XXI .
New Fundamental Experiments upon the Collision of Bodies .
By Mr. John Smeaton , F. R. S. in a Letter to Sir Joseph Banks , Bart. P. R. S. Read April 18 , 1782 .
TO SIR JOSEPH BANKS , BART .
P. R. S. SIR , THE subjects of the enclosed tract have been the object of my consideration for many years past ; and as they contain some matters that have not only been variously reasoned about , but variously concluded upon ; if what is contained therein shall appear of such a nature as either to establish truth , as it appears to me ; or to prompt some more able person , in reviewing the subject , to show what links in my chain of reasoning thereon are defective , so as to establish the whole doctrine of moving bodies upon one plain consistent basis , my end will be equally answered in offering them to you , to be laid before the Royal Society , in case you shall think that the importance of the subject shall merit the same : furthermore , I hope to be forgiven , if in some parts of this paper I have expressed myself with more pointedness than I might have done , for I declare , that it was solely owing to my earnestness that the subject of mechanic motions and powers should be fully and freely investigated , and established upon grounds that shall be uncontrovertible .
I have the honour to be , &amp;c. Gray's-Inn , April 18 , 1782 .
IT is universally acknowledged , that the first simple principles of science cannot be too critically examined , in or der to their being firmly established ; more especially those which relate to the practical and operative parts of mechanics , upon which much of the active business of mankind depends .
A sentiment of this kind occasioned my tract upon Mechanic Power , which was published in the Philosophical Transactions , vol. LXVI .
for the year 1776 .
What I have now to offer was intended as a supplement thereto , and the experiments were then , in part , tried ; but the completion thereof was deferred at that time , partly from want of leisure ; partly to avoid too great a length of the paper itself ; and partly to avoid the bringing forward too many points at once .
My present purpose is to show , that the true doctrine of the collision of bodies hangs as it were upon the same hook , as the doctrine of the gradual generation of motion from rest , considered in that paper ; that is , that whether bodies are put into gradual motion , and uniformly accelerated from rest to any given velocity ; or are put in motion , in an instantaneous manner , when bodies of any kind strike one another ; the motion , or sum of the motions produced , has the same relation to mechanic power therein defined , which is necessary to produce the motion desired .
To prove this , and at the same time to show some capital mistakes in principle , which have been assumed as indisputable truths by men of great learning , is the reason of my now pursuing the same subject .
I do not mean to point out the particular mistakes which have been made by particular men , as that would lead me into too great a length : I shall therefore content myself with observing , that the laws of collision , which have been investigated by mathematical philosophers , are principally of three kinds ; viz. those relating to bodies perfectly elastic ; to bodies perfectly unelastic , and perfectly soft ; and to bodies perfectly unelastic , and perfectly hard .
To avoid prolixity , I shall consider in each , only the simple case of two bodies which are equal in weight or quantity of matter striking one another .
Respecting those which are perfectly elastic , it is universally agreed , that when two such bodies strike one another , no motion is lost ; but that in all cases , what is lost by one is acquired by the other : and hence , that if an elastic body in motion strikes another at rest , upon the stroke the former will be reduced to a state of rest , and the latter will fly off with an equal velocity .
In like manner , if a non-elastic soft body strikes another at rest , they neither of them remain at rest , but proceed together from the point of collision with exactly one half of the velocity that the first had before the stroke ; this is also universally allowed to be true , and is fully proved by every good experiment upon the subject .
Respecting the third species of body , that is , those that are non-elastic , and yet perfectly hard ; the laws of motion relating to them , as laid down by one species of philosophers , have been rejected by another ; the latter alleging , that there are no such bodies to be found in nature whereon to try the experiment ; but those who have laid down and assigned the doctrine that would attend the collision of bodies of this kind ( if they could be found ) have universally agreed , that if a non-elastic hard body was to strike another of the same kind at rest , that , in the same manner as is agreed concerning non-elastic soft bodies , they neither of them would remain at rest , but would in like manner proceed from the point of collision , with exactly one half of the velocity that the first had before the stroke : in short , they lay it down as a rule attending all non-elastic bodies , whether hard or soft , that the velocity after the stroke will be the same in both , viz. one half of the velocity of the original striking body .
Here is therefore the assumption of a principle , which in reality is proved by no experiment , nor by any fair deduction of reason that I know of , viz. that the velocity of non-elastic hard bodies after the stroke must be the same as that resulting from the stroke of non-elastic soft bodies ; and the question now is , whether it is true or not ?
