III .
Observations on the Class of Animals called , by Linnaeus , Amphibia ; particularly on the Means of distinguishing those Serpents which are venomous , from those which are not so .
By Edward Whitaker Gray , M. D. F. R. S. Read December 18 , 1788 .
OF the various classes of the animal kingdom , no one has been so little attended to as the class , called by LINNAEUS , Amphibia .
What he himself did in that class ( though far superior to what any other person has done ) was evidently done in a hurry ; false references are , at least , as common in that , as in any other part of his works , and many of his descriptions are given in a very careless manner ; others there are , however , which are truly worthy of their author , and in which the specific characters are pointed out with that clearness and precision , which so eminently distinguish the descriptions of LINNAEUS from those of all his predecessors .
In the construction of the class , LINNAEUS has been particularly unfortunate ; as he has erred , not only in making an unilocular heart one of the characters of it , but also in making the cartilaginous fishes a part of it .
I think it needless to mention the causes which led him to this latter error ; every anatomist now agrees that the Amphibia Nantes are not furnished with lungs ; and every naturalist is convinced of the propriety of removing them , from the class of Amphibia , to that of Fishes .
I shall only observe that , by the removal , the name of the class ( which some naturalists have cavilled at ) becomes much less objectionable ; there being few genera , in the two orders of which it is now presumed to consist , which do not contain animals to which the term amphibious may , with some propriety , be given ; whereas , in the order of Nantes , not one species occurs which has the smallest claim to that title .
With respect to the other error I noticed ( viz. that of supposing the hearts of the Amphibia to be single ) it would be easy to show that it was not an uncommon one , at the time LINNAEUS formed his system .
And indeed he appears to have been led into it , by following an author whom he probably supposed of too great fame not to be safely relied on .
At least , in defence of his opinion , he quotes the following words of BOERHAAVE .
` ` In omnibus animalibus in quibus sanguis non calet , ventriculus cordis est unicus .
' ' Whether the hearts of all the different genera , of which the class is composed , have yet been accurately examined ; and whether an exact similarity of structure is found throughout the class ; are questions I do not mean , at present , to examine .
It is sufficient for my purpose to observe , that the hearts of most of the Amphibia are now well known to be double , with an immediate communication between the two cavities ; which structure seems peculiarly adapted to that change of element , which ( as I before observed ) many of them can , for a time , support ; and thereby furnishes another argument in favour of the name LINNAEUS has given to the class .
To consider the structure of the heart , however , is not absolutely necessary in forming the characters of the class : the animals of which it consists being sufficiently distinguished from all others , by having cold red blood , and breathing by means of lungs .
These two characters render the class perfectly distinct from the rest ; the two superior ones , viz. Mammalia and Birds , having warm blood ; and the three inferior ones , viz. Fishes , Insects , and Worms , not being furnished with lungs .
In his generic characters , LINNAEUS has been more successful than in those of the class ; insomuch that they may , I think , be considered as the best hitherto given .
Whoever will be at the pains of comparing LINNAEUS'S genera of Amphibia with those of GRONOVIUS , will find , that the generic characters of the former , though few in number , are precise and distinct ; while those of the latter , though more numerous , are vague , indistinct , and sometimes inaccurate .
As a glaring instance of inaccuracy , I need only refer to the Chamaeleon , which by GRONOVIUS is made a distinct genus , of which one of his characters is , Pedes unguibus destituti ; whereas , in fact , the feet of that animal are furnished with very distinct , and pretty large , claws .
But though LINNAEUS'S genera of Amphibia are , upon the whole , well formed , it must be allowed to be a great imperfection in them , that the venomous serpents are not separated from the others .
From some expressions of his , in the Preface to the Museum Regis , and in the Introduction to the Class Amphibia , in the Systema Naturae , it seems , that he thought it not easy to distinguish them , by any external characters ; and his ideas respecting the venomous fangs themselves were ( as we shall see hereafter ) so vague and confused , that it was hardly possible for him to attempt to found a generic distinction upon them * .
