XXXII .
Account of a Comet .
By Mr. Herschel , F. R. S. ; communicated by Dr. Watson , Jun. of Bath , F. R. S. Read April 26 , 1781 .
ON Tuesday the 13th of March , between ten and eleven in the evening , while I was examining the small stars in the neighbourhood of H Geminorum .
I perceived one that appeared visibly larger than the rest : being struck with its uncommon magnitude , I compared it to H Geminorum and the small star in the quartile between Auriga and Gemini , and finding it so much larger than either of them , suspected it to be a comet .
I was then engaged in a series of observations on the parallax of the fixed stars , which I hope soon to have the honour of laying before the Royal Society ; and those observations requiring very high powers , I had ready at hand the several magnifiers of 227 , 460 , 932 , 1536 , 2010 , &amp;c. all which I have successfully used upon that occasion .
The power I had on when I first saw the comet was 227 .
From experience I knew that the diameters of the fixed stars are not proportionally magnified with higher powers , as the planets are ; therefore I now put on the powers of 460 and 932 , and found the diameter of the comet increased in proportion to the power , as it ought to be , on a supposition of its not being a fixed star , while the diameters of the stars to which I compared it were not increased in the same ratio .
Moreover , the comet being magnified much beyond what its light would admit of , appeared hazy and illdefined with these great powers , while the stars preserved that lustre and distinctness which from many thousand observations I knew they would retain .
The sequel has shown that my surmises were well founded , this proving to be the Comet we have lately observed .
I have reduced all my observations upon this Comet to the following tables .
The first contains the measures of the gradual increase of the Comet 's diameter .
The micrometers I used , when every circumstance is favourable , will measure extremely small angles , such as do not exceed a few seconds , true to 6 , 8 , or 10 thirds at most ; and in the worst situations true to 20 or 30 thirds : I have therefore given the measures of the Comet 's diameter in seconds and thirds .
And the parts of my micrometer being thus reduced , I have also given all the rest of the measures in the same manner ; though in large distances , such as one , two , or three minutes , so great an exactness , for several reasons , is not pretended to .
TABLE 1 .
Measures of the Comet 's diameter* .
Days .
' ' ' ' ' Powers .
March 17 2 53 932 .
460 .
19 2 59 932 .
460 .
21 3 38 460 .
28 47 932 these measures agree to 9~ .
3 58 227 29 47 227 rather too small a measure .
4 25 227 seems right .
April 24 25 227 64 53 227 15 5 11 227 5 20 227 very good ; not liable to half a second of error .
18 52 227 true to 12~ or 18~ at most .
Having measured the diameter of the Comet with such high power as 932 and 460 , it may not be amiss to make one observation on this subject , lest it should be misapprehended that I pretend to a distinct power of such magnitude upon all celestial objects in general .
By experience I have found , that the aberration or indistinctness occasioned by magnifying much , provided the object be still left sufficiently distinct , is rather to be put up with , than the power to be reduced , when the angles to be measured are extremely small .
The reason of this may , perhaps , be that a small error of judgement , to which we are always liable , is of great consequence with a low power , as bearing a considerable proportion to the diameter of the object ; * There are several optical deceptions which may affect the measures of objects that subtend extremely small angles .
Thus I have found , by experience , that a very small object will appear something less in a telescope when we see it first than when we become familiar with it .
There is also a deflection of light upon the wires when they are nearly shut ; but as none of these deceptions are well enough understood to apply a correction , I leave them affected with them .
whereas with a higher power the proportion of this error to the whole becomes much less , and the measure more exact , even after we have made allowance for a small additional error occasioned by the want of that perfect distinctness which is required for other purposes .
However , to enter deeply into an explanation of this would lead me to speak of the causes of the aberration of rays in the focus of an object speculum , of which there are some that are seldom taken into consideration by opticians , and indeed are such as cannot be calculated ; but this not being my present purpose , suffice it to observe , that the method is justified by experience .
When the diameter of the Comet was increased to about 4~ , I thought it advisable to lessen the power with which I measured ; and , as I made use of two different micrometers , as well as eye-glasses , I took a measure with both of them .
The agreement of the micrometers to 9~ is no small proof of the goodness of the observations of the 28th of March , and very properly connects the measures of the high powers with those that were made with 227 .
TABLE II .
Distance of the Comet from certain telescopic fixed stars which I have marked ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ , ~ .
D. H. M. ' ' ' ' ' ' Mar. 13 10 30 from ~ , 2 48 0 by pretty exact estimation true to 20~ .
17 11 0 fig. 1* .
0 41 58 by the micrometer and power 227 .
