XI .
Experiments and Observations relating to the Principle of Acidity , the Composition of Water , and Phlogiston .
By Joseph Priestly , LL. D. F. R. S. Read February 7 , 1788 .
THAT water consists of two kinds of air , dephlogisticated and inflammable , is now , I believe , generally admitted as one of the most important , and best ascertained , doctrines in chemistry .
My own experiments having seemed to favour it , I made no difficulty of receiving it myself : but having , at the time of the publication of the last Volume of my Experiments , found that , in decomposing the two kinds of air above mentioned by the electric spark , I got much less water than I expected , and , instead of it , a dark-coloured vapour , not easily condensed , I could not help concluding that something yet remained to be investigated with respect to this subject , and determined , at a proper opportunity , to resume my inquiries into it .
At that time , however , I had no suspicion of any acid being produced in the process ; having never been able to find any in the water which I had hitherto procured in pretty large quantities from the decomposition of those two kinds of air , though the doctrine of dephlogisticated air being , or containing , the principle of universal acidity , had been advanced by M. LAVOISIER , and admitted by myself and others .
Suspecting that much of the water which had been procured in the above-mentioned process was no proper constituent part of the air , but only such as had been diffused through it , and in some manner attached to it , and kept suspended in it , and therefore might be separated from it , without decomposing the air ; on resuming these experiments , I used every precaution I could think of to detach all water from the air on which I operated .
In order to this , I kept it confined by mercury , together with a quantity of fixed ammoniac , which imbibes water more readily , if not in greater quantity , than quicklime , or any other known substance .
In this more accurate method of making the experiment , I was gradually led to discover the acid , which had escaped my observation before .
But I am not certain that I should have found it even now , if I had not been aided by the sagacity of Mr. KEIR , who was always of opinion , that some acid must be the produce of this experiment , or rather that the produce would be something which would become acid by exposure to the open air .
I began with making the explosions in the same glass vessel from which the mixture of air had displaced the mercury with which it had been filled ; when I found , as I have observed in my last publication , the whole of the vessel was filled with a dense smoke , which settled into a black coating of all the inside of the vessel , and which appeared , as before , to be mercury ; becoming white by exposure to the air .
For some time I perceived no appearance of water : but placing the vessel at a proper distance from a fire , I found about a quarter of a grain collected on the opposite side ; when , as the vessel contained four ounce measures of air , the water produced ought to have been at least a grain .
The mercury being an impediment in this process , I afterwards confined the mixture of air in one vessel ( with mercury and fixed ammoniac as before ) but I made the explosions in another , which I had previously exhausted of air .
This vessel was larger than that which I had used before , containing something more than eight ounce measures ; so that the air it contained , being onethird dephlogisticated and two-thirds inflammable , would have weighed about two grains .
After one explosion the quantity of water collected appearing inconsiderable , I repeated the process in the same vessel , and then collecting the water , I found it not to exceed a grain and an half .
I repeated this experiment very often , and constantly found some water , but it always fell far short of the weight of the air decomposed .
There must , therefore , have been something not very fluid adhering to the sides of the vessel , which could not be dislodged by a moderate heat ; and indeed the glass did not recover the perfect clearness that it had before the process .
I always observed , that , presently after every explosion , the vessel was filled with a dense vapour , so that it was sometimes impossible to see through it ; and before I admitted the external air , I could pour it from one end of the vessel to the other , and it seemed to fall almost as fast as a feather in a common vacuum , and in general it did not disappear in less than ten minutes .
I even found this dense vapour when the mixture of air had been confined by water .
The smell of the vessel , after the process , was that of the most offensive kind of inflammable air from iron .
From these experiments it was sufficiently evident , that something more than water had been produced ; and pouring into the vessel a quantity of the juice of litmus , it was instantly turned to a deep red ; so that it was equally evident , that an acid had been formed .
In all the preceding experiments the dephlogisticated air had been procured from manganese ; and in all the experiments mentioned in this Paper , the inflammable air was from iron by water only .
A great number of strong glass vessels having been broken in these experiments , and sometimes with some hazard to myself , and the quantity of air that I was able to decompose in them being small , I next procured a copper vessel , which contained about thirty-six ounce measures of air ; and having now no other object than discovering the kind of acid that I had procured , I made repeated experiments in it ; and after every ten or twelve explosions collected all the liquid matter I could find ; which , as the air had been previously confined by water , was pretty considerable , about equal to the weight of the air .
The liquor that I procured in this manner was always of a deep blue or green , being evidently a solution of copper .
But it also contained a redundant acid , as appeared by its turning the juice of litmus red .
Besides this blue liquor , there was always a quantity of seemingly abraded copper ; for it was perfectly and quickly dissolved by volatile alkali , as copper very minutely divided would have been .
In these experiments I used , at different times , dephlogisticated air from manganese , from red precipitate , and from red lead , as the most unexceptionable of all ; and as it was obligingly furnished me by Mr. KEIR , the preparation of it may be depended upon .
