possible , and also to differ as much in magnitude as we can find them .
GALILEO , I believe , was the first who suggested this method ; but in the manner he mentions it in his third dialogue of the Systema Cosmicum , it would be exposed to all the difficulties we have enumerated , and would wish to avoid ; for he does not observe , that the two stars should be so near each other as thereby to preclude the influence of every cause of error .
This method has also been mentioned by other authors ; and we find that Dr. LONG observed the double star which is the first of Aries in PTOLEMY'S catalogue ; that in the head of Castor ; the middle one in the sword of Orion ; and that in the breast of Virgo , with telescopes of fourteen and seventeen feet , and ` ` was persuaded they would be found always to appear the same .
' ' But when the theory of parallax will be explained , it will be seen that every one of these stars are totally improper for the purpose ; for the stars of ~ Arietis are near 10~ distant from each other , and moreover equal in magnitude .
In ~ Geminorum the stars , though near enough , do not sufficiently differ in magnitude to show any parallax .
The stars in the Nebula of Orion , on account of their extreme smallness or distance , are still more improper than any ; and those of ~ Virginis are equal in magnitude .
I do not find that any thing else has been done upon the subject .
GALILEO justly remarks , that such observations ought to be made with the best telescopes , and upon this occasion mentions the power of his own , which enlarged the disk of the sun a thousand times , from which we find it magnified about thirtytwo times ; but we can hardly think his nor even Dr. LONG'S , whose power might probably be sixty or seventy , sufficient for the purpose .
What would GALILEO say , if he were told that our present opticians make instruments that enlarge the disk of the sun above forty thousand times ?
What would even CASSINI say , if he were to view the first star of Aries , which appeared to him as split in two , through a telescope that will show ~ Coronae borealis and h Draconis to be double stars ?
But to proceed , I shall now prove that this method , if stars properly situated ( such as I have found ) are taken , is free from all the errors occasioned by refraction , nutation , precession of the equinoxes , changes of the obliquity of the ecliptic , and aberration of light ; and that the annual parallax , if it even should not exceed the tenth part of a second , may still become visible , and be ascertained at least to a much greater degree of approximation than it ever has been done .
It will also appear , from the great number of observations I have already made upon several double stars , especially ~ Bootis , that we can now with much greater certainty affirm the annual parallax to be exceedingly small indeed ; and that there is a great probability of succeeding still farther in this laborious but delightful research , so as to be able at last to say , not only how much the annual parallax is not , but how much it really is .
Let there be two stars at a distance from each other , not exceeding five seconds ; suppose them to be observed at an altitude of 20~ ; and let them be so situated with respect to each other , that one of them may be 20~ , and the other 20~ and 5~ high : then the whole effect of mean refraction at that altitude , by Dr. MASKELYNE'S excellent tables , will be 2~ 35~ , 5 for 20~ , and 2~ 35~ , 4888 for 20~ 5~ .
The difference is 0~ , 0111 .
Now , in the first place , we have nothing to do with the refraction itself , since the real altitude of the stars is not in question .
In the next place , we also have no concern with the difference of refracV O L. LXXII .
N tion tion between the two stars , though no more than the,0111th part of a second , because the real distance between the two stars is not required .
It follows then , that these observations can only be affected by the difference of the difference ; that is , by an alteration in the quantity of refraction occasioned by the change of heat and cold , or weight of the atmosphere , and pointed out to us by the rise and fall of the barometer and thermometer .
Let us then see what this difference of the difference may amount to .
Suppose a change of 22~ of FAHRENHEIT'S thermometer , that is , from the freezing point to the moderate air of a summer 's night , and a difference of an inch in the height of the barometer ; these two causes both conspiring , which does not often happen , may occasion an alteration of,00096th part of a second in five , at an altitude of 20~ ; but this being less than the thousandth part of a second may safely be rejected as a quantity altogether insensible .
Since it may not be always convenient to view those stars at the altitude of 20~ , it remains to see what effect different altitudes may have : let us then make the most unfavourable supposition , that they may one time be seen in a horizontal position , having before been seen vertical .
In this case , as the whole difference of refraction in a difference of 5~ of altitude is no more than,0111 , provided they are observed not lower than 20~ , and the whole difference of the difference of refraction is only,0009 ; the sum,012 , when both conspire , not exceeding much the hundredth part of a second , may still be rejected as insensible .
Let us also examine how near the horizon it may be safe to observe such stars .