18 7 20 10 35 9 16 16 59 10 55 1 10 40 19 7~1 46 40 10 42 1 51 23 21 10 03 39 46 24 8 12 from ~ , 2 55 39 true to 4 or 5~ , an indifferent observation .
10 58 fig. 2 .
2 53 4 true to 4 or 5~ .
25 7 24 2 12 46 true to 2 or 3~ .
9 47 2 14 18 26 10 43 1 48 3 true to 2 or 3~ .
28 7 46 2 55 49 true to 4 or 5~ .
29 8 50 from ~ .
2 20 51 true to 2~ .
30 7 55 fig. 3 .
1 28 48 true to 2 or 3~ .
Apr. 17 45 2 39 20 68 50 from ~ .
2 51 23 fig. 4 .
15 10 18 from ~ .
4 27 57 estimated by the field , true to 5 or 6~ .
16 7 50 fig. 5 .
39 14 by the micrometer , true to 3 or 4~ .
10 47 2 50 56 true to 3 or 4~ .
18 8 18 3 18 4 mean 3~ 17~ , true to 1~ or 11/ 2 .
3 15 57 8 50 from ~ , 2 24 57 19 8 38 fig. 6 .
325 true to 3 or 4~ .
* The figures are drawn upon a scale of 80 seconds to one inch .
TABLE III .
Angle of position of the Comet with regard to the parallel of declination of the same telescopic fixed stars measured by a micrometer , of which I have given the description , and a magnifying power of 278 .
See fig. 1 .
2 .
3 .
4 .
5 .
6 .
D. H. M. o ' by superficial estimation , liable to an error Mar. 13 10 30 B~ Comet , 00 of 10 or 12 degrees .
17 11 0A~ Comet , 89 56 by the micrometer .
18 8 20 fig. 1 * .
56 39 9 24 41 33 true to 1~ .
19 7 23 29 47 true to 1~ .
21 10 10 11 46 true to 4 or 5~ .
11 48 12 14 24 8 23 B~ Comet , 38 39 true to 2 or 3~ .
11 4 fig. 2 .
36 14 true to 3 or 4~ , air very tremulous .
25 7 33 53 18 9 55 56 32 liable to a considerable error .
26 10 55 A~ Comet .
87 0 true to 2 or 3~ .
28 7 58 28 51 true to 3 or 4~ .
29 9 25 B~ Comet , 32 19 true to 1 or 2~ .
30 8 25 fig. 3 .
72 14 true to 3 or 4~ .
Apr. 17 55 A~ Comet , 28 51 well taken , 27~ 46~ , true to 1~ .
27 14 more exact , 68 28 B~ Comet , 84 42 true to less than 2~ fig. 4 .
15 10 27 B~ Comet , 29 9 true to 2 or 3~ .
16 81 fig. 5 .
49 11 true to 1~ .
10 55 50 47 true to 11/ 2 or 2~1/ 2 .
18 8 31 A~ Comet , 47 9 very well taken , 47~ , true to less than 1~ .
46 35 pretty well , 98B~ Comet , 82 39 19 8 56 A~ Comet , 48 18 49~ 3~ , true to 1~ .
fig. 6 .
49 48 10 45 47 30 true to 2 or 3~ .
* The angles are drawn true to the measure , without allowing for errors .
Miscellaneous observations and remarks .
March 19 .
The Comet 's apparent motion is at present 21/ 4 seconds per hour .
It moves according to the order of the signs , and its orbit declines but very little from the ecliptic .
March 25 .
The apparent motion of the Comet is accelerating , and its apparent diameter seems to be increasing .
March 28 .
The diameter is certainly increased , from which we may conclude that the Comet approaches to us .
April 2 .
This evening at 8 h. 15~ the Comet was a little above the line drawn from ~ to ~ in fig. 7 .
This figure is only delineated by the eye , so that no very great exactness in the distances of the stars is to be expected ; but I shall take the first opportunity of measuring their respective situations by the micrometer .
April 6 .
With a magnifying power of 278 times the Comet appeared perfectly sharp upon the edges , and extremely well defined , without the least appearance of any beard or tail .
April 16 .
Fig. 8 .
represents the situation of the Comet this evening about nine o'clock , and is only an eye-draught of the telescopic stars .
Remarks on the path of the Comet .
We may observe , that the method of tracing out the path of a celestial body by taking its distance from certain stars , and the angle of position with regard to them , cannot be expected to give us a compleatly just representation of the tract it describes , since even the most careful observations are liable to little errors , both from the remaining imperfections of instruments , though they should be the most accurate that can be had , and from the difficulty of taking angles and positions of objects in motion .
Add to this a third cause of error , namely , the obscurity of very small telescopic stars that will not permit the field of view so well to be enlightened as we could wish , in order to see the threads of the micrometer perfectly distinct .
