XXII .
On the Georgian Planet and its Satellites .
By William Herschel , LL. D. F. R. S. Read May 22 , 1788 .
IN a Paper , containing an account of the discovery of two satellites revolving round the Georgian planet , I have given the periodical times of these satellites in a general way , and added that their orbits made a considerable angle with the ecliptic .
It is hardly necessary to mention , that it requires a much longer series of observations , to settle the mean motions of secondary planets with accuracy , than I can hitherto have had an opportunity of making ; but since it will be some satisfaction to astronomers to be acquainted with several of the most interesting particulars , as far as they can as yet be ascertained , I shall communicate the result of my past observations ; and believe that , considering the difficulty of measuring objects which require the utmost attention even to be at all perceived , the elements here delivered will be found to be full as accurate as we can at this time expect to have them settled .
The most convenient way of determining the revolution of a satellite round its primary planet , which is that of observing its eclipses , cannot now be used with the Georgian satellites , as will be shown when I come to give the position of their orbits ; and as to taking their situations in many successive oppositions of the planet , which is likewise another very eligible method , that must of course remain to be done at proper per opportunities .
The only way then left , was to take the situations of these satellites , in any place where I could ascertain them with some degree of precision , and to reduce them afterwards by computation to such other situations as were required for my purpose .
In January , February , and March , 1787 , the positions were determined by causing the planet to pass along a wire , and estimating the angle a satellite made with this wire , by a high magnifying power ; but then I could only use such of these situations where the satellite happened to be either directly in the parallel of declination , or in the meridian of the planet ; or where , at least , it did not deviate above a few degrees from either of them ; as it would not have been safe to trust to more distant estimations .
In October I had improved my apparatus so far as to measure the positions by the same angular micrometer with which I have formerly determined the relative positions of double stars * .
In computing the periods of the satellites I have contented myself with synodical appearances , as the position of their orbits , at the time when the situations were taken from which these periods are deduced , was not sufficiently known to attempt a very accurate sidereal calculation .
By six combinations of positions at a distance of 7 , 8 , and 9 months of time , it appears that the first satellite performs a synodical revolution round its primary planet in 8 days 17 hours 1 minute and 19,3 seconds .
The period of the second satellite deduced likewise from four such combinations , at the same distance of time , is 13 days 11 hours 5 minutes and 1,5 seconds .
The * For a description of this instrument , see Phil. Trans. Vol. LXXI .
p. 500~ and Vol. LXXV .
p. 46 .
combinations of which the above quantities are a mean do not differ much among themselves ; it may therefore be expected that these periods will come very near the truth ; and , indeed , I have for many months past been used to calculate the places of the satellites by them , and have hitherto always found them in the situations where these computations gave me reason to expect to see them .
The epochae , from which astronomers may calculate the positions of these satellites , are October 19 , 1787 ; for the first 19 h. 11~ 28~ ; and for the second 17 h. 22~ 40~ .
They were at those times 76~ 43~ north-following the planet ; which , as will be shown in the sequel , is the place of the greatest elongation of the second satellite ; where , consequently , its real angular situation is the same as the apparent one .
And I have brought the first satellite to the same place , as hitherto there has not been time to discriminate the situation of its orbit from that of the second .
The next thing to be determined in the elements of these satellites is their distance from the planet ; and as we know that , when the periodical times are given , it is sufficient to have the distance of one satellite in order to find that of any other , I confined my attention to the discovery of the distance of the second .
As soon as I attempted measures , it appeared , that the orbit of this satellite was seemingly elliptical ; it became therefore necessary , in order to ascertain its greatest elongation , to repeat these measures in all convenient situations ; the result of which was , that on the 18th of March , at 8 h. 2~ 50~ , I found the satellite at the distance of 46~,46 ; this being the largest of all the measures I have had an opportunity of taking .
Hence , by computation , it appears , that the satellite 's greatest visible elongation from its planet , at the mean distance of the Georgium sidus from the earth , will be 44~,23 .
It ought to be mentioned , that in the reduction of this measure I have used MAYER'S tables for the sun , and the tables published in the Connoissance des Temps of the year 1787 , reduced to the time of Greenwich , for the Georgian planet .
Very possibly this distance might not be taken exactly at the time when the satellite happened to be at the vertex of the transverse axis of its apparently elliptical orbit ; but , from other measurements , we have reason to conclude , that it could not be far from that point .
