IX .
Experiments upon the Resistance of the Air .
By Richard Lovell Edgworth , Esq. F. R. S. In a Letter to Sir Joseph Banks , Bart. P. R. S. Read January 16 , 1782 .
DEARSI R , Edgeworth 's Town , Ireland , May 2 , 1782 .
THE last time I had the pleasure of seeing you , the conversation turned upon the resistance of the air , and upon a singular experiment related by Mr. ROBINS in his Treatise upon Gunnery .
I have since repeated his experiment , and tried some others , which I beg you to lay before the Royal Society , if you think them worthy their attention .
I have the honour to be , &amp;c. MANY experiments have been tried to ascertain the force and velocity of the wind , with a view to the construction and management of different engines , and more particularly for the purposes of navigation .
Several machines , which have been employed in these enquiries , are described in the Transactions of the Royal Society , and in the Memoirs of Foreign Academies ; but the most accurate which I have seen was invented by the late Sir CHARLES KNOWLES ; and from a number of experiments made with it , he had constructed tables , showing at one view the force of the wind upon each sail of a ship at every degree of velocity from one to ninety miles an hour .
But these calculations , and many more of a similar nature , that are to be met with in BELIDOR'S Architecture Hydraulique , and other books , are founded upon a supposition that the effect of the wind is directly as the surface upon which it acts .
If , for instance , its force be estimated as one upon one square yard , its force upon two square yards should be estimated as two , upon three square yards as three , &amp;c. ; but in fact this proportion is not to be depended upon , nor must the resistance of surfaces be estimated merely by their extent ; but several other circumstances must be taken into consideration .
No figures can resemble each other more than a parallelogram and a square having the same superficial contents , as they are both bounded by four straight lines meeting at right angles , yet they oppose different degrees of resistance to the air .
If two similar cards , for instance , are placed opposite the wind , one upon its end , and the other on its side , and both inclined to the same angle , the wind will have the greater effect upon the card that is placed end-ways .
To determine the difference of resistance between these two surfaces , and to ascertain the effect of other figures moving through the air , I tried the following experiments .
The two first are to be found in Mr. ROBINS'S Treatise upon Gunnery ; but I thought it proper to repeat them , that they might be more readily compared with others made with the same apparatus , especially as Mr. ROBINS made use of a machine constructed upon a smaller scale than mine , and turning upon friction wheels , which are not proper for machines of this nature , nor indeed for any purpose , where an uniform motion is required .
Having fastened a strong joist of wood from one side of a large room to the other , so as to form a kind of bridge at some distance from the floor , I erected a perpendicular shaft or roller , which turned freely in brass sockets fixed into the floor and bridge upon pivots of hardened steel one-sixteenth of an inch in diameter .
On each side of this roller was extended an arm of deal , feather-edged , and supported by stays of the same material , feathered in the same manner , to oppose as little surface as possible to the air when in motion .
Round the upper part of this roller was wound a string of cat-gut , which , passing over pullies properly disposed , was fastened to a scale that descended into the well of an adjoining stair-case .
The extremity of these arms described a space of more than forty feet in every revolution , the weight descending in the same time only six inches .
The time in all the following experiments was the same ; and , as each revolution was performed in four seconds , the velocity of the end of the arm on which the surface was fixed , was at the rate of about seven miles an hour .
The first figure that I tried was a parallelogram of tin , nine inches long , and four inches wide .
Its longest side was placed parallel to the floor , at the extremity of one of the arms .
Its shortest sides were inclined to an angle of forty-five degrees from the perpendicular , and in this situation it was carried round with its surface against the air .
After suffering it to revolve until I was satisfied that its motion was become uniform , I put as much weight into the scale as moved it with a velocity of five turns in twenty seconds .
I then changed the situation of the parallelogram , placing its shortest sides parallel to the floor , and inclined to the same angle as before .
I now found , that more weight was required to produce the same velocity , though the quantity of surface was the same as in the preceding experiment .
The weight necessary to put the machine alone in motion , with the velocity above mentioned , was two pounds and a half .
When it carried the parallelogram with one of its shortest sides downwards , it required four pounds and a half additional weight ; and when the parallelogram was reversed , another half pound was barely sufficient to give it the same velocity .
The difference , therefore , occasioned by placing the same parallelogram with its longer or shorter sides inclined from the direction of its motion was equal to one-tenth of the greatest resistance .
It has been observed , that in these two experiments the mean velocity of the plane was not the same , as its extremity extended farther from the center of the machine in one than in the other .
This is strictly true ; but the size of the parallelogram bore so small a proportion to the length of the radius to which it was fastened , that the error arising from this circumstance is scarcely perceptible , and the advantage being in favour of that which required the least weight , I did not think it necessary to bring it into account .
