IX .
Observations and Remarks on those Stars which the Astronomers of the last Century suspected to be changeable .
By Edward Pigott , Esq. ; communicated by Sir Henry C. Englefield , Bart. F. R. S. and A. S. Read February 9 , 1786 .
IT is about a century since HEVELIUS , MONTANARI , FLAMSTEED , MARALDI , and CASSINI , noticed a certain number of stars which they supposed had either disappeared , changed in brightness , or were new ones ; and yet to this day we have acquired no further knowledge of them .
This may be attributed to the difficulty of finding out what star is meant , and the not having exact observations of their relative brightness .
I therefore have drawn up the following catalogue , and made the necessary observations ; so that in future we can examine them without much trouble , and be certain of any change that may take place .
To accomplish this , it was requisite to compare with attention many authors and most of the catalogues of stars ; in doing which I have perceived several undoubted errors , and others highly probable ; but as entering into a discussion of such disagreements would swell this account considerably , and make it very intricate , I shall avoid , as much as possible , any thing of the kind that is not immediately necessary .
In order to separate certainty from doubt , I have classed these stars in two divisions ; the first are undoubtedly changeable ; the others remain yet to be better authenticated .
Though some of them bear all the appearance of being variable , still no certainty of their being so has come to my knowledge .
To those of the first class are subjoined observations made on them within these last four years , from which the period and progressive changes of some are deduced , though never settled before , and if already known are more exactly determined by comparing my observations with former ones .
Also , as the position of several are determined only by ancient astronomers , and therefore inaccurately , I have observed them with great exactness , the declinations being taken with a BIRD'S eighteeninch quadrant , and the right ascensions with a three-feet transit instrument : these last may serve in future to discover their proper motions in right ascension , for which reason I shall specify the stars to which they were compared .
The stars of the second class have either their relative brightness exactly settled , or their non-existence ascertained .
I have also pointed out the probability of a mistake in several , and in general given an account of the appearance they have had within these few years .
Catalogue of variable Stars , reduced to the beginning of 1786 .
Class the first .
Greatest R. A. in From whence reNames .
Declination .
and least time .
duced .
magnitudes .
h. ' ' ' o ' ' ' Nova 1572 , in CassiRICCIOLUS'S Al00 13 00 62 58 +N10 opea , ... .
magestum , &amp;c. ~ Ceti ... .
28 33 3 57 25 S20 BRADLEY .
Algol ... .
2 54 19 40 6 55 N24 MAYER .
MAYER'S 420th in Leo 9 36 5 12 25 00 N60 MAYER .
In Hydra ... 13 18 4+ 22 9 38 S40 From my observat .
Nova 1604 in Ser17 18 00 21 10 1/ 2 S10 Phil. Tr. No 346 .
pentarius. .
~ Lyrae ... .
18 42 11 33 7 46 N3 4 .
5 BRADLEY .
Near the Swan 's head 19 38 58 26 48 1/ 2 N30 Phil. Tr. No 65 .
~ Antinoi ... 19 41 34 00 28 14 N 3 .
45 LA CAILLE .
In the Swan 's neck 19 42 21 32 22 58 N50 From my observat .
In the Swan 's breast 20 9 54 37 22 37 N30 From my observat .
~ Cepnei ... 22 21 00 57 20 00 N 4 .
3 4 .
5 FLAMSTEED .
Class the second .
HAVELIUS'S 6 Cassiopeae 00 23 16 60 50 00 N70 HEVELIUS .
46 or ~ Andromedae 19 46 44 24 00 N 4 .
5 5 .
6 FLAMSTEED .
50 or v Andromedae 1 24 16 40 20 15 N 4 .
50 FLAMSTEED .
HEVELIUS'S 41 Androm .
1 28 40 41 31 1/ 4 N5 - .
HEVELIUS .
TYCHO'S 20th Ceti 1 39 .
13 20 .
S50 TYCHO .
55 or Neb. Andromedae 1 40 30 39 40 3N6 - .
FLAMSTEED .
PTOL .
and UL .
BEIGH 2 42 .
9 40 .
S40 UL .
BEIGH .
~ Eridani. .
41 Tauri ... 3 53 27 27 00 39 N50 FLAMSTEED .
47 Eridani ... 4 23 54 8 41 40 S40 FLAMSTEED .
Near 53d Eridani .
4 29 00 12 30 ~S40 By estimation .
~ Canis Majoris .
6 54 5 15 19 36 S30 LA CAILLE .
~ Geminorum. .
7 32 11 + 28 31 38 N13 MASKELYNE .
~ Leonis ... .
9 20 24 12 14 23 N46 MAYER .
~ Leonis ... 9 32 3 14 59 36 N 5 .
60 MAYER .
25th Leonis. .
9 46 8 12 20 36 N 6 .
70 FLAMSTEED .
BAYER'S i Leonis .
9 52 1/ 2 15 30 .
N60 TYCHO .
~ Ursae Majoris. .
12 4 45 58 13 24 N24 LA CAILLE .
Class the second continued .
Greatest R. A. in From whence reNames .
Declination .
and least Time .
duced .
magnitudes .
h. ' ' ' o ' ' ' ~ Virginis ... 12 7 43 00 24 16 N60 MAYER .
BAYER'S * near g~ 12 53 00 10 00 .
S60 From maps .
In N. thigh of Virgo 13 29 + 00 30 .
S60 From maps .
