XXII .
Additional Observations on making a Thermometer for measuring the higher Degrees of Heat .
By Mr. Josiah Wedgwood , F. R. S. and Potter to Her Majesty .
Read June 22 , 1786 .
MY thermometer for measuring the higher degrees of heat having been honoured with the notice of this illustrious Society , I now request a further indulgence for a few more observations on the same subject .
In my first Paper *I communicated every thing that experience had then taught me , respecting both the construction and use of this thermometer ; but more extensive practice has since convinced me , that other managements and precautions are necessary , in order to bring it to the perfection it is capable of receiving : for pieces made of the same clay , and exactly of the same dimensions , have been found to differ in the degree of their diminution by fire , in consequence of some circumstances in the mode of their formation , at that time unheeded , and very difficult to be developed .
Of the two ways proposed for forming them , the mould and the press , the former was made choice of , as being , for general use , the most commodious .
The soft clay was pressed into a square mould with the fingers ; and the pieces , when dry , were pared down on two opposite sides , by means of a * Philosophical Transactions , Vol. LXXII .
paring gage made for that purpose , so as to pass exactly to 0~ at the entrance of the converging canal of the measuring gage .
But the pieces thus formed have been found liable , in passing through strong fire , to receive a little alteration in their figure , which produces an uncertainty with respect to their subsequent measurement : the two sides , instead of continuing flat , become concave ; the edges , both at top and bottom , projecting beyond the middle part , sometimes very considerably , as at a and b , fig. 1 , ( Tab. XIV .
) where AB represents a perpendicular section of an unburnt piece , and aba like section of the same piece after it has undergone a heat of 160 degrees .
This irregularity in the form , which is sensible only after passing through the high degrees of fire , was observed in some of the early experiments , but was not then looked upon as being productive of any error .
On more attentively examining this matter , it appeared , that when the clay is pressed into a mould , the surface in contact with the mould acquires a more compact texture than the inner part of the mass ; that this compactness restrains , in some degree , its diminution in the fire ; and therefore , that when this surface , or less diminishable crust , is pared off from the two sides only , the piece may be considered as having its upper and lower strata ( AA and BB , fig. 1 .
) composed of a less diminishable matter than the intermediate part , the necessary consequence of which structure will be such a figure as we find the pieces to assume ; for if any stratum in the mass shrinks less than the rest , the extremities of that stratum must be left proportionably prominent .
That this was the true cause of the inequality , I was convinced by firing some pieces unadjusted , with all their surfaces entire , as they came from the mould ; for these pieces , after passing through the same strong fires with the preceding , continued flat , with the angles regularly sharp , and without the least sensible prominence in any part .
Some of the moulds , employed for this use , were made of plaster , a material more convenient for the workman than metal , as the pieces part more freely from it , but which contributed greatly to increase the above-mentioned irregularity : for the plaster , by absorbing a portion of the water from the clay contiguous to it , renders the surface at the same time , even at the instant of contact , much more consistent , and consequently more difficult to press into the angles of the mould ; so that the outsides of these pieces were not only more compressed , but formed of clay of a different temper from the inner parts , being much drier or firmer ; a circumstance which , as will appear hereafter , restrains still more their diminution in the fire .
The moulds were therefore laid aside , and the press adopted in their stead ; for as the soft clay , pressed in a cylindrical vessel , gives way and escapes through an aperture made for that purpose ( by which means it is formed into long rods ) , the sides of the piece cannot be supposed to receive so great a degree of compressure against the sides of the aperture through which it is delivered in this operation , as it does against the sides of the mould , by which it is confined till every part has born a pressure sufficient to force the clay into every angle , which is much greater than even a workman would imagine till he comes to try the experiment himself .
But with this change some new difficulties arose ; for pieces pressed through the same aperture , and from the same press-ful of clay , and adjusted , when dry , to the same point in the gage , were found , after passing together through the same strong fires , to differ in their dimensions from one another , in some instances more than any of the preceding .
Having hitherto paid no particular attention myself to the mere manual labour of pressing the clay , I determined , upon this event , to go through that and every other operation , however simple and seemingly insignificant , with my own hands .
In doing this I observed , that the power necessary for forcing the clay through an aperture which bore but a small proportion to the diameter of the mass of clay in the press , was so great as to squeeze out , along with the clay that first passed through , a considerable portion of the water that belonged to the rest .
