X. Astronomical Observations on the Rotation of the Planets round their Axes , made with a View to determine whether the Earth 's diurnal Motion is perfectly equable .
In a Letter from Mr. William Herschel of Bath to William Watson , M. D. F. R. S. Read January 11 , 1781 .
SIR , Bath , October 18 , 1780 .
THE various motions of the planet we inhabit ; the annual revolution in its orbit ; the diurnal rotation round its axis ; the menstrual motion round the common center of gravity of the moon and earth ; the precession of the equinoctial points , the diminution of the obliquity of the ecliptic ; the nutation of the earth 's axis : in short , every one of the motions that arise from the actions of the sun , moon , and planets , combined with the spheroidical figure of the earth , and the projectile and rotatory motions first impressed upon it , have all been considered by astronomers , and their real and apparent inequalities investigated .
And to the great honour of modern astronomers it must be confessed , that no science has ever made such considerable strides towards perfection in so short a time as astronomy has done since the invention of the telescope .
There is one of the motions of the earth however which , it seems , has hitherto escaped the scrutiny of observers ; I mean the diurnal rotation round its axis .
The principal reason why this has not been looked into , is probably the difficulty of finding a proper standard to measure it by ; since it is itself used as the standard by which we measure all the other motions .
We have , indeed , no cause to suspect any very material periodical irregularity , either diurnal , menstrual , or annual ; for the great perfection of our present time-pieces would have discovered any considerable deviation from that equability which we have hitherto ascribed to the diurnal motion of the earth .
And yet , it is not perhaps altogether impossible but that inequalities may exist in this motion which , in an age where observations are carried to such a degree of refinement , may be of some consequence .
To show how far time-keepers , though ever so perfect , are from being a proper , or at least a sufficient , standard to examine the diurnal motion of the earth by , I may ask , whether it is probable , that any clock would have discovered to us the aberration of the fixed stars ?
And yet that aberration produces a change in longitude , and of consequence in right ascension , which causes an annual irregularity in a star 's coming to the meridian , which a time-piece , were it a sufficient standard , would soon have discovered , and which we might have attributed to an inequality of the earth 's diurnal motion , had we not been acquainted with its real cause .
And if we were to find out any apparent irregularity , acceleration , or retardation , should we not much rather suspect the clock than the diurnal motion ?
I may therefore venture to say , that the aberration of the fixed stars , though attended with the above mentioned consequence , would for ever have remained a secret to us , if it had not been found out by other methods than time-keepers .
Now , if time-pieces do fail us in this critical case , where we stand in the greatest need of their assistance , it is almost in vain to expect any help from another quarter ; for what mechanical movement on earth , or motion of the heavens , is there that can measure out such equal portions of time as we require to compare the diurnal motion of the earth to ?
However , to proceed , since we have already great proofs that the diurnal motion of the earth is , if not perfectly equable , at least more so than any other motion we are acquainted with , it will not appear absurd to suppose the diurnal rotation of the other planets to be so likewise .
This suggested to me the thoughts of estimating the diurnal motion of one planet very exactly by that of another , making each the standard of the other .
In this manner we may obtain a comparative view , by which future astronomers , if they shall hereafter be inclined to pursue the subject , may be enabled to make some estimate of the general equability of the rotatory motions of the planets .
For if in length of time they should perceive some small retardation in the diurnal motion of a planet occasioned by some resistance of a very subtle medium in which the heavenly bodies perhaps move ; or , on the other hand , if there should be found an acceleration from some cause or other , they might then ascribe the alteration either to the diurnal motion of the earth , or to the gyration of the other planet , according as circumstances , or observed phenomenon , should make one or the other of these opinions most probable .
Now , this method of comparing together different rotations of several planets , simple as it may appear , was not without some difficulties .
In the first place it was evident , that the common account of their diurnal motions * , which makes that * Venus spatio 23 horarum gyrationem circa axem ab occidente in orientem perficit .
Mars similem rotationem , horis 24 min. 40 absolvit .