There did not , however , appear to be any other difference in the liquors produced by means of these kinds of dephlogisticated air , except in the shade of the colour ; that from manganese being of the deepest blue , and that from red lead the lightest ; and this difference might be accidental .
By the assistance of Mr. KEIR I examined these solutions of copper , and presently found , by means of a solution of terra ponderosa in spirit of salt , that it was not , in any of the cases , the vitriolic ; and yet , as the dry substance left by the evaporation of the liquor did not deliquesce , I had concluded , that the acid was neither the nitrous , nor the marine ; but Mr. KEIR informs me , that this is the case with a fully saturated solution of copper in spirit of nitre .
Also Dr. WITHERING , who was so obliging as to examine some of these liquors for me ( for , not being much accustomed to these analyses , I had requested him to undertake it ) had procured from that in the production of which the red lead had been used , crystals of nitre , and other indisputable indications of nitrous acid ; so that I was satisfied that it was this acid that was produced in all the cases .
I had a farther proof of the acid being the nitrous , that having ( in order to get a quantity of liquor that should be as little saturated with any metal as possible ) used a vessel of tinned iron , I found , that after some time , when the tin had been much corroded ( and with every process a considerable quantity came away ) the liquor , which at first was colourless , was tinged with red .
In these experiments I made use of dephlogisticated air from red lead .
As both the kinds of air made use of in these experiments were exceedingly pure , it seems evident , that phlogisticated air does not contain all the elements of nitrous acid ; but only supplies a base for it , the dephlogisticated air ( which was used in a greater proportion in the valuable experiment of Mr. CAVENDISH ) supplying the acidifying principle , as I had conjectured in the last Volume of my Experiments , p. 404 .
Besides , though all phlogisticated air could not be excluded in those experiments in which the air-pump was used , this objection cannot well be made to those in which that instrument was not used ; and in them the slowly condensable vapour above mentioned seems to be an evident symptom that the produce was not mere water .
But it is a satisfactory answer to this objection , from the presence of phlogisticated air in the tube , that this kind of air is not decomposed , or at all affected , by this process , as will be found by mixing any quantity of it with the two other kinds of air .
That a considerable quantity of water enters into the composition of dephlogisticated air , will not be thought improbable , when it is considered that , in my former experiments , this appeared to be the case with respect to inflammable air .
For without water this air cannot be procured .
I can also now say , that the same is the case with respect to fixed air .
It is not therefore improbable , that the same may be true of every other kind of air , since water is used in the production of them all .
Terra ponderosa aerata ( a substance of which Dr. WITHERING has given us an excellent analysis ) gives no fixed air by mere heat .
But I find , that when steam is sent over it , in a red heat , in an earthen tube , fixed air is produced with the greatest rapidity , and in the same quantity as when it is dissolved in spirit of salt : and , making the experiment with the greatest care , I find , that fixed air consists of about half its weight of water .
From two ounces of the terra ponderosa I got , by means of steam , 190 ounce measures of fixed air , so pure that at first 150 ounce measures of it were reduced by agitation in water to 31/ 2 , and of the last produce , 30 ounce measures were reduced to one .
Examining the residuum of the first portion by means of nitrous air , I found it to be of the standard of 1.5 .
After this , attending to the water expended in the process , I found that I procured 330 ounce measures of fixed air with the loss of 160 grains of water .
According to this , as the air weighed 294 grains , the water in the fixed air must have been 80 parts of 147 of the whole .
In another experiment , having previously found that three ounces of the terra ponderosa yielded about 250 ounce measures of fixed air , I attended only to the loss of water in procuring it , and I found it to be about one-fifth of an ounce , in two successive trials .
The quantity of fixed air would weigh 225 grains , and the water expended about 100 grains ; so that , in this experiment also , the fixed air must have contained about one-half of its weight of water .
That water enters into the composition of fixed air , and adds considerably to its weight , is farther probable from the solution of terra ponderosa in spirit of salt .
Because when the solution is evaporated to dryness , and the residuum exposed to a red heat , the weight of the air , and of this residuum , exceeds that of the substance from which it was procured ; and it is probable , that a red heat would expel any marine acid adhering to it .
Forty-eight grains of terra ponderosa dissolved in spirit of salt , and then evaporated to dryness , and exposed to a red heat , lost four grains , and yielded eight ounce measures of fixed air , which would weigh 7.2 grains ; consequently , threesevenths of the weight of the air was something that had been gained in the process , and therefore probably water .
The near coincidence of the results of these different experiments is remarkable , and makes it almost certain , that no marine acid is retained in the terra ponderosa that has been dissolved in it , after exposure to a red heat ; that the generation of the fixed air carries off part of the water in the menstruum ; and that this part of the weight is about one-half of the whole .
I must observe , that the supposition of water entering into the constitution of all the kinds of air , and being , as it were , their proper basis , that without which no aeriform substance can subsist ( which the preceding experiments render in a high degree probable ) makes it unnecessary to suppose , as myself as well as others have done , that water consists of dephlogisticated air and inflammable air , or that it has ever been either composed or decomposed in any of our processes .
