XIII .
Experiments on Air .
By Henry Cavendish , Esq. F. R. S. &amp; S. A. Read Jan. 15 , 1784 .
THE following experiments were made principally with a view to find out the cause of the diminution which common air is well known to suffer by all the various ways in which it is phlogisticated , and to discover what becomes of the air thus lost or condensed ; and as they seem not only to determine this point , but also to throw great light on the constitution and manner of production of dephlogisticated air , I hope they may be not unworthy the acceptance of this society .
Many gentlemen have supposed that fixed air is either generated or separated from atmospheric air by phlogistication , and that the observed diminution is owing to this cause ; my first experiments therefore were made in order to ascertain whether any fixed air is really produced thereby .
Now , it must be observed , that as all animal and vegetable substances contain fixed air , and yield it by burning , distillation , or putrefaction , nothing can be concluded from experiments in which the air is phlogisticated by them .
The only methods I know , which are not liable to objection , are by the calcination of metals , the burning of sulphur or phosphorus , the mixture of nitrous air , and the explosion of inflammable air .
Perhaps it may be supposed , that I ought to add to these the electric spark ; but I think it much most likely , that the phlogistication of the air , and production of fixed air , in this process , is owing to the burning of some inflammable matter in the apparatus .
When the spark is taken from a solution of tournsol , the burning of the tournsol may produce this effect ; when it is taken from limewater , the burning of some foulness adhering to the tube , or perhaps of some inflammable matter contained in the lime , may have the same effect ; and when quicksilver or metallic knobs are used , the calcination of them may contribute to the phlogistication of the air , though not to the production of fixed air .
There is no reason to think that any fixed air is produced by the first method of phlogistication .
Dr. PRIESTLEY never found lime-water to become turbid by the calcination of metals over it * : Mr. LAVOISIER also found only a very slight and scarce perceptible turbid appearance , without any precipitation , to take place when lime-water was shaken in a glass vessel full of the air in which lead had been calcined ; and even this small diminution of transparency in the lime-water might very likely arise , not from fixed air , but only from its being fouled by particles of the calcined metal , which we are told adhered in some places to the glass .
This want of turbidity has been attributed to the fixed air uniting to the metallic calx , in preference to the lime ; but there is no reason for supposing that the calx contained any fixed air ; for I do not know that any one has extracted it from calces prepared in this manner ; and though most metallic calces prepared over the fire , or by long exposure to the atmosphere , where they are in contact with fixed air , contain that substance , it by no means follows that they must * Experiments on Air , vol. I. p. 137 .
do so when prepared by methods in which they are not in contact with it .
Dr. PRIESTLEY also observed , that quicksilver , fouled by the addition of lead or tin , deposits a powder by agitation and exposure to the air , which consists in great measure of the calx of the imperfect metal .
He found too some powder of this kind to contain fixed air * ; but it is by no means clear that this air was produced by the phlogistication of the air in which the quicksilver was shaken ; as the powder was not prepared on purpose , but was procured from quicksilver fouled by having been used in various experiments , and may therefore have contained other impurities besides the metallic calces .
I never heard of any fixed air being produced by the burning of sulphur or phosphorus ; but it has been asserted , and commonly believed , that lime water is rendered cloudy by a mixture of common and nitrous air ; which , if true , would be a convincing proof that on mixing those two substances some fixed air is either generated or separated ; I therefore examined this carefully .
Now it must be observed , that as common air usually contains a little fixed air , which is no essential part of it , but is easily separated by lime water ; and as nitrous air may also contain fixed air , either if the metal from which it is procured be rusty , or if the water of the vessel in which it is caught contain calcareous earth , suspended by fixed air , as most waters do , it is proper first to free both airs from it by previously washing them with lime water ~ .
Now I found , by repeated * Exper .
in Not .
Phil. vol. I. p. 144 .
~ Though fixed air is absorbed in considerable quantity by water , as I showed in Phil. Trans. vol. LVI .
yet it is not easy to deprive common air of all the fixed ed experiments , that if the lime water was clean , and the two airs were previously washed with that substance , not the least cloud was produced , either immediately on mixing them , or on suffering them to stand upwards of an hour , though it appeared by the thick clouds which were produced in the lime water , by breathing through it after the experiment was finished , that it was more than sufficient to saturate the acid formed by the decomposition of the nitrous air , and consequently that if any fixed air had been produced , it must have become visible .
Once indeed I found a small cloud to be formed on the surface , after the mixture had stood a few minutes .
In this experiment the lime water was not quite clean ; but whether the cloud was owing to this circumstance , or to the air 's having not been properly washed , I cannot pretend to say .
Neither does any fixed air seem to be produced by the explosion of the inflammable air obtained from metals , with either common or dephlogisticated air .
This I tried by putting a little lime-water into a glass globe fitted with a brass cock , so as to make it air tight , and an apparatus for firing air by electricity .
This globe was exhausted by an air-pump , and the two airs , which had been previously washed with lime-water , let in , and suffered to remain some time , to show whether they would affect the lime-water , and then fired by electricity .
The event was , that not the least cloud was produced in the lime-water , when the inflammable air was mixed with common air , and air contained in it by means of water .
On shaking a mixture of ten parts of common air , and one of fixed air , with more than an equal bulk of distilled water , not more than half of the fixed air was absorbed , and on transferring the air into fresh distilled water only half the remainder was absorbed , as appeared by the diminution which it still suffered on adding lime water .
only a very slight one , or rather diminution of transparency , when it was combined with dephlogisticated air .
This , however , seemed not to be produced by fixed air ; as it appeared instantly after the explosion , and did not increase on standing , and was spread uniformly through the liquor ; whereas if it had been owing to fixed air , it would have taken up some short time before it appeared , and would have begun first at the surface , as was the case in the abovementioned experiment with nitrous air .
What it was really owing to I cannot pretend to say ; but if it did proceed from fixed air it would show that only an excessively minute quantity was produced * .
On the whole , though it is not improbable that fixed air may be generated in some chemical processes , yet it seems certain that it is not the general effect of phlogisticating air , and that the diminution of common air is by no means owing to the generation or separation of fixed air from it .
As there seemed great reason to think , from Dr. Priestley 's experiments , that the nitrous and vitriolic acids were convertible into dephlogisticated air , I tried whether the dephlogisticated part of common air might not , by phlogistication , be changed into nitrous or vitriolic acid .