91 Virginis ... 13 43 43 25 50 N60 FLAMSTEED .
~ Draconis ... 13 58 36 65 24 8N24 BRADLEY .
Mem.de l'Acad .
In west scales of Libra 14 53 1/ 2 13 26 .
S60 des Sciences .
PTOL.andUL .
BEIGH'S 15 29 + 20 30 .
S47 UL .
BEIGH .
6th unformed in Libra ~ Librae ... .
15 29 39 19 58 27 S 4- .
LA CAILLE .
TYCHO'S 11th Librae 15 37 1/ 2 19 30 .
S40 TYCHO .
33 Serpentis. .
15 38 00 17 14 00 N60 FLAMSTEED .
Near ~ Ursae Minoris 16 1/ 4 .
82 3/ 4 .
N60 From maps .
PTOL .
14 Ophiuchi 17 2 14 26 15 37 S40 BRADLEY .
PTOL .
13 Ophiuchi 17 18 + 20 35 .
S40 PTOL .
PTOL .
18 Ophiuchi 17 22 .
24 10 .
S50 PTOL .
~ Sagittarii ... 18 42 00 26 32 34 S24 MAYER .
~ Serpentis ... 18 45 35 3 56 26 N45 LA CAILLE .
TYCHO'S 27th Capricor .
21 41 .
14 28 .
S60 TYCHO .
TYCHO'S 22d Androm .
21 43 1/ 2 49 15 .
N40 TYCHO .
TYCHO'S 19 Aquarii 22 25 .
15 55 .
S60 TYCHO .
~ Andromedae. .
22 52 6 41 10 45 N46 LA CAILLE .
LA CAILLE'S 483 22 55 40 8 50 45 S70 LA CAILLE .
Zodi .
Cat ... I shall now proceed to give a short account of these stars , and begin with those of the first class .
The famous Nova of 1572 in Cassiopea .
Several astronomers are of opinion , that it has a periodical return , which KEILL and others have conjectured to happen every 150 years .
This is also my opinion ; and I cannot think its not being noticed at the completion of every term a mate2 rial rial objection , since perhaps , as with most of the variables , it may at different periods have different degrees of lustre , so as sometimes to increase only to the ninth magnitude ; and if this be the case , its period is probably much shorter .
This induced me , in September 1782 , to take a plan of the smallest stars near its place , and which I have examined often since , but found no alteration .
~ Ceti .
Since the end of 1782 I have observed very exactly the decrease of brightness of this star ; but never have seen it of above the 6th magnitude .
Oct. 29 , 1782 , it was of the 7th magnitude , and gradually decreased till Dec. 30 , it being then of the 8 .
9th magnitude .
1783 , Feb. 16 , certainly less than the 9th magnitude .
1783 , August 25 , of the 6th magnitude , and gradually decreased until Dec. 14 , being then of the 10th magnitude , and equal to the little star close to it .
1784 , Jan. 11 , I thought it by intervals still less than the same little star .
1784 , Sept. 12 , it was of the 7 .
8th magnitude , and gradually decreased until Dec. 9 , and then was of the 9th magnitude , and rather brighter than the little star .
As a matter of curiosity , I have deduced its period from the times when it was equal to a certain star in the course of its decrease ; the results were 320-337 and 328 days ; but M. CASSINI determined its mean period with greater exactness to be 334 days .
Mr. GOODRICKE saw it Aug. 9 , 1782 , of the 2d magnitude , rather brighter than ~ and less than ~ Ceti .
Sept. 5 , it was of the 3d magnitude , being equal to ~ Ceti .
Algol .
The period of Algol , discovered by Mr. GOODRICKE , gave us some new light into the nature of the fixed stars .
Though the phenomenon seem to attract the attention of most astronomers , still there are some points which require further investigation .
Its degree of brightness , when at its minimum , is different in different periods ; and also , I think , when at its full , it is sometimes brighter than ~ Persei , and at other times less .
Whether these differences return regularly after a certain number of periods remains yet to be examined .
My last observations , when it was at the middle of its minimum , are , h. ' 1785 , July 8 , at 11 50 undoubtedly less than ~ Persei .
July 31 , at 9 50 equal to ~ Persei .
a remarkable observation ; rather less than ~ Persei ; Sept. 12 , at 10 45 evidently brightner than ~ ; nearly of the 3d mag .
MAYER'S No 420 , lately discovered to be variable by M. KOCH .
A few years before 1782 , M. KOCH saw the No 420 undoubtedly less than the No 419 of MAYER'S Catalogue .
In February 1782 , he found them both exactly of the same brightness , therefore of the 7th magnitude .
From an extract of a letter I have lately seen , the variable was of the 9th magnitude in April , 1783 , and of the 10th in April , 1784 .
I have often seen the No 419 , but never the variable , though I have frequently looked for it with a night-glass , and on the 4th of April , 1785 , in a 3-feet achromatic transit instrument .
Variable in Hydra .
MARALDI , in 1704 , having found that this star had a periodical variation , continued to examine it for several years , and concluded its period to be about two years , though with considerable variations ; in which he was much mistaken , as will appear from the following results , which show that its period in all probability is tolerably regular , and only of 494 days .
Dates when it was at the middle of its greatest brightness , estimated from MARALDI'S observations .
1704 , March 14 , he saw it nearly of the same magnitude from the beginning of March until the beginning of April ; it then decreased .
