XXXIII .
Account of an Observation of the Right Ascension and Declination of Mercury out of the Meridian , near his greatest Elongation , Sept. 1786 , made by Mr. John Smeaton , F. R. S. with an Equatorial Micrometer , of his own Invention and Workmanship ; accompanied with an Investigation of a Method of allowing for Refraction in such Kind of Observations ; communicated to the Rev. Nevil Maskelyne , D. D. F. R. S. and Astronomer Royal , and by him to the Royal Society .
Read June 7 , 1787 .
M. DE LA LAND having announced to some of my astronomical friends the utility of accurate observations of Mercury , at his two elongations the last year , in August and September ; I tried to get observations of that planet in crossing the meridian , for some days before and after the greatest elongation in August ; and though the state of the atmosphere about that time was not very favourable to the purpose , yet there was one day that I thought unexceptionable , but could not perceive the least appearance of Mercury ; at which I was the rather surprised , as I had formerly seen that planet in the like situation , with the same instrument , with perfect perspicuity* : and as I did not hear of any one else having succeeded in * The instrument mentioned is a transit , made by myself in the year 1768 ; at which time achromatic object-glasses not having been , so far as I knew , applied to astronomical instruments by others , but having found the good effects thereof in this observation , I thought it might be very possible for the same disappointment again to happen , with respect to the approaching elongation in September .
I judged , therefore , that it might be of some utility to astronomy , if , by any means , a good observation of Mercury could be got ; and also , that it would be a proper subject whereon to make trial of an instrument for such purposes , the idea of which I had conceived , and begun to construct , above forty years before ; but which , from various avocations , I did not perfect to my satisfaction till the year 1770* : since which time it has lain by , in hopes that something might happen , by which a full and effectual trial might be made thereof .
This instrument was orginally intended as an improvement of the common wire micrometer , for the purposes of taking differences of right ascension and declination , in a more commodious and effectual manner than could be done in the method then practised of using that instrument ~ ; and at the same for other purposes , I resolved to use a double achromatic object-glass , made by Mr. DOLLOND ; which being of equal aperture with the simple object-glass , then in the transit of the Royal Observatory , this telescope I therefore esteemed to be of nearly equal validity , as to quantity of light , with that at Greenwich , but reduced to the more commodious length of three feet six inches .
* Some observations made therewith , after it was completed , I transmitted to my friend Mr. AUBERT ; the consistency of which induced him to procure a similar instrument to be made for cometary and such kind of observations as cannot be commodiously made in the meridian .
Of this instrument the Rev. Mr. WOLLASTON has made honourable mention in Phil. Trans. Vol. LXXV .
for 1785 , p. 348 .
~ The common wire micrometer , as used by Dr. BRADLEY , and described from a paper of the Doctor 's hand-writing , is given by Dr. MASKELYNE in the Philosophical Transactions , Vol. LXII .
for the year 1772 ; and in addition to to which I must beg leave to observe , that the telescopes then in use for the same time more effectually to answer the purpose of GRAHAM'S astronomical sector , which was contrived by him ( as Dr. SMITH informs us ) to supply the deficiencies of the micrometer then in use* .
The most necessary and fundamental improvements seemed to be ; first , that of rendering the micrometer telescope manageable upon an equatorial motion ; and , secondly , the contrivance of a stand of such solidity and stedfastness that the telescope might preserve the position in which it was placed , for a length of time : for it occurred to me , that if the telescope could be maintained at rest ; or in a degree of stability superior to that of the astronomical sector ; then the necessity of taking in a greater compass in declination than could be commodiously given to the field of a telescope would be the less necessary : for , instead of confining the object to a comparison with a star not differing more than a few minutes of time , or at most a quarter of an hour in right ascension , those comparisons could be extended to an hour or two , or even on occasion to three or four hours ; there being scarcely any part of the heavens so devoid of stars , of a suitable magnitude for these observations , but that a proper one may be found within that compass in right ascension , provided there is allowed micrometer were from ten to fifteen feet long , made with wooden tubes , supported at each end upon two wooden supports , by which the telescope could be managed in altitude and azimuth ; but not to follow a celestial object in its proper motion on one center : which apparatus , I believe , is still remaining in the Royal Observatory .
* This instrument is described in SMITH'S Optics , Vol. II .
p. 350 .
; and the original one , made by Mr. GRAHAM , was , at his death , placed in the Royal Observatory , and is mounted upon a three-legged stand of wood .
the difference of a degree , either north or south of the object , in declination* .
Considering , however , that the approaching elongation would be in the morning ; and that the best chance of seeing Mercury with this instrument would be some time in the twilight , between Mercury 's rising and the rising of the Sun ; yet , on supposition of catching the planet in his passage over the wires , there would be no chance of seeing any star pass over the field , wherewith to compare him , till the following evening , which being at least fourteen hours , the certain position of the telescope for so great a length of time was almost more than I could reasonably hope for .
