XV .
Experiments and Observations relating to Air and Water .
By the Rev. Joseph Priestley , LL. D. F.R.S. Read February 24 , 1785 .
EVER since the discovery of the diminution of respirable air in those processes which are generally called phlogistic , it has been a great object with philosophers to find what becomes of the air which disappears in them .
Among others , I have made and published a variety of experiments with that view ; but though by this means some farther progress was made in the philosophy of air , and consequently our knowledge of the principles , or constituent parts , of natural substances was extended , I did not by any means succeed to my satisfaction with respect to the immediate object of my researches .
Others , however , were more successful , and their success has at length enabled me to resume my experiments with more advantage ; by which means I have been led both to confirm their conclusions , and , by diversifying the experiments , to throw considerable light upon various other chemical processes .
The result of these observations I shall lay before the Society , with as much brevity and distinctness as I can .
In the experiments of which I shall now give an account , I was principally guided by a view to the opinions which have lately been advanced by Mr. CAVENDISH , Mr. WATT , and M. LAVOISIER .
Mr. CAVENDISH was of opinion , that when air is decomposed , water only is produced ; and Mr. WATT concluded from some experiments , of which I gave an account to the Society , and also from some observations of his own , that water consists of dephlogisticated and inflammable air , in which Mr. CAVENDISH and M. LAVOISIER concur with him ; but Mr. LAVOISIER is well known to maintain , that there is no such thing as what has been called phlogiston , affirming inflammable air to be nothing else but one of the elements or constituent parts of water .
In the following experiments I also had a particular view to a conclusion which I had drawn from those experiments , of which an account is given in my last communications to the Royal Society ; viz. that inflammable air is pure phlogiston in the form of air , at least with the element of heat ; and that fixed air consists of dephlogisticated and inflammable air ; both which doctrines had been first advanced by Mr. KIRWAN , before I had made the experiments which I then thought clearly proved them .
Such were the hypotheses to which I had a view when I began the following course of experiments , which I hope will be an admonition to myself , as well as to others , to adhere as rigorously as possible to actual observations , and to be extremely careful not to overlook any circumstance that may possibly contribute to any particular result .
I shall have occasion to notice my own mistakes with respect to conclusions , though all the facts were strictly as I have represented them .
But whilst philosophers are faithful narrators of what they observe , no person can justly complain of being misled by them ; for to reason from the facts with which they are supplied is no more the province of the person who discovers them , than of him to whom they are discovered .
One of the most simple of all phlogistic processes is that in which metals are ignited in dephlogisticated air .
I therefore began with this , with a view to ascertain whether any water is produced when the air is made to disappear in it .
Accordingly , into a glass vessel containing 7 ounce measures of pretty pure dephlogisticated air , I introduced a quantity of iron turnings ( which is iron in small thin pieces , exceedingly convenient for these and many other experiments ) having previously made them , together with the vessel , the air , and the mercury by which it was confined , as dry as I possibly could .
Also , to prevent the air from imbibing any moisture , I received it immediately in the vessel in which the experiment was made , from the process of procuring it from red precipitate ; so that it had never been in contact with any water .
I then fired the iron , by means of a burning lens , and presently reduced the 7 ounce measures of air to.65 ; but I found no more water after this process than I imagined it had not been possible for me to exclude , as it bore no proportion to the air which had disappeared .
Examining the residuum of the air , I found one-fifth of it to be fixed air , and when I tried the purity of that which remained by the test of nitrous air , it did not appear that any phlogisticated air had been produced in the process : for though it was more impure than I suppose the air with which I began the experiment must have been , it was not more so than the phlogisticated air of the 7 ounce measures , which had not been affected by the process , and which must have been contained in the residuum , would necessarily make it .
In this case one measure of this residuum and two of nitrous air occupied the space of.32 .
In another experiment of this kind , ten ounce measures of dephlogisticated air were reduced to.8 , and by washing in lime water to.38 .
In another experiment , in which 71/ 2 ounce measures of dephlogisticated air were reduced to half an ounce measure , of which one-fifth was fixed air , the residuum was quite as pure as the air with which I began the experiment , the test with nitrous air , in the proportions above-mentioned , giving.4 in both cases .
To what circumstance the difference might be owing I cannot tell .
In these experiments the fixed air must , I presume , have been formed by the union of the phlogiston from the iron and the dephlogisticated air in which it was ignited ; but the quantity of it was very small in proportion to the air which had disappeared , and at that time I had no suspicion that the iron , which had been melted , and gathered into round balls , could have imbibed it ; a melting heat having been sufficient , as I had imagined , to expel every thing that was capable of assuming the form of air from any substance whatever .
I was therefore entirely at a loss about what must have become of the air .
Sensible , however , that such a quantity of air must have been imbibed by something to which it must have given a very perceivable addition of weight , and seeing nothing else that could have imbibed it , it occurred to me to weigh the calx into which the iron had been reduced ; and I presently found , that the dephlogisticated air had actually been imbibed by the melted iron , in the same manner as inflammable air , in my former experiments , had been imbibed by the melted calces of metals , however impossible such an absorption might have appeared to me a priori .
In the first instance , about twelve ounce measures of dephlogisticated air had disappeared , and the iron had gained six grains in weight .
Repeating the experiment very frequently , I always found , that other quantities of iron , treated in the same manner , gained similar additions of weight , which was always very nearly that of the air which had disappeared .
This calx of iron , I then concluded , was by no means what I had before taken it to be , viz. a pure calx or slag , but either the calx , or the iron itself , saturated with pure air .
