XXXI .
Experiments on the Power that Animals , when placed in certain Circumstances , possess of producing Cold .
By Adair Crawford , M. D. ; communicated by Sir Joseph Banks , Bart. P. R. S. Read June 14 , 1781 .
IN the following paper I shall lay before the Society the result of some experiments , which I made in the course of the last summer , on the power that animals , when placed in certain circumstances , possess , of producing cold , having premised a few remarks on the progressive improvements which have been made in the knowledge of heat in general .
The opinions of the ancients , respecting the nature and properties of fire , consisted of bold conjectures , which seem rather to have been the offspring of a lively and vigorous imagination , than of a just and correct judgement : their ideas on this subject being evidently derived , not so much from an accurate observation of facts , as from those sentiments of admiration and awe which many of the phenomena of fire are calculated to excite .
Thus , this element was supposed , on the original formation of the universe , to have ascended to the highest place , and to have occupied the region of the heavens : it was conceived to be the principle which first communicated life and activity to the animal kingdom : it was considered as constituting the essence of inferior intellectual beings ; and , by many of the ancient nations , it was reverenced as the supreme Deity .
Indeed the profound veneration with which the element of fire was contemplated , for a long succession of ages , by a great part of mankind , appears to be one of the most curious circumstances in the history of ancient opinions .
To account for this we may observe , that there is no principle in nature , obvious to the senses , which produces such important effects in the material system , and which , at the same time , in the mode of its operation , is so obscure and incomprehensible .
It appears to be accumulated in an immense quantity in the sun and fixed stars , from whence its beneficial influence seems to be continually diffused over the universe : it is the great instrument by means of which the changes of the seasons are effected ; the diversity of climates is chiefly owing to the various proportions in which it is distributed throughout the earth .
If we add to this the mighty alterations which have been produced in human affairs by the introduction of artificial fire , by its employment in the separation of metals from their ores , and in the various arts which are subservient to the comfort , the ornament , and the preservation , of the species , it will not appear surprising , that in a rude and ignorant age , this wonderful principle should have been considered as endued with life and intelligence , and that it should have become the object of religious veneration .
In the dark ages the alchymists regarded pure fire as the residence of the Deity : they conceived it to be uncreated and immense , and attributed to its influence most of the phenomena of nature .
Indeed , it is not wonderful that they should have assigned it a high rank in the scale of being , as it was the great agent which they employed in the chemical analysis of bodies , and was the instrument of those discoveries that attracted such universal admiration , and that enabled them so successfully to impose upon the ignorance and credulity of the times .
Upon the revival of literature , the importance of this branch of science began very soon to engage the attention of philosophers .
It could not escape the general observation , in a penetrating and inquisitive age , when the powers of the human mind were employed with so much ardour and success in exploring the operations of nature , that the element of fire acts a principal part in the system of the world ; that by the influence of this element those motions are begun and supported in the animal and vegetable kingdoms , which are essential to the production and preservation of life ; and that it is the great agent in those successive combinations and decompositions , by which all things on the surface of the earth , and probably throughout the universe , are kept in a continual fluctuation .
But though the utility of this branch of science was perceived , yet the progress that was made in the cultivation of it did not keep pace with the opinion which men entertained of its importance .
Our senses inform us , that heat has a real existence , but they give us no direct information with regard to its nature and properties : it is endowed with such infinite subtilty , that it has been called , by a very eminent philosopher , an occult quality : by some it has even been considered as an immaterial being .
It is , therefore , with great difficulty that it can be made the subject of philosophical investigation ; and hence the opinions of men concerning it have been fluctuating and various , and the words which express it vague and ambiguous .
The first step that was taken with a view to the cultivation of this branch of science was the construction of a machine for measuring the variations of sensible heat ; observing , that heat has the power of expanding bodies , and considering the degree of expansion as proportional to the increase of heat , philosophers have endeavoured by means of the former to render the latter obvious to the senses .
To this important invention , the author of which cannot be distinctly traced , we are indebted for all the succeeding improvements in the philosophy of heat .
By means of it men were enabled to establish a variety of interesting facts , and to bring some of the most obscure and intricate phenomena of nature to the test of experiment .
The opinion , that the heats inherent in various heterogenecus substances differed from each other in kind , as well as in degree , was now exploded , since all were found to produce similar effects upon the thermometer .