For instance , the 9th of November , at 15 h. 56~ 15~ , by a mean of four good measures , the satellite was 44~,89 from the planet ; which , by calculation , reduced to the same distance of the Georgian sidus from the earth as the former , gives 41~,33 .
And likewise , the 19th of March , at 7 h. 45~ 59~ , the distance measured 44~,24 ; which , computed as before , gives 42~,15 .
Now , we find , when the places are calculated in which the satellite happened to be at the times when these two measures were taken , that they fall on different sides of the former measure , and also on opposite parts of the satellite 's orbit ; but that nevertheless they agree sufficiently well with the position of the transverse axis which we have adopted in the sequel .
Admitting , therefore , at present , that the satellite moves in a circular orbit about its planet , we cannot be much out in taking the calculated quantity of 44~,23 for the true measure of its distance .
And , having ascertained this point , we calculate , by the law of KEPLER , and the assigned period of the first satellite , that its distance from the planet must be 33~,09 .
I ought however to remark , that , in this computation , a true sidereal period should have been used ; but , as that cannot as yet be had , the trifling inaccuracy thence arising may well be excused , till , at some future opportunity , we may be permitted to repeat these calculations in a more rigorous manner .
As we are now upon the subject of such parts of the theory of planets as may be determined by calculation , it will not be amiss to see how the quantity of matter and density of our new planet will stand , when compared with the tables that have been given of the same in the other planets ; and in order to this , let us admit the following data as a foundation for our computation .
The parallax of the sun 8~,63 .
The parallax of the moon 57~ 11~ .
Its sidereal revolution round the earth 27 d. 7 h. 43~ 11~,6 .
The mean distance of the Georgian planet from the sun 19,0818 .
The mean distance of its second satellite from the planet 44~,23 .
The periodical time of this satellite 13 h. 11 d. 5~ 1~,5 .
Hence we find , that a spectator , removed to the mean distance of the Georgian planet from the earth , would see the radius of the moon 's orbit under an angle of 27~,1866 ; and if 1 , d , t , represent the quantity of matter in the earth , the distance of the moon , and its periodical time ; M , D , T , be made to stand for the same things in our new planet and its second satellite , we obtain , by known principles , M= t2D3/ T2d3 .
And , consequently , the quantity of matter in the Georgian planet is to that contained in the earth as 17,740612 to 1 .
In order to caculate the density , I compare the mean of the four bright measures of the planet 's diameter 3 , ''7975 to the mean of the two dark ones 4~,295 ; as they are given in my Paper on the diameter and magnitude of the Georgium sidus , printed in Volume LXXIII .
of the Philosophical Transactions , p. 9 .
11 , 12 , 13 .
Whence we obtain another mean diameter 4~,04625 ; which is probably the most accurate of any that we have hitherto ascertained .
And let us suppose this measure to belong to the situations of the earth and of the new planet as they were at 10 o'clock , the 25th of October , 1782 ; which is about the middle of the several times when those measures from which this is deduced were taken .
Then , by the tables already referred to , we compute the distance of the two planets from the sun and the angle of commutation ; whence , by trigonometry , we find the distance of our new planet from the earth for the supposed 25th of October ; and thence deduce its mean diameter , which is 3~,90554 .
This , when brought to what it would appear if it were seen from the sun at the earth 's mean distance , gives 1~ 14~,5246 ; which , compared with 17~,26 , the earth 's mean diameter , is as 4,31769 to 1 .
The Georgium sidus , therefore , in bulk , is 80,49256 times as large as the earth ; and consequently its density less than that of the latter in the ratio of,220401 to 1 .
To these particulars , though many of them may be of no other use than merely to satisfy our curiosity , we may also add , that the force of gravity , on this planet 's surface , is such as will cause an heavy body to fall through 18,67308 feet in one second of time .
It remains now only , in order to complete our general idea of the Georgian planet , to investigate the situation of the orbits of its satellites .
I have before remarked , that when I came to examine the distance of the second , I perceived immediately that its orbit appeared considerably elliptical .
This induced me to attempt as many measures as possible , that I might be enabled to come at the proportion of the axes of the apparent ellipsis ; and thence argue its situation .
But here I met with difficulties that were indeed almost insurmountable .
The uncommon faintness of the satellites ; the smallness of the angles to be measured with micrometers which required light enough to see the wires ; the unwieldy size of the instrument , which , though very manageable , still demanded assistant hands for its movements , and consequently took away a great share of my own directing power , a thing so necessary in delicate observations ; the high magnifiers I was obliged to use by way of rendering the spaces and angles to be measured more conspicuous ; in short , every circumstance seemed to conspire to make the case a desperate one .
