XXIII .
Experiments on Air .
By Henry Cavendish , Esq. F.R.S. and A.S. Read June 2 , 1785 .
IN a Paper , printed in the last volume of the Philosophical Transactions , in which I gave my reasons for thinking that the diminution produced in atmospheric air by phlogistication is not owing to the generation of fixed air , I said it seemed most likely , that the phlogistication of air by the electric spark was owing to the burning of some inflammable matter in the apparatus ; and that the fixed air , supposed to be produced in that process , was only separated from that inflammable matter by the burning .
At that time , having made no experiments on the subject myself , I was obliged to form my opinion from those already published ; but I now find , that though I was right in supposing the phlogistication of the air does not proceed from phlogiston communicated to it by the electric spark , and that no part of the air is converted into fixed air ; yet that the real cause of the diminution is very different from what I suspected , and depends upon the conversion of phlogisticated air into nitrous acid .
The apparatus used in making the experiments was as follows .
The air through which the spark was intended to be passed , was confined in a glass tube M , bent to an angle , as in fig. 1 .
( tab .
XV .
) which , after being filled with quicksilver , was inverted into two glasses of the same fluid , as in the figure .
The air to be tried was then introduced by means of a small tube , such as is used for thermometers , bent in the manner represented by ABC ( fig. 2 .
) the bent end of which , after being previously filled with quicksilver , was introduced , as in the figure , under the glass DEF , inverted into water , and filled with the proper kind of air , the end C of the tube being kept stopped by the finger ; then , on removing the finger from C , the quicksilver in the tube descended in the leg BC , and its place was supplied with air from the glass DEF .
Having thus got the proper quantity of air into the tube ABC , it was held with the end C uppermost , and stopped with the finger ; and the end A , made smaller for that purpose , being introduced into one end of the bent tube M , ( fig. 1 .
) the air , on removing the finger from C , was forced into that tube by the pressure of the quicksilver in the leg BC .
By these means I was enabled to introduce the exact quantity I pleased of any kind of air into the tube M ; and , by the same means , I could let up any quantity of soaplees , or any other liquor which I wanted to be in contact with the air .
In one case , however , in which I wanted to introduce air into the tube many times in the same experiment , I used the apparatus represented in fig. 3 .
consisting of a tube AB of a small bore , a ball C , and a tube DE of a larger bore .
This apparatus was first filled with quicksilver ; and then the ball C , and the tube AB , were filled with air , by introducing the end A under a glass inverted into water , which contained the proper kind of air , and drawing out the quicksilver from the leg ED by a syphon .
After being thus furnished with air , the apparatus was weighed , and the end A introduced into one end of the tube M , and kept there during the experiment ; the way of forcing air out of this apparatus into the tube being by thrusting down the tube ED a wooden cylinder of such a size as almost to fill up the whole bore , and by occasionally pouring quicksilver into the same tube , to supply the place of that pushed into the ball C. After the experiment was finished , the apparatus was weighed again , which showed exactly how much air had been forced into the tube M during the whole experiment ; it being equal in bulk to a quantity of quicksilver , whose weight was equal to the increase of weight of the apparatus .
The bore of the tube M used in most of the following experiments , was about one-tenth of an inch ; and the length of the column of air , occupying the upper part of the tube , was in general from 11/ 2 to 3/ 4 of an inch .
It is scarcely necessary to inform any one used to electrical experiments , that in order to force an electrical spark through the tube , it was necessary , not to make a communication between the tube and the conductor , but to place an insulated ball at such a distance from the conductor as to receive a spark from it , and to make a communication between that ball and the quicksilver in one of the glasses , while the quicksilver in the other glass communicated with the ground .
I now proceed to the experiments .
When the electric spark was made to pass through common air , included between short columns of a solution of litmus , the solution acquired a red colour , and the air was diminished , conformably to what was observed by Dr. PRIESTLEY .
When lime-water was used instead of the solution of litmus , and the spark was continued till the air could be no further diminished , not the least cloud could be perceived in the limewater ; but the air was reduced to two-thirds of its original bulk ; which is a greater diminution than it could have suffered by mere phlogistication , as that is very little more than onefifth of the whole .
The The experiment was next repeated with some impure dephlogisticated air .
The air was very much diminished , but without the least cloud being produced in the lime-water .
Neither was any cloud produced when fixed air was let up to it ; but on the further addition of a little caustic volatile alkali , a brown sediment was immediately perceived .