For this purpose I impregnated some milk of lime with the sumes of burning sulphur , by putting a little of it into a large glass receiver , and burning sulphur therein , taking care to keep the mouth of the receiver stopped till the sumes were all absorbed ; after which the air of the receiver was changed , and more sulphur burnt in it as before , and the process repeated till 122 grains of sulphur were consumed .
The milk of lime was then filtered and evaporated , but it yielded no nitrous salt , nor any other substance except sele nite ; so that no sensible quantity of the air was changed * Dr. PRIESTLEY also found no fixed air to be produced by the explosion of in flammable and common air .
Vol. V. p. 124 .
into nitrous acid .
It must be observed , that as the vitriolic acid produced by the burning sulphur is changed by its union with the lime into selenite , which is very little soluble in water , a very small quantity of nitrous salt , or any other substance which is soluble in water , would have been perceived .
I also tried whether any nitrous acid was produced by phlogisticating common air with liver of sulphur ; for this purpose I made a solution of flowers of sulphur by boiling it with lime , and put a little of it into a large receiver , and shook it frequently , changing now and then the air , till the yellow colour of the solution was quite gone ; a sign that all the sulphur was , by the loss of its phlogiston , turned into vitriolic acid , and united to the lime , or precipitated ; the liquor was then filtered and evaporated , but it yielded not the least nitrous salt .
The experiment was repeated in nearly the same manner with dephlogisticated air procured from red precipitate ; but not the least nitrous acid was obtained .
It is well known that common selenite is very little soluble in water ; whereas that procured in the two last experiments was very soluble , and even crystallized readily , and was intensely bitter ; this however appeared to be owing merely to the acid with which it was formed being very much phlogisticated ; for on evaporating it to dryness , and exposing it to the air for a few days , it became much less soluble , so that on adding water to it not much dissolved ; and by repeating this process once or twice , it seemed to become not more soluble than selenite made in the common manner .
This solubility of the selenite caused some trouble in trying the experiment ; for while it continued much soluble it would have been impossible to have distinguished a small mixture of nitrous salt ; but by the abovementioned process I was able to distinguish as small a proportion as if the selenite had been originally no more soluble than usual .
The nature of the neutral salts made with the phlogisticated vitriolic and nitrous acids has not been much examined by the chymists , though it seems well worth their attention ; and it is likely that many besides the foregoing may differ remarkably from those made with the same acids in their common state .
Nitre formed with the phlogisticated nitrous acid has been found to differ considerably from common nitre , as well as Sal Polychrest from vitriolated tartar .
In order to try whether any vitriolic acid was produced by the phlogistication of air , I impregnated fifty ounces of distilled water with the fumes produced on mixing fifty-two ounce measures of nitrous air with a quantity of common air sufficient to decompound it .
This was done by filling a bottle with some of this water , and inverting it into a bason of the same , and then , by a syphon , letting in as much nitrous air as filled it half-full ; after which common air was added slowly by the same syphon , till all the nitrous air was decompounded .
When this was done , the distilled water was further impregnated in the same manner till the whole of the abovementioned quantity of nitrous air was employed .
This impregnated water , which was very sensibly acid to the taste , was distilled in a glass retort .
The first runnings were very acid , and smelt pungent , being nitrous acid much phlogisticated ; what came next had no sensible taste or smell ; but the last runnings were very acid , and consisted of nitrous acid not phlogisticated .
Scarce any sediment was left behind .
These different parcels of distilled liquor were then exactly saturated with salt of tartar , and evaporated ; they yielded 871/ 2 grains of nitre , which , as far as I could perceive , was unmixed with vitriolated tartar or any other substance , and consequently no sensible quantity of the common air with which the nitrous air was mixed was turned into vitriolic acid .
It appears , from this experiment , that nitrous air contains as much acid as 23/ 4 times its weight of saltpetre ; for fifty-two ounce measures of nitrous air weigh 32 grains , and , as was before said , yield as much acid as is contained in 871/ 2 grains of saltpetre ; so that the acid in nitrous air is in a remarkably concentrated state , and I believe more than 11/ 2 times as much so as the strongest spirit of nitre ever prepared .
Having now mentioned the unsuccessful attempts I made to find out what becomes of the air lost by phlogistication , I proceed to some experiments , which serve really to explain the matter .
In Dr. PRIESTLEY'S last volume of experiments is related an experiment of Mr. WARLTIRE'S , in which it is said that , on firing a mixture of common and inflammable air by electricity in a close copper vessel holding about three pints , a loss of weight was always perceived , on an average about two grains , though the vessel was stopped in such a manner that no air could escape by the explosion .
It is also related , that on repeating the experiment in glass vessels , the inside of the glass , though clean and dry before , immediately became dewy ; which confirmed an opinion he had long entertained , that common air deposits its moisture by phlogistication .
As the latter experiment seemed likely to throw great light on the subject I had in view , I thought it well worth examining more closely .
The first experiment also , if there was no mistake in it , would be very extraordinary and curious ; but it did not succeed with me ; for though the vessel I used held more than Mr. WARLTIRE'S , namely , 24,000 grains of water , and though the experiment was was repeated several times with different proportions of common and inflammable air , I could never perceive a loss of weight of more than one-fifth of a grain , and commonly none at all .
It must be observed , however , that though there were some of the experiments in which it seemed to diminish a little in weight , there were none in which it increased * .
In all the experiments , the inside of the glass globe became dewy , as observed by Mr. WARLTIRE ; but not the least sooty matter could be perceived .
Care was taken in all of them to find how much the air was diminished by the explosion , and to observe its test .
The result is as follows : the bulk of the inflammable air being expressed in decimals of the common air , Common air .
Inflammable Diminution .
Air remainTest of this Standard .
air .
ing after the air in first explosion .
method .
1,241,686 1,555,055,0 1 1,055,642 1,413,063,0 ,706,647 1,059,066,0 ,423,612,811,097,03 ,331,476,855,339,27 ,206,294,912,648,58 In these experiments the inflammable air was procured from zinc , as it was in all my experiments , except where otherwise expressed : but I made two more experiments , to try whether there was any difference between the air from zinc and that from iron , the quantity of inflammable air being the same in both , namely .
0,331 of the common ; but I could not find any difference to be depended on between the two kinds of air , * Dr. PRIESTLEY , I am informed , has since found the experiment not to proceed .
either in the diminution which they suffered by the explosion , or the test of the burnt air .
