XXII .
Experiments relating to Phlogiston , and the seeming Conversion of Water into Air .
By Joseph Priestley , LL. D. F. R. S. ; communicated by Sir Joseph Banks , Bart. P. R. S. Read June 26 , 1783 .
TO SIR JOSEPH BANKS , BART , P. R. S. DEAR SIR , AT the persuasion of my friends , I beg you would lay before the Royal Society my late observations on Phlogiston , and also on the seeming Conversion of water into air , though I have by no means done all that I have in view with respect to these subjects .
The principal facts are , I think , sufficiently ascertained , though I do not presume to give any opinion with respect to the theory of them .
I am , with the greatest respect , &amp;c. Birmingham , April 21 , 1783 .
Experiments relating to Phlogiston .
THERE are few subjects , perhaps none , that have occasioned more perplexity to chemists than that of phlogiston , or , as it is sometimes called , the principle of inflammability .
It was the great discovery of STAHL , that this principle , whatever it be , is transferrable from one substance to another , how different soever in their other properties , such as sulphur , wood , and all the metals , and therefore is the same thing in them all .
But what has given an air of mystery to this subject , has been that it was imagined , that this principle , or substance , could not be exhibited except in combination with other substances , and could not be made to assume separately either a fluid or solid form .
It was also asserted by some , that phlogiston was so far from adding to the weight of bodies , that the addition of it made them really lighter than they were before ; on which account they chose to call it the principle of levity .
This opinion had great patrons .
Of late it has been the opinion of many celebrated chemists , Mr. LAVOISIER among others , that the whole doctrine of phlogiston had been founded on mistake , and that in all cases in which it was thought that bodies parted with the principle of phlogiston , they in fact lost nothing , but on the contrary , acquired something ; and in most cases an addition of some kind of air ; that a metal , for instance , was not a combination of two things , viz. an earth and phlogiston , but was probably a simple substance in its metallic state ; and that the calx is produced not by the loss of phlogiston , or of any thing else , but by the acquisition of air .
The arguments in favour of this opinion , especially those which are drawn from the experiments of Mr. LAVOISIER made on mercury , are so specious , that I own I was myself much inclined to adopt it .
My friend Mr. KIRWAN , indeed , always held that phlogiston was the same thing with inflammable air ; and he has sufficiently proved this from many experiments and observations , my own as well as those of others .
I did not , however , accede to it till I discovered it by direct experiments , made with general and indeterminate views , in order to ascertain something concerning a subject which had given myself and others so much trouble .
I began with repeating the experiments in which I had found that inflammable air , made red-hot in flint glass tubes , gave them a black tinge , and was in a great measure absorbed , which I had discovered to be owing to the calx of lead in the glass attracting phlogiston from the inflammable air .
As the quantity of air in these tubes was very small , though I gave it as my opinion , that the residuum in one of the processes was phlogisticated air , because I perceived no marks of ascension on presenting to it the flame of a small candle ; I was not , on recollection , satisfied with this conclusion , and was desirous of repeating the experiment with more care , especially as , in one of the above-mentioned experiments , I found only a very small bubble of the inflammable air in the tube in which it had been heated .
I found , however , great difficulties in repeating these experiments ; and the quantity of inflammable air operated upon in them is necessarily so small , that the result is always liable to much uncertainty .
I thought , therefore , that throwing the focus of a burning lens upon a quantity of pounded flint glass , surrounded with inflammable air , or rather on the calx of lead alone , in the same circumstances , would be a much easier experiment , and might bring me nearer to my object ; and on making the experiment it immediately answered far beyond my expectation .
For this purpose , I put upon a piece of a broken crucible ( which could yield no air ) a quantity of minium , out of which all air had been extracted ; and placing it upon a convenient stand , introduced it into a large receiver , filled with inflammable air , confined by water .
As soon as the minium was dry , by means of the heat thrown upon it , I observed that it became black , and then ran in the form of perfect lead , at the same time that the air diminished at a great rate , the water ascending within the receiver .
I viewed this process with the most eager and pleasing expectation of the result , having at that time no fixed opinion on the subject ; and therefore I could not tell , except by actual trial , whether the air was decomposing in the process , so that some other kind of air would be left , or whethe it would be absorbed in toto .
The former I thought the more probable , as if there was any such thing as phlogiston , inflammable air , I imagined , consisted of it , and something else .
However , I was then satisfied that it would be in my power to determine , in a very satisfactory manner , whether the phlogiston in inflammable air had any base or not , and if it had , what that base was .
For seeing the metal to be actually revived , and that in a considerable quantity , at the same time that the air was diminished , I could not doubt but that the calx was actually imbibing something from the air ; and from its effects in making the calx into metal , it could be no other than that to which chemists had unanimously given the name of phlogiston .
Before this first experiment was concluded , I perceived , that if the phlogiston in inflammable air had any base , it must be very inconsiderable : for the process went on till there was no more room to operate without endangering the receiver ; and examining , with much anxiety , the air that remained , I found that it could not be distinguished from that in which I began the experiment , which was air extracted from iron by oil of vitriol .
I was therefore pretty well satisfied that this inflammable air could not contain any thing besides phlogiston ; for at that time I reduced about 45 ounce measures of the air to five .
In order to ascertain a fact of so much importance with the greatest care , I afterwards carefully expelled from a quantity of minium all the phlogiston , and every thing else that could have assumed the form of air , by giving it a red heat when mixed with spirit of nitre ; and immediately using it in the manner mentioned above , I reduced 101 ounce measures of inflammable air to two .
To judge of its degree of inflammability , I presented the flame of a small candle to the mouth of a phial filled with it , and observed , that it made thirteen separate explosions , though weak ones ( stopping the mouth of the phial with my finger after each explosion ) , when fresh made inflammable air , in the same circumstances , made only fourteen explosions , though stronger ones .
After this experiment I could not hesitate to conclude , that this inflammable air went totally , and without decomposition , into the lead which I formed at that time ; and if the necessary circumstances of the experiment be considered , it will be thought extraordinary that , even admitting this , the result should be so decisively clear in favour of it : for , in the first place , the greatest care must be used to expel all air from the minium , and it must be used before it can have atttacted any from the atmosphere ; and in the next place , the water also ( a considerable quantity of which must be used , and which will also be heated in the process ) should be made as free from air as possible .