* As a sort of comparative excuse for LINNAEUS , it may be observed , that GRONOVIUS ( though he made two more genera of Serpents than LINNAEUS ) did not separate the venomous ones ; neither has he distinguished them by a mark ( as LINNAEUS has ) or by any other means .
Whether venomous Serpents can be , with certainty , distinguished from others , and if so , how they are to be known , is what I mean to consider in this Paper ; in doing which I shall examine , first , how far they may be distinguished by any external characters ; secondly , supposing the venomous fangs to be the only certain criterion , how those fangs are to be distinguished from common teeth .
Though Serpents , by their internal organization , naturally belong to the third class of the animal kingdom , they are , in their external form , more simple than most of the animals belonging to the three inferior classes ; their external characters must consequently be very few .
I shall first examine those of the head ; and , as all venomous Serpents ( so far as our present experience extends ) are contained in the three first of LINNAEUS'S genera , I shall , at present , consider only those three .
In the first genus , Crotalus , the head is broader than the neck , depressed or flat at top , and covered with small scales .
These three characters are particularly observable in the three intermediate species horridus , Dryinas , and Durissus .
In the miliarius the scales of the head are rather larger than in the others .
The mutus I have never seen ; but it certainly should not be placed among the Crotali * .
As all the species of this genus are venomous , one is naturally led , by the examination of it , to consider the forementioned characters as being , in some measure , proper to venomous serpents .
In order to see how far they are so , I shall , for the present , pass over the next genus , Boa , and consider * LINNAEUS'S reason for not placing it among the Boae seems to have been , that he supposed none of them were venomous .
He appears , however , to have had his doubts about the contortrix .
I have examined it , and am convinced it is venomous .
that which follows it , Coluber .
In that genus are many venomous species , and it is very certain that , in general , they have the fore-mentioned characters ; examples of which may be seen in the Atropos , Cerastes * , atrox , Berus , and others .
It is , however , equally certain , that there are some in which they are not to be found .
As an example of this , I need only mention the Naja , a species well known to be very venomous ; the head of which is neither depressed nor broad , is covered with large scales , and is , in every respect , a complete exception to what has been said , respecting the heads of venomous Serpents .
Since then , there are venomous Serpents in which the fore-mentioned characters , viz. a broad and depressed head , covered with small scales , are not to be found ; I shall next examine whether those characters are to be found in any of those Serpents which are not venomous .
In the genus Coluber there are very few ( except venomous ones ) which have the head much broader than the neck ; and of those few , I believe , every one has the head covered with large scales .
But in the genus Boa , though no species is venomous , except the contortrix , almost every one has the head broad , depressed , and covered with small scales .
The canina , Constrictor , hortulama , besides some others not described by LINNAEUS , furnish * The Cerastes is hot marked by LINNAEUS as a venomous species .
He probably depended upon HASSELQUIST'S description , which I suspect to have been made from a mutilated specimen .
Mr. ELLIS'S description in the Philosophical Transactions , Vol. LVI .
p. 287 .
is only a Translation of HASSELQUIST'S .
But he observes , that Dr. TURNBULL told him it was venomous .
That it is so , I have not the smallest doubt , though in the only specimen I have seen of it the sangs were wanting .
IMPERATO , who has given a figure of it ( Hist. Not .
p. 784 .
Ed. Nap .
) .
says it is very venomous .
examples of this .
It must , however , be confessed , that the general character of the head of the Boa , though differing very widely from that of those Colubri which are not venomous , is not quite that of the Crotalus ; but the difference , though very obvious to a person accustomed to the examination of Serpents , is perhaps not easy to be fully expressed in words .
It seems , however , to consist principally in a lateral compression , and elongation , of the anterior part of the head , so as to form a kind of snout .
Hence the trivial name of canina is given by LINNAEUS to one of the species .
From the characters of the head ( as the trunk affords none deserving consideration ) I shall proceed to those of the other extremity .
In the Crotali I have never found the tail ( exclusive of the Rattle ) to exceed one-ninth part of the whole length ; sometimes I have found it much shorter .
In some of the venomous Colubri , the proportion is still less .
In the Atropos I found it only one-thirteenth .
In the English Viper ( Coluber Berus ) it is commonly about one-seventh or eighth .