This calciform substance I found , by various experiments , to be the same thing with the scales that fly from iron when it is made red-hot , or the substance into which it runs in a very intense heat , in an open fire .
Concluding from the preceding experiment , that iron , sufficiently heated , was capable of saturating itself with pure air , extracted from the mass of the atmosphere , I then proceeded to melt it with the heat of a burning lens in the open air ; and I presently found , that perfect iron was easily fused in this way , and continued in this fusion a certain time , exhibiting the appearance of boiling or throwing out air , whereas it was on the contrary imbibing air ; and when it was saturated the fusion ceased , and the heat of my lens could not make any farther impression upon it .
When this was the case , I always found that it had gained weight in the proportion of 71/ 2 to 24 , which is very nearly one-third of its original weight .
The same was the effect when I melted steel in the same circumstances , and also every kind of iron on which the experiment could be tried .
But I have some reason to think , that with a greater degree of heat than I could apply , the iron might have been kept in a state of fusion somewhat longer , and by that means have imbibed more air , even more than one-third of its original weight .
There was a peculiar circumstance attending the melting of cast iron with a burning lens , which made it impossible to ascertain the addition that was made to its weight , and at the same time afforded an amazing spectacle ; for the moment that any quantity of it was melted , and gathered into a round ball , it began to disperse in a thousand directions , exhibiting the appearance of a most beautiful fire-work , some of the particles flying to the distance of half a yard from the place of fusion ; and the whole was attended with a considerable hissing noise .
Some of the largest pieces which had been dispersed in this manner I was able to collect , and having subjected them to the heat of the lens , they exhibited the same appearance as the larger mass from which they had been scattered .
When I melted this cast iron in the bottom of a deep glass receiver , in order to collect all the particles that were dispersed , they firmly adhered to the glass , melting it superficially , though without making it crack , so that it was still impossible to collect and weigh the particles .
However , I generally found that , notwithstanding the copious dispersion , what remained after the experiment rather exceeded than fell short of the original weight of the iron .
Sometimes a piece of common iron , and especially steel , would make a little hissing in the fusion , and a particle or two would fly off ; but this was never considerable * .
Having now procured what I thought to be a new calx of iron , or a calx saturated with pure air , I endeavoured to revive it by making it imbibe inflammable air , in the same manner that I had before made iron , and various other metals , by melting them in a vessel containing inflammable air .
In this I succeeded ; but in the course of the experiment a new and very unexpected appearance occurred .
I took a piece of iron which I had saturated with pure air , and putting it into a glass vessel * On being informed of the above-mentioned phenomenon , Mr. WATT concluded , that the basis of the dephlogisticated air united to the phlogiston of the iron , and formed water , which was attracted by , and remained so firmly united to the clax of iron , as to resist the effects of heat to separate them .
containing inflammable air , confined by water , threw upon it the focus of the lens , and presently perceived the inflammable air to disappear , and without thinking of any thing escaping from the calx of iron ( which had been subjected to a greater heat before ) I imagined that I should have found the addition of the weight of air in the iron , and the result might be an iron different from the common sort .
But I found , to my surprise , that the iron , which had exhibited no new appearance in this mode of treatment , had lost weight , instead of gaining any .
The piece of iron on which I made this first experiment weighed 111/ 2 grains , and 71/ 2 ounce measures of inflammable air had disappeared while the iron had lost 21/ 2 grains .
Considering the quantity of inflammable air that had disappeared , viz. 71/ 2 ounce measures , and the dephlogisticated air which had been expelled from the iron , viz. 21/ 2 grains , which is equal to about 4.1 ounce measures , I found that they were very nearly in the proper proportion to saturate each other , when decomposed by the electrical spark , viz. two measures of inflammable air to one of dephlogisticated air .
I therefore had now no doubt but that the two kinds of air had united , and had formed either fixed air or water ; but which it was I could not tell , having had water on the receiver in which the experiment was made , and having neglected to examine the state of the air that remained , except in a general way , by which I found , that it was still , to appearance , as inflammable as ever .
With a view to determine whether fixed air , or water , would be the produce of this mode of combining inflammable and dephlogisticated air , I repeated the experiment in a vessel in which the inflammable air was confined by mercury , and both the vessel and the mercury had been previously made as dry as possible .
I had no sooner begun to heat the iron , or rather slag , in these circumstances , than I perceived the air to diminish , and at the same time the inside of the vessel to grow very cloudy , with particles of dew , that covered almost the whole of it .
These particles by degrees gathered into drops , and ran down the sides of the vessel in all places , except where it was heated by the sun-beams ; so that it then appeared to me very evident , that water , with or without fixed air , was the produce of the inflammable air , and the pure air let loose from the iron in this mode of operation ; though afterwards I was taught by Mr. WATT to correct this hypothesis , and to account for this result in a different manner .
When I had examined the remaining air , it was as inflammable as ever , without containing any mixture of fixed air at all .
When I collected the water which was produced in this experiment by means of a piece of filtering paper , carefully introduced to absorb it , I found it to be , as nearly as possible , of the same weight with that which had been lost by the iron : and also , in every experiment of this kind , in which I attended to this circumstance , I found that the quantity of inflammable air which had disappeared was about double to that of the dephlogisticated air set loose from the iron , supposing that weight to have been reduced into air .
Thus at one time I made a piece of this slag imbibe 51/ 2 ounce measures of inflammable air , while it lost as much as the weight of about 3 ounce measures of dephlogisticated air , and the water collected weighed 2 grains .