From the fourth experiment it appears , that 423 measures of inflammable air are nearly sufficient to completely phlogisticate 1000 of common air ; and that the bulk of the air remaining after the explosion is then very little more than four-fifths of the common air employed ; so that as common air cannot be reduced to a much less bulk than that by any method of phlogistication , we may safely conclude , that when they are mixed in this proportion , and exploded , almost all the inflammable air , and about one-fifth part of the common air , lose their elasticity , and are condensed into the dew which lines the glass .
The better to examine the nature of this dew , 500000 grain measures of inflammable air were burnt with about 2 1/ 2 times that quantity of common air , and the burnt air made to pass through a glass cylinder eight feet long and three-quarters of an inch in diameter , in order to deposit the dew .
The two airs were conveyed slowly into this cylinder by separate copper pipes , passing through a brass plate which stopped up the end of the cylinder ; and as neither inflammable nor common air can burn by themselves , there was no danger of the flame spreading into the magazines from which they were conveyed .
Each of these magazines consisted of a large tin vessel , inverted into another vessel just big enough to receive it .
The inner vessel communicated with the copper pipe , and the air was forced out of it by pouring water into the outer vessel ; and in order that the quantity of common air expelled should be 2 1/ 2 times that of the inflammable , the water was let into the outer vessels by two holes in the bottom of the same tin pan , the hole which conveyed the water into that vessel in which the common air was confined being 2 1/ 2 times as big as the other .
In trying the experiment , the magazines being first filled with their respective airs , the glass cylinder was taken off , and water let , by the two holes , into the outer vessels , till the airs began to issue from the ends of the copper pipes ; they were then set on fire by a candle , and the cylinder put on again in its place .
By this means upwards of 135 grains of water were condensed in the cylinder , which had no taste nor smell , and which left no sensible sediment when evaporated to dryness ; neither did it yield any pungent smell during the evaporation ; in short , it seemed pure water .
In my first experiment , the cylinder near that part where the air was fired was a little tinged with sooty matter , but very slightly so ; and that little seemed to proceed from the putty with which the apparatus was luted , and which was heated by the flame ; for in another experiment , in which it was contrived so that the luting should not be much heated , scarce any sooty tinge could be perceived .
By the experiments with the globe it appeared , that when inflammable and common air are exploded in a proper proportion , almost all the inflammable air , and near one-fifth of the common air , lose their elasticity , and are condensed into dew .
And by this experiment it appears , that this dew is plain water , and consequently that almost all the inflammable air , and about one-fifth of the common air , are turned into pure water .
In order to examine the nature of the matter condensed on firing a mixture of dephlogisticated and inflammable air , I took a glass globe , holding 8800 grain measures , furnished with a brass cock and an apparatus for firing air by electricity .
This globe was well exhausted by an air-pump , and then filled with a mixture of inflammable and dephlogisticated air , by shutting the cock , fastening a bent glass tube to its mouth , and letting up the end of it into a glass jar inverted into water , and containing a mixture of 19500 grain measures of dephlogisticated air , and 37000 of inflammable ; so that , upon opening the cock , some of this mixed air rushed through the bent tube , and filled the globe * .
The cock was then shut , and the included air fired by electricity , by which means almost all of it lost its elasticity .
The cock was then again opened , so as to let in more of the same air , to supply the place of that destroyed by the explosion , which was again fired , and the operation continued till almost the whole of the mixture was let into the globe and exploded .
By this means , though the globe held not more than the sixth part of the mixture , almost the whole of it was exploded therein , without any fresh exhaustion of the globe .
As I was desirous to try the quantity and test of this burnt air , without letting any water into the globe , which would have prevented my examining the nature of the condensed matter , I took a larger globe , furnished also with a stop cock , exhausted it by an air-pump , and screwed it on upon the cock of the former globe ; upon which , by opening both cocks , the air rushed out of the smaller globe into the larger , till it became of equal density in both ; then , by shutting the cock of the larger globe , unscrewing it again from the former , and opening it under water , I was enabled to find the quantity of the burnt air in it ; and consequently , as the proportion which the contents of the two globes bore to each other was * In order to prevent any water from getting into this tube , while dipped under water to let it up into the glass jar , a bit of wax was was stuck upon the end of it , which was rubbed off when raised above the surface of the water .
known , could tell the quantity of burnt air in the small globe before the communication was made between them .
By this means the whole quantity of the burnt air was found to be 2950 grain measures ; its standard was 1,85 .
The liquor condensed in the globe , in weight about 30 grains , was sensibly acid to the taste , and by saturation with fixed alkali , and evaporation , yielded near two grains of nitre ; so that it consisted of water united to a small quantity of nitrous acid .
No sooty matter was deposited in the globe .
The dephlogisticated air used in this experiment was procured from red precipitate , that is , from a solution of quicksilver in spirit of nitre distilled till it acquires a red colour .
As it was suspected , that the acid contained in the condensed liquor was no essential part of the dephlogisticated air , but was owing to some acid vapour which came over in making it and had not been absorbed by the water , the experiment was repeated in the same manner , with some more of the same air , which had been previously washed with water , by keeping it a day or two in a bottle with some water , and shaking it frequently ; whereas that used in the preceding experiment had never passed through water , except in preparing it .
The condensed liquor was still acid .
The experiment was also repeated with dephlogisticated air , procured from red lead by means of oil of vitriol ; the liquor condensed was acid , but by an accident I was prevented from determining the nature of the acid .
I also procured some dephlogisticated air from the leaves of plants , in the manner of Doctors INGENHOUSZ and PRIESTLEY , and exploded it with inflammable air as before ; the condensed liquor still continued acid , and of the nitrous kind .
In all these experiments the proportion of inflammable air was such , that the burnt air was not much phlogisticated ; and it was observed , that the less phlogisticated it was , the more acid was the condensed liquor .
I therefore made another experiment , with some more of the same air from plants , in which the proportion of inflammable air was greater , so that the burnt air was almost completely phlogisticated , its standard being 1/ 10 .
The condensed liquor was then not at all acid , but seemed pure water : so that it appears , that with this kind of dephlogisticated air , the condensed liquor is not at all acid , when the two airs are mixed in such a proportion that the burnt air is almost completely phlogisticated , but is considerably so when it is not much phlogisticated .
