XVIII .
An Account of some late fiery Meteors ; with Observations .
In a Letter from Charles Blagden , M. D. Physician to the Army , Sec. R. S. to Sir Joseph Banks , Bart. P. R. S. Read February 19 , 1784 .
TO SIR JOSEPH BANKS , BART .
P. R. S. DEARSI R , FROM the papers you were so good as to put into my hands , together with such other information as I could procure , the following account of the two most remarkable of the late meteors is collected .
I am sensible , that it is in many respects very imperfect ; yet still it gives a more satisfactory idea of the phenomenon than can well be acquired from the relation of any single observer , and therefore may not be disagreeable to the learned Society over which you so worthily preside , if no more perfect account shall previously have been laid before them .
These meteors were of the kind known to the ancients by the names of ~ , ~ , Bolides , Faces , Globi , &amp;c. from particular differences in their shape and appearance , and sometimes , I believe , under the general term of Comets * ; in the Philosophical * ARISTOTLE 's remark , that all the comets seen among them disappeared without setting , ~~~~~ ( ~ ) ~~~~~~~~ ~ ( Meteor .
lib. I. c. 6 .
) , seems scarcely applicable but to transitory meteors ; and many other expressions to the same purpose occur in that author , Philosophical Transactions they are called indiscriminately fireballs or fiery meteors ; and names of a similar import have been applied to them in the different languages of Europe .
The most material circumstances observed of such meteors may be brought under the following heads .
1 .
Their general appearance .
2 .
Their path .
3 .
Their shape or figure .
4 .
Their light and colours .
5 .
Their height .
6 .
Their noise .
7 .
Their size .
8 .
Their duration .
9 .
Their velocity .
I shall begin with the first of these meteors , that which was seen on the 18th of August .
~ 1 .
Its general appearance in these parts of Great Britain was that of a luminous ball , which rose in the N.N.W. nearly round , became elliptical and gradually assumed a tail as it ascended , and in a certain part of its course seemed to undergo a remarkable change compared to bursting ; after which it proceeded no longer as an entire mass , but was apparently divided into a great number or a cluster of balls , some larger than the others , and all carrying a tail or leaving a train behind ; under this form it continued its course with a nearly equable motion , dropping or casting off sparks , and yielding a prodigious light , which illuminated all objects to a surprising degree ; till having passed the cast , and verging considerably to the southward , it gradually descended , and at length was lost out of sight .
The PLINY , &amp;c. SENECA himself , though he conceived distinctly enough the difference between comets and fiery meteors , yet evidently did not know where to draw the line ( compare lib. I. and VII .
Quaest .
Natur .
) .
Even in modern times , these meteors have struck spectators at first as comets ( Fritzes Medizinische Annalen , vol. I. p. 77 .
) ; nay , expert astronomers , as appears by a letter from NATHANIEL PIGOTT , Esq. F. R. S. lately read before the Royal Society .
See also Mem. de l'Ac .
des Science .
1771 , p. 688 .
I have insisted the more on a subject apparently of so little consequence , in order to account for the strange opinions of the ancients respecting comets , which , I think , proceeded chiefly from confounding them with these fiery meteors .
time of its appearance was 9 h. 16~ P.M. mean time of the meridian of London , and it continued visible about half a minute .
~ 2 .
How far north the meteor may have begun I have no materials to determine with precision ; but , as it was seen in Shetland , and at sea between the Lewes and Fort William , and appeared to persons at Aberdeen and Blair in Athol ascending from the northward , and to an observer in Edinburgh as rising like the planet Mars , there can be little doubt but its course commenced beyond the farthest extremity of this island , somewhere over the northern ocean .
General MURRAY , F. R. S. being then at Athol House , saw it pass over his head as nearly vertical as he could judge , tracing it from about 45~ of elevation north-north-westward to 30~ or 20~ south-south-eastward , where a range of buildings intercepted it from his view .
From near the zenith of Athol House , it passed on a little westward of Perth , and probably a little eastward of Edinburgh ; and continuing its progress over the south of Scotland , and the western parts of Northumberland and the Bishopric of Durham , proceeded almost through the middle of Yorkshire , leaving the capital of that county somewhat to the eastward .
Hitherto its path was as nearly S.S.E. as can be ascertained ; but somewhere near the borders of Yorkshire , or in Lincolnshire , it appears to have gradually deviated to the eastward , and in the course of that deviation to have suffered the remarkable change already noticed under the denomination of bursting .
After this division , the compact cluster of smaller meteors seems to have moved for some time almost S.E. thus traversing Cambridgeshire and perhaps the western confines of Suffolk ; but gradually recovering its original direction , it proceeded over Essex and the strait of Dover , entering the continent probably not far from Dunkirk , where , as well as at Calais and Ostend , it was thought to be vertical .
Afterwards it was seen at Brussels , Paris , and Nuits in Burgundy * , still holding on its course to the southward ; nay , I have met with an intimation , though of doubtful authority ~ , that it was perceived at Rome .
Our information of its progress over the continent is , indeed , very defective and obscure ; nevertheless , I think , we have sufficient proof that it traversed in all 13 or 14 degrees of latitude , describing a track of 1000 miles at least over the surface of the earth ; a length of course far exceeding the utmost that has been hitherto ascertained of any similar phenomenon .
To adduce the different accounts from which this path is determined , would not only be insufferably tedious , but contrary to the intention of this letter , which is to give a summary view of the whole .
They are contained partly in letters , and partly in the different news-papers of England and Scotland , most of which have been perused for this purpose .
The information derived from the news-papers , however incorrect in the detail , is brought to some degree of certainty by the check of comparing them with one another ; and their frequent publication in most places of consequence in this island , procures us advantages on the occasion of such extraordinary phenomenon , not enjoyed in former ages , nor even now , to the like extent , in any other part of the world .
It seems scarcely more interesting to trace the path of these bodies with minute precision , than it would be to mark the progress of a cloud 's shadow upon the ground ; but it is of consequence to their theory to ascertain well the direction of their course ; and their deviations from a straight line , as implying some particular cause , should be carefully noticed .
I * Journ. de Paris , Aout 24 , 1783 .