Here it may be very properly asked , what ill effects can result to practical men , if philosophers should reason wrong concerning the effects of what does not exist in nature , since the practical men can have no such materials to work upon , or misjudge of ?
But it is answered , that they who infer an equality of effects between the two sorts , may from thence be misled themselves , and in consequence mislead practical men in their reasonings and conclusions concerning the sort with which they have abundant concern , to wit , the non-elastic soft bodies , of which water is one , which they have much to do with in their daily practice .
Previous to the trying my experiment on mills I never had doubted the truth of the doctrine , that the same velocity resulted from the stroke of both sorts of non-elastic bodies ; but the trial of those experiments made me clearly see at least the inconclusiveness , if not the falsity of that doctrine : because I found a result which I did not expect to have arisen from either sort ; and for the which , when it appeared from experiment , I could see a substantial reason why it should take place in one sort , and that it was impossible that it could take place in the other ; for if it did , the bodies could not have been perfectly hard , which would be contrary to the hypothesis .
Of this deduction I have given notice in my said tract on mills , published lished in the Philosophical Transactions , vol. LI .
for the year 1759 * .
It may also be said , that since we have no bodies perfectly elastic , or perfectly unelastic and soft , why should we expect and bodies perfectly unelastic and hard ?
Why may not the effects be such as should result from a supposition of their being imperfectly elastic joined with their being imperfectly hard ?
But here I must observe , that the supposition appears to be a contradiction in terms .
We have bodies which are so nearly perfectly elastic , that the laws may be very well deduced and confirmed by them ; and the same obtains with respect to non-elastic soft bodies ; but concerning bodies of a mixed nature , which are by far the greatest number , so far as they are wanting in elasticity , they are soft , and bruise , yield , or leave a mark in collision ; and so far as they are not perfectly soft they are elastic , and observe a mixture of the law relative to each ; but imperfectly elastic bodies , imperfectly hard come in reality under the same description as the former mixed bodies : for so far as they are imperfectly hard they are soft , and either bruise and yield , or leave a mark in the stroke ; and so far as they want perfect elasticity , they are non-elastic ; that is to say , they are bodies imperfectly elastic , and imperfectly soft ; and in fact I have never yet seen any bodies but what come under this description .
It seems , therefore , that respecting the hardness of bodies they differ in degrees of it , in proportion as they have a greater degree of tenacity or cohesion ; that is , are further removed from perfect * ` ` The effect , therefore , of overshot wheels , under the same circumstance of quantity and fall , is at a medium double to that of the undershot : and as a consequence thereof , that non-elastic bodies , when acting by their impulse or collision , communicate only a part of their original power ; the other part being spent in changing their figure in consequence of the stroke .
' ' Phil. Trans. vol. LI .
p. 133 .
softness , at the same time that their elastic springs , so far as they reach , are very stiff ; and hence we may ( by the war ) conclude , that the same mechanic power that is required to change the figure in a small degree of those bodies that have the popular appellation of hard bodies , would change it in a great degree in those bodies that approach towards softness , by having a small degree of tenacity or cohesion .
In the former kind we may rank the harder kinds of cast iron , and in the latter , soft tempered clay .
While the philosophical world was divided by the dispute about the old and new opinion , as it was called , concerning the powers of bodies in motion , in proportion to their different velocities : those who held the old opinion contending , that it was as the velocity simply , asked those of the new , How , upon their principles , they would get rid of the conclusions arising from the doctrine of unelastic perfectly hard bodies ?
They replied , They found no such bodies in nature , and therefore did not concern themselves about them .
On the other hand , those of the new opinion asked those of the old , How they would account for the case of non-elastic soft bodies , where , according to them , the whole motion lost by the striking body was retained in the two after the stroke ( the two bodies moving together with the half velocity ) , though the two nonelastic bodies had been bruised and changed their figure by the stroke ; for , if no motion was lost , the change of figure must be an effect without a cause ?
To obviate this , those of the old opinion seriously set about proving , that the bodies might change their figure , without any loss of motion in either of the striking bodies .
Neither of these answers have appeared to me satisfactory , especially since my mill experiments : for with respect to the first , it is no proper argument to urge the impossibility of find2 ing ing the proper material for an experiment , in answer to a conclusion drawn from an abstract idea .