Hence we may conclude , that the lime-water was saturated by some acid formed during the operation ; as in this case it is evident , that no earth could be precipitated by the fixed air alone , but that caustic volatile alkali , on being added , would absorb the fixed air , and thus becoming mild , would immediately precipitate the earth ; whereas , if the earth in the limewater had not been saturated with an acid , it would have been precipitated by the fixed air .
As to the brown colour of the sediment , it most likely proceeded from some of the quicksilver having been dissolved .
It must be observed , that if any fixed air , as well as acid , had been generated in these two experiments with the lime-water , a cloud must have been at first perceived in it , though that cloud would afterwards disappear by the earth being re-dissolved by the acid ; for till the acid produced was sufficient to dissolve the whole of the earth , some of the remainder would be precipitated by the fixed air ; so that we may safely conclude , that no fixed air was generated in the operation .
When the air is confined by soap-lees , the diminution proceeds rather faster than when it is confined by lime-water ; for which reason , as well as on account of their containing so much more alkaline matter in proportion to their bulk , soaplees seemed better adapted for experiments designed to investigate the nature of this acid , than lime-water .
I accordingly made some experiments to determine what degree of purity the air should be of , in order to be diminished most readily , and to the greatest degree ; and I found , that , when good dephlogisticated air was used , the diminution was but small ; when perfectly phlogisticated air was used , no sensible diminution took place ; but when five parts of pure dephlogisticated air were mixed with three parts of common air , almost the whole of the air was made to disappear .
It must be considered , that common air consists of one part of dephlogisticated air , mixed with four of phlogisticated ; so that a mixture of five parts of pure dephlogisticated air , and three of common air , is the same thing as a mixture of seven parts of dephlogisticated air with three of phlogisticated .
Having made these previous trials , I introduced into the tube a little soap-lees , and then let up some dephlogisticated and common air , mixed in the above-mentioned proportions , which rising to the top of the tube M , divided the soap-lees into its two legs .
As fast as the air was diminished by the electric spark , I continued adding more of the same kind , till no further diminution took place : after which a little pure dephlogisticated air , and after that a little common air , were added , in order to see whether the cessation of diminution was not owing to some imperfection in the proportion of the two kinds of air to each other ; but without effect * .
The soap-lees being then poured out of the tube , and separated from the quick* From what follows it appears , that the reason why the air ceased to diminish was , that as the soap-lees were then become neutralized , no alkali remained to absorb the acid formed by the operation , and in consequence scarce any air was turned into acid .
The spark , however , was not continued long enough after the apparent cessation of diminution , to determine with certainty , whether it was only that the diminution went on remarkably slower than before , or that it was almost come to a stand , and could not have been carried much further , though I had persisted in passing the sparks .
silver , seemed to be perfectly neutralized , as they did not at all discolour paper tinged with the juice of blue flowers .
Being evaporated to dryness , they left a small quantity of salt , which was evidently nitre , as appeared by the manner in which paper , impregnated with a solution of it , burned .
For more satisfaction , I tried this experiment over again on a larger scale .
About five times the former quantity of soap-lees were now let up into a tube of a larger bore ; and a mixture of dephlogisticated and common air , in the same proportions as before , being introduced by the apparatus represented in fig. 3 .
the spark was continued till no more air could be made to disappear .
The liquor , when poured out of the tube , smelled evidently of phlogisticated nitrous acid , and being evaporated to dryness , yielded 1 4/ 10 gr. of salt , which is pretty exactly equal in weight to the nitre which that quantity of soap-lees would have afforded if saturated with nitrous acid .
This salt was found , by the manner in which paper dipped into a solution of it burned , to be true nitre .
It appeared , by the test of terra ponderosa salita , to contain not more vitriolic acid than the soap-lees themselves contained , which was excessively little ; and there is no reason to think that any other acid entered into it , except the nitrous .
A circumstance , however , occurred , which at first seemed to show , that this salt contained some marine acid ; namely , an evident precipitation took place when a solution of silver was added to some of it dissolved in water ; though the soaplees used in its formation were perfectly free from marine acid , and though , to prevent all danger of any precipitate being formed by an excess of alkali in it , some purified nitrous acid had been added to it , previous to the addition of the solution of silver .
On consideration , however , I suspected , that this precipitation might arise from the nitrous acid in it being phloD dd2 gisticated ; gisticated ; and therefore I tried whether nitre , much phlogisticated , would precipitate silver from its solution .
For this purpose I exposed some nitre to the fire , in an earthen retort , till it had yielded a good deal of dephlogisticated air ; and then , having dissolved it in water , and added to it some well purified spirit of nitre till it was sensibly acid , in order to be certain that the alkali did not predominate , I dropped into it some solution of silver , which immediately made a very copious precipitate .