~ PARKER'S General Advertiser , October 7 , 1783 .
have ventured to ascribe such a deviation to this meteor , from the concurrent testimony of many observers , who speak in the plainest terms of a manifest change in its course about the time it was seen to burst ; and their evidence is confirmed by drawing a line S.S.E. from that part of Scotland to which the meteor was vertical , for such a line is found to correspond with its path as far as Yorkshire , but in the southern parts of the kingdom falls a great deal too much to the westward .
That it afterwards resumed its former course is rendered probable from the testimony of the observers in Kent , who almost uniformly mention its disappearance in the S.S.E. as well as from the remarks made by several persons near the metropolis , that when it attained its greatest elevation , it bore but one or two points to the northward of east .
~ 3 .
This meteor was described by most spectators under three different forms , and is thus represented by Mr. SANDBY in his beautiful Drawing * ; but the two first of those do not imply any real variation in its shape , depending only on a difference in the point of view .
Accordingly , in the first part of its course over Scotland , it was seen to have a tail , and is thus described by General MURRAY when it passed Athol House .
Two causes concur in this deception ; first , the fore-shortening , and even occultation , of the tail , when the object is seen nearly in front ; and , secondly , that the light of most part of the tail is of so inferior a kind , as to be difficultly perceived at a great distance , especially when the eye is dazzled by the overpowering brilliancy of the body .
The length and shape of the tail , however , were perpetually varying ; nor did the body continue always of the same magnitude and figure , but was sometimes round , at other times elliptical , with a blunt or * Since engraved .
See also the figures tab .
IV .
of this volume .
pointed protuberance behind .
From such changes of figure in this and other meteors it is , that they have been compared to columns or pyramids of fire , comets , barrels , bottles , flasks , paper-kites , trumpets , tadpoles , glass-drops , quoits , torches , javelins , goats , and many similar objects ; whence the multifarious appellations given to them by the ancients were borrowed .
Respecting the tails of meteors , it is here necessary to distinguish between two different parts of which they consist .
The brightest portion seems to be of the same nature as the body , and indeed an elongation of the matter composing it ; but the other , and that commonly the largest portion , might more properly be called the train , appearing to be a matter left behind after the meteor has passed ; it is far less luminous than the former part , and often only of a dull or dusky red colour .
A similar train or streak is not unfrequently left by one of the common falling stars , especially of the brighter sort ; and vestiges of it sometimes remain for several minutes .
It often happens , that even the large fire-balls have no other tail but this train , and ours of the 18th of August appeared at times to be in that state ; its tail was likewise thought by some spectators to be spiral .
Under this changeable form , but still as a single body , it proceeded regularly till a certain period , when expanding with a great increase of light , it separated into a cluster of smaller bodies or ovals , each extended into a tail and producing a train .
At the same time a great number of sparks appeared to issue from it in various directions , but mostly downward , some of which were so bright as also to leave a small train .
Most fireballs have suffered a bursting or explosion of this kind ; but in general they have been thought to disappear immediately afterwards .
This , however , continued its course , becoming more compact , or perhaps re-uniting , and seems to have undergone other similar explosions before it left our island , and again upon the continent * .
The different accounts tend to show , that its first separation or bursting happened somewhere over Lincolnshire , perhaps near the commencement of the sens .
Many observers did not get sight of it till after this period , and therefore never describe it as a single ball .
There appears to be some deception , in consequence of which spectators are led to believe , that a meteor is extinguished by these explosions ; for the same opinion was formed of this in several parts of this course , though we have such decisive evidence of its continued progress ; whether it be that the meteors really become more dull for a time immediately after their explosion , or merely appear so on account of the greater preceding light , since they are always described as being most luminous the instant they burst .
It is observable , that the great change in this meteor corresponds with the period in which it suffered a deviation from its course , as if there was some connexion between those two circumstances ; and there are traces of something of the same kind having happened to other meteors .
If the explosion be any sort of effort , we cannot wonder that the body should be moved by it from a straight line ; but on the other hand it seems equally probable , that if the meteor be forced , by any cause , to change its direction , the consequence should be , a division or separation of its parts .
~ 4 .
Nothing relative to these meteors strikes the beholders with so much astonishment as the excessive light they afford , * For another instance of repeated explosions consult Mem. de l'Ac .
des science .
1756 , p. 23 .
sufficient to render very minute objects visible upon the ground in the darkest night , and larger ones to the distance of many miles from the eye .
The illumination is often so great as totally to obliterate the stars , to make the moon look dull , and even to affect the spectators like the sun itself ; nay , there are many instances in which such meteors have made a splendid appearance in full sun-shine .
The colour of their light is various and changeable , but generally of a bluish cast , which makes it appear remarkably white .
A curious effect of this was observed at Brussels the 18th of August , that whilst the meteor was passing , ` ` the moon appeared quite red , but soon recovered its natural light * .
' ' The brightness alone of the meteor is not sufficient to explain this , for the moon does not appear red when seen by day ; but it must have depended on the the contrast of colour , and shows how large a proportion of blue rays enters into the composition of that light , which could make even the silver moon appear to have excess of red .
Prismatic colours were also observed in the body , tail , and sparks of this meteor .
variously by different persons ; some compared them to the hues of gems .
The moment of its greatest brightness seems to have been when it burst the first time ; but it continued long to be more luminous after that period , than it was before .
The body of the fire-ball , even before it burst , did not appear of an uniform substance or brightness , but consisted of lucid and dull parts , which were perpetually changing their respective positions ; so that the whole effect was to some eyes like an internal agitation or boiling of the matter , and to others like moving chasms or apertures .
Similar expressions * From a letter of the Abbe MANN'S , Director of the Academy at Brussels , to Sir JOSEPH BANKS , Bart. P. R. S. have been used in the description of former meteors .
The luminous substance was compared to burning brimstone or spirits , Chinese fire , the stars of a rocket , a pellucid ball or bubble of fire , liquid pearl~ lightning and electrical fire ; few persons fancied it to be solid , especially when it came near the zenith .
Different spectators observed the light of the meteor to suffer at times a sudden diminution and revival , which produced an appearance as of successive inflammation ; but might , in some cases at least , be owing to the interposition of small clouds in its path .
~ 5 .
