XVII .
On a Method of describing the relative Positions and Magnitudes of the Fixed Stars ; together with some Astronomical Observations .
By the Rev. Francis Wollaston , LL. B. F. R. S. Read February 5 , 1784 .
FROM some alterations which have of late years been discovered , in the relative positions and apparent magnitudes of a few of the stars we called fixed , it seems not unreasonable to conclude , that there may be many changes among others of them we little suspect .
This thought has led me into a wish , that some method were adopted whereby to detect such motions .
The first idea which occurred to me was , to make a proposal to astronomers in general ; that each should undertake a strict examination of a certain district in the heavens ; and , not only by a re-examination of the catalogues hitherto published , but by taking the right ascension and declination of every star in their several allotment , to frame an exact map of it , with a corresponding catalogue ; and to communicate their observations to one common centre .
This is what I could be glad to see begun .
Every astronomer must wish it , and therefore every one should be ready to take his share in it .
Such a plan , undertaken with spirit , and carried on gradually with care , would , by the joint labours and emulation of so many astronomers as are now in Europe , produce a celestial Atlas fan beyond any thing that has ever yet appeared .
But this would be a work of time , and not within the compass of every one .
What I mean now to propose is more immediate ; and not out of the reach of any who amuse themselves with viewing the heavenly bodies .
Meridian altitudes and transits can be taken but once in 24 hours ; and , though accurate , are therefore tedious .
Neither can any re-examination of them be made , but with the same labour as at the first .
Equatorial sectors are in the hands of few ; and require great skill .
Some more general method seemed wanting ; to discover variations , which , when detected or only surmised , should be consigned immediately to a more strict investigation .
Turning this in my thoughts , I considered , that the noting down at the time the exact appearance of what one sees , would be far more simple , and show any alterations in that appearance more readily , than any other method .
A Drawing once made would remain , and could be consulted at any future period ; and if it were drawn at first with care , a transient review would discover to one , whether any sensible change had taken place since it was last examined .
Catalogues , or verbal Descriptions of any kind , could not answer that end so well .
To do this with ease and expedition was then the requisite : and a telescope with a large field , and some proper sub-divisions in it , to direct the eye and assist the judgement , seemed to bid most fair for success .
The following is the method which , after various trials , I have adopted , and think I may now venture to recommend .
To a night-glass , but of DOLLOND'S improved construction , which magnifies about six times , and takes in a field of just about as many degrees of a great circle , I have added cross wires , intersecting each other at an angle of 45~ .
More wires may be crossed in other directions ; but I apprehend these will be found sufficient .
This telescope I mount on a polar axis .
One coarsely made , and without any divisions on its circle of declination , will answer this purpose , since there is no great occasion for accuracy in that respect : but as the heavenly bodies are more readily followed by an equatorial motion of the telescope , so their relative positions are much more easily discerned when they are looked at constantly as in the same direction .
An horizontal motion , except in the meridian , would be apt to mislead the judgement .
It is scarcely necessary to add , that the wires must stand so as for one to describe a parallel of the equator nearly .
Another will then be a horary circle ; and the whole area will be divided into eight equal sectors .
Thus prepared , the telescope is to be pointed to a known star , which is to be brought into the centre or common intersection of all the wires .
The relative positions of such other stars as appear within the field , are to be judged-of by the eye : whether at 1/ 2 , or 1/ 3 , or 1/ 4 from the centre towards the circumference , or vice versa ; and so with regard to the nearest wire respectively .
These , as one sees them , are to be noted down with a black lead pencil upon a large message card held in the hand , upon which a circle , similarly divided , is ready drawn .
( One of three inches diameter seems most convenient .
) The motion of the heavenly bodies in such a telescope is so slow , and the noting down of the stars so quickly done , that there is most commonly full time for it without moving the telescope .
When that is wanted , the principal star is easily brought back again into the centre of the field at pleasure , and the work resumed .
After a little practice , it is astonishing how near one can come to the truth in this way : and , though neither the right ascensions nor the declinations are laid down by it , nor the distances between the stars measured ; yet their apparent situations being preserved in black and white , with the day and year , and hour if thought necessary , written underneath , each card becomes a register of the then appearance of that small portion of the heavens ; which is easily re-examined at any time with little more than a transient view ; and which yet will show on the first glance , if there should have happened in it any variation of consequence .
It is obvious , that very delicate observations are not to be made in this way .
In order to explain my meaning more fully , a card so marked shall accompany this paper ( see tab .
V. fig. 1 .
) .