In these circumstances , had I found the small residuum , of 2 ounce measures from 101 , to have been phlogisticated or fixed air , I should not have been disappointed ; and it would not have prevented my concluding that phlogiston was the same thing with inflammable air , contained in a combined state in metals , just as fixed air is contained in chalk and other calcareous substances ; both being equally capable of being expelled again in the form of air .
Afterwards using a calx of lead , which had been prepared in the same manner with the former , but which had remained some weeks exposed to the air , I found , that when by using it I had reduced 150 ounce measures of inflammable air to 10 , this residuum was phlogisticated air .
But examining this calx separately , I found that it gave , by heat in a glass vessel , a considerable quantity of phlogisticated air .
I must observe , that the minium should not be reduced to a perfectly compact glass of lead ; for then it would be too refractory to be easily revived by this process .
Making use of some of it , I found that I could only melt it ; but that a copious black fume came from it , and coated the inside of the receiver : an experiment which I shall repeat and re-consider .
I must also observe , that the lead which I procured in the above-mentioned process was not to be distinguished from any other lead , and that the inflammable air was all procured from iron by oil of vitriol .
When I made use of inflammable air from wood , I found , that though I was able to reduce minium with it , it was effected with more time and difficulty .
Forty ounce measures of this kind of inflammable air I reduced to 25 ; when I found that the heat of the lens produced only glass of lead , and no metal .
The air was still , however , inflammable ; and there was a small mixture of fixed air in it .
This kind of inflammable air , which burns with a lambent flame , I have some reason to think , consists of an intimate union of fixed air with that which is of the explosive kind extracted from metals .
The result of those experiments which I made with that kind of inflammable air which is collected in the process for making phosphorus , and which burns with a lambent yellow flame , was similar to those which I made with inflammable air from wood , which burns with a lambent white flame .
Having had this remarkable result with inflammable air , I immediately tried all the other kinds of air in the same manner ; but in none of them did I procure any thing from the minium besides glass of lead , except in alkaline air , and vitriolic acid air .
In fixed air , nitrous air , phlogisticated air , marine acid air , fluor acid air , as also in common and dephlogisticated air , I got no metal at all .
In vitriolic acid air there was but a small quantity of lead produced , and I have observed that this kind of air imparts a certain portion of phlogiston to common air , rendering it in some measure phlogisticated , though by no means in so great a degree as nitrous air .
Though nitrous air and phlogisticated air certainly contain phlogiston , they appear by these experiments to hold it too obstinately to part with it to minium in this process , though nitrous air quits it so readily to respirable air .
I would observe , that there were some peculiar appearances in the experiments I made to revive the calx of lead in these kinds of air in which the attempt did not succeed ; but I must repeat the experiments , and note the appearances more accurately , before I report them .
In alkaline air lead seems to be formed from the minium as readily as in inflammable air , and indeed I thought rather more so ; and this is a remarkable confirmation and illustration of these experiments , in which , by taking the electric spark in a quantity of alkaline air , I converted it into three times as much pure inflammable air ; an experiment which , on account of the extraordinary nature of it , I have repeated many times since I first published the account of it , and always with the same result .
This experiment also throws some light upon those in which , by super-phlogisticating iron with nitrous air , I produced a strong smell of volatile alkali ; an experiment which I have also frequently repeated with the same result .
The reviving of lead in alkaline air may also help us to conceive how all acids should have an affinity both to phlogiston and to alkalies , which have hitherto appeared to be things so very different from each other ; since , from these experiments , it is probable that one of them is some modification of the other , or a combination of something else with the other .
To trace the connection between the alkaline and inflammable principles , is a curious subject ; and from these hints it may , perhaps , not be very difficult to prosecute it to advantage .
It is evident , however , from the following experiments , that alkaline air is the compound and inflammable air , or phlogiston , the more simple substance of the two .
From 51/ 2 ounce measures of alkaline air I got , by means of litharge , 17 grains of lead , besides some that was dissolved in the mercury , by which the air was confined .
There remained 21/ 2 ounce measures , which appeared to be phlogisticated air , and to have no fixed air in it .
At another time , in eight ounce measures of alkaline air I got 15 grains of lead , besides what was dissolved in the mercury , which seemed to be a good deal in proportion to it .
It was observable , that there remained in this process 31/ 2 ounce measures of phlogisticated without any mixture of fixed air in it , though the massicot which I used at this time gave by heat only a good deal of pretty pure fixed air .
These experiments with alkaline air well deserve to be resumed , and I shall not fail to do it at a proper opportunity .
Having thus produced lead in inflammable air , I proceeded in my attempts to revive other metals from their calces by the same means ; and I succeeded very well with tin , bismuth , and silver ; tolerably well with copper , iron , and regulus of cobalt ; but not at all with regulus of antimony , regulus of arsenic , zinc , or the metal of manganese .
I was desirous also of ascertaining by this means the quantity of phlogiston that enters into the composition of the several metals ; but in this I found more difficulty than I had expected : and this arose chiefly from the allowance that was to be made for the inflammable air which entered into that part of the calx which was only partially revived ; and it was not easy to revive the whole of any quantity of calx completely .
After many trials , I think I may venture to say , that an ounce of lead absorbs 100 ounce measures of inflammable air , or perhaps something more ; for in one result it seemed to have imbibed in the proportion of 108 ounce measures .
An ounce of tin absorbs inflammable air in the proportion of 377 ounce measures to the ounce .
An ounce of copper from verditer absorbed 403 ounce measures ; from a solution of blue vitriol , precipitated by salt of tartar , and afterwards made redhot with spirit of nitre , 640 ; but from blue vitriol itself 909 ounce measures .
In this case , however , much of the inflammable air went to the formation of the vitriolic acid air , the smell of which was very perceivable in the course of the experiment .
The copper that I made in this way was brittle , and therefore seemed not to be perfectly metalized ; but being fuzed with borax it became perfect copper , and , as I think , without any loss of weight .
Bismuth absorbed inflammable air in the proportion of 185 ounce measures to the ounce .
The calx I used was a precipitate from the solution of this metal in spirit of nitre .
Iron I got from a precipitate of a solution of green vitriol by salt of tartar , moistened with spirit of nitre , and exposed to a red heat .
