XIV .
On finding the Values of Algebraical Quantities by converging Serieses , and demonstrating and extending Propositions given by Pappus and others .
By Edward Waring , F.R.S. Professor of Mathematics at Cambridge .
Read February 8 , 1787 .
SUPPOSE the roots of the equation xb ~1=0 to be given , where h denotes any whole number or fraction ; to find the roots or values of any given algebraical quantity , by converging infinite serieses .
1 .
Let the algebraical quantity be n ~(~A ) , then the roots of the algebraical quantity will be A1/ n x ( ~ +~~ -1 ) , A1/ n x ( ~ +~~ -1 ) , A1/ n x ( ~ +~~ -1 ) , &amp;c. where ~+~ ~ -1 , ~+~~ -1 , ~+~~ -1 , &amp;c. are the roots of the equation xn~1=0 ; it will be +1 if it was A , and 1 if + A. 2 .
Let the given algebraical quantity be r~ ( ~n~ ( ~A ) ~ m~ ( ~B)~p~~C~ &amp;c. ) , and ~+~~ -1 , ~+~~ -1 , ~+~~ -1 , &amp;c. and T+~~ -1 be respectively one of the roots of the equations xn~1 = 0 , xm~1 = 0 , xp ~1= 0 , &amp;c. and xr~1 = 0 ; substitute ~P= ~A1/ n ~~B1/ n ~~C1/ n ~~ &amp;c. and ~Q = ~A1/ n ~~B1/ m~~C1/ m~~ &amp;c. In the first place let ~ be greater Q , and ~P be + P , then will ( P~Q~ ( -1))1/ r= ( P1/ r 1/ r. 1-r/ 2r x Q2/ P2r-1/ r + 1/ r. 1-r/ 2r .
1-2r/ 3r .
1-3r/ 4r x Q4/ P4r-1/ r &amp;c. = ~L ) ~ ( 1/ r. Q/ Pr-1/ r 1/ r. 1-r/ 2r .
1-2r/ 3r .
Q3/ P3r-1/ r + 1/ r. 1-r/ 2r .
1-2r/ 3r .
1-3r/ 4r .
1-4r/ 5r x Q5/ P5r-1/ r &amp;c. =~ M ) x~1= ~L~M ~ -1 , in which case the two serieses ~L and ~M converge , and ( ~ +~~ -1 ) x ( ~ L ~M ~ -1 ) will be a value or root of the given quantity .
In the same manner the remaining roots may be deduced .
2 .
Let ~P be P , multiply -P~Q ~ ( -1 ) into 1 , and it becomes P~Q ~ ( -1 ) a quantity of the same formula as the preceding ; let ~+~~ ( -1 ) be a root of the equation xr +1= 0 , then will ( ~ +~ ~-1 ) ( ~L~M ~ -1 ) =~H'~K ' ~ ( -1 ) be a root of the given quantity : otherwise ; the root may be deduced from the above-mentioned series by substituting in it for ( P)1/ r its value P1/ r x ( -1)1/ r , and it will become the same as the preceding .
3 .
Let P be less than Q , and the value of ( ~P~Q ~-1)1/ r may be deduced from the preceding series by substituting in it ~Q~-1 for P , and ~P for Q : otherwise , since ( ~P~Q~(-1))1/ r =~2r~ ( -1 ) x ( Q~P ~ ( -1))1/ r , and the root of ( Q~P ~ ( -1))1/ r can be deduced by the preceding method , which suppose L ' + M ' ~ ( -1 ) ; multiply this root into H~~ ~ ( -1 ) , where H+~~ ( -1 ) denotes a value of the root ~ ~2r ( -1 ) , and the quantity resulting will be one value of the given quantity ; the remaining values can be deduced by the same method .
In this case the given quantity is resolved into a series ascending according to the dimensions of P , and descending according to the dimensions of Q ; in the former case it was resolved into a series ascending according to the dimensions of Q , and descending according to the dimensions of P ; both the serieses affording the possible or impossible parts will always converge .
4 .