1705 , ... he saw it very faint in November , 1705 , and found it decreasing : this observation is too imperfect .
1708 , May 22 , accurately determined ; its increase and decrease being well observed .
1709 , Nov. 10 , : : doubtful , its decrease only being observed .
1712 , May 1 , : : ditto , ditto , ditto .
1784 , Jan. 26 , by me , very accurately , its increase and decrease being observed .
See the Observations that conclude this paper .
1785 , May 27 , ditto , ditto , ditto .
The four greatest intervals of MARALDI'S Observations give for single periods in days thus 495-517-480 and 510 , the mean being 5001/ 2 , which is tolerably exact considering how doubtful the observations of 1709 and 1712 are .
My two make it 487 days ; but as the interval is only a single period , it may err 10 days ; I therefore shall take a mean between the results , which is 494 , and proceed on to the following comparisons of MARALDI'S two best observations with mine .
1708 , May 22 , interval of 56 periods , each of 4932/ 3 days .
1784 , Jan. 26 , 1708 , May 22 , interval of 57 periods , each of 4931/ 2 days .
1785 , May 27 , 1704 , Mar. 14 , interval of 59 periods , each of 4941/ 2 days .
1784 , Jan. 26 , 1704 , Mar. 14 , interval of 60 periods , each of 4941/ ~ days .
1785 , May 27 , A single period , on a mean , 494 days .
If MARALDI'S observations of 1704 and 1708 are exact to a month , and there is no reason to believe otherwise , the period at that time seems to have been a few days longer than it is at present , and therefore the one here deduced may be esteemed as the mean period .
Particulars of the changes it undergoes .
1 .
When at its full brightness it is of the 4th magnitude , and has no perceptible change for about a fortnight .
2 .
It is about six months in increasing from the 10th magnitude , and returning to the same .
3 .
Therefore it may be considered as invisible also during six months .
4 .
It is considerably quicker in increasing than in decreasing , perhaps by half .
Though when at its full it may always be stiled of the 4th magnitude , it does not constantly attain exactly the same degree of brightness , but the differences are very small , as shown below .
1704 , brighter than ~ .
much brighter than ~ , being nearly 1784 , between ~ and ~ Hydrae .
1708 , brighter than ~ .
1785 , rather brighter than ~ .
Its mean right ascension , computed from my observations , and reduced to Jan. 1 , 1784 , is o ' ' ' from 4 observations , compared to ~ ~ , made between March 199 29 30 and May 1784 .
199 29 21 from 2 ditto , compared to MAYER'S 538 , made in May , 1784 .
199 29 20 from ~ ditto , compared to ~ Hydrae , made between March and May , 1784 .
199 29 24 mean right ascension for Jan. 1 , 1784 , on a mean .
HEVELIUS'S 30th Hydrae is the above star ; he marks it of the 6th magnitude ; I find it in no other Catalogue .
The famous Nova of 1604 , in Serpentarius .
A full account of this star is given by KEPLER , and it seems to have had a similar appearance to the Nova in Cassiopea ; therefore the reflections delivered there need not be again repeated .
In July , 1782 , I took a plan of the smallest stars near its place , which was examined every year since , but no alteration was perceived .
~ Lyrae .
Mr. GOODRICKE discovered the variation and period of this star , and hopes soon to settle its different phases with more exactness ; I shall therefore not enter into any detail , being certain it cannot be in better hands .
In his last account he mentions having first suspected the period to be only of six days nine hours ; such has always been my opinion , and which material point will probably be more satisfactorily determined in his next publication .
Nova near the Swan 's Head of 1670 .
This star was first seen in December 1669 by Don ANTHELME ; it soon became of the 3d magnitude , and disappeared in 1672 , after having undergone several variations .
I have constantly looked for it since November , 1781 , without success ; had it increased to only the 10th or 11th magnitude , I should have perceived it , having taken an exact plan of all the surrounding stars .
~ Antinoi .
The variation and period of this star I discovered last year , and had the honour of communicating an account of it to the Society : as at present a long interval is elapsed since my first observations , and that lately I have noted some of its phases with exactness , I shall compare them to those observed in 1784 , which of course will give results more satisfactory .
The period , as settled in my former paper , is 7 d. 4 h. 38~ ; but for reasons there alleged , it must be much less precise than the following .
1785 , July 18 , at 9 h. times when ~ Antinoi was between Sept. 6 , at 18 its least and greatest brightness .
Sept. 27 , at 22 These being compared to similar observations of Sept. 12 and 19 , 1784 , make the length of a single period thus : D. H. M. 74 12 74 19 74 17 74 22 747 74 12 74 15 on a mean .
I see no reason to alter materially the other points ; but believe them more exact thus : 40 hours at its greatest brightness .
66 in decreasing .
30 at its least .
36 in increasing .
It also , in every period , seems to attain the same degree of brightness when at its full , and to be equally decreased .
Variable in the Swan 's Neck .
During these three years I have observed this star with particular attention , as may be seen by the observations that conclude this Paper , and determined the middle time of its greatest brightness very exactly , thus : 1783 , July 9 , of the 6 .
7th magnitude .
1784 , Aug. 4 , of the 5 .
6th 1785 , Sept. 1 , of the 6th The The second of these , being compared to that of Nov. 20 , 1687 , made by KIRCH , gives 406 days exactly for one period , the interval between them being 35322 days , and divided by 87 periods .