At 10~ , for instance , the refraction is 5~ 14~ , 6 ; the difference for 5~ is,0388 ; the joint effect of the changes in the barometer and thermometer is ,0034 ; the sum of the whole together amounts to,0422 , which is less than half the tenth of a second : now this may either be taken into consideration , or such low observations may be avoided , as being by no means necessary , and but ill suiting the high powers a telescope proper for this purpose ought to bear .
The change of position of the earth 's axis I look upon as an unsurmountable obstacle to taking the parallax of stars by the method of zenith distances : for though refraction is much reduced in the zenith , this change is there no less sensible than in other parts of the heavens ; but as this will always affect our two stars exactly alike , we are entirely freed from this embarrassment .
The aberration of light can have no influence of the least consideration upon our two stars , as a mere inspection of the tables will show .
In a whole degree , its effects , when greatest , amount but to four-tenths of a second , and consequently in 5~ to no more than,0005 , or the two thousandth part of a second .
Observations of the relative distance of the two stars that make up a double star , being thus cleared of every impediment , are capable of being continually improved by every degree of perfection the telescope may acquire : we can chuse stars that may be viewed sufficiently high to be clear of the vapours that swim near the horizon , and consequently employ the greatest powers our instruments are capable of .
From experience I can also affirm , that the stars will bear a much higher degree of magnifying than other celestial objects .
Too much has hitherto been taken for granted in optics : every natural philosopher is ready enough to allow the necessity of making experiments , and tracing out the steps of nature ; why this method should not be more pursued in the art of seeing does not appear .
Theories are only to be used when proper data are assigned ; but the data are carefully to be re-examined , when new improvements may widely alter the result of former experiments .
Thus , we are told , that we gain nothing by magnifying too much .
I grant it ; but shall never believe I magnify too much till by experience I find , that I can see better with a lower power .
Nor is even that sufficient : a lower power may show more of the object ; it may show it brighter , nay even distincter , and therefore upon the whole better ; and yet the greater power may , in a particular case , be preferable : for if the object is so small as not to be at all visible with the lower power , and I can , by magnifying more , obtain a view of it , though neither so bright nor distinct as I could wish , is it not evident , that here this power is preferable to the former ?
The naturalist does not think himself obliged to account for all the phenomenon he may observe ; the astronomer and optician may claim the same privilege .
When we increase the power we lessen the light in the inverse ratio of the square of the power ; and telescopes will , in general , discover more small stars the more light they collect ; yet with a power of 227 I cannot see the small star near the star following o Aquilae , when , by the same telescope , it appears very plainly with the power of 460 : now , in the latter case , the power being more than double , the light is less than the fourth part of the former .
In such particular cases I generally suspect my own eyes , and have recourse to those of my friends .
I had the pleasure of showing this star to Dr. WATSON junior , who soon discovered the small star , which accompanies the other , with the power of 460 ; but saw nothing of it with 227 , though the place where to look for it had been pointed out to him by the higher power .
The experiment has been too often repeated to be doubtful , and has also been confirmed by others of nearly the same nature : for instance , the smallest of the two that accompany the star near k Aquilae , the small star near ~ Herculis , and the small star near ~ Lyrae , are invisible with my power of 227 , and visible with the same aperture when the power is 460 .
Also the small stars near FLAMSTEAD'S 24th of Aquila , the smallest of two near ~ Coronae , the small star near the star south of ~ Aquilae , the small star near the second o Persei , the small star near the star which accompanies FLAMSTEAD'S 10th sub pede et scapula dextra Tauri , the small star , near ~ Delphini , and the small star near the pole star , are all much brighter and stronger , and therefore much sooner seen with 460 than with 227 .
Great power may also , in particular circumstances , be favourable , even with an excess of aberration .
When two stars are so close together as to make the scale for measuring the distance of their centers too small , if , by magnifying much , we can enlarge that distance , we may gain a considerable advantage , provided the centers or apparent bodies of the stars remain distinct enough for the purpose of these measures .
The appearance of ~ Lyrae in my Newtonian reflector with a power of 460 is represented in fig. 2 .
; with 2010 in fig. 3 .
; with 3168 in fig. 4 .
; and with 6450 in fig. 5 .
Now in all these figures we see , that the centers are still distinct enough to measure their distances with sufficient truth ; or if any little error should be introduced by the magnitude of the central point , it will be more than sufficiently balanced by the largeness of the scale .
