IX .
Observations on the Manner in which Glass is charged with the electric Fluid , and discharged .
By Edward Whitaker Gray , M. D. F. R. S. Read January 17 , 1788 .
DR. FRANKLIN , in various parts of the first volume of his Experiments and Observations , asserts , That the natural quantity of electric fluid in glass cannot be increased or decreased ; and that it is impossible to add any to one surface of a plate or jar , unless an equal quantity be , at the same time , given out from the other surface * .
This error has been adopted by succeeding electricians ; among others , by the late Mr. HENLY , who in one of his last Papers , printed in the Philosophical Transactions for the year 1777 , has the following words : ` ` According to Dr. FRANKLIN'S theory , the same quantity of the electric matter which is thrown upon one of the surfaces of glass , in the operation of charging it , is at the same time repelled or driven out from the other surface ; and thus one of the surfaces becomes charged plus , the other minus ; and that this is really the case is , I think , satisfactorily proved , &amp;c. ~ .
' ' BECCARIA also has adopted the same opinion , saying , ` ` That a quantity of excessive fire cannot be introduced into one * ` ` The quantity proportioned to glass it strongly and obstinately retains , and will have neither more nor less .
' ' Experiments and Observations , Vol. I. p. 26 .
See also p. 75 .
81 .
et alibi .
~ Philosophical Transactions , Vol. LXVII .
p. 100 .
surface , but inasmuch as an equal dose of natural fire can quit the other surface * .
' ' These assertions are , I apprehend , directly contrary to what really happens .
Instead of which , I believe , we may safely assert , that glass , and every other known substance , may have its natural quantity of electric fluid either increased or diminished to a certain limited degree ; which degree bears no proportion to the quantity of matter contained in a body , but is ( caeteris paribus ) in proportion to the extent of its surface .
This law , which is , perhaps , without exception , may be considered as one of the fundamental laws of electricity , and one upon which many of its principal phenomenon depend .
At present I shall only consider it so far as it is the cause of what is commonly called the charge of a coated jar .
Suppose such a jar insulated , and connected by its knob to the prime conductor of an electric machine ; if then the machine be put in action , a certain quantity of electric fluid ( agreeable to the above-mentioned law ) is added to the natural quantity belonging to the inner surface of the jar .
After which , if the finger , or any other conducting substance , be presented to the outer coating of the jar , a quantity of electric fluid , nearly equal to that thrown in , comes from it .
But this departure of electric fluid from the outside of the jar , cannot be ( as Dr. FRANKLIN supposes it ) the cause which permits the addition of fluid to the inside , but is merely the consequence of the action of that superfluous quantity which was thrown in .
And the operator may , if he pleases , instead of taking electric fluid from the outside of the jar , take out again ( by touching the knob ) nearly the whole of what he had * Treatise upon Artificial Electricity .
Eng. Trans. sect. 181 .
thrown in , which he could not do if an equal quantity had already gone from the outside of the jar * .
When the quantity already spoken of has been taken from the outside of the jar ( the equilibrium being nearly restored ) another quantity like the first may again be added to the inner surface : after which a similar quantity may again be taken from the outside : thus , by the succession of a sufficient number of the quantities allowed by the before-mentioned law , the jar may , at length , be completely charged .
There are other ways of charging coated glass ; but if it be allowed , that the charge , in the foregoing instance , is produced in the manner I have supposed , it will not , I think , be disputed , that all other charges are produced by a similar alternation of small quantities .
This , however , will appear more clear from the observations I shall now make on the manner in which the discharge is produced .
When the astonishing velocity with which the charge of a jar or battery moves through a considerable space is considered , it may at first appear impossible , that the discharge should be made by the alternate giving and receiving such small quantities as those by which the charge was produced ; yet a more ample consideration of the matter will , I think , show that it cannot possibly be brought about any other way .
I presume it will be granted , that the charge of a jar ( in discharging ) either leaves it all at once , or goes out by the same small quantities by which it went in .
To suppose any inter* Much dispute has arisen among electricians respecting the degree of charge which may be given to an insulated jar ; but no one , that I know of , has taken notice of a deception which will happen , if care be not taken that the same side , by which the jar is attempted to be charged , be first touched in trying whether it be charged or not ; whereas it is clear , from what has been said , that , if the contrary surface be first touched , a small charge will , from that very circumstance , be produced .
mediate manner would neither lessen the difficulty , nor would it be consonant to any of the known laws of electricity .
If then the whole charge leave the jar all at once , there must be a point of time at which the jar will be without any electric fluid either on one side or the other : nay more , suppose a large jar or battery to be discharged by means of a few inches of thin wire , there will then be a point of time at which the whole quantity of electric fluid , which constituted the charge , must be contained in a piece of wire , weighing only a few grains .
Now , if it be considered , that time ( like matter ) is infinitely divisible , may we not rather suppose , that the discharge of a jar is nothing more than an inconceivably rapid succession of such small quantities as may be sent off , without causing such a destruction of the equilibrium as the laws of electricity seem not to admit ?
That this supposition is not quite free from objections I readily admit ; but before they are permitted to overthrow it , let it be well considered , whether they are ( upon the whole ) as strong as those I have stated against the opposite opinion , which I think may be pronounced to militate not only against what has been here mentioned as a fundamental law of electricity , but also against every known fact .