I make the divisor 87 , in order to get a result nearest to that settled by MARALDI and CASSINI of 405 , and by M. LE GENTIL of 405,3 days .
We cannot suppose that these great astronomers have made any mistake ; and on the other hand , it seems hardly possible , that the mean of my observations alone , which makes the period 392 days , can err 14 ; but perhaps its period is irregular ; to determine which several intervals of 15 years ought to be taken , and I am much inclined to believe , that it will be found of only 396 days 21 hours .
Particulars of the changes it undergoes .
1 .
When at its full brightness it has no perceptible change for about a fortnight .
2 .
It is about 31/ 2 months in increasing from the 11th magnitude to its full brightness , and the same in decreasing .
3 .
Therefore it may be considered as invisible during six months .
4 .
It does not attain the same degree of brightness at every period , being sometimes of the 5th , and other times of the 7th magnitude .
Its mean right ascension , computed from my observations , and reduced to Aug. 1 , 1783 , is 295 33 46 from 2 observe .
compared to ~ Cygni , made in July and August , 1783 .
295 33 45 from 2 ditto , compared to ~ Lyrae , ditto .
295 33 45 from 1 ditto , compared to ~ Lyrae , made in August , 1783 .
295 33 55 from 3 ditto , compared to ~ Lyrae , made in July and August , 1783 .
295 33 52 from 2 ditto , compared to ~ Cygni , made in August 1783 .
295 33 481/ 2 mean right ascension for August 1 , 1783 , on a mean .
Variable in the Swan 's Breast .
This star was first seen by G. JANSONIUS in 1600 , and afterwards frequently observed by different astronomers , but with intervals of ten or more years , which is probably the reason why no regularity in its changes has yet been deduced .
I have examined minutely the observations made in the last century , and shall venture to give the following results .
1 .
Continues at its full brightness for about five years .
2 .
Decreases rapidly during two years .
3 .
Invisible to the naked eye for four years .
4 .
Increases slowly during seven years .
5 .
All these changes , or its period , are completed in 18 years .
6 .
It was at its minimum at the end of the year 1663 .
It does not always increase to the same degree of brightness , being sometimes of the 3d , and at other times only of the 6th magnitude .
I am entirely ignorant whether it is subject to the same changes since this century , having not met with any series of observations on it ; but if the above conjectures are exact , it will be at its minimum in a very few years .
Since November , 1781 , I have constantly seen it of the 6th magnitude , being rather less than No 28 , 29 , and m , and rather brighter than 36 and 40 Cygni .
Sometimes I suspect it has rather decreased within these two last years , though in a very small degree .
Its mean right ascension , computed from my observations , and reduced to Sept. 1 , 1782 , is 302 26 43 from 3 observations , compared to ~ Cygni , made in October , 1781 .
302 26 46 from 3 ditto , compared to ~ Cygni , made in August , 1782 .
302 26 52 from 1 ditto , compared to ~ Aquilae , made ditto .
302 26 46 from 1 ditto , compared to ~ Cygni , made ditto .
302 26 39 from 1 ditto , compared to ~ Andromedae , made in October 1781 .
302 26 45 mean right ascension for Sept. 1 , 1782 , on a mean .
FLAMSTEED has this star in his Catalogue ; but , I believe , observed it only once .
~ Cephei .
This is the last variable star discovered , and again by Mr. GOODRICKE .
Its changes are very difficult to be seen , unless examined when at its minimum and full brightness .
I have lately made some good observations on it thus : 1785 , Aug. 30 , at 14 h. less than ~ Cephei .
31 , at 9 h. equal if not brighter than ~ Cephei .
Sept. 15 , at 121/ 2 h. less than ~ Cephei .
16 , at 8 h. between ~ and ~ Cephei .
at 11 h. increased , but not as bright as ~ .
17 , at 11 h. rather brighter than ~ .
26 , at 111/ 2 h. equal or less than ~ .
27 , at 8 h. evidently brighter than ~ .
Therefore it was between its least and greatest brightness August 31 , at noon , and Sept. 26 , at 21 h. : these being compared to my first observations , when also between its least and greatest brightness on Nov. 20 , at 3 h. and Nov. 30 , at 15 h. 1784 , give the following results , the mean of which corroborates that deduced by Mr. GOODRICKE of 5 d. 8 h. 37~ 1/ 2 .
D. H. M. 58 35 58 41 58 33 58 39 Length of a single period 58 37 on a mean .
~ Cephei concludes the stars of the first class ; those that follow are of the second .
HAVELIUS'S 6th Cassiopeae .
In 1782 I first perceived that this star was missing ; nor could I find it in 1783 and 1784 .
46th or ~ Andromedae .
This star is said to have diminished in brightness .
In 1784 and 1785 I found it , by very exact observations , less than ~ , equal to w * , and brighter than d and ~ ; yet I must mention that it is marked in my journal as being sometimes brighter , and at other times less than w * ; but still I am not convinced , that it varies in brightness .
FLAMSTEED , in his Catalogue , annexes no character to his 46th Andromedae ; but in vol. II .
of his Hist. Caelest .
p. 135 .
and 138 .
he marks it ~ .
*I suspect an error in this character , but cannot be certain .
H. E. FLAMSTEED'S 50 , 52 , ~ Andromedae , and HEVELIUS'S 41 Andromedae .
As the position and characters of these stars differ considerably in different Catalogues , and that some of them are mentioned by CASSINI to have disappeared and re-appeared , I shall give their brightness as observed in 1783 , 1784 , and 1785 .
