XVII .
Remarks on Mr. Brydone 's Account of a remarkable Thunder storm in Scotland .
By the Right Honourable Charles Earl Stanhope , F. R. S. Read February 15 , 1787 .
~ 1 .
NO storm of lightning has ever produced effects more curious to contemplate than those related by Mr. BRYDONE , in his Letter to the President of this Society .
That account contains facts of such consequence , and so perfectly inexplicable by the principles of electricity which are commonly received , that it undoubtedly deserves particular attention .
It appears , that a man ( named ` ` JAMES LAUDER ' ' ) sitting on the fore-part of a cart drawn by two horses , was suddenly struck dead , as also the horses that he was driving , and that the cart itself was much injured by electrical fire , although no lightning fell at , or near , the place where this accident happened .
~ 2 .
Before I attempt to account , by the laws of electricity , for this remarkable phenomenon , it may not be improper just to take notice , that few facts of this kind have ever been better authenticated than this is .
It appears , first , that a man , who was sitting upon the forepart of another cart , only twenty-four yards behind the cart that was struck , ` ` had LAUDER , his cart and horses , full in view when they fell ; he was stunned by a loud report , and saw his companion , his horses and cart , fall to the ground ; he immediately ran to his assistance , but found him quite dead ; he perceived ' ' ( at the time of the accident ) ` ` no flash or appearance of fire .
' ' It also appears , that another man , a shepherd of St. Cuthbert 's farm , was also a witness of this event .
He was distant from LAUDER ` ` between two and three hundred yards , and was looking at the two carts , when he was stunned by a loud report , and at the same instant saw the first of the carts fall to the ground .
He saw no lightning , nor appearance of fire whatever .
' ' The concurrent testimony of these two men is confirmed by PATRICK BRYDONE , Esq. who lives ` ` at a small distance ' ' from the spot where LAUDER was killed : and Mr. BRYDONE relates , that a storm appeared far off ; and that he , and some company in his house , were ` ` suddenly alarmed by a loud report , for which they were not prepared by any preceding flash .
' ' There is the greater weight to be given to this account of Mr. BRYDONE , as it so happened , that he was just then ` ` observing the progress of the storm , at an open window , in the second story of his house , ' ' and making the company ` ` observe , by a stop-watch , the time that the sound took to reach them .
' ' It is extremely fortunate , that a gentleman , fond of philosophical enquiries , should have been upon the spot at the time of this accident , to give to the world so clear and interesting an account .
~ 3 .
That the death of LAUDER and of the horses was not occasioned by any direct main stroke of explosion from a thundercloud , either positively or negatively electrified , is evident ; since no lightning whatever did pass from the clouds to the earth ( or from the earth to the clouds ) at the place where they were killed .
~ 4 .
It is equally evident ( and for the very same reason ) that they were not deprived of life by any transmitted main stroke of explosion , either positive or negative .
~ 5 .
It is also obvious , that the lateral explosion was not the cause of this mischief ; for the lateral * explosion does always proceed immediately from the main stroke itself ; and therefore there can exist no lateral explosion , in the case when there is no main stroke whatever .
~ 6 .
It might , perhaps , be supposed , that LAUDER and the two horses were suddenly suffocated by the sulphureous smell that often accompanies electricity .
But though the death of the man and of the horses might ( by some ) be attributed to this cause , the sulphureous smell will no wise account for ` ` many pieces of the coal having been thrown out , to a considerable distance , all round the cart ; ' ' and for the ` ` splinters ' ' ( from the wood-work of the cart ) that were ` ` thrown off in many places , ' ' as appears , by Mr. BRYDONE 's account , to have been the case .
~ 7 .
Some persons may imagine that LAUDER and the horses might have been killed , and that the other effects abovementioned might be accounted for , by some sudden and very violent commotion in the air , which commotion the thunder might be supposed to produce , though unaccompanied with any flash at that place ; in a manner , in some small degree , similar to the fatal wounds that sometimes have been known to have been given by the air having been suddenly displaced * See Dr. PRIESTLEY 's excellent Paper in the sixtieth volume of the Philosophical Transactions , page 192 et seq. See also my Principles of Electricity , ~ 386 .
567 by a cannon ball , in its passage through that atmospherical fluid , though the cannon ball itself had evidently neither struck the person wounded , nor even grazed his cloaths .