In order to see whether the same thing would obtain with air procured from red precipitate , I made two more experiments with that kind of air , the air in both being taken from the same bottle , and the experiment tried in the same manner , except that the proportions of inflammable air were different .
In the first , in which the burnt air was almost completely phlogisticated , the condensed liquor was not at all acid .
In the second , in which its standard was 1,86 , that is , not much phlogisticated , it was considerably acid ; so that with this air , as well as with that from plants , the condensed liquor contains , or is entirely free from , acid , according as the burnt air is less or more phlogisticated ; and there can be little doubt but that the same rule obtains with any other kind of dephlogisticated air .
In order to see whether the acid , formed by the explosion of dephlogisticated air obtained by means of the vitriolic acid , would also be of the nitrous kind , I procured some air from turbith mineral , and exploded it with inflammable air , the proportion being such that the burnt air was not much phlogisticated .
The condensed liquor manifested an acidity , which appeared , by saturation with a solution of salt of tartar , to be of the nitrous kind ; and it was found , by the addition of some terra ponderosa salita , to contain little or no vitriolic acid .
When inflammable air was exploded with common air , in such a proportion that the standard of the burnt air was about 4/ 10 , the condensed liquor was not in the least acid .
There is no difference , however , in this respect between common air , and dephlogisticated air mixed with phlogisticated in such a proportion as to reduce it to the standard of common air ; for some dephlogisticated air from red precipitate , being reduced to this standard by the addition of perfectly phlogisticated air , and then exploded with the same proportion of inflammable air as the common air was in the foregoing experiment , the condensed liquor was not in the least acid .
From the foregoing experiments it appears , that when a mixture of inflammable and dephlogisticated air is exploded in such proportion that the burnt air is not much phlogisticated , the condensed liquor contains a little acid , which is always of the nitrous kind , whatever substance the dephlogisticated air is procured from ; but if the proportion be such that the burnt air is almost entirely phlogisticated , the condensed liquor is not at all acid , but seems pure water , without any addition whatever ; and as , when they are mixed in that proportion , very little air remains after the explosion , almost the whole being condensed , it follows , that almost the whole of the inflammable and dephlogisticated air is converted into pure water .
It is not easy , indeed , to determine from these experiments what proportion the burnt air , remaining after the explosions , bore to the dephlogisticated air employed , as neither the small nor the large globe could be perfectly exhausted of air , and there was no saying with exactness what quantity was left in them ; but in most of them , after allowing for this uncertainty , the true quantity of burnt air seemed not more than 1/ 17th of the dephlogisticated air employed , or 1/ 0th of the mixture .
It seems , however , unnecessary to determine this point exactly , as the quantity is so small , that there can be little doubt but that it proceeds only from the impurities mixed with the dephlogisticated and inflammable air , and consequently that , if those airs could be obtained perfectly pure , the whole would be condensed .
With respect to common air , and dephlogisticated air reduced by the addition of phlogisticated air to the standard of common air , the case is different ; as the liquor condensed in exploding them with inflammable air , I believe I may say in any proportion , is not at all acid ; perhaps , because if they are mixed in such a proportion as that the burnt air is not much phlogisticated , the explosion is too weak , and not accompanied with sufficient heat .
All the foregoing experiments , on the explosion of inflammable air with common and dephlogisticated airs , except those which relate to the cause of the acid found in the water , were made in the summer of the year 1781 , and were mentioned by me to Dr. PRIESTLEY , who in consequence of it made some experiments of the same kind , as he relates in a paper printed in the preceding volume of the Transactions .
During the last summer also , a friend of mine gave some account of them to M. LAVOISIER , as well as of the conclusion drawn from them , that dephlogisticated air is only water deprived of phlogiston ; but at that time so far was M. LAVOISIER from thinking any such opinion warranted , that , till he was pre5 veiled veiled upon to repeat the experiment himself , he found some difficulty in believing that nearly the whole of the two airs could be converted into water .
It is remarkable , that neither of these gentlemen found any acid in the water produced by the combustion ; which might proceed from the latter having burnt the two airs in a different manner from what I did ; and from the former having used a different kind of inflammable air , namely , that from charcoal , and perhaps having used a greater proportion of it .
Before I enter into the cause of these phenomenon , it will be proper to take notice , that phlogisticated air appears to be nothing else than the nitrous acid united to phlogiston ; for when nitre is deflagrated with charcoal , the acid is almost entirely converted into this kind of air .
That the acid is entirely converted into air , appears from the common process for making what is called clyssus of nitre ; for if the nitre and charcoal are dry , scarce any thing is found in the vessels prepared for condensing the fumes ; but if they are moist a little liquor is collected , which is nothing but the water contained in the materials , impregnated with a little volatile alkali , proceeding in all probability from the imperfectly burnt charcoal , and a little fixed alkali , consisting of some of the alkalized nitre carried over by the heat and watery vapours .
As far as I can perceive too , at present , the air into which much the greatest part of the acid is converted , differs in no respect from common air phlogisticated .
A small part of the acid , however , is turned into nitrous air , and the whole is mixed with a good deal of fixed , and perhaps a little inflammable air , both proceeding from the charcoal .
It is well known , that the nitrous acid is also converted by phlogistication into nitrous air , in which respect there seems a considerable analogy between that and the vitriolic acid ; for the vitriolic acid , when united to a smaller proportion of phlogiston , forms the volatile sulphureous acid and vitriolic acid air , both of which , by exposure to the atmosphere , lose their phlogiston , though not very fast , and are turned back into vitriolic acid ; but , when united to a greater proportion of phlogiston , it forms sulphur , which shows no signs of acidity , unless a small degree of affinity to alkalies can be called so , and in which the phlogiston is more strongly adherent , so that it does not fly off when exposed to the air , unless assisted by a heat sufficient to set it on fire .
In like manner the nitrous acid , united to a certain quantity of phlogiston , forms nitrous fumes and nitrous air , which readily quit their phlogiston to common air ; but when united to a different , in all probability a larger quantity , it forms phlogisticated air , which shows no signs of acidity , and is still less disposed to part with its phlogiston than sulphur .
