VII .
Observations of a new variable Star .
In a Letter from Edward Pigott , Esq. to Sir H. C. Englefield , Bart. F. R. S. and A. S. Read December 23 , 1784 .
DEARSI R , FOR some years past I have been employed in verifying all the stars suspected to be variable , in order that hereafter we may know with certainty what to depend upon .
This undertaking , which is nearly completed , has already proved of use in detecting many mistakes , and producing some discoveries ; among which , the following is one of the most important .
September 10 , 1784 , I first perceived a change in the brightness of the star ~ Antinoi , and by a series of observations made ever since , I find it subject to a variation very similar to that of Algol , though not exactly the same in any one particular .
~ Antinoi , when brightest , is of the third or fourth magnitude , being between ~ and ~ Aquilae ; and at its least brightness of the fourth or fifth magnitude , it then being between that of ~ Antinoi and ~ Aquilae ; therefore , its greatest variation in brightness may be called about one magnitude ; and the changes it undergoes , though probably not nicely ascertained from so few observations , are nearly these : At its greatest brightness 44 ~ hours .
In decreasing 62 ~ hours .
At its least brightness 30 ~ hours .
In increasing 36 ~ hours .
All these changes , which hitherto seem to be regular and constant , are performed in 7 days 4 hours 38-minutes ; this I shall stile its period , and hereafter will show how it is determined with such exactness .
The stars to which ~ Antinoi was compared are in order thus : ~ Aquilae third magnitude , ~ Aquilae and ~ Serpentis fourth magnitudes , ~ Antinoi fourth or fifth magnitude , and ~ Aquilae a bright fifth .
I find , by several years observation , that ~ Aquilae retains the same brightness .
~ Antinoi , which has been examined with particular attention by Mr. GOODRICKE and myself , is suspected by us both to be subject to a small variation , but not sufficiently apparent , so as to affect materially these comparisons , and possibly it may be only the effect of some optical illusion ; for I have frequently remarked , that both in the twilight and moon-light , or when the air is in the least hazy , there is a greater difference between the brightness of many of the stars , than in a dark night and clear sky .
In the following journal of observations of ~ Antinoi , the Greek letters ~ , ~ , ~ , belong to Aquila , and ~ , ~ , to Antinous ; secondly , the magnitudes marked in column the third are by estimation , and can be of no further use than merely to give , at first sight , an idea of the star 's brightness ; and lastly , the lines distinguished by inverted commas , are extracts from Mr. GOODRICKE'S journal , whose friendly assistance I have often experienced , and was the more welcome on this occasion , because repeated attention and great exactness were requisite .
Dates .
MagniHours .
Journal of the comparative brightness of ~ Antinoi .
1783 .
tude .
Less than ~ Aquilae and brighter than ~ Serpentis ( ~ July 17 10~ 3 .
4 Aquilae and ~ Serpentis are equal ) weather hazy .
19 10~ 4 Rather brighter than ~ Aquilae and ~ Serpentis .
27 10~ 4 If any difference , less than ~ Aquilae .
N. B. These times are from recollection , and cannot 1784 err more than 11/ 2 hour .
Sept. 10 10~ 4 Less than ~ Aquilae and ~ Serpentis .
12 71/ 2 4 .
5 Much less than ~ , equal to ~ .
9 4 .
5 ` ` A little brighter than ~ , air clear .
' ' 71/ 2 13 3 .
4 Less than ~ , brighter than ~ , and much brighter than ~ .
91/ 2 8 3 .
4 ` ` Brighter than ~ and ~ .
' ' 15 84 Rather brighter than ~ , and much brighter than ~ .
91/ 2 18 4 .
5 ` ` Less than ~ and ~ .
' ' 11 19 71/ 2 4 .
5 Much less than ~ , and equal to ~ .
7 4 .
5 ` ` Less than ~ and ~ .
' ' 9 Brighter than ~ and ~ ; at 11 h. it seemed to have 20 8 3 .
4 increased .
71/ 2 Less than ~ , rather brighter than ~ ; thought it rather 23 3 .
4 8 less at 111/ 2 h. ; moon near .
28 9~ 3 .
4 Brighter than ~ ; moon-light .
29 30 9~ 3 .
4 If any difference , rather brighter than ~ .
9~ 3 .
4 ` ` Rather brighter than ~ .
' ' 7 Oct. 14 Less than ~ , brighter than ~ ; air clear , moon-light .
9 28 4 .
5 Equal to ~ , much less than ~ .
8 4 .
5 ` ` Less than ~ .
' ' 58 3 .
4 Between the brightness of ~ and ~ .
6 9~ 3 .
4 ` ` Brighter than ~ and ~ .
' ' 71/ 2 7 3 .
4 Rather brighter than ~ .
93/ 4 8~ 3 .
4 ` ` Much the same as yesterday .
' ' Brighter than ~ ; think it not less than ~ ; this obser8 8~ 4 vation doubtful , occasioned by intervening clouds .
8~ 4 .