When , in consequence of a more accurate attention to natural philosophy , such observations were first made upon fire-balls as determined their height , the computers were with reason surprised to find them moving in a region so far above that of the clouds and other familiar meteors of our atmosphere ; especially as to every uninformed spectator they appear extremely near , or as if bursting over his head , a natural effect of their great light when seen without intervening objects .
Their real height is to be collected from observations made at distant stations , which , for the greatest accuracy , ought to be so situated , that the line joining them may cut the path of the meteor at right-angles , and that , at its greatest elevation , it may appear from both of them about 45~ above the horizon , on opposite sides of the zenith .
Also two stations on the same side of its path , if the least angle of elevation be not very small , and the difference between that and the greatest angle be considerable , are by no means to be rejected .
But little reliance can be placed upon observations of a meteor 's altitude at any supposed period of its course , such as the moment of its bursting ; because those changes are seldom so inVOL .
LXXIV .
Ee stantaneous , stantaneous , or seen so much alike by different spectators , as to be marked with sufficient certainty .
Even in proper stations it rarely happens , that the angle of elevation can be observed with that degree of accuracy , which is necessary for any certain determination of the height .
An estimate by the eye is doubtful , not only on account of the flattened curve the sky seems to describe , for which the most experienced observers scarcely ever make a just allowance , but likewise of the emotion produced by such an unexpected , magnificent , and perhaps alarming spectacle , which renders it almost impossible to be quite collected .
Therefore , unless an observation be checked by means of a house , tree , or some fixed body , along which the meteor was found to range , it must be received as uncertain .
By night the stars afford excellent marks , especially if the time be known with exactness ; the brighter meteors , indeed , render these faint lights invisible for the moment , but here we derive an eminent advantage from the train , which remains after the meteor is gone , and delineates perfectly its track through the heavens .
If no such marks have been taken , the expedient of endeavouring to recollect the part of the sky where it passed , and ascertaining that height with a quadrant , may often be useful ; but there are many men of such a turn of mind , that the original impression made upon them will be totally perverted by their own subsequent reflexions and the remarks of others ; in which case such an application of instruments is likely to give a result farther from the truth , than their first immediate judgement , however vague and hazarded .
I am sorry to add , that most of the observations in my possession of the meteor which appeared the 18th of August , give its altitude by estimation only ; yet I hope their correspondence with one another will gain them a degree of credit , to which , if single , they would not be entitled .
1 .
In a letter from Perth in Scotland it is said , that ` ` a gentleman , who has a very good eye , observed the meteor pass about 6~ to the westward of the zenith ; ' ' and a Professor in one of the Universities , being at Ardoch on the banks of the Tweed , about two miles below Dunbarton , judged it to have ` ` at least 45~ of elevation above the horizon .
' ' These altitudes would make its real height 57 statute miles .
2 .
At St. Andrew 's in Scotland , ` ` it was not quite vertical , but according to some was 20~ or 25~ from the zenith , according to others not so much .
' ' Taking the greatest of these distances as nearest the truth , since we are usually led to estimate altitudes greater than they really are , this observation , calculated with that of Ardoch , gives 60 miles for the height .
For the communication of these observations , collected by his friends , I am indebted to General MELVILL F. R. S. At Edinburgh the meteor passed very near the zenith , in which case a deviation of a few degrees is scarcely perceptible to a common eye .
The rev .
Mr. WATSON of Whitby , in a letter to Lord MULGRAVE V. P. R. S. is very confident , that the greatest altitude of the meteor , which passed to the westward of his zenith , was 60~ .
Mr. EDGEWORTH F. R. S. in his letter to you , Sir , states its elevation at Edgeworth's-Town near Mullingar , in Ireland , as 10~ or 12~ above the eastern horizon .
These observations , calculated strictly from the latitudes and longitudes with the allowance for the curvature of the earth , as indeed were all the rest where the difference would be sensible , give 57 miles for the height of the meteor .
4 .
In the Morning Chronicle of Sept. 19 .
is inserted a letter from Newton Ardes , 7 miles east of Belfast , in Ireland , corresponding so well with Mr. EDGEWORTH'S in the description of the meteor , as to appear very good authority .
The altitude is there given as 16~ , whence a height of 58 miles with the observation at Whitby .
5 .
Mr. MORE , Secretary to the Society for the encouragement of Arts , Manufactures , and Commerce , saw the meteor as he was riding about three miles S. W. of Broseley in Shropshire , and judged it to be elevated 35~ .
By a perpendicular drawn from this spot to its supposed path in Lincolnshire , its height came out 59 miles .
6 .
The altitude of 25~ determined at Windsor I take to be one of those on which most reliance can be placed , because the gentlemen present , two of them Fellows of the Royal Society , were remarkably well qualified for such an estimation .
The letter you received , Sir , from Professor ALLAMAND of Leyden , mentions that the meteor was seen there about 30~ above the horizon , and the terms in which it is described in the Dutch news-papers * agree with this account .
Its height hence calculated appears to be 58 miles .
7 .
Mr. THOMAS SQUIRE , of Folkstone , observed the meteor over his house , as he was in the posture of leaning back against a hedge ; he afterwards tried ` ` its ranging with the roof by a quadrant , and found it 68~1/ 2 above the horizon .
' ' Reducing this observation to the perpendicular dropped from Windsor on the path of the meteor , its height comes out 54 or 55 miles .
Mr. SQUIRE'S altitude , determined by a fixed object , is confirmed by the estimate of several persons at Ramsgate .
* Amsterdamische Courant , Aug. 28 , 1783 .
8 .
The meteor was seen by Mr. STEEVENS F. R. S. at Hampstead near London , moving along over the top of a row of trees .
Mr. CAVENDISH F. R. S. having taken the altitude of these trees with a quadrant , found that of the highest , as seen from the part of the garden-walk opposite to it , to be 33~ ; which corresponds very well with the other observations , and consequently gives the same height for the meteor .
Mr. STEEVENS kept his eye upon it constantly , whilst he passed briskly along the walk .
This agreement of the different altitudes is nearer than could be expected ; yet I know of no contradictory observations of any authority , except some made near Plymouth and in Cornwall , where the meteor being pretty near the horizon , its altitude , as will commonly happen in such cases , is given too great .