On the other hand , if it can be shown , that the figure of a body can be changed , without a power , then , by the same law , we might be able to make a forge hammer work upon a mass of soft iron , without any other power than that necessary to overcome the friction , resistance , and original vis inertiae , of the parts of the machine to be put in motion : for , as no progressive motion is given the mass of iron by the hammer ( it being supported by the anvil ) , no power can be expended that way ; and if none is lost to the hammer from changing the figure of the iron , which is the only effect produced , then the whole power must reside in the hammer , and it would jump back again to the place from which it fell , just in the same manner as if it fell upon a body perfectly elastic , upon which , if it did fall , the case would really happen : the power , therefore , to work the hammer would be the same , whether it fell upon an elastic or non-elastic body ; an idea so very contrary to all experience , and even apprehension , of both the philosopher and vulgar artist , that I shall here leave it to its own condemnation .
As nothing , however , is so convincing to the mind as experiments obvious to the senses , I was very desirous of contriving an experiment in point ; and as I saw no hopes of finding matter to make a direct experiment , I turned my mind towards an indirect one ; so circumscribed , however , as to prove incontestably , that the result of the stroke of two non-elastic perfectly hard bodies could not be the same as would result from the collision of two soft ones ; that is , if it can be bona fide proved , that one half of the original power is lost in the stroke of soft bodies by the change of figure ( as was very strongly suggested by the mill experiments ) ; then since no such loss can happen in the collision of bodies perfectly hard , the result and consequence of such a stroke must be different .
The consequence of a stroke of bodies perfectly hard , but void of elasticity , must doubtless be different from that of bodies perfectly elastic : for having no spring the body at rest could not be driven off with the velocity of the striking body , for that is the consequence of the action of the spring or elastic parts between them , as will be shown in the result of the experiments ; the striking body will therefore not be stopped , and as the motion it loses must be communicated to the other , from the equality of action and re-action , they will both proceed together , with an equal velocity , as in the case of non-elastic soft bodies : the question , therefore , that remains is , what that velocity must be ?
It must be greater than that of the nonelastic soft bodies , because there is no mechanical power lost in the stroke .
It must be less than that of the striking body , because , if equal , instead of a loss of motion by the collision , it will be doubled .
If , therefore , non-elastic soft bodies lose half their motion , or mechanical power , by change of figure in collision , and yet proceed together with half the velocity , and the non-elastic hard bodies can lose none in any manner whatever ; then , as they must move together , their velocity must be such as to preserve the equality of the mechanic power , unimpaired , after the stroke the same as it was before it .
For example , let the velocity of the striking body before the stroke be 20 , and its mass or quantity of matter 8 ; then , according to the rule deduced from the experiments in the tract on Mechanic Power ( see exp .
third and fourth ) that power will be expressed by 20 x 20 = 400 , which x8= 3200 ; and if half of it is lost in the stroke , in the case of non-elastic soft bodies , it will be reduced to 1600 ; which ~ 16 the double quantity of matter , will give 100 for the square of their velocity ; the square root of which being 10 , will be the velocity of the two non-elastic soft bodies after the stroke , being just one half of the original velocity , as it is constantly found to be .
But in the non-elastic hard bodies , no power being lost in the stroke , the mechanic power will remain after it , as before it , = 3200 ; this , in like manner , being divided by 16 , the double quantity of matter , will give 200 for the square of the velocity , the square root of which is 14 .
14 , &amp;c. for their velocity after the stroke , which is to 10 , the velocity of the non-elastic soft bodies after the stroke , as the square root of 2 to 1 ; or as the diagonal of a square to its side .
It remains , therefore , now to be proved , that precisely half of the mechanic power is lost in the collision of non-elastic soft bodies ; for which purpose my mind suggested the following reflections .
In the collision of elastic bodies the effect seemingly instantaneous , is yet performed in time ; during which time the natural springs residing in elastic bodies , and which constitute them such , are bent or forced , till the motion of the striking body is divided between itself and the body at rest ; and in this state the two bodies would then proceed together , as in the case of non-elastic soft bodies ; but as the springs will immediately restore themselves in an equal time , and with the same degree of impulsive force , wherewith they were bent in this re-action , the motion that remained in the striking body will be totally destroyed , and the total exertion of the two springs , communicated to the original resting body , will cause it to fly off with the same velocity wherewith it was struck .
