II .
Objections to the Experiments and Observations relating to the Principle of Acidity , the Composition of Water , and Phlogiston , considered ; with farther Experiments and Observations on the same Subject .
By the Rev. Joseph Priestley , LL. D. F. R. S. Read November 27 , 1788 .
HAVING never failed , when the experiments were conducted with due attention , to procure some acid whenever I decomposed dephlogisticated and inflammable air in close vessels , I concluded that an acid was the necessary result of the union of those two kinds of air , and not water only ; which is an hypothesis that has been maintained by Mr. LAVOISIER and others , and which has been made the basis of an entirely new system of chemistry , to which a new system of terms and characters has been adapted .
The facts that I alleged were not disputed ; but to my conclusion it was objected , that the acid I procured might come from the phlogisticated air , which in one of my processes could not be excluded ; and that it was reasonable to conclude that this was the case , because Mr. CAVENDISH had procured the same acid , viz. the nitrous , by decomposing dephlogisticated and phlogisticated air with the electric spark .
In other cases it has been said , that the fixed air I procured came from the plumbago in the iron from which my inflammable air had been extracted .
With respect to the former of these objections I would observe , that my process is very different from that of Mr. CAVENDISH ; his decomposition being a very slow one by electricity , and mine a very rapid one by simple ignition , a process by which phlogisticated air , as I found by actual trial , was not at all affected ; the dephlogisticated and inflammable airs uniting , and leaving the phlogisticated air ( as they probably would any other kind of air with which they might have been mixed ) just as it was .
I would also observe , that there is no contradiction whatever between Mr. CAVENDISH'S experiment and mine , since phlogisticated air may contain phlogiston , and by means of electricity this principle may be evolved , and unite with the dephlogisticated air ( or with the acid principle contained in it ) as in the process of simple ignition the same principle is evolved from inflammable air , in order to form the same union ; in consequence of which , the water , which was a necessary ingredient in the composition of both the kinds of air , is precipitated .
That in other circumstances than those in which I made the experiments , the acid wholly escaped , and nothing but water was found , may be easily accounted for , from the small quantity of the acid principle in proportion to the water , and the extreme volatility of it , owing , I presume , to its high phlogistication when formed in this manner .
In order to ascertain the effect of the presence of phlogisticated air in this process , I now not only repeated the experiment of mixing a given quantity of phlogisticated air with the two other kinds of air , and found , as before , that it was not affected by the operation ; but I made the experiment with atmospheric air , instead of dephlogisticated .
Since the air of the atmosphere contains a greater proportion of phlogisticated air , it might be expected that , if the acid I got before came from the small quantity of phlogisticated air which I could not possibly exclude , I should certainly get more acid , when , instead of endeavouring to exclude it , I purposely introduced a greater quantity .
But the consequence was the production of much less acid than before , the liquor I procured being sometimes not to be distinguished from pure water , except by the greatest attention possible : for though the decomposition was made in the same copper vessel which I used in the former experiments , there was now no sensible tinge of green colour in it .
When I repeated this experiment in a glass vessel , I perceived , as I imagined , the reason of the small produce of acid in these new circumstances : for the vessel was filled with a vapour which was not soon condensed , and being diffused through the phlogisticated air ( which is not affected by the process ) is drawn away along with it , when the exhausting of the tube is repeated ; whereas , when there is little or no air in the vessel besides the two kinds which unite with each other , and are decomposed , the acid vapour , having nothing to attach itself to and support it ( by being entangled with it ) much sooner attacks the copper , making the deep green liquor which I have described .
Sometimes , however , I have procured a liquor which was sensibly green by the decomposition of atmospheric and inflammable air , but by no means of so deep a colour , or so sensibly acid , as when the dephlogisticated air is used .
The extreme volatility of the acid thus formed ( and which accounts for the escape of some part of it in all these processes ) is apparent from this circumstance , that if the explosions be made in quick succession ( the tube being exhausted immediately after each of them , and filled again as soon as possible ) no liquor at all will be collected , the whole of the acid vapour , together with the water with which it was combined , being drawn off uncondensed in every process .