If P=~Q , then will ( ~P~P ~ ( -1))1/ r = P1/ r x ( ~1~ ~ ( -1))1/ r = P1/ r x 21/ 2r ( ~~ 1/ 2 ~~ -1/ 2)1/ r = P1/ r x 21/ 2r x 4r~ ( -1 ) ; for 4~ ( -1 ) =~~ 1/ 2 ~~ 1/ 2 .
4 .
2 .
When P= 0 , or Q= 0 , then it becomes the first case n~ ( ~A ) .
5 .
Let P=Q~ ~ , where ~ has a very small ratio to Q ; then will ( P~Q~ ( -1))1/ r = ( P~P~~~ ( -1))1/ r = ( P x 21/ 2 x -11/ 4 ~~ ( -1))1/ r = P1/ r x 21/ 2r x 4r~ ( -1 ) ~ 1/ r x P1-r/ r x 21-r/ wr x 4r/ 1-~ ( -1 ) x~ ( -1 ) ~ 1/ r x 1-r/ 2r x P1-2r/ r x 21-2r/ 2r x 4r/ 1-2r~ ( -1 ) x ~2~1/ r. 1-r/ 2r .
1-2r/ 3r x P1-3r/ r x2 1-3r/ 2r x 4r/ 1-3r~(-1 ) x ~ ( -1 ) ~3 + &amp;c. In this series the same root of the quantity 4r~ ( -1 ) is always to be used .
6 .
If in the given quantity are contained more quantities of the above-mentioned kind or their roots ; then , by repeating the same operation , can be deduced the roots or values of the given quantity .
In some cases the impossible part may vanish , which may be the case in a quantity of the following formula , viz. n~a + ~2m~ b+ n~ a+ ~2m~ b+ n~a + ~2m~ b+ &amp;c. where ~ , ~ , ~ , &amp;c. denote the 2m roots of 2m~-1 .
The general principles of discovering the cases in which this happens have been given in the Meditationes Algebraicae .
The roots of the equation xb~1=0 will be found from common algebra and these principles , if h is not greater than 10 ; or , more generally , if h= 2l x 3l ' x 4l'. .
10l8 , where l , l ' , l''. .
ll8 denote any whole numbers : or , in general , the roots of the above-mentioned equation , or even of the equation x= r~~L~M ~ 1 , can be found from tables of sines .
The same principles may be applied to the discovery of the values of exponential irrational quantities .
In the Miscel .
Analy .
was given , from a substitution invented by me and not similar to any before given , a resolution of equations , which contains the resolutions of all equations before given , and from which the resolutions of some equations , not before delivered , have been added .
Part II .
1 .
Let an equation A=0 involving ( r ) unknown independent quantities be predicated of another equation containing the same quantities , and the demonstration of it be required .
1st .
Reduce both the equations to equations involving independent quantities only ; then reduce the two equations to one , so that one of the above-mentioned quantities may be exterminated , and if there results a self-evident equation , viz. A= A , or AA= 0 , in which the correspondent terms destroy each other respectively ; then the first equation is justly predicated of the second ; that is , if the above-mentioned equations afford the same value of the quantity exterminated , the proposition is true , otherwise not .
Cor. From these principles can be demonstrated many propositions given by PAPPUS and others .
Ex. Let AD=2AC=2x , DE=a , and EB=b , where AD , DE , and EB , are independent quantities ; if AB x BE = ( 2x+a+b ) xb= CB x BD = ( x+a+b ) ACDEB ( a+b ) , then will CB = x+a+b : BD= a+b : : AC x CE=x x ( x+a ) : AD x DE =2x x a. From hence can be deduced the two equations ( b-a ) x=a2+ab and 2a x ( x+a+b ) = ( a+b ) x ( x+a ) ; reduce these two equations to one , so as to exterminate x , and there results the self-evident equation ( a-b ) x a2+ab/ b-a ( -a2 -ab ) + a2 + ab = 0 , and consequently the proposition is true .
2 .