5 ` ` Believe it less than ~ ; weather bad .
' ' 9 8~ 4 .
5 ` ` Certainly less than ~ ; weather bad .
' 10 11 4 .
5 ` ` Less than ~ ; rather a doubtful observation .
' ' 11 101/ 2 4 Rather less than ~ , and brighter than ~ .
15 10 4 Equal to ~ .
8~ 4 ` ` Rather brighter than ~ .
' ' 16 84 Less than ~ , brighter than ~ .
Dates .
MagniHours .
Journal continued .
1784 tude .
Oct. 16 61/ 2 4 .
5 ` ` Less than ~ and ~ .
' ' 7 17 4 .
5 Undoubtedly less than ~ .
8 18 8 4 .
5 Less than ~ , brighter than ~ .
61/ 2 4 .
5 ` ` Less than ~ .
' ' 19 71/ 2 3 .
4 Evidently brighter than ~ .
20 8~ 3 .
4 ` ` Much brighter than ~ .
' ' 22 8~ 3 .
4 ` ` Brighter than ~ .
' ' 23 61/ 2 4 Less than ~ .
84 ` ` Not so bright as ~ , brighter than ~ .
' ' 24 7 4 .
5 Equal to ~ , much less than ~ ; moon-light , air clear.~ 61/ 2 ` ` Less than ~ ; rather , though very little , brighter 4 .
5 7 than ~ .
' ' 25 63/ 4 4 .
5 Much less than ~ , equal to ~ , brighter than ~ .
26 61/ 2 4 Sometimes seemed rather less , but generally equal to ~ .
91/ 4 4 Equal , if not rather brighter than ~ .
At 61/ 2 rather less , at 81/ 2 nearly equal , and at 91/ 2 4 rather brighter than ~ .
' ' .
Remarkably bright , nearer ~ than ~ ; moon-light , 27 6 3 .
4 air clear .
61/ 2 3 .
4 ` ` Nearer to ~ than to ~ .
' ' 31 81/ 4 4 Seemed equal to ~ ; air not very clear .
Nov. 3 51/ 2 3 .
4 ` ` Rather brighter than ~ .
' ' 6 81/ 2 4 Evidently less than ~ .
79 4 .
5 Much less than ~ .
71/ 2 4 .
5 ` ` Less than ~ and ~ .
' ' 11 7 3 .
4 Brighter than ~ , much less than ~ .
12 61/ 2 3 .
4 Rather brighter than ~ , certainly equal .
81/ 2 3 .
4 ` ` Rather brighter than ~ and ~ .
' ' 51/ 2 13 4 .
5 Less than ~ , equal to ~ .
7 7 4 .
5 ` ` Less than ~ , and rather less than ~ .
' ' Evidently less than ~ , and rather brighter than ~ ; at 16 53/ 4 4 8 it seemed increased , and about 84 Between its least and full brightness .
7 4 .
5 ` ` Less than ~ , and something less than ~ .
' ' 53/ 4 17 3 .
4 Brighter than ~ .
71/ 4 19 64 If any difference , rather brighter than ~ ; clouds covered the moon : at 8 h. if any difference rather less 84 than ~ ; moon-light , and air not so clear as at 6 .
64 ` ` Rather brighter than ~ , brighter than ~ .
' ' 20 74 Rather less than ~ , brighter than ~ .
21 63/ 4 4 Less than ~ , rather brighter than ~ ; moon-light .
25 7 3 .
4 ` ` Brighter than ~ .
' ' Dec. 4 61/ 2 4 If any difference , less than ~ .
In order to obtain a point of comparison , for setting the periodical changes of ~ Antinoi , which I suppose to be constant , it is natural to fix upon that phasis , which can be determined with the greatest precision ; and this seems to be at the time when it is between its least and greatest brightness , as almost the whole increase of brightness is completed in less than 24 hours , though the perfect completion is performed only in 36 ~ hours ; thus having settled this necessary point , and found roughly the length of a single period , the computations , in order to obtain greater exactness , are as follows .
Time when ~ Antinoi was Intervals between Number of peLength of a between its least and greatest the observations .
riods in ditto .
single period .
brightness .
Hours .
Days .
Hours .
Days .
Hours .
1784 , Sept. 12 .
at 20 28 15 4 each of 7 33/ 4 Oct. 11 .
at 11 Sept. 12 .
at 20 36 05 Do 7 43/ 4 + Oct. 18 .
at 20 Sept. 12 .
at 20 43 46 Do 7 43/ 4 Oct. 26 .
at 00 Sept. 12 .
at 20 64 12 9 Do 74 Nov. 16 .
at 8 Sept. 19 .
at 20 904 Do 76 Oct. 18 .
at 20 Sept. 19 .
at 20 36 45 Do 7 51/ 2 + Oct. 26 .
at 00 Sept. 19 .
at 20 57 12 8 Do 7 41/ 2 Nov. 16 .
at 8 Oct. 11 .
at 11 35 21 5 Do 7 41/ 4 Nov. 16 .
at 8 Oct. 18 .
at 20 28 12 4 Do 73 Nov. 16 .
at 8 Length of a single period , on a mean , 74 30 Perhaps other astronomers may not exactly agree with me , in fixing the times as set down in column the first ; for my part , I determined them without paying any regard to the results , by taking a medium between the times when ~ Antinoi had rather passed its least brightness , being nearly equal to ~ Antinoi , and when it was a little , but undoubtedly , brighter than ~ Aquilae .