I once made twenty successive explosions of this kind , in a copper tube , out of which I found that I drew 37 ounce measures of air by the action of the pump , and found not a single drop of liquid , though near an hour was employed in the whole process , and the vessel was never made more than a little warmer than my hand .
This was a degree of heat by no means sufficient to keep the whole of any quantity of water in a state of vapour ; and is a circumstance that of itself sufficiently proves , that the vapour did not consist of water only .
Indeed , I think it impossible for any one to see this vapour in a tall glass vessel , and especially to observe how it falls from one end of it to the other , and the time that is required to its wholly disappearing , without being satisfied that it consists of something else than mere water , the vapour of which would be more equally diffused .
If the appearance to the eye should fail to convince any person of this , the sense of smell would do it : for even in a glass vessel it is very offensive , though it might not be pronounced to be acid .
I conjecture , however , that this , and every other species of smell , is produced by some modification of the acid or alkaline principle .
Some may be disposed to ascribe this smell to the iron from which the inflammable air was produced ; but the smell is the same , or nearly so , when the air is from tin , and would probably be the same if it were from any other substance .
Besides using atmospheric air , which contains a greater proportion of phlogisticated air , I have sometimes used dephlogisticated air which was not very pure ; and in this case I have always observed , that the liquor I procured had less colour , and was less sensibly acid .
These observations might , I should think , satisfy any reasonable person , that the acid liquor which I procured by the explosion of dephlogisticated and inflammable air in close vessels did not come from the phlogisticated air which could not be excluded , whether it was that which remained in the vessel after exhausting it by the air pump , or that with which the dephlogisticated air was more or less contaminated .
But besides these experiments , in which I procured the green acid liquor by the explosion of dephlogisticated and inflammable air in close vessels , I made another , to which I thought the same objection could not have been made , because no air pump was used in it , and nothing but the purest dephlogisticated air was employed , being separated in the process from precipitate per se in contact with the purest inflammable air in a glass vessel which had been previously filled with mercury .
Accordingly , the only objection made to this experiment was , that the preparation I made use of might be impure , containing something which might yield phlogisticated air .
This appeared to me highly improbable , as the precipitate had been made by M. CADET , and for the purpose of philosophical experiments .
Besides , if the heat of a burning lens should dislodge phlogisticated air from any unperceived impurity in this preparation , mere heat will not decompose this air .
Let any person try the effect of a lens on such air , or any substance containing it , and produce an acid if he can .
M. BERTHOLLET , however , thinking that this might be the case , desired that I would send him a specimen of my precipitate per se .
Accordingly , I sent him all that remained of it ; and , in return , he sent me a quantity on the goodness of which I might depend .
With this preparation I repeated my former experiment ; and , by giving more attention to the process , found it to be far more decisively conclusive in favour of my opinion than I had imagined .
In the former experiment I had attended only to the drop of water which was found in the vessel in which the process was made ; and finding that it turned the juice of turnsole red , I concluded , that it contained nitrous acid : but I now examined the air that remained in the vessel , and found that a considerable proportion of it was fixed air ; so that I am now satisfied this was the acid with which it was impregnated , and not the nitrous .
Still , however , some acid is the constant result of the union of the two kinds of air , and not water only .
A quantity of the same precipitate per se yielded no fixed air by heat .
Comparing this experiment with that in which iron is ignited in dephlogisticated air , this general conclusion may be drawn , viz. that when either inflammable or dephlogisticated air is extracted from any substance in contact with the other kind of air , so that one of them is made to unite with the other in what may be called its nascent state , the result will be fixed air ; but that if both of them be completely formed before their union , the result will be nitrous acid .
It has been said , that the fixed air produced in both these experiments may come from the plumbago in the iron from which the inflammable air is obtained .
But since we ascertain the quantity of plumbago contained in iron by what remains after its solution in acids , it is in the highest degree improbable , that whatever plumbago there may be in iron , any part of it should enter into the inflammable air procured from it .