To judge how far I might form an expectation , by way of a previous trial , I compared Saturn with ~ Capricorni ~ , and found the return * The field of the telescope of Mr. AUBERT'S instrument is two degrees ; but that of the original , wherewith this observation was made , is 1~ 17~ : to gain which , the eye-glass being immovable ( and achromatic to prevent the indistinctness that would otherwise have taken place near the border ) the magnifying power was obliged to be considerably reduced , in respect of what has been usual for micrometers , that is , so as not to exceed 20 times : in consequence , there is , therefore , no need for so long a telescope , this being but 34 2/ 3 inches focal length of object-glass ; but being a double achromatic , made by the late Mr. JOHN DOLLOND , it is capable of as great an aperture as could be given to the simple object-glasses of twelve or fifteen feet telescopes , that were then generally given to micrometers ; but the pencil of light being greatest in this , is attended with this advantage , that the small stars can be seen very distinct and in great abundance , like the modern night-glasses : and there is in reality no need of great magnifying powers for the present purpose ; for the place of the wire being viewed by an eye-glass , of about 1 3/ 4 inches focus , its place may be distinguished to less than a 2300th part of an inch , which , on the radius of 34 2/ 3 inches , is scarce 2~1/ 2 of a degree ; and which , as I apprehend , is nearer the truth than can reasonably be expected from instruments out of the meridian .
~ According to this observation ~ preceded ~~ the 2d of Sept. at 9 h. 15~ P.M. mean time by 30~ 9~.7 MT , and with greater declination south than ~ by 41~ 23~ .
of the star to the same place two evenings afterwards , both in right ascension and declination , was so near , that I concluded I might very well expect a good observation of Mercury , in case I could get a sight of him , though the stars wherewith he was to be compared lay at the distance of the following evening at the soonest .
The micrometer is furnished with five horary wires , denominated in their order a , A , B , C , D ( B being the middle horary wire ) , and the two declination wires are denominated A and B , each moveable by a separate and independent micrometer-screw , from the outside of the field to the center , and a little beyond it ; so that each wire can be moved into the place of the other when at or near the center* .
The morning of the 23d of September , about a quarter past five o'clock , the air being clear and perfectly serene , it being then about an hour after Mercury 's rising , and near threequarters of an hour before the rising of the sun , I very readily found Mercury with the telescope , and when found could easily see him with an opera glass ; and Mercury being then in a state of very little alteration of declination , I adjusted one of the declination wires to his apparent run , by making him traverse the whole field .
The observations were then taken as * In Dr. BRADLEY'S Paper it is said , that before the late alterations , both the declination wires were made moveable ; and that it was an improvement to make one of them fixed , and one only moveable .
But however they might be immediately preceding the Doctor 's time , I believe , the original micrometers by Mr. TOWNLEY were with one fixed and one moveable declination wire , as I have seen one in this form among the remaining apparatus of Mr. ABRAHAM SHARPE .
In an instrument , however , fitted up for the purposes of the equatorial micrometer , I believe , it will be found most convenient to have both those wires moveable ; as by this means they not only are enabled to slide into each other 's place , but every part of the frame of the instrument remains fixed during the whole of the observation , the two slides carrying these two wires excepted .
in the first table ; and in the evening I was lucky enough t get those of ~ Ceti and o Tauri , intending to repeat the whole the next morning and evening .
The next morning prove cloudy , and so continued , that I saw the planet no more ; but in the evening of the 26th , I found the stars come again so near the same declination , that I was encouraged to continu the observation to see what change would happen .
It the came on bad rainy weather till the 30th , when I again re peated the observation , and found the stars to come so near i declination that I was fully satisfied of the stability of th instrument , so far at least as could regard twenty-four hours but as I was then appointed to go a journey , and coul have no other use for it , I locked the door of the Ob servatory , leaving the instrument in its position , that might see what change would happen by the time of my return and was quite astonished to find , on the 13th of October , that i had remained in a manner unmoved ; for it had suffered n more apparent alteration than what might occur by the error of observing , and alterations of the clocks and transit .
It must , however , be remarked , that , besides that in th construction of the instrument every thing was contrive that appeared likely to give it firmness , it was rested upon the frustum of an hexagonal pyramid of stone , in the founding whereof great care was taken as to its solidity , and was de tached from the floor for supporting the observer .
This Observatory at Austhorpe I esteem in the latitude o 53~ 47~ 54~ N. and 5~ 50~ of time W. from Greenwich .
Table I. Observations of Mercury at his elongation Sept. 1786 , with an Equatorial Micrometer .
Time as Time reReduced to Parts of MicroDay , object , and Mean of taken by duced to the middle the mimeter wires .
the wires .
the clock .
min. &amp; sec. wire .
crom .
reduc .
Hour .
Sept. 23 .
AM .
M. q. bea .
' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' Rev. Pts. Rev. Pts. Merc. to wire a5 24 35 24 47.5 26 34.8 A 25 3 141/ 2 25 52.3 26 34.8 Middle wire B 26 2 91/ 2 26 34.7 26 34.7 26 34 7B 28 85 ~ 0.74 N. B. The telescope 's center C 27 16 27 18 26 34.7 was pointed to horary circle D 28 1 15 28 22.5 26 34.6 VI .