Having formed a general idea of the reason of the difference in these experiments , it occurred to me , that there would be a greater disproportion between the resistance of some other figures , which Mr. ROBINS had not tried ; and having put a rhomboid , in the form of a lozenge , nine inches long , and four broad , in the place of the parallelogram , the difference was increased from one-tenth to one-seventh of the weight employed to give them the required velocity .
Pursuing the same reasoning that led me to the last experiment , it occurred to me , that even against figures of exactly the same shape , the resistance of the air , when the dimensions of the figures were enlarged , would not be increased in the same proportion as the size of the planes , but in a much higher ratio ; and that , by bending the planes as a sail , the resistance would be still farther increased , though the section of air , that would be intercepted by the planes , must by these means be considerably lessened .
The result far surpassed my expectations .
A square of tin , containing sixteen square inches , placed perpendicularly , was resisted as two and a half .
A square , containing sixty-four inches , or four times the former quantity , instead of meeting with a resistance as ten or four times the former resistance , required no less than fourteen pounds to give it the same velocity .
Four-tenths ( or nearly half as much again ) was an increase of resistance that made me suspect some error in the experiment ; but having repeated it several times with great care , and having examined all the parts of the machine , I was satisfied that I had made no mistake .
I now placed the parallelogram of nine inches long upon the arms of the machine , with its shortest sides parallel to the horizon , bending it to such an arch that its chord measured eight inches , and inclining it to an angle of forty-five degrees .
And though the section of air that it intercepted was by these means diminished one-ninth , yet the resistance was increased from five to five and a half .
And when the parallelogram was bent yet farther , and its chord contracted almost to seven inches , the resistance was increased to five and three-quarters .
I mention these numbers in gross to avoid confusion ; but in the table at the end of this paper , the measures and weights are set down exactly .
Dr. HOOX , whose name must be respected by every experimental philosopher , was aware , that although he thought he could demonstrate that flat sails were preferable to such as were curved and hollowed by the wind , yet until proper experiments had been tried , nothing could be positively determined .
He says somewhere in his posthumous works , ` ` That he was surprised at the obstinacy of seamen , in continuing , after what appeared the clearest demonstration to the contrary , to prefer bellying or bunting sails to such as were hauled taught ; but that he would , at some future time , add the test of experiment to mathematical investigation .
' ' He reasoned upon a supposition , that the air in motion followed the same laws as light ; and that it was reflected from surfaces with the angle of reflection equal to the angle of incidence , which is not the case , as it never makes an angle with the plane , but is always reflected in curves .
Mons. PARENT , and other mathematicians , have fallen into the same mistake .
No demonstration of this sort was more commonly known or received among practical mechanics , than that the best angle for the sails of a wind-mill , at the beginning of their motion , was an angle of forty-five degrees ; and that the maximum of an under-shot water-wheel was when it moved with one-third of the velocity of the water : but Mr. SMEATON , in an excellent paper in the Philosophical Transactions , has refuted this opinion by the clearest experiments .
I had intended to diversify these experiments , and to extend them to a more interesting subject of enquiry , to determine the best shape of sails , and the angle to which they should be set , to obtain the greatest progressive effect with the least leeway ; way ; but , as a more complicated apparatus than I could at present procure is necessary for this purpose , I determined to offer you the slight progress I have made , in hopes that some gentleman , more conversant and more interested than myself in these inquiries , may pursue them with success and advantage to the public .
I shall only remark , that the general cause of the different resistance of the air upon surfaces of different shapes , is the stagnation of that fluid near the middle of the plane upon which it strikes .
The shape and size of the portion thus stagnated , differs from the shape and angle of the plane .
The elasticity of the air permits the parts in motion to compress those which are first stopped or retarded by the plane , and forms , as it were , a new surface of a different shape , for the reception of those particles which succeed .
With the assistance of a good solar microscope the curves of the air striking against different surfaces may be delineated , and when the general facts are once clearly ascertained , mathematicians will have an ample field for curious and useful speculation .
TABL E. Turns .
Time .
Weight .
Machine alone 5428 With a parallelogram of nine inches long and four broad , one of its longest sides , parallel to the horizon and the parallelogram , inclined to an angle of 45~ , 5470 Ditto , with one of its shortest sides downwards , 5479 With a lozenge nine inches long and four broad , with its longest side parallel to the horizon , 5458 Ditto reversed , 5460 With a square piece of tin , four inches by four inches , 5450 Ditto , eight inches by eight inches , 54 16 6 With the former parallelogram , placed with one of its shortest sides downwards , inclined to an angle of 45~ , and bent into an arch whose chord was eight inches long , 5480 Ditto bent to an arch , the chord of which was seven inches and a quarter , 548 5