What I first happened to pitch upon was the constellation of Corona Borealis , which then fronted one of my windows ; and which I have since pursued throughout in this method ; making the stars ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , and ~ , successively central ; together with one or two belonging to Boots , for the sake of connecting the whole together .
These I have transferred since on a sheet of paper , to try how well they would unite into one map ; which they have done with very little alteration .
A copy of that shall also be laid before this Society ( fig. 2 .
) .
My design was , after marking down all such stars as are visible with so small a magnifier , to go over the whole again with another telescope of a higher power , divided in the same way ; and after that , with a third and a fourth ; so as to comprehend every star I could discern .
That would discover smaller changes : but it must be a work of time , if attempted at all .
After such a rough map of the constellation is made , the endeavouring to ascertain the right ascensions and declinations of these , may perhaps be adviseable in the next place , rather than searching for more .
In observing in this way it is manifest , that the places of such stars as happen to be under or very near any one of the wires , must be more to be depended upon , than of what are in the intermediate spaces , especially if towards the edges of the field : so also what are nearest to the centre , because better defined , and more within the reach of one wire or another .
For this reason , different stars in the same set must successively be made central , or brought towards one of the wires , where any suspicion arises of a mistake , in order to approach nearer to a certainty : but if the stand of the telescope be tolerably well adjusted and fixed in its place , that is soon done .
In such a glass it is very seldom that light is wanting sufficient to discern the wires .
When an illuminator is required , I find , that for this purpose , where you wish to see every small star you can , a piece of card or white paste-board , projecting on one side beyond the tube , and which may be brought forward occasionally , is better than one of any other kind .
By cutting across a small segment of the object-glass , it throws a sufficient light down the tube , though a candle is at a great distance ; and one may lose sight of that false glare when one pleases , by drawing back the head , and moving the eye a little side-ways , and then one sees the smaller stars just as well as if no illuminator were there .
This then is the method I would recommend to the practical astronomer , for becoming acquainted with the appearance of the stars , and setting a watch over the heavenly motions .
After a very few trials , every one would find this easy .
And if each person of every rank among astronomers would take a constellation or two under his care , the numbers who could undertake it in this way would compensate for the defects of a plan which cannot aspire at great accuracy .
The labour of it , even at first , is but little .
It has cost me more time indeed than I ought commonly to allot to mere amusement ; because I had my apparatus to contrive , and several different and fruitless schemes to try , before I could satisfy myself .
But a quarter , or at the most half , an hour is generally sufficient for the marking of one pretty full card in this way : and when once the cards are marked , and a general map of the constellation is formed , a little time given to it in a fine evening , to examine whether the stars on such or such a card remain in their former position , is little trouble indeed .
Perseverance is most likely to be wanting , and therefore must be determined upon ; because , after finding things time after time just as they were , one 's hopes of discovering any thing new will slacken .
But the different state of the air , or of one 's own eye , will frequently occasion a fresh star to become visible , or a small one which had been noted down to seem to have disappeared ; and such a mere accident will serve to re-kindle the desire of pursuing it .
Besides , if we observe no change after a tolerable interval of assiduous search , we may at any time turn to another constellation : yet ought we never to abandon the former entirely , after having once publicly undertaken it , without giving notice of our so doing .
In the cards or maps , it may be observed , I have not marked the respective sizes of the stars .
Nor have I distinguished them in any way , excepting a few of them with BAYER'S Greek letters .
It was because I have not hitherto satisfied myself how to do it .
Some method must be used by every one , to describe to himself what he means ; but , in laying any thing before the public , a deference ought to be paid to what has been done by others .
The calling any star by a new name would breed confusion : and as I was desirous this should appear before this Society in its first rude form , that a judgement might be made from it how far such a scheme would promise success , I was unwilling to look into catalogues or capital maps for the numbers or names of the stars , lest I should be tempted to adapt the positions of what I had observed to what I there found set down by more able astronomers .
Nothing , therefore , but a hemisphere of SENEX has been consulted , just for knowing how far the constellation is usually reckoned to extend , and what are BAYER'S references .
Should this plan meet with approbation , I shall be happy to have proposed it ; and will endeavour to forward it in any way that shall be judged proper : or should any other be preferred , which is within the abilities and leisure of one who is engaged in another profession , I shall be as happy to lend what assistance I can to it .
My aim is only , to render such observations as I am capable of making , useful to science .
Before I conclude on this head , give me leave to add a few hints .
