XXIV .
Observations tending to show that the Wolf , Jackal , and Dog , are all of the same Species .
By John Hunter , Esq. F. R. S. Read April 26 , 1787 .
THE true distinction between different species of animals must ultimately , as appears to me , be gathered from their incapacity of propagating with each other an offspring capable again of continuing itself by subsequent propagations : thus the Horse and Ass beget a Mule capable of copulation , but incapable of begetting or producing offspring .
If it be true , that the mule has been known to breed , which must be allowed to be an extraordinary fact , it will by no means be sufficient to determine the Horse and Ass to be of the same species ; indeed , from the copulation of Mules being very frequent , and the circumstance of their breeding very rare , I should rather attribute it to a degree of monstrosity in the organs of the Mule which conceived , not being those of a mixed animal , but those of the Mare or female Ass .
This is not so far-fetched an idea , when we consider that some true species produce monsters , which are a mixture of both sexes , and that many animals of distinct sex are incapable of breeding at all .
If then we find nature in its greatest perfection deviating from general principles , why may not it happen likewise in the production of Mules , so that sometimes a Mule shall breed from the circumstance of its being a monster respecting mules ?
The times of uterine gestation being the same in all the varieties of every species of animals , this circumstance becomes necessary to determine a species .
The affinity between the Fox , Wolf , Jackal , and several varieties of the Dog , in their external form and several of their properties , is so striking , that they appear to be only varieties of the same species .
The Fox would seem to be a greater remove from the Dog than either the Jackal or Wolf , at least in disposition , not being either so sociable respecting its own species or man , but naturally a solitary animal ; from all which I should suspect it is only allied to the Dog by being of the same genus .
It is considently asserted by many , that the Fox breeds with the Dog , but this has not been accurately ascertained ; but , if it had , it would probably have been carried further , and once breeding , according to what we have said , does not constitute a species ; this , however , is a part I mean to investigate .
Wolves and Jackals are found in herds ; and the Jackal is so little afraid of the human species , that , like a Dog , it comes into houses in search of food , more like a variety of the Dog in consequence of cultivation than chance .
It is by much the most familiar of the two ; for we shall find hereafter , that in its readiness to copulate with the Dog , and its familiarity with the Dog afterwards , it is somewhat different from the Wolf .
The Wolf then being an animal better known in Europe , where inquiries of this kind are made , some pains has been taken to ascertain , whether or not it was of the same species with the dog ; but , I believe , it has been hitherto considered as only belonging to the same genus .
Accident often does as much for natural history as premeditated plans , especially when nature is left to itself .
The first instance of the Dog and Wolf breeding in this country seems to have been about the year 1766 .
A Pomeranian Bitch of Mr. BROOKES'S , in the New Road , was lined only once by a Wolf , and brought forth a litter of nine healthy puppies .
The veracity of Mr. BROOKES is not to be doubted , respecting the Bitch being lined by a Wolf ; yet , as it was possible she might have been lined by some common Dog without his knowledge , the fact was not clearly made out ; but it has been since ascertained , that the Dog and Wolf will breed .
Several noblemen and gentlemen bought some of the puppies , as I was informed by Mr. BROOKES .
My Lord CLANBRASSIL purchased a Bitch-puppy ; and Mr. BROOKES presented one to me , which I kept for observations and experiment .
Its actions were not truly those of a Dog ; it had more quickness in attending to things , was more easily startled , as if particularly apprehensive of danger , quicker in transitions from one action to another , not so ready to the call , being less docile ; and from these peculiarities it lost its life , being stoned to death in the streets for a mad dog .
Hearing that Lord CLANBRASSIL'S Bitch had bred , Sir JOSEPH BANKS was so obliging as , at my request , to write to his Lordship , who sent the following account .
SIR , About seventeen or eighteen years ago , the late Lord MONTHERMER and I happened to see a Dog-wolf at Mr. BROOKES'S , who deals in animals , and lives in the New Road .
