XXVI .
Conjectures relative to the Petrifactions found in St. Peter 's Mountain , near Maestricht .
By Petrus Camper , M. D. F. R. S. Read July 6 , 1786 .
THE discovery of a great number of petrified bones about the year 1770 , in the mountain of St. Peter at Maestricht , and particularly of large jaw-bones with their teeth , suggested to the late M. HOFFMAN , first Surgeon to the Military Hospital at Maestricht , a worthy member of several learned Societies , and a great admirer of natural history , the idea that these maxillae belonged to crocodiles .
This notion was spread by himself and his literary correspondents through all Europe .
He did me the favour to send me , not only the history of those petrifactions , but also several figures of the jaw-bones in question , and of other bones , which were all entirely new to me , except some fragments of the bones of turtles .
I discovered , however , at the very first sight , the characteristical differences which distinguished these bones from those of crocodiles , of which I had at that time several in my collection .
His intention was to write upon this subject , and to send his essay , containing his reasons for supposing these bones to belong to crocodiles , to the Royal Society ; but I dissuaded him , as a friend , from doing this , lest he should afterwards be under a necessity of retracting his opinion : and I sent him a figure of the lower jaw of a crocodile , accurately done by my own hand , and soon after the skull and under jaw of a pretty large crocodile ; which induced him to defer his design of writing about these antiquities of the old world , until he should be better informed on the subject of cetaceous fishes .
Major DROUIN , of Maestricht , who made , about the same time , a collection of an infinite variety of corals , madrepores , alcyoniums , echinites , belemnites , shells , and petrified wood , from the same mountain and its environs , likewise procured a beautiful specimen of two maxillary bones of the same incognitum , but with the insides turned outwards ; and this gentleman also supposed them to belong to the crocodile .
A sketch of this specimen is to be found in M. BUCHOZ'S Dons de la Nature , tab .
68 .
But the specimen itself is now in TEYLER'S Museum , at Haerlem , with the whole of Major DROUIN'S collection .
Another still more valuable and perfect specimen is to be seen at the house of the reverend Dean GODDING , of which there is likewise a rough sketch in M. BUCHOZ'S Dons de la Nature , pl. 66 .
In this the greater part of both the upper and under maxillary bones is entire , and a bone , with small teeth , belonging to the palate ; by which it appears , the animal had not only teeth in the jaw-bones , but also in the throat , as several fishes have , but which are never found in the mouth of crocodiles .
Notwithstanding all my endeavours to convince my friends , and afterwards M. DROUIN , and particularly the Dean , whose valuable and truly beautiful specimens I saw in the year 1782 , I never could prevail upon them to adopt my opinion , that these bones belonged to physeteres or respiring fishes .
M. HOFFMANN , adhering closely to the Linnaean System , objected , jected , that the physeteres had teeth only in the lower jawbone , whereas this fossil monster had them in both upper and lower maxilla .
He did not seem to recollect , that ~ signifies something respiring , or breathing , and applied to fishes , breathing fishes ; nor that the physeteres , according to the Linnaean system , have small teeth in the upper jaw-bone , though larger ones in the lower jaw , according to the observations of Dr. OTHO FABRICIUS , in his Fauna Groenlandica , p. 42 .
where he mentions the macrocephalus , and p. 45 .
where he speaks of the microps .
In August 1782 , I sent M. GODDING , who had favoured me with a copy of his valuable specimen , a full demonstration of its being the head of a physeter , or breathing fish , Delphinus , or Orca , or under whatever genus it may be ranked , as having large teeth of the same size in both the maxillae .
But in vain ; for he continues still to call it a crocodile , as if its value depended upon the species of the animal .
The analogy of all the other marine bodies seems to make it still more probable , that these large bones belong to the inhabitants of the sea , and not of rivers .
The large turtles , the numberless echinites , madrepores , shells , alcyoniums , belemnites , orthoceratites , and so on , are all sea animals ; and the crocodile would , in that case , be the only inhabitant of the rivers mixed with them .
The pretended crocodile found near Whitby , in Yorkshire , Phil. Trans. vol. L. p. II .
1758 , ~ 92 .
p. 688 .
and ibid. ~ 108 .
p. 786 .
is undoubtedly the skeleton of a Balaena .
~ 2 .