This solution , however , being deprived of some of its phlogiston by evaporation to dryness , and exposure for a few weeks to the air , lost the property of precipitating silver from its solution ; a proof that this property depended only on its phlogistication , and not on its having absorbed sea-salt from the retort , or by any other means .
Hence it is certain , that nitre , when much phlogisticated , is capable of making a precipitate with a solution of silver ; and therefore there is no reason to think , that the precipitate , which our salt occasioned with a solution of silver , proceeded from any other cause than that of its being phlogisticated ; especially as it appeared by the smell , both on first taking it out of the tube , and on the addition of the spirit of nitre , previous to dropping in the solution of silver , that the acid in it was much phlogisticated .
This property of phlogisticated nitre is worth the attention of chemists ; as otherwise they may sometimes be led into mistakes , in investigating the presence of marine acid by a solution of silver .
In the above-mentioned Paper I said , that when nitre is detonated with charcoal , the acid is converted into phlogisticated air ; that is , into a substance which , as far as I could perceive , possesses all the properties of the phlogisticated air of our atmosphere ; from which I concluded , that phlogisticated air is nothing else than nitrous acid united to phlogiston .
According to this conclusion , phlogisticated air ought to be reduced to nitrous acid by being deprived of its phlogiston .
But as dephlogisticated air is only water deprived of phlogiston , it is plain , that adding dephlogisticated air to a body , is equivalent to depriving it of phlogiston , and adding water to it ; and therefore , phlogisticated air ought also to be reduced to nitrous acid , by being made to unite to , or form a chemical combination with , dephlogisticated air ; only the acid formed this way will be more dilute , than if the phlogisticated air was simply deprived of phlogiston .
This being premised , we may safely conclude , that in the present experiments the phlogisticated air was enabled , by means of the electrical spark , to unite to , or form a chemical combination with , the dephlogisticated air , and was thereby reduced to nitrous acid , which united to the soap-lees , and formed a solution of nitre ; for in these experiments those two airs actually disappeared , and nitrous acid was actually formed in their room ; and as , moreover , it has just been shown , from other circumstances , that phlogisticated air must form nitrous acid , when combined with dephlogisticated air , the above-mentioned opinion seems to be sufficiently established .
A further confirmation of it is , that , as far as I can perceive , no diminution of air is produced when the electric spark is passed either through pure dephlogisticated air , or through perfectly phlogisticated air ; which indicates the necessity of a combination of these two airs to produce the acid .
Moreover , it was found in the last experiment , that the quantity of nitre procured was the same that the soap-lees would have produced if saturated with nitrous acid ; which shows , that the production of the nitre was not owing to any decomposition of the soap-lees .
It may be worth remarking , that whereas in the detonation of nitre with inflammable substances , the acid unites to phlogiston , and forms phlogisticated air , in these experiments the reverse of this process was carried on ; namely , the phlogisticated air united to the dephlogisticated air , which is equivalent to being deprived of its phlogiston , and was reduced to nitrous acid .
In the above-mentioned Paper I also gave my reasons for thinking , that the small quantity of nitrous acid , produced by the explosion of dephlogisticated and inflammable air , proceeded from a portion of phlogisticated air mixed with the dephlogisticated , which I supposed was deprived of its phlogiston , and turned into nitrous acid , by the action of the dephlogisticated air on it , assisted by the heat of the explosion .
This opinion , as must appear to every one , is confirmed in a remarkable manner by the foregoing experiments ; as from them it is evident , that dephlogisticated air is able to deprive phlogisticated air of its phlogiston , and reduce it into acid , when assisted by the electric spark ; and therefore it is not extraordinary that it should do so , when assisted by the heat of the explosion .
The soap-lees used in the foregoing experiments were made from salt of tartar , prepared without nitre ; and were of such a strength as to yield one-tenth of their weight of nitre when saturated with nitrous acid .
The dephlogisticated air also was prepared without nitre , that used in the first experiment with the soap-lees being procured from the black powder formed by the agitation of quicksilver mixed with lead * , and that used * This air was as pure as any that can be procured by most processes .
I propose giving an account of the experiment , in which it was prepared , in a future Paper .
in the latter from turbith mineral .
In the first experiment , the quantity of soap-lees used was 35 measures , each of which was equal in bulk to one grain of quicksilver ; and that of the air absorbed was 416 such measures of phlogisticated air , and 914 of dephlogisticated .
In the second experiment , 178 measures of soap-lees were used , and they absorbed 1920 of phlogisticated air , and 4860 of dephlogisticated .
It must be observed , however , that in both experiments some air remained in the tube uncondensed , whose degree of purity I had no way of trying ; so that the proportion of each species of air absorbed is not known with much exactness .