The effect of this , however , would be to show , that the meteor was higher ; and therefore , I think , we may safely conclude , that it must have been more than 50 miles above the surface of the earth , in a region where the air is at least 30000 times rarer than here below .
Contrary to what has been asserted of most other fire-balls , this of the 18th of August appears by the preceding observations to have kept on in a parallel course , without any descent or approach toward the earth .
It may be much questioned , whether such a descent has been proved in any former instance .
The meteor described by Sir JOHN PRINGLE has been cited as the most certain example ; but any person who carefully examines the observations themselves , as stated in the 51st volume of the Philosophical Transactions , will find them totally inadequate for such a conclusion ; its height seems to me determined only in one part of its course , between Island-Bridge and Ancram , and was there from 48 to 50 miles * .
M. LE ROY supposes the fire-ball seen July 17 , 1771 , to have been 54 miles high when it began , and 27 at its explosion ~ ; but does not give the facts on which his calculation is founded .
Every philosopher must be struck with the agreement of these meteors in their distance from the earth , just beyond the limits of our crepuscular atmosphere .
~ 6 .
That a report was heard some time after the meteor of the 18th of August had disappeared , is a fact which rests upon the testimony of too many witnesses to be controverted , and is , besides , conformable to what has been observed in most other instances .
In general it was compared to the falling of some heavy body in a room above stairs , or to the discharge of one or more large cannon at a distance .
That rattling noise , like a volley of small arms , which has been remarked after other meteors , does not seem to have been heard on this occasion .
From a comparison of the different accounts , it appears as if the report was loudest in Lincolnshire and the adjacent countries , and again in the eastern parts of Kent ; in the intermediate places it was so indistinct as generally not to have been noticed , and all observers of credit in Scotland deny that they heard any thing of the sort .
If , therefore , this report be connected with the bursting of the meteor , I should be inclined to suppose , that found was produced two separate times , namely at the first explosion over Lincolnshire , and again when it seemed to burst soon after entering the continent .
Ingenious men have availed themselves of this sound , to calculate the distance and height of meteors ; and the exactness attained by this method , in the computation of the late fire-ball from the report heard at * Phil. Trans. vol. LI .
p. 241 .
and 274 .
~ Mem. de l ' Acad. des Science .
1771 , p. 676 .
Windsor * , is very remarkable ; but in general the accounts disagreed so much , that it would have been impossible to conclude any thing from them .
Perhaps too the method itself is less certain than has been thought ; for as the propagation of sound , and with intensity too , in air rarefied 30000 times , presents great difficulties in theory , though it may be in some measure explicable from the vast bulk of the meteor , and the large quantity of this rare air it may therefore displace by a sudden expansion ; I think it not improbable , that some hitherto unperceived circumstance comes into play , by which the whole effect may be modified : for instance , if matter belonging to the meteor itself be what conveys the sound to our lower atmosphere , it may either admit sound to be propagated through it at a different rate than through common air , or it may move much faster than sound travels , as the entire meteor certainly does , and carry on the sonorific vibrations with it .
Moreover , we cannot be sure what is the velocity of sound in air so much rarer than where our experiments have been made .
For these reasons , while we distrust calculations of meteors founded on the progress of sound , we should be particularly careful to note down the intervals , and all the circumstances , as they may lead to very curious discoveries .
The effect of the noise is , frequently , to produce such a shaking of the doors , windows , and the whole house , as is mistaken for an earthquake .
Besides the report as of explosions which was heard after the meteor , another sort of sound was said to attend it , more doubtful in its nature , and less established by evidence ; I mean , a kind of hissing , whizzing , or crackling , as it passed along .
That sound should be conveyed to us in an instant from a body above 50 miles distant , appears so irreconcilable to all we know of philosophy , that perhaps we should be justified in * See p. 111 .
of this volume .
imputing the whole to an affrighted imagination , or an illusion produced by the fancied analogy of fireworks .
The testimony in support of it is , however , so considerable , on the occasion of this as well as former meteors , that I cannot venture to reject it , however improbable it may be thought , but would leave it as a point to be cleared up by future observers .
~ 7 .
To determine the bulk of the fire-ball , we must not only have calculated its distance , but also know the angle under which it appeared .
For this purpose the moon is the usual term of comparison ; but as it was thought , at very different distances , to present a disk equal to that luminary 's , and the same expressions have been applied to most preceding fire-balls , I conceive this estimation rather to be a general effect of the strong impression produced by such splendid objects on the mind , than to convey any determinate idea of their size .
However , if we suppose its transverse diameter to have subtended an angle of 30~ when it passed over the zenith , which probably is not very wide of the truth , and that it was 50 miles high , it must have been almost half a mile across .
The tail sometimes appeared 10 or 12 times longer than the body ; but most of this was train , and the real elongation behind seems seldom to have exceeded twice or thrice its transverse diameter , consequently was between one and two miles long .
Now if the cubical contents be considered , for it appeared equally round and full in all directions , such an enormous mass , moving with extreme velocity , affords just matter of astonishment .
~ 8 .
The duration of the meteor is very differently stated , partly because some observers had it in view a much longer time than others , and partly because they formed different judgments of the time .
Those who saw least of it seem to have perceived its illumination about ten seconds , and those who saw most of it about a minute : hence the various accounts may in some measure be reconciled .
Mr. HERSCHEL F. R. S. at Windsor , must have kept it in sight long after other observers had thought it extinct : for though , probably , he did not see the beginning , as it never appeared to him like a single ball , he watched it as much as ` ` forty or forty-five seconds , the last twenty or twenty-five of which it remained almost in one situation , within a few degrees of the horizon .
' ' This confirms the foreign accounts of its long progress to the southward .
As scarcely any one had sufficient presence of mind to minute the time by his watch , the periods given for its duration are mostly by guess .
To correct this rude conjecture , it has been proposed , that the observer should endeavour to pass over the time in his own mind as well as he can by recollection , whilst another person silently marks the seconds with a watch .
This may do something , but still leaves the matter very uncertain , as the nature of the emotion felt by the spectator while it was passing will cause the impression of a longer or shorter time to be left upon his mind ; and the formal process of recollection is so tedious , that I believe the duration will in this way generally be made too short .
Mr. HERSCHEL , at my request , was so good as to act over his observation , with the positions and gestures he was obliged to employ ; and this seems likely to come nearer the truth than a simple effort of the mind at recollection .
