XIII .
Account of the Black Canker Caterpillar , which destroys the Turnips in Norfolk .
By William Marshall , Esq. in a Letter to Charles Morton , M. D. F. R. S. Read February 8 , 1783 .
SIR , Gunton , near Aylsham , Norfolk , August 22 , 1782 .
AFEW months after you did me the honour of presenting my minutes of agriculture to the British Museum , I came down into Norfolk , as agent to Sir HARBORD HARBORD .
To a person intelligent in matters of agriculture it would be superfluous to say , that Norfolk is celebrated for good husbandmen ; or that the turnip crop is the basis of the Norfolk husbandry .
If a Norfolk farmer loses his crop of turnips , his farm is injured for several succeeding years ; for it is not only the loss of the immediate profit , which would otherwise have arisen to him from his bullocks , but his land is deprived of the consequent manure and trampling ( esteemed highly beneficial to the light lands of this county ) on which his future crops of corn are essentially dependant .
Among the numerous enemies to which turnips are liable , none have proved more fatal here than the Black Canker ( a species of Caterpillar ) which in some years have been so numerous as to cut off the farmer 's hopes in a few days .
In other years , however , the damage has been little , and in others nothing .
About twenty years ago the whole country was nearly stripped ; and this year it has been subjected to a similar fate .
Many thousands of acres , upon which a fairer prospect for a crop of turnips has not been seen for many years , have been plowed up ; and as , from the season being now far spent , little profit can be expected from a second sowing ; the loss to the farmers , individually , will be very considerable , and to the county immense .
It was observed in the canker-year above mentioned , that , prior to the appearance of the caterpillars , great numbers of yellow flies were seen busy among the turnip plants ; and it was then suspected , that the canker was the caterpillar state of the yellow fly ; and since that time it has been remarked , that cankers have regularly followed the appearance of these flies .
From their more frequently appearing on the sea-coast , and from the vast quantities which have , I believe , at different times , been observed on the beach washed up by the tide , it has been a received opinion among the farmers , that they are not natives of this country , but come across the ocean , and observations this year greatly corroborate the idea .
Fishermen upon the eastern coast declare , that they actually saw them arrive in cloud-like flights ; and from the testimony of many , it seems to be an indisputable fact , that they first made their appearance on the eastern coast ; and , moreover , that on their first being observed , they lay upon and near the cliffs so thick and so languid , that they might have been collected into heaps , lying , it is said , in some places two inches thick .
From thence they proceeded into the country , and even at the distance of three or four miles from the coast they were seen in multitudes resembling swarms of bees .
About ten days after the appearance of the flies , the young caterpillars were first observed on the under sides of the leaves of the turnips , and in seven or eight days more , the entire plants , except the stronger fibres , were eaten up .
A border under the hedge was regularly spared until the body of the enclosure was finished ; but this done , the border was soon stripped , and the gateway , and even the roads have been seen covered with caterpillars travelling in quest of a fresh supply of turnips ; for the grasses , and indeed every plant , except the turnip and the charlock ( sinapis arvensis ) they entirely neglect , and even die at their roots , without attempting to feed upon them .
This destruction has not been confined within a few miles of the eastern coast , but has reached , more or less , into the very center of the county .
The mischief , however , in the western parts of Norfolk , and even on the north coast , has been less general ; but I am afraid it may be said , with a great deal of truth , that one half of the turnips in the county have been cut off by this voracious animal A circumstance so discouraging to industry , and injurious to the public at large , will , I flatter myself , Sir , be thought a sufficient apology for my troubling you with a relation of it , and for my taking the liberty of sending you a male and a female fly , also one of the animals in its caterpillar , and one which is in its chrysalis state , for your inspection , hoping that the public may become acquainted with the means of preventing in future so great a calamity .
Lest the flies may become disfigured in travelling , it may be prudent to say , that their wings are four ; that their antennae are clubbed , and about one-third of the length of their body , each being composed of nine joints , namely , two next the head , above which two there is a joint somewhat longer than the rest , and above this six more joints , similar to the two below ; that near the point of the tail of the female there is a black speck , outwardly fringed with hair ; but which , opening longitudinally , appears to be the end of a case , containing a delicate point or sting ( about one-twentieth of an inch in length ) which on a cursory view appears to be a simple lanceolated instrument , with a strong line passing down the middle , and serrated at its edges ; but , on a closer inspection , and by agitating it strongly with the point of a needle , it separates into three one-edged instruments , hanger-like as to their general form , with a spiral line or wrinkle winding from the point to the base , making ten or twelve revolutions , which line , passing over their edges , gives them some appearance of being serrated .
By the help of these instruments , I apprehend , the female deposits her eggs in the edge of the turnip-leaf ( or sometimes , perhaps , in the nerves or ribs on the under surface of the leaf ) ; thus far I can say , and I think with a considerable degree of certainty , that having put some fresh turnip leaves into a glass containing several of the male and female flies , I perceived ( by the means of a simple magnifier ) that one of the females , after examining attentively the edge of the leaf , and finding a part which appeared to me to have been bitten , unsheathed her instruments , insinuated them into the edge of the leaf , and having forced them asunder so as to open a pipe or channel between them , placed her pubes ( the situation of which from repeated and almost incessant copulations I had been able to ascertain precisely , and to the lower part of which these instruments seem to be fixed ) to the orifice , and having remained a few seconds in that posture , deliberately drew out the instruments ( which the transparency of the leaf held against a strong light afforded me an opportunity of seeing very plainly ) and proceeded to search for another convenient place for her purpose .
The caterpillar has twenty feet ( six of its legs being of considerable length , the other fourteen very short ) and in its first stage is of a jetty black , smooth as to a privation of hair , but covered with innumerable wrinkles .
Having acquired its full size , it fixes its hinder parts firmly to the leaf of a turnip , or any other substance , and breaking its outer coat or slough near the head , crawls out , leaving the skin fixed to the leaf , &amp;c. The under coat , which it now appears in , is of a blueish or lead colour , and the caterpillar is evidently diminished in its size .
In every respect it is the same animal as before , and continues to feed on the turnips for some days longer : it then entirely leaves off eating , and becomes covered with a dewy moisture , which seems to exsude from it in great abundance , and appearing to be of a glutinous nature , retains any loose or pliant substance which happens to come in contact with it , and by this means alone seems to form its chrysalis coat .
One I find laid up in the fold of a withered turnip leaf ( that which I have the honour of enclosing you ) was , among six others , formed by putting common garden mould to them while they were in the exsudatory state above described .
From the generic characters of the fly I conclude it to be a Tenthredo of HILL ; but whether that voluminous author be sufficiently accurate ; or whether , from being an almost entire stranger to natural history , I may , or may not , sufficiently understand my book , I must beg leave to submit to your superior knowledge of the subject .
I am endeavouring to extend my observations on these insects , and am making some experiments concerning them , the result of which I should be extremely happy in being permitted to communicate to you ; and it may be proper to add here , that I should not have taken the liberty of troubling you prematurely with this letter , had I not luckily met with an opportunity of procuring some live flies ( which are now become very scarce ) ; and I flatter myself they will come to your hands in a perfect state .
I am , with the greatest respect , &amp;c.

