piece of altered iron , without any action ensuing , although this acid readily acted on fresh iron , and when to the dephlogisticated nitrous acid , with a piece of altered iron lying immersed in it , I added a piece of fresh iron , this immediately began to dissolve , and soon afterwards the altered iron was acted on also by the acid .
18 .
I poured upon a piece of altered iron a solution of copper in nitrous acid ; but the copper was not precipitated by the iron ; neither did this iron precipitate copper from a solution of blue vitriol .
19 .
Altered iron was acted on by a dilute phlogisticated nitrous acid ; but not by a red concentrated acid , which is known to be highly phlogisticated .
20 .
I put some pieces of clean fresh iron wire into a concentrated and red fuming nitrous acid .
No apparent action ensued ; but the iron was found to be altered in the same manner as it is by a solution of silver ; that is , it was rendered incapable of being attacked either by a phlogisticated solution of silver , or by dephlogisticated nitrous acid .
21 .
Iron was also altered by being immersed some little time in a saturated solution of silver , which did not show any visible action on it .
22 .
The alteration thus produced on the iron is very superficial .
The least rubbing exposes some of the fresh iron beneath neath the surface , and thus subjects it to the action of the acid .
It is therefore with difficulty that these pieces of altered iron can be dried , without losing their peculiar property .
For this reason , I generally transferred them out of the solution of silver or concentrated nitrous acid into any other liquor , the effects of which I wanted to examine .
Or they may be transferred first into a glass of water , and thence into the liquor to be examined .
But it is to be observed , that if they are allowed to remain long in the water , they lose their peculiar property or alteration .
They may be preserved in their altered state by being kept in spirit of sal ammoniac .
23 .
To a saturated solution of copper in nitrous acid ( which was capable of being readily precipitated by fresh iron ) I added some saturated solution of silver .
From this mixture a piece of fresh iron neither precipitated silver nor copper : nor did the addition of some dephlogisticated nitrous acid effect this precipitation .
24 .
A solution of copper , formed by precipitating silver from nitrous acid by means of copper , was very reluctantly and slowly precipitated by a piece of fresh iron ; and the iron thus acted on by the acid was changed to an ochre .
25 .
A saturated solution of silver having been partly precipitated by copper , acquired the property of acting upon fresh iron , and of being thereby precipitated .
26 .
Fresh iron immersed some time in solutions of nitre of lead , or of nitre of mercury in water , did not occasion any precipitation of the dissolved metals ; but acquired an altered quality .
These metals then in this respect resemble silver .
27 .
It is well known , that a solution of martial vitriol , added to a solution of gold in aqua regis , precipitates the gold in its metallic state .
I do not recollect , that the precipitation of a solution of silver by the same martial vitriol has been observed .
However , upon pouring a solution of martial vitriol into a solution of silver in the nitrous acid , a precipitate will be thrown down , which acquires in a few minutes more and more of a metallic appearance , and is indeed perfect silver .
When the two solutions are pretty concentrated , a bright argentine film swims on the surface of the mixture , or silvers the sides of the glass in which the experiment is made .
When a phlogisticated solution of silver is used , the mixture is blackened , as happens generally to a solution of martial vitriol , when a phlogisticated nitrous acid is added to it .
I added about equal parts of water to a mixture of a phlogisticated solution of silver and a solution of martial vitriol , in which all the silver had been precipitated , and digested the diluted mixture with heat , by which means most of the precipitated silver was re-dissolved .
BERGMAN has observed a similar re-dissolution of gold precipitated by martial vitriol upon boiling the mixture ; but he attributes the re-dissolution to the concentration of the aqua regis by the evaporation .
As this explanation did not accord with my notions , I diluted the mixture with water , and found that the same re-dissolution occurred both with the solution of silver and with that of gold .
But with neither of the metals did I find that the re-dissolution ever took place , unless there had been a superabundant acid in the solutions of gold and silver employed .
28 .
Mercury is also precipitated in its metallic state from its solution in nitrous acid by a solution of martial vitriol .
When the liquor is poured off from the precipitate , this may be changed into running mercury by being dried near the fire .
29 .
I found also , that silver may be precipitated in its metallic state , from its solution in vitriolic acid , by addition of a solution of martial vitriol .
A vitriol of mercury may also be decompounded by a solution of martial vitriol , and the mercurial precipitate , which is a black powder , forms globules , when dried and warmed .
30 .
Luna cornea is not decompounded by martial vitriol ; consequently there is no operation of a double affinity .
Nevertheless , this luna cornea may be decompounded by the elements of martial vitriol , while they are in the act of dissolution ; that is , the silver may be precipitated in its metallic state , by digesting luna cornea with a dilute vitriolic acid , to which some pieces of iron are added .
And it is to be observed , that this reduction of the silver and precipitation take place , while the acid is yet unsaturated .
Marine acid and iron applied to luna cornea effect the same reduction of the silver to a metallic state , even when there is more acid than is sufficient for both metals .
The explanation of these phenomenon will be attempted in the subsequent Papers which I propose to present on this subject to the Society .