34 1/ 2 Decl. N. 7~ ~ .
PM .
~ Ceti to B9 15 1 27 15 28.5 15 28.5 15 28.4 C 16 0 23 16 11.5 15 28.3 ~ Tauri to B 40 1 25 40 27.5 40 27.5 40 27.4 B 8.39 N 19.72 C 41 0 21 41 10.5 40 27.3 Sept. 26 .
~ Ceti to a922 13 2 36.5 4 23.5 A32 23 3 41.5 4 23.9 4 23.8 B 16.97 N 11.14 C50 141/ 2 5 7.3 4 24.1 ~ Tauri to A 28 2 21 28 40.5 29 22.9 B 29 1 16 29 23 29 23 29 23 B 8.47 N 19.64 Sept. 30 .
~ Ceti to a8 47 0 31/ 2 47 1.8 48 48.8 A 48 0 13 48 6.5 48 48.9 B 48 38 48 49 48 49 48 49 B 16.97 N 11.14 C 49 2 41/ 2 49 32.3 48 49.1 ~ Tauri to A9 13 0 11 13 5.5 13 47.9 B 13 36 13 48 13 48 13 48.1 B 8.48 N 19.63 C 14 23 14 31.5 13 48.3 ~ Orionis to a 11 41 3 12 41 51 43 38 A 42 3 201/ 2 42 55.3 43 37.7 B 43 2 17 43 38.5 43 38.5 43 37.9 A 15.07 S 15.77 C 44 1 12 44 21 43 37.8 D 45 1 201/ 2 45 25.3 43 37.7 Oct. 13 .
~ Ceti to A7 58 30 58 45 59 27.4 B 59 1 251/ 2 59 27.7 59 27.7 59 27.5 B 16.97 N 11.14 C800 211/ 2 0 10.7 59 27.5 ~ Tauri to C 25 0 20 25 10 24 26.8 24 26.8 B 8.50 N 19.61 ~ Orionis to a 10 52 2 01/ 2 52 30.2 54 17.2 A 53 29 53 34.5 54 16.9 B 54 1 41/ 2 54 17.2 54 17.2 54 17.1 A 15.07 S 15.77 C 55 0 01/ 2 55 0.2 54 17 D 56 0 10 56 5 54 17.4 Table II .
For reducing the horary wires of the Equatorial Micrometer to that of the middle , when taken in mean solar time .
Equatorial Declination object .
7~ 48~ Wires .
~s run * 's run ~s run * 's run ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' The 1st wire precedes the middle , add a1 46.2 1 46 1 47.3 1 47 2d A0 42.1 0 42 0 42.5 0 42.4 3d , or middle wire B 4th is subsequent to the middle , subtract C0 42.9 0 42.8 0 43.3 0 43.2 5th D1 46.8 1 46.6 1 47.9 1 47.6 123456 Table III .
Containing the observations of Tab. I. reduced so as to show the correct differences of right ascension and declination between Mercury and the stars wherewith he was compared .
Passage Correction ~ of Pts. of micr .
Correct mean Intervals micromereduced= over mid .
to reduce time of the of mean time ter ~ decline .
from 1786 .
hor. wire the clock the telethe teleobservation .
of different Date and object .
by journ .
to mean scope 's scope 's cenobservations .
center .
ter .
Hour .
clock .
time .
Sept. 23 .
AM h. Rev. Pts. ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ~ to the mid .
wire 5 26 34.7 3 59.8 5 22 34.9 S 0.74 S18 PM h. ' ' ' ~ Ceti to mid .
wire 9 15 28.4 4 0.1 9 11 28.3 15 48 53.4 ~ Tauri to the same 9 40 27.4 4 0.1 9 36 27.3 0 24 59 N 19.72 N 30 26 Sept. 26 .
~ Ceti to mid .
wire 94 23.8 4 43.2 8 59 40.6 N 11.14 N 17 11 ~ Tauri to the same 9 29 23 4 43.2 9 24 39.8 0 24 59.2 N 19.64 N 30 18 Sept 30 .
~ Ceti to mid .
wire 8 48 49 4 50.9 8 43 58.1 N 11.14 N 17 11 ~ Tauri to the same 9 13 48.1 4 50.9 98 57.2 0 24 59.1 N 19.63 N 30 17 ~ Orion.to the same 11 43 37.9 4 50.8 11 38 47.1 2 29 49.9 S 15.77 S 24 20 Oct. 13 .
~ Ceti to mid .
wire 7 59 27.5 6 36.4 7 52 51.1 N 11.14 N 17 11 ~ Tauri to the same 8 24 26.8 6 36.8 8 17 50 0 24 58.9 N 19.61 N 30 15 ~ Orion.to the same 10 54 17.1 6 37 10 47 40.1 2 29 50.1 S 15.77 S 24 20 12345678 Table IV .
Deviations in the direction of the axis of the telescope of the Equatorial Micrometer in right ascension and declination in 20 days , from the 23d of September to the 13th of October , both inclusive .
4 days from 13 days from 17 days from Objects observed .
3 days from the the 26th to 7 days from the the 30th to the 26th to 20 days from the 23d to 26th .