In this manner , with a power of 3168 , I have obtained a scale of no less than ten inches six tenths for the distance of the centers of the two stars of ~ Geminorum ; and as we know these centers to be but a few seconds distant , it is plain how great an advantage we gain by such an enlarged scale .
These experiments have but very lately pointed out to me a method of making a new micrometer , upon a construction entirely different from any that are now in use , which I have been successful enough to put in practice , and by which I have already begun to determine the distance of the centers of some of the most remarkable double stars to a very great degree of accuracy * .
The powers that may be used upon various double stars are different , according to their relative magnitudes : ~ Bootis , for instance , will not bear the same power as ~ Geminorum , nor would it be difficult to assign a reason for it ; but as I here shall merely confine myself to facts , it will be sufficient in general to mention , that two stars , which are equal , or nearly so , will bear a very high power : with ~ Geminorum I have gone as far as 3168 ; but with the former only to 2010 .
The difficulty of using high powers is exceedingly great ; for the field of view takes in less than the diameter of the hair or wire in the finder , and the effect of the earth 's diurnal motion is so great , that it requires a great deal of practice to find the object , and manage the instrument .
It appears to me very probable , that the diurnal motion of the earth will be the greatest obstacle to our progress in magnifying , except we can introduce a proper mechanism to carry our telescopes in a con trary motion .
Notwithstanding opticians have proved that two eye-glasses will give a more correct image than one , I have always ( from experience ) persisted in refusing the assistance of a second glass , which is sure to introduce errors greater than those we would correct .
Let us resign the double eye-glass to those who view objects * For a description of this micrometer see a subsequent paper .
merely for entertainment , and must have an exorbitant field of view .
To a philosopher this is an unpardonable indulgence .
I have tried both the single and double eye-glass of equal powers , and always found that the single eye-glass had much the superiority in point of light and distinctness .
With the double eye-glass I could not see the belts on Saturn , which I very plainly saw with the single one .
I would , however , except all those cases where a large field is absolutely necessary , and where power joined to distinctness is not the sole object of our view .
The application of the different powers of a telescope in general is of some consequence ; and in answer to those who may think I have strained or over-charged mine , I must observe , that a single glance at the subsequent h Draconis , ~ Coronae , and the star near ~ Bootis , with a power of 460 , showed them to me as double stars ; when , in two former reviews of the heavens , I had twice set them down in my journal as single stars , where I used only the power of 222 and 227 , and in all probability should never have found them double , had I not looked with a higher power .
We are to remember , that it is much easier to see an object when it is pointed out to us than when it falls in our way unexpectedly , especially if of such a nature as to require some attention to be seen at all ; but to say no more of other advantages of high powers , it is evident , that in the research of the parallax of the fixed stars they are absolutely necessary .
If we would distinctly perceive and measure or estimate extremely small quantities , such as a tenth of a second , it appears , that when we use a power of 460 , this tenth of a second will be no more in appearance than 46~ , and even with a power of 1500 will be but 2~ 30~ , which is a quantity not much more than sufficient to judge well of objects and distinguish them from each other , such as a circle from a square , triangle , or polygon * .
It has been observed , that objects grow indistinct when the principal optic pencil at the eye becomes less than the 40th or 50th part of an inch in diameter .
In the experiments that have been made upon this subject it appears to me , that the indistinctness which is ascribed to the smallness of the optical pencil may be owing to very different causes : at least it will be easy to bring contrary experiments of extremely small pencils , not at all affected by this inconvenience ; for instance , it is well known , that microscopes , consisting of a single lens or globule , are remarkable for distinctness .
We also know , that they have been made so small as to magnify above 10,000 times ~ .
From this we may infer that their apertures , and consequently the diameters of the optic pencil at the eye could not exceed the 2500th part of an inch .
I am therefore inclined to believe , that we must look for distinctness in the perfection of the object-speculum or object-glass of a telescope ; and if we can make the first image in the focus of a speculum almost as perfect as the real object , what should hinder our magnifying but the want of light ?
Now , if the object has light sufficient , as the stars most undoubtedly have , I see no reason why we should limit the powers of our instruments by any theory .
Is it not best to have recourse to experiments to find * By a set of experiments , made in the year 1774 , I found , that I could discover or perceive a bright object , such as white paper , against the sky-light , when it subtended an angle of 35~ ; but could only distinguish it to be a circle , and no other figure , when it appeared under an angle of 2~ 24~ .