FLAMSTEED'S 50th of the 4 .
5th magnitude , and equal , if not rather less than ~ Andromedae .
~ of the 5th magnitude , and equal to 46 and 48 Andromedae .
49 of the 5 .
6th magnitude , and are of the 52 same brightness .
HEVELIUS'S 41 A star between FLAMSTEED'S 52 and HEVELIUS'S 41 is of the 6th magnitude , or rather less .
I could not see TYCHO'S 19th Andromedae ; but I take this star to be the same as HEVELIUS'S 41 Andromedae .
TYCHO'S 20th Ceti .
This must be the star which HEVELIUS said had disappeared , being TYCHO'S second in the Whale 's belly .
There can hardly be any doubt but that it is the ~ , misplaced by TYCHO .
This ~ is of the 4 .
5th magnitude , and of the same brightness as the three ~ Aquarii .
FLAMSTEED'S 55th Andromedae , marked Neb. in his Catalogue .
It is mentioned in the latest Catalogues of Nebulae that this nebula could not be found .
FLAMSTEED , who , I believe , only observed it once , viz. Oct. 17 , 1691 , does not mark it nebulous ; nor does it appear to me such , but as a star of the 6th magnitude .
There are a few small stars near it , which to the naked eye , when the air is very clear , make it appear nebulous , which probably is the reason why FLAMSTEED marked it thus in his Catalogue .
~ or PTOL .
and UL .
BEIGH'S 17th Eridani .
FLAMSTEED says , he could not see this star in 1691 and 1692 .
In 1782 , 1783 , and 1784 , I observed one of the 7th magnitude in that place ; the relative brightness of which appeared always the same , viz. less than two little stars near and below n Eridani .
FLAMSTEED'S 41 Tauri .
This star was thought by CASSINI to be a new one or variable .
I see little or no reason to be of that opinion ; that it is not new is evident , since it is UL .
BEIGH'S 26th and TYCHO'S 43d .
In 1784 and 1785 I found it of the 5th magnitude , being equal to ~ , and brighter than ~ , P , and ~ Tauri .
Star about 201/ 4 North of 53d Eridani , and 47 Eridani .
The first of these stars CASSINI thought a new one , and that it was not visible in 1664 .
In 1784 I found it was less than w , and d , brighter than A , and seemed equal to ~ Eridani .
CASSINI mentions another star thereabouts , which he also esteemed a new one : this is probably FLAMSTEED'S 47th .
In 1784 it appeared rather less than 46th .
~ Canis Majoris .
MARALDI could not see this star in 1670 ; but in 1692 and 1693 it appeared of the fourth magnitude .
I have very frequently noticed it since 1782 , but perceived not the least variation , being constantly of the 4th magnitude , very little brighter than ~ , and decidedly brighter than ~ .
~~ Geminorum .
If either of these stars have changed in brightness , it is probably the ~ .
In 1783 , 1784 , 1785 , the ~ was undoubtedly brighter than ~ .
~ Leonis .
MONTANARI says , this star was hardly visible in 1693 .
I found it constantly in 1783 , 1784 , and 1785 , of the same brightness , being of the 5th magnitude ; less than A , ~ , and , if any difference , rather brighter than h and w Leonis .
TYCHO , FLAMSTEED , MAYER , BRADLEY , &amp;c. mark it of the 4th magnitude .
~ Leonis .
This star is said to have disappeared before the year 1667 .
It is now , and has ever been since 1783 , of the 5 .
6th magnitude , being less than w , and brighter than i , FLAMSTEED 's 46th .
25th Leonis .
In 1783 I first perceived this star was missing ; nor was it visible in 1784 and 1785 , even with the transit-instrument .
BAYER 's i Leonis , or TYCHO 's 16 Leonis .
It was not visible in 1709 , nor could I see it in 1785 .
This is a different star from the i Leonis of the other Catalogues , though TYCHO 's description of its place is the same .
~ Ursae Majoris .
This star is suspected to change in brightness ( see LONG 's Astronomy ) , on account of its being marked by TYCHO , Prince of HESSE , &amp;c. of the 2d magnitude ; while HEVELIUS , BRADLEY , and others , have it of the 3d .
At present , and for these three years past , it appears as a bright 4th magnitude , being rather less than ~ , equal to ~ , and rather brighter than ~ Draconis .
n Virginis .
This star is supposed to be variable , because FLAMSTEED , on the 27th of January , 1680 , says he could not see it .
He observed it May 12 , 1677 , and some years afterwards , since it is in his Catalogue .
I examined it frequently in 1784 and 1785 , without perceiving the least change , being of the 6th magnitude , less than c , and rather brighter than a star three degrees lower in a right line with c and n Virginis .
BAYER 's star of 6th magnitude , 1~ South of g Virginis .
This star is not in any of the nine Catalogues that I have .
MARALDI looked for it in vain ; and in May , 1785 , I could not see the least appearance of it .
It certainly was not of the 8th magnitude .
In the northern thigh of Virgo .
This star , which is marked by RICCIOLUS of the 6th magnitude , could not be seen by MARALDI in 1709 ; nor was it of the 9th magnitude , if at all visible , in 1785 .
91 or 92 Virginis .
In 1785 I found that one of these stars was missing , and which seems to be the 91 ; the remaining one is of the 6 .
7th magnitude .