If ( s ) equations involving ( t + r ) unknown and independent quantities be predicated of ( t ) equations involving the above-mentioned quantities : reduce the ( t ) equations and one of the above-mentioned ( s ) equations to one , so that ( t ) unknown quantities may be exterminated , and if there results a selfevident equation , then the above-mentioned equation is justly predicated of the ( t ) equations ; and in the same manner we may reason concerning the remaining ( s 1 ) equations .
3 .
1 .
If one equation is justly predicated of another , and in both the unknown quantity exterminated has only one dimension ; then the latter equation can be predicated of the former ; for in this case both equations have only one and the same value of the unknown quantity exterminated .
3 .
2 .
If the quantity exterminated has more dimensions than one in the equations , then the proposition may not geneL 2 rally rally be true ; for the equations may have some roots the same , but not all .
These observations may be applied to more equations .
4 .
From ( n ) given equations a= 0 , b= 0 , c= 0 , &amp;c. can easily be deduced others dependent on them , by finding any direct algebraical functions of the above-mentioned equations , that is , ~ ( a , b , c , &amp;c. ) , which will always = 0 ; and in like manner , from the relation between any lines being given , can be deduced innumerable relations between the above-mentioned lines , and other lines dependent on them .
PartIII .
1 .
Ratios , which are supposed greateror less than others , can easily be transformed into equations , which contain affirmative and negative quantities : for example , let the ratio a : b be greater than the ratio c : d , then will b/ a = c/ d k ; if it be less , then will b/ a = c/ d + k , where k denotes an affirmative quantity ; and , vice versa , if b/ a = c/ a k , then will the ratio of a : b be greater than the ratio of c : d , &amp;c. 2 .
If one quantity ( a ) is affirmed to be greater than another b , for a in the given equations substitute its value b+ k ; if less , for a write b k , where k denotes an affirmative quantity .
3 .
Reduce the equations , so as to take away their denominators , and the demonstration of the proposition will often very easily follow .
4 .
Let k= P/ Q and k ' = P'/ Q ' ; and if P and Q be affirmative , let P ' and Q ' be affirmative ; and , vice versa , if negative , negative ; then , if k be affirmative , will k ' also be affirmative ; the same also may be affirmed , if P and Q have both contrary trary signs to P ' and Q ' ; but if one has the same , and the other contrary , then will k and k ' have contrary signs .
5 .
Let some affirmative quantities be less than others , then any direct affirmative function of the former , viz. function , in which no negative or impossible quantities or indexes are contained , will be less than the same function of the latter .
The contrary happens when the indexes are all negative , and the quantities affirmative as before : for example , let two quantities be less than two others , then the product of the two former will be less than the product of the two latter .
Cor. Hence some quantities may often be known to be greater or less than others from their direct functions being greater or less than the same functions of the others : for example , let a2 b2 be an affirmative quantity , then will a be greater than b. 6 .
If one equation or ratio is affirmed on the supposition that another given one is true , reduce both the equations by the methods given above , and from the principles before delivered , the proposition will often be evident .
Hence may be deduced demonstrations to propositions of this sort given by PAPPUS and others .
Ex. Let the ratio a+ b : b be greater than c+ d : d , then the ratio b : ab will be less than d : c d. For , since the ratio a+ b : b is greater than c+ d : d , the ratio b : a+b will be less than d : c+ d , and consequently a+ b/ b ( a/ b + 1 ) =c+ d/ d ( c/ d + 1 ) + k , whence a/ b 1= c/ d 1+ k , and a b/ b =c d/ d + k , and the ratio b : ab less than d : c d. Ex. 2 .
Let the ratio of a+ b : c+d be greater than the ratio of a : c , then will the ratio of b : d be greater than the ratio of a+ b : c+ d. By the preceding method convert these ra7 tios tios into equations , and there result c+ d/ a +b+k= c/ a and d/ b + k ' = c+ d/ a + b ; and the proposition asserts , that if k be an affirmative quantity , k ' will also be an affirmative quantity .