The ` ` dust that rose at the place ' ' might be brought as an additional argument in favour of the opinion , that a sudden and violent commotion of the air did occasion the effects produced .
But such an explanation ( vague as it is ) would not account for the ` ` marks of fusion ' ' on the iron of the wheels ; nor for ` ` the hair of the horses having been singed ; ' ' nor for the skin of LAUDER 's body having been burnt ' ' in many places .
~ 8 .
I think , from the different circumstances of this case , that it is clear to demonstration , that the effects produced proceeded from electricity ; and that no electrical fire did pass immediately either from the clouds into the cart , &amp;c. or from the cart , &amp;c. into the clouds .
From ` ` the circular holes ' ' in the ground ( ` ` of about twenty inches in diameter ' ' ) the respective ` ` centers of which were exactly in the track of each wheel , ' ' and the corresponding ` ` marks of fusion ' ' on the iron of the wheels , which marks ` ` answered exactly to the center of each of the holes ; ' ' it is evident , that the electrical fire did pass ( from the earth to the cart , or from the cart to the earth ) through that part of the iron of the wheels which was in contact with the ground .
From the ` ` splinters that had been thrown off , in many places , particularly where the timber of the cart was connected by nails or cramps of iron , ' ' and from the various other effects mentioned in Mr. BRYDONE 's Paper , it is moreover evident , that there was a violent motion of the electrical fluid in all , or ( at least ) in different parts of the cart , and of the bodies of the man and horses , although there were no lightning .
~ 9 .
Wonderful as these combined facts may appear , and uncommon as they certainly are in this country , they are , nevertheless , easy to be explained by means of that particular species of electrical shock , which I have distinguished in my Principles * of Electricity ( published in 1779 ) by the appellation of the ` ` electrical returning stroke : ' ' and although at the time I wrote that Treatise , I had it not in my power to produce any instance of persons or animals having been killed in the very peculiar manner since related in Mr. BRYDONE 's Paper ; I did , however ( from my experiments mentioned in that Book ) , venture to assert , with confidence , that ~ , ` ` if persons be strongly superinduced by the electrical atmosphere of a cloud , they may ( under circumstances similar to those explained in that Treatise ) receive a very strong shock , be knocked down , or be even killed , at the instant that the cloud discharges , with an explosion , its electricity , whether the lightning falls near the very place where those persons are , or at a very considerable distance from that place , or whether the cloud be positively or negatively electrified .
' ' And I moreover stated that~ , ` ` whether the distance between the person so circumstanced , and the place where the lightning falls , be fifty or an hundred yards , or one mile , or two miles , or three miles , or more , the truth of the ge* See Principles of Electricity , containing divers new Theorems and Experiments , together with an Analysis of the superior Advantages of high and pointed Conductors ; by CHARLES Viscount MAHON , F. R. S. from ~ 202 .
to ~ 347 .
inclusively .
~ See Principles of Electricity , ~ 311 .
~ See Principles of Electricity , ~ 313 .
neral proposition there laid down would not be any wise affected .
' ' I have also explained , in that Treatise , how a still more singular effect might be produced , namely , how * ` ` an explosion , which happens in one place , may cause in a second place ( at a very considerable distance from the first place ) a sudden returning stroke , which may knock down , or even kill , persons and animals at that second place ; at the same time that other persons , or other animals , situated in a third place , that is even immediately between the first place where the lightning falls , and the second place ( just mentioned ) where the shock of the returning stroke happens , shall receive no detriment whatever .
' ' ~ 10 .
Having , in my Principles of Electricity ~ , explained at large the nature of the returning stroke , I will not trespass upon the time of this Society , by repeating the account of any of the various experiments that I made , to prove the possible existence of such an electrical stroke ; but I will , at once , apply the general laws , which I have ( therein ) laid down , to the particular phenomenon related by Mr. BRYDONE .
But , before I speak of the accident of LAUDER , which appears to me to have been occasioned by a returning stroke , proceeding from an assemblage of clouds , I will say a few words upon one or two other facts , mentioned in Mr. BRYDONE 's account .
~ 11 .
Mr. BRYDONE informs us , that ` ` the shepherd belonging to the farm of Lennel-Hill was in a neighbouring field , when he observed a lamb ( only a few yards from him ) drop down , although the lightning and claps of thunder were , * See Principles of Electricity , ~ 314 .