Another time a piece of slag lost 1.5 grains , and the water produced was 1.7 grains ; but perfect accuracy is not to be expected .
I shall only mention one more experiment of this kind , in which 61/ 2 ounce measures of inflammable air were reduced to.92 ounce measure , and the iron had lost 2 grains , equal in weight to 3.3 ounce measures of dephlogisticated air .
In all the above-mentioned experiments , the inflammable air was that which is produced by the solution of iron in acids .
As before I had finished this course of experiments I had satisfied myself that inflammable air always contains a portion of water , and also , that when it has been some time confined by water , it imbibes more , so as to be increased in its specific gravity by that means , I repeated the experiment with inflammable air which had not been confined by water , but which was received in a vessel of dry mercury from the vessel in which it was generated ; but I presently perceived that water was produced in this case also , and to appearance as copiously as in the former experiment .
Indeed , the quantity of water produced , which so greatly exceeded the weight of all the inflammable air , is sufficient to prove that it must have had some other source than any constituent part of that air , or the whole of it , together with the water contained in it , without taking into consideration the corresponding loss of weight in the iron .
I must here observe , that the iron slag which I had treated in this manner , and which had thereby lost the weight which it had acquired by melting in dephlogisticated air , became perfect iron as at first , and was then capable of being melted by the burning lens again ; so that the same piece of iron would serve for these experiments as long as the operator should chuse .
It was evident , therefore , that if the iron had lost its phlogiston in the preceding fusion , it had acquired it again from the inflammable air which it had absorbed ; and I do not see how the experiment can be accounted for in any other way , which necessarily implies the reality of phlogiston as a constituent principle in bodies .
This , at least , is the most natural way of accounting for the appearances .
Having had this success with the calx , or scales of iron , I tried the calx of copper , or those scales which fly from it when it is made red-hot ; and I found water produced in the inflammable air in the same manner as when I used the scales of iron in the same circumstances .
I also had the same result when I revived precipitate per se in inflammable air ; but having at that time a very weak winter 's sun , I could not make the experiment with so much advantage as I could have wished .
Iron , I found , acquired this additional weight by melting in an earthen retort , as well as in the open air by the sunbeams , if it were possible for it to attract air , or whatever else it is that is the immediate cause of its additional weight .
Three ounces of common iron filings , exposed to a strong heat in an earthen retort , gained 11 dwts , or 264 grains , and yet was very far from having been completely fused .
Having a glass tube communicating with the retort , in order to collect any air that the iron filings might give out , I found that when they were very hot , the water ascended within the tube ; which shows that the iron was then in a state of absorbing , and not of giving out any air .
Seeing so much water produced in these experiments with inflammable air , I was particularly led to reflect on the relation which they bore to each other , and especially to Mr. CAVENDISH'S ideas on the subject .
He had told me that , notwithstanding the experiments of which I had given an account to the Royal Society , and from which I had concluded that inflammable air was pure phlogiston , he was persuaded that water was essential to the production of it , and even entered into it as a constituent principle .
At that time I did not perceive the force of the arguments which he stated to me , especially as , in the experiments with charcoal , I totally dispersed any quantity of it with a burning lens in vacuo , and thereby filled my receiver with nothing but inflammable air .
I had no suspicion that the wet leather on which my receiver stood could have any influence in the case , while the piece of charcoal was subject to the intense heat of the lens , and placed several inches above the leather .
I had also procured inflammable air from charcoal in a glazed earthen retort two whole days successively , in which it had given inflammable air without intermission .
Also iron filings in a gun-barrel , and a gun-barrel itself , had always given inflammable air whenever I tried the experiment .
These circumstances , however , deceived me , and perhaps would have deceived any other person ; for I did not know , and could not have believed , the powerful attraction that charcoal , or iron , appear to have for water when they are intensely hot .
They will find , and attract it , in the midst of the hottest fire , and through any pores that may be left open in a retort ; and iron filings are seldom so dry as not to have moisture enough adhering to them , capable of enabling them to give a considerable quantity of inflammable air .
But my attention being now fully awake to the subject , I presently found that the circumstances above mentioned had actually misled me ; I mean with respect to the conclusion which I drew from the experiments , and not with respect to the experiments themselves , every one of which , I doubt not , will be found to answer , whenever they are tried by persons of sufficient skill and properly attentive to all the circumstances .
Being thus apprised of the influence of unperceived moisture in the production of inflammable air , and willing to ascertain it to my perfect satisfaction , I began with filling a gun-barrel with iron filings in their common state , without taking any particular precaution to dry them , and I found that they gave air as they had been used to do , and continued to do so many hours ; I even got ten ounce measures of inflammable air from two ounces of iron filings in a coated glass retort .
At length , however , the production of inflammable air from the gun-barrel ceased ; but on putting water into it , the air was produced again , and a few repetitions of the experiment fully satisfied me that I had been too precipitate in concluding that inflammable air is pure phlogiston .
I then repeated the experiment with the charcoal , making the receiver , the stand on which I placed the charcoal , and the charcoal itself , as dry and as hot as possible , and using cement instead of a wet leather to exclude the air .
In these circumstances I was not able , with the advantage of a good sun , and an excellent burning lens , to decompose quite so much as two grains of the piece of charcoal , which gave me ten ounce measures of inflammable air ; and this , I imagine , was effected by means of so much moisture as was deposited from the air in its state of rarefaction , and before it could be drawn from the receiver .