After the decease of M. HOFFMAN , his family having offered the whole collection for sale , I went in August 1782 to Maestricht on purpose to examine it ; and I could not but greatly admire the richness and beauty of the collection , espeM mm2 cially cially that of the fossil bones from St. Peter 's mountain ; but as the heirs did not consider the expenses necessary to transport the collection down the Maese , where each sovereign puts an enormous duty upon every thing that passes through his territories , nor the small number of persons who were likely to purchase it , they rated the price so high that nobody chose to bid for it .
The eldest daughter having at length become possessed of the whole , offered me the principal specimens at a price I agreed to .
Amongst them were the duplicates I have already sent to the British Museum , and with which the honourable Trustees are perfectly satisfied .
These specimens may serve likewise to ascertain what I have said about them , as being ~ fragments of physeteres , some of turtles , and the like , but not a single one of any species of crocodile .
~ 3 .
The arguments for their being jaw-bones and vertebrae of fishes seem to be , first , the smoothness of these bones ; and , secondly , the many holes by which the nerves go out at the side , and under each tooth , as is very evident in that beautiful specimen now in the British Museum , on the outside of which eleven holes are visible , in the same manner as they are in the delphini , and more particularly in the lower jaw-bone of the cete , the Physeter macrocephalus , or pot-fish , cachalot , &amp;c. Thirdly , the form of the teeth , which have solid roots , as in tab .
XV .
fig. 6 .
B , C , E , F , and the six teeth of tab .
XVI .
Fourthly , because there are little teeth in the palate , as in Dean GODDING'S specimen .
Fifthly , because the vertebrae have the appearance of true cetaceous vertebrae , as in fig. 5 .
tab .
XV .
and in several beautiful and large specimens now in the Museum .
Several of these vertebrae were besides entirely unknown known to me , and not at all analogous to the vertebrae of the crocodile , described and represented by Dr. N. GREW .
~ 4 .
As I intended to visit London in 1785 , I flattered myself I should still find the skeleton of the great crocodile formerly at Gresham College , and be able to find out such characteristic distinctions as should be necessary to decide the question .
Dr. GRAY was so kind as to go with me to the lower apartments of the British Museum , where we found , though not without difficulty , the skeleton much neglected , spoiled , and deprived of several interesting parts .
I admired , nevertheless , the remainder of it , being infinitely pleased with the transverse futures , tab .
XV .
fig. 1 , 2 , a , b. c , f. ~ , ~ .
by which not only those of the neck and thorax , but those of the loins also , are divided , and which I made a drawing of , as large as the life , the 20th of October , 1785 , of which fig. 1 .
and 2 .
are very accurate copies .
I confess I had not observed that particular division or future in the skeleton of a small crocodile , of thirteen inches , made by my youngest son ; but after being apprised of it by the large skeleton in the Museum , of twelve feet four inches , Paris measure , on looking at my own when I returned home , I found them both alike , and that those parts were not epiphyses ; of which , however , the transverse processes of the neck .
fig. 1 .
d , e , q , o , n , p , have all the appearance , though there is no other epiphysis to be observed in the rest of the bones of that large skeleton .
When we compare the fossil vertebra , fig. 5 .
with those now in the Museum , we shall find the epiphyses AB , CD , analogous to a , b , c , d , fig. 4 .
being the real epiphyses in the vertebra of a young porpoise .
I procured , in London , the largest vertebrae of the neck of a turtle I could get , and prepared two of them as in fig. 3 .
in which , as along the back of that singular creature , I found the transverse divisions a , c , d , f : of all which I have not seen a single instance amongst the dorsal spinae from St. Peter 's mountain , one of which consists of seven , another of twelve , and a third of fourteen vertebrae .
Some of the vertebrae have , I acknowledge , an inferior process , as in the crocodile , l , m , fig. 1 .
Of these I have sent likewise two to the Museum .
The ostrich , and the turtle Mydas , have such processes , but no quadruped I know of .
The articulation of the vertebrae with each other , by the surfaces of the bodies themselves , is entirely different , not only from that of the crocodile , but from that of all the cetaceous fishes I have ever seen : and I dare venture to assert , I have seen a great many , exclusive of those in my collection .
The anterior part of the Maestricht vertebrae is more or less triangular and hollow , as in fig. 5 .
