XXVIII .
Investigation of the Cause of that Indistinctness of Vision which has been ascribed to the smallness of the Optic Pencil .
By William Herschel , LL. D. F.R.S. Read June 22 , 1786 .
SOON after my first essays of using high powers with the Newtonian telescope , I began to doubt whether an opinion which has been entertained by several eminent authors , ` ` that vision will grow indistinct , when the optic pencils are less than the 40th or 50th part of an inch , ' ' would hold good in all cases .
To judge according to so rigid a criterion , I perceived that I was not entitled to see distinctly with a power much more than about 320 , in a 7-feet telescope which bore an aperture of 6,4 inches ; whereas in many experiments on double stars I found myself very well pleased with magnifiers that far exceeded such narrow limits .
This induced me , as it were , by way of apology to myself , for seeing well where I ought to have seen less distinctly , to make a few experiments on the subject of the diameter of optic pencils .
It occurred to me , that an opinion which limits them to any given size cannot be supported by theory , which does not determine on subjects of this nature , but must be decided , like many other physical questions relating to matters of fact , by careful experiments made upon the subject .
The way , therefore , to come at truth , in a case which seemed to me of considerable importance , lay still open to me , as it had done to former ob7 servers ; servers ; and I thought myself authorised , according to a Cartesian maxim ( Dubia etiam pro falsis habenda ) , to suppose , for a while , the size of optic pencils , requisite for distinct vision , entirely undecided .
The first opportunity I had of making the proposed experiments was in the year 1778 , and the result of them proved so decisive that I have never since resumed the subject ; and had it not been for a late conversation with some of my highly esteemed and learned friends , I might probably have left the papers , on which these experiments were recorded , among the rest of those that are laid aside when they have afforded me the information I want .
But a doubt seeming still to be entertained on the subject of the smallness of the optic pencils , it may now be proper for me to communicate these experiments , that it may appear how far the conclusions I have drawn from them are warranted by the facts on which I suppose them to rest .
Experiments with the naked eye .
Exp. 1 .
Through a very thin plate of brass I made a minute hole with the fine point of a needle ; its magnified diameter , very accurately measured under a double microscope , I found to be,465 of an inch , while under the same apparatus a line of,05 in length gave a magnified image of 3,545 inches .
Hence I concluded , that the real diameter of the perforation was about the 152d part of an inch .
Through this small opening , held close to the eye , I could very distinctly read any printed letters on which I made the trial .
Proper allowance must be made for the very inconvenient situation of the eye , which by the unusual closeness to the paper cannot be expected to see with its common facility .
Besides , the continual motion of the letters , which is required on account of the smallness of the field of view , must needs take up a considerable time .
Exp. 2 .
In some other pieces of brass I made smaller holes ; and among many , that were measured with the same accuracy as in the former experiment , I found one whose magnified diameter was,29 : hence the real diameter could not exceed the 244th part of an inch .
Through this opening I could also read the same letters ; but the difficulty of managing so as not to intercept all the incident light , as well as the very uneasy situation of the eye , were sufficient reasons for not carrying the intended experiments any further under this form .
Besides , I should hardly have allowed them to be fair , if , on a further contraction of the hole in the brass plate , an indistinctness had come on ; as we might well have suspected at least two other causes , besides the smallness of the pencils , to contribute to such an imperfection ; viz. want of light , and a deflection of it on the contracted edges of the hole .
Microscopic Experiments .
Exp. 3 .
I had now recourse to a double microscope , consisting , for simplicity 's sake , of only two lenses .
The focal length of the eye-glass , carefully ascertained by an object half a mile off , being,9 ; the distance of the object-glass from the eye-glass 9,36 ; and the aperture of the object-glass,0405 .
Hence we compute that the diameter of the optic pencil , when it entered the eye , could not exceed the 232d part of an inch ; yet with this construction I saw very distinctly every object I placed under the microscope .
Exp. 4 .
I reduced the aperture of the object-glass to,013 ; hence the pencil was found to be the 724th part of an inch ; and yet I saw with this construction very distinctly every object that was placed under the magnifier .
Exp. 5 .
I made a second reduction of the aperture of the object-glass , so that now it was no more than,0052 ; and therefore the optic pencil less than the 1800th part of an inch ; and yet I could very well count the bristles on the edge of the wing of a fly , and distinguish their length and thickness .
Exp. 6 .
Changing the construction of the microscope , I now reduced the pencils by an increase of power .
Solar focus of the eye-glass,52 ; distance between the object-glass and eye-glass 7,6 ; aperture the same as in the third experiment .
This gave me a pencil of the 336th part of an inch , with which I saw very distinctly .
Exp. 7 .
Applying now the reduced aperture of the fourth experiment , I had a pencil of the 1139th part of an inch , with which I saw very well .
Exp. 8 .
I changed the eye lens for another of,171 focal length ; the object-glass and distance between the two lenses remaining as in the two last experiments ; aperture,02 .
This gave a pencil of the 2173d part of an inch , with which I could count , or rather successively see , the bristles before-mentioned very well ; the field , on account of the great power , not taking in more than two large and a small one at a time .
Exp. 9 .