This being premised , there seem two ways by which the phenomenon of the acid found in the condensed liquor may be explained ; first , by supposing that dephlogisticated air contains a little nitrous acid which enters into it as one of its component parts , and that this acid , when the inflammable air is in a sufficient proportion , unites to the phlogiston , and is turned into phlogisticated air , but does not when the inflammable air is in too small a proportion ; and , secondly , by supposing that there is no nitrous acid mixed with , or entering into the composition of , dephlogisticated air , but that , when this air is in a sufficient proportion , part of the phlogisticated air with which it is debased is , by the strong affinity of phlogiston to dephlogisticated air , deprived of its phlogiston and turned into nitrous acid ; whereas , when the dephlogisticated air is not more than sufficient to consume the inflammable air , none then remains to deprive the phlogisticated air of its phlogiston , and turn it into acid .
If the latter explanation be true , I think , we must allow that dephlogisticated air is in reality nothing but dephlogisticated water , or water deprived of its phlogiston ; or , in other words , that water consists of dephlogisticated air united to phlogiston ; and that inflammable air is either pure phlogiston , as Dr. PRIESTLEY and Mr. KIRWAN suppose , or else water united to phlogiston * ; since , according to this supposition , these two substances united together form pure water .
On the other hand , if the first explanation be true , we must suppose that dephlogisticated air consists of water united to a little nitrous acid and deprived of its phlogiston ; but still the nitrous acid in it must make only a very small part of the whole , * Either of these suppositions will agree equally well with the following experiments ; but the latter seems to me much the most likely .
What principally makes me think so is , that common or dephlogisticated air do not absorb phlogiston from inflammable air , unless assisted by a red heat , whereas they absorb the phlogiston of nitrous air , liver of sulphur , and many other substances , without that assistance ; and it seems inexplicable , that they should refuse to unite to pure phlogiston , when they are able to extract it from substances to which it has an affinity ; that is , that they should overcome the affinity of phlogiston to other substances , and extract it from them , when they will not even unite to it when presented to them .
On the other hand , I know no experiment which shows inflammable air to be pure phlogiston rather than an union of it with water , unless it be Dr. PRIESTLEY'S experiment of expelling inflammable air from iron by heat alone .
I am not sufficiently acquinted with the circumstances of that experiment to argue with certainty about it ; but I think it much more likely , that the inflammable air was formed by the union of the phlogiston of the iron filings with the water dispersed among them , or contained in the retort or other vessel in which it was heated ; and in all probability this was the cause of the separation of the phlogiston , as iron seems not disposed to part with its phlogiston by heat alone , without being assisted by the air or some other substance .
as it is found , that the phlogisticated air , which it is converted into , is very small in comparison of the dephlogisticated air .
I think the second of these explnations seems much the most likely ; as it was found , that the acid in the condensed liquor was of the nitrous kind , not only when the dephlogisticated air was prepared from red precipitate , but also when it was procured from plants or from turbith mineral : and it seeems not likely , that air procured from plants , and still less likely that air procured from a solution of mercury in oil of vitriol , should contain any nitrous acid .
Another strong argument in favour of this opinion is , that dephlogisticated air yields no nitrous acid when phlogisticated by liver of sulphur ; for if this air contains nitrous acid , and yields it when phlogisticated by explosion with inflammable air , it is very extraordinary that it should not do so when phlogisticated by other means .
But what forms a stronger and , I think , almost decisive argument in favour of this explanation is , that when the dephlogisticated air is very pure , the condensed liquor is made much more strongly acid by mixing the air to be exploded with a little phlogisticated air , as appears by the following experiments .
A mixture of 18500 grain measures of inflammable air with 9750 of dephlogisticated air procured from red precipitate were exploded in the usual manner ; after which , a mixture of the same quantities of the same dephlogisticated and inflammable air , with the addition of 2500 of air phlogisticated by iron filings and sulphur , was treated in the same manner .
The condensed liquor , in both experiments , was acid , but that in the latter evidently more so , as appeared also by saturating each of them separately with marble powder , and precipitating the earth by fixed alkali , the precipitate of the second experiment weighing one-fifth of a grain , and that of the first being several times less .
The standard of the burnt air in the first experiment was 1,86 , and in the second only 0,9 .
It must be observed , that all circumstances were the same in these two experiments , except that in the latter the air to be exploded was mixed with some phlogisticated air , and that in consequence the burnt air was more phlogisticated than in the former ; and from what has been before said , it appears , that this latter circumstance ought rather to have made the condensed liquor less acid ; and yet it was found to be much more so , which shows strongly that it was the phlogisticated air which furnished the acid .
As a further confirmation of this point , these two comparative experiments were repeated with a little variation , namely , in the first experiment there was first let into the globe 1500 of dephlogisticated air , and then the mixture , consisting of 12200 of dephlogisticated air and 25900 of inflammable , was let in at different times as usual .
In the second experiment , besides the 1500 of dephlogisticated air first let in , there was also admitted 2500 of phlogisticated air , after which the mixture , consisting of the same quantities of dephlogisticated and inflammable air as before , was let in as usual .
The condensed liquor of the second experiment was about three times as acid as that of the first , as it required 119 grains of a diluted solution of salt of tartar to saturate it , and the other only 37 .
The standard of the burnt air was 0,78 in the second experiment , and 1,96 in the first .
The intention of previously letting in some dephlogisticated air in the two last experiments was , that the condensed liquor was expected to become more acid thereby , as proved actually to be the case .
In the first of these two experiments , in order that the air to be exploded should be as free as possible from common air , the globe was first filled with a mixture of dephlogisticated and inflammable air , it was then exhausted , and the air to be exploded let in ; by which means , though the globe was not perfectly exhausted , very little common air could be left in it .
In the first set of experiments this circumstance was not attended to , and the purity of the dephlogisticated air was forgot to be examined in both sets .
From what has been said there seems the utmost reason to think , that dephlogisticated air is only water deprived of its phlogiston , and that inflammable air , as was before said , is either phlogisticated water , or else pure phlogiston ; but in all probability the former .
As Mr. WATT , in a paper lately read before this Society , supposes water to consist of dephlogisticated air and phlogiston deprived of part of their latent heat , whereas I take no notice of the latter circumstance , it may be proper to mention in a few words the reason of this apparent difference between us .
If there be any such thing as elementary heat , it must be allowed that what Mr. WATT says is true ; but by the same rule we ought to say , that the diluted mineral acids consist of the concentrated acids united to water and deprived of part of their latent heat ; that solutions of sal ammoniac , and most other other neutral salts , consist of the salt united to water and elementary heat ; and a similar language ought to be used in speaking of almost all chemical combinations , as there are very few which are not attended with some increase or diminution of heat .