From this over-proportion of water in the composition of the first pieces they were soft and spongy , and the succeeding ones more and more compact , till at length the clay proved so stiff as scarcely to be forced through at all .
Clay , containing different proportions of water , is well known to diminish differently in drying ; but it was not imagined that , when dry , there would be any difference in its subsequent diminutions by fire .
Experiments however , multiplied in a variety of circumstances , showed decisively , what the pieces formed in the mould had given grounds to suspect , that those formed of the softest clay , and which had undergone the least pressure , diminished most in burning ; and that the diminution is uniformly less and less , in proportion to the greater degree of pressure or compactness .
The knowledge of the cause of the irregularity suggested a remedy .
I lessened the width of the press very much , so as to bring the diameter of the mass of clay , and that of the aperture through which it is delivered , to a nearer proportion with one another .
A much less degree of force being now sufficient , the pieces , or rods , were proportionably more uniform , though there was still a sensible difference , in consistence , between those which were first and last pressed out from the same mass of clay .
The intermediate ones , within a certain distance from the two extremes , corresponded very nearly with one another ; so that by rejecting a sufficient number of the first and last , and using the intermediate ones only , the inequality may be considered as almost annihilated .
I nevertheless still found that , in strong fire , the edges became a little prominent , though not so much as before .
I was aware that these pieces must partake , in some degree , of the imperfection of those made in the mould ; having their surfaces rendered , by their friction against the sides of the aperture , more compact than the inner part .
But I suspected that something might depend also upon the form , and accordingly made many trials for ascertaining the form that might be least liable to this irregularity : the angles only were bevilled off , the sides were rounded , the pieces were rounded all over , made of ovals and other curves , and both the longest and shortest dimensions were used as the extent to be measured : the general result was , that the nearer they came to a circular figure , the less inequality they contracted in the fire , and by making them entirely circular , the imperfection appeared to be obviated altogether ; cylindric pieces bearing the strongest fires without the least appearance of prominence or inequality in any part of their surface .
I have therefore chosen this last form , leaving only one narrow flat side ( ab , fig. 2 .
) as a bottom for the pieces to rest upon , and to distinguish the position in which they are to be measured in the gage .
I have endeavoured at the same time to obviate whatever inaccuracy the inequality of compactness may be capable of producing , by so adjusting the aperture through which the rods are pressed , and on which their figure and dimensions depend , as to supersede the use of the paring gage altogether ; that the whole surface may remain of the same uniform compactness which it received in the press .
And as it is scarcely practicable , in any mode of forming soft clay , to have all the pieces precisely of the same dimensions after drying , I do not reject those which come within two or three degrees of the standard , but , instead of injuring the surface by paring or rubbing , I mark on the ends the degrees which they respectively exceed or fall short ; which degrees are accordingly to be substracted , or added , in all observations of heat made with those pieces .
Strictly speaking , an allowance ought to be made also for the proportional diminution upon this excess or deficiency itself ; but the allowance for three degrees would not , at the melting heats of copper , silver , or gold , amount to more than a seventh part of a degree ; and at the extreme point of heat that I have been able to attain , when the piece has diminished 160/ 600 , or nearly one-fourth of its whole thickness , it comes only to four-fifths of a degree .
It may be proper to take notice of an irregularity in the apparent diminutions of the pieces , which was sometimes observed to happen from another cause , their bending a little in strong fire , so as to be prevented from going so far in the gage as they would have done if they had continued perfectly straight .
But as this takes place only in pieces of considerable length , and as they derive no advantage of any kind from that length , the remedy is too obvious to need being here mentioned .
Another fallacious appearance arose , not from any imperfection in the pieces themselves , but from a deception with respect to the heat in which the comparison of them had been made .
In one period of the course of my experiments , I employed , for firing them , a small , shallow , cylindrical vessel ( fig. 3 .
) setting the pieces on end , close together , on its bottom , and placing it in the middle of the fuel , in a common air-furnace , with care to keep the fire as equal all round it as possible .
It was expected , that all the pieces would receive an equal heat ; and as they were found , after the operation , to differ in their dimensions , sometimes considerably , from one another , these differences proved a source of much perplexity , till it was discovered that the pieces had really undergone unequal degrees of heat .