Add to this , that no measure could possibly succeed which had not the most beautiful sky in its favour ; and we may easily judge how scarce the opportunities of taking such measures must be in the variable climate of this island .
As far then as small number of select measures will permit , which , out of about twenty-one that were taken , amounts only to five , I shall enter into our present subject of the position of the second satellite 's orbit .
The following table contains in the first column the correct mean time when the measures were taken .
The second gives the quantity of these measures .
In the third column are the same measures reduced to the mean distance of the Georgian planet from the earth .
The fourth contains the calculated positions of the satellite as it would have appeared to be situated if it had moved in a circular orbit at rectangles to the visual ray ; and the degrees are numbered from the first observation supposed to have been at zero , and are carried round the circle from right to left .
D. H. ' ' ' ' ' ' ' o ' March 18 82 50 46,46 44,23 00 19 7 47 59 44,24 42,15 26 28 20 7 44 8 40,23 38,37 53 8 April 11 9 18 27 35,32 34,35 283 13 Nov. 9 15 56 15 44,89 42,88 199 59 In the use of this table I shall partly content myself with the construction of a figure , and only apply calculation to the most material circumstances .
By the third column we see that 44~,23 is the greatest , and 34~,35 the least , distance of the satellite .
Let therefore an ellipsis be drawn Tab. V. fig. 1 .
having the transverse and conjugate diameters cp and cv , in the proportion of the above-mentioned measures .
About the center c , with the radius cp , describe the circle PSFN ; and set off the points March 18 , 19 , 20 .
April 11 .
and Nov. 9 .
according to the tabular order of degrees , beginning at p , the supposed zero .
From these points to the transverse draw the ordinates March 19 s , 20 t , April 11 x , Nov. 9 y. Then , if the satellite moved in a circular orbit at rectangles to the visual ray , we should have seen it at the time given in the table , as the points are placed in the circumference of our circle ; but , supposing the plane of the orbit inclined to the visual ray , these points will be projected in the direction of the ordinates ; and , falling on the places pnmr o , will form the ellipsis we have delineated .
Now , on comparing the tabular measures of the third column with the distances of pnmr and o from the center c , we find , that they agree full as well as we could expect ; and thus , as far as a few observations can do , these measures establish the truth of the above hypothesis .
That we may have a point in our ellipsis from which to depart , I shall have recourse to two measures of positions .
The first was taken October 14 d. 16 h. 28~ 42~ , when the satellite was 66~ 3~ south-following the planet .
In fig. 2 .
let qmv be a portion of an ellipsis , constructed on the semi-transverse cq , and semi-conjugate cv , taken as 44,23 to 34,35 ; qMF an arch of a circle , described with the radius cq about the center c ; m the situation of the satellite in its elliptical orbit , the 14th of October ; A its apparent , and M its real place in the circle ; Fc the parallel of the planet .
Then we shall have , by calculating from the known period , the arch qM 45~ 17~ ; and FA , by observation , 66~ 3~ .
But from the nature of the ellipsis , as Vc is to vc so is Mn ( the tangent of the angle qcM to the radius cn ) to mn ( the tangent of the angle qcA to the same radius ) .
Hence qcA is found 38~ 7~ ; and therefore AcM 7~ 10~ .
That is , when the angle of position was taken , the satellite appeared to be 7~ 10~ less advanced in its orbit than it should have done , owing to its motion in an orbit whose plane is inclined to the visual ray .
The measure therefore corrected , or rather reduced to the circle , instead of 66~ 3~ , will be 58~ 53~ south-following ; to which , adding the calculated arch qA , and from the sum deducting 90~ , we have the position qcS with the meridian 14~ 10~ on the south-preceding side .
In the same manner I proceed with the second measure taken October 20 d. 16 h. 7~ 34~ ; when the satellite appeared to be 82~ 12~ north-preceding the planet .
Here the arch qM is 25~ 21~ , AcM 5~ 9~ ; and the measure corrected 77~ 3~ northpreceding , which gives the inclination of the axis to the meridian 12~ 24~ on the north-following side .
I have no reason to prefer either of the measures , and therefore take a mean of both , which is 13~ 17~ from south-preceding to north-following the meridian , as probably nearest the truth ; and this position of the axis we may suppose to belong to a time which is about the mean of those from which it has been deduced ; or October , 17 d. 16 h. We are , in the next place , to find the angle which the plane of the meridian made at that time with the plane of the orbit of the Georgian planet .
