X. On the Height of the luminous Arch which was seen on Feb. 23 , 1784 .
By Henry Cavendish , Esq. F. R. S. and A.S. Read February 25 , 1790 .
THIS arch was observed , at the same time , at Cambridge by Mr. WOLLASTON ; at Kimbolton in Huntingdonshire , by the Rev. Mr. HUTCHINSON ; and at Blockley near Campden in Gloucestershire , by Mr. FRANKLIN ; and is described in letters from those gentlemen read to the Royal Society in December 1786 * .
It has been remarked , that as the arches of the kind described in these Papers have usually but a very slow motion , their height above the surface of the earth may readily be determined , provided they are observed about the same time , at places sufficiently distant ; and they seem to be the only meteors of the aurora kind whose height we have any means of ascertaining .
The three places at which this phenomenon was seen are not so well suited for this purpose as might at first be expected from their distance , because they lie too much in the direction of the arch ; they however seem sufficient to determine its height within certain limits , and perhaps are as well adapted for it as any observations we are likely to have of such phenomenon .
The latitude of Cambridge is 52~ 12 ' 36 ' ' : that of Kimbolton is said by Mr. HUTCHINSON to be 52~ 20 ' , and , * See p.~-46 .
of this Volume .
according to the survey of Huntingdonshire , published by JEFFERIES , is 52~ 19 ' 50 ' ' ; so that we may suppose it to be seven geographical miles north of Cambridge , and by the maps it seems to be about 18 such miles west of it : and Blockley is by the map 12 geographical miles south and 72 west of Cambridge .
At Cambridge the observations of its track seem to have been made at about 9 h. 15 ' P.M. or 8 h. sidereal time .
At Kimbolton , allowing for the difference of meridians , they could hardly have been made more than 5 ' sooner ; and at Blockley they were most likely made nearly at the same time as at Cambridge .
At Blockley the arch passed about 7~ south of the zenith ; but it is unnecessary to determine this point with precision .
At Kimbolton it was found by a quadrant to pass 11~ to the south of it ; and at Cambridge it was observed to pass through ~ and ~ Tauri , ~ Aurigae , ~ Ursae majoris , Cor Caroli , and Arcturus .
Now , if an arch was drawn through these stars , it must , I think , have appeared sensibly waved to the eye ; whereas Mr. WOLLASTON did not take notice of any crookedness in this part of its course .
It is most likely , therefore , that the middle of the arch must have passed to the south of ~ Aurigae , and to the north of ~ Ursae ; and if a circle is drawn through ~ Tauri , Arcturus , and a point one degree north of the zenith , it will differ but little from a great circle , will agree as well with the positions of these stars as any regular line which can be drawn , and will pass 21/ 2 degrees below ~ Aurigae , and as much above ~ Ursae ; which is not a greater difference from observation than may well have taken place , considering how much care and acquaintance with the fixed stars are required to determine a path by them so nearly .
The direction of the arch here described in that part near the zenith is W. 18~ S. ; and if a line is drawn through Cambridge in this direction , Kimbolton is 12,8 geographical miles north of it ; and therefore , as the arch appeared 12~ more south at Kimbolton than at Cambridge , the height of the arch above the surface of the earth must be 611/ 2 geographical or 71 statute miles .
If we suppose that the middle of the arch really passed through ~ Aurigae , the height comes out 52 statute miles .
On the whole , I should think , the height could hardly be less than 52 miles , and is not likely to have much exceeded 71 .
The common aurora borealis has been supposed , with great reason , to consist of parallel streams of light shooting upwards , which , by the laws of perspective , appear to converge towards a point ; and when any of these streams are over our heads , they appear actually to come to a point , and form a corona .
Hence , from analogy , it seems not unlikely , that these luminous arches may consist of parallel streams of light , disposed so as to form a long thin band , pretty broad in its upright direction , and stretched out horizontally to a great length one way , but thin in the opposite direction .
If this is the case , they will appear narrow and well defined to an observer placed in the plane of the band ; but to one placed at a little distance from it they will appear broader , fainter , and less well defined ; and when the observer is removed to a great distance from the plane , they will vanish , or appear only as an obscure ill-defined light in the sky .
There are two circumstances which rather confirm this conjecture : first , that though we have an account of another arch besides this * having been seen at great distances in the * That of Feb. 15 , 1750 .
Phil. Trans. XLVI .
p. 472 .
and 647 .
direction of the arch , we have none of any having been seen in places much distant from each other in the contrary direction ; and , secondly , that most of them have passed near the zenith , whereas otherwise they ought frequently to appear in other situations ; for if they appeared near the zenith to an observer in one latitude , they should appear in a very different situation in a latitude much different from that .
I wish it to be understood , however , that I do not offer this as a theory of which I am convinced ; but only as an hypothesis which has some probability in it , in hopes that by encouraging people to attend to these arches , it may in time appear whether it is true or not .
If it should hereafter be found , that these arches are never seen at places much distant from each other in a direction perpendicular to the arch , it would amount almost to a proof of the truth of the hypothesis ; but if they ever are seen at the same time at such places , it would show that the hypothesis is not true .
Supposing the hypothesis to be well founded , the height above determined will answer to the middle part of the band , provided the breadth of it was small in respect of its distance from the earth , but otherwise will be considerably below the middle .
If the breadth of the band was equal to the distance of its lower edge from the earth , the height of the lower edge would be three-fourths of that above found ; and if the breadth was many times greater , would be half of it .
In the common aurora borealis , an arch is frequently seen low down in the northern part of the sky , forming part of a small circle .
What this is owing to , I cannot pretend to say ; but it is likely that it proceeds from streams of light which appear more condensed when seen in that direction than in any other , and consequently that the streams which form the arch to an observer in one place are different from those which form it to one at a distant place , and consequently that no conclusion as to its height can be drawn from observations of it in different places .
Attempts , however , have been made to determine the height of the aurora from such observations , and even from those of the Corona* ; though the latter method must surely be perfectly fallacious , and most likely the former is so too .
* BERGMAN .
Opusc .
Vol. V.