Macularum revolutionibus saepius observatis , Ds .
CASSINI comperuit periodum Jovis circa proprium Axem esse horarum 9 , minutorum 56 .
KEILL , Ast .
Lect. V. of Jupiter 9 h. 56~ of Mars 24 h. 40~ , how true soever it may be in a general way , was much too inaccurate for this critical purpose .
The gyration of Venus was still less to be depended upon , being only noted to the hour without the minutes : it became , therefore , necessary to proceed to observations of a more determinate kind .
From what I had already seen of the rotation of the planets , I concluded , that Mars on several accounts would be the most eligible planet for my purpose : for the spots on Jupiter change so often that it is not easy , if at all possible , to ascertain the identity of the same appearance , for any considerable length of time .
Nor do the dark spots only change their place , which may be supposed to be large black congeries of vapours and clouds swimming in the atmosphere of Jupiter ; but also the bright spots , though they may adhere firmly to the body of Jupiter , may undergo some apparent change of situation by being differently covered or uncovered on one side or the other , by alterations in the belts .
It will be seen hereafter , that I have observed the revolution of a very bright spot , not suspected of any change of situation , to be first , by one set of observations , at the rate of 9 h. 51~ 45~,6 ; and afterwards , by another set immediately following at the rate of 9 h. 50~ 48~ .
As the principal belts on Jupiter are equatorial , and as we have certain constant winds upon our planet , especially near the equator , that regularly , for certain periods , blow the same way * , it is easily supposed , that they may form equatorial belts by gathering together the vapours which swim in our atmosphere , and carrying them about in the same direction .
This will , by analogy , account for all the irregularities of Ju* See Acta Eruditorum , 1687 .
Dr. HALLEY'S Account of periodical Winds .
piter 's revolutions , deduced from spots on his disk that may have changed their situation ; for if we suppose the rotation of Jupiter , according to CASSINI , to be 9 h. 56~ then some spots that I have observed must have been carried through about 60~ of Jupiter 's equator in 22 of his revolutions or days .
This would certainly be a very great velocity in the clouds , which is , however , not unparalleled by what has happened in our own atmosphere .
But to return to my purpose : on the planet Mars we see spots of a disserent nature ; their constant and determined shape , as well as remarkable colour , show them to be permanent and sastened the body of the planet .
These will give the revolution of his equator to a great certainty , and by a great number of revolutions , to a very great exactness also .
Supposing then , that , by a method I shall hereafter describe , we can determine whether a spot on the disk of Mars is , or is not , in the line which joins the center of the earth and the center of that planet , to half an hour 's time with certainty ( I believe ten or twelve minutes will be found sufficient for that purpose ) , in this case we shall in 30 days have the revolution true to a minute ; and , by continuing these observations for three months , we shall have it to 20~ .
When we are so far certain , we can easily arrive to a much greater degree of exactness ; for as we now can no longer mistake a whole revolution , if we take the time of any particular spot 's being in the line which joins the centers of the planets during one opposition of Mars , and take the same again at or near the next opposition , we shall have an interval of about 780 days , which will give the diurnal motion of that planet true to about 2~ .
The next opposition will give it to one , and so forth ; by which means , and by taking a proper number of such periods , we may determine the rotation of Mars to as great an exactness as we shall think necessary for the purpose of our comparative view .
Had such observations as these been made two thousand , or perhaps only so many hundred years ago , we might now , by repeating them , most probably become acquainted with some curious minute changes of the solar system that have hitherto passed unnoticed .
There is a certain circumstance which would almost create a suspicion that there has been some retardation in the diurnal motion of the earth .
The difference between the equatorial and polar diameters of the earth , by actual measurement has been found to be about 36 English miles and 9 tenths ; but by a calculation wherein the present rotation is made use of it will only amount to about 33 miles and 8 tenths : from which it should seem probable , that when the earth assumed the present form , the diurnal rotation was somewhat quicker than it is at present , by which means the centrifugal force bore a greater proportion to the force of gravity to which it is contrary , and thus occasioned a higher elevation of the equatorial parts .