Besides , according to the antiphlogistic hypothesis , all inflammable air comes from water only .
As it cannot be said , that any real fixed air is found in inflammable air from iron ( since it is not discoverable by lime1 water ) water ) it must be supposed , that the elements , or component parts of fixed air are in it ; but one of these elements is pure air , and the mixture of nitrous air shows , that it contains no such thing , though , according to M. LAVOISIER , fixed air contains 72 parts in 100 of pure air .
However , being apprised of this objection to inflammable air from iron , I made use of inflammable air from tin , and I had the same result as with that from iron .
I also calculated the weight of the fixed air which I got in the process , and comparing it with the plumbago which the iron necessary to make the inflammable could have contained , I found , that , in all the cases , it far exceeded the weight of the plumbago ; so that it was absolutely impossible , that the fixed air which I found should have had this origin .
For the greater satisfaction , I shall recite the particulars of a few experiments of this kind .
In ten ounce measures of inflammable air from malleable iron I revived red precipitate till there remained only 1.1 oz. measure of air , and of this 0.07 oz. m. was fixed air , being completely absorbed by water .
The weight of this air would be 0.063 gr. But , since 960 grains of iron will yield 1054 oz. measures of inflammable air , the iron employed in procuring all the inflammable air that was used in this experiment , viz. 8.9 oz. measures ( without allowing for any that went to the revivification of the mercury ) would be 8.1 grains ; and since M. BERGMAN supposes , that 100 grains of iron contains 0.12 gr. of plumbago , the quantity of it in this iron would only be 0.01008 gr. which is not quite a sixth part of the weight of the fixed air .
With the precipitate per se , sent me by M. BERTHOLLET , I revived mercury till 81/ 2 oz. m. of inflammable air was reduced to 21/ 2 oz. m. , and of this 0.04 oz , m. at least was fixed air .
This is not quite so much in proportion as in the preceding experiment , but abundantly more than the weight of the plumbago .
In 8 oz. m. of inflammable air I revived minium ( which I found to have exactly the same effect in this process as red precipitate , or precipitate per se ) , till it was reduced to 1.2 oz. m. ; and of this 0.028 oz. m. was fixed air , which would exceed the weight of the plumbago more than three times .
In reviving lead from massicot ( which I prepared by expelling the pure air from minium ) I had no fixed air in the residuum .
In 7 oz. m. of inflammable air from tin by spirit of salt , I revived red precipitate till it was reduced to 1.1 oz. m. ; and in this the fixed air was something more than in proportion to that in the last experiment .
In my last volume of Experiments , p. 30 .
I mentioned some instances of the revival of red precipitate in inflammable air , without finding any fixed air , though in one I perceived a slight appearance of it .
To this I can only say , that I now always find it , and have , in the preceding cases , measured the quantity of it ; so that , though I did not find any before , I must presume that I did not use the same precautions that I did at this time : and it is possible , that I might not attend to the effect of admitting a large quantity of water to a small quantity of fixed air , which would presently absorb the greatest part of it .
I also think I recollect , that I then continued the process as far as I possibly could , and consequently left very little air in the vessel ; whereas I now purposely left a good deal , that the admission of water might have less effect on the fixed air diffused through it .
This also may be said in favour of the greater accuracy of my present experiments , that they entirely remove a very great difficulty , which I acknowledged , p. 128 .
in finding different results from seemingly similar circumstances ; whereas I now find that both the circumstances and the results are different .
Besides , the positive evidence of actually finding a substance is always more conclusive than the negative one , of not finding it .
I do not know that any objection can be made to the inflammable air from tin , as this metal has not been proved to contain plumbago .
I wished , however , to repeat this experiment with inflammable air from sulphur .
But though , when steam is sent over melted sulphur , a small quantity of inflammable air is procured , as I observed in my last volume of experiments ; yet , as sulphur cannot part with much phlogiston , except in proportion as it imbibes pure air , to form oil of vitriol , I could not in this manner easily procure enough for my purpose .
