VII .
Determination of the Heliocentric Longitude of the descending Node of Saturn .
By Thomas Bugge , Professor of Astronomy in the University of Copenhagen ; communicated by Sir Joseph Banks , Bart. P. R. S. Read December 7 , 1786 .
THE culmination of Saturn was observed with a 6-feet achromatic transit-instrument , and the planet compared with ~ and ~ of Sagittarius , whose apparent right-ascensions in the middle of August 1784 were 282~ 56~ 54~ and 284~ 14~ 33~ .
The meridian altitude was observed with a 6-feet mural quadrant .
The original observations are to be published in the second volume of my Astronomical Observations .
From those are calculated the right-ascension and declination , the geocentric longitude and latitude , of Saturn , which are to be depended upon to 4 or 6 seconds .
Those observed longitudes and latitudes are compared with the tables of Dr. HALLEY and of M. DE LA LAND .
In the errors of the tables + signifies that the longitude of the tables is less than the observed longitude ; and the meaning of is , that the calculated longitude is greater than the observed .
It ought to be observed , that the heliocentric longitudes of Dr. HALLEY'S Tables have been corrected for the perturbations after the principles of M. LAMBERT ( Memoires de Berlin , pour 1783 , p. 216 .
and Collection des Tables Astronomiques de Berlin , tom .
II .
p. 269 .
) ~ culmiThe error of The error of M. nation , ~ observed ~ observHALLEY DE LA LAND .
1784 mean time longitude .
ed latiat Copen .
tude .
in long .
in lat. in long .
in lat. h. ' ' ' s. o ' ' ' o ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' July 12 12 319 20 34~ 48 03 35 B+2 22 + 32 9 40 + 33 20 11 29 99 19 59 39 02 59 +2 14 + 38 Aug. 1 10 38 25 9 19 9 22 01 44 +1 45 + 27 9 49 + 28 8 10 909 18 42 56 012+1 48 + 21 21 9 14 59 9 18 1 23 002+1 35 + 28 27 8 50 19 9 17 46 19 00 29A +1 26 26 9 35 30 31 8 33 47 9 17 38 700 53 +1 19 23 Sept. 58 13 45 9 17 29 36 01 26 +1 20 25 9 25 27 15 7 33 45 9 17 19 39 024+1 18 25 Oct. 864 23 9 17 34 603 57 +1 22 26 8 48 32 In order to reduce the observed geocentric longitude to the sun , or by observation to find the heliocentric longitude , it is required to know the angle at the planet = p. If this angle is calculated in the common way only by the tables , there will arise some difference , according to the different elements and the different constructions of the tables .
Thus , at the time of Saturn 's culmination , this angle is found the 12th of July , by the tables of Dr. HALLEY = 0~ 3~ 13~ , and by the tables of M. DE LA LAND = 0~ 2~ 0~ ; the 8th of August by HALLEY = 2~ 43~ 35~ , and by M. DE LA LAND = 2~ 42~ 34~ ; the 27th of August after Dr. HALLEY = 4~ 14~ 15~ , and after M. DE LA LAND = 4~ 13~ 47~ .
To avoid those differences , which often may alter the heliocentric longitude more than one or two minutes , the following method may be useful .
The heliocentric longitude of the earth , calculated after the tables of M. MAYER , is to be depended upon to eight or ten seconds .
From the heliocentric longitude of the earth , and from the observed geocentric longitude of the planet , corrected for the aberration and nutation , is deduced the angle at the earth = t , or the distance between the sun and the planet seen from the earth .
The dimensions of the elliptical orbit of the planet are so far ascertained , that the logarithms of the distance from the sun have not any material difference in the different tables .
From the angle t , the distance of the earth from the sun , and the distance of the planet from the sun , the angle p is calculated to a sufficient degree of accuracy .
Thus , the 12th of July , by the distances of Dr. HALLEY , p= 0~ 2~ 59~ , and by the distances of M. DE LA LAND = 0~ 2~ 59~ ; the 8th of August after Dr. HALLEY p= 2~ 43~ 25~ , and after M. DE LA LAND p= 2~ 43~ 36~ ; the 27th of August after Dr. HALLEY p= 4~ 14~ 10~ , and after M. DE LA LAND p= 4~ 14~ 28~ .