To the production of this kind of inflammable air I was therefore now convinced , that water is as necessary as to that from iron .
It was in this state of my experiments that I received an authentic account of those of M. LAVOISIER , on transmitting water through an hot iron tube and also through a hot copper tube containing charcoal , and thereby procuring large quantities of inflammable air , M. LAVOISIER himself having been so obliging as to send me a copy of his Memoir on that subject .
I had heard an account of the experiments some months before ; but it was so imperfect a one , that I own I paid little attention to them .
At this time , however , I was prepared to be sufficiently sensible of their value .
In my last communications to the Royal Society , it will be seen that I had transmitted the vapour of several fluid substances through red-hot earthen tubes , and thereby procured different kinds of air .
M. LAVOISIER adopted the same process , but used an iron tube ; and by means of that circumstance made a very valuable discovery which had escaped me .
I had indeed on one occasion made use of an iron tube , and transmitted steam through it ; but not having at that time any view to the production of air , I did not collect it at all , contenting myself with observing that water , after being made red-hot , was still water , there being no change in its sensible properties .
Being now farther instructed by the experiment of M. LAVOISIER , I was determined to repeat the process with all the attention I could give to it ; but I should not have done this with so much advantage , if I had not had the assistance of Mr. WATT , who always thought that M. LAVOISIER'S experiments by no means favoured the conclusion that he drew from them .
As to myself , I was a long time of opinion that his conclusion was just , and that the inflammable air was really furnished by the water being decomposed in the process .
But though I continued to be of this opinion for some time , the frequent repetition of the experiments , with the light which Mr. WATT'S observations threw upon them , satisfied me at length that the inflammable air came principally from the charcoal , or the iron .
I shall first relate the result of the experiment that was made with charcoal , and then those with iron and other substances , in contact with which ( when they were in a state of fusion , or at least red-hot ) I made steam , or the vapour of other liquid substances , to pass .
I shall only observe that , previous to this , I began to make the experiments with coated glass tubes , which I found to answer very well during the process , though they never failed to break in cooling .
At length I procured a tube of copper , on which , as M. LAVOISIER discovered , steam had no effect ; and at last I made use of earthen tubes , with which Mr. WEDGEWOOD , that most generous promoter of science , liberally supplied me for the purpose ; and these glazed on the outside only I find far preferable to copper .
They are , indeed , every thing that I could wish for in experiments of this kind ; the reason of which will appear in my account of another course of experiments , which I hope to lay before the Society in due time .
The disposition of the apparatus , with which these experiments were made , was as follows .
The water was made to boil in a glass retort , which communicated with the copper or earthen tube which contained the charcoal or iron , &amp;c. and which , being placed in an horizontal position , was surrounded with hot coals .
The end of this tube opposite to the retort communicated with the pipe of a common worm tub , such as is generally used in distillations , by means of which all the superfluous steam was condensed , and collected in a proper receptacle , while the air which had been produced , and had come along with it through the worm tub , was transmitted into a trough of water , where proper vessels were placed to receive it , and ascertain the quantity of it ; after which I could examine the quality of it at leisure .
In the experiment with charcoal , I found unexpected difficulties , and considerable variations in the result ; the proportion between the charcoal and water expended , and also between each ofthem and the air produced , not being so no arly the same as I imagined they would have been .
Also the quantity of fixed air that was mixed with the inflammable air varied very much .
This last circumstance , however , some of my experiments may serve to explain .
Whenever I had no more water than was sufficient for the production of the air , there was never any sensible quantity of uncombined fixed air mixed with the inflammable air from charcoal .
This was particularly the case when I produced the air by means of a burning lens in an exhausted receiver , and also in an earthen retort with the application of an intense heat .
I therefore presume , that when the steam transmitted through the hot tube containing the charcoal was very copious , the fixed air in the produce was greater than it would otherwise have been .
The extremes that I have observed in the proportion of the fixed to the inflammable air have been from one-twelfth to one-fifth of the whole .
As I generally produced this air , the latter was the usual proportion ; and this was exclusive of the fixed air that was intimately combined with the inflammable air , and which could not be separated from it except by decomposition with dephlogisticated air ; and this combined fixed air I sometimes found to be one-third of the whole mass , though at other times not quite so much .
To ascertain this , I mixed one measure of this inflammable air from charcoal ( after the uncombined fixed air had been separated from it by lime-water ) with one measure of dephlogisticated air , and then fired them by the electric spark .
After this I always found that the air which remained made lime-water very turbid , and the proportion in which it was now diminished , by washing in lime-water , showed the quantity of fixed air that had been combined with the inflammable .
That the fixed air is not generated in this process , is evident from there being no fixed air found after the explosion of dephlogisticated air and inflammable air from iron .
Notwithstanding the above-mentioned variations , the loss of weight in the charcoal was always much exceeded by the weight of the water expended , which was generally more than double of the charcoal ; and this water was intimately combined with the air ; for when I received a portion of it in mercury , no water was ever deposited from it .
The experiment which , upon the whole , gave me the most satisfaction , and the particulars of which I shall therefore recite , was the following .
Expending 94 grains of perfect charcoal ( by which I mean charcoal made with a very strong heat , so as to expel all fixed air from it ) and 240 grains of water , I procured 840 ounce measures of air , one-fifth of which was fixed air , and of the inflammable part nearly onethird more appeared to be fixed air by decomposition .