In some venomous species , however , the proportion is something greater .
In the Naja I have found it as much as one-sixth ; which proportion is , I believe , as great as I have ever observed : but that I may be sure to keep within the truth , I will only say , that I have never met with a venomous Serpent , the tail of which was equal to one-fifth of the whole length* .
* The tail of the Boa contortrix is said by LINNAEUS to be one-third ; but his own enumeration of the Scuta sufficiently shows that this must be an error .
The Coluber Leberis , Dipsas , and mycterizans appear , by the number of scales under their tail , to furnish exceptions to what I have said .
The two first I have never seen , but suspect they are not venomous ; that the last is not so I am very certain , having examined many specimens of it .
With respect to those Colubri which are not venomous , it must be confessed , that there are many whose tails are within the limits assigned to the venomous ones .
In the Coluber AEsculapii , doliatus , getulus , and some others , the tail is not , in general , more than one-seventh of the whole length .
In the lemniscatus I have found it not exceeding one-twelfth or thirteenth ; but I know no other Linnaean species in which it is so short .
In the greater number , however , the proportion of tail is more considerable ; in many , it is full one-third .
In the Ahaetulla , and in some species not described by LINNAEUS , I have seen it more than two-fifths ; but have never met with a species in which it was quite so long as the trunk , or half of the whole length .
I have not considered the Boae , because none of the Linnaean species , of that genus , have their tails either remarkably long , or short ; but , in two species , not described LINNAEUS , I found the tail very little exceeding the proportion I have assigned to the Coluber lemniscatus .
In the thickness of the tail , or in the acuteness of its termination , I have observed no difference worth remarking .
In every species of the three first genera , the tail is thinner than the trunk ; and in most of them it is more or less acute .
The few exceptions I have observed were , I believe , none of them venomous ; but they are too few to deserve any particular consideration .
A character of great use in distinguishing the species of Serpents , and which was not overlooked by LINNAEUS , is , that elevated line , or carina , with which the scales of many species are furnished .
In order to show how far this is to be considered as serving to distinguish venomous Serpents from others , I need only observe , that I have examined one hundred and twelve species of Serpents , not venomous , belonging to the three first genera ; and find that eighty of them have smooth scales , and thirty-two only have carinated ones .
Of venomous Serpents I have examined twenty-six ; of which number , twenty have carinated scales , and only six have smooth ones .
Upon the whole , therefore , carinated scales must be considered as being , in some measure , a character of venomous Serpents .
In what I have hitherto said , I have considered only the three first genera of Serpents ; I shall now make some remarks upon the three last .
These three ( viz. Anguis , Amphisbaena , and Caecilia ) , besides the characters assigned them by LINNAEUS , have some others which are common to all , and which render them very different , in their external appearance , from any of the three first genera .
These are , a very thick and obtuse tail , and a head which is very indistinct * , and furnished with very small eyes .
This last character ( viz. very small eyes ) is sometimes , though very rarely , met with among the Colubri , for instance , in the lemniscatus ; in the three last genera , however , it takes place , I believe , without exception .
The thickness of the tail is also common to every species ; and though in the Anguis bipes , and in another species , not described by LINNAEUS , but figured in BROWNE'S History of Jamaica ( Tab. XLIV .
fig. 1 .
~ ) , the tail has an acute termination , yet in both those species , especially in the last , it continues thick to the end , and becomes suddenly sharp , being what in botanical language would be called , obtusa cum acumine .
With respect to the proportionate length of tail , however , it is very remarkable , that the genus * This indistinctness of the head , which is more or less common to each genus , is in the Amphisbaena so considerable , as to have given rise to the supposition of that Serpent 's having a head at each end .
~ This figure is , by LINNAEUS , erroneously quoted as his Anguis lumbricalis .
Anguis affords examples of much less proportion , and also of much greater , than is to be found in any of the three first genera .
In the Anguis Scytale the tail is not above one-twentieth of the whole length ; in the maculata it is not above onefortieth ; yet in the Anguis fragilis , and in the ventralis , the tail is always longer than the trunk , or , in other words , is more than half the whole length .