Whether this method be followed , or any other , if a general plan be set on foot , whoever undertakes a constellation , or district , should determine to examine it with as great accuracy as he can ; yet never be ashamed to let others know of his mistakes .
The error of one proves a caution to another .
Such a rough sketch , once made , will be found of great use to most of us , in knowing which star next to examine with greater care .
He who can do no more than this , will do a useful work by going thus far : and his frequently sweeping over his district in this way , may lead him to a discovery which might escape a more regular astronomer .
But whoever can , ought to do more .
By degrees the exact positions of every star he has noted down may be ascertained , by the method practised by Mr. DE LA CAILLE in his Southern Hemisphere , or by any other which shall be esteemed more convenient .
Every one , indeed , must use such instruments as he can procure : but assiduity can do more with indifferent ones , than will ever be accomplished with the very best without it .
Whatever references are made for one 's own convenience , when a map and catalogue are given to the public stock , the old letters and numbers should be retained as far as they go : though yet notice should be taken , where the magnitudes of the stars at present do not appear to correspond with the order in which they have been laid down .
To render this more complete , it were to be wished , that each should give in a copy of his original observations , with an account of the instruments he used ; since they ought to be preserved as data from whence his deductions were made , which may then be re-examined at any future time .
Yet must it be desired , that no one would trust himself without carrying on his calculations as fast as the observations are made : they will otherwise multiply upon his hands till the labour will dishearten him from attempting it at all .
A heap of crude , undigested observations would be an unwelcome present to the public .
Having thus stated this Proposal , I shall leave it to be proceeded upon , or not , as shall be seen proper : And will now only subjoin a List of such occasional observations as I have had opportunity of making , since the last which I communicated to this Society .
I find , indeed , that it is much longer than I had apprehended : but as I perceive some astronomers abroad have referred to a few of those which have been honoured with a place in our Transactions , it may be as well to follow it up .
An observation retained among one 's own private papers I hold to be of little use .
One thing let me desire Foreigners to remark : that the registers I gave of the going of my clock were meant only as the relations of a mere fact ; that a clock , of such a construction , kept or altered its rate so or so .
They seem to have understood it as an account of a capital clock , by valuing themselves upon some of theirs going better .
The time-keepers in most of our Observatories are far more accurate ; but , excepting those of the Royal Observatory at Greenwich , their accuracy is not made public .
Another remark it may also be proper to make ; that , since my former papers , the longitude of this place has been ascertained by comparative observations on the bursting of some rockets , let off on purpose ; which , on a mean of several , turns out to be 19~,02 in time E. of Greenwich Observatory ; that is , it may hereafter be considered as 19~ , instead of 18~,6 as I had before calculated it trigonometrically from the bearings .
Observations made at Chislehurst , in Kent , longitude 19~ in time East of the Royal Observatory at Greenwich , and latitude 51~ 24~ 33~ North .
Eclipse of the moon , ~ July 30 , 1776 : observed with a 31/ 2 feet achromatic telescope , and a power magnifying 29 times ( that is , a single eye-glass belonging to the day-tube ) the aperture of the telescope being reduced to 1 1/ 2 inches .
The night very clear and still .
Apparent time .
h. ' ' ' The beginning not properly observed .
10 11 31 Grimaldus touched by the shadow .
10 12 49 covered .
10 14 5 Galilaeus covered .
10 19 36 Aristarchus covered .
10 26 0 The spot in Kepler bisected .
10 24 25 Schikardus ( but Q. ) touched .
10 25 52 bisected .
10 27 19 covered .
10 28 15 Copernicus touched .
10 29 49 covered .
10 31 22 Helicon ( but Q. ) covered .
10 37 9 Plato touched .
10 37 54 + covered .
10 38 55 Tycho touched .
10 39 39 bisected .
10 40 25 covered .
Apparent time .
h. ' ' ' 10 43 16 Manilius covered .
10 46 51 Menelaus covered .
10 48 5 Dionysius covered .
10 55 4 Censorinus covered .
10 58 57 A point ( Promontorium acutum , I believe ) touched .
11 0 21 A spot between M. Faecunditatis and M. Nectaris touched .
11 0 23 M. Crisium touched .
11 3 55 covered .
11 7 57 The eclipse seemingly total .
11 11 11 The moon covers a small star near her south limb .
The star hangs on the limb , before it disappears .
11 28 17 She covers another star a little south of her centre .
This vanishes instantaneously .
These occultations were observed with another power of the same telescope ; which is usually reckoned 100 , and which I have formerly so called ; but which on an accurate examination really magnifies almost 75 times .