But the surest method would be , to repeat any uniform action in which the spectator might have been engaged at the time ; as , for instance , to walk over the same space of ground~ that he passed while the meteor was in sight .
~ 9 .
From the apparent motion of the meteor , compared with its height , some computation may be formed of its astonishing velocity .
As at the height of 50 miles above the surface of the earth , it might be visible from the same station for a tract of more than 1200 miles , and the longest continuance of its illumination scarcely exceeded a minute , we have hence some presumption that it moved not less than 20 miles in a second .
The rev .
Mr. WATSON , in his letter to Lord MULGRAVE , says , that the arc described by it whilst in his view could not be less than 70~ or 80~ , and yet the time could not exceed 4~ or 5~ at most .
This , with an altitude of 60~ , and height of 50 miles , gives for its velocity about 21 miles in a second .
The observer at Newton Ardes estimated its motion to be 10~ in a second , at the altitude of 16~ ; this would make its velocity 30 miles in a second .
Mr. HERSCHEL found it describe an arch of 167~ during the 40 or 45 seconds he observed it , which gives a velocity of more than 20 miles in a second .
Finally , Mr. AUBERT F. R. S. thought it described an arch of 136~ of azimuth in 10 or 12 seconds , which would make its velocity above 40 miles in a second .
I am sensible of the objections that may be made to all these computations ; undoubtedly they are too vague ; and yet , all taken together , perhaps they may have some weight , especially as they correspond so well with the different phenomenon of the meteor 's duration , and other fireballs have been computed to move as fast * .
Stating the velocity at the lowest computation of 20 miles a second , it exceeds that of sound above 90 times , and begins to approach toward that of the earth in her annual orbit .
At such a rate , it must have passed over the whole island of Great Britain in less than half a minute , and might have reached Rome within a minute * See Mem. de l'Acad .
des Scienc .
1771 , p. 678 .
Phil. Trans. No 341 .
and 360 .
and vol. LI .
p. 263 , &amp;c. afterwards , or in seven minutes have traversed the whole diameter of the earth !
From this calculation it will be evident , that there is little chance of determining the velocity of meteors from the times of their passing the zenith of different places ; and that therefore we must principally depend on observing carefully , with a watch that shows seconds , their apparent velocity through the heavens .
THE fire-ball which appeared on the 4th of October , at 43 past six in the evening , was much smaller than that already described , and of much shorter duration .
It was first perceived to the northward as a stream of fire , like the common shooting stars , but large ; and having proceeded some way under this form , it suddenly burst out into that intensely bright bluish light which is peculiar to such meteors .
At this period I saw it , and can compare the colour to nothing I am acquainted with so well , as to the blue lights of India , and some of the largest electrical sparks .
The illumination was very great ; and on that part of its course where it had been so bright , a dusky red streak or train was left , which remained visible perhaps a minute even with a candle in the room , and was thought by some gradually to change its form .
Except this train , I think the meteor had no tail , but was nearly a round body , or perhaps a little elliptical .
After moving not less than 10~ in this bright state , it became suddenly extinct , without any appearance of bursting or explosion .
This meteor was seen for so short a way , that it is scarcely possible to determine the direction of its course with accuracy ; but as in proceeding to the eastward it very perceptibly inclined towards the horizon , it certainly moved somewhere from the north-westward to the south-eastward .
Its duration was so short , that many persons thought it passed in an opposite direction ; for my own part , I found myself absolutely unable to determine whether the motion was from or toward the S.E. Some spectators were of opinion , that it changed its course the moment it became bright , proceeding no longer in the same straight line ; but my information is not sufficient to determine this question .
My situation , Sir , was particularly fortunate for ascertaining the height of this meteor , as I saw it from your Library , ranging immediately over the opposite roof of your house .
Hence I find by a quadrant that its altitude , even when it became extinct , could not be less than 32~ .
The upper northernmost end of the train it left bore , as I judge by the compass , about 28~ northward of true E. and the lower end about 14~ .
I have only one observation to compare with this , which was made by Mr. BOYS of Sandwich .
He concludes , from the train I imagine , that ` ` it disappeared just under , and a very little to the westward ' ' ( rather northward ) ` ` of , the star ~ in the foot of Cepheus .
' ' At that time ~ Cephei was about 57~ high , and bore above 21~ to the eastward of N. whence the height of the meteor above the surface of the earth , after all proper allowances are made * , must have been between 40 and 50 miles .
As there was no appearance of bursting at the extinction of this fire-ball , so no report was heard after it ; nor did any sound attend it .
Some observers thought this meteor also near as big as the moon , but to me it did not appear above one quarter of her diameter , which would make its breadth somewhat above a furlong .
* It appears from observations taken by Gen. ROY , F. R. S. that the bearing of Sandwich from London is not so much to the southward of east , as it is laid down in our maps .
If the whole of the meteor 's track be included , it seems to have lasted as much as three seconds , but in the bright state its duration was less than two , I think not much above one .
Supposing it described an arc of 14~ in 11/ 2 second , or , according to Mr. AUBERT'S observation , of 25~ in 3~ , its real velocity was about 12 miles a second .
Such meteors as these , which pass like a flash of lightning , and describe so short a course , are very unfavourable for calculating the velocity , but afford great advantages for determining the height , as they must be seen nearly at the same moment and in the same place by the different observers .
Other instances are found of fire-balls beginning with a dull red light like a falling star , particularly the great one of March 19 , 1719 , treated of so fully by Dr. HALLEY * and Mr. WHISTON ~ .
It is remarkable , that a similar meteor had appeared the same day , that is , Saturday the 4th of October , about three in the morning , though , on account of the early hour , it was seen by fewer spectators .
They represent it as rising from the northward to a small altitude , and then becoming stationary with a vibratory motion , and an illumination like day-light ; it vanished in a few moments , leaving a train behind .
This sort of tremulous appearance has been noticed in other meteors , as well as their continuing stationary for some time , either before they began to shoot forward , or after their course was ended .
* Phil. Trans. vol. XXX .
No 350 .
p. 978 .
~ Account of a surprising meteor seen March 19 , 1719 .