Receiving this kind of air in a variety of experiments , but not in the preceding ones in particular ( for then I could not have ascertained the quantity of it ) consisting of fixed and inflammable air together , I found some variations in its specific gravity , owing , I imagine , to the different proportions of fixed air contained in it ; but upon the whole , I think , that the proportion of 14 grains to 40 ounce measures is pretty near the truth , when the proportion of fixed air is about one-fifth of the whole .
With respect to the weight of the inflammable air after the fixed air was separated from it , I found no great difference , and think it may be estimated at 8 grains to 30 ounce measures .
Upon these principles , the whole weight of the 840 ounce measures of air will be 294 grains that of the charcoal will be 94 that of the water 240 334 which , considering the na7 ture ture of the experiment , will perhaps be thought to be tolerably near that of the air .
If the air be analyzed , the 840 ounce measures will be found to contain 168 of uncombined fixed air = 151 grains .
and 672 impure imflammable = 179 so that the whole 840 will weigh 330 Lastly , if the 672 ounce measures of impure inflammable air be decomposed , it will be found to contain 164 ounce measures of fixed air = 147.6 grs. and 508 inflammable = 30.7 so that the whole 672 will weigh 178.3 which is very near to 179 , the weight of the whole together .
It may , however , be safely concluded from this experiment , and indeed from every other that I made with charcoal , that there was no more pure inflammable air produced than the charcoal itself may be very well supposed to have supplied .
There is , therefore , no reason for deserting the old established hypothesis of phlogiston on account of these experiments , since the fact is by no means inconsistent with it .
The pure inflammable air with the water necessarily contained in it would weigh no more than about 30 grains , while the loss of weight in the charcoal was 94 grains .
But to this must be added the phlogiston contained in 392 ounce measures of fixed air , which , according to Mr. KIRWAN'S proportion , will be nearly 65 grains , and this and the 30 grains will be 95 grains .
The basis to this fixed air , as well as to the inflammable , must have been furnished by the water ; and from this it may be concluded , that the water must have been so far altered as to be changed into fixed air , which will be thought not to be any great paradox , if it be considered that , according to the latest discoveries , fixed air and water appear to consist of the same ingredients , namely dephlogisticated and inflammable air .
However , in this change of the water we cannot be absolutely sure that the same proportion of the ingredients is contained , and therefore it cannot be absolutely determined whether the inflammable air which it contains enters wholly into the fixed air , or not .
Farther experiments , or a careful comparison of these experiments with those made by Mr. KIRWAN and others , may perhaps throw some light upon this subject .
Whether the combined fixed air comes wholly from the charcoal , or whether the charcoal only supplies the phlogiston , and the water its basis , that is , the dephlogisticated air , deserves to be investigated .
Before I conclude my account of the experiments with charcoal , I would observe , that there is another in which I place some dependence , in which , with the loss of 178 grains of charcoal , and 528 grains of water , I procured 1410 ounce measures of air , of which the last portion ( for I did not examine the rest ) contained one-sixth part of uncombined fixed air .
This was made in an earthen tube glazed on the outside .
The experiments with iron were more satisfactory than those with charcoal , being subject to less variation ; and it is still more evident from them , that the inflammable air does not come from the water , but only from the iron , as the quantity of water expended , added to the weight of the air produced , was as nearly as could be expected in experiments of this kind , found in the addition of weight gained by the iron .
And though the inflammable air procured in this process is between one-third and one-half more than can be procured from iron by a solution in acids , the reason may be , that much phlogiston is retained in the solutions , and therefore much more may be expelled from iron , when pure water , without any acid , takes the place of it .
I would further observe , that the produce of air , and also the addition of weight gained by the iron , are much more easily ascertained in these experiments than the quantity of water expended in them , on account of the great length of the vessels used in the process , and the different quantities that may perhaps be retained in the worm of the tub , though I did not fail to use all the precautions that I could think of to guard against any variation on these accounts .
Of the many experiments which I made with iron , I shall content myself with reciting the following results .
With the addition of 267 grains to a quantity of iron , and the loss of 336 grains of water , I procured 840 ounce measures of inflammable air ; and with the addition of 140 grains to another quantity of iron , and the consumption of 253 grains of water , I got 420 ounce measures of air * .
The inflammable air produced in this manner is of the lightest kind , and free from that very offensive smell which is generally occasioned by the rapid solution of metals in oil of vitriol , and it is extricated in as little time in this way as it is possible to do it by any mode of solution .
On this account it occurred to me , that it must be by much the cheapest method that has yet been used of filling balloons with the lightest inflammable air .
For this purpose it will be proper to make use of cast-iron cylinders of a considerable length , and about three or four inches , or perhaps more , in diameter .
Though the iron tube itself will contribute to the production of air , and therefore may become unfit for the purpose in time ; yet , for any * If the perfect accuracy of the former of these experiments may be depended on ( and it may always be presumed , that those in which little water is expended are preferable to those in which more is consumed ) the water that necessarily enters into this kind of inflammable air is about equal in weight to the phlogiston that is in it .
But I propose to give more particular attention to this subject .
thing that I know to the contrary , the same tube may serve for a very great number of processes , and perhaps the change made in the inside surface may protect it from any farther action of the water , if the tube be of sufficient thickness ; but this can only be determined by experiment .
Some estimate of what may be expected from this method of procuring inflammable air may be formed from the following observations .