The increase and diminution of temperature in the different seasons and climates , the laws which nature observes in the heating and cooling of bodies , the melting , the vaporific , and shining points , and the degrees of heat in the animal , the mineral , and the vegetable kingdoms , were accurately determined .
In consequence of the attention that was paid to this subject , many curious questions arose , which have long exercised the ingenuity of philosophers .
That property of heat by which it is capable of expanding the densest and hardest bodies ; its power in producing fluidity ; its tendency to an equilibrium ; and the causes of its various distribution throughout the different substances in nature , have become the objects of philosophical enquiry .
It was observed , that some bodies on exposure to heat , become red and luminous , but are incapable of producing flame , or of maintaining fire : that , on the contrary , others , by the application of fire , and the contact of fresh air , kindle into flame , and continue to emit light and heat , apparently from a source within themselves , till they are consumed .
Hence arose the questions concerning the pabulum lum of fire , the use of the air in inflammation , and the distinction of bodies into combustible and incombustible .
From the first dawnings of philosophy it must have been perceived , that most animals have a higher temperature than the medium in which they live ; and that a constant succession of fresh air is necessary to the support of animal life .
The causes of these phenomena have afforded matter for much speculation in ancient as well as modern times : but the discovery that animals have , in certain circumstances , the power of keeping themselves at a lower temperature than the surrounding medium , was reserved for the industry of the present age .
This discovery seems originally to have arisen from observations on the heat of the human body in warm climates .
It was mentioned by Governor ELLIS in 1758 ; it was taught by Dr. CULLEN before the year 1765 ; and at length it was completely established by the experiments of Dr. FORDYCE in heated rooms , which were laid before the Society in 1774 .
In the course of these experiments the doctor remained in a moist air heated to 130~ for the space of fifteen minutes , during which time the thermometer under his tongue stood at 100~ , his pulse made 139 beats in a minute , his respiration was but little affected , and streams of water ran down over his whole body , proceeding from the condensation of vapour , as evidently appeared from a similar condensation on the side of a Florentine flask that had been filled with water at 100~ .
He found , however , that he could bear a much greater degree of heat when the air was dry .
In this situation , he frequently supported , naked , for a considerable time , without much inconvenience , the heat of 260~ , his body preserving very nearly its proper temperature , being never raised more than 2~ above the natural standard .
Various opinions have been entertained with regard to the causes of the facts which were established by these experiments .
Some have attributed the cold solely to evaporation , and have conceived that the same degree of refrigeration would have been produced by an equal mass of dead matter , containing an equal quantity of moisture .
Others have affirmed , that the cold did not arise solely from this cause ; but have maintained , that it depended partly upon the energy of the vital principle , being greater than what would have been produced by an equal mass of inanimate matter .
The ingenious Dr. MUNRO , of Edinburgh , ascribes the cold in the above mentioned experiments to the circulation of the blood , in consequence of which the warmer fluids are continually propelled from the surface towards the center , where they are mixed with blood at a lower temperature , and hence the animal is slowly heated , in the same manner as the water in a deep lake , during the winter , is slowly cooled , and not without a long continuance of frost congealed , no part of it becoming solid till the whole is brought down to the freezing point .
The following experiments were made with a view to determine with greater certainty the causes of the refrigeration in the above instances .
To discover whether the cold produced by a living animal , placed in air hotter than its body , be not greater than what would be produced by an equal mass of inanimate matter , I took a living and a dead frog , equally moist , and of nearly the same bulk , the former of which was at 67~ , the latter at 68~ , and laid them upon flannel in air which had been raised to 106~ .
In the course of twenty-five minutes the order of heating was as follows * .
* In the two following experiments the thermometers were placed in contact with the skin of the animals under the axillae .
Air .
Dead frog .
Living frog .
'ooo In 1 701/ 2 671/ 2 2 102 72 68 3 100 721/ 2 691/ 2 4 100 73 70 25 95 811/ 4 781/ 4 The thermometer being introduced into the stomach , the internal heat of the animals was found to be the same with that at the surface .
From hence it appears , that the living frog acquired heat more slowly than the dead one .
Its vital powers must , therefore , have been active in the generation of cold .
To determine whether the cold produced in this instance depended solely upon the evaporation from the surface , increased by the energy of the vital principle , a living and dead frog were taken at 75~ , and were immersed in water at 93~ , the living frog being placed in such a situation as not to interrupt respiration .
Dead frog .
Living frog .