~ See Principles of Electricity , from ~ 202 to ~ 347 , inclusively .
then , at a great distance from him .
He ran up immediately , but found the lamb quite dead ; nor did he perceive the least convulsive motion , or symptom of life remaining , although , the moment before , it appeared to be in perfect health .
' ' This effect is so precisely similar to those explained in my Principles of electricity , and particularly to that mentioned in section 328 , that it is quite unnecessary to enlarge upon it .
I will only observe , that such an electrical returning stroke as that by which this lamb was destroyed ( namely , a returning stroke , which happens at a place where there is neither lightning nor thunder near ) belongs to the most simple class of returning strokes ; and that it may be produced by the sudden removal of the elastic electrical pressure of the electrical atmosphere of a single * main cloud , as well as by that of an assemblage ~ of clouds .
It appears by Mr. BRYDONE 's account , that the shepherd , who saw the lamb fall , was near enough to it to feel , in a small degree , the electrical returning stroke ` ` at the same time ' ' that the lamb dropped down .
~ 12 .
Mr. BRYDONE further relates , that ` ` a woman making hay near the banks of the river fell suddenly to the ground ; and called out to her companions , that she had received a violent blow on the foot , and could not imagine from whence it came .
' ' This blow was , unquestionably , the electrical returning stroke .
When a person , walking or standing out of doors , is knocked down or killed by the returning stroke , the electrical fire must rush in , or rush out , as the case may be , through that * See Principles of Electricity , ~ 312 .
~ See , in my Principles of Electricity , the end of the note to ~ 312 .
person 's sect * , and through them only ; which would not be the case , were the person to be knocked down or killed by any main stroke of explosion , either positive or negative .
These things are evident .
But the manner in which LAUDER and the two horses were killed is not quite so evident , though it appears to me to be very easily accounted for .
I will now state , in what manner I conceive that the clouds may have been placed , when the effects mentioned in Mr. BRYDONE 's Paper were produced .
~ 13 .
I must premise that , by that account , it appears , that the cloud was many miles in length ; inasmuch , as just before the ` ` loud report , ' ' the lightning was at a very ` ` great distance : ' ' for Mr. BRYDONE ` ` observed , by a stop-watch , that the time that the sound took to reach him was generally from 25 to 30 seconds .
' ' Mr. BRYDONE relates , that the ` ` loud report resembled the firing of several muskets , so close together , that the ear could hardly separate the sounds , and was followed by no rumbling noise like the other claps .
' ' This description indicates , that the electrical explosion was not far distant ; and also shows , that it was not extremely near : for , if the explosion had been extremely near , the ear could not at all have separated the sounds .
~ 14 .
Now let us suppose a cloud , eight , ten , or twelve miles in length ( be the same more or less ) to be extended over the surface of the earth , in the situation represented by ABC in the figure .
( See Tab. VIII .
) And let another cloud ( as represented by DEF ) be situated between the above-mentioned cloud and the earth .
* See Principles of Electricity , from ~ 322 .
to ~ 327 .
inclusively .
Let the two clouds be supposed to be charged ( for instance ) with the same kind of electricity , and to be both positive .
Let us further suppose , that the lower cloud DEF be near the earth , only a little beyond the striking distance ; and let a man , cart and horses , be situated at L , under that part ( E ) of the cloud which is the nearest to the earth .
Now , let us suppose this cart to be ascending an hill , and to be in the situation described by Mr. BRYDONE , namely , to have ` ` almost gained the highest part of the ascent , ' ' and to be followed by ` ` another cart ' ' ( M ) lower down the hill .
Let us suppose also , that the two clouds DEF and ABC be near each other , perpendicularly over the place where the cart L was situate ( as at DA ) .
And let the remote end C , of the upper cloud ABC , approach the earth , within the striking distance , and suddenly discharge its electricity into the earth at G. ~ 15 .
Things being situated as above described , let us examine what consequences must follow .
