XIV .
Remarks on Mr. Cavendish 's Experiments on Air .
In a Letter from Richard Kirwan , Esq. F. R. S. to Sir Joseph Banks , Bart. P. R. S. Read Feb. 5 , 1784 .
SIR , HAVING listened with much attention , and derived much useful information from the very curious experiments of Mr. CAVENDISH , read at our last meeting , it is with peculiar regret I feel myself withheld from yielding an entire assent to all he has advanced in his very ingenious paper ; and it is with still greater that I find myself obliged , by reason of the opposition of some of his deductions to those I had the honour to lay before the society about two years ago , to expose the reasons of my dissent , through you mediation , before this meeting .
In the paper already mentioned , read in April , 1782 , I attributed the diminution of respirable air , observed in common phlogistic processes , to the generation and absorption of fixed air , which is now known to be an acid , and capable of being absorbed by several substances .
That fixed air was some how or other produced in phlogistic processes , either by separation or composition , I took for granted from the numerous experiments of Dr. PRIESTLEY ; and among these I selected , as least liable to objection , the Calcination of Metals , the decomposi5 tion tion of nitrous by mixture with respirable air , the phlogistication of respirable air by the electric spark , and , lastly , that effected by amalgamation .
In each of these instances Mr. CAVENDISH is of opinion , that the diminution of respirable air is owing to the production of water , which , according to him , is formed by the union of the phlogiston , disengaged in those processes , with the dephlogisticated part of common air ; and that fixed air is never produced in phlogistic processes , except some animal or vegetable substance is concerned in the operation , from whose decomposition it may arise .
To which of these causes the diminution of respirable air is to be attributed , I shall now endeavour to elucidate .
Of the Calcination of Metals .
I attributed the diminution of air by the calcination of metals , to the conversion of the dephlogisticated part of common air into fixed air , by reason of its union with the phlogiston of the metal , for this plain reason , because I find it acknowledged on all hands , that the calces of all the base metals yield fixed air , when sufficiently heated .
Mr. Cavendish allows the fact in general , but ascribes the fixed air found in them to their long exposure to the atmosphere , in which he says fixed air pre-exists ; but that it exists in common air in any quantity worth attending to , or is extracted from it in any degree , I take the liberty of denying , grounded on the following facts .
First , I have frequently agitated 18 cubic inches of common air in 2 of lime-water , and 2 of common air in 18 of lime-water , but could never perceive the slightest milkiness ; and yet the thousandth part of a cubic inch of fixed air would thus be made sensible ; for if a cubic inch of it be dissolved in 3 ounces of water , a few drops of that water let into lime-water will produce a cloud .
Mr. FONTANA says , he frequently agitated 1 cubic inch of Tincture of Turnsole in 7 or 800 of common air , without reddening it ( 23 Roz .
p. 188 .
) ; and yet , according to Mr. BERGMAN , 1 cubic inch of fixed air is sufficient to redden 50 of Tincture of Turnsole ( 1 BERGM .
11 .
) ; from whence I am apt to think , that 700 cubic inches of common air do not even contain 1/ 50th of a cubic inch of fixed air .
Dr. WHYTT found that 12 ounces of strong lime-water , being exposed to the open air for 19 days , still retained about 1 grain of lime , ( on Limewater , p. 32 .
) .
Now 12 ounces of strong lime-water contain at most 9,5 grains of lime , and 1 grain of lime requires only 0,56 of a cubic inch of fixed air to precipitate it , the thermometer at 55 and the barometer at 29,5 , as I have found .
Therefore in 19 days this lime-water did not come in contact with more than four cubic inches of fixed air ; yet it is certain that a large quantity of fixed air is continually disengaged , and thrown into the atmosphere , by various processes , as putrefaction , combustion , &amp;c. but it seems equally certain that it is either decomposed , or more probably absorbed by various bodies .
Mr. FONTANA let loose 20000 cubic inches of fixed air , in a room whose windows and doors were closed , yet in half an hour after he could not discover the least trace of it ( ibid. ) .
Though fixed air perpetually oozes from the floor of the Grotto del Cane , yet at the distance of four or five feet from the ground none is found ; animals may live , lights burn , &amp;c. ( Roz .
Ibid. Mem. Stockh .
1775 .
) .
If distilled water be exposed to the atmosphere , it is never found to absorb fixed air , but rather dephlogisticated air , according to Mr. SCHEELE'S experiments , which could never happen if the atmosphere contained any sensible proportion of fixed air ; nor has rain-water been ever found to contain any , which it certainly should on the same hypothesis ; even Mr. CAVENDISH himself could find no fixed air in the residuum or products of about 1040 ounce measures of common air , which he burnt with inflammable air .