Indeed , in one specimen of the last mentioned species , I found the tail nearly two-thirds of the whole length .
It may , however , be questioned whether that species is really an Anguis , or a Lacerta * .
I shall make no further remarks on the external characters of Serpents ; the principal inferences to be deduced from those I have already made , are the following .
1st , That a broad head , covered with small scales , though it be not a certain criterion of venomous Serpents , is , with some few exceptions , a general character of them .
2dly , That a tail under one-fifth of the whole length , is also a general character of venomous Serpents ; but , since many of those which are not venomous have tails as short , little dependence can be placed upon that circumstance alone .
On the other hand , a tail exceeding that proportion , is a pretty certain mark that the species , to which it belongs , is not venomous .
3dly , That a thin and acute tail is by no means to be considered as peculiar to venomous Serpents ; though a thick and obtuse one is only to be found among those which are not venomous .
* The Anguis ventralis of LINNAEUS , is so very like the Lacerta apoda , described by PALLAS , in Vol. XIX .
of the Novi Comment .
Petrop .
as to render it doubtful whether it may not be the same .
When I first examined it , I considered it as a Lacerta , on account of the projecting future along the body , and the open ears ; but I have since met with a specimen which had two large echinated Penes ( as they are called ) a character which is , I believe , peculiar to Serpents .
4thly , That carinated scales are , in some measure , characteristic of venomous Serpents , since in them they are more common than smooth ones , in the proportion of nearly 4 to 1 ; whereas , smooth scales are , in those Serpents which are not venomous , more common , in the proportion of nearly 3 to 1 .
Upon the whole therefore it appears , that though a pretty certain conjecture may , in many instances , be made , from the external characters ; yet , in order to determine , with certainty , whether a Serpent be venomous or not , it becomes necessary to have recourse to some more certain diagnostic .
This can only be sought for in the mouth ; I shall therefore next consider , how the fangs , with which the mouths of venomous Serpents are furnished , are to be distinguished from common teeth .
To those who form their ideas of the fangs of venomous Serpents , from those of the Rattle-snake , or even from those of the English Viper , it will appear strange , that there should be any difficulty in distinguishing those weapons from common teeth ; and indeed the distinction would really be very easy , were all venomous Serpents furnished with fangs as large as those of the fore-mentioned species .
But the fact is , that in many species the fangs are full as small as common teeth , and consequently cannot , by their size , be known from them ; this is the case with the Coluber laticaudatus * , lacteus , and several others .
I cannot , however , better demonstrate that the distinction , between the venomous fangs and common teeth , is not very obvious , than by showing how very vague and erroneous * This species is by LINNAEUS reckoned venomous , in the Museum Regis , though the mark is not affixed to it in the Systema Naturae .
To me it appears to be certainly venomous , and is the only water Serpent I have met with that is so .
LINNAEUS'S ideas about them were ; nor can I better prove the want of information on this subject , than by observing that , erroneous as the ideas of LINNAEUS were , no one , that I know of , has yet attempted to furnish more correct ones .
LINNAEUS thought the fangs might be distinguished by their mobility ; this , at least , may be fairly inferred , from his never mentioning them in the Museum Regis , without adding the epithet mobilia , except in one instance ( the Coluber aulicus ) ; and , in that very instance , the want of mobility in the supposed fangs appears evidently to raise doubts in his mind , whether they are really fangs or not .
His words are , ` ` Dentes , sive tela , duo , rigida , parva , non mobilia .
' ' These doubts , respecting the above-mentioned species , I am not able to remove , as I am not sure that I have ever seen it * .
But with regard to mobility , considered in general as a character of venomous fangs , I must assert , not only that I have never found it so , but also , that I have never been able to discover in them any thing which I thought could properly be called mobility .
I have , indeed , sometimes found some of them loose in their sockets ; but then I have found others , in the same specimen , quite fixed .
The same thing was observed both by Dr. NICHOLLS ~ , and by the Abbe FONTANA ~ , in the common Viper , even during life .