This calx absorbed in the proportion of 890 ounce measures of the inflammable air to an ounce of iron , which was in the form of a black powder ; but to all appearance as much attracted by the magnet as iron filings .
But it could not be expected , that perfect iron , containing its full proportion of phlogiston , should be produced in this manner , since inflammable air may be expelled from perfect iron in this very process .
Silver I evidently revived from a solution of it in spirit of nitre precipitated by salt of tartar , and also from luna cornea .
A quantity of this last substance absorbed 23 ounce measures of inflammable air ; but I could not get any calx of silver free from small grains of the perfect metal , which was easily discovered by a magnifier , and therefore I could not ascertain the quantity of inflammable air absorbed by it .
Small grains of regulus cobalt I produced from zaffre , and inflammable air was absorbed ; but I did not estimate the quantity .
A quantity of manganese absorbed 7 ounce measures of inflammable air ; but I could not perceive any thing in it which had the appearance of metal .
But I imagined I had not heat enough for the purpose , and mixing with it some calcined borax , I repeated the experiment , when there was again an evident absorbtion of air , and in the course of that experiment , I once thought that I did perceive a small globule of metal .
Zinc and arsenic were only sublimed in this process .
The same was the case with the glass of antimony ; but the experiment was attended with this peculiar circumstance , that when the glass was melted in inflammable air it formed itself into needle-like crystals arranged in a very curious manner , though I could not produce that appearance in other kinds of air .
Inflammable air being clearly imbibed by the calces of metals , and thereby reviving them , is a sufficient proof of its containing what has been called phlogiston ; and its being absorbed by them in toto , without decomposition , is a proof of its being nothing besides phlogiston in the form of air , unless there should be something solid deposited from it at the same time that the proper phlogistic part of it was absorbed .
With respect to this , I can only say that , in the course of the experiments , I did not perceive any thing of the kind : for though in some of the processes there was a black smoke produced , in others I could perceive nothing but part of the calx subliming , and clouding the glass .
On this account , however , I could not pretend to ascertain the weight of the inflammable air in the calx , so as to prove that it had acquired an addition of weight by being metallized , which I often attempted .
But were it possible to procure a perfect calx , no part of which should be sublimed and dispersed , by the heat necessarily to be made use of in the process , I should not doubt but that the quantity of inflammable air imbibed by it would sufficiently add to its weight .
Besides the formation of metals from their calces , I had other proofs , and of a nature sufficiently curious , of inflammable air containing phlogiston , though perhaps not sufficiently conclusive with respect to its being wholly and simply phlogiston itself .
Thus , by means of it , I was able to make phosphorus , nitrous air , liver of sulphur , and sulphur itself , in all of which phlogiston is acknowledged to be a principal ingredient .
Throwing the focus of the lens upon a quantity of that glassy matter which is made from calcined bones by oil of vitriol in inflammable air , some of it was absorbed , and all the inside of the receiver was covered with an orange-coloured substance , which had a strong smell of phosphorus .
I then wanted sun-shine to continue the experiment ; but I was satisfied that there was sufficient proof of phosphorus being actually formed in this manner .
With alkaline air I succeeded much better .
In 21/ 2 ounce measures of this air I produced , from the glassy matter mentioned above , 2 grains of phosphorus in one mass , the vessel being only filled with white fumes during the process .
One-fourth of the bulk of the air remained , and this was inflammable , burning with a yellow lambent flame , exactly like that which is produced in the process for making phosphorus .
That nitrous air contains phlogiston is sufficiently evident , if there be any such thing as phlogiston : and I have farther proved , that it contains as much phlogiston , in proportion to its bulk , as inflammable air itself .
I have now , however , the farther satisfaction to be able to make nitrous air from its two constituent principles , viz. nitrous vapour and inflammable air .
The most easy process for this purpose is , to throw a stream of nitrous vapour into a large phial previously filled with inflammable air .
In this manner nitrous air is instantly formed , and in great quantities ; but as this nitrous vapour is produced by the rapid solution of bismuth in spirit of nitre , which at the same time produces a quantity of nitrous air , the experiment is not quite unexceptionable .
I therefore attempted the same thing in the following manner .
Taking a quantity of what I have called a nitrated calx of lead , which I first produced by uniting nitrous vapour to minium ( in consequence of which , from being a red and powdery substance , it became white , compact , and brittle ) , I placed it upon a stand , in a receiver filled with inflammable air , and throwing the focus of the lens upon it , there was a diminution of the inflammable air , which amounted to about two-thirds of the whole , and during this time lead was revived from the calx .
After this there was no more diminution of the air , or revival of the calx : and then examining what remained of the air , I found it to be all strongly nitrous : and , from the circumstances in which it was produced , it must have been formed from the nitrous vapour contained in the calx , and the inflammable air in the receiver .
In order to ascertain the purity of this nitrous air , I mixed it with an equal quantity of common air , and found that they occupied the space of 1,32 measures .
Fresh nitrous air , made in the usual way , and mixed with common air in the same proportion , occupied the space of 1,26 .
This difference arose not from any impurity in the nitrous air , but from the mixture of the dephlogisticated air , which is also expelled from this calx by heat .
Liver of sulphur was procured by throwing the focus of the lens upon vitriolated tartar in inflammable air , and it appeared to be perfectly well formed .
Lastly , to produce sulphur , I threw the focus of the lens on a quantity of oil of vitriol , contained in an hollow earthen vessel , and evaporated it to dryness in a receiver filled with inflammable air , in consequence of which the inside of the receiver acquired a whitish incrustation , which when warmed had a strong smell of sulphur ; and repeating the process in the same receiver , I was able , this second time , to scrape off enough of the matter to put on a piece of hot iron , and to produce the genuine blue flame , as well as the peculiar smell of sulphur .
I shall conclude these observations on phlogiston with two articles ; one of which seems to contradict an established maxim among chemists ; and the other a former opinion of my own .
It is generally said , that charcoal is indestructible , except by a red heat in contact with air .
But I find that it is perfectly destructible , or decomposed , in vacuo , and by the heat of a burning lens almost wholly converted into inflammable air ; so that nothing remains besides an exceedingly small quantity of white ashes , which are seldom visible , except when , in very small particles , they happen to cross the sun-beam , as they fly about within the receiver .