The animal was remarkably tame ; and it struck us , for that reason , that a breed might be procured between him and a Bitch .
We promised Mr. BROOKES a good price for puppies , if he succeeded .
In about a year a Bitch produced nine , and Lord MONTHERMER bought one ; and I had another , which was a Bitch .
Lord MONTHERMER'S died of fits in about two years : mine lived longer , and had puppies only once .
One I gave to Lord PEMBROKE ; but what became of it I do not remember .
It was grand-daughter of the Wolf by the dam , and got by a large Pointer of mine .
It might be considered , that Mr. BROOKES'S word was not sufficient proof that the puppies were really got by the Wolf ; but the appearance of the animals , so totally different from all others of the canine species , did not leave a doubt upon our minds ; and I remember HANS STANLEY , who had adopted BUFFON'S opinion , was thoroughly convinced upon seeing mine .
The animals had the shape of the Wolf refined : the fur long , but almost as fine as that of the black Fox .
I am afraid I have trespassed too much upon your time , and will only beg you will be assured nothing can give me more pleasure than any opportunity of assuring you how truly I am , Sir , &amp;c. CLANBRASSIL .
Jan. 7 , 1787 .
Upon the supposition that Mr. BROOKES'S Bitch was lined by no Dog but the Wolf , which I think we have no reason to doubt , the species of the Wolf is ascertained ; but I chose to trace this breed still further ; and hearing that Lord PEMBROKE'S Bitch had likewise bred , I was anxious to know the truth of it ; and , finding his lordship was in France , I took the liberty of writing to Lord HERBERT , and received in answer the following letter .
SIR , Wilton-house , Dec. 20 , 1786 .
The half-bred Wolf-bitch you allude to was given , as I have always understood , to Lord PEMBROKE by Lord CLANBRASSIL .
She might , perhaps , have been bought at BROOKES'S by him .
She had four litters , one of ten puppies , by a Dog between a Mastiff and a Bull-dog .
One of these was given to Dr. EYRE , at Wells in Somersetshire , and one to Mr. BUCKETT , at Stockbridge .
The second litter was of nine puppies , some of which were sent to Ireland , but to whom I know not .
This litter was by a different Dog , but of the same breed as the first .
The third litter was of eight puppies , by a large Mastiff .
Two of these were , I believe , sent to the present Duke of QUEENSBERRY .
The fourth litter consisted of seven puppies ; two of which were sent to M. CERJAT , a gentleman who now resides at Lausanne in Switzerland , and is famous for breaking dogs remarkably well .
These two puppies were , however , naturally so wild and unruly , that he found it impossible to break them .
She died four years ago , and the following inscription was put over the place where she is buried in this garden , by Lord PEMBROKE'S orders .
Here lies Lupa , whose grand-mother was a Wolf , whose father and grand-father were Dogs , and whose mother was half Wolf and half Dog .
She died on the 16th of October , 1782 , aged 12 years .
I am sorry it is not in my power to give you any better account ; but if you think proper to write to Lord PEMBROKE , who is at Paris , I am convinced he will be very happy to give you any further information .
I am , &amp;c. HERBERT .
BUFFON , whose remarks in natural history are well known , made experiments to ascertain how far the Wolf and Dog were of the same species , but without success .
He says , ` ` A Shewolf , which I kept three years , although shut up very young , and along with a Greyhound of the same age , in a spacious yard , could not be brought to agree with it , nor endure it , even when she was in heat .
She was the weakest , yet the most mischievous ; provoking , attacking , and biting the Dog , which at first only defended itself , but at last killed her .
' ' And in another part of his work , he makes the following observation : ` ` The Dog , the Wolf , the Fox , and the Jackal , form a genus , of which the different species are really so nearly allied to each other , and of which the individuals resemble each other so much , particularly by the internal structure and parts of generation , that it is difficult to conceive why they do not breed together * .