But I would not lay much stress upon this argument ; for , in the calculation , it has been supposed , that the earth is nearly of an equal density at the surface and towards the center , which it seems is not agreeable to some late curious experiments and calculations that have been made under the conduct of the Astronomer Royal upon the attraction of a mountain * , the result of which ought now to be taken into consideration , and the calculation repeated .
If all the data could be exactly depended upon , it would be practicable enough from the laws of * See Mr. HUTTON'S Account of the Calculations made from the Survey and Measures taken at Schehallien , in order to ascertain the mean Density of the Earth .
Phil. Trans 1778 .
gravity , and the present rotation and given form of the earth , to find the centrifugal force required to produce that form , and thence to show what must have been its diurnal motion when it assumed the same .
However , these are researches that in my present situation I neither have opportunity nor perhaps ability enough to investigate properly ; and which , therefore , I hope some of our excellent mathematicians will think worth while to look into .
I shall now relate my observations on Jupiter and Mars .
The telescopes I used are of my own construction ; and are , a twenty-feet Newtonian reflector , a ten-feet reflector of the same form , and a seven-feet reflector already mentioned in my paper on the mountains of the moon .
My time I gained by equal altitudes taken with a brass quadrant of two-feet radius , carrying a telescope which magnifies about 40 times ; for the correction of altitudes taken of the sun I used DE LA LANDE'S tables .
I kept my time by two very good pieces ; one having a deal pendulum-rod , the other a compounded one of brass and iron , both having a proper contrivance not to stop when winding up .
The rate of going of my clocks I determined by the transit of stars .
Observations on Jupiter in the year 1778 .
February 24 .
Clock 1~ 10~ too soon .
About 9 o'clock I saw a bright belt on one part of the disk of Jupiter , see tab .
V. fig. 1 .
About 10 o'clock it was advanced as far as the center , fig. 2 .
11 h. The white belt still more advanced , fig. 3 .
11 h. 25~ .
It approached towards the edge of the disk ; and at 12 h. was extended all over , as in fig. 4 .
February 25 .
8 h. The same bright belt I observed yesterday extends all over .
8 h. 45~ .
It is divided by a darkish spot , situated at some distance from the center , as in fig. 5 .
9 h. 5~ .
The small dark division is advanced a little farther than the center , as in fig. 6. .
9 h. 23~ .
The spot is visibly advanced a considerable deal farther .
March 2 .
8 h. 2~ .
The darkish spot , with some alteration in its shape , is now in the middle of the disk , see fig. 7 .
March 3 .
10 h. 34~ .
The bright belt on the south of the equator is now in the middle ; that is to say , if a line be drawn perpendicular to the equatorial belt , and through the center , the end of the equatorial belt now touches it , fig. 8 .
13 h. 49~ .
The darkish spot , in which there has been some alteration since yesterday , seems now to be in the center , fig. 9 .
March 14 .
The clock altered to true equated time ; but the rate of going not changed , being well regulated .
7 h. 35~ .
The spot is now in the center , but does not seem quite to fill the white belt ; nor is it so large and distinct as it was before , fig. 10 .
April 7 .
9 h. 31~ .
There are three dark spots in the equatorial belt nearly in the center , see fig. 11 .
April 12 .
7 h. 50~ .
The three dark spots are in the center .
The sourthernmost of the three is nearly quite vanished ; the other two are also much fainter .
They are , however , distinct enough to be known , fig. 12 .
Observations on Jupiter in 1779 .
April 14 .
Clock 52~ too late .
8 h. 48~ A remarkable bright spot in the equatorial belt towards the north is in the center , see fig. 18 .
8 h. 58~ .
The spot is a little past the center .
April 19 .
Clock true mean time .
7 h. 10~ .
There is a bright spot just now in the center , which , from its shape , I take to be the same that was there April 14th .
7 h. 20~ .
The spot is visibly past the center .
April 23 .