I was now convinced , that we may see distinctly with pencils incomparably less than the 40th or 50th part of an inch ; and indeed so far from expecting any obstruction to distinct vision from the smallness of the pencils , it appeared to me now as if their size might in future be entirely left out of the account .
With a view , however , of seeing what other cause might bring on that indistinctness which had been ascribed to the smallness of the optic pencils , I continued these experiments with a variation in the apparatus , and used now an object lens of a different focal length ; the aperture and other particulars being as in the 4th experiment .
By this construction , which gave me a pencil of the 724th part of an inch , I could see objects very well ; but though they appeared distinctly , they were not so sharp on the edges as one would wish to see them .
This being compared with the 4th experiment , it appeared that , with equal pencils , unequal degrees of distinctness may take place ; and a pretty striking circumstance , which served to lead me in the following experiments , was , that the smallest power gave me the least distinct image ; notwithstanding , from former trials , the goodness of the lenses I employed could not be doubted .
Exp. 10 On an examination of circumstances it occurred to me , as indeed I had already before surmised , that a certain proportion of aperture might be necessary to a given focal length of an object-lens or speculum ; and that a failure in this point might probably bring on that indistinctness which had been ascribed to the smallness of the pencils .
In order , therefore , to put this to a trial , I used now an object-lens of 1,25 focal length , with an aperture confined to,01 ; the rest of the apparatus being as in the 3d , 4th , and 5th experiments .
The pencil in this case was about the 1000dth part of an inch ; and though by a different construction I had already seen very well with a pencil of not half that diameter , I found this to give me , as now I had reason to expect , a very indistinct picture , so much so indeed , that it could hardly be called a representation of the object .
Exp. 11 .
Increasing the aperture of the object-lens to,0124 , I had a pencil of the 758th part of an inch , but could see no better with it .
Exp. 12 .
Proceeding in the track now pointed out to me , I admitted an aperture of,017 , which gave a pencil of the 550th part of an inch , but could see not much better with it than before .
Exp. 13 .
On a farther increase of the aperture to,0231 , and a pencil of the 406th part of an inch , I saw a little better ; but still had not distinctness enough even to see the bristles before-mentioned at all .
Hence we may conclude , that , in such constructions as the present one , the aperture of the objectglass must bear a considerable proportion to its focal length ; since the 54th part ( for,0231 : 1,25 : : 1 : 54 ) is here not nearly sufficient .
Exp. 14 .
To the same apparatus I applied a higher power , by an exchange of the eye-glass ; but the indistinctness remained as before .
Exp. 15 .
Returning again to the former construction , I admitted an aperture of about,037 ; and having now a pencil of nearly the 250th part of an inch , I could but just perceive some of the large bristles , which shows that even the 34th part ( for ,037 : 1,25 : : 1 : 34 ) of the focal length is not a sufficient aperture for object-lenses that act under such circumstances as the present .
So far I have only related experiments that were made in the year 1778 ; and my opinion that the smallness of the optic pencils could be no objection to seeing well being thus supported by evident facts , I hesitated not , in a Paper on the Parallax of the Fixed Stars ( Phil. Trans. vol. LXXII .
p. 96 .
) to affirm , that we might see distinctly with pencils much smaller than the 40th or 50th part of an inch .
It did not appear to be necessary , nor would the subject of that Paper permit me to enter into a detail of experiments ; but having , in the course of my reading about that time , met with an account of some very small globules made for microscopic uses , I contented myself with an instance of small pencils taken from them .
I shall , however , now proceed just to hint at a few inferences that may be drawn from these related experiments ; as , upon a mature consideration , we may find reason to believe they point out a cause of indistinctness of vision hitherto never noticed by optical writers ; and which , when properly investigated , cannot but influence , and in some respects contribute to the improvement of , our theories in optics .
For , admitting that every object-glass or speculum , whose aperture bears less than a certain ratio to its focal length , will begin to give an indistinct picture , it will follow , that while former opticians have been endeavouring to diminish the aberrations arising from the spherical figure , and the different refrangibility of rays , by increasing the focal length , they have been unaware of exposing themselves to the consequences of the cause of indistinctness here pointed out .
And till its influence shall be well ascertained and brought to a proper theory , we must suspect that such tables as those which are given in our best authors of optics , pointing out an aperture of less than 6 inches for a glass of 120 feet focal length ( or a ratio of 1 to 240 ) must be far from having that degree of perfection which may yet be obtained .
No wonder that telescopes , made according to theories or tables , where one of the causes of indistinctness is unsuspected , and therefore left out of the account , can bear no smaller pencil than the 40th or 50th part of an inch !
If then , on one hand , by increasing our apertures we certainly run into great imperfections , we ought nevertheless also to consider what dangers , on the other , we may incur by lessening them too much .
As soon as convenient , I intend experimentally to pursue this subject , in order to obtain proper data for submitting this cause of optical imperfection to theory ; at present my engagement with the work of a 40-feet reflector will hardly permit so much leisure ; and till I shall have repeated , extended , and varied these experimental investigations , I would wish them to be looked upon as mere hints that may afford matter for future disquisitions to the theoretical optician .