The emersions of these stars were not observed .
12 43 0I judge the beginning of the emersion to be about this time ; but cannot be certain .
12 48 1 Grimaldus quitted by the shadow .
12 58 25 Aristarchus quitted .
12 59 22 Kepler bisected .
13 0 15 Tycho begins to emerge .
13 19 bisected .
13 1 53 emerges .
Till this time I had used the whole aperture ( 3,6 ) having forgotten to reduce Apparent time .
h. ' ' ' it , till the moon 's brightness reminded me .
Same power as at first ; that is , 29 .
13 6 51 Copernicus begins to emerge .
13 7 20 seemingly bisected .
13 8 19 emerges .
13 10 27 Helicon emerges .
13 15 26 Plato begins to emerge .
13 16 31 emerges .
13 21 30 Manilius emerges .
13 23 54 Dionysius emerges .
13 24 57 Menelaus emerges .
13 29 47 Censorinus emerges .
13 31 21 The spot by M. Faecunditatis emerges .
13 35 31 The point of Prom .
Acutum emerges .
13 37 21 + M. Crisium begins to emerge .
13 40 26 quitted by the shadow .
13 42 0 The end of the eclipse .
The air was very clear and still the whole time : the shadow but ill defined .
Indeed , it was little more than a penumbra ; the principal spots remaining always visible on the moon 's dusky face .
Eclipse of the sun ~ June 24 , 1778 : observed with a 31/ 2 feet achromatic telescope magnifying 75 times .
The aperture reduced to two inches , to prevent breaking the smoked glasses .
3 41 33,5 Beginning .
I suspect the minute to be mistaken , and that it should be 3 h. 40~ 33~,5 .
The first Apparent time .
h. ' ' ' impression could not be 2~ , I believe not 1~ , before I observed it .
5 25 24 End .
An undulation on the sun 's limb ; but the observation pretty good .
Eclipse of the moon ~ November 23 , 1779 : observed with the same telescope , magnifying 75 times .
The aperture reduced to two inches .
Night clear and frosty .
No wind .
The beginning not ascertained .
6 13 19 Grimaldus touched by the shadow .
6 13 28 covered .
6 17 29 Aristarchus covered .
6 20 46 Kepler bisected .
6 23 40 M. Humorum touched .
6 27 47 Helicon covered .
6 28 40 Copernicus and Timocharis both bisected .
6 29 57 M. Humorum covered .
6 33 50 Plato touched .
6 34 27 covered .
6 41 52 Tycho touched .
6 43 8 covered .
6 47 11 Plinius ( but Q. ) covered .
6 59 1 M. Crisium touched .
73 16 covered .
77 31 The eclipse total .
8 46 23 Moon 's edge begins to emerge .
8 51 14 Grimaldus begins .
8 52 1 emerges .
A haze comes on .
Apparent time .
h. ' ' ' 92 23 : : Kepler bisected .
This not clearly seen .
9 11 41 Plato begins to emerge .
9 12 35 emerges .
9 13 46 Tycho emerged .
The haze comes on again too much for the observation to be pursued any farther .
Eclipse of the sun ~ Oct. 16 , 1781 : observed with the same telescope and magnifying power .
The beginning not visible ; sun too low .
20 22 13,5 The end .
Good .
Eclipse of the Moon ~ Sept. 10 , 1783 : observed with the same telescope , viz. 31/ 2 feet achromatic , with the aperture reduced to two inches ; but with a small magnifying power of 36 times , which I had made by Mr. DOLLOND for these observations , and which I found very convenient .
Night a little hazy , but pretty favourable .
9 33 0A duskiness comes on the moon .
9 45 35 The beginning of the shadow , I believe .
9 47 20 A haziness obscures the moon .
9 50 55 Aristarchus covered .
9 52 20 Kepler covered .
So it is set down ; but I do not recollect what I meant by this ; whether it might not be only the spot in the centre , so that it might more properly be called bisected .
Apparent time .
h. ' ' ' 9 57 57 Gassendus covered .
I suspect the minute here ; and that it should be 56~ 57~ .
9 59 41 Heraclides covered .
10 1 42 Copernicus touched .
10 35 covered .
10 3 26 Helicon covered .
10 4 12 Bulialdus covered .
10 80A haziness again .
10 8 57 Plato covered .
10 15 30 Manilius covered .
10 15 54 Tycho touched .
10 17 5 : : covered .
This doubtful .
10 19 10 Menelaus covered .
10 21 38 Dionysius covered .