As far as the experiments hitherto published extend , we scarcely know more of the nature of the phlogisticated part of our atmosphere , than that it is not diminished by lime-water , caustic alkalies , or nitrous air ; that it is unfit to support fire , or maintain life in animals ; and that its specific gravity is not much less than that of common air : so that , though the nitrous acid , by being united to phlogiston , is converted into air possessed of these properties , and consequently , though it was reasonable to suppose , that part at least of the phlogisticated air of the atmosphere consists of this acid united to phlogiston , yet it might fairly be doubted whether the whole is of this kind , or whether there are not in reality many different substances confounded together by us under the name of phlogisticated air .
I therefore made an experiment to determine , whether the whole of a given portion of the phlogisticated air of the atmosphere could be reduced to nitrous acid , or whether there was not a part of a different nature from the rest , which would refuse to undergo that change .
The foregoing experiments indeed in some measure decided this point , as much the greatest part of the air let up into the tube lost its elasticity ; yet , as some remained unabsorbed , it did not appear for certain whether that was of the same nature as the rest or not .
For this purpose I diminished a similar mixture of dephlogisticated and common air , in the same manner as before , till it was reduced to a small part of its original bulk .
I then , in order to decompound as much as I could of the phlogisticated air which remained in the tube , added some dephlogisticated air to it , and continued the spark till no further diminution took place .
Having by these means condensed as much as I could of the phlogisticated air , I let up some solution of liver of sulphur to absorb the dephlogisticated air ; after which only a small bubble of air remained unabsorbed , which certainly was not more than 1/ 120 of the bulk of the phlogisticated air let up into the tube ; so that if there is any part of the phlogisticated air of our atmosphere which differs from the rest , and cannot be reduced to nitrous acid , we may safely conclude , that it is not more than 1/ 120 part of the whole .
The foregoing experiments show , that the chief cause of the diminution which common air , or a mixture of common and dephlogisticated air , suffers by the electric spark , is the conversion of the air into nitrous acid ; but yet it seemed not unlikely , that when any liquor , containing inflammable matter , was in contact with the air in the tube , some of this matter might be burnt by the spark , and thereby diminish the air , as I supposed in the above-mentioned Paper to be the case .
The best way which occurred to me of discovering whether this happened or not , was to pass the spark through dephlogisticated air , included between different liquors : for then , if the diminution proceeded solely from the conversion of air into nitrous acid , it is plain that , when the dephlogisticated air was perfectly pure , no diminution would take place ; but when it contained any phlogisticated air , all this phlogisticated air , joined to as much of the dephlogisticated air as must unite to it in order to reduce it into acid , that is , two or three times its bulk , would disappear , and no more ; so that the whole diminution could not exceed three or four times the bulk of the phlogisticated air : whereas , if the diminution proceeded from the burning of the inflammable matter , the purer the dephlogisticated air was , the greater and quicker would be the diminution .
The result of the experiments was , that when dephlogisticated air , containing only 1/ 20 of its bulk of phlogisticated air ( that being the purest air I then had ) , was confined between short columns of soap lees , and the spark passed through it till no further diminution could be perceived , the air lost 4 3/ 2 00 of its bulk ; which is not a greater diminution than might very likely proceed from the first-mentioned cause ; as the dephlogisticated air might easily be mixed with a little common air while introducing into the tube .
When the same dephlogisticated air was confined between columns of distilled water , the diminution was rather greater than before , and a white powder was formed on the surface of the quicksilver beneath ; the reason of which , in all probability , was , that the acid produced in the operation corroded the quicksilver , and formed the white powder ; and that the nitrous air , produced by that corrosion , united to the dephlogisticated air , and caused a greater diminution than would otherwise have taken place .
When a solution of litmus was used , instead of distilled water , the solution soon acquired a red colour , which grew paler and paler as the spark was continued , till at last it became quite colourless and transparent .
The air was diminished by almost half , and I believe might have been still further diminished , had the spark been continued .
When lime-water was let up into the tube , a cloud was formed , and the air was further diminished by about one-fifth .
The remaining air was good dephlogisticated air .
In this experiment , therefore , the litmus was , if not burnt , at least decompounded , so as to lose entirely its purple colour , and to yield fixed air ; so that , though soap-lees cannot be decompounded by this process , yet the solution of litmus can , and so very likely might the solutions of many other combustible substances .
But there is nothing , in any of these experiments , which favours the opinion of the air being at all diminished by means of phlogiston communicated to it by the electric spark .
M Fig. 2 .
E B A F E Fig. 3 .
B A C C