It is true , Dr. PRIESTLEY supposed common air to contain 1/ 55 of its bulk of fixed air ; but he drew this conclusion not from any direct experiment , but from the quantity of fixed air produced by breathing , which he at that time believed to have been barely precipitated , and not generated , an opinion which he has found reason to alter from his own experiments .
I think I may therefore conclude , that the quantity of fixed air contained in the atmosphere is absolutely inappreciable .
Secondly , supposing the atmosphere to contain a very small proportion of fixed air , yet I do not think it can be inferred that metals , during their calcination , extract any , because I find that lime exposed to red heat ever so long extracts none , though it is formed by a calcination in open air , which lasts at least as long as that of any metal ; neither does precipitate per se attract any , though its calcination lasts several months ; nor does this proceed from the want of affinity , for if a saturate solution of mercury in any of the acids be precipitated by a mild vegetable alkali , very little effervescence is perceived , and the precipitate weighs much more than the quantity of mercury employed , and that this increase of weight arises in part from the fixed air absorbed will presently be seen .
Since then metals may be calcined in close vessels , since they then absorb one fourth part of the common air to which they are exposed , since all metallic calces ( except those of mercury , which I shall presently mention ) yield fixed air , since common air contains scarce any fixed air ; is it not apparent that the fixed air thus found was generated by the very act of calcination , by the union of the phlogiston of the metal with the dephlogisticated part of the common air , since after the operation the metal is deprived of its phlogiston , and the air of its dephlogisticated part ?
But Mr. CAVENDISH objects , that no one has extracted fixed air from metals calcined in close vessels .
To which I answer , that this further proof is difficult , and no way necessary ; it is difficult , because the operation can easily be performed only on small quantities ; it is unnecessary , because it differs from the operation in open air only by the quantities of the materials employed , in every other respect it is exactly the same .
Since Mr. CAVENDISH suspects the results are different , it is incumbent on him to show that difference ; but until then , according to Sir ISAAC NEWTON'S second rule , to natural effects of the same kind the same causes are to be assigned , as far as it may be done , that is , until experience points out some other cause .
It may further be urged , that precipitate per se yields only dephlogisticated air , that minimum also yields a large proportion of it .
This difficulty I have formerly answered by asserting , that these calces are in fact united only to fixed air , and that they yield dephlogisticated air , merely because the fixed air is decomposed by the total or partial revivification of the metallic substances ; this I think may be demonstrated by the following experiments .
Let sublimate corrosive singly be treated in any manner , it will not yield dephlogisticated air ( 4 Pr .
240 .
) ; but let a solution of sublimate corrosive be precipitated by a mild fixed alkali , this precipitate washed , dried , and distilled in a pneumatic apparatus , will yield dephlogisticated air , and the mercury will be revived ; but , if the solution of sublimate corrosive be precipitated by lime-water , it seems no air will be produced .
Here then we see , 1st , that the calx of mercury unites with fixed air ; and , 2dly , that this fixed air is , during the revivification of the mercury , converted into dephlogisticated air .
Again : let one ounce of red precipitate , which , according to Mr. CAVENDISH , contains no nitrous acid , be distilled with two ounces of filings of iron ; this quantity of precipitate , which , if distilled by itself , would yield 60 ounce measures of dephlogisticated air , will , when distilled with this proportion of filings of iron , yield 40 ounce measures of fixed air , as Dr. PRIESTLEY has shown in his last paper : whichever way this is explained , some or other of my opinions are confirmed ; for either the mercurial calx is already combined with fixed air ( which I believe to be the case ) , and this air passes undecomposed , because the mercury extracts phlogiston from the iron ; or it contains dephlogisticated air , which is converted into fixed air by its union with the phlogiston of the iron .
If precipitate per se be digested in marine acid , the mercury will be revived ( 3 BERGM .
415 .
) .
Now this calx does not dephlogisticate the marine acid ; for this acid , when dephlogisticated , dissolves mercury ; how then does it revive it , if not by expelling the fixed air contained in it , which in the moment of its expulsion is decomposed , leaving its phlogiston to the mercury , which is thereby revived ?
Again : if litharge be heated in a gun-barrel , it will afford more fixed and less dephlogisticated air than if heated in glass or earthen vessels .
Does not this happen , because the calx of lead , receiving some phlogiston from the metal , does not dephlogisticate so great a proportion of the fixed air as it otherwise would ?
Further : there is no substance which yields dephlogisticated air , but yields also fixed air , even precipitate per se not excepted ; ( 3 PRIEST .
16 .
