XXXIV .
A remarkable Case of numerous Births , with Observations .
By Maxwell Garthshore , M. D. F. R. S. and A. S. in a Letter to Sir Joseph Banks , Bart. P. R. S. Read June 21 , 1787 .
TOSIRJOSEPHBANK S , BAR T. P. R. S. SIR , St. Martin's-Lane .
May 28 , 1787 .
THE following very extraordinary case , communicated to me by Dr. BLANE , F. R. S. I take the liberty , at his desire , to transmit to you , with his letter to me , containing the proofs of its authenticity ; hoping that it will appear to you , as it did to us , worthy of being read at one of the meetings of the Royal Society , as a fact in natural history , which is equally uncommon , curious , and well vouched .
In order , however , to make its singularity more apparent , I have taken the liberty to subjoin some observations on births of this kind , with such well authenticated accounts of similar events as I have been able to procure , confining myself chiefly to those which have happened in our own country , where we are least likely to be deceived .
I have the honour to be , &amp;c. MAXWELL GARTHSHORE .
P. S. As one proof of its singularity , I , many months ago , employed various friends at Petersburg , Berlin , Vienna , Lyons , Paris , and Ghent , to collect for me well authenticated cases of this kind , and I have not as yet been able to procure any .
Copy of a letter from Dr. BLANE , Physician to his Majesty 's Navy and to St. Thomas 's Hospital , F. R. S. to Dr. Garthshore , Physician to the British Lying-in Hospital .
DEARSI R , Sackville-Street , June 22 , 1786 .
A few days ago , I received from the country an account of a woman who was delivered of five children at a birth in April last .
As your extensive experience and reading in this line of practice enable you to judge , how far this fact is rare or interesting , I submit it to you , whether it deserves to be communicated to the Royal Society .
Mr. HULL , the gentleman who sent me the case , is a very sensible and ingenious practitioner of physic at Blackburn , in Lancashire .
He attended the labour himself from beginning to end , and his character for fidelity and accuracy is well known to me , as he was formerly a pupil at the hospital to which I am physician ; so that no fact can be better authenticated .
He mentions also , that he has preserved all those five children in spirits ; and , if desired , he will send them for the inspection of the Society * .
I am , with great regard , &amp;c. GILBERT BLANE .
* They were accordingly sent ; and having been exhibited to the Society when this Paper was read , are now deposited in the Museum of Mr. JOHN HUNTER .
MARGARET WADDINGTON , aged twenty-one , a poor woman of the township of Lower Darwin , near Blackburn in Lancashire , formerly delivered of one child at the full term of pregnancy , conceived a second time about the beginning of December 1785 , and from that period became affected with the usual symptoms that attend breeding .
At the end of the first month , she became lame , complained of considerable pains in her loins , and the enlargement of her body was so remarkably rapid , that she was then judged by her neighbours to be almost half gone with child .
At the end of the second month she found herself somewhat larger , and her breeding complaints continued to increase .
When the third month was completed , she thought herself fully as large as she had formerly been in her ninth month , and to her former symptoms of nausea , vomiting , lameness , and pain of the loins , she had now added a distressing shortness of breath .
She continued to increase so rapidly in size , that she thought she could perceive herself growing larger every day , and she was under the frequent necessity of widening her cloaths .
When she reckoned herself eighteen weeks gone , she first perceived somewhat indistinctly the motion of a child .
By the 20th of April , 1786 , all her complaints were become much more distressing ; she had much tension and pain over all the abdomen , her vomiting was incessant , and she now could not make water but with the utmost difficulty .
The symptoms being palliated by Mr. LANCASTER , she advanced in her pregnancy to Monday the 24th of April , when being supposed to have arrived at the twentieth week , she was seized with labour pains .
These continued gradually to increase till the next day , about two in the afternoon ; at which time I was sent for , Mr. LANCASTER being absent , and she was soon delivered of a small , dead , but not putrid , female child .
The pains continuing , this was soon followed by a second less child ; to this very soon succeeded a third , larger than the first , which was alive ; to these a fourth soon followed , somewhat larger than the first , and very putrid ; last of all , there soon succeeded a fifth child , larger than any of the former , and born alive .
These five children were all females ; two were born alive ; and the whole operation was performed in the space of fifty minutes .
The first made its appearance at two in the afternoon , and the last at ten minutes before three .
Each child presented naturally , was preceded by a separate burst of water , and was delivered by the natural pains only .
In a short time after the birth of the last , the placenta was expelled by nature without any haemorrhage , was uncommonly large , and in some places beginning to be putrid .
It consisted of one uniform continued cake , and was not divided into distinct placentulae , the lobulated appearance being nearly equal all over .
Each funis was contained in a separate cell , within which each child had been lodged ; and it was easy to perceive , by the state of the funis , and that part of the placenta to which it adhered , in which sac the dead , and in which the living children had been contained .