C , D , L. The posterior AB is convex .
Both these surfaces are very smooth , as if they had been convered with a very thin cartilage , and moved one upon the other , without being united by an elastic lamella , as in all quadrupeds and cetaceous fishes ; in which the vertebrae have on both the surfaces a round brim , or circular edge , a , h , i , b , by means of which the ligaments are connected , and a flat hollow surface within , as h , i , fig. 4 .
for the elastic pulp that is between them .
~ 5 .
The dentition is so singular in these fossil jaw-bones that it deserves a particular description .
In all quadrupeds , as in man , the teeth which appear first are all shed at a certain period of life , and in the mean time new ones are formed above , under , or at the sides of the primordial or temporary teeth , but in different sockets .
The grinders are not all renewed , but in general three when there are six , and two when there are five .
Nature , however , is not always uniform in this operation .
Mr. JOHN HUNTER , a worthy Member of our Society , has given a very interesting and complete natural history of the teeth , in which these observations are stated .
In the crocodile the succeeding or secondary teeth appear even when the animal 's head is equal to two feet ; that is , when it has acquired one-third of its usual growth .
When they grow too fast , before the temporary tooth is shed , they perforate the side of the bone , at the part where they meet with the least resistance .
Instances of this variety occur in the large crocodile 's head , which is in my collection .
In all quadrupeds the enamel is , of the solid parts of the teeth , the first formed , making a cavity , in which the other bony substance is deposited , and formed by lamellae placed one within another , as is observed by Mr. JOHN HUNTER in the work already mentioned , p. 92 .
To this the root is added , which is filled in the same manner till the tooth is long enough to pierce through the gums .
But in the fossil jaw-bones of St. Peter 's mountain , a small secondary tooth is formed , with its enamel and solid root at once , within the bony substance of the primordial or temporary tooth itself , as is to be seen in the small fragment now in the British Museum , and in tab .
XVI .
A , B , C , D , E ; which , by continuing to grow , seem to make by degrees sufficient cavities in the bony roots of the primary teeth : but what becomes of them at last , and how they are shed , I am not able to guess .
I have one in my collection , where the succeeding tooth is entirely formed within the center and substance of the primordial tooth .
In the 6th figure ( tab .
XV .
) a little oval cavity is observable , which has been the seat of a new or secondary tooth .
~ 6 .
The maxilla inferior of the incognitum , sent by me to the British Museum , is a most magnificent specimen , having fourteen teeth .
A similar one , somewhat longer ( as it measures 32/ 3 feet ) in my own collection , has also fourteen .
Another fragment of the left side , two feet long and eight inches broad , shows the primordial and succeeding teeth in the clearest manner .
The specimen , of which I sent a drawing ( tab .
XVI .
) to the illustrious President of our Society , Sir JOSEPH BANKS , is still more useful to confirm the mode of dentition than any other I have in my museum .
~ 7 .
Several ribs and the phalanges of the toes of the forefeet , a specimen of which I sent in a fragment from the same rock , of about a foot long and eight inches broad , may serve as another proof of the difference between these and the crocodile 's toes , when compared with the still valuable , though neglected , skeleton in the British Museum ; which I am sorry I could not make a drawing of , having been too much employed on other objects .
All these characteristic differences cannot fail to convince the learned Society of the truth of what I have asserted , about the animal these bones belonged to ; for though we cannot determine exactly the species itself , yet I flatter myself the preceding observations evidently prove , that they did not belong to any animal of the crocodile kind .
~ 8 .
Another very beautiful specimen , a foot and a half long , and about ten inches broad , I have been induced to add , because it contains the anterior part of the scutum of a very large turtle .
Of this Mr. JOHN HUNTER has an analogous bone from the same mountain in his valuable collection , but sent to him under another name .
I am convinced it belonged formerly to a turtle ; first , because I have from the same mountain the entire back of a turtle , four feet long and sixteen inches broad , a little damaged at the sides , and a pretty large fragment of another turtle , in my possession .
2dly , Because I have a similar one , but so placed within the matrix as to show the inside , which is perfectly analogous to the inside of that piece in the back of a large turtle I got in London , by the favour of Mr. SHELDON .