Now I have chosen to avoid this form of speaking , both because I think it more likely that there is no such thing as elementary heat , and because saying so in this instance , without using similar expressions in speaking of other chemical unions , would be improper , and would lead to false ideas ; and it may even admit of doubt , whether the doing it in general would not cause more trouble and perplexity than it is worth .
There is the utmost reason to think , that dephlogisticated and phlogisticated air , as M. LAVOISIER and SCHEELE suppose , are quite distinct substances , and not differing only in their degree of phlogistication ; and that common air is a mixture of the two ; for if the dephlogisticated air is pretty pure , almost the whole of it loses its elasticity by phlogistication , and , as appears by the foregoing experiments , is turned into water , instead of being converted into phlogisticated air .
In most of the foregoing experiments , at least 1 6/ 1 7ths of the whole was turned into water ; and by treating some dephlogisticated air with liver of sulphur , I have reduced it to less than 1/ 3 0th of its original bulk , and other persons , I believe , have reduced it to a still less bulk ; so that there seems the utmost reason to suppose , that the small residuum which remains after its phlogistication proceeds only from the impurities mixed with it .
It was just said , that some dephlogisticated air was reduced by liver of sulphur to 1/ 3 0th of its original bulk ; the standard of this air was 4,8 , and consequently the standard of perfectly pure dephlogisticated air should be very nearly 5 , which is a confirmation of the foregoing opinion ; for if the standard of pure dephlogisticated air is 5 , common air must , according to this opinion , contain one-fifth of it , and therefore ought to lose one-fifth of its bulk by phlogistication , which is what it is actually found to lose .
From what has been said , it follows , that instead of saying air is phlogisticated or dephlogisticated by any means , it would be more strictly just to say , it is deprived of , or receives , an addition of dephlogisticated air ; but as the other expression is convenient , and can scarcely be considered as improper , I shall still frequently make use of it in the remainder of this paper .
There seemed great reason to think , from Dr. PRIESTLEY'S experiments , that both the nitrous and vitriolic acids were convertible into dephlogisticated air , as that air is procured in the greatest quantity from substances containing those acids , especially the former .
The foregoing experiments , however , seem to show that no part of the acid is converted into dephlogisticated air , and that their use in preparing it is owing only to the great power which they possess of depriving bodies of their phlogiston .
A strong confirmation of this is , that red precipitate , which is one of the substances yielding dephlogisticated air in the greatest quantity , and which is prepared by means of the nitrous acid , contains in reality no acid .
This I found by grinding 400 grains of it with spirits of sal ammoniac , and keeping them together for some days in a bottle , taking care to shake them frequently .
The red colour of the precipitate was rendered pale , but not entirely destroyed ; being then washed with water and filtered , the clear liquor yielded on evaporation not the least ammoniacal salt .
It is natural to think , that if any nitrous acid had been contained in the red precipitate , it would have united to the volatile alkali and have formed ammoniacal nitre , and would have been perceived on evaporation ; but in order to determine more certainly whether this would be the case , I dried some of the same solution of quicksilver from which the red precipitate was prepared with a less heat , so that it acquired only an orange colour , and treated the same quantity of it with volatile alkali in the same manner as before .
It immediately caused an effervescence , changed the colour to grey , and yielded 52 grains of ammoniacal nitre .
There is the utmost reason to think , therefore , that red precipitate contains no nitrous acid ; and consequently that , in procuring dephlogisticated air from it , no acid is converted into air ; and it is reasonable to conclude , therefore , that no such change is produced in procuring it from any other substance .
It remains to consider in what manner these acids act in producing dephlogisticated air .
The way in which the nitrous acid acts , in the production of it from red precipitate , seems to be as follows .
On distilling the mixture of quicksilver and spirit of nitre , the acid comes over , loaded with phlogiston , in the form of nitrous vapour , and continues to do so till the remaining matter acquires its full red colour , by which time all the nitrous acid is driven over , but some of the watery part still remains behind , and adheres strongly to the quicksilver ; so that the red precipitate may be considered , either as quicksilver deprived of part of its phlogiston , and united to a certain portion of water , or as quicksilver united to dephlogisticated air* ; after which , on further increasing the heat , the water in it rises deprived of its phlogiston , that is , in the form of dephlogisticated * Unless we were much better acquainted than we are with the manner in which different substances are united together in compound bodies , it would be ridiculous to say , that it is the quicksilver in the red precipitate which is deprived of its phlogiston , and not the water , or that it is the water and not the quicksilver ; all that we can say is , that red precipitate consists of quicksilver and water , one or both of which are deprived of part of their phlogiston .
In like manner , during the preparation of the red precipitate , it is certain that the acid absorbs phlogiston , either from the quicksilver or the water ; but we are by no means authorised to say from which .
air , and at the same time the quicksilver distils over in its metallic form .
It is justly remarked by Dr. PRIESTLEY , that the solution of quicksilver does not begin to yield dephlogisticated air till it acquires its red colour .
Mercurius calcinatus appears to be only quicksilver which has absorbed dephlogisticated air from the atmosphere during its preparation ; accordingly , by giving it a sufficient heat , the dephlogisticated air is driven off , and the quicksilver acquires its original form .
It seems therefore that mercurius calcinatus and red precipitate , though prepared in a different manner , are very nearly the same thing .
From what has been said it follows , that red precipitate and mercurius calcinatus contain as much phlogiston as the quicksilver they are prepared from ; but yet , as uniting dephlogisticated air to a metal comes to the same thing as depriving it of part of its phlogiston and adding water to it , the quicksilver may still be considered as deprived of its phlogiston ; but the imperfect metals seem not only to absorb dephlogisticated air during their calcination , but also to be really deprived of part of their phlogiston , as they do not acquire their metallic form by driving off the dephlogisticated air .
In procuring dephlogisticated air from nitre , the acid acts in a different manner , as , upon heating the nitre red-hot , the dephlogisticated air rises mixed with a little nitrous acid , and at the same time the acid remaining in the nitre becomes very much phlogisticated ; which shows that the acid absorbs phlogiston from the water in the nitre , and becomes phlogisticated , while the water is thereby turned into dephlogisticated air .
