IV .
A Supplement to the Third Part of the Paper on the Summation of infinite Series , in the Philosophical Transactions for the Year 1782 .
By the Rev. S. Vince , M. A. ; communicated by Nevil Maskelyne , D. D. F. R. S. and Astronomer Royal .
Read November 25 , 1784 .
THE reasoning in the third part of my paper on the Summation of infinite Series having been misunderstood , I have thought it proper to offer to the Royal Society the following explanation .
When I proposed , for example , to sum the series 1/ 2 ~/ 3 + 3/ 4 &amp;c. sine fine , I wanted to find some quantity which , by its expansion , would produce that series , and that quantity I called its sum ; not ( as I conceived must have been evident to every one ) in the common acceptance of that word , that the more terms we take , the more nearly we should approach to that quantity , and at last arrive nearer to it than by any assignable difference , for there manifestly can be no such quantity ; but as being a quantity from which the series must have been deduced by expansion , which quantity I found to be 1/ 2 + H. L. 2 .
If therefore in the solution of any problem , the conclusion , whose value I want , is expressed by the above series , and which arose from the necessity of expanding some quantity in the preceding part of the operation , surely no one can deny but that I may substitute for it 1/ 2 + H. L. 2 .
For whatever quantity it was , which by its expansion produced at first a series , the same reduction which , from that series , produced the series 1/ 2 2/ 3 + 3/ 4 &amp;c. must also have produced 1/ 2 + H. L. 2 .
from the quantity which was expanded .
This value of the series I obtained in the following manner .
I supposed the series 1/ 2 2/ 3 + 3/ 4 &amp;c. to be divided into two parts ; the first part to contain all the terms till we come to those where the numerators and denominators become both infinitely great , in which case every term afterwards may be supposed to be equal to unity : the second part , therefore , would necessarily be ( supposing the first part to terminate at an even number of terms ) 11+11+ &amp;c. sine fine .
The first part , by collecting two terms into one , becomes 1/ 2 .
3 1/ 4 .
5 1/ 6 .
7 &amp;c. which series , as it is continued till the terms become infinitely small , is equal to 1+ H. L. 2 .
The second part 11+1 &amp;c. has not , taken abstractedly of its origin , any determinate value ( as will be afterwards observed ) , but considered as part of the original series it has , for that series must have been deduced from the expansion of the binomial 1+x -1 , or 1/ 1 + x ; and hence , when x= 1 , 11+1 &amp;c. can in this case have come only from 1/ 1 + 1 , which , therefore , must be substituted for it ; consequently the two parts together give 1/ 2 + H. L. 2 .
Having thus explained the nature of the series which I proposed to sum , and the principle upon which the correction depends , I must beg leave to acknowledge my obligations to my very worthy and ingenious friend GEORGE ATWOOD , Esq. F.R.S. who first observed that the series 11+11+ &amp;c. has no determinate value in the abstract , as it may be produced by 1/ 1 +1+1+ &amp;c. whatever be the number of units in the denomiVOL .
LXXV .
F nator ; nator * ; and it may also be added , that the same series arises from 1+1+1+ &amp;c. / 1 +1+1+1+ &amp;c. , provided the number of units be greater in the denominator than in the numerator .
The correction will therefore be different in different circumstances , and will depend on the nature of the quantity which was at first expanded .
In the third part of my paper , I applied the correction to those cases where the original series arose from the expansion of a binomial , where the correction is in general as I there gave it ; but as I did not apply my method to any other series , I confess that it did not appear to me , that the correction would then be different , which it necessarily would had I extended my reasoning to other cases .
I shall therefore add one example to show the method of correction in other instances , where the value of the correction will be found to be different , according as we begin to collect at the first or second term .
Let the series be 2/ 1 3/ 2 + 5/ 4 6/ 5 + 8/ 7 &amp;c. sine fine , which came originally from 1/ 1 +x+ x2 ; now if we begin to collect at the first term , the series becomes 1/ 1 .
2+ 1/ 4 .
5+ &amp;c. and for the same reason as before , the correction , to be added , is 1/ 3 ; but 1/ 1 .
2+ 1/ 4 .
5+ &amp;c. = 4/ 3 of a circular arc ( A ) of 30~ to the radius ~3/ 2 ; hence the sum required = 4/ 3 A+ ~/ 3 .
If we begin to collect at the second term the series becomes 2 2/ 2 .
4 2/ 5 .
7 &amp;c. ; and the correction to be subtracted is 2/ 3 ; for the second part of the original series is now 1+11+1 &amp;c. which was produced by 1+ 1/ 1 +1+ 1 ; but *I have been since informed by Mr. WALES , F. R. S. that a pupil of his , Mr. POND , made the same observation .
2 2/ 2 .
4 2/ 5 .
7 &amp;c. =1+ 4/ 3 A ; therefore the sum required = 1/ 3 + 4/ 3 A as before .
In the same manner we may apply the correction in all other cases .
Although , therefore , the series 11+11+ &amp;c. or 1+11+1 &amp;c. have no determinate value in the abstract , yet the given series will fix its value by pointing out the quantity from which the series must have been originally produced .