I examined the septa of the cells very carefully , but could not divide them as usual into distinct laminae , nor determine which was chorion or which amnios .
I could not prevail on the good women to allow me to carry it home , to be more narrowly inspected ; and I submitted more readily to their prejudice for its being burned , as its very soft texture seemed to me to render it hardly capable to bear injection .
The two living children having survived their birth but a short time , I was allowed to carry them home ; and I have preserved the whole five in spirits , and have since weighed and measured them , and find their proportions to be as follows in Avoirdupois weight , inches and parts .
Oz .
Dr. Inches .
The 1st born dead 6 12 Length 9 The 2d putrid 46 81/ 4 The 3d alive 8 12 91/ 3 The 4th putrid 6 12 91/ 3 The 5th alive 9 91/ 3 The mother , in spite of the crowds with which her chamber was continually filled , continued to recover , and was able to be out of bed on the 27th and 28th , her third and fourth days ; but finding herself then weak , by my advice , kept her bed till the 11th of May .
when she went out of doors , and on the 21st walked to Blackburn , two miles distant .
This was the 27th day from her delivery , she having entirely recovered her strength without any accident .
It may not be improper to add , that the husband of this woman has been in an infirm state of health for three years past , and is now labouring under a confirmed phthisis .
I am , &amp;c. Signed , JOHN HULL .
Blackburn , Lancashire , June 9 , 1786 .
Observations on numerous Births .
THOUGH the females of the human species produce most commonly but one child at a birth ; and though their formation with only two breasts , and one nipple to each , renders it probable they were not originally intended to produce in general more than two ; yet , from what we know of the womb and its appendages , and what from the latest experiments we are led to conjecture as to the mode of conception , we cannot presume a priori to set limits to the fertility of nature , nor determine decisively what number of faetuses may be conceived and nourished to a certain period in the human uterus at the same time .
The present singular and well-attested case assures us , that five have certainly been born at once , and we have no title absolutely to reject all the testimonies of even more numerous births , or to say that , in some rare instances , this number has never been exceeded .
What has tended to render relations of this sort ridiculous , and to throw a degree of discredit on the whole , is the many marvellous , and evidently absurd and incredible histories , which not only the retailers of prodigies , but even the credulous writers of medical observations , have collected .
I need only refer those , who wish to amuse themselves with surprising relations of this kind , to the curious collections of SCHENKIUS , SCHURIGIUS , AMBROSE PAREY , and others .
But , in order to show how very uncommon births of this kind are , and how truly singular the case communicated by Mr. HULL to Dr. BLANE is , I take the liberty to subjoin a short view of the usual course of nature in this matter among our own country-women , where we are least likely to be deceived .
Though female fertility certainly varies according to the climate , situation , and manner of lite ; yet , I believe , it may be taken for a general rule , that where people live in the most simple and natural state , if they are the best nourished , and if they enjoy the firmest health and strength , they will there be the most fertile in healthy children ; but we have no data to determine that they will there have the greatest number at one birth .
At the British Lying-in Hospital , where we have had 18,300 delivered , the proportion of twins born has been only one in 91 births .
In the Westminster Dispensary , of 1897 women delivered , the proportion of twins has been once in 80 births ; but in the Dublin Lying-in Hospital , where above 21,000 have been delivered , they have had twins born once every sixty-second time .
The average of which is once in 78 births nearly , in these kingdoms .
The calculations made in Germany from great numbers , in various situations , state twins as happening in a varied proportion from once every sixty-fifth to once every seventieth time .
But in a more accurate and later calculation made at Paris , by M. TENON , Surgeon to the Salpetriere , we learn , that in 104,591 births the proportion of twins was only one in 96 , which is only a small degree less than we have calculated at the British Lying-in Hospital .
It would be easy to add other calculations , all differing from these and from one another , more or less ; but I hope these are sufficient to show that nature observes no certain rule in this matter ; and that even twins , the most usual variation , is not a very common occurrence .
When we advance to triplets , or three born at once , we find comparatively very few instances in this or any other country ; and though every one has heard of such events as now and then happening , yet very few have seen them .
In all those 18,300 women delivered at the British Lying-in Hospital , there has not been one such case .
In the London Lying-in Hospital , where , being instituted later , much fewer have been delivered , they have had two such recorded as prodigies .
In the Westminster Dispensary , in 1897 women delivered , there has been but one such event .
In the Dublin Hospital , in 21,000 births , they have had triplets born thrice , or once in 7000 times , but have never exceeded that proportion or number , born at one time .
In a pretty extensive practice of above thirty years , both in the county of Rutland and in London , I have attended but one labour where three children were born ; am personally acquainted but with one lady who , at Dumfries , in Scotland , after bearing twins twice , was delivered of three children at once ; and I was never acquainted with any one who produced a greater number .