It would be impossible to collect or weigh them ; but , according to appearance , the ashes thus produced from many pounds of wood could not be supposed to weigh a grain .
The great weight of ashes produced by burning wood in the open air arises from what is attracted by them from the air .
The air which I get in this manner is wholly inflammable , without the least particle of fixed air in it .
But , in order to this , the charcoal must be perfectly well made , or with such a heat as would expel all the fixed air which the wood contains ; and it must be continued till it yield inflammable air only , which , in an earthen retort , is soon produced .
Wood , or charcoal , is even perfectly destructible , that is , resolvable into inflammable air , in a good earthern retort , and a fire that would about melt iron .
In these circumstances , after all the fixed air had come over , I have several times continued the process during a whole day , in all which time inflammable air has been produced equally , and without any appearance of a termination .
Nor did I wonder at this , after seeing it wholly vanish into inflammable air in vacuo .
A quantity of charcoal made from oak , and weighing about an ounce , generally gave me about five ounce measures of inflammable air in twelve minutes .
The second article that I shall now mention affords an indisputable proof of the generation of fixed air from dephlogisticated air and phlogiston , or inflammable air .
I have several times given it as my opinion , that fixed air is a factitious substance , and a modification of the nitrous and vitriolic acids , my former experiments greatly favouring that conclusion ; but that it was composed of dephlogisticated air and phlogiston , though maintained by my friend Mr. KIRWAN , I was far from being satisfied with , till I was forced to consent to his proof of it from my own former experiments , and gave him leave to mention it , as he has done in his late excellent paper on salts .
But I have lately had two direct proofs of it by experiment .
The first was when , in repeating a beautiful experiment first made by Dr. INGEN-HOUSZ , but with some variation , I was firing some shavings of iron in dephlogisticated air confined by mercury , by means of a burning lens .
In this way I quickly fired the iron , and it burned away in a very pleasing manner .
But what struck me most was , that , of the air that remained , a considerable portion was fixed air , though in the receiver I had nothing but the purest dephlogisticated air , together with the iron , which could only give inflammable air .
I would observe , that the melted iron formed itself into large balls , which appeared to be a mere slag or glass , and was no longer iron .
Afterwards , to put this hypothesis concerning the constituent principles of fixed air to a more direct proof , I mixed iron filings , which gave only inflammable air , with red precipitate , which I found to give nothing but the purest dephlogisticated ; and when I heated them in a coated glass retort , they gave a great quantity of fixed air , in some portions of which nineteen-twentieths were absorbed by lime-water ; but the residuum was inflammable .
However , when I mixed with iron filings a quantity of powdered charcoal , which I had found to give only inflammable air , the fixed air produced from it was so pure , that only one-fortieth part of it remained unabsorbed by water ; so that this fixed air was as pure as that which is generally procured from chalk by oil of vitriol .
It appeared , in some of these experiments , that three ounce measures of dephlogisticated air go into the composition of two ounce measures of fixed air .
For one ounce of this red precipitate gave 60 ounce measures of dephlogistated air ; and when mixed with two ounces of iron filings , it gave about 40 ounce measures of fixed air that were actually absorbed by water , besides a residuum that was inflammable .
I had the same proportion when I used half an ounce of each of the materials .
But when I used one ounce of each , I got only 20 ounce measures of fixed air , including the residuum .
At other times I had different proportions with different quantities of iron filings and charcoal .
I cannot conclude these observations without taking notice , how very valuable an instrument in philosophy is a good burning lens .
This must have been perceived in many of my former experiments , but more especially in these .
By no other means can heat be given to substances in vacuo , or in any other kind of air besides atmospherical ; and without some method of doing this , no such experiments as these can possibly be made .
I therefore congratulate all the lovers of science on the successful attempt of Mr. PARKER to execute so capital an instrument as he has done of this kind .
Such spirited and generous exertions reflect honour on himself and on our country .
It is only to be wished , that we could have lenses of a smaller size ( viz. from 12 to 18 inches diameter ) made tolerably cheap , so that they might be in more common use .
All my experiments were made with one of 12 inches in diameter .
Experiments relating to the seeming Conversion of Water into Air .
SINCE many persons have expressed a wish to be acquainted with the experiments I have lately made , which at first seemed to favour the idea of a conversion of water into air , but which terminated in the discovery of a fact , in my opinion , still more extraordinary , I shall submit to the Royal Society the result of the observations I have already made ; though , as yet , I have by no means been able to satisfy myself so fully as I could wish with respect to some particulars connected with the subject .
All the facts which I shall state may be depended upon ; but it is probable , that different persons may draw different conclusions from them ; and to mere opinions I have never shown myself much attached .
Having formerly observed several remarkable changes in fluid substances , in consequence of long exposure to heat in glass vessels hermetically sealed ( of which an account may be seen in the fourth volume of my Philosophical Observations ) ; I then formed a design of exposing all kinds of solid substances to great heats , in a similar state of confinement ; and for that purpose provided myself with a cast-iron vessel , which I could close at one end , like a digester , and of such a length , that one of the ends might be red-hot , while the other was sufficiently cool to be handled .
To this end there was a cock connected to a tube , by means of which I could let off steam , or air , in any period of the process .
I imagined , that when substances consisting of parts so volatile as to fly off before they had attained any considerable degree of heat , in the usual pressure of the atmosphere , were compelled to bear great heats under a greater pressure , they might assume new forms , and undergo remarkable changes , similar to what we may suppose to be the case within the bowels of the earth , where , by means of subterraneous fires , various substances bear great heats under very great pressures .
I have had this instrument some years ; but it was so ill constructed , that I could not make the use of it that I had originally intended .
I therefore lately fitted up some gun-barrels in the same manner , and made my first experiment with limestone ; expecting , that when the fixed air , and other volatile matters , that might be contained in it , should be compelled to bear a red heat , without a possibility of making their escape , the substance itself might undergo some change ; but I had no particular expectation concerning the nature of that change .
I had , however , been so often favoured with valuable results from merely putting things into new situations , that I was encouraged to make the experiment ; but I found an unexpected difficulty in getting a cock that would be air-tight and steamtight under so great a pressure as I wished to apply .