'oo In 1 85 81 2 881/ 2 85 3 901/ 2 87 5 911/ 2 89 6 911/ 2 89 8 911/ 2 89 These experiments prove , that living frogs have the faculty of resisting heat , or producing cold , when immersed in warm water : and the experiments of Dr. FORDYCE prove , that the human body has the same power in a moist as well as in a dry * In the above experiment the water , by the cold frogs and by the agitation which it suffered during their immersion , was reduced nearly to 91~1/ 2 .
air : it is therefore highly probable , that this power does not depend solely upon evaporation .
It may not be improper here to observe , that healthy frogs , in an atmosphere above 70~ , keep themselves at a lower temperature than the external air , but are warmer internally than at the surface of their bodies : for when the air was 77~ , a frog was found to be 68~ , the thermometer being placed in contact with the skin ; but when the thermometer was introduced into the stomach , it rose to 70~1/ 2 .
It may likewise be proper to mention , that an animal of the same species placed in water at 61~ , was found to be nearly 61~1/ 4 at the surface , and internally it was 66~1/ 2 .
These observations are meant to extend only to frogs living in air or water at the common temperature of the atmosphere in summer .
They do not hold with respect to those animals , when plunged suddenly into a warm medium , as in the preceding experiments .
To determine whether other animals also have the power of producing cold , when surrounded with water above the standard of their natural heat , a dog at 102~ was immersed in water at 114~ , the thermometer being closely applied to the skin under the axilla , and so much of his head being uncovered as to allow him a free respiration .
In 5 minutes the dog was 108~ , water 112~ 6 109 112 11 108 112 the respiration having become very rapid .
In thirteen minutes the dog was 108~ , water 112~ , the respiration being still more rapid .
In about half an hour the dog was 109~ , water 112~ , the animal was then in a very languid state .
Small quantities of blood being drawn from the femoral artery , and from a contiguous vein , the temperature did not seem to be much increased above the natural standard , and the sensible heat of the former appeared to be nearly the same with that of the latter .
In this experiment a remarkable change was produced in the appearance of the venous blood : for it is well known , that in the natural state , the colour of the venous blood is a dark red , that of the arterial being light and florid ; but after the animal , in the experiment in question , had been immersed in warm water for half an hour , the venous blood assumed very nearly the hue of the arterial , and resembled it so much in appearance , that it was difficult to distinguish between them .
It is proper to observe , that the animal which was the subject of this experiment , had been previously weakened by losing a considerable quantity of blood a few days before .
When the experiment was repeated with dogs which had not suffered a similar evacuation , the change in the colour of the venous blood was more gradual ; but in every instance in which the trial was made , and it was repeated six times , the alteration was so remarkable , that the blood which was taken in the warm bath could readily be distinguished from that which had been taken from the same vein before immersion , by those who were unacquainted with the motives or circumstances of the experiment .
To discover whether a similar change would be produced in the colour of the venous blood in hot air , a dog at 102~ was placed in air at 134~ .
In ten minutes the temperature of the dog was 104~1/ 2 , that of the air being 130 .
In fifteen minutes the dog was 106~ , the air 130~ .
A small quantity of blood was then taken from the jugular vein , the colour of which was sensibly altered , being much lighter than in the natural state .
The effect which is produced by external heat upon the colour of the venous blood , seems to confirm the following opinion , which was first suggested by my worthy and ingenious friend Mr. WILSON , of Glasgow .
Admitting that the sensible heat of animals depends upon the separation of absolute heat from the blood by means of its union with the phlogistic principle in the minute vessels , may there not be a certain temperature at which that fluid is no longer capable of combining with phlogiston , and at which it must of course cease to give off heat ?
It was partly with a view to investigate the truth of this opinion that I was led to make the experiments recited above .
I shall now endeavour , from the preceding facts , to explain what appear to me to be the true causes of the cold produced by animals when placed in a medium , the temperature of which is above the standard of their natural heat .
In a work which I some time ago laid before the public , having attempted to prove , that animal heat depends upon the separation of elementary fire from the air in the process of respiration , I observed , that when an animal is placed in a warm medium , if the evaporation from the lungs be increased to a certain degree , the whole of the heat separated from the air will be absorbed by the aqueous vapour .
From the experiments on venous and arterial blood , recited in the third section of that work , it appears , that the capacity of the blood for containing heat is so much augmented in the lungs , that , if its temperature were not supported by the heat which is separated from the air , in the process of respiration , it would sink 30~ .
