XXIV .
Advertisement of the expected Return of the Comet of 1532 and 1661 in the Year 1788 .
By the Rev. Nevil Maskelyne , D. D. F. R. S. and Astronomer Royal .
Read June 29 , 1786 .
THE comet of 1531 , 1607 , and 1682 , having returned in the year 1759 , according to Dr. HALLEY'S prediction in his Synopsis Astronomiae Cometicae , first published in the Philosophical Transactions in 1705 , and re-published with his Astronomical Tables in 1749 , there is no reason to doubt that all the other comets will return after their proper periods , according to the remark of the same author .
In the first edition of the Synopsis he supposed the comets of 1532 and 1661 , from the similarity of the elements of their orbits , to be one and the same ; but in the second edition he has seemed to lessen the weight of his first conjecture by not repeating it .
Probably he thought it best to establish this new point in astronomy , the doctrine of the revolution of comets in elliptic orbits , as all philosophical matters in the beginning should be , on the most certain grounds ; and feared that the vague observations of the comet , made by APIAN in 1532 , might rather detract from , than add to , the evidence arising from more certain data .
Astronomers , however , have generally acquiesced in his first conjecture of the comets of 1532 and 1661 being one and the same , and to expect its return to its perihelium accordingly in 1789 .
The interval between the passages of the comet by the perihelium in 1532 and 1661 is 128 years , 89 days , 1 hour , 29 minutes ( 32 of the years being bissextile ) , which added to the time of the perihelium in 1661 , together with 11 days to reduce it from the Julian to the Gregorian stile , which we now use , brings out the expected time of the next perihelium to be April 27th , 1 h. 10~ in the year 1789 .
The periodic times of the comet , which appeared in 1531 , 1607 , and 1682 , having been of 76 and 75 years alternately , Dr. HALLEY supposed , that the subsequent period would be of 76 years , and that it would return in the year 1758 ; but , upon considering its near approach to Jupiter , in its descent towards the sun in the summer of 1681 , he found , that the action of Jupiter upon the comet was , for several months together , equal to onefiftieth part of the sun upon it , tending to increase the inclination of the orbit to the plane of the ecliptic , and lengthen the periodic time .
Accordingly , the inclination of the orbit was found by the observations made in the following year 1682 to be 22~ greater than in the year 1607 .
The effect of the augmentation of the periodic time could not be seen till the next return , which he supposed would be protracted by Jupiter 's action to the latter end of the year 1758 , or the beginning of 1759 .
M. CLAIRAUT , previous to its return , took the pains to calculate the actions both of Jupiter and Saturn on it during the whole periods from 1607 to 1682 , and from 1682 to 1759 , and thence predicted its return to its perihelium by the middle of April ; it came about the middle of March , only a month sooner , which was a sufficient approximation to the truth in so delicate a matter , and did honour to this great mathematician , and his laborious calculations .
The comet in question is also , from the position of its orbit , liable to be much disturbed both by Jupiter and Saturn , particularly in its ascent from the sun after passing its perihelium , if they should happen to be near it , when it appoaches to or crosses their orbits ; because it is very near the plane of them at that time .
When it passed the orbit of Jupiter in the beginning of February 1682 , O. S. it was 50~ in consequentia of that planet ; and when it passed the orbit of Saturn in the beginning of October 1663 , it was 17~ in consequentia of it .
Hence its motion would be accelerated while it was approaching towards the orbit of either planet by its separate action , and retarded when it had passed its orbit ; but , as it would be subjected to the effect of retardation through a greater part of its orbit than to that of acceleration , the former would exceed the latter , and consequently the periodic time would be shortened ; but probably not much , on account of the considerable distance of the comet from the planets when it passed by them ; and therefore we may still expect it to return to its perihelium in the beginning of the year 1789 , or the latter end of the year 1788 , and certainly some time before the 27th of April 1789 .
But of this we shall be better informed after the end of this year , from the answers to the prize question proposed by the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris , to compute the disturbances of the comet of 1532 and 1661 , and thence to predict its return * .
* Since this was written , I received the unwelcome news , in a letter from M. MECHAIN , of the Royal Academy of Sciences at Paris , that the Academy has not received satisfactory answers concerning the disturbances of the comet between 1532 and 1661 , and 1661 and the approaching return , and that the prize is referred to be adjudged of at Easter 1788 , and that it will be 6000 livres .