I was mentioning these ideas to Mr. WATT , in whose neighbourhood I have the happiness to be situated , when he mentioned a similar idea of his , viz. that of the possibility of the conversion of water , or steam , into permanent air ; saying , that some appearances in the working of his fire-engine had led him to expect this .
He thought that if steam could be made red-hot , so that all its latent heat should be converted into sensible heat , either this or some other change would probably take place in its constitution .
The idea was new to me , and led me to attend more particularly to my former projects of a similar nature , and I began with lime-stone , wishing to try of effect of giving a red heat to lime in which water only should be previously combined , thinking it might possibly have the same effect with making the water itself red-hot .
Accordingly , I took a quantity of well calcined lime , and mixing with it a little water , out of which all air had been carefully boiled , I exposed it gradually to a strong heat in an earthen retort , such as I had been usually supplied with by Mr. WEDGWOOD ( who is as much distinguished by his love and generous encouragement of science , as he is by his improvements in his own curious art ) , not imagining that it could make any difference whether the lime , so prepared , should receive its heat in an earthen retort , or in a vessel of iron or glass .
Proceeding , however , in this manner , I found that nothing came over in the form of steam , but that there was a great quantity of air , several hundred times more than the bulk of the water , and at that time there was in it a considerable proportion of fixed air , which I imagined might either be that which had not been sufficiently expelled before , or might be composed of some phlogistic matter contained in the lime , and the purer air that was yielded by the water : for I own I then concluded , that the air which I got ( and which , when the fixed air was extracted from it , was such as a candle would just burn in ) came from the water , especially as in some of the processes , the weight of the air I caught was very nearly , if not quite equal to that of the water , and interposing a large glass balloon between the retort and the recipient for the air , I observed that it remained perfectly cool and dry during the whole process ; and several hours afterwards there was not the least moisture condensed in it .
I also received a quantity of another produce of air made in this manner in mercury , and having viewed it with the greatest attention , observed that , after several days , it never deposited the least moisture .
I then calcined a quantity of natural lime-stone with this glass balloon , interposed in the same manner , and found no water , but only air to come from it , though the stone is generally supposed to contain water .
But when I used much more than half an ounce of water to the quantity of whiting or lime above-mentioned , I always had some water come over , though very little in proportion to the quantity made use of .
I did not fail to examine whether there had been any loss in the weight of the lime , or whiting , in order to determine whether any part of these solid substances had entered into the composition of the air ; but I found much difficulty in weighing them with exactness , after shaking them out of an earthen retort , into which I could not see , and to which part of these earthy matters often adhered , so that I could not obtain much satisfaction even when I broke the retort .
Besides , there was always some loss of the earth in the cloudiness of the air , whenever the production of it was rapid .
In a future process I had abundant proof that the air did not come from any earthy matter with which the water had been combined .
Hitherto I had no idea but that all that was necessary to the conversion , as I concluded it to be , of water into air , was to give it a red heat , without which it would not quit the calcareous earth ; and I imagined by this means the matter or principle of heat was so intimately combined with it , as not to be separated from it by cooling , as in the case of steam .
But I , as well as all my friends , was a long time utterly disconcerted upon finding that when I put the whiting and water into a coated glass retort , the water came over in the form of steam , and little or no air was produced .
The result was also the same when I made the process in a gun-barrel , in a porcelain retort , or even in an earthen retort glazed in the inside .
That the earth had not lost its property of doing its part in the business , I found by putting more water to the same whiting which had failed in the glass retort , and which had been used no less than four times before , and then heating it in an earthen retort ; when again it gave air only , and no water , the same as before .
And at this time I observed , that part of the air was hardly to be distinguished from that of the atmosphere .
I cannot express my surprise at my unexpected failure with the glass retort ; and my speculations on the subject were various , but at that time altogether ineffectual .
Among other things it occurred to me that , possibly , some phlogiston , either contained in the earthen retort , or coming through it ( though I could not tell how , or on what principle ) from the fire , might be necessary to water , and all other substances , assuming the form of air .
But when , with this idea , I put spirit of wine , oil , or iron-filings to the lime , I got nothing from these mixtures in glass retorts besides steam and inflammable air , from the decomposition of these substances containing phlogiston .
That there was nothing in the materials of which the earthern retort was made that necessarily produced the air , was evident from my not succeeding when I pounded a broken retort , and heated it , mixed with water , in one of glass .
Being satisfied that the production of air depended very much upon the retort itself , I thought of using the retort only with water , but without any lime , or earthy substance ; and I found it succeed far beyond my expectation .
For when I put a small quantity of water into one of these retorts , and endeavoured to distil it gently , I never failed to procure about an hundred ounce measures of air ; and this I could do as often as I pleased , with the same retort , and without its losing any weight ; and the air produced in this manner had never any portion of fixed air in it , and was always but very little inferior to that of the atmosphere .
In all these processes I observed , that very little of this air was procured till all the water that could be poured out of the retort was evaporated , for the difference in the produce was very little , whether I exposed the retort to the fire quite full of water , or with only about an ounce measure of water in it , or even after letting it remain full for a short time , and then pouring out all that I could from it ; so that it was only that water which was entangled , as it were , in the pores of the retort , and which had been in some measure united to the substance of it , that had contributed to this production of air .
These retorts ( which Mr. WEDGEWOOD informs me are made of a mixture of fresh and of burnt Devonshire pipe clay ) are pervious to water , though not to air ; so that while the air is produced from that water which has entered the pores , the rest is sometimes visibly making its escape in the form of a copious smoke on the outside .
It was evidently impossible , however , and contrary to all the laws of hydrostatics , that air should enter by the same pores by which the water or steam was escaping , and at the same time that its endeavour to force its way out of the retort was such that it overcame a considerable resistance from the column of water , at the mouth of my recipients .
Air might have escaped through any unobserved pores in the retort , but none could have entered that way : and if there was the least sensible crack in any part of the retort , I was never able to collect any air at all .
But the following experiments may , perhaps , show that it is sufficient for the production of air that steam come into contact with clay sufficiently heated .
Between a copper still and the glass tube communicating with my recipient for air , I introduced the stem of a tobacco-pipe ; and by means of a small furnace , I kept about three inches of the middle part of it moderately red-hot .
