XV .
Answer to Mr. Kirwan 's Remarks upon the Experiments on Air .
By Henry Cavendish , Esq. F. R. S. and S. A. Read March 4 , 1784 .
IN a paper lately read before this Society , containing many experiments on air , I gave my reasons for supposing that the diminution which respirable air suffers by phlogistication , is not owing either to the generation or separation of fixed air from it ; but without any arguments of a personal nature , or which related to any one person who espouses the contrary doctrine more than to another .
This being contrary to the opinion maintained by Mr. KIRWAN , he has written a paper in answer to it , which was read on the fifth of February .
As I do not like troubling the Society with controversy , I shall take no notice of the arguments used by him , but shall leave them for the reader to form his own judgement of ; much less will I endeavour to point out any inconsistencies or false reasonings , should any such have crept into it ; but as there are two or three experiments mentioned there , which may perhaps be considered as disagreeing with my opinion , I beg leave to say a few words concerning them .
Mr. DE LASSONE found that filings of zinc , digested in a caustic fixed alkali , were partially dissolved with a small effervescence , and that the alkali was rendered in some mea1 sure sure mild .
This mildness of the alkali Mr. KIRWAN accounts for by supposing , that the inflammable air , which is separated during the solution , and causes the effervescence , unites to the atmospheric air contiguous to it , and thereby generates fixed air , which is absorbed by the alkali .
But , in reality , the only circumstance from which Mr. DE LASSONE judged the alkali to become mild , was its making some effervescence when saturated with acids ; and this effervescence is more likely to have proceeded from the expulsion of inflammable air than of fixed air , as it seems likely , that the zinc might be more completely deprived of its phlogiston by the acid than by the alkali .
In the abovementioned paper I say , Dr. PRIESTLEY observed , that quicksilver fouled by the addition of lead or tin , deposits a powder by agitation and exposure to the air , which consists in great measure of the calx of the imperfect metal~ He found too some powder of this kind to contain fixed air ; but it must be observed , that the powder used in this experiment was not prepared on purpose , but was procured from quicksilver fouled by having been used in various experiments , and may therefore have contained other impurities besides the metallic calces .
On this Mr. KIRWAN remarks , that Dr. PRIESTLEY did not at first prepare this powder on purpose , but he afterwards did so prepare it ( 4 PR .
p. 148 .
and 149 .
) , and obtained a powder exactly of the same sort .
It was natural to suppose from this remark , that Dr. PRIESTLEY must have obtained fixed air from the powder prepared on purpose , and that I had overlooked the passage ; but , on turning to the pages referred to , I was surprised to find that it was otherwise , and that Dr. PRIESTLEY not so much as hints that he procured fixed air from the powder thus prepared .
With regard to the calcination of metals it may be proper to remark , that this operation is usually performed over the fire , by methods in which they are exposed to the fumes of the burning fuel , and which are so replete with fixed air , that it is not extraordinary , that the metallic calx should , in a short time , absorb a considerable quantity of it ; and in particular red lead , which is the calx on which most experiments have been made , is always so prepared .
There is another kind of calcination , however , called rusting , which is performed in the open air ; but this is so slow an operation , that the rust may easily imbibe a sufficient quantity of fixed air , notwithstanding the small quantity of it usually contained in the atmosphere .
Mr. KIRWAN allows that lime-water is not rendered cloudy by the mixture of nitrous and common air ; but contends that this does not prove that fixed air is not generated by the union , as he thinks it may be absorbed by the nitrous selenite produced by the union of the nitrous acid with the lime .
This induced me to try how small a quantity of fixed air would be perceived in this experiment .
I accordingly repeated it in the same manner as described in my paper , except that I purposely added a little fixed air to the common air , and found that when this addition was 1/ 25th of the bulk , or 1/ 50th of the weight of the common air , the effect on the lime-water was such as could not possibly have been overlooked in my experiments .
But as those who suppose fixed air to be generated by the mixture of nitrous and common air , may object to this manner of trying the experiment , and say , that the quantity of fixed air absorbed by the lime-water was really more than 1/ 75th of the bulk of the common air , being equal to that quantity over and above the air generated by the mixture , I made another experiment in a different manner ; namely , I filled a bottle with lime-water , previously mixed with as much nitrous acid as is contained in an equal bulk of nitrous air , and having inverted it into a vessel of the same , let up into it , in the same manner as in the above-mentioned experiments , a mixture of common air with 1/ 75th of its bulk of fixed air , until it was half full .
The event was the same as before ; namely , the cloudiness produced in the lime-water was such that I could not possibly have overlooked .
It must be observed , that in this experiment no fixed air could be generated , and a still greater proportion of the lime-water was turned into nitrous selenite than in the above-mentioned experiments ; so that we may safely conclude , that if any fixed air is generated by the mixture of common and nitrous air , it must be less than 1/ 75th of the bulk of the common air .
As for the nitrous selenite , it seems not to make the effect of the fixed air at all less sensible , as I found by filling two bottles with common air mixed with 1/ 100dth of its bulk of fixed air , and pouring into each of them equal quantities of diluted limewater ; one of these portions of lime-water being previously diluted with an equal quantity of distilled water , and the other with the same quantity of a diluted solution of nitrous selenite , containing about 1/ 400dth of its weight of calcareous earth ; when I could not perceive that the latter portion of limewater was rendered at all less cloudy than the former .