Clock shows true time .
9 h. 38~ .
The same bright spot is in the center .
9 h. 43~ .
It is past the center .
Memorandum , my timepiece may be depended upon to a few seconds .
It will not be amiss to observe , that the spots , as well as a great many other phenomenon , were watched as they came on , passed over the center , and went off the disk of Jupiter ; but I have only selected those observations that were necessary to my present purpose .
Comparing together the observations that were made in the year 1778 , February 24th and March 3d , we obtain an interval of 7 days 34 minutes , which being divided by 17 revolutions made by Jupiter on his axis , we have the time of one synodical revolution equal to 9 h. 54~ 56~,4 .
The dark spot on February 25 was observed some time before , and also just after it was past the center ; therefore I have supposed it to be in the center about 8 h. 58~ : and we have , D. H. M. February 25 8 58 March 282 Divided by 12 rev .
4 23 4 1 revolution =9 h. 55~ 20~ February 25 8 58 March 3 13 49 15 revol .
64 51 1 revolution =9 h. 55~ 24~ .
February 25 8 58 0 March 14 7 36 10 allowing 1~ 10~ for the alt .
of the clock .
41 revol .
16 22 38 10 1 revolution =9 h. 55~ 4~,6 .
March 282 3 13 49 1 revol .
15 47 1 revolution =9 h. 55~ 40~ .
March 2820 14 7 36 10 29 revol .
11 23 34 10 1 revolution =9 h. 54~ 58~ , 2 .
D. H. M. S. March 3 13 49 0 14 7 36 10 Divided by 26 rev .
10 17 47 10 1 revolution =9 h. 54~ 53~,4 .
April 79 31 12 7 50 12 revol .
4 22 29 1 revolution =9 h. 51~ 35~ .
Again , comparing together the observations of 1779 , which were made with the utmost attention to time , we have , April 14 8 48 52 April 19 7 10 0 12 revol .
4 22 21 8 1 revolution =9 h. 51~ 45~6 .
April 19 7 10 April 23 9 38 10 revol .
42 28 1 revolution =9 h. 50~ 48~ .
And taking both together , April 14 8 48 52 April 23 9 38 0 22 revol .
90 49 8 1 revolution =9 h , 51~ 19~,4 .
These several results are so exceedingly various , that it is evident Jupiter is not a proper planet for the critical purpose of a comparative view of the diurnal motions ; nor can this great variety proceed from any inaccuracy in the observations : for , in my opinion , it is not well possible to make a mistake in the situation of a spot that shall amount to so much as five minutes of time .
The observation of April 23 , 1779 , was made with a view to ascertain this point , when it was found that five minutes of time made a sensible difference in the situation of a spot when near the center .
If we reduce the synodical revolutions to sidereal ones , the result will be so little different from the above , that I have not thought it worth while to do it in this place .
By a comparison of the different periods it appears , that a spot which is carried about in the atmosphere of Jupiter generally suffers an acceleration , or , which is the same thing , performs its revolutions by degrees in less time than it did at first ; for the spot observed in 1778 moved at the following rates .
From February 25 .
to March 2 .
in 9 h. 55~ 20~ ; to March 3 .
nearly the same ; to March 14 .
in 9 h. 55~ 4~ ; from March 2 .
to March 3 .
in 9 h. 55~ 40~ ; to March 14 .
in 9 h. 54~ 58~ ; from March 3 .
to March 14 .
in 9 h. 54~ 53~ .
In 1779 a spot moved from April 14 .
to April 19 .
at the rate of 9 h. 51~ 45~ ; to April 23 .
in 9 h. 51~ 24~ ; and from April 19 .
to April 24 .
in 9 h. 50~ 48~ ; all which is agreeable enough to the theory of equatorial winds , since it may probably take up sometime before a spot can acquire a sufficient velocity to go as fast as those winds may blow .