' ' This * In the Supplement to his Works , he gives the following account which had been sent to him .
` ` A very young She-wolf , brought up at the Marquis of SPONTIN'S , at Namur , had a Dog , of nearly the same age , kept with it as a companion .
For two years they were at liberty , coming and going about the apartments , the kitchen , the stables , &amp;c. lying under the table , and upon the feet of those who sat round it .
They lived in the greatest familiarity .
The Dog was a strong Greyhound .
The wolf was sed on milk for six months ; after that , raw meat was given her , which she preferred to that which was This part of natural history lay dormant till Mr. GOUGH , who sells birds and has a collection of animals on Holborn Hill , repeated the experiment on a Wolf-bitch , which was very tame , and had all the actions of a Dog under confinement .
A Dog is the most proper subject for comparison , as we have opportunities of being acquainted with its dispositions and modes of expressing its sensations , which are most distinguishable in the motion of the ears and tail ; such as pricking up the ears when anxious , wishing , or in expectation ; depressing them when supplicant , or in fear ; raising the tail in anger or love , depressing it in fear , and moving it laterally in friendship ; and likewise in raising the hair on the back from many affections of the mind .
This animal became in heat in the month of December 1785 ; and as Mr. GOUGH had some idea of breeding from wild animals , as Monkies , Leopards , &amp;c. he was anxious to have the Wolf lined by some Dog ; but she dressed .
When she ate no one durst approach her ; but at other times people might do as they pleased , provided they did not use her ill .
At first she made much of all the Dogs which were brought to her ; but afterward she gave the preference to her old companion , and from that time she became very fierce if any strange Dog approached her .
She was lined for the first time on the 25th of March ; this was frequently repeated while her heat coutinued , which was sixteen days ; and she littered the 6th of June , at eight o'clock in the morning ; the period of gestation was therefore seventy three days at the most * .
She brought forth four young ones of a blackish colour , some of whose feet , and a part of the breast , were white ; in this respect taking after the Dog , who was black and white .
From the time she littered she became surly , and set up her back at those who came near her ; did not know her masters , and would even have killed the Dog , if it had been in her power .
' ' * This is a longer period than in the Bitch by at least ten days ; but as the account was made from the first time of her being lined , and she was in heat for a fortnight , and lined in that time , it is very probable , if the time was known when she conceived , that it would prove to be the same period as in the Dog .
would not allow any Dog to come near her , probably from her not being accustomed to be with Dogs , and being always chained .
She was held , however , while a greyhound Dog lined her , and they were fastened together exactly as the Dog and Bitch .
While in conjunction she was pretty quiet ; but when at liberty , she endeavoured to fly at the Dog .
In this way she was twice lined .
She conceived , and brought forth four young ones .
The time she went with young was not exactly known ; but it was believed to be the same as in the Bitch .
Two of the puppies were like the Dog in colour , who had large black spots on a white ground ; one was of a black colour , and the fourth of a kind of dun , and would probably have been like the mother .
She took great care of them , yet did not seem very anxious when one was taken from her by the keeper ; nor did she seem afraid when strangers came into the room .
Unfortunately these experiments were carried no further ; one being sold to a gentleman , who carried it to the East-Indies ; and the other three were killed by a Leopard , one of which I was to have had .
The same Wolf was in heat in December 1786 , and was lined several times by a Dog .
She pupped on the 24th of February 1787 , and had six puppies , which may afford opportunities , if they are thought necessary , of repeating experiments on this subject .
While pursuing this subject , I was informed , that Captain MEARS , of the Royal Bishop East-India-man , had brought home a bitch Jackal with young , which had brought forth soon after his arrival ; and that he had given the bitch Jackal and one puppy to Mr. BAILEY , Bird-merchant , in Piccadilly .
I went to see them , and purchased the puppy , the subject of the following experiment , which had dispositions very similar to the half-bred Wolf which I had from Mr. BROOKES before mentioned .