On distilling 3155 grains of nitre in an unglazed earthen retort , it yielded 256000 grain measures of dephlogisticated air* , the standard * This is , about eighty-one grain measures from one grain of nitre ; and the standard of different parts of which varied from 3 to 3,65 , but at a medium was 3,35 .
The matter remaining in the retort dissolved readily in water , and tasted alcaline and caustic .
On adding diluted spirit of nitre to the solution , strong red fumes were produced ; a sign that the acid in it was very much phlogisticated , as no fumes whatever would have been produced on adding the same acid to a solution of common nitre ; that part of the solution also which was supersaturated with acid became blue ; a colour which the diluted nitrous acid is known to assume when much phlogisticated .
The solution , when saturated with this acid , lost its alcaline and caustic taste , but yet tasted very different from true nitre , seeming as if it had been mixed with sea-salt , and also required much less water to dissolve it ; but on exposing it for some days to the air , and adding fresh acid as fast as by the flying off of the fumes the alcali predominated , it became true nitre , unmixed , as far as I could perceive , with any other salt * .
It has been remarked , that the dephlogisticated air procured from nitre is less pure , than that from red precipitate and many other substances , which may perhaps proceed from unglazed earthen retorts having been commonly used for this purpose , and which , conformably to Dr. PRIESTLEY'S discovery , may possibly absorb some common air from without , and emit it along with the dephlogisticated air ; but if it should be found that the dephlogisticated air procured from nitre in glass or glazed earthen vessels is also impure , it would seem to show that part weight of the dephlogisticated air , supposing it 800 times lighter than water , is one tenth of that of the nitre .
In all probability it would have yielded a much greater quantity of air , if a greater heat had been applied .
* This phlogistication of the acid in nitre by heat has been observed by Mr. SCHEELE ; see his experiments on air and fire , p. 45 .
English translation .
of the acid in the nitre is turned into phlogisticated air , by absorbing phlogiston from the watery part .
From what has been said it appears , that there is a considerable difference in the manner in which the acid acts in the production of dephlogisticated air from red precipitate and from nitre ; in the former case of acid comes over first , leaving the remaining substance deprived of part of its phlogiston ; in the latter the dephlogisticated air comes first , leaving the acid loaded with the phlogiston of the water from which it was formed .
On distilling a mixture of quicksilver and oil of vitriol to dryness , part of the acid comes over , loaded with phlogiston , in the form of volatile sulphureous acid and vitriolic acid air ; so that the remaining white mass may be considered as consisting of quicksilver deprived of its phlogiston , and united to a certain proportion of acid and water , or of plain quicksilver united to a certain proportion of acid and dephlogisticated air .
Accordingly on urging this white mass with a more violent heat , the dephlogisticated air comes over , and at the same time part of the quicksilver rises in its metallic form , and also part of the white mass , united in all probability to a greater proportion of acid than before , sublimes ; so that the rationale of the production of dephlogisticated air from turbith mineral , and from red precipitate , are nearly similar .
True turbith mineral consists of the abovementioned white mass , well washed with water , by which means it acquires a yellow colour , and contains much less acid than the unwashed mass .
Accordingly it seems likely , that on exposing this to heat , less of it should sublime without being decompounded , and consequently that more dephloogisticated air should be procured from it than from the unwashed mass .
This is an instance , that the superabundant vitriolic acid may , in some cases , be better extracted from the base it is united to by water than by heat .
Vitriolated tartar is another instance ; for , if vitriolated tartar be mixed with oil of vitriol and exposed even to a pretty strong red heat , the mass will be very acid ; but , if this mass is dissolved in water , and evaporated , the crystals will be not sensibly so .
In all probability , the vitriolic acid acts in the same manner in the production of dephlogisticated air from alum , as the nitrous does in its production from nitre ; that is , the watery part comes over first in the form of dephlogisticated air , leaving the acid charged with its phlogiston .
Whether this is also the case with regard to green and blue vitriol , or whether in them the acid does not rather act in the same manner as in turbith mineral , I cannot pretend to say , but I think the latter more likely .
There is another way by which dephlogisticated air has been found to be produced in great quantities , namely , the growth of vegetables exposed to the sun or day-light ; the rationale of which , in all probability , is , that plants , when assisted by the light , deprive part of the water sucked up by their roots of its phlogiston , and turn it into dephlogisticated air , while the phlogiston unites to , and forms part of , the substance of the plant .
There are many circumstances which show , that light has a remarkable power in enabling one body to absorb phlogiston from another .
Mr. SENEBIER has observed , that the green tincture procured from the leaves of vegetables by spirit of wine , quickly loses its colour when exposed to the sun in a bottle not more than one third part full , but does not do so in the dark .
or if the bottle is quite full of the tincture , or if the air in it is phlogisticated ; whence it is natural to conclude , that the light enables the dephlogisticated part of the air to absorb phlogiston from the tincture ; and this appears to be really the case , as I find that the air in the bottle is considerably phlogisticated thereby .
Dephlogisticated spirit of nitre also acquires a yellow colour , and becomes phlogisticated , by exposure to the sun 's rays * ; and I find on trial that the air in the bottle in which it is contained becomes dephlogisticated , or , in other words , receives an increase of dephlogisticated air , which shows that the change in the acid is not owing to the sun 's rays communicating phlogiston to it , but to their enabling it to absorb phlogiston from the water contained in it , and thereby to produce dephlogisticated air .
Mr. SCHEELE also found , that the dark colour acquired by luna cornea on exposure to the light , is owing to part of the silver being revived ; and that gold , dissolved in aqua regia and deprived by distillation of the nitrous and superfluous marine acid , is revived by the same means ; and there is the utmost reason to think , that , in both cases , the revival of the metal is owing to its absorbing phlogiston from the water .
Vegetables seem to consist almost entirely of fixed and phlogisticated air , united to a large proportion of phloogiston and some water , since by burning in the open air , in which their phlogiston unites to the dephlogisticated part of the atmosphere and forms * If spirit of nitre is distilled with a very gentle heat , the part which comes over is high coloured and fuming , and that which remains behind is quite colourless , and fumes much less than other nitrous acid of the same strength , and the fumes are colourless .
This is called dephlogisticated spirit of nitre , as it appears to be really deprived of phlogiston by the process .
The manner of preparing it , as well as its property of regaining its yellow colour by exposure to the light , is mentioned by Mr. SCHEELE in the Stockholm Memoirs , 1774 .
water , they seem to be reduced almost entirely to water and those two kinds of air .