I FIND it , Sir , impossible to quit this subject , without some reflexions about the cause , that can be capable of producing such appearances at an elevation above the earth , where , if the atmosphere cannot absolutely be said to have ceased , it is certainly to be considered as next to nothing .
The first idea which suggested itself , that they were burning bodies projected with such a velocity , was quickly abandoned , from the want of any known power to raise them up to that great height , or , if there , to give them the required impetus ; and the ingenuity of Dr. HALLEY soon furnished him with another hypothesis , in which he thought both these difficulties obviated .
He supposes there is no projection of a single body in the case ; but that a train of combustible vapours , accumulated in those lofty regions , is suddenly set on fire , whence all the phenomenon are produced by the successive inflammation * .
But Dr. HALLEY gives no just explanation of the nature of these vapours , nor of the manner in which they can be raised up through air so extremely rare ; nor , supposing them so raised , does he account for their regular arrangement in a straight and equable line of such prodigious extent , or for their continuing to burn in such highly rarefied air .
Indeed , it is very difficult to conceive , how vapours could be prevented , in those regions where there is in a manner no pressure , from spreading out on all sides in consequence of their natural elasticity , and instantly losing that degree of density which seems necessary for inflammation .
Besides , it is to be expected , that such trains would sometimes take fire in the middle , and so present the phenomenon of two meteors at the same time , receding from one another in a direct line .
These difficulties have induced other philosophers to relinquish Dr. HALLEY'S hypothesis , and propose , instead of it , * Phil. Trans. vol. XXX .
No 360 .
one of a very opposite nature , that meteors are permanent solid bodies , not raised up from the earth , but revolving round it in very eccentric orbits ; or , in other words , that they are terrestrial comets * .
The objections to this opinion , however , seem to me equally great .
Most observers describe the meteors , not as looking like solid bodies , but rather like a fine luminous matter , perpetually changing its shape and appearance .
Of this many defenders of the opinion are so sensible , that they suppose the revolving body gets a coat or atmosphere of electricity , by means of which it becomes luminous ; but , I think , whoever carefully peruses the various accounts of fireballs , and especially ours of the 18th of August when it divided , will perceive that their phenomenon do not correspond with the idea of a solid nucleus enveloped in a subtle fluid , any more than with the conjecture of another learned gentleman , that they become luminous by means of a contained fluid , which occasionally explodes through the thick solid outer shell ~ .
A strong objection to this hypothesis of permanent revolving bodies , is derived from the great number of them there must be to answer all the appearances .
Such a regular gradation is observed , from those large meteors which strike all beholders with astonishment , and occur but rarely , down to the minute fires called shooting stars , which are seen without being regarded in great numbers every clear night , that it seems impossible to draw any line of distinction between them , or deny that they are all of the same nature .
But such a crowd of revolving bodies could scarcely fail to announce their existence by some other means than merely a luminous train in the night ; * See a dissertation on this subject by Professor CLAP , of Yale College , New England .
~ Phil. Trans. vol. LI .
p. 267 .
as , for instance , by meeting or justling sometimes near the earth , or by falling to the earth in consequence of various accidents ; at least we might expect they would be seen in the day-time , either with the naked eye of telescopes , by some of the numerous observers who are constantly examining the heavens .
With regard to these falling stars , it were much to be wished , that observations should be made upon them by different persons in concert at distant stations , for the purpose of ascertaining their height and velocity ; which would tend very much to illustrate all this part of meteorology .
Another argument of great weight against the hypothesis that fire-balls are terrestrial comets , is taken from their great velocity .
A body falling from infinite space toward the earth , would have acquired a velocity of no more than 7 miles a second , when it came within 50 miles of the earth 's surface ; whereas these meteors seem to move at least three times faster .
And this objection , if there be no mistake in regard to the velocity of the meteors , as I think there is not , absolutely oversets the whole hypothesis .
What then can these meteors be ?
The only agent in nature with which we are acquainted , that seems capable of producing such phenomenon , is electricity .
I do not mean that by what is already known of that fluid , all the difficulties relative to meteors can be solved , as the laws , by which its motions on a large scale are regulated in those regions so nearly empty of air , can scarcely , I imagine , be investigated in our small experiments with exhausted vessels * ; but only that several of the facts point out a near connexion and analogy with electricity , and that none of them are irreconcilable to the discovered laws of that fluid .
* How nearly the phenomenon of meteors have been represented by artificial electricity is known from a very remarkable experiment of Mr. ARDE N'S .
See PRIESTLE Y , vol. V. p. 379 .
1 .
Electricity moves with such a prodigious velocity , as to elude all the attempts hitherto made by philosophers to detect it ; but the swiftness of meteors , stating it at 20 miles a second , is such as no experiments yet contrived could have discovered , and which seems to belong to electricity alone .
This is , perhaps , the only case in which the course or direction of that fluid is rendered perceptible to our senses , in consequence of the large scale on which these fire-balls move .
2 .
Various electrical phenomenon have been seen attending meteors .
Lambent flames are described as settling upon men , horses , and other objects * ; and sparks coming from them , or the whole meteor itself , it is said , have damaged ships , houses , &amp;c. in the manner of lightning ~ .
These facts , I must own , are but obscurely related , yet still they do not seem to be destitute of foundation .
If there be really any hissing noise heard while meteors are passing , it seems explicable on no other supposition than that of streams of electric matter issuing from them , and reaching the earth with a velocity equal to that of the meteor , namely , in two or three seconds .
Accordingly , in one of our late meteors , the hissing was compared to that of electricity issuing from a conductor ~ .
The sparks flying off so perpetually *PRIESTLE Y ' S History of Electricity , p. 352 .
Mem. de l'Acad .
des Scienc .
1771 , p. 681 , 682 .
See an odd fact , perhaps of this nature , in PARKER'S General Advertiser , Dec. 1 , 1783 .
~ Mem. anc .
de l'Acad .
de Dijon , tom .
1 .
Hist. p 42 .
Phil. Trans. vol. XLVI .
p. 366 .
Hist. de l'Acad .
des Scienc .
1761 , p. 28 .
~ Chester Weekly Courant , August 26 , 1783 .