Hence , if the evaporation from the lungs be so much increased as to carry off the whole of the heat that is detached from the air , the arterial blood when it returns by the pulmonary vein will have its sensible heat greatly diminished , and will consequently absorb heat from the vessels which are in contact with it , and from the parts adjacent .
The heat which is thus absorbed in the greater vessels will again be extricated in the capillaries , where the blood receives a fresh addition of phlogiston .
If , in these circumstances , the blood during each revolution were to be equally impregnated with this latter principle , it is manifest , that the whole effect of the above process would be to cool the system at the center , and to heat it at the surface ; or to convey the heat to that part of the body where it is capable of being instantly carried off by evaporation .
But it appears , from the experiments which have been last recited , that , when an animal is placed in a heated medium , the sanguineous mass , during each revolution , is less impregnated with phlogiston ; for we have seen , that the venous blood , in these circumstances , becomes gradually paler and paler in its colour till at length it acquires very nearly the appearance of the arterial : and it is rendered highly probable by the experiments of Dr. PRIESTLEY , that the dark and livid colour of the blood in the veins depends upon its combination with phlogiston in the minute vessels .
Since , therefore , in a heated medium , this fluid does not assume the same livid hue , we may conclude , that it does not attract an equal quantity of the phlogistic principle * .
* It is of no consequence in the above argument , whether we suppose , with Dr. PRIESTLEY , that the alteration of colour in the blood depends upon its combination with phlogiston in the capillary arteries , or maintain with some other philosophers that this alteration arises from a change produced in the blood itself by the action of the vessels ; it is sufficient for our purpose to assume it as a fact , which , I think , has been proved by direct experiment , that , in the natural state of the animal , the blood undergoes a change in the capillaries , by which its capacity for containing heat diminished ; and that in a heated medium it does not undergo a similar change .
It follows , that the quantity of heat given off by the blood in the capillaries will not be equal to that which it had absorbed in the greater vessels , or positive cold will be produced .
If the blood , for example , in its passage to the capillaries , absorb from the greater vessels a quantity of heat as 30~ , and if in consequence of its receiving a less impregnation of phlogiston than formerly , it give off at the extreme vessels a quantity of heat only as 20~ , it is manifest , that upon the whole a degree of refrigeration will be produced as 10~ , and this cause of refrigeration will continue to act while the venous blood is gradually assuming the hue of the arterial , till the difference between them is obliterated ; after which it will cease to operate .
Thus it appears , that when animals are placed in a warm medium , the same process which formerly supplied them with heat becomes for a time the instrument of producing cold , and probably preserves them from such rapid alterations of temperature as might be fatal to life .
Upon the whole , the increased evaporation , the diminution of that power by which the blood in the natural state is impregnated with phlogiston , and the constant reflux of the heated fluids towards the internal parts , seem to be the great causes upon which the refrigeration depends .
Having found that the attraction of the blood to phlogiston was diminished by heat , it appeared probable , on the other hand , that it would be increased by cold .
To determine this , a dog at 100~ was immersed in water nearly at 45~ .
In about a quarter of an hour a small quantity of blood was taken from the jugular vein , which was evidently much deeper in its colour than that which had been taken in the warm bath , and appeared to me , as well as to several other gentlemen , to be the darkest venous blood we had ever seen .
From this experiment , compared with those which have been recited above , we may perceive the reason why animals preserve an equal temperature , notwithstanding the great variations in the heat of the atmosphere , arising from the vicissitudes of the weather , and the difference of season and climate : for , as soon as by exposure to external cold , an unusual dissipation of the vital heat is produced , the blood , in the course of the circulation , begins to be more deeply impregnated with the phlogistic principle .
It will therefore furnish a more copious supply of this principle to the air in the lungs , and will imbibe a greater quantity of fire in return .
In summer , on the contrary , the reverse of this will take place , less phlogiston will be attracted in the minute vessels , and less fire will be absorbed from the air .
And hence the power of generating heat is in all cases proportioned to the demand .
It is increased by the winter colds , diminished by the summer heats : it is totally suspended or converted into a contrary power , according as the exigencies of the animal may require .
From the changes which are produced in the colour of the venous blood by heat and cold , we may likewise perceive the reason why the temperature of the body is frequently increased by plunging suddenly into cold water , and why the warm bath has such powerful effects in cooling the system , and in removing a general or partial tendency to inflammation .