In the paper on the comparison of this thermometer with FAHRENHEIT'S * , I have taken notice of the great difficulty of obtaining , in small furnaces , a perfectly equal heat , even through the extent occupied by a few of these little pieces : and how different the heat may be in different parts of one vessel , we may be satisfied by an easy experiment , viz. setting a cylindrical rod of clay , of the length of eight or ten inches , upright in the middle of a crucible , and urging it with strong fire in a common small furnace ; the rod will be found very differently diminished at different parts of its height ; and if its height be sufficient to reach some way above the fuel , nearly the whole range of the thermometric scale may be produced in one rod ; an ocular proof , not only of the diversity of heat within a small compass , but likewise of the peculiar sensibility of this thermometer , every part of the mass expressing distinctly the degree of heat which it has itself felt .
It will be proper , in this experiment , to have a tube fixed in the bottom of the crucible , for keeping the rod steady , as at fig. 4 .
By this means the heat of my air-furnace renders a * Philosophical Transactions , vol. LXXIV .
rod of the thermometric clay tapering , from about four parts in diameter at top to three at bottom , which are nearly the proportions between the width of the piece when unburnt , or but just ignited , and when it has suffered a heat of 160 degrees .
To the foregoing sources of inequality in the pieces , one more may be added , small cavities , or air-bubbles accidentally enclosed , which sometimes happened in the earlier experiments .
In order to prevent these , particular attention is now paid by the workmen to what we call handing or slapping the clay , an operation by which its different parts are intermixed , and the mass rendered of an uniform temper throughout .
The workman takes a lump of the clay in his hands , perhaps of two pounds weight , and , breaking it in two in the middle , lays one part upon the other , and presses them flat again , repeating this forty or fifty times , or perhaps oftener .
Now , considering the pieces at first as two dissimilar masses , with any number of airbubbles enclosed ; each of these pieces being by the first doubling divided into two , by the next into four , by the third into eight , and so on in geometrical progression , each of the original masses will be divided by the fiftieth repetition into upwards of eleven thousand millions of millions of invisible laminae~-invisible , because the lump of clay would , long before the last doubling , be of one uniform colour , though at first one-half of it had been black , and the other white .
If therefore no air be enclosed between the pieces at the times of their being put together in this process , all the air which might have been in the mass before would certainly be driven out ; and , to avoid as much as possible the introduction of any fresh portions of air , the two separated pieces are each time made smooth , and a little convex , on the surfaces that are to be brought together .
By due attention to the circumstances above stated , any single quantity of clay may be made up into thermometer-pieces , that shall differ very little , if any thing at all , from one another .
But a new difficulty now arose , more embarrassing than any of the former ; that of procuring fresh supplies of clay , of the same thermometric quality with the first .
The quantity of the clay which , after trial of many others , I had made choice of , was small ; but the particular spot it was taken from being known , and having purchased the little estate in which it was raised , I had not a doubt of obtaining more of the same when it should be wanted : for clays in general , when raised from an equal depth , in the same stratum , and near the same place , are found to possess the same properties , with respect to ductility in the hands of the workman , a disposition to assume by fire a porcelain or vitreous texture , singly or in composition , and all other qualities relative to their use in pottery .
In this , however , I was deceived ; for when a fresh supply was wanted , to complete my experiments , though I had some taken from a pit joining to the first , and at the same depth , it was found to diminish differently from the former parcel .
I then had some raised from different parts of the same field and bed , and at different depths ; and in various other places in Cornwall , from the spot where this species of clayis first met with to the Land'sEnd ; but all these clays differed so much from the first in the quantity of their diminution by fire , and most of them likewise from each other , that I despaired of being ever~able to find one that would correspond with it , or any natural clays that could be obtained twice of exactly the same thermometric properties , how similar soever in other respects .
Upon a review of the numerous comparisons which I have made of these new clays , in different degrees of heat , from the commencement of redness up to intense fire , the most striking differences of the greatest part of them from the old seemed to originate in the lower stages of heat ; and of those which were got from the neighbourhood of the old , the variations from it in the higher stages seemed , for the most part , to be only consequences of those differences in the lower ones .
I have mentioned , in the first Paper , that the original thermometer-pieces had their bulk enlarged a little on the approach of ignition ; but that by the time they became visibly red-hot throughout , they are reduced to their former dimensions again ; and at this moment the thermometric diminution begins .