~ Draconis .
I am of Mr. HERSCHEL 's opinion , that it is highly probable this star is variable .
BRADLEY , FLAMSTEED , &amp;c. mark it of the 2d magnitude ; at present it is only of a bright 4th .
I have frequently examined it since October , 1782 , without perceiving the least change , being constantly rather less than ~ Draconis , equal to ~ Ursae Majoris , and rather brighter than ~ Draconis .
BAYER 's star in the west scales of Libra .
MARALDI says he could not see this star ; nor could I in 1784 and 1785 .
With a night-glass may be seen thereabouts some small stars of about the 8th magnitude , none of which are near as bright as the 2d v Librae .
PTOL .
and UL .
BEIGH 's No 6 of the unformed in Libra .
In examining different Catalogues I do not find this star in any other than the above , though it is marked of the 4th magnitude .
If PTOLEMY had not the x it might be thought to be that .
In 1785 I frequently observed a star of the 7th magnitude very near its place , which appeared rather less than FLAMSTEED 's 41 .
FLAMSTEED has not this little star in his Catalogue ; but he observed it May 9 , 1681 .
x Librae .
This star is thought to be variable .
I am not of that opinion ; though certainly it is rather singular that HEVELIUS , whose attention was directed to this part of the heavens , to find TYCHO 's 11th , did not observe the x ; and the more so , as he has noticed two much lesser stars not far from it .
During these three years I have found the x constantly of the 5th magnitude , being less than ~ or ~ , equal to ~ , and brighter than ~ .
TYCHO 's 11th Librae .
HEVELIUS says he could not find a star of the 4th magnitude in Libra noticed by TYCHO .
This must be TYCHO 's 11th , since he has all the others .
It was not visible in 1783 , 1784 , and 1785 , nor probably ever existed ; for it is , I think , evident , that this 11th is no other than the x , with an error of two degrees in longitude .
33 Serpentis .
In 1784 I perceived that this star was missing ; nor was it visible in 1785 with a night-glass .
A star marked by BAYER near ~ Ursae Minoris .
CASSINI could not see this star .
In 1782 I took , with a night-glass , a plan of all the stars near its place , and near the ~ , none of which were brighter than the 7 .
8th magnitude .
I have since re-examined the plan , but found no alteration .
The ~ or PTOL .
and UL .
BEIGH 's 14th Ophiuchi or FLAMSTEED 's 36th .
I have no doubt but that this is the star which is said to have disappeared before 1695 .
It is also evident , by what HEVELIUS says in his Catalogue on the ~ and B , that the ~ was not seen by him .
In 1784 and 1785 I found it of the 4 .
5th magnitude , much brighter than 39 , also rather brighter than 51 and 58 , and less than 44 .
On the 30th of June , 1783 , I have marked it in my journal equal to 39 , and less than 51 and 58 ; but as the observation was not repeated , I am far from being certain it has undergone any change , particularly as this star has a southern declination of 26~ , and therefore great attention must be given to the state of the atmosphere .
PTOL .
13th and 18th Ophiuchi , 4th magnitude .
If there is no error in the Catalogue , these two stars have disappeared ; but I am confident that PTOLEMY 's 13th is FLAMSTEED 's 40th , and that PTOLEMY 's 18th ought to be marked with a north latitude instead of south , which would make it agree nearly with FLAMSTEED 's 58th .
~ Sagittarii .
Mr. HERSCHEL , with great reason , has placed this star among those which probably have changed their magnitudes .
I had long since remarked the singular disagreement in all the Catalogues , which induced me to observe it frequently , particularly in 1783 , 1784 , and 1785 , when it appeared of the 2 .
3d magnitude , and brighter than ~ Sagittarii .
~ Serpentis .
MONTANARI says he saw this star of the 5th magnitude , and that the next year it grew bigger .
I examined it frequently in 1783 , 1784 , and 1785 , and found it always less than ~ Aquilae , equal to ~ Aquilae , and P Ophiuchi ; 4th magnitude .
TYCHO 's 27th Capricorni .
This star was not visible in HEVELIUS 's time ; nor could I see it 1778 , 1782 , 1784 , with the transit-instrument .
TYCHO'S 22d Andromedae and o Andromedae .
CASSINI remarked , that the star placed by TYCHO at the end of the chain of Andromeda as of the 4th magnitude , was grown so small that it could scarcely be seen .
This is TYCHO'S No 22 , the longitude and latitude of which places it near the two ~ Cygni , and where no star was visible in 1784 and 1785 .
As possibly , by TYCHO'S description , CASSINI took the 22d for the o Andromedae , I have also examined this star , and in 1783 , 1784 , and 1785 , found its relative brightness thus : less than ~ Cephei ; equal to ~ Cassiopeae , though , if any difference , rather brighter ; and brighter than ~ , x , or ~ Andromedae .
TYCHO'S 19th Aquarii .
This is the star that HEVELIUS says was missing , and that FLAMSTEED could not see with his naked eye Nov. 18 , 1679 ; nor could I see the least appearance of it in 1782 .
I am convinced it is the same star as FLAMSTEED'S 56th , marked f by BAYER , from which it is only 1~1/ 2 .
FLAMSTEED'S 53d , marked f in PTOLEMY'S Catalogue , is a different star .
LA CAILLE'S 483 Aquarii .
I first discovered that this star was missing in 1778 .
It was not visible in 1783 , 1784 .