First , when the upper cloud ABC discharges its electricity into the earth at G , the lower cloud DEF must immediately discharge its electricity into the upper cloud at the place DA , which is directly or nearly over the cart L. This accounts for the ` ` loud report ' ' of thunder that was unaccompanied by lightning at L or at M. The report must be loud , from its being near ; but no lightning could be perceived at L or M , by reason of the thick thunder cloud DEF being situated immediately between the spectator at M and DA , the place between the two clouds where the lightning situation represented in the figure ; the earth at L must , of course , become superinduced by the elastic electrical pressure of the electrical atmosphere of the thunder-cloud ; which superinduced elastic electrical pressure must gradually have increased as the cloud came closer to the earth , and approached nearer to the limit of the striking distance .
~ 17 .
Consequently , if any conducting body ( not having any prominent conducting points ) were to be placed at L , upon the surface of the earth , and to be there electrically insulated ; then such conducting body , by the laws of electricity , must , at its upper extremity ( namely , the part nearest to the positive cloud ) become negative ; at its lower extremity , it must become positive ; and , at a certain intermediate point , it will be neither plus nor minus .
So that this insulated conducting body , thus situated , will be in three opposite states at one and the same time ; that is to say , that it will be , at the same instant , positively electrified , negatively electrified , and not electrified at all .
This proposition I have rigorously demonstrated in any Treatise * on Electricity .
~ 18 .
But if this conducting body , on the surface of the earth , be not insulated ~ , or be but imperfectly insulated , then the whole of such body ( from its being immerged in the electrical atmosphere of the positive cloud ) will become negative ; because part of the electricity of this conducting body will , in this case , pass into the earth .
And this conducting body will become the more negative , as it becomes the more deeply immerged into the dense part of the elastic electrical atmosphere of the approaching thunder-cloud .
* See Principles of Electricity , from ~ 55 to ~ 74 , inclusively .
~ See Principles of Electricity , ~ 182 and ~ 183 .
~ 10 .
Now , when the positive cloud DEF ( in the manner above stated ) comes suddenly to discharge , with an explosion , its superabundant electricity into the other cloud ABC , then the elastic electrical atmosphere of the cloud DEF will cease to exist ; consequently , the electrical fluid , which had been gradually expelled into the common stock , from the conducting body situated ( at L ) upon the surface of the earth , must ( by the sudden removal of the superinduced elastic electrical pressure of the electrical atmosphere of the thunder-cloud ) suddenly return from the earth into the said conducting body , producing a violent * commotion , similar to the pungent shock of a Leyden jar in its sensation and effects .
This is what I call the electrical returning ~ stroke .
~ 20 .
It was by such a returning stroke that LAUDER and the horses that he was driving were killed , they having become strongly negative ~ previous to the explosion .
LAUDER was ` ` sitting ' ' when he was struck dead ; and his legs appear to have been ` ` hanging over the fore-part of the cart , at the time of the explosion .
' ' The returning stroke , therefore , could not issue into his body through his legs ; and this accounts for the ` ` skin of his legs ' ' not having been at all burnt or shrivelled , ' ' as the skin was on many other parts of his body .
And it likewise shows the reason , why the ` ` zigzag line ' ' on LAUDER'S skin ( which was terminated at one end by the chin ) ` ` did not extend lower than the thigh .
' ' * See Principles of Electricity , ~ 304 and ~ 603 .
~ See Principles of Electricity , from ~ 202 to ~ 208 , inclusively , and ~ 387 .
~ Note , I have here supposed the thunder-cloud ( and of course its electrical atmosphere ) to have been positive ; but similar effects would have been produced if the thunder-cloud had been negative ; only , in that case , LAUDER and the horses would have been strongly positive , previous to the explosion .
~ 21 .
Mr. BRYDONE mentions , that ` ` the hair of the horses was much singed over the greatest part of their bodies ; but was most perceptible on the belly and legs .
' ' This effect is easily accounted for by the returning stroke ; for the lower part * of the bodies of those animals must of course have been more strongly affected than any other part , as the electrical fire from the earth must suddenly have rushed into their bodies through ` ` their legs , which had made a deep impression in the dust .
' ' ~ 22 .
The various effects produced on the cart may be explained , with equal facility , by means of the returning stroke ; and I have stated , in my Principles ~ of Electricity , ` ` not only in what manner persons and animals may be destroyed , but how ' ' inanimate bodies , such as ` ` particular parts of buildings , may be considerably damaged by an electrical returning stroke , namely , all those parts where there is , in any kind of conducting substance or substances ( upon which a strong elastic electrical pressure is superinduced ) , any kind of electrical interruption , across which the returning electrical fire might suddenly strike , and might thereby rend and destroy all the bodies that it might meet with in its passage .