The new clays had their bulk enlarged in a much greater proportion , and the enlargement was of much longer continuance : some of them required a heat of 15 degrees to destroy the increase which ignition had produced in their bulk , and bring them back to their original dimensions : after this period , most of them diminished pretty regularly , and uniformly with the old , being nearly so many degrees behind it , in all the succeeding stages of heat , as they required to bring them back from the enlarged state .
I have mentioned also , in my former paper , that a quantity of air is extricated from the clay , most rapidly at the period in which the augmentation of bulk takes place ; and that the augmentation was probably owing to this air forcing the particles of the clay a little asunder , previous to the instant of its escape .
It was therefore presumed , that the greater extension of these new clays might be owing , either to a greater quantity , or stronger adhesion , of this combined air : and as clay , kept moist for a length of time , in certain circumstances , undergoes a process seemingly analogous to fermentation , tion , it was hoped that , by such a process , part of its combined air might be detached .
But experiments made on this idea have proved , that these clays , kept moist for a twelvemonth , -kept for a considerable length of time in a heat just below visible redness , -boiled in water for many hours , -alternately , and repeatedly , moistened and dried , -suffer no alteration in their thermometric properties , and continue to differ from the standard clay just as much as they did at first .
Some of these new clays differed from the old in a property still more essential , and by which I was much more disconcerted ; for though they continued diminishing with tolerable regularity , keeping only some degrees behind it , up to a certain period of heat , about that in which cast iron melts ; yet many of the pieces , urged with a heat known to be greater than that , were found not to be diminished so much as those which had suffered only that lower heat .
Further experiments showed , that , after diminishing to a certain point , they begin , upon an increase of the heat beyond that point , to swell again : and as this effect is constant in certain clays , and begins earliest in those which are most vitrescible , and as clays are found to swell upon the approach of vitrification , I look upon this second enlargement of bulk , however inconsiderable , as a sure indication of the clay or composition having gone beyond the true porcelain state , and of a disposition taking place towards vitrification ; which stage is always , so far as my experience reaches , attended with a new extrication of air ; and in some instances , this air being unable to make its escape from the tenacious mass that envelopes it , the burnt clay is thereby so much increased in bulk as to swim on water like very light wood .
The degree of heat therefore , at which this enlargement meant begins , may be considered as a criterion of the degree of vitrescibility of the composition ; which points out a new use of this thermometer , enabling us to ascertain the degree of vitrescibility of bodies that cannot actually be vitrified by any fires which our furnaces are capable of producing .
All my researches among the natural clays proving fruitless , and the experiments having shown that all those , which could sufficiently resist vitrification , diminished too little in the fire , I endeavoured to find a body possessed of the opposite property , that is , diminishing too much , and , by a mixture of these two , to produce the medium diminution required .
As I could not find any natural substance possessed of that property , which would not at the same time render the compound too vitrescible , I was obliged to have recourse to some artificial preparation ; and as the earth of alum is the pure argillaceous earth , to which all clays owe their property of diminution in the fire , possessing that property in a greater or less degree according to the quantity of alum earth in their composition , I mixed some of this earth with the clay , and found it to answer my wishes completely , both in procuring the necessary degree of diminution , and increasing its unvitrescibility .
So little is this compound disposed to vitrification , that the greatest heat I could give it , that of 160~ , did not even bring it to a porcelain texture , but left it still bibulous ; and as it does not arrive at the porcelain state in this fire , there can be no danger of its approaching too near to the vitrescent in any heat that we can produce in a furnace .
In order to obtain the exact medium required , I took one of the best of the clays I had procured from Cornwall , and mixed it with different proportions of the alum earth , till the composition was found , on repeated trials , to agree with the original in all degrees of heat .
This coincidence was not indeed essential ; but as many degrees of heat were already before the public , measured by thermometer-pieces made of the first clay , and as the correspondence of the first with FAHRENHEIT'S scale had likewise been in some measure ascertained , it was desirable that the same degrees of heat should continue to be expressed by the same numbers .