30th .
23d to 30th 13th .
13th 23d to 13th .
' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' R. Ascension exact 0 too late 1.1 too late 1.1 too soon 0.3 too late 0.8 too late 0.8 ~ Ceti Declination not taken the 23d exact 0 .
not taken the 23d exact 0 .
exact 0 .
not taken the 23d R. Ascension too late 0.2 too late 1.0 too late 1.2 too soon 0.5 too late 0.5 too late 0.7 ~ Tauri Declination South 8 .
South 1 .
South 9 .
South 2 .
South 3 .
South 11 .
R. Ascension too soon 0.3 ~ Orionis Declination exact 0 .
N. B. The right ascension is expressed in the integer and decimal parts of a second of time .
The declination is expressed in seconds of a degree .
Explanation of the less obvious parts of the Tables of the Observation of Mercury near his Elongation , Sept. 1786 .
The third column of Tab. I contains the times of observation as they were taken down from the half-second journeyman clock , in minutes , quarters , and beats , according to the following method ; which was , by taking up the beat when the second hand came to 15 , 30 , 45 , or 60 , and then counting 30 beats repeatedly till the arrival of the object at the middle of the wire it was approaching ; after its arrival , the beats ( or interval between two beats ) being retained in memory , and the eye cast upon the dial-plate , it was easily seen whether it was so many beats more than the quarter , the half , three-quarters , or the whole minute , and was set down accordingly .
Those reduced to minutes , seconds , and tenths of seconds , by allowing.2 or.3 for the quarter second,.5 the half , and.7 or.8 for the threequarters of a second , are contained in the fourth column .
The reduction of the fourth column to the fifth was by means of the auxiliary Tab. II .
; and Mercury being then nearly stationary respecting the sun , the sun 's run was used for the planet instead of that of a star .
The mean of each set of observations of the fifth column is carried into the sixth .
The seventh column contains the parts of the micrometer as they were read off ; to render which intelligible , it is to be noted , that the declination wire A travels from the upper side of the field of view of the telescope towards the center , and somewhat beyond it : and upon it are taken all the objects that pass the field of view on the upper side , answerable ( by inversion of the object ) to the southern half of the field : and in like manner those that pass the field of view on the lower half are taken upon the wire B , and for the same reason denote a declination north .
The scale of the micrometers of each wire begins from a point assumed somewhat without the field , and the number increases from thence towards the center of the field , and continues beyond it ; the integral parts are the turns of the screw , and the centesimal the divisions of the index plate , being divided into 100 parts .
The point of the scale , answerable to the center of the field of view , having been found by observations on each scale respectively ; when the wire A ( Australis ) stands at 30.84 , it is in the center of the field ; and when the wire B ( Borealis ) is at 28.11 , it also cuts the same center .
Hence the parts of the micrometer being respectively taken from those two numbers ( which may therefore be called constant numbers ) the remainder will be the distance of each respective wire from the center in parts of the micrometer .
Thus , in the observation of o Tauri upon the 23d , the parts are B 8.39 ; this taken from 28.11 , leaves N 19.72 , which are placed in col .
8 .
as the distance , in parts of the micrometer , that o Tauri passed north of the center of the field of view , or axis of the telescope .
In like manner , in the observation of Mercury on the 23d , the parts are B 28.85 ; but this being greater than the constant number 28.11 , the excess will be.74 parts ; which being the parts reaching beyond the center , they will be so much south of it , and are set down therefore in col .
8 .
S 0.74 : and in this manner the declinations of the rest are made out , from their respective numbers of parts of the micrometer , and set down in col .
8 .
The numbers of the sixth column of Tab. I. are transferred to the third column of Tab. III .
; and the declinations set down in parts of the micrometer , Tab. I. col .
8 .
are transferred to col .
7 .
of Tab. III .
Col. 4 .
of this table contains the corrections of the times deduced from the journeyman clock ( as per col .
3 .
) to reduce it to mean time ; which corrections are made out from the general account of the goings of the transit clock , corrected by transits of the sun , taken the 22d , 23d , 27th , and 30th of September , and the 12th , 13th , and 14th of October * .
The journeyman clock was regularly compared at nights and mornings with the transit clock ; and generally immediately after the observation .
The meridian and rotative observatories in which the clocks respectively were , are at the distance of 53 yards E. and W. ; the comparisons were made by a seconds stop watch ~ .
The numbers of the fourth column being properly applied to those of the third produce the fifth ; and which , with the sixth column , will be sufficiently explained by their titles .
The parts of the micrometer in the seventh column , being reduced into minutes and seconds , are contained in col .
8 .
and respectively show the minutes and seconds at which each object passed to the north or south of the center of the telescope .
The value of the parts of the micrometer were obtained by previous observations , from whence the following rule was deduced : the numbers of turns and centesimal parts being considered as integral , and divided by 1.08 , the quotient will be the number of seconds .
Thus , in the observation of o Tauri * The transit clock was made by HINDLEY , and has a pendulum rod of cedar wood .
~ The journeyman clock was generally set to the transit clock on Sunday mornings ; and when from home the former was suffered to go down .