About twelve inches in length of a copper tube , three-fourths of an inch in diameter , filled with iron turnings ( which are more convenient for this purpose than iron filings , as they do not lie so close , but admit the steam to pass through their interstices ) when it was heated , and a sufficient quantity of steam passed through it , yielded thirty ounce measures of air in fifty seconds ; and eighteen inches of another copper tube , an inch and a quarter in diameter , filled and treated in the same manner , gave two hundred ounce measures in one minute and twenty-five seconds ; so that this larger tube gave air in proportion to its solid contents compared with the smaller ; but to what extent this might be depended upon I cannot tell .
However , as the heat penetrates so readily to some distance , the rate of giving air will always be in a greater proportion than that of the simple diameter of the tube .
The following experiment was made with a view to ascertain the quantity of inflammable air that may be procured in this way from any given quantity of iron .
Two ounces of iron , or 960 grains , when dissolved in acids , will yield about 800 ounce measures of air ; but treated in this manner it yielded 1054 ounce measures , and then the iron had gained 329 grains in weight , which is little short of one-third of the weight of the iron .
Considering how little this inflammable air weighs , viz. the whole 1054 ounce measures not more than 63 grains , and the difficulty of ascertaining the loss of water to so small a quantity as this , it is not possible to determine , from a process of this kind , how much water enters into the composition of the inflammable air of metals .
It would be more easy to determine this circumstance with respect to the inflammable air of charcoal , especially by means of the experiment made with a burning lens in vacuo .
In this method two grains of charcoal gave at a medium thirteen ounce measures of inflammable air , which , in the proportion of 30 ounce measures to 8 grains , will weigh 3.3 grains ~ so that water in the composition of this kind of inflammable air is in the proportion of 1.3 to 2 , though there will be some difficulty with respect to the fixed air intimately combined with this kind of inflammable air .
Since iron gains the same addition of weight by melting in dephlogisticated air , and also by the addition of water when red-hot , and becomes , as I have already observed , in all respects the same substance , it is evident , that this air or water , as existing in the iron , is the very same thing ; and this can hardly be explained but upon the supposition that water consists of two kinds of air ; viz. inflammable and dephlogisticated .
I shall endeavour to explain these processes in the following manner .
When iron is melted in dephlogisticated air , we may suppose that , though part of its phlogiston escapes , to enter into the composition of the small quantity of fixed air which is then procured , yet enough remains to form water with the addition of dephlogisticated air which it has imbibed , so that this calx of iron consists of the intimate union of the pure earth of iron and of water ; and therefore when the same calx , thus satuQ q2 rated rated with water , is exposed to heat in inflammable air , this air enters into it , destroys the attraction between the water and the earth , and revives the iron , while the water is expelled in its proper form .
Consequently , in the process with steam , nothing is necessary to be supposed but the entrance of the water , and the expulsion of the phlogiston belonging to the iron , no more phlogiston remaining in it than what the water brought along with it , and which is retained as a constituent part of the water , or of the new compound .
Having procured water from the scales of iron ( which I must again observe is , in all respects , the same substance with iron melted in dephlogisticated air , or saturated with steam by means of heat ) and having thereby converted it into perfect iron again , I did not entertain a doubt but that I should be able to produce the same effect by heating it with charcoal in a retort ; and I had likewise no doubt but I should be able to extract the additional weight which the iron had gained ( viz. one-third of the whole ) in water .
In the former of these conjectures I was right ; but with respect to the latter , I was totally mistaken .
Having made the scales of iron , and also the powder of charcoal very hot , previous to the experiment , so that I was satisfied that no air could be extracted from either of them separately by any degree of heat , and having mixed them together while they were hot , I put them into an earthen retort , glazed within and without , which was quite impervious to air .
This I placed in a furnace , in which I could give it a very strong heat ; and connected with it proper vessels to condense and collect the water which I expected to receive in the course of the process .
But , to my great surprise , not one particle of moisture came over , but a prodigious quantity of air , and the rapidity of its production astonished me ; so that I had no doubt but that the weight of the air would have been equal to the loss of weight both in the scales and in the charcoal ; and when I examined the air , which I repeatedly did , I found it to contain one-tenth of fixed air , and the inflammable air , which remained when the fixed air was separated from it , was of a very remarkable kind , being quite as heavy as common air .
The reason of this was sufficiently apparent when it was decomposed by means of dephlogisticated air ; for the greatest part of it was fixed air .
The theory of this process I imagine to be , that the phlogiston from the charcoal reviving the iron , the water with which it had been saturated , being now set loose , affected the hot charcoal as it would have done if it had been applied to it in the form of steam as in the preceding experiments ; and therefore the air produced in these two different modes have a near resemblance to each other , each containing fixed air , both combined and uncombined , though in different proportions ; and in both the cases I found these proportions subject to variations .
In one process with charcoal and scales of iron , the first produce contained one-fifth of uncombined fixed air , the middle part one-tenth , and the last none at all .
But in all these cases the proportion of combined fixed air varied very little .
Why air and not water should be produced in this case , as well as in the preceding , when the iron is equally revived in both , I do not pretend perfectly to understand .
There is , indeed , an obvious difference in the circumstances of the two experiments ; as in that with charcoal the phlogiston is found in a combined state ; whereas in that of inflammable air , it is loose , or only united to water ; and perhaps future experiments may discover the operation of this circumstance .
There is some analogy between the experiment of the calx of iron imbibing inflammable air , and the iron itself imbibing dephlogisticated air .
In the former case water is produced , and in the latter fixed air .
However , this case of iron imbibing dephlogisticated air more nearly resembles the case of the blood in the lungs imbibing the same kind of air , and in both the cases as dephlogisticated air is imbibed , fixed air is formed .