Yet so much does this matter vary at Edinburgh , that Dr. HAMILTON , Professor of Midwifry , writes , he had seen triplets born there , five or six times in less than twenty-five years .
MAURICEAU , in a long life of very extensive practice at Paris , with opportunities of knowing most things extraordinary that happened in his time in France , tells us , he had seen triplets born but a few times ; had heard of four in that city but once , and mentions no greater number .
One circumstance which he relates is so far worthy of attention , as it accords with one somewhat similar subjoined to Mr. HULL'S case now read , viz. ` ` That the husband of one of those women who bore three children was by trade a painter , and had been , for two years preceding this birth , paralytic over one-half of his body , and yet had no reason to doubt the fidelity of his wife .
' ' These facts , as far as they are to be depended on , may show us , that the capacity of procreation in the male may remain under very infirm health ; and that we ought to judge with candour of such wives as are fruitful when living with very ailing husbands , and who produce healthy children in the eighth , or even ninth , month after their death ; as we can never say determinately under what degree of disease the male is totally incapable of procreation : more especially as we are very certain , that the female is not , when labouring under very desperate , and certainly fatal , diseases , provided the principal organs of generation be sound .
Nay , in cases of pulmonary phthisis , the life of the female seems to be protracted by pregnancy ; and I have attended a lady , who , after being pronounced irrecoverably hectic , lived long enough to be twice delivered naturally of healthy children at the full time .
But what particular circumstances of constitution , or state of health , can capacitate the male to become the father of more than one child at a birth , or how this could be effected , should it be wished , remains among those secrets of nature which our want of facts and observations renders us utterly incapable to speculate upon .
It seems probable , and these two observations , as well as SPALLANZANI'S , and other late experiments , would rather incline us to suppose , that these numerous births do depend most on the structure and state of the female organs ; but nothing , that I know of , has ever been discovered in this obscure matter .
The occurrence of four born at once we find to be much more uncommon ; and , I think , HALLER'S conjecture rather than calculation of its happening once in 20,000 births , very much under-rated , as it appears that once in 100,000 would be much nearer the truth .
Of this , however , we have several well authenticated cases which have happened in this island .
In the year 1674 , there was published in London a quarto pamphlet , entitled , ` ` The fruitful Wonder , or a strange Relation , from Kingston upon Thames , of a Woman who , on Thursday and Friday , the Fifth and Sixth Days of this Instant March , 1673-4 , was delivered of Four Children at one Birth , viz. Three Sons and One Daughter , all born alive , lusty Children , and perfect in every Part , which lived Twenty-four Hours , and then died , all much about the same Time , with several other Examples of numerous Births , from credible Historians , with the Physical and Astrological Reasons for the same .
By J. P. Student in Physic .
' ' Dr. PLOT , in his History of Staffordshire , p. 194 .
mentions ELEANOR , the wife of HENRY DIVEN , of Watlington , who was delivered of four children at a birth in the year 1675 .
Sir ROBERT SIBBALD , in his Scotia Illustrata , after mentioning a case of three born at once , adds , ` ` Imo in variis regni locis repertae sunt mulieres quae quatuor faetus uno partu ediderunt ; ' ' but makes no mention of more .
In the Gentleman 's Magazine , which is reckoned a pretty authentic record of the times , we have the following accounts of numerous births .
ANN BOYNTON , of Hensbridge , in Somersetshire , was this day , June 1 , 1736 , delivered of three daughters and one son ; one of the daughters died , the rest are likely to live .
The mother has been married but four years , and has had twice twins before , which completes the number of eight children at three births .
October 3 , 1743 , at Rate , in Berkshire , JOAN GALLOWAY was delivered of two boys and two girls , three of whom were alive .
In January , 1746 , the wife of PLUMER , a labouring man , at Mill-Wimley , near Hitchin , Hertfordshire , was delivered of three living boys and one dead .
August 22 , 1746 , the wife of WILLIAMS , of Coventrystreet , Piccadilly , was delivered of two boys and two girls , all likely to live .
June , 1752 , a woman in the parish of Tillicultrie , near Stirling , in Scotland , was delivered of four children , which were all immediately baptised , and all died at the same time next morning .
In September , 1757 , a poor woman , of Burton Ferry , Glamorganshire , was delivered of three boys and a girl .
Dr. HAMILTON before mentioned writes , that , not many years ago , a woman was delivered of four children , at Pennycuick , the seat of Sir JOHN CLARK , Bart. near Edinburgh , when she was advanced to the middle of her last month of pregnancy , and that some of these children lived two or three years .
He further says , that , five years ago , he attended a woman at Edinburgh , who , in the seventh month of her pregnancy , after a journey of thirty miles , was suddenly delivered of four children , all perfect and well grown for the time , of which one was born dead , and three alive ; but those three died next day .