Tho journeyman will generally agree with the transit clock to 2~ in 24 hours ; but during the period of these observations , went remarkably well .
upon the 23d , the parts 1972 , divided by 1.08 , gives 1826~ = 30~ 26~ ; and the parts of mercury.74 , divided by 1.08 = 68~ = 1~ 8~ .
Now the telescope being fixed to one point of the heavens during the whole period of these observations , without any motion of any of the parts , the screws commanding the declination wires A and B excepted , we are enabled to judge of its steadiness to this point by the following remarks .
If it varied in declination , this would be shown by the passage of the same star at a different distance from the center of the telescope at different revolutions ; and if it varied in right ascension , it would be shown by its not passing the horary wires at the due time , according to the acceleration of the stars upon the mean time of the sun .
Both the right ascension and declination may be varied by differences of refraction of the air at the same altitude ; and the right ascension is further liable to be apparently varied , by the errors of the transit instrument , the transit clock , the transferring of its time to the journeyman clock , the intermediate errors of the same , and of the observation itself ; and as there passed an interval of almost 16 hours betwixt the passage of Mercury over the field of view of the telescope and that of ~ Ceti , which was the nearest star wherewith a comparison could be made , it will be a satisfaction to see , as before intimated , what variations arose in still greater intervals of time .
In right ascension .
h. ' ' ' Thus ~ Ceti upon Sept. 23 .
passed the horary wires at 9 11 28.3 and 26 .
8 59 40.6 .
~ Ceti therefore came sooner in three days by 11 47.7 but ought to accelerate on mean time 11 47.7 therefore came after three days exactly to the time .
h. ' ' ' Again , 0 Tauri upon Sept. 23 .
passed the horary wires at 9 36 27.3 and 26 .
9 24 39.8 0 Tauri therefore came sooner after three days by 11 47.5 ought to accelerare on mean time 11 47.7 therefore came too late in three days by -.2 In declination .
' ' ' 0 Tauri upon Sept. 23 .
passed north of telescope 's center 30 26 26 .
30 18 therefore passed less north , or more south , than before by 8 In like manner every comparison that Tab. III .
affords is particularly set down in Tab. IV .
which containing thirteen comparisons in right ascension and ten in declination , the greatest deviation in right ascension is 1~.2 , and 11~ of a degree in declination .
This supposes every error before mentioned to reside in the instrument , and every other instrument and observation , which were concerned in the result , to be perfect ; which , from the smallness of the total errors , seems to indicate a degree of steadiness in the instrument unexperienced or unnoticed before .
Deduction of the position of Mercury from the preceding observations as set down in Tab. III .
In right ascension from col .
6 .
' ' ' ~ Tauri followed ~ Ceti Sept. 23 .
24 59 26 .
24 59.2 30 .
24 59.1 Oct. 13 .
24 58.7 at a mean of the four 24 59 h. ' ' ' ~ Orionis followed 0 Tauri Sept. 30 .
2 29 49.9 Oct. 13 .
2 29 50.1 at a mean 2 29 50 Now Mercury preceded ~ Ceti Sept. 23 .
15 48 53.4 ~ Ceti preceded 0 Tauri by mean of four 24 59 0 Tauri preceded ~ Orionis by mean of two 2 29 50 Mercury therefore preceded ~ Orionis by 18 43 42.4 In declination from col .
8 .
' ' ' Sept. 23 .
A.M. Mercury passed the middle horary wire , south of its center 18 Same evening 0 Tauri passed the middle horary wire , north of it 30 26 Therefore Mercury passed the middle horary wire more S. than 0 Tauri by 31 34 ' ' ' ' ' ' But Sept. 26 .
~ Ceti passed N. of center 17 11 Diff. 13 7 0 Tauri 30 18 30 .
~ Ceti 17 11 13 6 0 Tauri 30 17 Oct. 13 .
~ Ceti 17 11 13 4 0 Tauri 30 15 From the smallness of the above differences we may infer , that very little uncertainty in declination had attended the passage of 0 Tauri upon Sept 23 .
' ' ' ' ' ' Upon Sept. 30 .
0 Tauri passed N 30 17 Sum 54 37 ~ Orionis S 24 20 Upon Oct. 13 .
0 Tauri passed N 30 15 54 35 ~ Orionis S 24 20 ' ' ' ~ Orionis then at a mean passed more south than 0 Tauri 54 30 Merc. therefore on the 23d passed with more N. declination than ~ Orionis 23 2 Investigation of the effects of refraction .
The preceding deductions and remarks show the consistency of the observations with themselves ; yet , from the position of the telescope , it being only elevated 11~1/ 2 above the horizon * , it is necessary to examine how far the deductions above specified were capable of being affected by refraction .
And in this respect it will appear , that if it be supposed , there is no difference in the quantity of refraction of such objects as appear within the limits of the field of view of this instrument ( which is 1~ 17~ ) , then their relative positions to each other will not be affected thereby : for if in fig. 1 .
( Tab. XIII .