This , therefore , seems to be a confirmation of the conclusion which I drew from my former experiments on blood , viz. that it parts with phlogiston in respiration .
Only I would now add , that at the same time that it parts with phlogiston it takes in dephlogisticated air , which makes the case perfectly similar to that of the experiment with iron , which likewise parts with phlogiston to form fixed air , at the same time that it imbibes dephlogisticated air in contact with which it is fused .
I propose to reserve for a future communication the continuation of these experiments , containing an account of the application of the same process to other substances ; but it may not be amiss just to mention a few of the general results , and those which have the nearest connexion with the experiments recited above .
After having transmitted steam in contact with charcoal and iron in a copper tube , I proposed to do the same with other substances containing phlogiston , and I began with bones , which were burnt black , and had been subjected to an intense heat , covered with sand , in an earthen retort .
From three ounces of bone thus prepared , and treated as I had done the charcoal , I got 840 ounce measures of air , with the loss of 288 grains of water .
The bones were by this means made perfectly white , and had lost 110 grains of their weight .
As the air ceased to come a considerable time before all the water had been transmitted through the tube containing them , I concluded that the air was formed from the phlogiston contained in the bones , and so much water as was necessary to give it the form of air .
This air differs considerably from any other kind of inflammable air , being in several respects a medium between that from charcoal and that from iron .
It contains about one-fourth of its bulk of uncombined fixed air , but not quite one-tenth intimately combined with the remainder .
The water that came over was blue , and pretty strongly alkaline , which must have been occasioned by the volatile alkali not having been entirely expelled from the bones in the former process , and its having in part dissolved the copper of the tube in which the experiment was made .
I subjected to the same process a variety of substances that are said not to contain phlogiston , but I was never able to procure inflammable air by means of them ; which strengthens the hypothesis of the principal element in the constitution of this air having been derived from the substance supposed to contain phlogiston , and therefore that phlogiston is a real substance , capable of assuming the form of air by means of water and heat .
The experiments above-mentioned relating to iron were made with that kind which is malleable ; but I had the same result when I made use of small nails of cast iron , except that these were firmly fastened together after the experiment , the surfaces of them being crystallized , and the crystals mixing with each other , so that it was with great difficulty that they could be got out of the tube after the experiment , and in general the solid parts of the nails were broken before they were separated from each other .
Indeed the pieces of malleable iron adhered together after the experiment , but by no means so firmly .
Cast iron annealed ( by being kept red-hot in charcoal ) is remarkably different from the cast iron which has not undergone that operation , especially in its being , to an extraordinary degree , more soluble in acids .
With the turnings of annealed cast iron I made the following experiment .
From 960 grains of this iron , and with the loss of 480 grains of water , I got 870 ounce measures of inflammable air , and transmitting steam through them a second time , I got 150 ounce measures more .
The iron had then gained 246 grains in weight , and the pieces adhered firmly together ; but being thin they were easily broken and got out of the tube , whereas it had required a long time , and a sharp steel instrument , to clear the tube of the cast-iron nails .
Having got water from the scales of iron and of copper saturated with dephlogisticated air , by heating them in inflammable air , it occurred to me to make the same experiment with precipitate per se , and I found , that the moment that the focus of the lens fell upon this substance the mercury began to revive , the inflammable air rapidly disappeared , and water was formed on the sides of the vessel in which the experiment was made .
For want of a better sun , I could not ascertain every circumstance relating to this process ; but what I did seemed to afford a sufficient proof that mercury contains phlogiston , and that it is not revived by the mere expulsion of dephlogisticated air , as M. LAVOISIER supposes ; especially as no fixed air was found in what remained of the inflammable air .
In one of these experiments 4.5 ounce measures of inflammable air had disappeared , and 1.6 ounce measure remained ; and this appeared to contain some dephlogisticated air mixed with the inflammable .
Willing to try the effect of heating iron , and other substances , in all the different kinds of air , without any particular expectation , I found that iron melted more readily in vitriolic acid air than in dephlogisticated air , the air was diminished as rapidly , and the inside of the vessel was covered with a black sooty matter , which , when exposed to heat , readily sublimed in the form of a white vapour , and left the glass quite clean .
The iron , after the experiment , was quite brittle , and must , I presume , be the same thing with iron that is sulphurated ; but I did not particularly examine it .
Of seven ounce measures of vitriolic acid air , in one of these experiments , not more than three-tenths of an ounce measure remained ; of this two-thirds was fixed air , and the residuum of this was inflammable .
I had put three of such residuums together , in order to make the experiment with the greater certainty .
Having transmitted steam , or the vapour of water , through a copper tube , I was willing to try the effects of spirit of wine through the same tube when red-hot , having before procured inflammable air by sending the same vapour through a red-hot tobacco-pipe .
In this case , the vapour of the spirit of wine had no sooner entered the hot copper tube , than I was perfectly astonished at the rapid production of air .
It resembled the blowing of a pair of bellows .
But I had not used four ounces of the spirit of wine before I very unexpectedly found , that the tube was perforated in several places ; and presently afterwards it was so far destroyed , that in attempting to remove it from the fire it actually fell in pieces .
The inside was full of a black sooty matter resembling lamp-black .
Upon this I had recourse to earthen tubes , and found , that by melting copper and other metals in them , and transmitting the vapour of spirit of wine in contact with them , different substances were formed according to the metals employed .
The new substances hereby formed may be said to be the several metals super-saturated with phlogiston , and may perhaps not be improperly called the charcoal of metals .