This and many other curious circumstances , relative to meteors , are so well exemplified in the following observation , made several years ago by Mr. ROBINSON at Hinckley in Leicestershire , that I think it worth transcribing here , especially as it occurs in a work which few people would think of consulting on such a subject .
` ` Oct. 26 , 1766 , at half past five in the evening , after a violent strom of wind and rain , perpetually from the body of fire-balls , may possibly have some connexion with these streams * .
In the same manner the found of explosions may perhaps be brought to us quicker , than if it were propagated through the whole distance by air alone .
Should these ideas be well founded , the change of direction which meteors seem at times to undergo , may possibly be influenced by the state of the surface of the earth over which I observed a fiery meteor .
Its direction was from N.W. to S.E. nearly in a horizontal direction ; it passed very near to me , and was of an elliptical form ; its motion about 40~ in 2~ or 3~ of time .
It was very bright and lucid to appearance like the palest lightning , and emitted sparks continually , which formed a kind of tail toward the N.W. which seemed to be extinguished at the distance of 2~ or 3~ from the body ; there was a small portion that parted from it .
The cohesion of matter was so great , that it drew a thread of considerable length from the body , before it broke from it .
During the passage there was a kind of hissing noise , much like to what we hear from the electrical machine when the electric matter is running away , or as when it is escaping from a full charged jar .
' ' Bibliotheca Topographica Britannica , No VII .
p. 81 .
* Hist. de l'Acad .
des Scienc .
1761 , p. 28 .
Mem. de l'Acad .
des Scienc .
1771 , p. 682 .
Extract of a letter from the Abbe MANN , Director of the Academy at Brussels , to Sir JOSEPH BANKS , Bart. P. R. S. ` ` I shall only mention one singular circumstance , which was communicated to me by a particular friend of mine .
It happened at Mariekercke , a small village on the coast , about half a league to the W. of Ostend .
The curate of the village was sitting in the dusk of the evening with a friend , when a sudden light surprised them , and immediately after a small ball of light-coloured flame came through a broken pane of glass , crossed the room where they were sitting , and fixed itself on the chink of a door opposite to the window where it entered , and there died gradually away .
It appeared to be a kind of phosphoric light , carried along by the current of air .
The curate and his friend , greatly surprised at what they saw , apprehended fire in the neighbourhood ; but going out , found that the fire , which had come in through the window , had been detached from a large meteor in its passage .
' ' How far these and similar appearances may be owing simply to the illumination produced by meteors , should be attentively considered in the investigation of such facts .
they are passing , and to which the streams are supposed to reach .
A similar cause may occasion the apparent explosion , the opening of more channels giving new vent and motion to the electric fluid .
May not the deviation and explosion which appear to have taken place in the fire-ball of the 18th of August over Lincolnshire , have been determined by its approach toward the sens , and an attraction produced by that large body of moisture ?
3 .
A further argument for the electric origin of meteors is deduced from their connexion with the northern lights , and the resemblance they bear to these electrical phenomenon , as they are now almost universally allowed to be , in several particulars .
Instances are recorded , where northern lights have been seen to join and form luminous balls , darting about with great velocity , and even leaving a train behind like the common fire-balls * .
This train I take to be nothing but the rare air left in such a highly electrified state as to be luminous ; and some streams of the northern lights are very much like it .
The aurora borealis appears to occupy as high , if not a higher , region above the surface of the earth , as may be judged from the very distant countries to which is has been visible at the same time ~ ; indeed the great accumulation of electric matter seems to lie beyond the verge of our atmosphere , as estimated by the cessation of twilight .
Also with the northern * Hist. de l'Acad .
des Scienc .
1705 , p. 35 .
WHISTO N ' S Account of a Meteor seen in the Air 1715/ 6 .
Phil. Trans. vol. XLI .
p. 626 ; and LIII .
p. 6 ?
Also a most pointed fact in the Act .
Liter .
Sueciae , 1734 , p. 78 .
~BERGMA N , upon a mean of 30 computations , makes the average height of the northern lights to be near 70 Swedish , that is , about 460 English miles .
Kong .
Vetensk .
Acad. Handlingar , vol. XXV .
p. 193 .
See also Phil. Trans. vol. LIV .
p. 327 .
and M. DE MAIRA N ' S Traite de l'Aurore Boreale , p. 51 .
lights a hissing noise is said to be heard in some very cold climates ; GMELIN speaks of it in the most pointed terms , as frequent and very loud in the north-eastern parts of Siberia * ; and other travellers have related similar facts ~ .
But , * Reise durch Siberien , vol. III .
p. 135 .
As the whole passage is very remarkable , and has never , that I know , appeared in English , I thought the following translation of it might be acceptable .
These northern lights begin with single bright pillars , rising in the N. and almost at the same time in the N.E. which gradually increasing comprehend a large space of the heavens , rush about from place to place with incredible velocity , and finally almost cover the whole sky up to the zenith .
The streams are then seen meeting together in the zenith , and produce an appearance as if a vast tent was expanded in the heavens , glittering with gold , rubies , and sapphire .
A more beautiful spectacle cannot be painted ; but whoever should see such a northern light for the first time , could not behold it without terroy .
For however fine the illumination may be , it is attended , as I have learned from the relation of many persons , with such a hissing , cracking , and rushing noise throughout the air , as if the largest fire-works were playing off .
To describe what they then hear , they make use of the expression , Spolochi chodjat , that is , the raging host is passing .
The hunters who pursue the white and blue foxes in the confines of the Icy Sea , are often overtaken in their course by these northern lights .
Their dogs are then so much frightened , that they will not move , but lie obstinately on the ground till the noise has passed .
Commonly clear and calm weather follows this kind of northern lights .
I have heard this account , not from one person only , but confirmed by the uniform testimony of many , who have spent part of several years in these very northern regions , and inhabited different countries from the Yenisei to the Lena ; so that no doubt of its truth can remain .
This seems indeed to be the real birth-place of the aurora borealis .
' ' It is here to be observed , that GMELIN did not collect the account himself , but extracted it from letters or papers of M. DE L'ISLE DE LA CROYER E ' S , who was himself far to the northward of Yakutsk , without hearing these noises ; probably , therefore , it is much exaggerated , though one can scarcely suppose the whole to be fabulous .
~ Musschenbroeck Introduct .
~ 2495 .