) we suppose the circle VHRO to represent the boundary of the field of view , HO being an horizontal and VR a vertical line , each passing through the center of the field at L ; and if PLP denotes a part of a parallel of declination , then BLX perpendicular thereto , will be a part of an horary circle , both passing through the same center .
Now let d* be the apparent path of a star , supposing it unaffected by refraction till it comes to the vertical line at * , and there to be lifted up by refraction in the said vertical to L. Let e+ denote another star , also unaffected by refraction , to pass along the different parallel of declination e+ till it comes to + ; then , if it be supposed that the two stars are both situated in the same horary circle , if at the point + refraction takes place , and by hypothesis this is lifted up equally with the other , in the perpendicular +l , then the line +* being drawn through the places of the two stars , will be cotemporary and parallel to LX ; and the figure l+ *L being evidently a rhomboids , the two stars , so altered by * This will readily be deduced by inspection of the celestial globe .
refraction , will arrive together at the horary circle LX at the same time , and with the same difference of declination , as if no refraction had taken place .
It is therefore only the difference of refraction which takes place in objects at different heights in the same field , that can alter their relative situations : however , it appears necessary to examine what this may amount to .
Let the letters in fig. 2 .
denote the same things as before ; to which we will add , that a , A , B , C , D , denote the parallel horary wires of the micrometer , and AA , BB , the declination wires , denoted A and B in the tables : now from the celestial globe we shall also readily obtain the horary angle VLP = 54~1/ 2 = Lbc .
Let now an object pass along the wire AA from the horizontal line at d to the vertical line at b ; in this it will pass through a difference of refraction , according as it gets more and more elevated above the horizontal line HO ; and let the elevation Lb be half a degree or 30 minutes : then , according to Dr. BRADLEY'S Table of Refraction * , the difference of refraction betwixt the 78th and 79th degrees of zenith distance is 23~.6 , half of which 11~.8 , may be esteemed the difference of refraction for a difference of half a degree of altitude at 78~1/ 2 zenith distance , or of 11~1/ 2 altitude : the object , therefore , in passing from the horizontal line at d to the vertical line at b passes through every difference of refraction from o ' ' to 11~.8 ; and the question is , how much it is at a medium , that is , when it arrives at the middle wire at the point c ?
From this point let fall the perpendicular ce .
Now , the proportion of the sides of the triangle dbL being given from construction , they may be taken off by a scale , viz. * Inserted in Dr. MASKELYNE'S Observations , Vol. I. p. 15 .
Suppose Lb=174 db=299 dL=242 and assuming the side Lb=30 the other sides by proportion db=51.6 as above will be dL=41.7 The triangles Lbc and dce are similar to dbL ; therefore say , as db=51.6 : dL=41.7 : : Lb=30 : Lc=24 ; and as Lb= 30 : Lc=24 : : dL=41.7 : dc=33.5 ; and again , as db= 51.6 : dc=33.5 : : Lb=30 : ce=19.5 : but this will affect the declination , only in proportion of the line of drawn parallel to LX ; and it will affect the right ascension according to the line fc : but the triangle ecf being similar to the original one dbL , we shall have db=51.6 : Lb=30 : : ce=19.5 : sc=11.3 for the line affecting the right ascension ; and also , as db= 51.6 : dL=41.7 : : ce=19.5 : ef=15.8 for the line affecting the declination .
But the effect of difference of refraction upon the line Lb=30~ being only 11~.8 , the respective effects of the lines fc and of will be in proportion ; that is , ' ' ' ' ' ' as 30 : 11.3 : : 11.8 : 4.4 for the effect in right ascension , and as 30 : 15.8 : : 11.8 : 6.2 declination ; but as it has been determined , that when the line Lb is 30 minutes , the line LC , or the corresponding declination , will be only 24 minutes ; the effects of refraction above stated will be therefore due to 24~ .
Correction sor the position of the wires .
The above corrections take place on supposition that the several wires of the micrometer were strictly parallel to the respective parts of the circles of declination , and horary circles in the heavens ; but in the practical use of this instrument it is found more convenient , on account of a ready and certain adjustment , to place one of the wires AA or BB parallel to the apparent track of the star wherewith the planetary body is to be compared : in consequence , when the star * , fig. 1 .
is lifted up to L , it will not strictly pursue the line LP ; but being less and less lifted up as it mounts higher , it will apparently fall more and more below the line LP as it ascends above the line HO , and will therefore take a course , suppose Lp .
The wire PLP being therefore adjusted to agree with pLp ; by construction of the instrument , the wire BLX will assume the position qLx perpendicular to pLp .
The star , therefore , that ran along the parallel e+ before it suffered refraction , and at + was supposed to be lifted up to l , there not meeting LX will take the course lie , nearly parallel to Lp , and have some distance , as lz , to travel before it arrives at the new-placed wire Lx ; and it is now proper to examine what this quantity may be .