And , by the by , if Jupiter 's spots should be observed in different parts of his year , and be found in some to be accelerated , in others to be retarded , it would almost amount to a demonstration of his monsoons and their periodical changes ; but if his axis should not be inclined enough to his orbit , to occasion such a change , they may probably always blow in the same direction .
Observations on Mars in the year 1777 .
Twenty-feet Newtonian reflector ; power 300 .
April 8 .
7 h. 30~ .
I observed two spots upon Mars , with a bright belt or partition between them .
The belt was not very well defined , see tab .
VI .
fig. 14 .
9 h. 30~ .
The spots are advanced , and more spotted parts are visible , fig. 15 .
10 h. The revolution of Mars on his axis is now very evident , fig. 16 .
April 17 .
Ten-feet Newtonian reflector ; power about 211 .
7 h. 50~ .
Mars appeared as in fig. 17 .
At a and b there were two bright spots , so luminous that they seemed to project beyond the disk .
At c and d there were two very dark spots , joined by a lesser black line in the middle , which however was crossed at e and f by a very faint whitish partition .
April 26 .
Ten-feet reflector ; power 211 .
9 h. 5~ .
The spots on the planet are very faint , and much about as in fig. 18 .
April 27 .
Ten-feet reflector ; power 324 .
8 h. 40~ .
The evening very fine : my telescope in complete order .
The spots as in fig.19 .
Observations on Mars in the year 1779 .
May 9th .
Clock 15~ too fast ; by equal altitudes on the 14th of April , and by the transit of a star , is found to lose 1 ',45 per day .
11 h. 1~ by the clock , I found the situation of the spots on Mars as in figure 20 ; there is a very remarkable dark spot not far from the center .
11 h. 30~ .
The figures are gone from the center .
May 11 .
Clock 12~ too fast .
10 h. 18~ .
The same spot that was visible May 9 .
is on the disk , the darkest place being entirely south-east of the center , see fig. 21 .
11 h. 43~ .
The darkest part is almost arrived at the center , fig. 22 .
12 h. 17~ .
The dark spot is with its edge just near the center , as in fig. 23 .
May 13 .
Seven-feet reflector ; power 222 .
Clock 9~ too fast .
11 h. 26~ .
Mars seems now to be in the same situation he was the 11th , at 10 h. 8~ .
May 22 .
Clock 4~ too slow .
12 h. 5~ .
The figure of May 11th is not on the disk ; but some other fainter spots are visible .
The air is full of vapours .
June 6 .
The clock set by ten equal altitudes taken to-day , and by the transit of ~ Scorpii loses 1~,9 per day .
What I have perhaps improperly called a transit is the occultation of a star passing behind the perpendicular edge of a high building at about 40 yards distance , observed with a fixed telescope directed to the place where it vanishes .
10 h. 10~ .
The same figure is upon the disk of Mars which was there April 8 , 1777 , at 7 h. 30~ .
June 15 .
Clock 17~ too slow .
9 h. 45~ .
The same figure is upon Mars that was there May 9 .
at 11 h. 1~ ; but it is more advanced .
I suppose it to be the same , and in the same situation , as April 17 , 1777 , at 7 h. 50~ .
June 17 .
Clock 20~ slow .
9 h. 12~ .
The dark spot on Mars is rather more advanced than it was May 11th , at 10 h. 18~ .
10 h. The spot is visibly advanced : I suppose it will take near an hour to come to the center .
10 h. 15~ .
A very thick fog obscures the sky .
11 h. 15~ .
The same darkness .
June 19 .
Clock 22~ too slow by the transit of ~ Scorpii observed this evening .
8 h. 40~ .
The figure on the disk of Mars appears now to be as it was April 26 , 1777 , at 9 h. 5~ , see fig. 18 .
11 h. 30~ .
The figure of May 11 .
which I have been hitherto watching , is not come to the position it was then at 11 h. 43~ , but cannot be far from it .
I fear , as Mars approaches the horizon , I shall not be able to follow him till the figure comes to the center .
11 h. 47~ .
The state of the air near the horizon is very unfavourable .