Beccaria dell ' Elletricismo artif .
et not , But , in my opinion , the most remarkable analogy of all , and that which tends most to elucidate the origin of these meteors , is the direction of their course , which seems , in the very large ones at least , to be constantly from or toward the north or north-west quarter of the heavens , and indeed to approach very nearly to the present magnetical meridian .
This is particularly observable in those meteors of late years whose tracks have been ascertained with most exactness ; as that of November 26 , 1758 , described by Sir JOHNPRINGL E ; that of July 17 , 1771 , treated of by M. LERO Y ; and this of the 18th of last August .
The largest proportion of the other accounts of meteors confirm the same observation , even those of a more early period * ; nay , I think , some traces of it are perp .
221 .
There is now working with Mr. NAIRNE F. R. S. a person of the name of ARNOL D , who resided seven years at Hudson 's Bay , the last three at Fort Henley .
He confirms M. GMELI N'S account of the sine appearance and brilliant colours of the northern lights , and particularly of their rushing noise , which he affirms he has very frequently heard , and compares it to the sound produced by whirling round a stick swiftly at the end of a string .
He adds , that on conversing about this matter with a Swedish watch-maker of the name of LIN D , that person assured him , that he had heard a similar noise in his own country .
Mr. NAIRNE too , one time , at Northampton , when the northern lights were remarkably bright , is confident he perceived a hissing or whizzing sound .
This hissing or rushing noise , as well as that attending meteors in their passage , supposing it in both cases to be real , I would attribute to small streams of electric matter , running off to the earth from the great masses or accumulations of electricity , by which I suppose both meteors and the northern lights to be produced .
Compare M. DEMAIRA N'S Traite de l'Aurore Boreale , p. 126 .
* See Phil. Trans. and Mem. de l'Acad .
des Sciences , &amp;c. I have found , of an earlier or later period , accounts of more than 40 different fire balls .
Of these above 20 are so described , that it is certain their course was in the abovementioned direction ; only 3 or 4 seem to have moved the contrary way ; and with regard to the remainder , it is left doubtful , from the imperfect state of the relations , perceivable in the writings of the ancients * .
Whether their motion shall be from the northern quarter of the heavens or toward it , seems nearly indifferent , as the numbers of those going each way are not very unequal ; I consider them , in the former case , as masses of the electric fluid repelled , or bursting from the great collected body of it in the north ; and , in the latter case , as masses attracted toward that accumulation ; a distinction , probably , much the same in effect , as that of positive and negative electricity near the surface of the earth .
This tendency toward the magnetic meridian , however , seems to hold good only with regard to the largest sort of fireballs ; the smaller ones move more irregularly , perhaps because they come further within the verge of our atmosphere , and are thereby more exposed to the action of extraneous causes .
That the smaller sort of meteors , such as shooting stars , are really lower down in the atmosphere , is rendered very probable by their swifter apparent motion ; perhaps it is this very circumstance which occasions them to be smaller , the electric tions .
When we consider that even the meteor of the 18th of August last was thought by some spectators to move south-westward , it will rather appear surprising that so many of these accounts should correspond , than that a few of them should differ .
*ARISTOTLE ( Meteor .
~ .
~ .
c. 6 .
) denies that comets , with which I take meteors to be confounded , are generated only in the north ; which shows it to have been then the prevalent opinion , that they appeared most frequently in that quarter .
~~~~ ~ , ~~~~~~~~~ ~ .
So likewise PLINY ( lib. II .
c. 25 .
) Xiphias , Disceus , Pitheus~ doliorum ~ figura , in concavo sumidae lucis .
Ceratias .
Lampadias .
Hippeus .
Candidus ~ .
Omnes ferme sub ipso septentrione , aliqua ejus part non certa , sed maxim in candida , quae lactei circuli nomen accepit .
And SENECA ( Quaest .
Not .
lib. VII .
) Placet ergo nostris , Cometas , sicut Tubas , Trabesque , et alia ostenta coeli , denso aere creari .
Ideo circa septentrionem ~ apparent , quia illie plurimum est ~ pigri .
fluid being more divided in more resisting air .
But as those masses of electricity , which move where there is scarcely any resistance , so generally affect the direction of the magnetic meridian , the ideas which have been entertained of some analogy between these two obscure powers of nature , seem not altogether without foundation * .
If the foregoing conjectures be just , distinct regions are allotted to the electrical phenomenon of our atmosphere .
Here below we have thunder and lightning , from the unequal distribution of the electric fluid among the clouds ; in the loftier regions , whither the clouds never reach , we have the various gradations of falling stars ; till beyond the limits of our crepuscular atmosphere the fluid is put into motion in sufficient * It appears to me more rational to resolve this analogy into a power of electricity to influence magnetism , than into a supposed similarity of two fluids ; as the former can be made evident by our artificial experiments , but there is no proof of the latter .
When fire-balls , therefore , are said to affect the magnetic meridian , I do not mean that they are drawn in that direction because it is the line of magnetism , but rather that the magnetic poles of the earth are thrown into their present position , by the accumulation and action of that very electricity upon which the fire-balls depend .
Should a change be produced by any cause in the place of this accumulation , or the state of its motion , it is not improbable , that the main polarity would be given to other portions of the earth , whence a variation in the pointing of the compass would necessarily ensue .
If Dr. FRANKLI N'S hypothesis be admitted , ascribing the electrical state of the polar atmosphere to the crust of ice ( a bad conductor ) in those regions , it follows , that should ice form or be collected in one part more than in another , the atmosphere there would become more highly electrical , and , in so far as the magnetism is given by electricity , the adjoining portion of the earth would acquire a stronger polarity .
Now it is certainly worthy of remark , that since our first northern navigations , the coast of West Greenland and its surrounding seas have become gradually more and more inaccessible on account of ice , and that the magnetic needle all this time has been constantly changing its variation to the westward .
masses to hold a determined course , and exhibit the different appearances of what we call fire-balls ; and probably at a still greater elevation above the earth , the electricity accumulates in a lighter less condensed form , to produce the wonderfully diversified streams and coruscations of the aurora borealis .
I have the honour to be , with the greatest respect , SIR , Your most obedient humble servant , C. BLAGDE N. ENDOFPART I. OFVO L. LXXIV .

