XX .
A Description of the Teeth of the Anarrhichas Lupus Linnaei , and of those of the Chaetodon nigricans of the same Author ; to which is added , an Attempt to prove that the Teeth of cartilaginous Fishes are perpetually renewed .
By Mr. William Andre , Surgeon ; communicated by Sir Joseph Banks , Bart. P. R. S. Read March 18 , 1784 .
THE amazing variety there is in the external from of fishes must be obvious to a common observer ; and whoever examines will be convinced , that the same variety prevails in their internal structure .
No parts , perhaps , afford a more convincing proof of the last assertion than the teeth of fishes .
To adduce a few instances , let us only recollect the tuberculated teeth in the thorn-back ; the triangular serrated teeth in the shark ; the slender flexible teeth in the chaetodontes , or angel-fishes .
There is not only a difference of their form , but also in the substances of which they are composed ; some being of a soft horny nature ; others made up of bone ; others of that substance we call enamel in the teeth of quadrupeds ; and some having the apparent hardness and transparency of crystal .
We may also notice their uncommon situation ; many fishes having teeth not only in their jaws , but on the tongue , the palate , and about the fauces .
To illustrate in some degree this part of natural history , I shall describe the teeth of the Anarrhichas Lupus , or Seawolf , and those of the Chaetodon nigricans , a species of Angel-fish .
The former have been but imperfectly described , and never represented distinct from the fish , without which it is impossible to have any exact idea of their disposition , number , or form , while the true shape and composition of the latter , from their minuteness , have been entirely overlooked .
I shall then attempt to prove , that a continual renovation of the teeth takes place in cartilaginous fishes .
THE SEA-WOLF is a fierce and ravenous fish , as its name imports , found in the northern parts of the globe , where it frequently grows to the length of four feet and upwards .
The jaws of the Wolf-fish are made up of several bones , to each of which a greater or less number of teeth are affixed ; but , before I enter upon the description of them , I shall take notice of the palate ( marked A. tab .
XI .
) , that being a kind of basis or support to the other bones , to which they are all more or less connected .
The palate is a thick and firm bone united above to the bones of the cranium and nose , and ending below in a flat oval surface , on which are encrusted about twelve or thirteen strong , blunt , and rather flat teeth of the molar or grinder kind .
The external edges of the teeth are the most prominent ; by which means a hollow is formed in the middle of the palate .
The upper jaw is composed of three bones , two of which ( BB ) are placed laterally , forming the sides of the upper jaw , and the third ( C ) anteriorly , making the fore-part of the jaw .
The third bone may be divided through its middle into two portions ; but since it has the appearance of one bone only , the connection being very firm , I shall describe it agreeably to that appearance , to prevent needless divisions .
The side bones of the upper jaw have nearly the shape of an italic s. At their posterior ends may be observed a smooth articular surface , for their connection with a similar surface on the posterior extremities of the lower jaw ; and on their anterior ends there are two rows of teeth .
The external row consists of three or four sharp or conical teeth ; and the internal row of four or five blunt and rather flat ones .
These bones are connected to the palate and bones of the nose by loose but strong ligaments .
The third bone of the upper jaw , which may be called the anterior or nasal portion , is of a triangular form , connected above to the bones of the nose , and ending below in a flat surface , thick-set with sharp conical teeth .
The external teeth , about four in number , are large and strong , and bend a little inwards ; but the internal ones are small , and nearly straight , of which we may reckon about ten .
This bone is connected above ( as I have before observed ) to the bones of the nose ; between which a complete joint is formed , of that kind called by anatomists ginglymus , that is , where the projecting parts of one bone are received by corresponding cavities in the other .
Like other articulations , it is furnished with a capsular ligament , and no doubt an apparatus for the secretion of synovia .
Although a joint exists between this bone , and those of the nose , yet no muscles are provided for its motion , which depends entirely upon the resistance made by those hard bodies which the animal takes into its mouth .
The lower jaw ( D ) consists of two bones , united at their fore-parts by a strong ligament , which allows of some motion .