The loose fangs may be such as have not yet been firmly fixed in their socket , or they may have been loosened by some accident : for I suspect that the fangs may be at any time loosened , and even displaced , by a small degree of violence ; and that , perhaps , may be one *I have seen one , which agreed pretty well with LINNAEUS'S description ; if that was really his species , it is not venomous .
~ Appendix to Dr. MEAD'S Account of the Viper .
~ FONTANA , Traite sir le Venin de la Vipere , chap .
1st and 2d .
reason why there is always a certain number of small fangs , near the base of the full grown ones , ready to enlarge and take their place , if they should be , by any accident , torn out .
LINNAEUS seems also to have thought that the fangs might be known by their situation .
In the Introduction to the class Amphibia in the Systema Naturae , he says they are , ` ` Dentibus simillima sed extra maxillam superiorem collocata ; ' ' and in the description of the Crotalus Dryinas , in the Amoenitates Academicae , he says , ` ` Dentes ejus duo canini uti in reliquis venenatis Serpentibus non in maxillis haerent , iis enim vulner ando , non autem ictus infligendo utitur .
' ' These two quotations show , that LINNAEUS thought the situation of the fangs different from that of the common teeth ; the last also shows that he thought their mode of action influenced by it .
What difference in situation may be found by accurate dissection , it is foreign from my present purpose to enquire ; I am , however , very certain that common examination * will not discover any difference , in that respect , between the fangs of venomous Serpents , and the teeth of others .
But the most singular opinion of LINNAEUS , respecting the venomous fangs , was , that they were sometimes fixed in the base of the jaw .
Of this he has given two instances in the Museum Regis .
One in the description of the Coluber severus , of which he says , ` ` Hastae mobiles solitariae versus basin maxillarum interius adhaerent .
' ' The other in that of the Coluber stolatus .
His words there are , ` ` Tela mobilia ad basin maxil* By common examination I mean such as may be made without dissecting , or otherwise damaging , the specimen to be examined ; and such only do I suppose allowable in the distinction I am seeking to establish .
larum affixa , ut vix vulnerare valeat hostess , solum cibos veneno inficere .
' ' LINNAEUS'S opinion respecting the use of the fangs , in the last mentioned species , appears to me not very clearly expressed * .
But I have quoted both descriptions , merely to show that LINNAEUS thought the fangs were sometimes placed in the base of the jaw ; an idea for which I have never been able to discover any foundation .
The first of the two species in question I have never seen ; of the stolatus I have examined several specimens , and am convinced it is not venomous .
I shall not dwell any longer on the false notions which have been entertained , respecting the fangs of venomous Serpents , but shall proceed to show how , in my opinion , they may be most easily , and most certainly , distinguished from common teeth .
With respect to their size , I have already observed that it is very various , consequently no certain judgement can , in all cases , be made from that circumstance .
In some species they are so large , that their size alone sufficiently distinguishes them from common teeth ; but in others they are so small , that it is very difficult to discover them .
The size of the common teeth also varies very much , in different species .
In the Coluber mycterizans they are remarkably large , especially those which are situated near the apex of the upper jaw ; which circumstance probably helped to lead LINNAEUS into the erroneous opinion he entertained , that this Ser* LINNAEUS'S opinion seems not unlike that of the Abbe FONTANA , who ( in the work already mentioned , chap .
12 .
) supposes the poison of the Viper may be of use , to the animal , in digestion .
To me the venomous fangs have ever appeared to be merely offensive weapons ; nor can I see greater difficulty in supposing such a weapon , with the power of injecting poison , placed in the head of a Viper or Rattle-snake , than in supposing such an one , with a similar power , placed in the tail of a Wasp or Hornet .
pent was venomous .
But in many species the teeth are so small , that it is impossible to discover , merely by looking into the mouth , that the animal has any .
Yet in that case they may be very easily detected , by drawing a pin ( or any other hard substance ) with a moderate degree of pressure , along the edge of the jaw , from the apex to the angle of the mouth , when they will be felt to grate against the pin , like the teeth of a saw .
Although the size of the venomous fangs is very various , their situation is , I believe , always the same ; namely , in the anterior and exterior part of the upper jaw , which situation I consider as the only one in which venomous fangs are ever found .