In order to supply the sulphur with pure air , I mixed with it a quantity of turbith mineral ; but this made it yield vitriolic acid air , though in great abundance , there not being , I imagine , water enough to form inflammable air : for when iron is dissolved in concentrated acid of vitriol , vitriolic acid air is produced ; but in diluted vitriolic acid , the produce is inflammable air .
With a view to supply these materials with water , I sent steam over them ; but it did not combine with the air , which was still only vitriolic acid air .
Since , however , vitriolic acid air unquestionably contains the same principle which forms the inflammability of inflammable air , this experiment proves , that sulphur is not that simple substance which the antiphlogistians suppose it to be ; but that it contains phlogiston .
Had it been nothing more than a substance which had a strong affinity to pure air , it would have united with the pure air from the turbith mineral , and have made vitriolic acid ; but no vitriolic acid air would have been produced .
That vitriolic acid air contains the same inflammable principle with inflammable air is evident from the quantity of vitriolic acid air which I produced by reviving copper from blue vitriol in inflammable air .
See my Experiments , vol. VI .
p. 15 .
Mr. KIRWAN also produced this air from sulphur and red precipitate .
See his Treatise on Phlogiston , p. 29 .
When I used a small quantity of sulphur in proportion to the turbith mineral , the first produce was vitriolic acid air , and afterwards dephlogisticated air , from the turbith mineral alone , the effect of the sulphur having been exhausted .
According to the antiphlogistic theory , phosphorus , as well as sulphur , is a simple substance ; and when it is ignited imbibes pure air , and thereby becomes the phosphoric acid , without parting with any thing .
But I find , that after the accension of it in dephlogisticated air , there is a considerable quantity of fixed air in the residuum ; and this fixed air could only be formed by the union of the dephlogisticated air in the vessel with the phlogiston contained in the phosphorus .
Mr. KIRWAN had a similar result from phosphorus confined in atmospheric air .
As it is not pretended , that there is any plumbago in phosphorus , this experiment is not liable to the objection that has been made to those in which inflammable air from iron was made use of .
It will be expected , that in this reply to the objections that have been made to my experiments establishing the doctrine of phlogiston , I should consider what has been alleged by Mess .
LAVOISIER , BERTHOLLET , and DE FOURCROY , in favour of their new system , in their Report on the subject of the new chemical characters invented by Mess .
HASSENFRATZ and ADET , subjoined to the new Nomenclature Chymique .
I shall therefore notice what appears to me to be most important in that publication .
One of the articles of the modern doctrine ' ' ( of which they say , p. 311 .
` ` that it cost more than twenty years labour , which the force of reasoning has obliged many celebrated chemists to adopt , and in favour of which much greater numbers are ready to decide ; ' ' and the evidence for which they say , p. 301 .
is the most complete chemical proof ) , which seems the most solidly established , ' ' p. 298 , ` ` is the formation , the decomposition , and recomposition of water ; and how is it possible , ' ' they add , ` ` to doubt of it , when we see that , in burning together 15 grains of inflammable air and 85 of pure air , we get exactly 100 grains of water ; and when we can , by decomposition , find again these same two principles , in the same proportions ?
' ' To this I must say , as I have done , Experiments , vol. VI .
p. 139 .
( and when I wrote that , I was myself a believer in the decomposition of water ) , that I have never been able to find the full weight of the air decomposed in the water produced by the decomposition ; and that now I apprehend it will not be denied , that the produce of this decomposition is not mere water , but always some acid .
As to the supposed decomposition of water by means of iron , I have shown that it is a fallacy ; since the iron imbibes nothing but water when it parts with its phlogiston .
And I have observed ( Experiments , vol. VI .
p. 83 .
) , that when this finery cinder is reconverted into iron by inflammable air , nothing but water is expelled from it ; and that the residuum of the air is purely inflammable , without containing any fixed air .
It is evident , therefore , that the iron had imbibed pure water only .
Had the iron imbibed dephlogisticated air from the water , and not water itself , there seems to be no reason why fixed air should not be found in this , as well as in the exactly similar process with minium and precipitate per se .