There are a few other stars suspected by the ancient astronomers to have been new or altered a little in brightness , which I have omitted , not seeing any reason to think them so ; and some that are certainly variable , but cannot be observed in these latitudes .
I have also , contrary to my first intention , added several which are not mentioned by them ; such are those that I lately discovered to be missing .
Perhaps many persons would place in the first class several stars which I have put in the second , relying on the positive assertions we have of their having disappeared , diminished , or being new ; for my part , I am confident that most of these supposed changes may be attributed to mistakes ; and in general for those that are said to be lost , an attentive comparison of different Maps and Catalogues will point out the error ; and thus I have ventured to give my opinion of TYCHO 's 20th Ceti , 11th Librae , and 19th Aquarii , &amp;c. Since FLAMSTEED'S Catalogue has been more particularly investigated , the number of these supposed lost stars is considerably increased ; but if the second volume of his Hist. Coelest .
is also examined , many errors will be detected ; among which it will appear very unaccountable , that the 71st , 80th , and 81st of Hercules , which were discovered to be missing by Mr. HERSCHEL , are not in FLAMSTEED'S observations under the name of Hercules , though I looked for them with particular attention , and find the 70th .
The 19th Persei , which Mr. HERSCHEL also could not see , was observed but once by FLAMSTEED , viz. Jan. 16 , 1693 , and in all probability is the ~ with the time of its transit erroneously set down .
The ~ was observed on Jan. 17 , 1693 , and Jan. 18 , 1694 .
Besides these Mr. GOODRICKE has found several other errors still more evident .
I scarcely need add , that these corrections do not in the least intimate any mistake or diminish the merit of those that first point them out , but fall entirely on the ancient catalogues and observations .
Mr. HERSCHEL , in selecting several stars which possibly may be reckoned new ones , very judiciously gives us plausible reasons not to lay great stress on their being so ; and the following remark only confirms what he there suggests ; for that star of the 5th magnitude following ~ Persei , mentioned by him , and which with great reason might be esteemed a new one , is in all probability the same as one observed by FLAMSTEED , Jan. 18 , 1694 , though not inserted in his Catalogue .
With regard to those stars which are said to have diminished or increased , as those in Andromeda , Leo , &amp;c. they are , in my opinion , far from being confirmed as variable .
I know , from repeated experience , that even more than a single observation , if not particularised and compared with neighbouring stars , is very little to be depended on ; different states of the weather , thin streaks of clouds , have several times made me err a whole magnitude in the brightness of a star .
Whether these apparent changes in the stars proceed entirely from themselves ; or whether they are effected by any foreign power that may in part occasion some of their particular appearances and irregularities , we have not sufficient data to determine : but whatever are the causes , a division of the different phenomenon seems to be the most probable means of forwarding any conjecture that hereafter may be formed ; I shall therefore divide the first class into three orders .
The first contains those that are periodical with long intervals ; and such I reckon o Ceti , that in Hydra , that in the Swan 's breast and neck , and also MAYER'S No 420 .
For the second order I shall mention only three , though others might be added ; but the accounts of them are so unsatisfactorily recorded , and their places so little known , that I prefer selecting only that in Cassiopea of 1572 , that in Serpentarius of 1604 , and that near the Swan 's head .
The phenomenon of these certainly bear a great resemblance to the first : still their sudden appearance , and no certainty of a period , or at least infinitely longer , are , I think , sufficient reasons to separate them .
Lastly , Algol , n Antinoi , ~ Lyrae , and ~ Cephei , are so similar to each other , and so different from the above , that there can be but little or no hesitation in distinguishing them ; also the cause of their changes seem in general to be attributed to spots , and a rotation on their axis .
This property of the fixed stars , though often suspected , was far from being evident till within these two years ; and we are not only indebted to Mr. GOODRICKE for the discovery of the first , but also for three of the only four known .
Further may be added , that all those of the first order ( MAYER'S 420 being yet so little known remains doubtful ) attain in different periods different degrees of brightness when at their full ; also the progressive increase of brightness of that in Hydra , that in the Swan 's breast , of o Ceti , ~ Lyrae , n Antinoi , and ~ Cephei , is not similar to their decrease .
This peculiarity with regard to Algol is yet uncertain , owing to the rapidness of its changes , so that there is only one that seems to have these points uniform , viz the variable in the Swan 's neck .
I shall now conclude with the observations from which some results , given in this Paper , have been deduced ; they are here collected together , in order to avoid confusion .
Observations on the variable in Hydra .
n. NORTH ~ of 3d magn .
* Variable *~ of 4th ~ SOUTH ~k of 6.7th x of 8th n of 11th 1783 , Dec 11 .
A. M. much less than ~ , and rather less than k. 24 .
A. M. equal , if not less than , ~ ; of the same colour as ~ .
1784 , Jan. 4 .
A. M. brighter than ~ ; of about 1/ 4 of the difference between ~ and ~ ; of a more copper colour than ~ .
9 .
A. M. if any difference brighter .
10 .
A. M. 25 .
A. M. with the naked eye , it appeared in the brightness nearly between ~ and ~ ; and of a more copper colour than either ~ or ~ .
Feb. 1 .
of the same brightness , but seemed of a more copper 2 .
colour , 23 .
between ~ and k ; air not clear .
29 .
between ~ and k , but nearer the brightness of ~ .
March 10 .
April 11 .
12 .
rather brighter than k. 19 .