3dly , Because I have amongst these bones the lower jaw-bone of a very large turtle , of which the crura , though not entire , are seven inches long , and distant from one another six inches ; the thickness is equal to 1 1/ 4 inch .
All these fragments prove the frequency of turtle bones amongst the other fossil bones found in the mountain near Maestricht .
Dr. MICHAELIS wrote to me some time ago , that the abovementioned fragment , in Mr. J. HUNTER'S Collection , belonged to a bird ; which I could hardly believe , as I never had seen in any collection whatsoever , either in London , Paris , Brussels , Gottingen , Cassel , Brunswic , Hanover , or Berlin , nor in my own country , any fossil bone belonging to a bird .
I know there is a small one described in the Abbe ROZIER'S Journal de Physique , for March 1782 , which is at present in the collection of M. D'ARCET , at Paris .
I expect also from Montmartre a small leg of a petrified bird ; but these are the only ones I have ever heard of , those of Stonefield , near Woodstock , being most undoubtedly of fishes .
I think it is a circumstance worthy the attention of the curious , that no human bones , and of birds but very few , have been hitherto found in a petrified state , and belonging to the old world .
PETRUSCAMPE R. Klein Lankum , near Franeker , June 18 , 1786 .
EXPLANATIONOFTHEPLATE S. TA B. XV .
Fig. 1 , 2 .
Are vertebrae taken from the skeleton of the crocodile described by Dr. NEH .
GREW , in his Catalogue of the Natural Rarities at Gresham College , p. 42 .
and p. 43 .
a , b. c , f. ~ , ~ .
the bodies of the vertebrae ; a , b of the fourth ; c , f of the first vertebra of the neck ; ~ , z , t. and x , y , w. the spinous processes ; ~ ~ .
and s. the ascending ; t , and u v. the descending processes ; g , h , c , i. d , e , n , p , o , q. the transverse , united by cartilages to the bodies of the vertebrae .
GREW calls them ossa mucronata .
The tranverse processes of the fourth vertebra being lost , the roots of the mucronated processes are very evident at g h , i k. On the under part of these vertebrae are ( l and m ) processes , similar to those we find in the vertebrae of the neck in turtles and birds .
Not only the six posterior but the five anterior vertebrae of the back are provided with such processes ; of these , however , Dr. GREW makes no mention .
Fig. 2 .
Represents the seventh vertebra of the back ; A , and C. are the ascending and descending processes , forming the articulations with the adjacent vertebrae ; B. the transverse process , to which is united the rib FB .
in B. ; DE .
the spinous process ; H , H , I. the body of the same vertebra .
These figures are as large as the life , and made from the same skeleton , now in the British Museum .
The whole length is equal to 121/ 3 feet , Paris measure ; the head equal to 2 feet ; the neck equal to 1 foot ; the trunk equal to 3 feet 8 inches ; the tail equal to 5 feet 8 inches .
The measurement given by Dr. GREW does not agree with mine ; but he seems not to have taken it with great attention ( p. 42 .
) , for he makes use of the words about , almost , &amp;c. OBSERVATION .
What struck me was , the transverse future , a , b. c , f. ~ , ~ .
which divided the bodies of all the vertebrae of the neck , back , and loins .
This division ended with the os sacrum , which was entire , as were also the vertebrae of the tail .
Dr. GREW seems only to haven taken notice of the sutures belonging to the transverse processes .
I have a small skeleton of a crocodile equal to 13 inches , in which the 7 vertebrae of the neck , 12 of the back , and the 5 of the loins , are divided in the same manner as in the large skeleton in the British Museum .
Those of the os sacrum and tail are without , and have no mark of an epiphysis .
CONCLUSION .
The transverse division of the vertebrae abovementioned is also peculiar to this animal ; and there is no epiphysis , as in other animals .
To be sure of this , I dissected and made a skeleton of the Lacerta Iguana , LINN .
sp. 26 .
perfectly well described by MARCGRAF , Hist. Bras .
p. 236 .
cap. 11 .
; but I found no such divisions , though the animal was young , and though it had still epiphyses on the legs , &amp;c. The neck consists of 4 vertebrae , the back of 11 , the loins of 9 , the os sacrum of 2 , as in the crocodile ; the tail of more than 60 .