~ See Padre DELLA TORRE'S Method , &amp;c. Scelta di Opusculi .
how far our endeavours to render the first image perfect have been successful .
As soon as I was fully satisfied that in the investigation of parallax the method of double stars would have many advantages above any other , it became necessary to look out for proper stars .
This introduced a new series of observations .
I resolved to examine every star in the heavens with the utmost attention and a very high power , that I might collect such materials for this research as would enable me to fix my observations upon those that would best answer my end .
The subject has already proved so extensive , and still promises so rich a harvest to those who are inclined to be diligent in the pursuit , that I cannot help inviting every lover of astronomy to join with me in observations that must inevitably lead to new discoveries .
I took some pains to find out what double stars had been recorded by astronomers ; but my situation permitted me not to consult extensive libraries , nor indeed was it very material : for as I intended to view the heavens myself , Nature , that great volume , appeared to me to contain the best catalogue upon this occasion .
However , I remembered that the star in the head of Castor , that in the breast of the Virgin , and the first star in Aries , had been mentioned by CASSINI as double stars .
I also found the Nebula in Orion was marked in HUGEN'S Systema Saturnium as containing seven stars , three of which ( now known to be four ) are very near together .
With this small stock I begun , and in the course of a few years observations have collected the stars contained in my catalogue .
I find , with great pleasure , that a very excellent observer , whom I have the honour to call my friend * , has also , though un* Phil. Trans. for the year 1781 , part II .
double stars discovered in 1779 , at Frampton-house , Glamorganshire , by NOT .
PIGOTT , Esq. F. R. S. &amp;c. known to me , met with three of those stars that will be found in my catalogue : and upon this occasion I also beg leave to observe , that the Astronomer Royal , when I was at Greenwich last May , with his usual politeness , showed me , among other objects , ~ Herculis as a double star , which he had discovered some years ago .
The rev .
Mr. HORNSBY also , when I had the pleasure of seeing him at Oxford , in a conversation on the subject of the stars of the first magnitude that have a proper motion , mentioned ~ Bootis as a double star .
It is a little hard upon young astronomers to be obliged to discover over-again what has already been discovered ; however , the pleasure that attended the view when I first saw these stars has made some amends for not knowing they had been seen before me .
If I should mention in my list of observations a few that may be found difficult to be verified by other telescopes , I must beg the indulgence of the observers .
I hope it will sufficiently appear , that I have guarded against optical delusions ; and every astronomer , I make no doubt , will find , by those observations that fall within the compass of his instruments , and attention to circumstances necessary to the right management of them , that I have had all along truth and reality in view , as the sole object of my endeavours ; and therefore he will be inclined to give some credit to what he does not immediately perceive , when he finds himself successful where he takes the proper precautions so necessary in delicate observations , even with the best instruments .
I have been in some doubt in what manner to communicate these observations .
My first view was to have methodized them properly ; but I find them so extensive that there is but little probability that one person should be able to bring them to a conclusion , for which reason I have now resolved to give them unfinished as they are , that every person who is inclined to engage in this pursuit may become a fellow-labourer .
In settling the distances of double stars I have occasionally used two different ways .
Those that are extremely near each other may be estimated by the eye , in measures of their own apparent diameters .
For this purpose their distance should not much exceed two diameters of the largest , as the eye cannot so well make a good estimation when the interval between them is greater .
This method has often the preference to that of the micrometer : for instance , when the diameter of a small star , perhaps not equal to half a second , is double the vacancy between the two stars .
Here a micrometer ought to measure tenths of seconds at least , otherwise we could not , with any degree of confidence , rely on its measures ; nay , even then , if the stars are situated in the same parallel of declination and near the equator , their quick motion across the micrometer makes it extremely difficult to measure them , and in that case an estimation by the eye is preferable to any other measure ; but this requires not a little practice , precaution , and time , and yet with proper care it will be found that this method is capable of great exactness .
Let two small circles be drawn either equal or unequal , at a distance not exceeding twice the diameter of the largest ; let these be shown to several persons in the same light and point of view .
Then , if every one of them will separately and carefully write down his estimation of the interval between them , in the proportion of either of their diameters , it will be found upon a comparison that there will seldom be so much as a quarter of a diameter difference between all the estimations .
If this agreement takes place with so many different eyes , much more may we expect it in the estimations of the same eye when accustomed to this kind of judgement .
I have divided the double stars into several different classes .