With much difficulty I can but just see that the figure is not quite so far advanced as it was May 11th , at 11 h. 43~ , but can certainly not be above two or three minutes from it .
11 h. 51~ .
The undulation of the air prevents all further observation .
Let us now examine the result of the above mentioned observations : comparing together the two following short intervals of the year 1779 , we have , D. H. M. S. From May 9 11 0 45 to May 11 12 16 48 Divided by 2 revol .
21 16 3 Gives 1 revolution = 24 h. 38~ 1~ , 5 .
A second small interval .
May 11 10 17 48 13 11 25 51 2 revol .
2183 1 revolution = 24 h. 34~ 1~ , 5 .
Here we have two very short intervals that agree to 4~ , which is more than we could have expected in such short periods of time .
Comparing together observations that were made at a greater distance , we find , First monthly period , May 11 10 17 48 allowing 3~ because the obs .
says the June 17 99 20 spot was rather more advanced .
36 revol .
36 22 51 32 1 revolution = 24 h. 38~ 5~ , 9 .
Second monthly period , May 11 11 42 48 allowing 3~ for the time the spot would have June 19 11 50 22 taken to come to the place mentioned .
38 revol .
39 07 34 1 revolution = 24 h. 38~ 5~ , 4 .
Third monthly period , D. H. M. S. May 13 11 25 51 June 17 99 20 34 revol .
34 21 43 29 1 revolution = 24 h. 38~ 20~,3 This last is , perhaps , as likely to be near the truth as any , since the same spot was here observed for the third time , and therefore its motion become more familiar .
Here we have three longer periods that agree to fifteen seconds , which is quite sufficient for extending the interval of time to those observations that were made in the year 1777 .
But as these are the synodical revolutions , it will be necessary first to reduce them to sidereal rotations .
In figure 24 .
let us suppose the orbit of Mars , MAB C , to be in the same plane with the orbit of the earth , EDFG ; and the axis of Mars to be perpendicular to his orbit .
Let M , E , m , e , be the situations of Mars and the earth on the 13th of May and 17th of June ; then will the line EM , that connects the centers of Mars and the earth , point out the geocentric place of Mars on the 13th of May ; and the line em , the geocentric place of the same planet on the 17th of June .
Draw er and ms parallel to ER ; then will er point out the geocentric place of Mars on the 13th of May ; and the angle sme is equal to the angle mer. Now , by an ephemeris * the geocentric place of Mars , May 13 .
at 11 h. 26~ was 7 s. 20 d. 59~ 21~ ; * The Nautical Almanac gives the geocentric place of Mars only to every sixth day ; for which reason I used WHIT E'S Ephemeris , where it is given for every day , though perhaps not with so much exactness as I could wish .
and on the 17th of June , at 9 h. 9~ , it was 7s 12 d. 27~ 22~ , by which we obtain the difference or angle rem=ems= 8 d. 31~ 59~ .
Now a spot on Mars , situated in the direction ME , will have made a sidereal revolution when it returns to the same , or a parallel direction ms .
From which we gather , that the spot on the 17th of June , after coming to the line me , where it finishes the synodical revolution , will have to go through an arch of 8 d. 31~ 59~ , in order to arrive into the direction of the line ms , where it finishes the sidereal rotation .
The time it will take to go through this arch , at the sidereal rate of 24 h. 39~ 20~ to 360 degrees , or 4~ , 109 per minute of a degree , will be 35~ 3~ , 8 ; this being divided by the numbers of revolution 34 , gives 1~ 1~ , 8 ; which , added to 24 h. 38~ 20~ , 3 , gives us 24 h. 39~ 22~ , 1 for the sidereal revolution of Mars , as found by the third of the monthly periods .
This quantity will help us to find a proper divisor for the three following long biennial periods .