The difference very seldom will amount to 20 seconds , and is of no consequence in this matter .
From the observed geocentric latitude of the angle at the sun = s , and the angle at the earth = t , the heliocentric latitude of the planet is found = tang .
lat. geoc .
x sin. s/ sin. t. Mean time at ~ observed helio~ ~ observed helio1784 Copenhagen .
centric longitude .
centric latitude .
h. ' ' ' s. o ' ' ' o ' ' ' July 12 12 319 20 37 29 03 13 B 20 11 29 99 20 51 53 02 41 Aug. 1 10 38 85 9 21 13 17 01 34 8 10 909 21 26 200 56 21 9 14 59 9 21 49 27 002 27 8 50 19 9 22 0 12 00 27 A 31 8 33 47 9 22 7 32 00 50 Sept. 58 13 45 9 22 16 28 01 21 15 7 33 45 9 22 34 32 01 59 Oct. 864 23 9 23 16 15 03 35 When two heliocentric longitudes , and the corresponding northern and southern latitude are given , the distance of A E N D of the node from one of the longitudes or places may be found .
Let DE be the ecliptic , AF the orbit of the planet , N the node , DE the difference between the two observed heliocentric longitudes = a , OF the southern latitude = d , AD the northern latitude = b , NO the distance of the node from the heliocentric place at E , and corresponding to the southern latitude = x. In the spherical triangles ADN and FEN , sin. ( a x)/ tang .
b= cot .
N= sin. x/ tang .
~ .
By placing the value of sin. ( a x ) in the equation sin. a. cos. x sin. x. cos. a/ tang .
b= sin. x/ tang .
~ .
By resolving this equation sin. x/ cos. x= tang .
x= sin. a. tang .
~/ tang .
b+ cos. a. tang .
~ .
If a , b , and ~ , are very small arcs , which commonly is the case with the planets , then sin. a= a , tang .
~= ~ , tang .
b= b , and cos. a= 1 .
Hence the spherical formula will be transformed into another x= a~/ b + ~ .
This formula belongs to plane geometry , and may besides be thus demonstrated .
DN : NO = AD : OF .
Hence DN + NO : NO = AD + OF : OF ; and NO = DE x OF / AD + OF .
If the difference of the longitudes do not exceed one degree , and the latitudes are not greater than ten minutes , the spherical and the rectilineal formula will agree to very few seconds .
Small faults in the longitude will not very much alter the true place of the node ; but very small errors in the latitude are of great consequence .
Let the error in the southern heliocentric latitude be FG = + d. The error in the northern latitude AH = d. Hence DH : Dn = GE : En , and En =a ( ~ + d)/ b + ~ .
By subtracting EN = A NO D F ~ H nNE D F = a~/ b + ~ , the error in the heliocentric longitude of the node , Nn = ad/ b + ~ .
If the fault in the southern latitude = d , in the northern latitude =+ d , the same formula is still true ; but then EN &gt; En , and the place of the erroneous node will be between E and N. In both cases the errors in the place of the node are directly as the errors in the latitudes .
Let us now suppose , that only the one latitude is erroneous ~ d. Then Nn =~ En~EN =ax ( ~ ~~d/ b+~~d ~ ~/ b + ~ ) = abd/ ( b + ~)2 ~d(b + ~ ) .
In the case when the error in both latitudes in positive =+ d , and ~ &gt; b , or ~ &lt; b , the resulting error in the place of the node = ad ( ~b~~)/ ( b + ~)2 + 2d ( b + ~ ) .
In the case when the error in both latitudes is negative d , and ~ &gt; b , or ~ &lt; b , then the error in the node = ad ( ~b~~)/ ( b + ~)2 2d ( b + ~ ) .
In those two cases the error is less than in any of the former , and quite nothing when b=~ .
If the radius of the instrument , with which the meridian altitudes are observed , is given , the quantity of d is also given .
In a mural quadrant of 6 or 8 feet d=5 or 3 seconds .
Take a= 34~ 3~ , b= 56~ , ~= 27~ , d= 5~ , and the error in the southern latitude + d , in the northern = d ; then Nn = 10215~/ 83 = 2~ 12~ .