The dissection of tortoises seemed to me of consequence , at least a more accurate inspection of the vertebrae , particularly those of the neck , as being analogous in some respects to those of the crocodile , especially in the structure of the inferior processes D , and E , with l , m , fig. 1 .
Fig. 3 .
Represents two vertebrae of the neck of a pretty large turtle , natural size .
AB , BC .
the bodies ; L. and I. the ascending , H. and T. the descending processes ; R. K. the spinous , a , b. d , e. the transverse , and D. E. the inferior processes .
a , b , c. d , e , f. the transverse division of these , similar to that in the crocodile .
Fig. 4 .
A vertebra from the tail of a young phocaena or porpoise ; in which a , b. is an orbicular plate , united by means of cartilage to the body of the vertebra a , d. which is provided with such a one on both sides , a , b. and c , d. Those bony lamellae are the epiphyses of the vertebrae , and are alike in all quadrupeds , to which class all the cetaceous fishes belong .
When we consider the structure in general of these last , we find the hind legs only are wanting , and of course the ossa innominata ; but the ossa pubis are very remarkable in all of them .
Fig. 5 .
Is a fossil vertebra of the unknown animal , whose bones are so often met with in St. Peters ' Mountain at Maes7 tricht , tricht .
A , B , C , D. is the body ; C , I , K , E , F. the spinous processes ; C , K , I. the medullary canal , running under K , E , F , in a direction parallel to IF , and coming out again at F. The remaining marks of the lamellated epiphyses I , D. and A , B. are evident proofs of the analogy between these and the vertebrae of the cetaceous fishes ; and also of their want of resemblance to the vertebrae of the crocodile , as will appear by comparing the first and second figures with the fifth .
Fig. 6 .
Is a very accurate drawing of one of the fossil teeth belonging to the same incognitum .
AB C. is its point , of a lanceolated figure , whose edges B A , and A C , are dentated ; B C. is the root , uneven , bony , fixed within the socket with D , G , F. ; D , G , B , C. is covered with the gums ; H , I. is an oval sinuosity , in which generally the secondary teeth are generated , as is seen in tab .
XVI .
representing a fragment of the upper jaw-bone of the same incognitum , A , B , C , D , E. The teeth in all the Physeteres and Delphini have solid roots , except in the young ones , in which they often have cavities to receive the blood-vessels and nerves .
But the crocodile has the teeth entirely hollow , as appears in Fig. 7 .
in which the cavity ~ , ~ , ~ , shows the difference between the crocodile 's teeth and those of the cetaceous and other fishes .
This tooth is the anterior one of a large head of a crocodile , two feet long , and of the same size as that in the British Museum .
A hollow tooth may notwithstanding belong to a Physeter , as Dr. OTHO FABRICIUS observes in his Fauna Groenlandica , p. 44 .
when speaking of the Physeter microps : of which he says , ` ` Habet in maxilla inferiori dentes 22 , utrinque 11 arcuatos , falciformes , intus ad apicem usque cavos , ' ' within they are hollow to the very end .
TA B. XVI .
Fragmentum Maxillae superioris , lateris dextri capitis Physeteris incogniti , ex Monte St. Petri , Traj .
ad Mosam .
Origo dentium serotinorum ex ipsis radicibus solidis primo enatorum in quinque manifesta est .
Quae ad dentitionem hanc singularem pertinent , ex figur .
2 .
Tab. Fragm .
similis sed Maxill .
ins .
12 Aug. 1784 .
peti debent .
Crocodili Nilotici Colli Vert. IV .
V ~ ~stu Fig.2 .
xw Fig.1 .
A v abc gh def~ i no lp mr H oq Physet .
Incogn Dens .
A ex M. S. Petri .
Crocodili Dens .
Fig.6 .
~ Fig.7 .
B C D H D VII .
E Dorsi Testudines Ma Vertebrac ~ ~ Fig.3 .
R LH I Ca b Acde BB F ohD ~oE ooo~ G I Physeteris Incogniti ex Monte S Petri .
~ Fig.4 .
Fig 5 .
gCK aI h ac bef L Marinae ~ Collo .
~.3 .
H K T def C ~ E A E~ F P. Camper ~ Lancum , 15 ~ 786 .
bd Vertebra e cauda Phocaenae Junious .
D H A E ~ .
Camper f Lancumu 27 May 1785~ ~ .
natur