It is to be observed , that Mars has been retrograde in the above example , for which reason the measure of the angle ems was to be added to the synodical revolution when we wanted to find the sidereal rotation ; but if he had been direct , or if his place had been more advanced in the ecliptic than that to which we compared it , as at ~ , then the line ~~ parallel to EM would be the direction to which the spot should return , in order to accomplish a sidereal revolution , and therefore the quantity of the angle ~~e = ~er , or difference of the geocentric places ought to be subtracted from the synodical revolution to obtain the sidereal one .
D. M. S. First biennial period , 1777 , April 87 30 1779 , June 6 10 10 789 2 40 The geocentric places of Mars at those times were , S. D. ~~ 66 31 26 7 13 48 30 17 17 4 turned into time at 4~ , 109 per minute of a degree and subtracted , because Mars is more advanced in the ecliptic , is 789 2 40 0 2 33 11,8 Divided by 768 rev .
789 06 48,2 1 revolution = 24 h. 39~ 23~ , 03 .
D. H. M. S. Second biennial period , 1777 , April 17 7 50 0 1779 , June 15 9 45 17 789 1 55 17 S. D. ~~ Geocentric places 63 31 27 7 12 40 23 198 56 Turned into time 789 1 55 17 and subtracted 2 40 52 768 revol .
788 23 14 25 1 revolution = 24 h. 39~ 18 , ' ' 94 .
D. H. M. S. Third biennial period , 1777 , April 26 950 1779 , June 19 8 40 22 783 23 35 22 S. D. ~~ Geocentric places 61 24 36 7 12 31 48 1 11 7 12 Turned into time 783 23 35 22 and subtracted 2 45 15,6 763 revol .
783 20 50 6,4 1 revolution = 24 h. 39~ 23~ , 04 .
As these three periods are supported by observations of equal validity , I shall take a mean of them all for the nearest approximation to the true sidereal revolution of Mars on his axis , which therefore is 24 h. 39~ 21~ , 67 .
It remains now only to see how far we may depend upon this determination of Mars 's diurnal rotation as coming near the truth ; and looking over those causes which may possibly produce any errors , we find , first of all , that in the long biennial periods a mistake in the number of revolutions would produce a considerable deviation from truth .
Secondly , in the observations of a spot which moves so slow , we are also liable to some considerable mistake in estimating the time when it comes to a certain place ; and the more so , if that place is not the center .
Lastly , the time itself is liable to inaccuracy .
As to the first , it appears from the three monthly periods observed in the year 1779 , when the proper allowances for the geocentric places are made , that the sidereal revolution of Mars cannot well be less than 24 h. 39~ 5~ , nor more than 24 h. 39~ 22~ ; but if we should divide any one of the three biennial periods by a supposed number of revolutions , only one more or one less than we have done , the difference would be so considerable , that nothing but a mistake in every one of the three monthly periods , of at least one whole hour , could justify such a supposition ; and that such a mistake in the situation of a spot on Mars cannot have been made in those observations , I think , is evident enough from the exactness with which they were made , and from their agreement with each other .
The second cause of error , which is the uncertainty in assigning the exact time when a spot comes to the center , is of some force .
But it seems to me highly probable , from the manner in which I have seen the spots on Mars pass over the disk of that planet , that there can hardly be so great an error as 10~ in an observation of any remarkable spot 's coming to the center .
However , not being willing to trust more to the eye than I ought to do , I had recourse to the following experiment .
I drew several circles of one inch radius , taking care to make no visible impression of a center ; and placed in each a fine point at the several distances of.0424,.0636,.0848 , in ten thousands of an inch from the real center ; some to the right , others to the left .
These measures are the sines to radius one , of 2~ 26~ , 3~ 39~ , and 4~ 52~ , which are the arches a spot on Mars passes over in 10 , 15 , 20~ minutes respectively .
I exposed them to several persons unacquainted with my designs , and found , that not one of them made a single mistake in saying whether the point was , or was not , in the center of the circle , and which way it deviated from it .
As the direction of the motion of a spot on Mars is known , I thought the persons who were to judge of the place of the points were entitled to be acquainted with the line in which they were placed , which for that reason was always to the right and left only .