Through the point z draw the line rzos parallel to HO , and cutting the vertical RLV in 0 , and let Lo be assumed = 30~ ; then , since the angle XLx is supposed to be minute , the gross proportions of the sides of the triangles Lyz and Lyl may be , for this purpose , supposed the same * , and the same as Lbc , dbL , fig. 2 .
to which the triangle Lzo , fig. 1 .
will also be similar ; as likewise the triangle yzo , and also the little triangle zlv : but making the side lv of the triangle zlv equal to the effect of refraction in perpendicular = 11~.8 ; then , to find the side lz , *I am aware , that the supposition of the sides of the triangles Lyz and Lyl being the same cannot be strictly so ; nor can they have the same proportions ; nor are any of the lines concerned right lines , that are supposed such ; but assumptions near the truth are allowable for the correction of an error in the greatest part , that if uncorrected would scarcely amount to a gross error .
the distance run from the first to the last supposed place of the wire , we need only say , as Lb = 30 : db = 51.6 : : lv = 11~.8 : lz = 20~.3 ; and this will be its value when the declination Lc , fig. 2 .
is 24~ ; but then the declination Ll or Lz , fig. 1 .
being greater than the perpendicular side Lo ( assumed 30~ ) in the proportion of Lz : Lo , say , by similarity of triangles conversely , as dL = 41.7 : db = 51.6 : : Lo = 30~ : Lz = 38~.2 ; but as the correction before stated of 20~.3 is an angular error , taking place in proportion to the distance from the center , or the declination ; for the declination given of 24~ say , as 38.2 : 24~ : : 20~.3 : 13 ; to which adding 4~.4 , we shall have 17~.4 for the whole error in right ascension , supposing it in the equator , but must be again increased in the proportion in which a star having declination is slower than a star in the equator ; that is , it must be increased in the proportion of any of the numbers in the fourth column of Tab. II .
to the similar ones in col .
6 .
of the same table ; that is , as 1~ 46~ : 1~ 47~ or as 106 : 107 , : : 17~.4 : 17~6 * .
As all these errors , arising from difference of refraction , are in proportion of the distance of the object from the center of the telescope , they will take place in proportion to the difference of declination of the two objects to be compared , whether they have passed the field on the same , or on different sides of the center .
Now the difference of declination of Mercury and ~ Orionis being only 23~ 2~ , and the quantities being made out for 24~ say ( rejecting the 2 seconds ) , as 24~ : 23~ : : 17~.4 : 16~.7 , which turned into time in the run of the star will be 1~.1 in right ascension .
* My friend Dr. MASKELYNE observes , that in strictness each star ought to have its own proper reduction , on account of difference of declination , which in extreme cases will amount to a sensible quantity .
Say again , as 24~ : 23~ : : 6~.2 : 6~ , the correction in declination .
From the near equality of the lines Ll and Lz , it is evident , that no correction of declination is necessary on account of the inclination of the wires , the whole difference falling in right ascension .
As therefore Mercury passed with 23~ 2~ more north declination than ~ Orionis , and passed through a part of the medium that lifted him up less ; it therefore gave him less north declination than it did to ~ , and therefore apparently diminished the real difference ; hence 6~ must be added to the apparent difference 23~ 2~ , making it 23~ 8~ difference of declination : and as Mercury was lifted up less than ~ , he would not so soon come to the middle wire by 1~.1 as he should have done , he therefore came too late by 1~.1 , which must be subtracted from the time of Mercury 's passage the 2d of Sept. which will increase the time in which he preceded ~ Orionis ; that is , 18 h. 43~ 42~.4 increased by 1.1 will become 18 h. 43~ 43~.5 difference of right ascension .
I have been the more particular in the investigation of this observation , first of all to ascertain the degree of dependence that may be formed on an instrument of the kind ; and , secondly , to infer such easy and simple rules , that other similar observations may be the more easily reduced .
Being therefore satisfied of the stability of the instrument ; if we had concluded the observation with that of Mercury in the morning , and of o Tauri in the evening of the 23d , then the result from Tab. III .
should have been h. ' ' ' Mercury passed the wires at 17 22 34.9 And o Tauri passed at 9 36 27.3 Difference of right ascension 15 13 52.4 which is the very same as was before deduced from the mean of the whole : ' ' ' And if to Mercury 's declination south of telescope 's center 18 We add o Tauri 's north 30 26 We shall have for the difference of declination 31 34 the same as before determined .
Our observation would , therefore , in this case simply have been , that Mercury preceded o Tauri in right ascension 15 h. 13~ 52~.4 mean time , and passed the wire with more south declination than o Tauri by 31~ 34~ .
After this , o Tauri would have required to be compared with some well rectified star by meridian instruments ; but in the present case ~ Orionis , one of Dr. MASKELYNE'S Catalogue of 34 principal stars happened to lie sufficiently near the same parallel of declination , to admit of o Tauri to be compared therewith by the same instrument , while pointed to the same place of the heavens .
The operations which were subsequent , therefore , must be considered as intended to save those of a meridian instrument .
Now had our observation concluded with the above , then the correction would have taken place upon the difference of declination of o Tauri with Mercury , instead of the ultimate one with ~ Orionis ; but it must be observed , that whatever quantity of correction the difference of declination would occasion , it would be compensated in the difference of refraction of of o Tauri and ~ Orionis , when they came to be observed on the meridian ; however , in the present case it happens to be more commodious , as both can be done under one .
