XXXVII .
Experiments on mixing Gold with Tin .
In a Letter from Mr. Stanesby Alchorne , of his Majesty 's Mint , to Peter Wolf , Esq. F. R. S. Read June 24 , 1784 .
Tower of London , DEARSI R , March 25 , 1784 .
YOU know it is a generally received opinion among metallurgists , that tin has a property of destroying the ductility of gold , on being melted with it , even in very small quantities .
Our late ingenious countryman Dr. LEWIS , in his Philosophical Commerce of Arts , p. 85 .
has well expressed the sense of most writers on this subject , in the following words : ` ` The most minute proportion of tin and lead , ' ' says he , ` ` and even the vapours which rise from them in the fire , though not sufficient to add to the gold any weight sensible in the tenderest balance , make it so brittle that it flies in pieces under the hammer .
' ' Divers circumstances , nevertheless , long since induced me to disbelieve the fact ; but these , having chiefly arisen from small experiments , did not seem to warrant any general conclusion .
A late public occasion , however , which led me to various trials to mixing these metals together , in different proportions , and in sufficiently large quantities , has put the matter out of dispute ; and shown me , that tin , in small quantity at least , may be added to gold , either pure or alloyed , without producing any other effect than what might easily be conceived , ceived , a priori , from the different texture of the two metals .
In confirmation of which , I beg leave to lay some of the experiments before you .
EXPERIMENT I. Sixty Troy grains of pure tin were stirred into twelve ounces of refined gold , in fusion ; and the mixture was then cast into a mould of sand , producing a flat bar , one inch wide , and oneeighth of an inch thick .
The bar appeared sound and good , suffered flatting under the hammer , drawing several times between a large pair of steel rollers , and cutting into circular pieces , of near an inch diameter , which bore stamping in the money-press , by the usual stroke , without showing the least sign of brittleness ; or rather with much the same ductility as pure gold .
EXPERIMENT II .
Ninety grains of like tin were added to twelve ounces of sine gold , stirred , and cast as above .
The bar produced was scarcely distinguishable from the former , and bore all the operations , as before-mentioned , quite as well .
EXPERIMENT III .
One hundred and twenty grains of fine tin were mixed with twelve ounces of fine gold , and being cast like the foregoing , produced a bar rather paler and harder than the preceding , but which suffered the like operations very well ; except that , on drawing between rollers , the outer edges were disposed to crack a little .
EXPERIMENT IV .
One hundred and forty grains , or half an ounce , of the like grained tin , were mixed , as before , with twelve ounces of fine gold ; and the bar resulting from this mixture was completely sound and good ; evidently paler and harder , however , than any of the foregoing , and cracking rather more than the last on passing between the rollers ; but bearing every other operation , even stamping under the press , by the common force , without any apparent injury .
EXPERIMENT V. One ounce of tin was next stirred into twelve ounces of the like refined gold , and then cast as before ; but the bar produced , though seemingly solid and good , was bad coloured , brittle in texture , and , on the first passing between the rollers , split into several pieces , so that no farther trials were made with it .
EXPERIMENT VI .
To inquire how far the fumes of tin , brought into contact with the gold , would do more than mixing the metal in substance , a small crucible , filled with twelve ounces of standard gold , 11/ 12 sine , was placed in a larger crucible , having one ounce of melted tin in it , and kept there in fusion , the whole being covered by another large inverted crucible , for about half an hour .
In this time a full quarter part of the tin was calcined ; but the gold remained unaltered , and equally capable of being manufactured as another portion of the same gold melted in the common manner .
It may well be asked , whether the tin , or part of it , in every trial , might not be destroyed , and thus render the conclusions fallacious ?
But as , in any of these experiments , not more than six or eight grains of the original weight were missing after the casting , and as even fine gold can scarcely be melted without some loss in the operation , so we may reasonably suppose , that our small losses , in the foregoing trials , do not deserve consideration .
The above experiments then seem to show , that tin is not so mischievous to gold as hath been generally represented .
But it would be unfair to infer , that the original author of this doctrine ( from whom so many have implicity transcribed ) had no foundation for the assertion .
Gold and Tin , indeed , are substances pretty well known ; but it is easy to imagine , that coins or trinkets may have been used for one , and impure tin , or pewter , perhaps , for the other ; and it is difficult to guess what might be the result of such uncertain combinations .
To inquire farther , therefore , the experiments were continued as follows .
EXPERIMENT VII .
To determine whether the two metals might be more intimately combined , and the mass rendered brittle , by additional heat ; the mixture of gold and tin , produced in the first of these experiments , was re-melted in a stronger fire than before , and thus kept in fusion full half an hour .
By this operation six grains only were lost in the weight ; and the bar obtained was no less manufacturable than at first .
EXPERIMENTS VIII .
AND IX .
The mixtures of gold and tin , from the second and fourth experiments , were re-melted separately , and one ounce of copper added to each .
Being both well stirred , they were cast as usual ; and the bars , though sensibly harder , bore all the operations of manufacturing as before .
The last bar cracked a little at the edges , on drawing through the rollers , as it had done without the copper , but not materially , and bore cutting rather better than in its former state .
EXPERIMENTS X. AND XI .
A quarter of an ounce of the last mixture ( being tin half an ounce , and copper one ounce , with gold twelve ounces ) , and as much of the bar from experiment the third ( being tin one hundred and twenty grains with gold twelve ounces ) , were each melted by a Jeweller , in the most ordinary manner , with a common sea-coal fire , into small buttons , without any loss of weight .
These buttons were forged by him into small bars , nealing them often by the flame of a lamp , and afterwards drawn each about twenty times through the apertures of a steel plate , into fine wire , with as much ease as coarse gold commonly passes the like operation .
EXPERIMENT XII .
To enquire whether the adding of tin to gold , already alloyed , would cause any difference , sixty grains of tin were stirred into twelve ounces of standard gold , 11/ 12 fine ; and the result passed every operation before described , without showing the least alteration from the tin .
For greater certainty , several other trials were made , of different mixtures of copper , tin , and silver , with gold , even so low as two ounces and a half of copper , with half an ounce of tin , to twelve ounces of gold .
But these are not worth particularising ; for they all bore hammering , and flatting by rollers , to the thinness of stiff paper , and afterwards working into watch-cases , cane-heads , &amp;c. with great ease .
They all , indeed , grew more hard and harsh , in proportion to the quantity of alloy ; but not one of them had the appearance of what all workmen well know by the name of brittle gold .
Whence it should seem , that neither tin in substance , or the fumes of it , tend much to render gold unmanufacturable .
Whenever , therefore , brittleness has followed the adding small quantities of tin to fine gold , it must be supposed to have arisen from some unfriendly mixture in the tin , probably from Arsenic ; for other experiments have shown me , that twelve grains of regulus of arsenic , injected into as many ounces of fine gold , will render it totally unmalleable .
From the foregoing experiments , I presume , we may fairly conclude , that though tin , like other inferior metals , will contaminate gold , in proportion to the quantity mixed with it , yet there does not appear any thing in it specifically inimical to this precious metal .
And this being contrary to the doctrine of most chemical writers , I submit to your better judgement , whether it may not be useful to publish these experiments , by laying them before the Royal Society .
I am , &amp;c. S. ALCHORN E.