On their anterior extremities are placed six large and as many small sharp and conical teeth ; the large teeth are placed externally , and their points are bent a little inwards ; while the small ones , which stand within them , are nearly straight .
Behind these are two or three rows of grinder teeth .
The external teeth stand nearly upright ; but the internal ones are placed obliquely , inclining towards each other .
The teeth are formed of a hard bony matter , not covered with enamel as in some animals ; nor is there an equal distribution of enamel and bone as in some others .
They are not fixed in sockets , but are fastened to the jaws in the same manner as the epiphyses are united to the bodies of the bones in young animals .
From the foregoing description it will appear , that the anterior sharp teeth of the Sea-wolf are admirably calculated for seizing its prey , while the posterior grinding teeth serve to break down the hard shells of lobsters , crabs , muscles , scollops , &amp;c. which this animal is known to feed upon .
The external teeth on the sides of the upper and lower jaw being higher than those placed within them , a hollow is formed above and below , in which the convex shells of crustaceous animals , &amp;c. are confined during their compression between the jaws , which is effected by the action of strong muscles placed on the sides of the head .
The jaws being made up of a number of pieces , and connected by loose ligaments , a freedom of motion is allowed and the collision or shock arising from the comminution of hard bodies is so much the less by being divided among a number of bones .
MERRET informs us * , the lapis bufonites are the flat grinder teeth of this fish petrified .
But certainly these fossils are not the production of the Sea-wolf alone , since they may originate from all those fishes which have flat teeth in their palate or jaws ; a structure which the French naturalists distinguish by the appellation of palais pave .
* Pinax RErum Naturalium Britannicarum .
OF THE CHAETODON NIGRICANS .
The individual which furnished the following account was brought from the West Indies , and measured about five inches in length * .
Its teeth ( the only parts I mean to describe ) were so small as to require the assistance of a microscope to discover their real shape .
There were fourteen teeth in each jaw , seven of which from the upper one are represented tab .
XII .
They consist of a cylindrical body fixed in the jaw , above which they spread out into a broad and rather flat surface , on the edges of which are twelve or thirteen denticuli , making an uncommon appearance , and totally different from the teeth of any other animal .
Another singularity is their being transparent , unless viewed with a deep magnifier , when a few opaque lines may be perceived , which point out the cellular part of the tooth through which the blood vessels ramify , which are destined for its growth and nourishment .
They are not all of the same length .
Those in the anterior parts of the jaws are the longest , from whence they gradually diminish in length as they approach the angles of the mouth .
From the foregoing description of the teeth of the Chaetodon nigricans , this fish seems to be misplaced in the Systema Naturae of LINNAEUS ; since one generic distinction of the Chaetodontes is to have numerous , slender , and flexible teeth ; whereas the teeth of the Chaetodon nigricans are few in number , placed in one row , and of a crystalline hardness .
* This fish is well represented in DU HAMEL Traite general des Pesches , tom .
III .
second party , section IV .
planche xii .
under the name of Chirurgien ou Port Lancette .
OF THE TEETH OF CARTILAGINOUS FISHES .
When STENO examined the teeth of the shark , he was surprised to find a great number of them placed on the inside of each jaw , lying close to the bone , and many of them buried in a loose spongy flesh ; concluding that these internal teeth could be of little or no use to the animal .
Mr. HERISSANT * afterwards showed the use of these internal or posterior teeth , by proving , that as the anterior teeth of each row are broken off , drop out , or wear away , the posterior ones come forward to supply their places ~ .
But though it be certain that the anterior teeth , when lost , are replaced by the posterior ones , neither of the above naturalists , or any other that I know of , have attempted to ascertain how often this circumstance happens .
Whether the renovation be perpetual during life ; or whether that operation be suspended after a limited number of teeth have been supplied .
From a singular circumstance , which I met with some time ago , I am inclined to think the former is the fact ; or , that in cartilaginous fishes , such as sharks , rays , &amp;c. there is a perpetual renovation of the teeth .