Take now the error only in the southern latitude =+ d ; then Nn = 572040~/ 7304 = 1~ 18~ ; in the case of d ; Nn = 572040~/ 6474 = 1~ 28~ .
From hence it appears , that in comparing VO L. LXXVII .
G two A NO n D F two single observations , it scarce will be possible to avoid a fault of ~2 minutes in the place of the node .
If the instrument is of a less force than a mural quadrant of 6 feet , and the possible faults in the altitudes greater , for example , 10 or 15 seconds , the resulting error in the place of the node may very easily be calculated ; but the error in the node will be enormous , and the observations of no use for a nice astronomer .
~ heliocentric Heliocentric Compared Observations longitude on the ~ distance longitude of 1784 .
last day .
from the ~ .
~~ s. o ' ' ' o ' ' ' s. o ' ' ' July 12 with Sept. 15 9 22 34 32 0 44 38 9 21 49 54 July 12 Oct. 89 23 16 15 1 23 41 9 21 52 36 July 20 Sept. 15 9 22 34 32 0 43 37 9 21 50 55 July 20 Oct. 89 23 16 15 1 22 33 9 21 53 42 Aug. 1 Sept. 59 22 16 28 0 29 15 9 21 47 13 Aug. 1 Sept. 15 9 22 34 32 0 45 23 9 21 49 9 Aug. 1 Oct. 89 23 16 15 1 25 34 9 21 50 41 Aug. 8 Aug. 27 9 22 0 12 0 11 79 21 49 5 Aug. 8 Aug. 31 9 22 7 32 0 19 34 9 21 47 58 Aug.21 Aug. 27 9 22 0 12 0 10 09 21 50 12 Aug.21 Aug. 31 9 22 7 32 0 17 23 9 21 50 9 Mean 9 21 50 8,5 This mean agrees pretty well with the observations on the 21st , 27th , and 31st of August , which are nearest the node , and most to be depended upon .
The 21st of August , at 9 h. 12~ 26~ true time at Copenhagen , the heliocentric longitude of Saturn =9 s. 21~ 49~ 27~ , and the distance from the node = 41~ .
The 27th of August , at 8 h. 49~ 23~ , the heliocentric longitude =9 s. 22~ 0~ 12~ ; therefore , in 5 days 23 h. 36~ 57~ Saturn has described an arc of 10~ 45~ , and 10~ 45~ : 5 d. 23 h. 36~ 57~ = 41~ : x. Hence Saturn has spent 9 h. 7~ 44~ in going through those 41~ ; and Saturn 's passage through the node happened August 21 , 1784 , at 18 h. 20~ 10~ , and the heliocentric longitude of his descending node =9 s. 21~ 50~ 8~,5 .
The errors in the place of the node are relative to the tables of Dr. HALLEY + 19~ 39~ , to the tables of M. CASINI + 16~ 4~ , and to the tables of M. DE LA LAND + 1~ 31~ .
In the foregoing computation of Saturn 's heliocentric longitude from the tables of Dr. HALLEY , this longitude has been corrected for the perturbation after the principles of M. LAMBERT .
Though the geocentric places , calculated in this manner , will agree still better with the observations than without those perturbations , nevertheless they are only empiric , and not founded upon the theory and principles of gravitation ; I shall therefore conclude this Paper , by adding the faults in the heliocentric places of Saturn , calculated only and directly from the tables of Dr. HALLEY , which may be of some use to improve those valuable tables , ~ heliocentric lon~ heliocentric la1784 gitude from Dr. Error in titude from Dr. Error in HALLEY'S tables .
longitude .
HALLEY'S tables .
latitude .
s. o ' ' ' ' ' ' o ' ' ' ' ' July 12 9 20 27 40 +9 49 02 45 B +28 20 9 20 42 3 +9 50 02 17 +24 Aug. 19 21 3 41 +9 36 01 10 +24 89 21 16 19 +9 43 00 37 +21 21 9 21 39 45 +9 42 00 24 A -22 27 9 21 50 34 +9 38 00 53 -26 31 9 21 57 47 +9 45 01 11 -21 Sept. 59 22 6 48 +9 40 01 45 -24 15 9 22 24 50 +9 42 02 22 -23 Oct. 89 23 6 33 +9 44 041 -26