That this appellation is not very improper , may appear from these substances yielding inflammable air very copiously when they are made red-hot , and the steam of water is transmitted in contact with them , just as when the charcoal of wood is treated in the same manner .
The detail of these experiments I reserve for another communication , as also those of the conversion of spirit of wine , aether , and oil , into different kinds of inflammable air , by transmitting them , in vapour , through hot earthen tubes .
In the mean time , I shall think myself happy if the communication of the preceding experiments shall give any satisfaction to the Members of the Society .
POSTSCRIP T. BEFORE I close this paper , I wish to make a few general inferences from the principal of the experiments above-mentioned , especially relating to the proportional quantity of phlogiston contained in iron and water .
When any quantity of iron is melted in dephlogisticated air , it imbibes the greatest part of it , and gains an addition of weight very nearly equal to that of the air imbibed .
Thus the absorption of twelve ounce measures of dephlogisticated air gave an addition of six grains to the piece of iron which had been melted in it .
But there was always a quantity of fixed air produced in this process ; and on the supposition that this air consists of the union of dephlogisticated and inflammable air , it proves that the dephlogisticated air which enters the iron expels more phlogiston than is necessary to constitute an equal weight of water , so that water does not contain so much phlogiston as iron ; but the difference is not very considerable .
Admitting Mr. KIRWAN'S conclusion , viz. that 100 cubic inches of fixed air contain 8,357 grains of phlogiston , the.13 ounce measure of fixed air , which ( in an experiment recited in these papers ) was found in the residuum of seven ounce measures of dephlogisticated air absorbed by iron , would not have contained more than.01 grain of phlogiston , or about.16 ounce measure of inflammable air .
Then , as the absorption of 12 ounce measures of dephlogisticated air occasioned an addition of 6 grains to the weight of the iron which had absorbed it , the absorption of seven ounce measures must have occasioned the addition of 3.5 grains to the iron which had imbibed it .
But the same addition of weight to iron given by steam ( which carries its own inflammable air along with it ) would have expelled near 12 ounce measures of inflammable air : consequently , about ten ounce measures of inflammable air ( or the phlogiston requisite to form it ) must , in the former experiment , have been retained in the iron , in order to compose the water which was now made by the union of the dephlogisticated air imbibed by the iron and the phlogiston contained in it : and therefore the proportion between the quantity of phlogiston in iron to that which is contained in an equal weight of water , may be about 12 to 10 , or more accurately to 10.4 .
Had no fixed air at all been found in the residuum abovementioned , it might have been concluded , that water had conR r2 tained tained the very same proportion of phlogiston with iron .
Since when iron that has been saturated with dephlogisticated air is heated in inflammable air ( in which process an equal weight of water is produced , and the loss of weight in the iron is equal to that of such a quantity of dephlogisticated air as would have been one-half of the bulk of the inflammable air which disappears in that process ) it might have been concluded , that onefifth of any quantity in water had been inflammable air .
For , neglecting the difference between the weight of dephlogisticated and common air , which is not considerable , and estimating the latter 1/ 800 th part of water , and inflammable air at one-tenth of the weight of common air , an ounce measure of dephlogisticated air will weigh.6 grain , and two ounce measures of inflammable air will weigh.12 grain , which numbers are to each other as 5 to 1 * .
Though , in consequence of the small quantity of fixed air which is found in the process of melting iron in dephlogisticated air , this conclusion is not accurate , it is pretty nearly so ; and it is remarkable that , upon this supposition , about as much inflammable air is expelled from iron when water is com* It appears from the prosecution of these experiments , that the water which is found on heating the scales of iron in inflammable air , is not formed by the dephlogisticated air expelled from them uniting with the inflammable air in the vessel , but was the water previously contained in the scales , which is made to quit its place by the introduction of the phlogiston from the inflammable air ; yet that water carries out with it not much less phlogiston than was taken in by the iron , and a little more must be allowed for that water which was necessary to make inflammable air , and which could not enter the iron when it was revived ; so that , on the whole , the phlogiston in the water that is found after the process must be very nearly the same quantity that is imbibed by the iron , and the water is nearly the same that would have been produced , on the supposition of its being made from dephlogisticated air expelled from the scales uniting with the inflammabel air in the vessel .
bined with it , as the water itself brings along with it , as an essential ingredient in its composition .
For in one experiment 296 grains added to the weight of a quantity of iron by steam , made it to yield about 1000 ounce measures of inflammable air .
This would weigh 60 grains , and one-fifth of the 296 grains of water will be 59.2 grains .
Again , 267 grains added to iron by steam made it to yield 840 ounce measures of inflammable air , which would weigh 50.4 grains , and one-fifth of the 267 would be 53.4 grains .
When the experiments on the melting of iron in dephlogisticated air shall be repeated on a larger scale , which it will not be difficult to do by the help of a larger burning lens than I am at present possessed of , it will be easy to reduce these calculations to a greater certainty .
All that I can do at present is to approximate to such general conclusions as I have mentioned ; but they are of so much consequence in philosophy , that it will certainly be well worth while to ascertain them with as much accuracy as possible .
Nice calculations would be ill bestowed on the imperfect data which I am as yet able to furnish .
Attention must also be given to the quantity of water contained in inflammable air from iron ; which not being yet ascertained is not considered in these inferences .
I wish only to hint in this Postscript , that some important conclusions seems to be nearly within our reach .
ENDOFPART 1 .
OFVO L. LXXV .