) and what is remarkable , they all yield fixed air first , and dephlogisticated air only towards the end of the process .
Does not this happen because metallic calces attract phlogiston so much more strongly , as they are more heated ?
Thus many calciform iron ores become magnetic by calcination , though they were not so before ; so also do all the calces of iron when exposed to the focus of a burning glass ( 5 Dict .
Chy .
179 ) .
Thus mercury cannot be calcined but in a heat inferior to that in which it boils ; thus minimum cannot be formed but in a moderate heat , and if heated still more it returns to the state of massicot , in which it was before it became minimum , and much of it is reduced .
So if a solution of luna cornea in volatile alkali be triturated with mercury , the silver will be revived , and the marine acid unite to the mercury , which shows this acid has a stronger attraction to Mercury than to silver ; yet if sublimate corrosive and silver be distilled in a strong heat , the mercury will be revived , and the marine acid unite to the silver , which shows that the attraction of mercury to phlogiston increases with the heat applied .
Before I conclude this head , I will mention another experiment , which I think decisive in favour of my opinion of the composition of fixed air .
If filings of zinc be digested in a caustic fixed alkali in a gentle heat , the zinc will be dissolved with effervescence , and the alkali will be rendered in great measure mild .
But if , instead of filings of zinc , flowers of zinc be used , and treated in the same manner , there will be no solution , and the alkali will remain caustic .
In the first case the effervescence arises from the production of inflammable air , which phlogisticates the common air contiguous to it , and produces fixed air , which is immediately absorbed by the alkali , and renders it mild .
In the second case , no inflammable air is produced , the common air is not phlogisticated , and consequently the alkali remains caustic * .
This experiment also proves that metallic calces attract fixed air more strongly than alkalies attract it ; for the calces of zinc are known to contain fixed air , and yet alkalies digested with them remain caustic ; and this accounts for the slight turbidity of lime-water when metals are calcined over it ; for as soon as the phlogiston is disengaged from the metal , and before it has absorbed the whole quantity of fire requisite to throw it into the form of inflammable air , it meets with the dephlogisticated part of the common air on the surface of the metal , and there forms fixed air , which is instantly absorbed by the calx with which it is in contact , so that it is not to be wondered that it does not unite to the lime from which it is distant .
Of the Decomposition of Nitrous Air by mixture with Common Air .
AS soon as I had heard Mr. CAVENDISH'S paper read , I set about trying whether lime would be precipitated from limewater during the process , an experiment I had never made before with common air , taking it for granted that it was so , from the repeated experiments of Dr. PRIESTLEY , and indeed of all others who had treated this subject ~ : and , in effect , * See Mr. LASSONE'S Experiments on zinc .
Mem. Par. 1777 .
p. 7 &amp; 8 .
~ See 1 Pr .
114 .
189 .
2 Pr .
218 .
Font .
Recherches Phys. p. 77 .
1 Chy .
Dij .
324 .
when I made the experiment with nitrous air prepared and confined by the water of my tub , I found lime-water admitted to it instantly precipitated .
But after I had read Mr. CAVENDISH'S paper , which he had the politeness to permit me , and had , according to his direction , received the nitrous air over lime-water , I did not then perceive the least milkiness after admitting common air .
After 12 hours I indeed perceived a whitish dust , on the bottom of the glass vessel in which I made the experiment , which I cannot assure to be calcareous ; and , on breathing into the lime-water , an evident milkiness ensued ; so that I little doubt but the precipitation I observed in the first experiment arose from the decomposition of the aerial selenite contained in the water of the tub .
And it is very possible that the precipitation of lime , which I perceived some years ago on mixing dephlogisticated air and nitrous air , might have arisen from the same cause , or from fixed air pre-contained in the dephlogisticated , as this last had not been washed in lime-water .
Yet I do not think the failure of this experiment at all conclusive against the supposed production of fixed air on this occasion , because the quantity of fixed air is so small , that it may well be supposed to unite to the nitrous selenite formed in the limewater .
It is well known that a small quantity of fixed air is capable of uniting to all neutral salts : thus Dr. PRIESTLEY has extracted it from tartar vitriolate and alum , ( 2 PR .
115 , 116 .
) and gypsum , ( 2 PR .
80 .
) ; and Dr. MAC BRIDE found it in nitre and common salt , though in small quantity .
But to try whether nitrous selenite would attract any , I made a solution of chalk in nitrous acid , which , when saturate , weighed 381,25 grains ; but , being exposed to the air for a few hours , it weighed 382,25 .