Reduce these two equations , so as to take away their denominators , and the resulting equations will be ac + ad +ax ~a +bxk= ac + bc and ad + bd + ~a + b. bk ' = bc + bd , whence k= bc ad/ a(a + b ) and k ' = bc ad/ b ( a + b ) , and the proposition is evident .
Ex. 3 .
Let a be greater than c , and b , and ( a + b ) x ( a b ) = ( c + d ) x ( c d ) , that is , a2 b2 = c2 d2 , then will b be greater than d ; for a in the equation a2 b2 = c2 d2 write c+ k , and there results 2ck + k2 = b2 d2 , whence b2 d2 is an affirmative quantity , and consequently b greater than d. Ex. 4 .
Let , as in Ex. 1 .
the ratio a+ b : b be greater than c+ d : d , then will b : ab be less than the ratio d : c d. By the preceding method translate these ratios into the two equations b/ a +b+k= d/ c +d and a b/ b =c d/ d + k ' , reduce these equations , so as to take away their denominators , and there result bc + bd + ~a +bx ~c + dk = ad + bd and da db = bc bd + bdk ' , and consequently k= ad bc/ ( a + b ) ( c + d ) and k ' = ad bc/ bd ; but these two fractions which express the values of k and k ' have the same numerators , and their denominators both affirmative ; therefore , if one k be affirmative , the other k ' will also be affirmative .
Cor. From these principles can easily be deduced innumerable propositions of this sort .
Assume two or more ratios , of which let some be supposed greater than others ; then , from the above-mentioned transformation , by addition , subtraction , multiplication , division , &amp;c. can be found such functions of the above-mentioned quantities , that some may become greater than others , and thence may be deduced the propositions abovementioned .
7 .
It may not be improper in this place to adjoin a few observations on finding the limits of some quantities in which others contained in given equations become negative or affirmative .
1 .
Given an equation involving two unknown quantities x and y ; the limits of the quantity y , between which the quantity x will become affirmative or negative , may be deduced from the following principles .
The quantity x passes from affirmative to negative or from negative to affirmative , either through nothing or infinite ; or from two impossible roots it passes to affirmative or negative through two or more equal roots ; and , vice versa , from affirmative or negative to two or more impossible roots through two or more equal roots .
Find therefore the values of y , when x becomes = 0 , or infinite ; and also all the cases in which two , &amp;c. values of x become equal , that is , when its roots become impossible ; and from thence can be deduced the limits of the quantity y , between which ( x ) becomes affirmative or negative .
2 .
If x= P/ Q be an affirmative quantity , then P will be affirmative or negative , according as Q is an affirmative or negative quantity , &amp;c. Assume therefore P=0 and Q= 0 , and from the roots of the resulting equation can be deduced the cases , in which ( x ) becomes an affirmative quantity .
3 .
If more ( n ) unknown quantities ( x , y , z , v , &amp;c. ) be contained in a given equation ; then , by the preceding method , find the limits of ( z , v , &amp;c. ) , between which ( x ) becomes an affirmative or negative quantity , and let the quantities denoting the limits contain not more than ( n 1 ) unknown quantities : from the above-mentioned quantities or equations expressing the limits , find others denoting their limits , which do not contain more than ( n 2 ) above-mentioned quantities , and so on .
4 .
Often from the substitution of the limits of given quantities can be acquired the limits of the remaining one ( x ) .
Find all the greatest values of the quantity ( x ) contained between the above-mentioned limits , and thence can be deduced the limits sought .
5 .
If there are given ( m ) equations involving g(m + 1 ) or more unknown quantities ; then sometimes with , and sometimes without , reducing them to others involving more few unknown quantities can be found by the preceding method limits : and from comparing the limits so acquired can sometimes be deduced the limits sought .
6 .
If a given function of the unknown quantities ( x , y , z , &amp;c. ) is asserted to be contained between given limits , when other functions of the above-mentioned quantities are contained between given limits , and the demonstration of it is required ; from the given equations and the given functions find limits of the unknown quantities respectively , and if the latter limits are contained between the former , the proposition is generally true , otherwise not .