10 22 40 Plinius covered .
A haziness again .
10 28 25 Censorinus covered .
10 34 34 M. Crisium touched .
10 39 45 covered .
10 46 34 Total darkness , as I judged it .
At 10 h. 41~ the moon had grown reddish , and the eclipsed part become more visible than before .
After some time , during the total darkness , the moon was barely to be seen .
In general , about the centre , it was darker than towards the circumference , which was ill-defined .
About 12 00 The eastern limb became more visible , and better defined .
Apparent time .
h. ' ' ' 12 14 0 The light spreads a great way over the moon from that side towards the centre , extending about two-thirds of her circumference ( see fig. 3 .
) 12 23 0 The moon seems beginning to emerge .
12 25 0 Emersion certainly has begun .
12 28 21 Grimaldus emerged .
12 31 40 Galileus emerged .
12 33 52 Aristarchus emerged .
12 37 26 Kepler ( but Q. this as before ) .
12 39 36 Heraclides emerged .
12 42 56 Helicon emerged .
12 45 52 Copernicus emerged entirely .
12 47 22 Plato begins to emerge .
12 47 58 emerges .
12 48 30 Tycho begins to emerge .
12 49 58 emerges .
12 58 8 Manilius emerges .
13 1 40 Menelaus emerges .
13 3 18 Dionysius emerges .
13 5 40 Plinius emerges .
13 11 22 Censorinus ( but Q. ) emerges .
13 16 35 M. Crisium begins to emerge .
13 20 53 emerges .
13 25 38 The shadow quits the moon near Langrenus , between that and M. Crisium .
The duskiness does not leave the moon till some time afterwards , but I did not wait to observe it .
The moon was darker during the eclipse than usual ; but the air was not clear enough for any occultations of stars to be observed .
Transit of Mercury over the sun 's disk ~ Nov. 12 , 1782 : observed with the same telescope , and a power of 75 times .
The aperture reduced to two inches .
Apparent time .
h. ' ' ' 2 51 49 First impression observed .
It could not be 2~ sooner .
2 54 57 Thread of light completed ; but seen through clouds .
The planet seemed to hang on the sun 's limb 30~ at least .
460 Through a break in the clouds , of short duration , ~ seemed to have quitted the sun ; but indeed the clouds were very unfavourable the whole time .
Occultation of Saturn by the moon , ~ February 18 , 1775 : observed with the same telescope ; and , I believe , the same power , with the whole aperture of the object-glass 3,6 inches ; but , I perceive , I have not set down these particulars .
95 39 Praec .
ansa of the ring im , 969 Praec .
limb of the planet im. Subsequent limb not set down .
96 48 Subsequent ansaim .
The moon low at these immersions , and much undulation .
The emersions lost by looking at a wrong part of the moon 's disk , except 10 17 Subsequent ansa emerges .
Night very clear ; but the observation on the whole imperfect .
Occultations of stars by the moon : observed with the same telescope , and a power of 75 times , with the whole aperture of the object-glass .
Apparent time .
1775 .
h. ' ' ' ~ Aug. 1 .
~~ Virginis 7 48 17 Both stars visible when a cloud covered them .
7 49 20 A short break ; only one star visible .
7 52 15 Another break ; but before this the second star was immerged .
8 48 58,5 First*em .
good .
8 49 6,5 Second*em .
good .
~a bright * 8 54 13 Im. good .
N of ~ Virginis Em .
not till the moon was too low .
~ Dec. 12 .
~ Regulus 10 5 46 Em .
very good , though the moon low .
1776 .
~ June 30 .
~1 ad ~~93 49 Im good ; some flying clouds .
10 6 38 Em .
; perhaps sooner .
1777 .
~ Aug. 23 .
~~ Ceti 10 41 17 Im. : the moon low ; night clear and still .
11 32 10 Em .
~ Nov. 15 .
~1 ad ~ Tauri Im. not seen ; undulation too great .
7 22 56 Em .
pretty good .
~ Nov. 16 .
~~ Tauri 11 17 1,5 Im. good .
These were observed with a 12 23 28 Em .
good .
power of 67 times , and an oblique speculum .
1783 .
~ May 16 .
~~ Scorpii 11 21 49 Im. Night clear and still ; the obser12 31 49,5 Em .
vations good .
~ Jul 10 .
~~ Scorpii Im. not seen for clouds .
8 43 56 Em .
; it might be 1~ or 2~ sooner ; the moon 's edge ill defined .
~ Dec. 30 .