In this state , making the water boil , I uniformly received air , though mixed with steam , at the rate of five ounce measures in twelve minutes for more than an hour ; but when I let the pipe cool , nothing but steam was delivered by it without any air at all .
There was no fixed air in this produce , and it was all such as a candle would hardly have burned it .
It might , I thought , have been better and also more in quantity if I had not used the stem of a foul pipe .
But when I used a clean pipe in the same manner , I did not find the air much , if at all improved .
Suspecting this to arise from the near contact of the fuel , I enclosed the tobacco-pipe in an earthen tube , and then I had air as good as I had generally got in the earthen retort , and not much worse than that of the atmosphere .
Another circumstance I observed was , that if the outside of the vessel which contained the water or steam , through which it passed , when the requisite heat was applied to it , was not dry , or perhaps surrounded with good air ( for in those circumstances the following experiment differs from the preceding ones ) the experiment did not succeed .
When I put the ball of an earthern retort , filled with moist clay , into an iron digester , and applied heat to it , I get only a very little fixed air , which was probably composed of a small quantity of air beginning to be produced from the materials and inflammable air from the vessel .
All that come over besides was steam , and at last inflammable air , from the vessel itself .
Being now able to procure air by means of water in this most simple method , viz. by water only in the earthen retort , I had an opportunity of ascertaining , with great ease and exactness , several circumstances relating to the process , and of obviating , as I thought , some objections to the conclusion that I had drawn from it .
Among other things I fully satisfied myself that the earth of the retort contributed nothing at all to this production of air , but the water only : for having used the same retort till I had got from it nearly an ounce weight of air , or 800 ounce measures , I found that it had not lost so much as a single grain in weight .
After the first process it weighed just three grains more than it did at first , and it continued to weigh the same till after the last process .
This small addition of weight might easily have come from a little of the water having been imbibed by the neck of the retort , where the heat of the fire could not reach it .
When all the processes were over , I kept the whole retort in a red heat for several hours , and then found that , besides losing those three grains , it weighed eight grains less than it did at first .
Before this I had found , that the calcined whiting which I had used in the first experiment could not , as some supposed , attract from the atmosphere any considerable part of the air which I got from it , after combining water with it : for two ounces of the whiting ( which was the quantity which I generally made use of ) did not attract more than eight grains of any thing when it was exposed a whole day in an open dish , though it had lost more than half its weight in calcination .
It has been imagined by some , that the air which I got in these earthen retorts was that which had been attracted from the atmosphere by the inside surface of them .
But , besides that no air could ever be produced without water , to obviate this objection more particularly , when one of these retorts was giving its last portion of air , I immersed the mouth of it in a bason of water ; and letting it cool in that situation , filled it again without admitting any access of air to the inside ; and yet , on repeating the process with it , the air was produced just as freely as before .
This operation I repeated several times .
If it be said , that the outside of the retort attracted the air , still the inside , being composed of the same materials , must have attracted air also ; and it would have appeared by the ascent of the water from the bason , the retort being sufficiently impervious to air .
By some it was imagined , that either the air itself that I procured , or at least the power of the retort to contribute to the production of it , was owing to something that was transmitted from the burning coals , but which could not pass through glass or metals .
To determine this , I took an earthen tube , of the same composition with the retort , and putting a little water in it , placed it , surrounded with sand , in a glass vessel , and this again , surrounded also with sand , in an iron one ; and yet the heat transmitted through all these substances enabled the earthen tube to give air , in the same proportion , and of the same quality , as it would have done if it had been exposed to the naked fire .
Having now procured air , by means of a water , in a very simple and , as I thought , an unexceptionable manner , I wished to make it in greater quantities in proportion to the water employed ; and for this purpose I first thought of increasing the size or the thickness of the porous retorts ; but I thought it might answer as well if I put into the retort , in powder , the materials of which they were made , or other substances of the same kind .
Accordingly , by mixing ground flint and clay in various proportions , I presently increased the quantity of air much beyond my expectation .
In the first trials , in which I had much flint and a little clay , I never failed to get 200 ounce measures of air from one of water .
Then , using more clay and less flint , I had still more air ; and at last , leaving out the flint altogether , and using clay only , I never failed to get much more than 400 , and generally between 500 and 600 , ounce measures of air from one of water , which was about threefourths of the weight of the water ; and in one particular process I procured very little less than nine-tenths of the weight of the water in air , and this air was never much less pure than that of the atmosphere .
Sometimes it could not be distinguished at all from it at all by the test of nitrous air ; and once or twice I thought it even purer than that of the atmosphere .
I must here observe , that I found it not convenient to put so much water to any quantity of clay as would make it cohere in one mass , but only so much as that it should remain in the form of powder .
By this means it would easily pour out of the retort when the experiment was over .
The weight of the water expended in this production of air I ascertained , in the most unexceptionable manner , by weighing the retort , with all its contents , before and after the process .
I shall explain this by the result of two of the processes .
In one of them , the retort and moistened clay together lost in weight 1 oz. 4 dwts .
12 grs. after yielding 741 ounce measures of air , which ( in the proportion of six grains to one ounce measure ) would have weighed 18 dwts .
12 grs. and consequently three-fourths of the weight of the water .
In the other process the loss of weight was 15 dwts .
18 grs. after yielding 556 ounce measures of air , which would have weighed 13 dwts .
21 grs. The proportion , therefore , between the weight of the air and that of the water was 111 to 116 , or nearly nine to ten .
I also found now , that so much heat as I had hitherto applied was neither necessary nor useful .
In the last mentioned process the retort was constantly suspended about six inches above a moderate charcoal fire ; at another time more than twelve or fifteen inches above it , where a FAHRENHEIT 's thermometer did not show more than 210~ .
With this moderate heat I got 465 ounce measures in the course of about twelve hours .
When the retort was suspended within six inches of the fire , the air was generally produced at the rate of 30 ounce measures in five minutes .
But a thermometer , the bulb of which was immersed in the clay , was still only at the heat of boiling water .
In all these processes , however , there was evidently some loss of water ; for , excepting the first experiment with the lime , I never got the whole weight of the water in air ; and it might be said that I only expelled the air before contained in the water , though from these experiments it appeared to contain much more air than it had been thought capable of containing .
To obviate this objection , I contrived to catch all the water that escaped through the pores of the retort in the following manner .