Upon this idea , if we could construct a couple of bodies in such a way that they should either act as bodies perfectly elastic ; or , that their springs should at pleasure be hooked up , retained , or prevented from restoring themselves , when at their extreme degree of bending ; and if the bodies under these circumstances observed the laws of collision of non-elastic soft bodies , then it would be proved , that one half of the mechanical power , residing in the striking body , would be lost in the action of collision ; because the impulsive force or power of the spring in its restitution being cut off , or suspended from acting , which is equal to the impulsive force or power to bend it ( and which alone has been employed to communicate motion from one body to the other ) , it would make it evident , that one half of the impulsive force is lost in the action , as the other half remains locked up in the springs .
It also follows , as a collateral circumstance , that be the impulsive power of the springs what it may from first to last , yet as one half of the time of the action is by this means cut off , in this sense also it will follow , that one half of the mechanic power is destroyed ; or rather , in this case , remains locked up in the springs , capable of being re-exerted whenever they are set at liberty , and of producing a fresh mechanical effect , equivalent to the motion or mechanical power of the two non-elastic soft bodies after their collision .
Hence we must infer , that the quantity of mechanical power expended in displacing the parts of non-elastic soft bodies in collision , is exactly the same as that expended in bending the springs of perfectly elastic bodies ; but the difference in the ultimate effect is , that in the non-elastic soft bodies , the power taken to displace the parts will be totally lost and destroyed , as it would require an equal mechanic power to be raised afresh , and exerted in a contrary direction to restore the parts back again to their former places ; whereas , in the case of the elastic bodies , the operation of half the mechanic power is , as observed already , only locked up and suspended , and capable of being re-exerted without a further original accession .
These ideas arose from the result of the experiments tried upon the machine described in my said tract upon Mechanic Power , and were also communicated to my very worthy and ingenious friend WILLIAMRUSSEL L , Esq. F. R. S. at the same time that I showed him those experiments in 1759 ; but the mode of putting this matter to a full and fair mechanical trial has since occurred ; and though some rough trials , sufficient to show the effect , were made thereon , prior to the offering the paper on mechanical power to the Society in 1776 , yet the machine itself I had not leisure to complete to my satisfaction till lately ; which I mention to apologize for the length of time that these speculations have taken in bringing forward .
DESCRIPTIONOFTHEMACHINEFORCOLLISIO N. Fig. 1 .
shows the front of the machine as it appears at rest when fitted for use .
A is the pedestal , and AB the pillar , which supports the whole , C , D are two compound bodies of about a pound weight each , but as nearly equal in weight as may be .
These bodies are alike in construction , which will be more particularly explained by fig. 2 .
These bodies are suspended by two white fir rods of about half an inch diameter of and gh , being about four feet long from the point of suspension to the center of the bodies ; and their suspension is upon the cross-piece II , which is mortoised through , to let the rods pass with perfect freedom ; and they hand upon two small plates filed to an edge on the under side , and pass through the upper part of the rods .
Their centers are at k and l , and the edges being let into a little notch , on each side the mortoise , the rods are at liberty to vibrate freely upon their respective points ( or rather edges ) of suspension , and are determined to one plain of vibration .
MN is a flat arch of white wood , which may be covered with Paper , that the marks thereupon may be the more conspicuous .
The cross-piece II is made to project so far before the pillar , that the bodies in their vibrations may pass clear of it , without danger of striking it ; and also the arch MN is brought so far forward as to leave no more than a clearance , sufficient for the rods to vibrate freely without touching it .
Fig. 2 .
Shows one of the compound bodies , drawn of its full size .
AB is a block of wood , and about as much in breadth as it is represented in height , through a hole in which the wood rod CC passes , and is fixed therein .
DB represents a plate of lead about three-eighths of an inch thick , one on each side , screwed on by way of giving it a competent weight .
dBefg represents the edge of a springing plate of brass , rendered elastic by hard hammering ; it is about fiveeighths of an inch in breadth , and about one-twentieth of an inch thick .