Now plants growing in water without earth , can receive nourishment only from the water and air , and must therefore in all probability absorb their phlogiston from the water .
It is known also that plants growing in the dark do not thrive well , and grow in a very different manner from what they do when exposed to the light .
From what has been said , it seems likely that the use of light , in promoting the growth of plants and the production of dephlogisticated air from them , is , that it enables them to absorb phlogiston from the water .
To this it may perhaps be objected , that though plants do not thrive well in the dark , yet they do grow , and should therefore , according to this hypothesis , absorb water from the atmosphere , and yield dephlogisticated air , which they have not been found to do .
But we have no proof that they grew at all in any of those cases in which they were found not to yield dephlogisticated air ; for though they will grow in the dark , yet their vegetative powers may perhaps at first be entirely checked by it , especially considering the unnatural situation in which they must be placed in such experiments .
Perhaps too plants growing in the dark may be able to absorb phlogiston from water not much impregnated with dephlogisticated air , but not from water strongly impregnated with it ; and consequently , when kept under water in the dark , may perhaps at first yield some dephlogisticated air , which , instead of rising to the surface , may be absorbed by the water , and , before the water is so much impregnated as to suffer any to escape , the plant may cease to vegetate , unless the water is changed .
Unless therefore it could be shown that plants growing in the dark , in water alone , will increase in size , without yielding dephlogisticated gisticated air , and without the water becoming more impregnated with it than before , no objection can be drawn from thence .
Mr. SENEBIER finds , that plants yield much more dephlogisticated air in distilled water impregnated with fixed air , than in plain distilled water , which is perfectly conformable to the abovementioned hypothesis ; for as fixed air is a principal constituent part of vegetable substances , it is reasonable to suppose that the work of vegetation will go on better in water containing this substance , than in other water .
There are several memoirs of Mr. LAVOISIER published by the Academy of Sciences , in which he entirely discards phlogiston , and explains those phenomenon which have been usually attributed to the loss or attraction of that substance , by the absorption or expulsion of dephlogisticated air ; and as not only the foregoing experiments , but most other phenomenon of nature , seem explicable as well , or nearly as well , upon this as upon the commonly believed principle of phlogiston , it may be proper briefly to mention in what manner I would explain them on this principle , and why I have adhered to the other .
In doing this , I shall not conform strictly to his theory , but shall make such additions and alterations as seem to suit it best to the phenomenon ; the more so , as the foregoing experiments may , perhaps , induce the author himself to think some such additions proper .
According to this hypothesis , we must suppose , that water consists of inflammable air united to dephlogisticated air ; that nitrous air , vitriolic acid air , and the phosphoric acid , are also combinations of phlogisticated air , sulphur , and phosphorus , with dephlogisticated air ; and that the two former , by a further addition of the same substance , are reduced to the common nitrous and vitriolic acids ; that the metallic calces consist of the metals themselves united to the same substance , commonly , however , with a mixture of fixed air ; that on exposing the calces of the perfect metals to a sufficient heat , all the dephlogisticated air is driven off , and the calces are restored to their metallic form ; but as the calces of the imperfect metals are vitrified by heat , instead of recovering the metallic form , it should seem as if all the dephlogisticated air could not be driven off from them by heat alone .
In like manner , according to this hypothesis , the rationale of the production of dephlogisticated air from red precipitate is , that during the solution of the quicksilver in the acid and the subsequent calcination , the acid is decompounded , and quits part of its dephlogisticated air to the quicksilver , whereby it comes over in the form of nitrous air , and leaves the quicksilver behind united to dephlogisticated air , which , by a further increase of heat , is driven off , while the quicksilver re-assumes its metallic form .
In procuring dephlogisticated air from nitre , the acid is also decompounded ; but with this difference , that it suffers some of its dephlogisticated air to escape , while it remains united to the alkali itself , in the form of phlogisticated nitrous acid .
As to the production of dephlogisticated air from plants , it may be said , that vegetable substances consist chiefly of various combinations of three different bases , one of which , when united to dephlogisticated air , forms water , another fixed air , and the third phlogisticated air ; and that by means of vegetation each of these substances are decomposed , and yield their dephlogisticated air ; and that in burning they again acquire dephlogisticated air , and are restored to their pristine form .
It seems , therefore , from what has been said , as if the phenomenon of nature might be explained very well on this princi5 ciple , ciple , without the help of phlogiston ; and indeed , as adding dephlogisticated air to a body comes to the same thing as depriving it of its phlogiston and adding water to it , and as there are , perhaps , no bodies entirely destitute of water , and as I know no way by which phlogiston can be transferred from one body to another , without leaving it uncertain whether water is not at the same time transferred , it will be very difficult to determine by experiment which of these opinions is the truest ; but as the commonly received principle of phlogiston explains all phenomenon , at least as well as Mr. LAVOISIER'S , I have adhered to that .
There is one circumstance also , which though it may appear to many not to have much force , I own has some weight with me ; it is , that as plants seem to draw their nourishment almost entirely from water and fixed and phlogisticated air , and are restored back to those substances by burning , it seems reasonable to conclude , that notwithstanding their infinite variety they consist almost entirely of various combinations of water and fixed and phlogisticated air , united according to one of these opinions to phlogiston , and deprived according to the other of dephlogisticated air ; so that , according to the latter opinion , the substance of a plant is less compounded than a mixture of those bodies into which it is resolved by burning ; and it is more reasonable to look for great variety in the more compound than in the more simple substance .
Another thing which Mr. LAVOISIER endeavours to prove is , that dephlogisticated air is the acidifying principle .
From what has been explained it appears , that this is no more than saying , that acids lose their acidity by uniting to phlogiston , which with regard to the nitrous , vitriolic , phosphoric , and arsenical acids is certainly true .
The same thing , I believe , may be said of the acid of sugar ; and Mr. LAVOISIER'S experiment is a strong confirmation of BERGMAN'S opinion , that none of the spirit of nitre enters into the composition of the acid , but that it only serves to deprive the sugar of part of its phlogiston .
But as to the marine acid and acid of tartar , it does not appear that they are capable of losing their acidity by any union with phlogiston .
It is to be remarked also , that the acids of sugar and tartar , and in all probability almost all the vegetable and animal acids , are by burning reduced to fixed and phlogisticated air , and water , and therefore contain more phlogiston , or less dephlogisticated air , than those three substances .