N. M. If it should come to its perihelium on the 1st of January 1789 , it might probably be visible , with a good achromatic telescope , in its descent to the sun , the middle of September 1788 , and sooner or later , according as its perihelium should be sooner or later .
It will approach us from the southern parts of its orbit , and therefore will first appear with considerable south latitude and south declination ; so that persons residing nearer the equator than we do , or in south latitude , will have an opportunity of discovering it before us .
It is to be wished that it may be first seen by some astronomer in such a situation , and furnished with proper instruments for settling its place in the heavens , the earliest good observations being most valuable for determining its elliptic orbit , and proving its identity with the comets of 1532 and 1661 .
The Cape of Good Hope would be an excellent situation for this purpose .
In order to assist astronomers in looking out for this comet , I have here given its heliocentric and geocentric longitudes and latitudes and correspondent distances from the sun and earth , on supposition that it shall come to its perihelium on January 1 , 1789 .
But if that should happen sooner or later , the heliocentric longitudes and latitudes and distances from the sun will stand good if applied to days as much earlier or later , as the time of the perihelium may happen sooner or later ; and the geocentric longitudes and latitudes and distances from the earth must be re-computed accordingly .
The calculations are made for a parabolic orbit from the elements determined by Dr. HALLEY from HEVELIUS'S observations in 1661 , only allowing for the precession of the equinoxes .
The elements made use of were as follows : Time of perihelium January 1 , 1789 , at noon .
Perihelium distance 0,44851 .
Place of ascending node 2~ 24~ 18~ .
Inclination of orbit to the ecliptic 32~ 36~ .
Perihelium forwarder in orbit than the ascending node 33~ 28~ .
It motion is direct .
Computed places of the comet , on supposition that it shall return to its perihelium January 1 , 1789 , at noon .
Dist .
Dist .
HeliocenHeliocen GeocenGeocenProduct of from from tric longiric latiric longiric latidistances Times .
~ .
the tude .
tude .
tude .
tude .
from ~ earth .
~ earth .
1788 S. D. M. D. M. S. D. M D. M. Apr. 23 , 7 4 , 0 4,52 11 3 54 30 56 S 11 16 ~ 27 5S 18,07 June 4 , 1 3 , 5 3,54 11 76 31 25 11 26 31 31 4 12,38 July 14 , 5 3 , 2,57 11 11 16 31 55 03 21 38 11 7,70 Aug. 2,46 2,75 2,15 11 13 47 32 10 048 42 59 5,90 20,43 2 , 5 1,79 11 16 39 32 22 02~ 48 16 4,48 Sept. 7 , 3 2,25 1,51 11 20 9 32 32 11 25 ~ 53 28 3,39 24 , ~ 2 , 1,29 11 24 16 32 36 11 13 12 56 45 2,58 Oct. 10,26 1,75 1,13 11 29 24 32 30 10 28 ~ 56 36 1,75 26,64 1,50 1,01 05 51 32 4 10 15 ~ 52 6 1,51 Nov. 9,34 1,25 0,88 0 14 19 31 0 10 8 36 46 47 1,10 23,39 1 , 0 0,76 0 26 4 28 32 10 4 10 39 0 0,76 Dec. 7,21 0,75 0,62 1 13 58 22 29 9 29 18 27 45 0,46 23,32 0,50 0,50 2 20 58 289 14 31 27S 0,25 24,35 0,49 0,51 2 24 18 009 12 ~00 0,25 1789 Jan. 1 , 0 0,45 0,59 3 23 25 17 17 N92 50 13 8N 0,26 The last observation made by HEVELIUS on the comet in 1661 was when its distance from the earth was 0,986 , and from the sun 1,37 , with what he calls a very long and good telescope ; at which time it appeared faint and small with it , though still sufficiently visible .
Let us suppose this to have been a telescope of 9-feet focal length , with an aperture of 1,65 inch ; then , because the diameter of the aperture of a telescope sufficient to render the comet equally visible should be as the product of its distances from the sun and earth , and the product of the numbers above-mentioned 0,986 and 1,37 is 1,35 , we shall have the following analogy to find the aperture of a refracting telescope sufficient to show the comet as it appeared to HEVELIUS .
As 1,35 : 1,65 inch : : 9 : 11 inches , so is the product of distances from the sun and earth to the diameter of the aperture required in inches .