It is fixed down upon the wooden block at its end dB by means of a bridge plate , whose end is shown hi , and is screwed down on each side the spring plate by a screws which being relaxed the spring can be taken out at pleasure , and adjusted to its proper situation .
kl is a light thin slip of a plate , whose under edge is cut into teeth like a fine saw or ratchet , and is attached to the spring by a pin at k , which passes through it , and also through a small stud rivetted into the back part of the spring , and upon which pin , as a center , it is freely moveable .
mn shows a small plate or stud seen edgeways raised upon the bridge plate , through an hole in which stud the ratchet passes ; and the lower part of the hole is cut to a tooth shaped properly to catch the teeth of the ratchet , and retain it together with the spring at any degree to which it may be suddenly bent ; and for this intent it is kept bearing gently downward , by means of a wire-spring opq , which is in reality double , the bearing part at o being semi-circular ; from which branching off on each side the rod cc , passes to p , and fixes at each end into the wood at q. However , to clear the ratchet , which is necessarily in the middle as well as the rod , the latter is perforated ; and also the block is cut away , so far as to set the main spring at e free of all obstacles that would prevent its play from the point B. The part fg is shown thicker than the rest , by being covered with thin kid leather tight sowed on , to prevent a certain jarring that otherwise takes place on the meeting of the springs in collision .
Let us now return to fig. 1 .
the marks upon the arch MN are put on as follows .
op is an arch of a circle from the center l , and qr an arch of a circle from the center k intersecting each other at s. Now the middle line of the marks t , v , are at the same distance from the middle line at s that the centers kl are ; so that when each body hangs in its own free position , without bearing against the other , the rod of will cover the mark at t , and the rod gh will cover the mark at v. From the point S upon the arches Sp and Sq respectively , set off points at an equal and competent distance from S each way , which will give the middle of the mark w and x : and upon the arch Sp find a middle point between the mark v and w , which let be y ; and on the other side , in like manner , upon the arch Sq find a middle point for the mark z ; then set off the distance Sv or St from y each way , and from z each way ; and from these points , drawing lines to the respective centers l and k , they will give the place and position of the marks a , b , and c , d ; and thus is the machine prepared for use .
FORTRIALSONELASTICBODIE S. For this use take out the pins and ratchets from each respectively , and the springs being then at liberty , with a short bit of stick ( suppose the same size as the rods ) turn aside the rod gh with the right-hand , carrying the body D upwards till the stick is upon the mark w , as suppose at ~ ; there hold it , and with the left set the body C perfectly at rest ; in which case the rod of will be over the mark t ; then suddenly withdraw the stick , in the direction that the rod gh is to follow it , and the spring of the body D , impinging upon that of the body C , they will be both bent , and also restored ; and the body C will fly off , and mount till its rod of covers the mark x ; the rod of the striking body D remaining at rest upon its proper mark of rest v , till the body C returns , when the body D will fly off in he same manner ; the two bodies thus rebounding a number of times , losing a part of their vibration each time ; but so nearly is the theory of elastic bodies fulfilled hereby , that the single advantage of originally pushing the rod gh beyond the mark w , by the thickness of the stick , or its own thickness , is sufficient to carry the rod of the quiescent body C completely to its mark x. There are several other experiments that may be made with this apparatus , in confirmation of the doctrine of the collision of elastic bodies ; which being universally agreed upon , and well known , it is needless further to dwell upon here ; but respecting the application to non-elastic soft bodies , it is far more difficult to come at a fitness of materials for this kind of experiments , than it is for those supposing perfectly elasticity .
The conclusions , however , may be attained with equal certainty .
FORTRIALSONNO N-E LASTICSOFTBODIE S. For this purpose the ratchets must be applied and put in order as before described , and the springs being both put to their point of rest , let the body D be put to its mark w in the same manner as before described , and the body C to rest .
The body D being let go , and striking the body C at rest , in consequence of the stroke , the springs being hooked up by the ratchets , they both move from their resting marks t , v , respectively toward M : Now if they both moved together , and the rod of covered the mark c , and the rod gh covered the mark d at their utmost limit , then they would truly obey the laws of non-elastic soft bodies ; because their medium ascent would be to the mark z , which is just half the angle of ascent to the mark x ; but as in this piece of machinery , though the main or principle springs are hooked up , yet every part of them , and all the materials of which they are composed , and to which they are attached , have a degree , or more properly speaking , a certain compass of elasticity , which , as such , is perfect , and no motion lost thereby .
We must not , therefore , expect the two compound bodies after the stroke to stick together without separating , as would be the case with bodies truly non-elastic and soft ; but that from the elasticity they are possessed of , they will by rebounding be separated ; but that elasticity being perfect , can occasion no loss of motion to the sum of the two bodies ; so that if the body C ascends as much above its mark c as the body D falls short of its mark d , then it will follow , that their medium ascent will still be to the mark z , as it ought to have been , had theybeen truly non-elastic soft bodies ; and this , in reality , is truly the case in the experiment , as nearly as it can be discerned .