But as , in those Serpents which are not venomous , common teeth are found in that part of the jaw , it is plain that we cannot , by situation alone , distinguish one from the other .
They may , however , be distinguished with great ease , and I believe also with great certainty , by the following simple operation .
When it is discovered that there is something like teeth in the fore-mentioned part of the upper jaw , let a pin be drawn , in the manner already described , from that part of the jaw to the angle of the mouth ( which operation may , for greater certainty , be tried on each side ) .
If no more teeth are felt in that line , it may I believe be certainly concluded , that those first discovered are what I have distinguished by the name of fangs , and consequently , that the Serpent is a venomous one * .
If , on the contrary , the teeth first discovered are found not to stand alone , but to be only a part of a complete row , it may as certainly be concluded , that the Serpent is not venomous .
* If a specimen should be met with , in which no teeth , of any kind , can be discovered in the margin of the upper jaw , the presumption is , that it is a venomous Serpent , which has lost its fangs ; but I have never met with such an one , except the Coluber Cerastes already mentioned .
In the upper jaw , both of venomous Serpents and others , besides the teeth already spoken of , there are two interior rows ; consequently , the distinction I have endeavoured to establish might be expressed in other words , by saying , that all venomous Serpents have only two rows of teeth , in the upper jaw , and all others have four * .
I think it better , however , to leave the interior rows out of the question , as , in many species , the teeth of which they are composed are so small , as to make it very difficult to discover them .
Indeed , in two species of Anguis , I can hardly be sure that I have discovered them ; but as , in every other species , I have never failed to do so , I presume I may , with very little risk of error , assert , that all Serpents whatever are furnished with them ; and that those only , which are not venomous , have the exterior rows .
What I have said sufficiently shows that LINNAEUS'S ideas , respecting venomous serpents , were such as did not permit him to separate them from the others ; if the method I have proposed shall be found to render the distinction of them sufficiently clear and easy , it naturally follows , that they should be made generically distinct .
Some other reforms might also be made in LINNAEUS'S class of Amphibia , the consideration of which I do not mean , at present , to enter further into .
But , before I conclude , I think it necessary to notice an inaccuracy of LINNAEUS , of a different kind from those I have already pointed out .
* GRONOVIUS , of whose inaccuracy I have already given one instance , in describing the Crotalus Durissus , in his Museum Ichthyologicum , says it has no teeth , except the venomous fangs .
KLEIN , in his Tentamen Herpetologiae , has gone still further , having actually made a genus of Serpents without teeth , which he calls Anodon .
He appears not to have examined the mouth of a single species ; but to have depended entirely upon the descriptions of SEBA .
In the Preface to the Museum Regis , and in the Introduction to the class Amphibia , in the Systema Naturae , LINNAEUS says , that the proportion of venomous Serpents to others , is 1 in 10 ; yet in the Systema Naturae , in which the sum total of species is one hundred and thirty-one , he has marked twentythree as venomous , which is somewhat more than 1 in 6 .
How he came to be so much at variance with himself , I know not ; but the last mentioned proportion seems to me to be not far from the truth ; as I find that I have examined one hundred and fifty-four species of Serpents , of which number twenty-six appear to be venomous .
I have already mentioned , that the Coluber stolatus and the mycterizans , though marked by LINNAEUS as venomous Serpents , certainly are not so ; and that I suspect the same may be said of the Leberis , and Dipsas .
I have also observed , that the Boa contortrix , Coluber Cerastes , and laticaudatus , none of which are marked in the Systema Naturae , are all of them venomous ; to these last may be added the Coluber fulvus .
If LINNAEUS'S species were all accurately examined , I have no doubt but more errors , of both kinds , would be found ; for it must be observed , that though I have examined a greater number of species than LINNAEUS , not above half that number are of those described by him ; consequently there remains more than one-third of his species which I have never seen .
The number I have examined , however , seems to me sufficiently great to warrant the inferences I have drawn from that examination .
That some exceptions to them might be found , by the examination of a greater number , is very possible ; but , if these observations shall tend to rectify the false notions which have been entertained respecting venomous Serpents , and to render the distinction between them and others more clear , I trust they will be thought not totally useless .