' ' Mr. BRYDONE relates , that ` ` splinters had been thrown off in many places , particularly where the timber of the cart was connected by nails or cramps of iron .
' ' The electrical interruption between these pieces of metal , across which interruption the returning electrical fire did suddenly strike , accounts for its rending the bodies that it met with in its passage .
* See , in my Principles of Electricity , the note to ~ 594 , where somewhat of a similar effect is mentioned .
~ See Principles of Electricity , ~ 333 , ~ 334 , and ~ 347 .
It is also evident , that it was the electrical returning fire , that produced the ` ` marks of fusion ' ' on that part of the iron of the wheels which was in contact with the ground ; inasmuch as the whole electricity , that , at the instant of the explosion , returned into the cart , did enter at those places .
~ 23 .
No person , the least versed in the principles of electricity , can hesitate to assent to the proposition , that the electrical returning stroke must exist , under circumstances similar to those explained above .
But it may be objected to me , that although all the aforesaid effects of a returning stroke might take place in a small degree , yet those effects could not have been sufficiently powerful to have killed LAUDER , the horses , and the lamb , or to have melted the iron of the cartwheels ; especially , considering the small quantity of electrical fluid that is contained in the body of a man , of a lamb , or of a horse ; or that is contained in any body of the size of a common cart ; that is to say , considering the small quantity of electrical fluid that could , by being disturbed , have produced the returning stroke .
To this objection ( plausible as at first sight it may appear ) I conceive , I have given a complete answer in my Principles of Electricity , from section 337 to section 347 , inclusively ; and also from section 592 to section 606 , inclusively ; but it may not be improper to add a few words to what I have already said upon that part of the subject .
~ 24 .
No legitimate conclusion can be drawn from premises that are not proved : therefore , no person can legitimately conclude , that the force of a returning stroke must always be weak , when produced by the disturbed electrical fluid of a man 's body , by reason that a man 's body contains but a small quantity of electricity : for , it has never been proved , that a man 's body does contain only a small quantity of electrical fluid ; neither is there the smallest reason to believe such an hypothesis , which appears , on many accounts , to be completely erroneous .
And , if that hypothesis be erroneous , the objection to the strength of an electrical returning stroke remains perfectly unsupported by argument .
When a body is said to be plus or positive , it simply means , that the body contains more electricity than it does in its unelectrified , that is to say , natural state ; but does not signify , that such body is completely saturated * with electricity .
In like manner , when a body is said to be minus or negative , it only signifies , that the body contains less than its natural share of electricity ; but does not imply , that such body is completely exhausted of the electricity which it contains in its natural state .
Now , the strength of natural electricity is so immense , when compared to the very weak effects of our largest and best contrived electrical machines , that I conceive , that we cannot , by means of artificial electricity , expel , from a man 's body , the thousandth ( or perhaps even the ten thousandth ) part of the electrical fluid which it contains , when in its natural state .
~ 25 .
That hypothesis , by which natural phenomenon are easily accounted for , has a better claim to our attention than an opposite hypothesis , which prevents those phenomenon from being intelligibly explained .
There is no reason whatever for concluding , that any electrical machine of any given size is capable of rendering a conducting body either completely plus , or completely minus ; but far otherwise .
And it would have been as logical , for any person , some years ago ( when electrical machines were not brought to * See Principles of Electricity , ~ 342 .
their present state ) , to have maintained , that those very imperfect machines were capable of rendering a conducting body completely positive , or completely negative , as for us , in the year 1787 , to conclude , that we ( by our still imperfect machines ) have attained the limit of electrical exhaustion , or condensation .
We evidently have not , with our machines , even approached the limit of electrical strength , particularly in respect to the returning stroke : for it is remarkable , that ( by the laws of electricity * ) the strength of the electrical returning stroke , near the limit of the striking distance , does increase in a greater ratio , ' ' than the strength of the main stroke from the charged body , producing the elastic electrical atmosphere superinduced .
~ 26 .
For example , let the returning stroke be attempted to be produced , by means of a metallic prime conductor of 20 or 21 inches in length , and of about two inches in diameter ; and by means of another metallic body of equal dimensions , placed parallel to the prime conductor , just out of the limit of the striking distance ; and let the prime conductor be charged , by means of one of the common glass globes , of less than nine inches in diameter .