After a few vibrations , by the rubbing of the springs against one another , they are soon brought to rest ; and here they would always rest had they been truly and properly perfect non-elastic soft bodies ; but here , as in the case of these bodies , by a change of the figure and situation of the component parts , there is expended one half of the mechanical power of the first mover , yet in this case the other half is not lost , but suspended , ready to be re-exerted whenever it is set at liberty ; and that it is really and bona fide one half and neither more or less , appears from this uncontroverted simple principle , that the power of restitution of a perfect spring is exactly equal to the power that bends it .
And this may , in a certain degree , be shown to be fact by experiment , if there were any need of such a proof ; for if , when the bodies are at rest after the last experiment , the two rods are lashed together near the bottom with a bit of thread , and then the ratchets unpinned and removed ; on cutting the thread with a pair of scissors they will each of them rebound , C towards M , and D towards N ; and if they rebounded respectively to z and y , the mechanical power exerted would be the same as it was after the stroke , when the mean of their two ascents was up to the mark z ; but here it is not to be expected , because not only the motion lost by the friction of the ratchets is to be deducted , because it had the effect of real non-elasticity ; but also the elasticity that separated them in the stroke , which was lost in the vibrations that succeeded ; neither of which hindered the mean ascent to be to z ; but yet , under all these disadvantages in the machine ( if not unreasonably ill made ) the rod of will ascend to d , and gh to a : and hence I infer , as a positive truth , that in the collision of non elastic soft bodies , one half of the mechanic power residing in the striking body is lost in the stroke .
Respecting bodies unelastic and perfectly hard , we must infer , that since we are unavoidably led to a conclusion concerning them , which contradicts what is esteemed a truth capable of the strictest demonstration ; viz. that the velocity of the center of gravity of no system of bodies can be changed by any collision betwixt one another , something must be assumed that involves a contradiction .
This perfectly holds , according to all the established rules , both of perfectly elastic and perfectly non-elastic soft bodies ; rules which must fail in the perfectly non-elastic hard bodies , if their velocity after the stroke is to the velocity of the striking body as one is to the square root of 2 ; for then the center of gravity of the two bodies will by the stroke acquire a velocity greater than the center of gravity the two bodies had before the stroke in that proportion , which is proved thus .
At the outset of the striking body , the center of gravity of the two bodies in our case will be exactly in the middle between the two ; and when they meet it will have moved from their half distance to their point of contact , so the velocity of the center of gravity before the bodies meet will be exactly one half of the velocity of the striking body ; and , therefore , if the velocity of the striking body is 2 , the velocity of the center of gravity of both will be one .
After the stroke , as both bodies are supposed to move in contact , the velocity of the center of gravity will be the same as that of the bodies ; and as their velocity is proved to be the square root of 2 , the velocity of their center of gravity will be increased from 1 .
to the square root of 2 .
; that is , from 1 .
to 1.414 , &amp;c. The fair inference from these contradictory conclusions therefore is , that an unelastic hard body ( perfectly so ) is a repugnant idea , and contains in itself a contradiction ; for to make it agree with the fair conclusions that may be drawn on each side , from clear premises , we shall be obliged to define its properties thus : that in the stroke of unelastic hard bodies they cannot possibly lose any mechanic power in the stroke ; because no other impression is made than the communication of motion ; and yet they must lose a quantity of mechanic power in the stroke ; because , if they do not , their common center of gravity , as above shown , will acquire an increase of velocity by their stroke upon each other .
In a like manner the idea of a perpetual motion , perhaps , at first sight , may not appear to involve a contradiction in terms ; but we shall be obliged to confess that it does , when , on examining its requisites for execution , we find we shall want bodies having the following properties ; that when they are made to ascend against gravitation their absolute weight shall be less ; and that when they descend by gravitation ( through an equal space ) their absolute weight shall be greater ; which , according to all we know of nature , is a repugnant or contradictory idea .
Machine for COLLIS~ Fig. 2.d g m o p k l hn i qB d D Ae C f ~ kl II ~ Fig. 1.st o~wr cb zy da MlvN qSp CD eg A Scale ~ Feet .