Being engaged in dissecting the jaws of a very large shark , I was surprised to find a portion of that sharp , bearded bone found in the tail of the fire-flaire , or sting-ray ~ , driven quite * BOMARE Dictionaire d'Histoire Naturelle , article Requien .
~ It may not be improper on this occasion to point out a mistake which some naturalists have fallen into , in allowing a set of muscles for raising the numerous teeth placed in the jaws of sharks .
I have frequently dissected the jaws of those animals , and am certain no such muscles exist , nor are they indeed at all necessary .
~ Raia Pastinaca LINNAEI .
The French naturalists , on account of the bone in the tail , call this fish Raie baionnette .
through the lower jaw among the posterior teeth , and fixed almost immovably .
How this happened must be obvious to every one .
( See the figure , tab .
XIII .
) Before I proceed , it will be necessary to observe , first , that the posterior teeth of cartilaginous fishes are always found in a soft , membranous state , and but imperfectly formed ; notwithstanding this , they have the whiteness of teeth from a small quantity of calcareous earth already deposited within their substance .
Their hardness and perfect form is acquired as they advance towards the anterior parts of the jaws .
Secondly , that of the three angles in each tooth of the shark , one is placed towards the right , another towards the left , and the other , which is in the middle , and the most acute angle , is directed inwardly towards the tongue or fauces .
They are placed then in such a manner as that the angles of the teeth on the left-side in one row , approach the angles of the teeth on the right-side in the next row .
Those teeth which stand on a line from without inwards , I call a row ; not those which are placed nearly in a parallel line from one side of the mouth to the other .
The sharp bone of the sting-ray was fixed in the lower jaw between two rows of teeth , and at their posterior part , where the first rudiments of the future teeth are formed , and it will be clear to every one , particularly those who are conversant in such matters , that this could not have happened without producing a great deal of pain , swelling , and disorder in the part where it was fixed .
It is unnecessary to enumerate the different kinds of mischief this might occasion .
Let it suffice to observe , that on account of the space taken up by this extraneous body , the teeth on each side of it , for want of room , could never after be perfectly formed .
The teeth on the left-side C BB A CHAETODON nigricans LINN .
BB AA wanting their angles to the right , and the teeth on the rightside being destitute of their angles to the left .
As it is certain , that the anterior teeth were formerly posterior ones , and as the teeth in each row were all deficient in one angle , it follows , that they must have been formed posterior to the insertion of this extraneous body .
Again , if we allow that before the accident the animal was in possession of perfect teeth , it follows also , that they were consumed and replaced by imperfect ones .
There were six teeth in each row , and fifty-two rows , making together about 312 teeth .
Now allowing the consumption to have been equal in all parts of the jaws , it follows , that the animal had already consumed 312 teeth , and was in possession of a like number for future consumption .
The teeth of sharks , rays , &amp;c. may be divided into active and passive .
The active teeth are the anterior ones of each row , standing with their points upwards .
The passive teeth are the remaining ones , lying one upon another , like the tiles upon a house ( imbricated ) , with their points downwards .
It appears from the foregoing account , that the anterior or active teeth had been replaced six times ; and that they might have been renewed six times more , making in all twelve times .
From which , I think , we may reasonably conclude , that this does not happen any precise number of times ; but that the renovation is perpetual during the life of the animal .
The longevity of fishes is a fact pretty well established .
In addition to this part of natural knowledge , I have endeavoured to prove , that a part of the inhabitants of the great deep retain , in the article of teeth , a perpetual juvenility , being apparently utter strangers to edentulous old age .
EXPLANATION OF THE PLATES .
Tab. XI .
The jaws of the Wolf-fish .
A. The palate .
BB .
The side bones of the upper jaw .
C. The anterior or nasal portion of the same .
D. The lower jaw .
Tab. XII .
The teeth of the Chaetodon nigricans magnified .
Tab. XIII .
Part of the lower jaw of a large shark .
AA .
Two rows of perfect teeth .
BB .
Two rows of imperfect ones .
C. The bone of the sting-ray .