Having put the moistened clay in an earthen tube , to which I had fitted a cock and a long glass tube ( by means of which I could collect all the air that came from it ) , I put this within an iron tube , which was closed at the end next the fire , but open at the other end , and so long that I could easily keep this open and quite cool while the other was in the fire ; consequently , whatever water escaped through the pores of the earthen tube , it would be condensed in the cool part of the iron one .
This water I carefully collected , and always found that the weight of it , together with that of the air produced in the experiment , was nearly that of the original weight of the water , estimated by the loss of weight in the earthen tube and its contents .
I also found , that the water so collected served for the production of more air , just as well as any other water whatever , so that there had been no decomposition of the water in the case .
In the last process that I went through of this kind , the loss of weight in the earthen tube , or rather of the water contained in it , was 12 dwts .
4 grs. ; the air collected was 173 ounce measures , which would have weighed 4 dwts .
3 grs. and the water which escaped through the pores of the earthen tube , and which I collected , was nearly 8 dwts .
3 grs. ; so that the air and this water together weighed 12 dwts , 14 grs. or ten grains more than the original water .
But as I estimated the weight of the water only by the space which it occupied in a cylindrical glass tube , divided according to ounces and parts of ounces of water , it was not easy to avoid an error of a few grains .
At other times there was an error of a small magnitude on the other side .
But it will appear hereafter , that more steam must have escaped invisibly at the open mouth of the iron tube than I was aware of .
That nothing could enter by the pores of the retort at the same time that the water was making its escape out of them , I thought I ascertained pretty satisfactorily by immersing the bulb of it in mercury , contained in an iron vessel .
In these circumstances I obtained air as usual , only the produce was not so rapid .
In this way , however , I procured above an hundred ounce measures of air from moistened clay ; and I discontinued the process without perceiving any termination of it .
But the moment the retort was raised out of the mercury , it gave air three times as fast as it had done before .
The quality of the air was the same in both cases , viz. a little worse than that of the atmosphere .
I even collected thirty ounce measures of air when the bulb of the same retort was immersed in hot linseed oil , but the production of air gradually ceased , and the next day I found the retort almost full of the oil , which had soaked through it .
Distilling this oil I get 300 ounce measures of air , wholly inflammable , except a very few ounce measures at the last , which were only phlogisticated .
Still hearing of many objections to the conversion of water into air , I now gave particular attention to an experiment of Mr. CAVENDISH 's , concerning the re-conversion of air into water , by decomposing it in conjunction with inflammable air .
And in the first place , in order to be sure that the water I might find in the air was really a constituent part of it , and not what it might have imbibed after its formation , I made a quantity of both dephlogisticated and inflammable air in such a manner as that neither of them should ever come into contact with water , receiving them as they were produced in mercury ; the former from nitre , and in the middle of the process ( long after the water of crystallization was come over ) , and the latter from perfectly-made charcoal .
The two kinds of air thus produced I decomposed by firing them together by the electric explosion , and sound a manifest deposition of water , and to appearance in the same quantity as if both the kinds of air had been previously confined by water .
In order to judge more accurately of the quantity of water so deposited , and to compare it with the weight of the air decomposed , I carefully weighed a piece of filtering paper , and then having wiped with it all the inside of the glass vessel in which the air had been decomposed , weighed it again , and I always found , as nearly as I could judge , the weight of the decomposed air in the moisture acquired by the paper .
As there is a source of deception in this experiment , in the small globules of mercury , which are apt to adhere to the inside of the glass vessel , and to be taken up by the paper with which it is wiped , I sometimes weighed the paper with the moisture and the mercury adhering to it ; and then exposing it in a warm place , where the water would evaporate , but not the mercury , weighed it again , and still found , as nearly as I could pretend to weigh so small a matter , a loss of weight equal to that of the air .
I wished , however , to have had a nicer balance for the purpose : the result was such as to afford a strong presumption that the air was re-converted into water , and therefore that the origin of it had been water .
Another presumption in favour of the generation of our atmosphere from water was , that the purity of the air that I produced from it is so very nearly the same with that of the atmosphere .
And the degree of heat requisite to produce it is no greater than may be given by the rays of the sun in certain circumstances .
Subterraneous fires , however , would be abundantly sufficient for the purpose , as it appears to be sufficient for the conversion of water into respirable air , that it come into contact with clay , and perhaps many other earthy substances in the form of vapour .
I must , however , observe , that when I threw the focus of a burning lens upon a quantity of moist clay , either in vacuo , or in common air , I got no air from it .
I made this experiment both with the clay exposed in an open dish , and also confined in a short earthen tube .
Had I then proceeded to repeat this last process with a communication between the inside of the earthen tube and the external air , as I then proposed to do , but was prevented , I should much sooner have discovered what I did afterwards , viz. that there was no real conversion of water into air in this process .
In favour of which , however , it may not be amiss to observe , that the great difficulty Mr. DE LUC and others have found in expelling all air from water , is best accounted for on the supposition of the generation of air from water , though in other circumstances than those that I have observed .
I have the pleasure to add , that Mr. DE LUC himself concurs with me in this opinion .
The difficulty that strikes many persons the most forcibly , is the want of analogy between the conversion of water into air with any other known facts in philosophy or in nature .
But admitting that this conversion is effected by the intimate union of what is called the principle of heat with the water , it appears to me to be sufficiently analogous to other changes , or rather combinations of substances .
Is not the acid of nitre , and also that of vitriol , a thing as unlike to air as water is , their properties being as remarkably different ?
And yet it is demonstrable , that the acid of nitre is convertible into the purest respirable air , and probably by the union of the same principle of heat .
It is true , that steam is a thing very different from air , and I find that it is not able to decompose nitrous air ; but then , though it has acquired sensible heat , it has got no latent heat so intimately combined with it as it is with air ; and for the same reason , perhaps , the vapour of nitrous acid is not dephlogisticated air .
By the same process by which respirable air is made by means of water , inflammable air may be made from liquid substances containing phlogiston .
Making spirit of wine to boil in a glass retort , I made the vapour pass through the stem of a hot tobacco-pipe , and found that it was all seemingly converted into inflammable air , and it was of that kind which burns with a lambent white flame .