The points that answer to the excentricity of 15 and 20~ are indeed so visibly out of the center , that I believe we may safely say , that any mistake , in estimating the time of a spot on Mars coming to the center , cannot well exceed a quarter of an hour at the outside .
As for the third and last occasion of error , the time itself , I believe my manner of obtaining and keeping it in the year 1779 will appear satisfactory , and may , I think , be depended upon to a few seconds ; but the observations of the year 1777 , indeed , are far from having the same advantage .
I was not then provided with an altitude instrument , therefore set my clock by a good sun-dial , with the equation of time contained in the Nautical Almanac , and found it to agree generally to a minute or two with the time calculated for the eclipses of Jupiter 's first satellite , as I deduced it for Bath from the Nautical Almanac .
However , it was certainly liable to an error of several minutes ; therefore , allowing no less than 10~ for the clock in 1777 , and 20~ for an error in estimating the situation of a spot in 1779 , it will both amount to half an hour : then , if we take a mean of the three numbers , whereby we have divided the three biennial periods , we have 766 1/ 3 ; and half an hour , divided by 766 1/ 3 , will therefore give us the quantity to which , it seems , can amount , all the uncertainty in the sidereal diurnal rotation of Mars , which is 2~ , 34 .
A nearer approximation to truth I hope to obtain at the next opposition , which will happen about the middle of July 1781 .
I have ventured to calculate the times for that opposition , when the edge of the remarkable dark spot will be seen near the center , as it is in figure 23 , or , which is the same thing , as it was the 11th of May 1779 , at 12 h. 17~ .
The spot not being visible at the time of the opposition , I have taken the nearest period , before and after , in which it will pass over the disk .
There is , however , a circumstance which may make the appearance of the spot not quite similar to the figure I have drawn , even though the rotations should perfectly answer as to the times ; for the position of the axis of Mars being still in some measure unknown , I could make no allowance for a change , which a difference in the situation of no less than two signs may occasion , though in all probability it will not be very considerable .
Those who are provided with proper telescopes will have an opportunity to see how far the calculated times agree with the spot 's appearance ; and it is by this means I also hope to correct and improve the tables I have drawn up for this purpose , and further to approximate to a true theory of the gyration of this planet .
Not knowing the exact difference of meridians between Greenwich and this place , I have calculated the spot 's appearance for the meridian of Bath .
From an eclipse or two of Jupiter 's satellites , of which , by the favour of the Rev. Mr. HORNSBY , I have seen correspondent observations , I suppose the difference cannot be much less than 9~ west of Greenwich ; and at the same time I join an account of the solar eclipse of the 24th of June 1778 , which may be depended upon as a very complete observation , and may serve to ascertain the longitude of this place .
Eclipse of the sun observed at Bath .
June 24 , 1778 .
H. M. S. Beginning by equated or mean time , 3 30 10,7 End , 5 18 7,7 Calculations , or ( as the principles on which they are founded are still established upon a few observations only , and require some time for mature confirmation ) I would rather , if I might be allowed the expression , call them calculated conjectures of the times when the remarkable dark spot will be seen near the center of the disk of Mars .
For June , July , and August , of the year 1781 .
D. H. M. S. D. H. M. S. June 28 9 48 39 July 8 16 13 23 29 10 27 10 August 38 11 6 30 11 5 42 48 49 57 July 1 11 44 13 59 28 48 2 12 22 32 6 10 7 39 3 13 0 51 7 10 46 31 4 13 39 10 8 11 25 44 5 14 17 29 9 12 4 56 6 14 55 46 10 12 44 8 7 15 34 4 I have the honour to be , &amp;c. Fig.5 .
Fig.6 .
Fig.7 .
Fig.10 .
Fig.11 .
Fig.12 .
3 .
Fig.4 .
Fig.8 .
Fig.9 .
Fig.17 .
Fig.18 .
Fig.19 .
a c f d e b Fig.20 .
Fig.21 .
Fig.22 .
Fig R r M Fig.24 .
m ~ E e s ~ ADGC F B