Though the nitrous selenite , however , does not make the effect of the fixed air less sensible , yet the dilution of the lime-water , in consequence of some of the lime being absorbed by the acid , does ; but , I believe , not in any remarkable degree .
There is an experiment mentioned by Mr. KIRWAN which , though it cannot be conisdered as an argument in favour of the generation of fixed air , as he only supposes , without any proof , that fixed air is produced in it , does yet deserve to be taken notice of as a curious experiment .
It is , that , if nitrous and common air be mixed over dry quicksilver , the common air is not at all diminished , that is , the bulk of the mixture will be not less than that of the common air employed , until water is admitted , and the mixture agitated for a few minutes .
The reason of this in all probability is , that part of the phlogisticated nitrous acid , into which the nitrous air is converted , remains in the state of vapour until condensed by the addition of water .
A proof that this is the real case is , that , in this manner of performing the experiment , the red fumes produced on mixing the airs remain visible for some hours , but immediately disappear on the addition of water and agitation .
The most material experiment alleged by Mr. KIRWAN is one of Dr. PRIESTLEY'S , in which he obtained fixed air from a mixture of red precipitate and iron filings .
This at first seems really a strong argument in favour of the generation of fixed air ; for though plumbago , which is known to consist chiefly of that substance , has lately been found to be contained in iron , yet one would not have expected it to be decompounded by the red precipitate , especially when the quantity of pure iron in the filings was much more than sufficient to supply the precipitate with phlogiston .
The following experiment , however , shows that it was really decompounded ; and that the fixed air obtained was not generated , but only separated by means of this decomposition .
500 grains of red precipitate mixed with 1000 of iron filings yielded , by the assistance of heat , 7800 grain measures of fixed air , besides 2400 of a mixture of dephlogisticated and inflammable air , but chiefly the latter .
The same quantity of iron filings , taken from the same parcel , was then dissolved in diluted oil of vitriol , so as to leave only the plumbago and other impurities .
These mixed with 500 grains of the same red precipitate , and treated as before , yielded 9200 grain measures of fixed air , and 4200 of dephlogisticated air , of an indifferent quality , but without any sensible mixture of inflammable air .
It appears , therefore , that less fixed air was produced when the red precipitate was mixed with the iron filings in substance , than when mixed only with the plumbago and other impurities ; which shows , that its production was not owing to the iron itself , which seems to contain no fixed air , but to the plumbago , which contains a great deal .
The reason , in all probability , why less fixed air was produced in the first case than the latter is , that in the former more of the plumbago escaped being decompounded by the red precipitate than in the other .
It must be observed , however , that the filings used in this experiment were mixed with about 1/ 13 th of their weight of brass , which was not discovered till they were dissolved in the acid , and which makes the experiment less decisive than it would otherwise be .
The quantity of fixed air obtained is also much greater than , according to Mr. BERGMAN'S experiment , could be yielded by the plumbago usually contained in 1000 grains of iron ; so that though the experiment seems to show that the fixed air was only produced by the decomposition of the impurities in the filings , yet it certainly ought to be repeated in a more accurate manner .
Before I conclude this paper , it may be proper to sum up the state of the argument on this subject .
There are five methods of phlogistication considered by me in my paper on air ; namely , first , the calcination of metals , either by themselves or when amalgamated with quicksilver ; secondly , the burning of sulphur or phosphorus ; thirdly , the mixture of nitrous air ; fourthly , the explosion of inflammable air ; and , fifthly , the electric spark ; and Mr. KIRWAN has not pointed out any other which he considers as unexceptionable .
Now the last of these I by no means consider as unexceptionable , as it seems much most likely , that the phlogistication of the air in that experiment is owing to the burning or calcination of some substance contained in the apparatus * .
It is true , that I have no proof of it ; but there is so much probability in the opinion , that till it is proved to be erroneous , no conclusion can be drawn from such experiments in favour of the generation of fixed air .
As to the first method , or the calcination of metals , there is not the least proof that any fixed air is generated , though we certainly have no direct proof of the contrary ; nor did I in my paper insinuate that we had .
The same thing may be said of the burning of sulphur and phosphorus .
As to the mixture of nitrous air , and the combustion of inflammable air , it is proved , that if any fixed air is generated , it is so small as to elude the nicest test we have .
It is certain too , that if it had been so much as 1/ 70th of the bulk of the common air employed , it would have been perceived in the first of these methods , and would have been sensible in the second though still less .
So that out of the five methods enumerated , it has been shown , that in two no sensible quantity is generated , and not the least proof has been assigned that any is in two of the * In the experiment with the litmus I attribute the fixed air to the burning of the litmus , not decomposition , as Mr. KIRWAN represents it , which is a sufficient reason why no fixed air should be found when the experiment is tried with air in which bodies will not burn .
others ; and as to the last , good reasons have been assigned for thinking it inconclusive ; and therefore the conclusion drawn by me in the above-mentioned paper seems sufficiently justified ; namely , that though it is not impossible that fixed air may be generated in some chemical processes , yet it seems certain , that it is not the general effect of phlogisticating air , and that the diminution of common air by phlogistication is by no means owing to the generation or separation of fixed air from it .