~~ Piscium 83 13 Im. dark limb , very good .
98 30 Em .
good .
It could not be above 1~ sooner , if that .
Night very clear and still ; hard frost ; therm. 13~1/ 2 .
Eclipses of Jupiter 's satellites : observed with the same telescope and power ( that is , 75 times ; called usually 100 ) and whole aperture .
Apparent time .
1775 .
h. ' ' ' ~ Sept. 8 .
1 Sat. 11 33 14 Im. flying clouds ; observation doubtful .
~ Oct. 1 .
1 Sat. 11 51 1 Im. good ; unless the minute be mistaken .
~ Nov. 2 .
1 Sat. 8 28 2 Im. good .
~ 16 .
2 Sat. 90 13 Im. pretty good ; air clear , but a cold in my eyes rendered the observation not satisfactory .
~ Dec. 18 .
1 Sat. 10 45 48 Em .
good .
2 Sat. 11 20 Em .
pretty good .
~ 27 .
1 Sat. 73 48 Em .
good .
1776 .
~ Nov. 17 .
3 Sat. 9 38 48,5 Im. ; a scintillation for some seconds before it quite disappeared .
1778 .
~ May 21 .
1 Sat. 99 38 Em .
good .
2 Sat. 10 10 ~ Em .
so near the first satellite ; as scarcely to be distinguishable from it for some minutes .
~ June 11 .
4 Sat. 9 52 4 Im. good for the fourth satellite , yet visible by fits for some seconds longer .
~ 13 .
1 Sat. 9 19 6 Em .
pretty good .
1779 .
~ Mar. 9 .
1 Sat. 6 59 19 Im. ; that is , this was the last of my seeing it ; but , though the night was clear , the satellite was too near Jupiter for the observation to be satisfactory .
~ May 22 .
2 Sat. 11 5 54 Em .
good .
1781 .
~ May 24 .
1 Sat. 10 3 31 Em .
very good .
~ 31 .
1 Sat. 11 57 35 Em .
pretty good .
~ June 16 .
1 Sat. 10 13 13 Em .
; clouds , but pretty good .
1782 .
~ July 20 .
3 Sat. 96 42 Em .
good .
2 Sat. 11 30 30 Em .
good .
Apparent time .
h. ' ' ' ~ July 21 .
1 Sat. 9 39 50 Emersion ; windy ; but good .
~ Aug. 29 .
1 Sat. 8 20 15,5 Em .
~ 30 .
4 Sat. 8 52 19 Em .
; satellite seen then , but not distinct for some time .
1783 .
~ July 8 .
1 Sat. 12 14 13 Im. pretty good .
~ Aug. 2 .
1 Sat. 9 10 31,5 Em .
good .
~ 25 .
1 Sat. 9 28 54 Em~ ~ Sept. 26 1 Sat. 6 19 44 Em .
pretty good , but twilight strong .
~ 30 .
3 Sat. 10 3 24 Im. It was visible only by fits for the last 8~ ' .
Jupiter near a tree .
~ Oct. 3 .
1 Sat. 8 18 0 Em .
pretty good ; but the moon below Jupiter .
~ 26 .
1 Sat. 8 39 17 Em .
Jupiter low and near a tree ; great undulation .
EXPLANATION OF THE FIGURES IN TAB. V. Fig. 1 .
~ Cor. Bor .
~ Aug. 6 , 1783 , per night-glass .
The * marked Sept. 24 .
was not observed till that night , but has continued since , and was only overlooked at first .
Fig. 2 .
A map of 107 stars , besides those marked by BAYER , in the constellation of Corona Borealis , or the Northern Crown ; together with a part of Boots : laid down from observations made 1783 with a nightglass furnished with cross-wires ; as their relative positions were estimated by the eye .
Fig. 3 .
The moon as she appeared ( inverted ) ~ Sept. 10 , 1783 , about a quarter of an hour before she began to emerge from total darkness .
* * + * * +* * +* * +* *~ *~ *~ ~ * ** Sep.24 * + *** + * + +* *~ *~ * *~ *~ ** ** * * * ** *~ * Fig. 3 .
*~ ** *~ * * *** * * * * * Fig. 2 .
* * *~ * *~ * *~ Bootis **** * ** *~ * * *~ * * * * ** Bootis * ** *~ *~ * * * * *~ * * ** * * * ** ** ~* *~ * * * *~ * * *~ * * *~ *~ Bootis *** ** * * * * *~ Bootis * *~ ~ * ** *~ * *~ ** *** ** ** * *