But when I let the pipe cool no air was produced , but only vapour , which was instantly condensed in the water .
Being now master of a new and easy process , I was willing to extend it to other liquid substances ; and I presently found , as I then imagined , that , by this means , I could give a permanent aerial form to any liquid substance that had been previously thrown into the form of vapour .
When I made the vapour of spirit of nitre , heated in a glass retort , pass through the stem of the hot tobacco-pipe , I got as pure dephlogisticated air as ever I have procured from nitre ; though the cork , by which the retort was connected with the pipe , was dissolved , and must have contributed to contaminate it , and give it a slight mixture of fixed air .
With oil of vitriol I got air considerably phlogisticated , so that a candle would not have burned in it ; but this I also attribute to the cork , which was dissolved in the process .
The result was nearly the same when I used water impregnated with vitriolic acid air , though the cork was not dissolved .
But this acid is known to contain much phlogiston .
Spirit of salt gave air no purer than the best atmospherical air .
But as by this process I never got air so pure as this from water only , I concluded , that even this acid , as well as the nitrous and vitriolic , is capable of being turned into dephlogisticated air .
When I used water impregnated with fixed air , this air was expelled by the heat , and came over without any change that I could perceive , except that the residuum was larger , from the water that came along with it .
The air I got afterwards was only that from the water , and of the same quality as if it had not been impregnated with fixed air .
Water impregnated with alkaline air gave neither fixed nor inflammable air , which I had rather expected , but only air considerably phlogisticated ; though some of it was so pure that a candle would have burned in it .
N. B. In all these experiments with the tobacco-pipe all the air was remarkably turbid , like milk , and even the common air in the retort before the process properly began .
In this state of the experiments I think I may venture to say , that no person could have seen them without concluding that there was a real conversion of water into air , there being no known principle or fact in philosophy , that could have led any person to suspect a fallacy in the case .
In this , therefore , I must have acquiesced , as indeed did all my acquaintance , even those who had been the most incredulous on the subject , after they had themselves seen the experiments .
But I was led to the farther prosecution of this business , in consequence of having observed that the purity of the air which I procured depended upon the state of that which was immediately contiguous to the earthen retort , or tube , in which I supposed the conversion to have been made ; and that some communication with the atmosphere was necessary to the production of any air , as in the experiment with the digester , and those with the clay and the burning lens .
And since pure external air was necessary in order to procure good air , it was concluded by several of my friends , and especially Mr. WATT , that the operation of the earthen retort was , to transmit phlogiston from the water contained in the clay to the external air ; and that the water , thus dephlogisticated , was capable of being converted into respirable air by the intimate union of the principle of heat .
In order to ascertain what the influence of the external air in this case really was , I enclosed an earthen retort filled with moistened clay in a large glass receiver , open at both ends , through the upper orifice of which ( being narrow ) I thrust the neck of the retort , luting it so as to be perfectly air-tight ; and placing the receiver in a bason of water , by which the air within was cut off from all communication with the external air , I fitted to the mouth of the retort a glass tube , through which I could receive whatever was produced in the process .
In this situation I heated the retort by means of Mr. PARKER 's excellent burning lens , when air was received through the tube communicating with the inside of the retort as usual ; but at the same time the water rose within the receiver .
This effect might be owing to a phlogistication of the air within the receiver ; but it was soon diminished far beyond the utmost limit of that process , so that very little of it remained ; and examining this air , I found it to be but very little worse than that of the atmosphere , as that which came from the retort was a little better .
This experiment made it probable , that the air on the outside of the receiver had actually passed through it , only a little purified in its passage ; and yet it was contrary to all the known principles of hydrostatics , and even any thing hitherto known in chemistry , that air should be transmitted through a vessel of this kind , and in a direction contrary to that in which it would have been forced by the pressure of the atmosphere ; while the water , with which the clay was moistened , went the other way .
For had the retort been pervious to air , as the inside had a free communication with the atmosphere , the water could not have risen within the receiver .
This , however , appeared to be the case by the following decisive experiments .
Having filled the earthen retort with the moistened clay as before , I made the inside of the receiver perfectly dry , and placed it in a bason of mercury ; when , upon heating the retort as before , the receiver was all covered with dew , which collecting into drops trickled down the inside of the receiver , and remained upon the mercury , which rose within the receiver , while air was received from the retort as usual .
I had no doubt , therefore , but that all the water within the retort would have got through into the receiver .
Spirit of wine , or something that had the smell of it , was transmitted from the clay through the retort in the same manner .
I then filled the receiver with inflammable air , and upon heating the retort it was all drawn through it , and delivered as strongly inflammable as ever by the tube communicating with the inside of it , while the water rose within the receiver , and even covered the retort , which was fixed at the very top of it , so that hardly any of the inflammable air remained within it .
In like manner nitrous air passed through the retort unchanged .
From these experiments it is impossible not to infer , that the clay of the earthen retort , being thus heated , destroys for a time the aerial form of whatever air is exposed to the outside of it ; which aerial form it recovers after it has been transmitted in combination from one part of the clay to another , till it has reached the inside of the retort , while the water is drawn through it in the contrary direction .
Had this hypothesis been proposed a priori , it would , I doubt not , have been thought more extraordinary than the conversion of water into air .
I propose to make many other experiments in the prosecution of these ; but till I have an opportunity of doing this , I shall not trouble the Society with any conjectures that have occurred to me on the subject .
The great difficulty with respect to the experiment with the lens is , that the water should pass through the retort one way , and the air the other , and yet that the air should not be able to pass without the water .
It is also not a little extraordinary , that the weight of the air and that of the water should be so nearly equal .
In the last place I must observe , that there is nothing in this experiment that contradicts the idea of the conversion of water into air , though it does not prove it : for still the experiment with the tobacco-pipe , in which the steam is made red-hot ( whereas in that with the lens it is only of a boiling heat ) cannot be explained so well on any other hypothesis any more than Mr. CAVENDISH'S experiment on finding water on the decomposition of air .
I cannot conclude this account without acknowledging my obligation to Mr. PARKER for the use of his incomparable lens , and his obligingly assisting me in the management of it .
Indeed , without this very instrument , or one of greater power than my own , I do not know that the last mentioned experiments could have been made at all ; certainly not to so much satisfaction .