May 2 .
9 .
rather less than k , and brighter than x. 1784 , Dec. 1 .
A.M. did not see the variable ; strong moon-light .
9 .
A.M. ditto ditto .
22 .
A.M. ditto ditto .
1785 , Mar. 4 .
or 11 .
ditto ditto .
April 17 .
saw the x , but not the variable .
May 4 .
visible to the maked eye ; less than ~ , and much brighter than k ; of a more copper colour than ~ 7 .
rather less than ~ 11 .
rather less than ~ .
1785 , May 14 .
equal to ~ ; air not very clear , and moon-light .
15 .
equal to ~ ; air clear ; moon-light .
19 .
undoubtedly brighter than ~ ; little hazy ; moon near .
22 .
rather brighter than ~ ; moon-light strong .
27 .
~ 10 .
rather brighter than ~ , though I think decreased .
12 .
equal to ~ : but am not sure if the sky was quite clear .
13 .
rather less bright than ~ ; air clear .
Mr. GOODRICKE also frequently observed the variable , and his observations agree with the above .
Observations on n Antinoi .
h. 1785 , May 20 .
at 121/ 2 equal or less than ~ Antinoi .
21 .
121/ 2 equal to ~ , evidently less than ~ ; moon-light .
22 .
121/ 4 equal if not brighter than ~ Aquilae ; moon .
12~ thought it brighter than ~ ; air clear .
June 10 .
121/ 2 rather brighter than ~ Antinoi .
12 .
113/ 4 rather brighter than ~ , less than ~ .
13 .
121/ 2 a little brighter than ~ , much less than ~ .
July 15 .
121/ 2 less than ~ , brighter than ~ .
17 .
11 less than ~ , brighter than ~ .
18 .
11 between ~ and ~ , I think rather nearer ~ .
101/ 2 19 .
between ~ and ~ , rather nearer ~ ; air clear .
111/ 2 20 .
11 rather brighter than ~ , certainly equal .
Aug. 30 .
91/ 2 rather brighter than ~ , at least equal to it .
31 .
9 much brighter than ~ .
Sept. 6 .
9 less than ~ ; a single view of it , not very satisfactory .
7 .
91/ 2 much brighter than ~ .
91/ 4 26 .
much less than ~ or ~ , brighter than ~ .
101/ 2 8 27 .
much less than ~ , less than ~ , brighter than ~ .
101/ 2 28 .
93/ 4 rather brighter than ~ .
11 increased a little in brightness .
The brightness of the stars to which ~ Antinoi is compared are given in the Philosophical Transactions , vol. LXXV .
part I. Observations on the variable in Cygnus 's Neck .
h~ of 6th mag .
As KIRCH'S plan ~~~~d of 7th ( see Phil. Trans. ~~~~~~~*~e of 7th abridged by Variable ~ga of 8th JONES ) is much b~b of 8th the same as this , ~ ~~ ac of 8.9 I have annexed ~~h of 9th the same letters to the stars .
Dates .
Mag. 1783 Mar. 28 0 if visible , not of the 8th magnitude .
June 97 rather brighter than d or e. 11 7 rather increased .
23 6 .
7 less than ~ .
30 6 .
7 rather increased .
July 15 6 .
7 of the same brightness as on the 30th of June .
27 7a little brighter than d or e. Aug. 77 rather brighter than d ; decreased .
87 equal to d. 16 7 less than d , brighter than e. 25 7 .
8 less than e. Sept. 4 7 .
8 think brighter than a. 12 8 equal to a. 22 8 .
9 much less than a , equal to c , and brighter than h. 24 9 equal to h. Oct. 14 9 .
10 less than h. seen with the greatest difficulty ; less than any stars of the 24 10 .
11 plan ; am doubtful if I saw it by intervals .
27 I looked constantly for the variable between October and 1784 0 April , but could not see it .
April 23 10 .
11 less than any stars of the plan .
24 10 .
11 ditto .
May 9 9 .
10 rather less than h. Dates .
Mag. 1784 May 21 8 .
9 rather brighter than h , but not so bright as b. June 17 8 equal to a , brighter than b. July 21 6 equal to ~ with the naked eye .
22 6 if any difference the ~ was the brightest .
27 6 rather brighter than ~ .
Aug. 1 5 .
6 undoubtedly brighter than ~ .
10 6 think it decreased , but still rather brighter than ~ .
13 6 rather less than ~ .
19 Sept. 2 6 .
7 much decreased , less than ~ , but brighter than d. 12 6 .
7 still brighter than d. 19 7 if any difference brighter than d. 20 7 rather less than d. Oct. 5 7 .
8 less than e , about equal to a. 16 7 .
8 rather brighter than a. Nov. 11 9 less than h , about equal to f. 17 10 rather less than f. 1785 May 90 not visible .
June 21 9 .
10 less than h. July 23 8 rather brighter than a. Aug. 13 a little brighter than d and e , much less than ~ ; am not sure 15 7I could see it with the naked eye .
27 not so bright as ~ , much brighter than d ; I could see it 28 6 .
7 with the naked eye , but the ~ more distinctly .
30 6 not quite so bright as ~ ; naked eye .
Sept. 26 ditto ditto .
7 11 very difficult to see with the naked eye , decreased in 12 6 .
7 brightness ; air clear .
26 though the air was remarkably clear , it was with the utmost 7 27 difficulty I could sometimes see it with the naked eye .