Preparatory then to the laying down the simple rule for the correction of refraction , it is proper to premise , that it is evident , dent , the lines , fig. 2 .
Lb , Lc , ce , of , being in continued proportion Lb will be to of in triplicate proportion of Lb to Lc ; and that Lc will be to of in duplicate proportion of Lb : Lc .
The difference of declination , therefore , due to 30~ difference of elevation will be as Lb to Lc simply ; but the effect of difference of refraction in declination will be less than the difference of declination in the proportion of Lb2 : Lc2 ; and that the effect of difference of refraction in right ascension will be less than the difference of refraction in declination in the proportion of Lb : cb simply .
Now it has been remarked , that the elevation of the telescope 's center above the horizon , and the horary angle VLP , will always be readily given near enough for the purpose by the globe .
A triangle given Lbd can therefore be constructed , and the side Lb being made 30~ ( or any convenient aliquot part of a degree ) the other sides will be found by proportion : say then , as in the present case , db = 51.6 : dL = 41.7 : : Lb = 30 : Lc = 24 , for the difference of declination corresponding to half a degree of altitude : say then , as 51.62 : 41.72 , that is , as 2663 : 1739 : : 24 : 15.7 = of .
But without troubling ourselves with high numbers , if we take the proportion 51.6 to 41.7 by the slide-rule twice , we shall arrive at 15.7 , near enough for the value of the line of : say then , as Lb = 30 : of = 15.7 : : 11~.8 : 6~.2 for the refraction in declination : and as dL = 41.7 : Lb = 30 : : 6~.2 : 4~.4 for the refraction in right ascension , according to the true position of the wires : and , for the correction of right ascension in the position of the wires , say , Fig. 2 .
Fig 1 .
As Lb=30 : db=51.6 : : lv=11~.8 : lz=20~.3 ; and again , dL=41.7 : db=51.6 : : Lo=30~ : Lz=38~.2 .
Take now Lh , fig. 1 .
= Lc , fig. 2 .
= 24~ , and draw the line hik , fig. 1 .
parallel to the line lzy , and then say , as Lz = 38~.2 : Lh ( or Li ) = 24~ : : lz = 20~.3 : hi = 13~ , which +4~.4 = 17~.4 for the whole error in right ascension , with a declination or distance from the center of 24~ ; but as the errors both of right ascension and declination are in proportion to distance from the center , as the difference of the planet and star is only 23~ , say , as 24~ : 23~ : : 17~.4 : 16~.7 = 1~.1 time ; and for the declination , say again , as 24~ : 23~ : : 6~.2 : 6~ declination * .
Reduction of Mercury 's comparison with ~ Orionis , to right ascension and declination .
We have laid it down , that the 23d Sept. 1786 , A.M. at 5 h. 22~ 34~.9 mean time , Mercury preceded ~ Orionis 18 h. 43~ 43~.5 , and had then a more northern declination by 23~ 8~ .
According to Dr. MASKELYNE'S Catalogue of 34 stars , the right ascension of ~ Orionis reduced to the time when he was observed is 85~ 54~ 12~ .
Now as the whole circle of the sphere makes a revolution in the time that ~ Orionis makes one turn , which is h. ' ' ' 23 56 4.1 then from this deduct 18 43 43.5 5 12 20.6 remains for the time that ~ Orionis preceded * If the comparison had been with o Tauri , then we must have said , ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' As 24 : 311/ 2 : : 17.5 : 23 = 1.5 of time , and 24 : 311/ 2 : : 6.2 : 8.1 correction for declination .
N. B. All these and the above proportions will be commodiously wrought with the slide-rule .
Fig. 2 .
Fig. 1 .
W y Axk XX rvzos bPlP +p i ch f 54~1/ 2 Be 54~1/ 2 HdeLOHLO Aa* p PAP d BB q BC Mercury in right ascension ; but if ~ ran the whole rotation = 360~ in 23 h. 56~ 4~.1 , what portion of it will be run in 5 h. 12~ 20~.6 = 18740~.6 ?
But 24 h. = 86,400 seconds , and 360 = 1,296,000 seconds : Time .
Time .
Of degrees .
Of degrees o ' ' ' Say then , as 86400~ : 18740~.6 : : 1296000~ : 281109~ = 78 59 But , according to Dr. MASKELYNE'S select Catalogue , the right ascension of ~ Orionis for Sept. 30 , 1786 , was , ( which add ) 85 54 12 The right ascension of Mercury at the time of observation was therefore 163 59 21 According to Dr. MASKELYNE'S select Catalogue ~ Orionis had declio ' ' ' nation north , corrected for precession 7 21 8.8 The sum of aberration and nutation from Connoissance des Temps + 8.4 The correct declination north of ~ Orionis 7 21 17.2 To which add that Mercury passed more north 23 8 Mercury 's declination therefore was 7 44 25.2 The result .
1786 , Sept 23 .
A.M. right ascension 163 59 21 Mercury 's at 5 h. 22~ 35~ M.T. declination north 7 44 25