To have a true history of this animal , I took the liberty of writing to Mr. MEARS , who politely called upon me , and , at my request , put down the particulars in the form of a letter to me , of which the following is a copy .
SIR , I had the honour of your the 15th instant ; and with regard to the female Jackal , I can assure you , that she took a small spaniel Dog of mine on board my ship , the Royal Bishop .
I had her , when a cub , at Bombay ; and a very short time before I arrived in England she got to heat , and enticed this small dog into the long-boat , where I saw them repeatedly fast together .
I brought her to my house in the country , where she pupped six puppies , one of which you have seen .
Mr. PLAW , at No 90 , Tottenham-Court-Road , has a Dogpuppy , which will be at your service at any time you chuse to send for him , to make any further experiments : I called on Mr. PLAW , and got his promise to let you have the Dog .
I have the honour to be , Sir , &amp;c. WM .
MEARS .
No 107 , Hatton-street , 16th Jan. 1786 .
P. S. I had the Bitch on board fourteen months .
I took this puppy into the country , and chained it up near a mastiff Dog , and they were very familiar , and seemingly fond of each other .
When the Bitch became first in heat , I could not get a proper Dog for her ; but the latter end of September being again in the same situation , several Dogs were procured , and left with her .
They appeared indifferent about her , probably from being in a strange place ; and she did not seem inclined to be familiar with them ; whether the great Dog might be able to line her I do not know ; she was , however , twice tied by a Tarrier on the 3d of October .
In a few weeks she was evidently become bigger ; and on the 30th of November , in all fifty-nine days , she brought forth five puppies .
Some days before this period she dug a hole under ground , by the side of the kennel , in which she brought forth , and it was some time before she would allow the puppies to stay in the kennel when put there .
In about eight days some , and nine days others of them began to open their eyelids .
Here then is an absolute proof of the Jackal being a Dog ; and it appears to me , that the Wolf is equally made out to be of the same species .
It now then becomes a question , whether the Wolf is from the Jackal , or the Jackal from the Wolf , supposing they had but one origin ?
From the supposition , that varieties become more tame in their nature , we should be led to believe , the Wolf to be the original , and that the Jackal was a step towards civilisation in that species of animal .
There are Wolves of various kinds , each country having a Wolf peculiar to itself ; but the Jackals that I have seen have been more uniformly the same , both those from Africa , and those from the East-Indies .
I am informed , however , that they vary in size .
Whether all the Wolves of different countries are of one species , or some of them only of the same genus , I do not know ; but I should rather suppose them to be all of one species .
What is with me an argument in favour of this supposition is , that , if there were Wolves of distinct species , we should have had by this time a great variety of that species of Wolves , with the various dispositions arising from variation in other respects ; and those varieties now turned to very useful purposes , as has been the case with the Dog ; for all the Wolves we are yet acquainted with , have naturally the principle of cultivation in them , as much probably as any animal , or as much at least as those Wolves we now know to be Dogs .
The not having a civilised species of Wolf is , indeed , with me a proof that they are all of the same species with the Dog .
If they are all of the same species with the Dog , then the first variety that took place was still in the character of a Wolf , differing only in colour , or some trivial circumstance , which could only take place from a difference in climate ; civilisation or cultivation in a state of nature being the same in them all .
Where they became Jackal , or what we now call Dog , is difficult to say ; or what Dog we can call the first remove , as many Dogs differ very much from one another ; or whether the Jackal is the intermediate link between the Wolf and the Dog .
In either case we have three great varieties in this species , Wolf , Jackal , and Dog , with the varieties in each .
If the Dog is proved to be the Wolf tamed , the Jackal may probably be the Dog returned to his wild state .
To ascertain the original animal of a species , it is proper to examine all the varieties of that species , and see how far they have the character of the genus , and what resemblance they bear to the other species of the genus ; for it is natural to suppose , that the original , or the animal which is nearest to it , will have more of the true character of the genus , and will have a stronger resemblance to the species nearest allied to it , than any of the other varieties of its own species .