Though it does not appear , as I have already said , that any of the other phases can be settled with equal precision , different comparisons nevertheless may prove satisfactory towards corroborating the above ; I have therefore also deduced its period from the best and most distant observations , made when at its least brightness ; they are thus : 7 days 0 hours and 7 days 5 hours .
These results I reject , and retain the mean given by the first set , with which we may proceed on to gain a much greater exactness ; let one period be substracted from the observation of July 27th , 1783 , and it will appear , that ~ Antinoi had varied in brightness during the following four days , though at that time it did not strike me .
July 17th , decidedly brighter than ~ Aquilae .
18th , not observed .
1783 , 19th , rather brighter than ~ Aquilae .
20th ( answering to the 27th ) equal or rather less than ~ Aquilae .
As it is therefore evident , that on July 19th and 27th , 1783 , ~ Antinoi was decreasing in brightness , I shall compare those days observations to corresponding ones made in 1784 .
Hours .
1784 , Sept. 30 .
at 6 Oct. 7 .
at 16 Similar observations to that of 1783 Oct. 15 .
at 6 July 19th , at 10 h. ~ , ~ Antinoi being Oct. 22 .
at 12 rather brighter than ~ Aquilae .
Nov. 12 .
at 2 Nov. 19 .
at 00 Hours .
1784 , Sept. 30 .
at 18 Oct. 15 .
at 14 Similar Observations to that of 1783 , Oct. 22 .
at 19 July 27th , at 10 h. ~ , ~ Antinoi being Nov. 12 .
at 14 equal to or rather less than ~ Aquilae .
Nov. 19 .
at 14 In estimating the above times , I paid much attention to the observations of the preceding and following days ; however , a few hours more or less do not make a material difference .
The results of these comparisons are D. H. M. 74 391/ 2 74 441/ 2 74 531/ 3 74 542/ 3 74 32 74 261/ 2 74 32 74 421/ 2 74 43 74 26 74 211/ 2 On a mean 74 38 length of a single period .
As this approaches the most to the preceding result , it may be assumed as nearest the truth , provided the changes be uniformly periodical .
Hitherto the opinion of astronomers concerning the changes of Algol 's light seem to be very unsettled ; at least none are universally adopted , though various are the hypotheses to account for it ; such , as supposing the star of some other than a spherical form , or a large body revolving round it , or with several dark spots or small bright ones on its surface , also giving an inclination to its axis , &amp;c. ; though most of these conjectures with regard to Algol be attended with difficulties , some of them combined do , I think , account for the variation of ~ Antinoi .
Those persons who are accustomed to examine the stars attentively will not be surprised to find , that Mr. GOODRICKE and I do not always perfectly agree in our observations ; these small differences in the magnitudes of the stars are very difficult to be ascertained with the naked eye , which has often made me lament , we had not some contrivance for determining their relative brightness , and even I attempted several methods , but did not pursue them with sufficient attention and diligence to obtain any satisfactory results ; nevertheless I shall just mention them , as perhaps somebody else may overcome those difficulties , which to me appeared so very considerable .
1 .
In 1778 I had small pieces of fine glass stained with different shades , which being applied to the eye end of a telescope , I could easily find what degree of shade was requisite to efface stars of different brightness ; and thus I observed some of the stars and planets .
2 .
Diaphragms were attempted ; but , besides other difficulties , they did not efface stars of the first magnitude .
3 .
A method which pleased me much , and perhaps may not prove unsuccessful , is , by putting the stars out of the focus of a telescope till they become invisible ; this is performed by drawing the eye-tube of a refractor either in or out ; the point of focal distance being previously determined , the brighter the star the greater length of tube must be slid either in or out to efface it ; thus I was in hopes of determining their magni2 tudes , tudes , and for that purpose had in 1776 divisions engraved on the eye-tube of a refractor ; but found that its high magnifying powers prevented stars of the first and second magnitude becoming invisible .
Lastly , I am inclined to think the following method practicable , viz. to reflect in a telescope , by means of an illuminator , different degrees of light in a known proportion , so that stars of all magnitudes may be obliterated .
The changeable state of the weather will perhaps be thought a considerable obstacle to these contrivances , and to throw doubt on the observations ; but this may be sufficiently obviated by attending to small telescopic stars , which according to the clearness of the atmosphere are more or less distinctly seen .
I beg the favour of you , dear Sir , to present these observations to the Royal Society ; and believe me , with the greatest regard , &amp;c. York , Dec. 5 , 1784 .
EDWARD PIGOTT .