This will account for the apparent distortions to be observed in my figures of the Comet 's path .
Some little irregularity therein may also proceed from different refractions , as they have not been taken into account , though the observations have been made at very different altitudes , where consequently the refractions must have been very different .
But though this method may be liable to great inconveniences , the principal of which is , that many parts of the heavens are not sufficiently stored with small stars to give us an opportunity to measure from them , yet the advantages are not less remarkable .
Thus we see that it enabled me to distinguish the quantity and direction of the motion of this Comet in a single day ( from the 18th to the 19th of March ) to a much greater degree of exactness than could have been done in so short a time by a sector or transit instrument ; nay even an hour or two , we see , were intervals long enough to show that it was a moving body , and consequently , had its size not pointed it out as a Comet , the change of place , though so trifling as 21/ 4 seconds per hour , would have been sufficient to occasion the discovery .
A gentleman very well known for his remarkable success in detecting Comets * seems to be well aware of the difficulty to discover a motion in a heavenly body by the common methods when it is so very small ; for in a letter he favoured me with , speaking of the Comet , he says : ` ` Rien n'etoit plus difficile que de la reconnoitre et je no puis pas concevoir comment vous aves pu * Mons. MESSIER .
revenir plusieurs fois sir cette etoile ou Comet ; car absolument il a fallu l'observer plusieurs jours de suite pour s'appercevoir qu'elle avoit un mouvement .
' ' I need not say that I merely point this out as a temporary advantage in the method I have taken ; for as soon as we can have regular , constant , and long continued observations by fixed instruments , the excellence of them is too well known to say any thing upon that subject : for which reason I failed not to give immediate notice of this moving star , and was happy to surrender it to the care of the Astronomer Royal and others , as soon as I found they had begun their observations upon it .
Description of a micrometer for taking the angle of position .
FIG. I. Represents the micrometer enclosed in a turned case of wood , as it is put together , ready to be used with the telescope .
A is a little box which holds the eye-glass .
B is the piece which covers the inside work , and the box A is screwed into it .
C is the body of the micrometer containing the brass work , showing the index plate a projecting at one side , where the case is cut away to receive it .
D is a piece , having a screw b at the bottom , by means of which the micrometer is fastened to the telescope .
To the piece C is given a circular motion , in the manner the horizontal motion is generally given to Gregorian reflectors , by the lower part going through the piece D , where it is held by the screw E , which keeps the two pieces C and D together , but leaves them at liberty to turn upon each other .
Fig. II .
Is a section of the case containing the brass work , where may be observed the piece B hollowed out to receive the BA March 13 real place March 17 18 19 21 March 24 25 26 28 B ~ Fig.2 .
March 29 30 Aprils .
~ BA April 6 .
A 21 ~ Fig. 4 .
B Fig. 5 .
~ B A April 15 .
16 18 19 A Fig. 6 .
~ ~A ~A 19 ~ ~A ~ ~~ ~ Fig. 7 .
~~ ~ ~ ~~~n ~ April 2 .
~ ~~~~~ April 16 .
~~~ ~~~~~ Fig. I. Fig. II .
AA BB df ce aa CFg C DD b EE Fig. IV .
C d o Fig. III .
cq m~~ hiif~ d cehsfea a~ n Fg 60 r c pt d box A , which consists of two parts enclosing the eye lens .
This figure also shows how the piece C passes through D , and is held by the ring E : the brass work , consisting of a hollow cylinder , a wheel and pinion , and index plate , is there represented in its place .
F is the body of the brass work , being a hollow cylinder with a broad rim c at the upper end ; this rim is partly turned away to make a bed for the wheel d. The pinion e turns the wheel d , and carries the index plate a. One of its pivots moves in the arm f , screwed upon the upper part of c , which arm serves also to confine the wheel d to its place upon c. The other pivot is held by the arm g fastened to F. Fig. III .
Is a plan of the brass work .
The wheel d , which is in the form of a ring , is laid upon the upper part of F or c , and held by two small arms f and h , screwed down to e with the screws i , i. Fig. IV .
Is a plan of the brass work .
d , d , is the wheel placed upon the bed or socket of the rim of the cylinder c , c , and is held down by the two pieces , f , h , which are screwed upon c , c. The piece f projects over the center of the index plate to receive the upper pivot of the pinion m , n , is the fixed wire fastened to c , c. o , p , the moveable wire fastened to the annular wheel d , d. The index plate a is divided into 60 parts , each sub-divided into two , and milled upon the edge .
When the finger is drawn over the milled edge of the index plate from q towards r , the angle m , s , o , will open , and if drawn from r towards q , it will shut again .
The case C , C , must have a sharp corner t , which serves as a hand to poin out the division on the index plate .