The alum earth is prepared for this purpose by dissolving the alum in water , precipitating with a solution of fixed alkali , and washing the earth repeatedly with large quantities of boiling water : when the earth has settled , the water above it is let off by cocks in the sides of the hogsheads ; and when the vessels are filled up with fresh water , care is taken to stir up the earth from the bottom , and mix it thoroughly with the liquor .
I find it most convenient to use the earth undried , in its gelatinous state , as in this state it unites easily and perfectly with the clay ; whereas , when the alum earth has concreted into dry masses , great labour is necessary to mix them uniformly together .
I have tried several different parcels of English alum , from the same and from different manufactories , and found no material difference in the quantity of earth it contains * .
Nor indeed would it be of any consequence if there was a difference in this respect , as the proportion of alum earth necessary for *A difference in the quantity of earth may arise from different proportions of GLAUBER'S salt and vitriolated tartar , of which I have found quantities very considerable , but nearly alike , in all the English alum I have examined .
These salts are doubtless formed by the kelp ashes employed in the preparation of the alum .
They are discovered by calcining the dried alum with charcoal powder , which decomposes the alum only , leaving the other two salts intermixed with the alum earth , from whence they may be extracted by water .
different clays , and even for different parcels of the same clay , can only be ascertained by repeated trials , adding successive quantities of the earth till the desired effect is found to be produced .
Ten hundred weight of the Cornwall porcelain clay which I have now in use required all the earth that was afforded by five hundred weight of alum .
It is material in this place to observe , that the earth of alum is extremely tenacious of water , insomuch that , though apparently dry , the water and air amount to near as much as the pure earth , and are not to be completely driven out without a full red heat .
When divided by the admixture of other earthy bodies , it parts with its water easier indeed than before ; but a mixture containing so much of it as the thermometric composition does , is far more retentive of water than common clay , and requires to be kept for some time in a heat equal to that of boiling water , before it is to be considered as dry , that is , before the adjustment of the pieces in the gage .
If they are adjusted when only apparently dry , or of such a degree of dryness as they can be brought to by a heat that the hand can bear , the heat of boiling water will diminish them two or three degrees ; and the greatest part of what they have thus been deprived of , they gradually recover again on being exposed to the atmosphere , so that the adjustment must be made immediately after the boiling heat .
By the same expedient to which I have thus been obliged to have recourse for procuring to the porcelain clay of Cornwall the standard degree of diminution , and resistance to fire , the same qualities may probably be communicated to any other clay that is tolerably pure from calcareous earth and iron ; so that the thermometer clay is no longer to be considered as the produce of any particular spot ( which was the principal inconVOL .
LXXVI .
Ggg venience venience originally imagined to attend it ) , but may be procured and prepared in all parts of the world where good common clay , and alum , are to be found ; and corresponding thermometers may , consequently , be constructed , without any standard to copy from .
For , if a converging canal be formed , of any convenient length , with the widths at the two ends in the proportion of 5 to 3 , with the sides perfectly straight , and divided into 240 equal parts , numbering the divisions from the wider end * ; -and if a clay be obtained of such quality , that when formed , in the manner already mentioned , into pieces of such size as to enter to o in the gage or canal , these pieces shall just begin to diminish , or go a little further in the canal , by a heat visibly red ; -go to 27 , by the heat in which copper melts ; about 90 by the welding heat of iron ; about 160 , by the greatest heat that can be produced with coaked pit-coal in a well constructed common air-furnace , about eight inches square , still continuing bibulous , so as to stick to the tongue : such gages , and pieces of such clay , so adjusted , will always compose correspondent thermometers .
Having mentioned occasionally several alternate periods of dilatation and contraction in clay , it may be proper to state , and bring into one view , the whole succession of changes which I have observed in this curious material ; as otherwise they might create some confusion in the minds of those who have not had occasion to think attentively on this subject , and lead them to ask how a body so variable , and liable to such opposite changes from different degrees of heat , can yet be a just measure of those degrees .
* Or the divisions on the side may be continued to 300 ; and in that case , instead of the widths of the two ends being in proportion of the odd numbers 5 and 3 , the one will be just double to the other .
The changes which take place in all the natural clays that have come under my examination are six .
1 .
The first is , the shrinking of the moist clay in drying , from the mere loss of its water .
The purer the clay is , the more water it requires to soften it , and the more it diminishes in bulk by the loss of that water .
2 .
The dry clay , gradually heated , preserves its bulk unvaried up to the approach of ignition .