If we apply this to the Dog , and consider the Fox as a distinct species , which there is great reason to believe it is , that variety which has the strongest resemblance to the Fox , is to be looked upon as the original of all the others ; which will prove to be the Wolf .
Another mode of considering this subject , which is however secondary to the above , is , supposing that all animals were at first wild ; and , therefore , that those animals which remain wild , are the original stock ; and that the further we find animals removed from their originals in appearance , they are really further removed in consequence of variation taking place from cultivation , so that we may still be able to trace the gradation .
What gives some force to this idea is , that where the Dogs have been least cultivated , there they still retain most of their original character , or similarity to the Wolf or the Jackal , both in shape and disposition .
Thus the shepherd 's Dog , all over the world , has strongly the character of the Wolf or Jackal ; so that but little difference is to be observed , except in size and hair .
Size is , perhaps , a variety taking place under a variety of circumstances ; but difference in hair is , in general , influenced by climate , although perhaps not always so .
Thus the Wolf has longer and softer hair than the Jackal , because he is a more northern animal ; and the Jackal and shepherd 's Dog in Portugal and Spain have shorter and stronger hair than those of Germany or Kamchatka , from inhabiting warmer climates .
But when we consider their general shape , the character of countenance , the quick manner with the pricked and erect ears , we must suppose them varieties of the same species .
The smelling at the tail has been described as characteristic of the Dog ; but , I believe , it is common to most animals , and only marks the male ; for it is the most certain way the male has of knowing the female , and also discloses another scent , which is the final intention , whether the female is disposed to receive the male .
The Esquimaux Dog , and that found among the Indians as far south as the Cherokees ; the shepherd 's Dog in Germany , called Pomeranian ; the shepherd 's Dog in Portugal and Spain ; have all a strong similarity to the Wolf and Jackal .
BUFFON , on the origin of Dogs , seems to have possessed nearly the same idea ; for he says the shepherd 's Dog is the original stock from which the different races of Dogs have sprung .
As the Wolf turns out to be a Dog , it seems astonishing , that there was no account of Dogs being found in America .
But this I consider as a defect in the first history of that country , for there are Wolves ; and I think , in spite of all that has been said to the contrary , the Esquimaux and Indian Dog is only a variety from a Wolf in that country , which had been tamed .
Mr. CAMERON , of Titchfield-street , who was many years among the Cherokees , and considerably to the westward of that country , observes , that the Dog found there is very similar to the Wolf ; and that the natives consider it to be a species of tame Wolf ; but as we come more among the Europeans who have settled there , the Dogs are more of a mixed breed ; for why they should only have had this kind of Dog transported among them , while every other part of America has the varieties of Europe , is not easily solved .
The voice of animals is commonly characteristic of the species ; but I should suppose , it is only characteristic of the original species , and not always of the variety , and this supposition holds good in the Dog species .
It would appear , that the voice of the Wolf and the Jackal is very similar , and is principally conveyed through the nose , and exactly resembles that noise in Dogs , which is a mark of longing or melancholy , and also of fondness ; but has no resemblance to the bark of the Dog , which they do not perform .
Barking is peculiar to certain varieties of the Dog kind , and even some that do bark , do it less than others .
The Dogs in the South-Sea islands do not bark : our Greyhound barks but little ; while the Mastiff , and many of the smaller tribe , as Spaniels , are particularly noisy in this way .
It would appear as if the frequency of this noise arose from imitation ; for the Dogs in the SouthSeas learn to bark ; and others , as the Hound , have a peculiar howl , which , by huntsmen , is called the tongue .
This noise , as also the bark , is made by opening the mouth .
A variety in the voice , or some parts of the voice , in the varieties of the same species , is not peculiar to the Dog .