7 .
From the above-mentioned principles can be found the cases in which an unknown quantity ( x ) admits of one or more affirmative values .
8 .
It appears from the principles before delivered , that the finding the number of affirmative and negative roots of a given equation necessarily includes the finding the number of its impossible roots ; and therefore it may not be improper to subjoin somewhat on what has been done on this subject .
1 .
DESCARTES gave a method of finding the number of affirmative and negative roots of a given equation , when all its roots are possible ; but all the roots are very seldom in equations of superior dimensions possible , unless when the equation is purposedly made .
2 .
It has been demonstrated by others and myself , that the equation will at least have so many changes of signs from + to - , and to + , as there are affirmative roots , and so many continued progresses from + to + and to - , as there are negative roots .
3 .
A rule for finding in general the number of affirmative or negative roots in a biquadratic , and in the equation xn + Anm +B= 0 , was first published in the Medit .
Algebr .
4 .
HARRIOT demonstrated a method of finding the number of impossible roots contained in a cubic equation .
In the year 1757 I sent to the Royal Society a method of finding the number of impossible roots contained in a biquadratic and quadrato-cubic equations , and in the equation xn ~ Axm ~B= 0 .
5 .
SCHOOTEN gave a method of finding the number of impossible roots which can be concluded from the deficient terms of an equation .
NEWTON gave a rule which often discovers the number of impossible roots contained in a given equation .
CAMPBELL discovered a new rule on the same subject .
Mr. MACLAURIN has added somewhat more general on these subjects : these rules may be rendered more general by a principle first given in the Miscell .
Analyt .
viz. multiplying the given equation into a quantity xa or ( x a ) x ( x b ) , &amp;c. and finding from the rule the number of impossible roots contained in the given equation .
Similar and more general rules and principles have been added in the Medit .
Algebr .
These rules , in equations of superior dimensions , seldom discover the true number of imV O L. LXXVII .
M possible possible roots .
I believe also , that I first gave a rule in the Miscell .
Analyt .
for finding the number of impossible roots from finding an equation , whose roots are the squares &amp;c. of the roots of a given equation , which rule in equations of superior dimensions sometimes finds impossible roots , when NEWTON'S , CAMPBELL'S , &amp;c. rules fail , and fails when they find them ; and also a rule for finding impossible roots from an equation , whose roots are the squares of the differences of the roots of the given equation ; this rule ( as has been observed by me in the Miscell .
Analyt .
and Philosophical Transactions ) always discovers whether all the roots of the given equation are possible or not ; and the last term of the resulting equation discovers also , whether 0 , 4 , 8 , 12 , &amp;c. or 2 , 6 , 10 , 14 , &amp;c. impossible roo 's , are contained in the given equation ; to which may be subjoined , if the given equation has r possible and nr= 2t impossible roots , that the number of changes of signs from + to and to + in the resulting equation will not be less than r. r 1/ 2 , and the number of continued progresses from + to + and to will not be less than t : whence , if the number of continued progresses be t ' , the number of impossible roots will not be greater than 2t ' , and the number of possible roots not less than n 2t ' .
If the number of changes of signs be h ' , the number of possible roots will not be greater than r ' , where r ' x r ' 1/ 2 is the greatest possible number which does not exceed h ' , and the number of impossible roots not less than n r ' .
Another rule was , I believe , first given by me in the Miscell .
Analyt .
1762 , for finding impossible roots by finding an equation whose roots are z , where xn pxn-1 + qxn-2 &amp;c. = z , and nxn-1 n1 pxn-2 +n2 qxn-2 &amp;c. = 0 .
In the Medit .
Algebr .
somewhat has been added concerning impossible , affirmative , and negative values of the unknown quantities in an equation which involves two or more unknown quantities ; and also was first delivered a rule from the number of affirmative , negative , and impossible roots of an equation being known to find the number of impossible , negative , and affirmative roots of an equation , whose roots have a given algebraical relation to the roots of a given equation ; on which two last subjects little , I believe , had been before published .