To this end we calculate its longitude and latitude for the given time .
Then , in fig. 3 .
where ~ NO is part of the solstitial colure , nc a portion of the orbit , and ~s of the ecliptic ; there is given the arch NO , 23~ 28~ ; Ec , 89~ 27~ 49~,2 the complement of the planet 's latitude ; and the angle ~ Es , 27~ 0~ 52~,2 , or planet 's distance from Cancer .
By these we find the angle EcN between the circle of latitude Nc and the meridian Ec 11~ 11~ 41~ .
Now , let c , in fig. 4 .
be the place of the Georgian planet , and G~ca part of its orbit ; e~s part of the ecliptic ; Nc the meridian ; ~ the place of the planet 's ascending node ; pcq the position of the axis of the apparently elliptical orbit of the second satellite ; EcN the angle of position of the Georgium sidus .
Then , by calculation , for the above-mentioned day we have ~ c , the planet 's distance from the node on its orbit 44~ 8~ 17~ ; c~s the inclination of its orbit to the ecliptic 46~ 13~ ; and ~ sc a right-angle ; whence Ec ~ 90~ 33~ 10~,1 the supplement of the angle sc ~ is found ; from which , taking the angle of position NcE , before obtained , we have the remaining angle , NcG , 79~ 21~ 29~,1 ; or inclination of the planet 's orbit to the plane of the meridian , which was required .
From the proportion of the transverse cp , fig. 1 .
to the conjugate cv , we calculate the angle vpc , which may be either acute or obtuse .
For here I must take notice , that observations cannot immediately determine whether the satellite , in passing from p through nmv to q , be in the farthest or nearest part of its orbit ; as we shall presently show that this orbit is not in a situation to permit the satellite to suffer either eclipses or occultations for some time to come .
The angle vpc , therefore , if the arch pvq be turned towards us will be 129~ 2~ 46~,5 ; but , if directed the contrary way , 50~ 57~ 13~,5 .
There is one circumstance which will bring on a discovery of this particular , without waiting for eclipses ; for if the apparent ellipsis of the satellite 's orbit should contract in a year or two , we may conclude this arch to lie towards the sun ; if , on the contrary , it opens , we shall know that the satellite has passed through one of its nodes about eight or nine years ago ; and that , therefore , we must not expect to see it eclipsed for more than thirty years to come .
Now , having already determined the position of the axis pc with respect to the meridian , by adding the angles Ncp and NcG , fig. 4 .
we obtain pcn , 92~ 38~ 29~,1 ; and having also now calculated the ambiguous angle npc , we may resolve the quadrantal triangle pcn , in which the angle cnp gives the inclination of the orbit of the satellite to the orbit of its planet , which will be 99~ 39~ 48~,9 , if the satellite be approaching to its ascending node ; but 80~ 20~11~,1 , if it be lately past the descending one .
In the same triangle we find the side nc , which is either 50~ 59~ 0~,8 or 129~ 0~ 59~,2 ; and taking these quantities , increased by six signs , from the longitude of the planet in its orbit , gives the place of the satellite 's ascending node upon the orbit of the planet , either 8 s. 6~ 2~ 0~,3 , if the preceding arch of the orbit pmn , be concave towards the sun ; or 5 s. 18~ 0~ 1~,9 , if it be convex .
These elements obtained , we reduce them to the ecliptic by resolving the triangle ~ nm , in which we have m~ n , 46~ 13~ ; n~ the distance of the ascending node of the satellite from the descending node of the planet 6~ 50~ 43~,8 or 84~ 52~ 42~,1 ; and ~n m , the inclination of the satellite 's orbit to that of its planet 99~ 39~ 49~,9 answering to the former , or 80~ 20~ 11~,1 to the latter .
In consequence of this resolution , we have the place of the ascending node of the satellite upon the ecliptic , 5 s. 18~ 0~ 3~,9 , and its inclination to the same 862 2,3 99~ 43~ 53~,3 .
The orbit being situated so , that when the 81 6 4,4 planet will be in the ascending node of this satellite , which 1799 , will happen about the year the northern half of it 1818 East will be turned towards the at the time of its meridian West passage .