I afterwards took a very dilute nitrous acid , in which an acid taste was barely perceptible , and impregnated it with a very small proportion portion of fixed air , and then let fall a few drops of it into limewater ; not the smallest cloud was perceived , and yet when I breathed into it afterwards it became milky in a few seconds ; so that this experiment is perfectly analogous to that in which nitrous and common air were mixed .
But if nitrous air and common air be mixed over dry mercury , the result is entirely adverse to the opinion of Mr. CAVENDISH , and favourable to mine ; for in this case the common air is not at all diminished until water is admitted to it , and the mixture agitated a few minutes , and then the diminution is nearly the same as if the mixture were made over water .
Thus when I mixed two cubic inches of common air with one of nitrous air , they occupied the space of two inches and oneeighth , and the surface of the mercury was immediately calcined ; which shows that the inch of nitrous air was decomposed , and produced nitrous acid ; but the common air was undiminished ; and the one eighth of an inch over and above the two inches of common air , proceeded from an addition of new nitrous air , formed by the corrosion of the surface of the mercury .
That the common air should remain undiminished is easily explained in my system , because fixed air is formed , which , on this occasion , must remain unabsorbed , at least for a long time , as there is nothing at hand that can immediately receive it ; and hence , if water be admitted soon after the mixture of both airs , the diminution will be nearly the same as if the mixture had been originally made over water , though not exactly the same ; because the nitrous air , produced by the union of the newly formed nitrous acid with the mercury , is not entirely absorbable by water .
But , in Mr. CAVENDISH'S hypothesis , the common air should be diminished just as much as if the mixture were made over water ; for , according to him , this diminution arises from the conversion of the dephlogisticated part of the common air into water , which water should immediately unite to the nitrous salt of mercury , and leave the common air lessened in its bulk by a portion commensurate to that converted into water , or , if he will not allow the water to have immediately united to the mercurial salt , at least by the difference of the bulk of the water produced , and that of an equal weight of the common air converted into it : but neither happens ; for the common air is not at all diminished ; not can he explain , consistently with his system , why the admission of water should immediately produce a diminution in the common air , as , according to him , it contains nothing that can be absorbed .
Dr. PRIESTLEY has remarked , that if a mixture of both airs be suffered to stand several hours , even the admission of water will produce no diminution .
This is owing to two causes ; 1st , because a large quantity of nitrous air is produced , by the continued action of the concentrated nitrous acid newly formed ; and , 2dly , because the fixed air , on whose absorption the diminution depends , is absorbed by the mercurial salt , as may be inferred from the experiment in 1 LAVOISIER , p. 248 .
Of the Diminution of Common Air by the Electric Spark .
Of all the instances of the artificial production of fixed air , by the union of phlogiston with the dephlogisticated part of common air , there is none perhaps so convincing , as that exhibited by taking the electric spark through common air , over a solution of litmus , or lime-water ; for the common air is diminished one fourth , the litmus reddened , and the lime-water precipitated .
Mr. CAVENDISH indeed attributes the redness of the litmus to fixed air ; but he thinks it proceeds from a decomposition of some part of the vegetable juice , as all vegetable juices contain fixed air .
Yet that such a decomposition does not take place , I think may be inferred from the following reasons : first , if the electric spark be taken through phlogisticated or inflammable air confined by litmus , no redness is produced , the air not being in the least diminished ; and , 2dly , if the litmus were decomposed , inflammable air should be produced as well as fixed air ; and then there should be an addition of bulk instead of a diminution ; but what sets the origin of the fixed air from the phlogistication of the common air beyond all doubt is , that if lime-water be used instead of litmus , the diminution is the same , and the lime is precipitated .
Here Mr. CAVENDISH says , the fixed air proceeds either from some dirt in the tube ; a supposition , which , being neither necessary nor probable , is not admissible ; or else from some combustible matter in the lime ; but lime contains no combustible matter , except perhaps phlogiston , which cannot produce fixed air but by uniting to the common air , according to my supposition ; but it is much more probable , that the diminution does not arise from any phlogiston in the lime , as it is exactly the same whether lime-water be used or not ; and the lime does not appear to be in the least altered , and in fact contains scarce any phlogiston .
Of the diminution of Common Air , by the Amalgamation of Mercury and Lead .
I attributed this diminution to the phlogistication of the common air by the process of amalgamation , and the consequent production and absorption of fixed air .
On this Mr. CAVENDISH VENDISH observes , ` ` that mercury , fouled by the addition of lead or tin , deposits a powder which consists in great measure of the calx of the metal : he found also , that some powder of this sort contained fixed air ; but it is not clear that this air was produced by the phlogistication of the air in which the mercury was shaken , as the powder was not prepared on purpose , but was formed from mercury fouled by having been used for various purposes , and may therefore contain other impurities , besides the metallic calx .