Also , it can never be supposed , that the addition which iron gains , of one-third of its weight , is from air contained in steam , if it could be proved to contain any ; because , if there be a sufficient quantity of iron , the whole of the water will be imbibed ; so that , on this hypothesis , water must be nothing but dephlogisticated air condensed .
There is , I acknowledge , a great difficulty in explaining the experiment of iron first imbibing water , and parting with phlogiston , and again parting with its water , and imbibing phlogiston , in circumstances of heat so nearly similar as those which I have described .
It seems as if the affinity of iron to water and to phlogiston was each , in their turns , stronger than the other .
To this I can only say , that the whole doctrine of affinities , as far as it is true , is founded on facts ; and these are clearly such as I have represented ; and that a difference of circumstances , which is not apparent at present , may become so when we shall have given sufficient attention to them .
In order to satisfy myself whether any thing besides water was expelled from finery cinder by heat , I went through similar processes with this substance and massicot , from which all air had been previously expelled ; and after reviving both of them in inflammable air , I found the results , in all respects , the very same .
The residuums of the inflammable air were equally free from fixed air ; and when they were fired with equal quantities of dephlogisticated air , the diminutions of bulk were very nearly the same , less than when the original inflammable air was used , because all the impurities in the whole quantity were retained in a small residuum , the metals having imbibed nothing but pure phlogiston .
Also the inflammable air had been long confined by water , in consequence of which it is always altered more or less .
The particulars of the processes were as follows : The finery cinder was revived in 7 oz. m. of inflammable air , which was thereby reduced to 11/ 4 oz. m. ; and an oz. m. of this residuum being fired together with an equal quantity of dephlogisticated air , not very pure , the diminution of both was to 28 divisions of a tube , of which 30 was one oz. m. when with equal quantities of the same dephlogisticated and the original inflammable air the diminution was to 18 .
The massicot was reduced in 8 oz. m. of inflammable air till it was reduced to 11/ 4 oz. m. ; and after the process with the dephlogisticated air , the diminution was to 29 , when with the original inflammable air it was to 171/ 2 .
In both the residuums , after the explosion , there was a slight appearance of fixed air , though none could be perceived before the explosion ; but in both cases it was so slight that it could not have been perceived by the diminution of its bulk .
But since both fixed air and nitrous acid are produced from the same materials in different circumstances , it cannot be thought extraordinary if , in some cases , both should be produced at the same time .
M. LAVOISIER and his associates farther observe , p. 300 .
with respect to my experiments , that ` ` when a calx is revived in inflammable air , more water is found in the vessel than the weight of inflammable air that disappears , so that it could not have been contained in that air .
' ' They only refer to my experiments in general ; but as they speak of the water produced as appearing both on the inside of the vessel , and on the surface of the mercury , it can be no other than the experiment of the revival of iron from finery cinder ; and the water that is found in this process was never supposed to come from the little that is contained in the inflammable air , but the much greater quantity contained in the cinder .
Before I conclude this Paper , I shall just mention a few circumstances attending the many explosions I have made of inflammable and dephlogisticated air in the long metallic and glass vessels I have made use of , as they were pretty remarkable .
The explosions were made by a small electric spark at one end of the vessel , and the greatest force of the explosion was always at the other end .
No tinned iron vessel could bear many of them before they swelled out at that end , and at length burst ; and even the flat end of the copper vessel , which was not less than one-tenth of an inch thick , was in time made quite convex , and the cylindrical part next to it was made very sensibly wider than any other part of the tube .
This must have been effected by mere force , and not by heat ; for the hottest part of the tube , after every explosion , was never there , but always about the middle , though something nearer to that end than the other , and in the glass vessel the dense cloud was always formed at that end .
The probability is , that the air where the electric spark is made taking fire first , the inflammation does not extend itself so rapidly but that the air at the opposite end is first condensed , in consequence of the inflammation and expansion of the air at the other end , so that the air is there fired in a condensed state ; and hence its greater force .