That water is decomposed when inflammable air is procured from iron by steam , is not probable ; since the inflammable principle may very well be supposed to come from the iron , and the addition of weight acquired by the iron may be ascribed to the water which has displaced it .
Also when the scale of iron , or finery cinder , is heated in inflammable air , it gives out what it had gained , viz. the water .
The most plausible objection to this hypothesis is , that iron gains the same addition of weight , and becomes the same thing , whether it be heated in contact with steam , or surrounded by dephlogisticated air .
But from the preceding experiments it appears , that by far the greatest part of the weight of dephlogisticated air is water ; and the small quantity of acid that is in it may well be supposed to be employed in forming the fixed air , which is always found in this process : for that there is one common principle of acidity , and that all the acids are convertible into one another ( at least the nitrous acid into fixed air ) is by no means an improbable supposition , though we are not yet in possession of any process by which it may be done .
It is pretty evident that , in this respect , nature actually does what we are not able to do .
In my last Volume of Experiments , I recited the particulars of one , the result of which seemed to be dissimilar to this with the scales of iron and inflammable air ; for heating red precipitate in inflammable air , I then found little or no water ; but having used more precautions , I have since found it in sufficient quantity in this process , even though the inflammable air was previously well dried with fixed ammoniac .
In this experiment I discontinued the process after three ounce measures of air were absorbed , leaving room in the vessel , that the moisture might be more easily collected .
With this precaution , and warming the vessel , I collected between an half and threefourths of a grain of water .
This experiment may be thought to be unfavourable to my present hypothesis , as all water was carefully excluded , and yet a sufficient quantity was found in the process .
But besides taking into the account the water that is necessary to constitute the inflammable air , why may not red precipitate , in its dryest state , be supposed to contain water , as well as the scales of iron , which will bear any degree of heat without parting with it .
Red precipitate is made by a liquid process , and therefore the water , that may enter into its composition as a calx , may quit it when it becomes a metal .
I shall take the liberty to observe farther , that the doctrine of the decomposition of water being set aside , that of phlogiston ( which , in consequence of the late experiments on water , has been almost universally abandoned ) will much better stand its ground , as all the newly discovered facts are more easily explained by the help of it .
If water be not decomposed , both metals and sulphur do certainly yield inflammable air , when steam is made to pass over them in a red heat .
They cannot , therefore , be simple subX 2 stances , stances , as the antiphlogistic theory makes them to be .
Also , the same thing that they have parted with , viz. inflammable air ( or rather something that is left of inflammable air when the water is taken from it , and which may as well be called phlogiston as any thing else ) may be transferred to other substances , and thus contribute to form any of the metals , sulphur , phosphorus , or any thing else that has been deemed to contain phlogiston .
This phlogiston also , no doubt , having weight , it perfectly corresponds to the definition of a substance , having certain affinities , by means of which it is transferred from one body to another , as much as the different acids .
If there be no such thing as one principle of phlogiston , transferable from one substance to another , it must be admitted , that inflammable air from sulphur is real sulphur and water , that from iron , iron and water , as well as that very different substance , the scale of iron .
And since copper , or any other metal , may be made of inflammable air from iron , &amp;c. all the metals will be , in fact , convertible into one another .
At least , it may be said , that all the component parts of any one metal may be so incorporated with any other , that no test can detect it .
Also iron , made of inflammable air from sulphur , ought , upon this hypothesis , to have the properties of sulphurated iron , which undoubtedly it would not have .
An hypothesis loaded with these difficulties must be inadmissible ; whereas that of phlogiston is extremely simple , and , as far as appears , of universal application .
The discovery that the greatest part of the weight of inflammable air , as well as of other kinds of air , is water , does not make the use of the term phlogiston less proper : for it may be still given to that principle , or thing , which , when added to water , makes it to be inflammable air ; as the term oxygenous principle may be given to that thing which , when it is incorporated with water , makes dephlogisticated air .
As there is something in dephlogisticated air that seems to be the principle of universal acidity , so I am still inclined to think , as I observed in my last Volume of Experiments , that phlogiston is the principle of alkalinity , if such a term may be used ; especially as alkaline air may be converted into inflammable air .
In the course of experiments recited in this Paper , I discovered more completely than before the source of my former mistake , in supposing that fixed air was a necessary part of the produce of red lead , and also of manganese .
Both these substances , I find , give of themselves only dephlogisticated air , and that of the purest kind ; and all the fixed air they yielded in my former experiments must have come from the gunbarrel I then made use of , which would yield inflammable air , which , with dephlogisticated air , forms fixed air .
For though the dephlogisticated air from red lead was so pure tha , mixed with two measures of nitrous air , the three measures were reduced to five hundredth parts of a measure , and the substance gave no fixed air at all when it was heated in an earthen tube or retort ; yet by mixing iron filings with it , or with manganese , as I had formerly done with red precipitate , I got more or less fixed air at pleasure , and sometimes no dephlogisticated