He further adds , that these are the only cases of quadruplets , or any larger number , he had ever heard of , as born in Scotland , in his memory .
Though cases similar to the present of five children born at once , are still much more uncommon ; and though HALLER'S assertion of their not happening above once in a million of births , may be reckoned a very moderate calculation , yet we are not altogether without such instances in this country .
From the Gentleman 's Magazine we learn , that on the 5th of October , 1736 , a woman at a milk-cellar , in the Strand , was delivered of three boys and two girls at one birth ; and that in March , 1739 , at Wells , in Somersetshire , a woman was delivered of four sons and a daughter , all alive , all christened , and all then seeming likely to live .
In the Commercium Literarium Norimbergense for the year 1731 , we have two such cases ; one happening in Upper Saxony , the other near Prague , in Bohemia ; in each of which five children were born and christened , all of whom were arrived to that equal degree of maturity , which rendered it probable , they were all conceived about the same time .
I learned from two foreign Professors , when in London last winter , that they had each heard of a case of five children born near Paris , and near Ghent in Flanders ; but the particulars not being sent as promised , I presume they may have been misinformed .
When we advance farther we get into the region of tradition and improbability ; and it would ill become me to trouble a Society , whose professed object is truth and science , with the numerous and wounderful relations which many grave and learned authors have recorded as facts they themselves believed ; yet I still think we have no authority to reject absolutely every relation of this kind , when AMBROSE PAREY , a very honest though credulous man , tells , that in his time , in the parish of Sceaux , near Chambellay between Sarte and Maine , the mother of the then living lord of the noble house of MALDEMEURE had , in the first year of her marriage , brought forth twins , in the second triplets , in the third four , in the fourth five , and in the fifth year six children at one birth , of which labour she died ; and when he adds , that of these last six one is yet alive , and is now Lord of Maldemeure , how can we disbelieve this circumstance ?
This story may very possibly be inaccurately stated , yet the whole cannot be a fiction , as it was published among the very people , and in the age when it happened , and never has been since contradicted so far as we know .
Though the wonderful regularity of the progress gives an appearance of fable to the whole , yet we must believe the thing to be possible : and that this then existing lord might be the only one of the six who lived long enough to be born at the full time , in a mature state ; the whole , or most of the other five , as we have sometimes seen in cases of twins , having been born as dead abortions , which had never arrived to a bulk sufficient to interfere with his growth .
I leave the learned to pay what degree of credit they please to the wonderful relations we read of the extreme fertility of the women of Egypt , Arabia , and other warm countries , as recorded by ARISTOTLE , by PLINY , and by ALBUCASIS , where three , four , five , and six children are said to have been frequently born at once , and the greatest part of these reared to maturity ; and will only say , that though a late traveller M. SAVARY gives ample testimony of the extreme general fertility of Egypt in all vegetable and animal productions , and particularly ticularly of its abundant population , he mentions nothing of the numerous births recorded by the ancient naturalists and historians .
Of still more fruitful births I will pass over a number of instances which I could adduce from JOHANNES RHODIUS , LUCAS SCHROECKIUS , CASPAR BAUHIN , JOHANNES HELVIGIUS , BIANCHI , and others , and finish with one case more , recorded by PETRUS BORELLI in his Second Century of Observations , published at Paris in the year 1656 ; a collection indeed filled with many wonderful stories , though by a man of equal integrity and ingenuity : he tells us , that in the year 1650 , just five years before , the lady of the then present Lord DARRE produced at one birth eight perfect children , which he owns was a very unusual event in that country .
I think it totally unnecessary to pursue this enquiry farther ; but must observe , that the present is the only case I have found , where the children were all females ; that the males have in all the other cases been at least equal , and generally the most numerous ; that in many of them , at least a part was dead born ; and that most commonly the rest died in a short time .
It is thence clear , that those numerous births are certainly unfavourable to population , as very few indeed of those children can be carried to near the full term of pregnancy , and fewer still to that degree of strength that admits of their being reared , where more than two are born at one time .
As from Mr. JOHN HUNTER'S very curious Experiments and Observations , read lately to this Society , on the Procreation of Swine , we are led to believe , that a certain determined number of ova , capable of receiving male impregnation , are originally formed in each ovarium ; and which number , when exhausted , the female constitution has no power to renew ; if this be the true account of the oeconomy of nature in this particular , which has every appearance of probability , those numerous births must occasion a very fruitless profusion and waste of the human race , and become every way detrimental to its increase .
From the united testimony of all the foregoing cases , it is undeniably clear , that the females of the human species , though most commonly uniparous , are , in certain circumstances to us unknown , every now and then capable of very far exceeding their usual number ; and I must again repeat , that it does not appear that we can set any bounds to the powers of nature in that respect ; or pretend , as some have done , with certainty to say , what may be the utmost limits of human