In justice to the foregoing calculations I should add , that the result of them must be considerably affected by any small alteration in the measures upon which they are founded ; the general theory , however , will certainly stand good , and a greater perfection in particulars could not have been obtained , unless I had waited some years , at least , in order to multiply good observations .
But with objects that are out of the reach of common telescopes , and which therefore cannot be much attended to , even by our most assiduous astronomers , a general theory will perhaps nearly answer all the ends that may be required of it .
The measures of the distances were taken by a good parallelwire micrometer , contrived so that one of the wires , which is moveable , can pass over the other ; by which means central measures may be obtained with more accuracy than by allowing for the thickness of the wires , the ascertaining of which is liable to some difficulties in other constructions ; but here , as we can note the divisions on the first appearance of light at either side of the fixed wire , when the moveable one passes over it backwards and forwards , we may very conveniently determine that part of the scale to which the zero ought to answer in central measures .
The value of the scale was ascertained by the transit of stars over the two wires opened to a certain number of divisions , and a chronometer beating five times in two seconds of mean time ; and in a number of several sets of experiments , the mean of each seldom differed so much as the 500dth part of a second of space for each division , and these are large enough to be sub-divided and read off , with good exctness to tenths ; and yet the space answering to each part amounts only to 282 millesimals of a second .
The measures of the distances also were as often repeated as the opportunities would permit , and a mean of them has been used .
The light of the satellites of the Georgian planet is , as we may well expect , on account of their great distance , uncommonly faint .
The second is the brightest of the two , but the difference is not considerable ; besides , we must allow for the effect of the light of the planet , which is pretty strong within the small distances at which they are revolving .
I have seen small fixed stars , as near the planets as the satellites , and with no greater light , which , on removal of the planet , shone with a considerable lustre , such as I had by no means expected of them .
A satellite of Jupiter , removed to the distance of the Georgian planet , would shine with less than the 180th part of its present light ; and may we not conclude , that our new satellites would be of a very considerable brightness if they were brought so near as the orbit of Jupiter , and thus appeared 180 times brighter than at present ?
Nay , this is only when we take both the planets at their mean distance ; for , in their oppositions , a satellite brought from the superior planet to the orbit of the inferior one , would reflect nearly 250 times the former light ; from all which it is evident , that the Georgian satellites must be of a considerable magnitude .
If we draw together the results of the foregoing calculations into a small compass , they will stand as follows : The first satellite revolves round the Georgian planet in 8 days 17 hours 1 minute and 19 seconds .
Its distance is 33~ .
And on the 19th of October , 1787 , at 19 h. 11~ 28~ , its position was 76~ 43~ north-following the planet .
The second satellite revolves round its primary planet in 13 days 11 hours 5 minutes and 1,5 seconds .
Its greatest distance is 44~,23 .
And on the 19th of October , 1787 , its position at 17 h. 22~ 40~ , was 76~ 43~ north-following the planet .
Last year its least distance was 34~,35 ; but the orbit is so inclined , that this measure will change very considerably in a few years , and by that alteration we shall know which of the double quantities put down for the inclination and node of its orbit are to be used .
The orbit of the second satellite is inclined to the ecliptic 99~ 43~ 53,3~ .
81 6 4,4 18 degrees of Virgo .
Its ascending node is in 6 degrees of Sagittarius When the planet passes the meridian , being in the node of this satellite , the northern part of its orbit will be turned East .
towards the West The situation of the orbit of the first satellite does not seem to differ materially from that of the second .
We shall have eclipses of these satellites about the year 1799 , when they will appear to ascend through the shadow 1818 of the planet almost in a perpendicular direction to the ecliptic .
The satellites of the Georgian planet are probably not less than those of Jupiter .
The diameter of the new planet is 34217 miles .
The same diameter seen from the earth , at its mean distance , is 3~,90554 .
From the sun , at the mean distance of the earth , 1~ 14~,5246 .
Compared to that of the earth as 4,31769 to 1 .
This planet in bulk is 80,49256 times as large as the earth .
Its density as,220401 to 1 .
Its quantity of matter 17,740612 to 1 .
And heavy bodies fall on its surface 18 feet 8 inches in one second of time .
W. HERSCHEL .
Slough , March 1 , 1788 .
S Nov 19 q o y Fig. 1 .
Fig. 2 .
A M ~ FP rVv ~ w ~F t m 20 s n March 18 p 19 Nsq ~ ~ s Fig.3 .
~ 69 Fig.4 .
n Ep 2 .
Sq A M m n ~ P n ~G m