The returning stroke , in this case , will not only be considerably weaker than a spark taken from the prime conductor , but it will be so extremely weak , that it can hardly be said even to exist .
~ 27 .
Whereas , if the experiment be made in a manner exactly similar , by means of a large glass cylinder ( instead of the small globe ) and by means of a metallic prime conductor , of about three feet four inches long ~ , by nearly four inches and a * See my Principles of Electricity , ~ 340 and ~ 341 .
~ It is better if the prime conductor , and the other metallic body , be still larger .
half diameter * ; and also by means of another metallic body of equal dimensions with this prime conductor ; then , there will be no kind of comparison between the strength of the returning stroke obtained out of the striking distance of the prime conductor , and the strength of the main stroke received immediately from the prime conductor , the sharpness and pungency of the returning stroke being so much superior .
The returning stroke in this case is like the sudden discharge of a weakly electrified Leyden jar , provided that due attention be paid to the four rules for obtaining a very strong returning stroke , as laid down in section 307 of my Principles of Electricity .
~ 28 .
When I performed the experiment of the returning stroke , by means of a still stronger electrical apparatus , the commotion ~ felt was similar to that of a Leyden jar , strongly electrified , suddenly discharged through my body ; so that , having taken the returning stroke eight or ten times one morning ( without having taken the main stroke a single time that day ) , I felt a considerable degree of pain across my chest during the whole evening , and a disagreeable sensation in my arms and wrists all the next day .
I have also found , that ( by an advantageous disposition of the apparatus ) metal ~ may be melted by means of the electrical returning stroke , not only entirely out of the striking distance , but even without any communication with the common stock , although the conducting body , from which issued the electrical * See Principles of Electricity , ~ 593 , 594 , and 595 .
~ See Principles of Electricity , ~ 304 and ~ 310 .
~ See Principles of Electricity , from ~ 603 to ~ 606 , inclusively .
fluid that formed the returning stroke , had less than twenty-seven square feet of surface in contact with the air .
~ 29 .
The fact is , that in the case of the returning stroke , it is not so much upon the quantity of electrical fluid , as upon the velocity * of that fluid , that the strength of that stroke depends ; therefore , the strength of the returning stroke depends less upon the quantity of surface used , than upon the strength of the electrical pressure of the elastic electrical atmosphere , superinduced upon the body struck , previous to the explosion .
But , the electrical pressure of the elastic electrical atmosphere of the great thunder-cloud in Scotland must have been immense , when compared to the electrical pressure of the elastic electrical atmosphere of a metallic prime conductor , of whatsoever shape ; consequently , it is not at all surprising that LAUDER should have been killed ( or that the other effects , related by Mr. BRYDONE , should have been produced ) by the returning stroke ; inasmuch as it is not surprising , that effects should be proportionate to the causes by which they are respectively produced .
~ 30 .
Mr. BRYDONE relates , that ` ` LAUDER'S cart was higher on the bank ' ' than the cart that followed him ; which , in some degree , accounts for the man , sitting on the other cart , not having felt the returning stroke .
But , that is to be accounted for in another way , namely , by supposing the cloud to have been pending nearer to the earth , over the spot where * See Principles of Electricity , from ~ 592 to ~ 602 , inclusively ; and particularly ~ 601 .
LAUDER * was killed , than over the place where his companion was : for , I have shown , in my Treatise upon Electricity ~ , that , in order for a person to receive a dangerous returning stroke , such person should be immerged , not merely in the electrical atmosphere of the thundercloud , but in the dense part of the cloud 's electrical atmosphere .
The fact above alluded to may also be accounted for in the following way , viz. by supposing that the second cart were either better connected with the common stock , or that it were better insulated , than LAUDER'S cart : for , I have shown , in my Principles of Electricity ~ , ( what is very remarkable , namely , ) that either of these two opposite circumstances will weaken the force of a returning stroke prodigiously .
Now , Mr. BRYDONE mentions , that there had been an ` ` almost total want of rain for many months .
' ' He also says , that ` ` the ground ' ' ( at the place where LAUDER was killed ) ` ` was remarkably dry , and of a gravelly soil .