' ' On this I remark , that Dr. PRIESTLEY did not indeed at first prepare this powder on purpose ; but he afterwards did so prepare it ( 4 PRIEST .
p. 148 , 149 .
) and obtained a powder exactly of the same sort ; and it is certain that the fixed air found in it proceeded from the common air , both because metallic calces , not formed by amalgamation , will not unite with mercury , as is well known ; and because this calx cannot be formed by agitation of the mercury and lead , in phlogisticated , inflammable , or any other air which is not respirable ; and the fixed air cannot proceed from any impurity , as mercury will not unite in its running form to any other but metallic substances , which it always partially dephlogisticates , like other menstruums ( 3 Chy .
Dijon , 425 .
) .
Of the Diminution of Respirable Air by Combustion .
Though I have no doubt but the diminution of respirable air , by the combustion of sulphur and phosphorus , proceeds also in great measure from the production and absorption of fixed air , yet I avoided mentioning this operation , as the presence of a stronger acid renders the presence of a weaker impossible to be proved , more especially , as both these acids precipitate lime from lime-water ; but the great increase of weight which the phosphoric acid gains is a strong additional inducement to think that it absorbs fixed air .
During the combustion of vegetable substances , I think it highly probable that fixed air is formed , both from my own experiments on the combustion of wax candles , and that mentioned in the first volume of Dr. PRIESTLEY'S Observations , p. 136 ; but when inflammable air from metals and dephlogisticated air are fired , as a great diminution takes place , and yet no fixed air is found , I am nearly convinced , by Mr. CAVENDISH'S experiments , that water is really produced ; nor am I surprised that , in this instance , the union of phlogiston and dephlogisticated air should form a compound very different from that which it forms in other instances of phlogistication , but should rather be led to expect it a priori ; for in this case the phlogiston is in its most rarefied known state , and unites to dephlogisticated air , the substance to which it has the greatest affinity , in circumstances the most favourable to the closest and most intimate union ; for both , in the act of inflammation , are rarefied to the highest degree ; both give out their specific fire , the great obstacle to their union , it being by the inflammation converted into sensible heat ( a circumstance which , in my opinion , constitutes the very essence of flame ) ; the resulting compound having then lost the greatest part of its specific fire , is necessarily reduced , according to Dr. BLACK'S theory , into a denser state , which the present experiment shows to be water ; whereas , in common cases of combustion , the phlogiston being denser and less divided , unites less intimately with the dephlogisticated part of common air , consequently expels less of its specific fire , and therefore forms less dense compounds , viz. fixed and phlogisticated airs ; and so much the more , as a great part entirely escapes combustion ; but it seems probable that in very strong and bright inflammations , the union is more perfect , and water formed .
Water being then the result of the closest and most intimate union of dephlogisticated air and phlogiston , it seems to me very improbable , that it is ever decomposed by the affinity of any acid to phlogiston , as all the experiments hitherto made seem to prove , that phlogiston has a stronger affinity to dephlogisticated air than to any other substance , except hot metallic calces ; and these , in my opinion , are incapable of forming any union with water , except as far as they are saline , but they never can be reduced by it .
So also water is incapable of uniting with any more phlogiston , as sulphur is , both being already saturated .
Mr. CAVENDISH is inclined to think , that pure inflammable air is not pure phlogiston , because it does not immediately unite with dephlogisticated air , when both airs are simply mixed with each other ; this reason seems to me of no moment , because I see several other substances , that have the strongest affinity to each other , refuse to unite suddenly , or even at all , through the very same cause that dephlogisticated and inflammable airs refuse to unite ; viz. on account of the specific fire which they contain , and must lose , before such union can take place : thus fixed air will never unite to dry lime , though they be kept ever so long together ; thus , if water be poured on the strongest oil of vitriol , they will remain several weeks in contact , without uniting , as I myself have experienced ; and yet , in both cases , the specific fire need be expelled only from one of the substances , and not from both : but after a long time they will unite ; so also will inflammable and dephlogisticated air , as Dr. PRIESTLEY has discovered since his last publication .
That phlogisticated air should consist of supersaturated nitrous air , I think improbable , as it retains its phlogiston much more strongly than nitrous air , which , according to the general laws of affinities , it should not , if it contained an excess of phlogiston ; and as Dr. PRIESTLEY and Mr. FONTANA repeatedly assure us , they have converted it into common air , by washing it in water , in contact with the atmosphere .
I am , &amp;c. R. KIRWAN .
London , Jan. 29 , 1784 .