At this period it is enlarged a little ; probably , as already observed , from its combined air endeavouring to escape .
3 .
When this air has made its escape , the clay begins to diminish , or to lose the bulk it had before acquired ; and returns back , sooner or later , to the same dimensions which it was of when dry .
It is at this point that the thermometric diminution commences .
4 .
From this point the clay continues to diminish more and more in proportion as the heat is increased .
This I call the thermometric stage of diminution : it is of greater or less extent , terminating at different periods of heat , according to the nature of the clay : in the standard thermometer clay , it commences with visible ignition , and continues to ( doubtless far beyond ) the extreme heats of our furnaces , an interval consisting of 160 degrees of the scale : in others , it begins 4 , 6 , and in some even 15 of those degrees later , and terminates also much sooner : and in some its whole extent is not above 20 of the same degrees .
Throughout the greatest part of this stage , the clays are found to retain their property of sticking to the tongue and imbibing water : between this bibulous state and the vitrescent there is an intermediate one , distinguished by the name of porcelain ; and to the higher term of this porcelain state the stage of thermometric diminution seems to continue .
5 .
When the clay has passed the porcelain state , it begins to be enlarged again , a symptom of the vitrescent stage being commenced ; and in this period it swells more or less , according to the nature of its composition .
6 .
By further heat the swelled mass , becoming fluid , subsides , is converted into glass or flag , and contracted into less volume than the clay occupied in any of its preceding states .
It is plain , therefore , that clay can be a measure of heat no further than from ignition , or that point beyond ignition where the third stage terminates , to the beginning of the vitrescent stage ; and that , as the three first changes are completely passed before the clay is applied to thermometric purposes , being strictly no other than preparatory processes , the thermometerpieces , whatever clay they may be made of ( provided it is sufficiently unvitrescible ) , are to be considered as possessing only the fourth stage .
But a singular property of the composition of clay and alum earth remains to be mentioned , viz. that it has really no other than this one stage : it suffers no enlargement of its bulk at ignition , or in any other period ; but proceeds in one uninterrupted course of diminution , from the soft state in which the pieces are formed , up to the extreme fires of our furnaces .
Though the diminution , however , is uninterrupted , it is at the same time so inconsiderable at the beginning , from the heat of boiling water ( at which the pieces are adjusted ) up to ignition , that the same point of visible redness is taken for the commencement of the scale , in this as in the original clay , without any sensible error or variation in their progress .
I am inclined to believe , though experiments have not yet enabled me to speak with certainty on this point , that the same cause which enlarges the natural clays on their first exposure to the fire , operates also in this composition , but in a much lower degree ; that while the natural clays have their whole mass distended by the efforts of the air in forcing its passage , the composition is only restrained in its diminution , or prevented from diminishing so fast as it otherwise would do , and as it is found to do in the subsequent part of its course , after the air has escaped from it .
As the composition of clay and alum earth is far more tenacious of water than the clay itself , and was found , after being dried by the heat of boiling water , to yield , by distillation in a retort , above three times as much aqueous fluid as the original thermometric clay did ; it seems probable , that a part of this water , retained to the approach of ignition , and in a state of chemical combination , may facilitate the passage of the air , serving as a vehicle to convey it off through interstices not permeable to air alone , and consequently enabling it to escape without doing that violence to the mass , which the natural clays sustain from the expulsion of their air after the water has been detached from it ; for the experiments of Dr. PRIESTLEY have shown , that vessels even of burnt clay are permeable to air when they have imbibed water into their substance , though not at all so in a dry state .
I have now communicated the result of a series of experiments which have taken considerable time , attention , and labour to complete .
Whether the importance of the object will justify me in troubling this illustrious Society with so minute a detail of the most material operations , and their results , is not for me to determine .
If the thermometer should not yet be brought to the perfection that may be wished , I flatter myself that some abler hand may now take up the subject to more advantage ; and that philosophers and artists will not be less successful in supplying what may still be deficient , and in ascertaining , by the contraction of argillaceous matter , the measurements and effects of the various degrees through the immense extent of luminous fire , than they have been with respect to the limited and narrow compass of low heat , which is measurable by the expansion of fluids .
Fig.4 .
Fig.1 .
AAaa BBbb Fig.2 .
ab