' ' This state of the ground was particularly adapted to the production of the electrical returning stroke , when produced upon the large scale of nature , where the elastic electrical pressure is so powerful .
~ 31 .
The account which Mr. BRYDONE has given of this thunder-storm in Scotland is not more curious than it is instructive .
* See Principles of Electricity , ~ 318 .
~ See , in my Principles of Electricity , Experiments 38 , 39 , and 40 , from ~ 280 to ~ 296 , inclusively .
See also ~ 312 , ~ 318 , ~ 334 , and ~ 307 .
~ See Principles of Electricity , from ~ 248 to ~ 310 , inclusively ~ and see particularly ~ 307 .
In part XIX .
of my Principles of Electricity * , I have enumerated ` ` eleven necessary requisites ' ' in erecting conductors to secure buildings against damage by lightning .
The ninth requisite is ~ , ` ` that there be neither large nor prominent bodies of metal , upon the top of the building proposed to be secured , but such as are connected with the conductor ' ' ( and consequently with the common stock ) ` ` by some proper metallic communication .
' ' And in section 538 , I state , that the consideration of the electrical returning stroke fully evinces the utility of such precaution .
' ' The circumstances mentioned by Mr. BRYDONE , that ` ` splinters had been thrown off in many places , particularly where the timber of the cart was connected by nails , or cramps of iron , ' ' still more fully proves that such precaution is right .
~ 32 .
The tenth ~ necessary requisite in erecting conductors , mentioned in my Principles of Electricity , is , ` ` that there be a sufficient number of rods .
' ' And in section 542 I state that , ` ` the highest parts of a building , the most elevated ridges , all the very prominent stacks of chimneys , and all the most salient angles , ought , in order for the building to acquire the greatest degree of security , to be armed with an high , tapering , and acutely pointed metallic conductor , properly connected with the common stock .
And upon edifices of great importance ( especially magazines of gunpowder ) the pointed conductors ought never to be above * See Principles of Electricity , from ~ 519 to ~ 544 , inclusively ; and particularly see ~ 519 .
~ See Principles of Electricity , ~ 519 and ~ 538 .
~ See Principles of Electricity , ~ 519 ; and from ~ 539 to ~ 542 , inclusively .
forty or fifty feet asunder ; and , if they were to be at still smaller distances asunder , the security they would afford would be still more perfect .
' ' The reason of this precaution is fully explained in many parts of the above-mentioned Treatise , particularly in section 423 * ; and the circumstance , very worthy of observation , related by Mr. BRYDONE , namely , that the distance was only about twenty-four yards , ' ' between LAUDER , who was killed , and his companion , who ` ` was sensible of no shock , nor uncommon sensation , ' ' does clearly demonstrate the propriety of this precaution , of erecting several ~ conducting rods upon an extensive building .
This information must be particularly interesting to the Board of Ordnance , on account of the security of their magazines , particularly their powder magazines at Purfleet .
The * See also Part XVIII .
of my Principles of Electricity ( from ~ 494 to ~ 518 inclusively ) , where I have clearly demonstrated this proposition , namely , that , high and pointed metallic conductors [ when properly constructed , and when made to communicate completely with the common stock ] tend not only to prevent a main stroke of lightning and the lateral explosion ; but tend likewise most powerfully to prevent any dangerous electrical returning stroke whatever from taking place near that part of the edifice upon which they are erected .
So admirable , and so extensive , is the principle upon which is founded this simple and most incomparable invention !
' ' ~ See also ( in the volume LXVIII .
of the Philosophical Transactions , part I. p. 313 .
et seq./ 600 ) the ` ` Report of the Committee , appointed by the Royal Society , to consider of the most effectual Method of securing the Powder Magazines at Purfleet against the Effects of Lightning , in compliance with the Request of the Board of Ordnance ; ' ' in which Report , several high and acutely-pointed conductors , properly connected with the bottom of the wells , are proposed to be erected ; and other precautions , founded on a like principle , are recommended .
security of those magazines is a great national object , not only on account of their importance in time of war ; but , also on account of their vicinity to the City of London .
For , from the immense quantity of gunpowder they contain ( when full ) , their situation upon the river Thames , and their being within the distance of only a few miles of London , those magazines being blown up would probably produce , in the Metropolis , a violent shock , like that of an earthquake .
D E L B C G