In the first I have placed all those which require indeed a very superior telescope , the utmost clearness of air , and every other favourable circumstance to be seen at all , or well enough to judge of them .
They seemed to me on that account to deserve a separate place , that an observer might not condemn his instrument or his eye if he should not be successful in distinguishing them .
As these are some of the finest , most minute , and most delicate objects of vision I ever beheld , I shall be happy to hear that my observations have been verified by other persons , which I make no doubt the curious in astronomy will soon undertake .
I should observe , that since it will require no common stretch of power and distinctness to seeIthese double stars , it will therefore not be amiss to go gradually through a few preparatory steps of vision , such as the following : when ~ Coronae borealis ( one of the most minute double stars ) is proposed to be viewed , let the telescope be some time before directed to ~ Geminorum , or if not in view to either of the following stars , ~ Aquarii , ~ Draconis , ~ Herculis , ~ Piscium , or the curious doubledouble star ~ Lyrae .
These should be kept in view for a considerable time , that the eye may acquire the habit of seeing such objects well and distinctly .
The observer may next proceed to ~ Ursae majoris , and the beautiful treble star in Monoceros 's right fore-foot ; after these to i Bootis , which is a fine miniature of ~ Geminorum , to the star preceding ~ Orionis , and to n Orionis .
By this time both the eye and the telescope will be prepared for a still finer picture , which is ~ Coronae borealis .
It will be in vain to attempt this latter if all the former , at least i Bootis , cannot be distinctly perceived to be fairly separated because it is almost as fine a miniature of i Bootis as that is of ~ Geminorum .
If the observer has been successful in all these , he may then , at the same time , try h Draconis , though I question whether any power less than 4 or 500 will show it to be double ; but the former I have all seen very well with 227 .
To try the stars of unequal magnitudes it will be expedient to take them in some such order as the following : ~ Herculis , ~ Aurigae , ~ Geminorum , ~ Cygni , ~ Persei , and b Draconis ; from these the observer may proceed to a most beautiful object , ~ Bootis , which I have closely attended these two years as very proper for the investigation of the parallax of the fixed stars .
It appears , from what has been said , that these double stars are a most excellent way of trying a telescope ; and as the foregoing remarks have suggested the method of seeing how far the power and distinctness of our instruments will reach , I shall add the way of finding how much light we have .
The observer may begin with the pole-star and ~ Lyrae ; then go to the star south of ~ Aquilae , the treble star near ~ Aquilae , and last of all to the star following o Aquilae .
Now , if his telescope has not a great deal of good distinct light , he will not be able to see some of the small stars that accompany them .
In the second class of double stars I have put all those that are proper for estimations by the eye or very delicate measures of the micrometer .
To compare the distances with the apparent diameters the power of the telescope should not be much less than 200 , as they will otherwise be too close for the purpose .
The instrument ought , moreover , to be as much as possible free from rays that surround a star in common telescopes , and should give the apparent diameters of a double star perfectly round and well-defined , with a deep black division between them , as in fig. 6 .
which represents ~ Geminorum as I have often seen it with a power of 460 .
It will be necessary here to take notice , that the estimations made with one telescope cannot be applied to those made with another : nor can the estimations made with different powers , though with the same telescope , be applied to each other .
Whatever may be the cause of the apparent diameters of the stars , they are certainly not of equal magnitude with the same powers in different telescopes , nor of proportional magnitude with different powers in the same telescope .
In my instruments I have ever found less diameter in proportion the higher I was able to go in power , and never have I found so small a proportional diameter as when I magnified 6450 times * ; therefore if we would wish to compare any such observations together , with a view to see whether a change in the distance has taken place , it should be done with the very same telescope and power , even with the very same eye-glass or glasses ; for others , though of equal power and goodness , would most probably give different proportional diameters of the stars .
In the third class I have placed all those double stars that are more than five but less than 15~ asunder ; and for that reason , if they should be used for observations on the parallax of the fixed stars , they ought not to be looked upon as quite free from the effects of refraction , &amp;c. In the same manner that the stars in the first and second classes will serve to try the goodness of the most capital instruments , these will afford objects for telescopes of inferior power , such as magnify from 40 to 100 times .
The observer may take them in this or the like order : ~ Ursae majoris , ~ Delphini , ~ Arietis , ~ Bootis , ~ Vir* See the measures of the diameter of ~ Lyrae .
Catalogue of double stars , 5th class .
ginis , ~ Cassiopeae , ~ Cygni .
And if he can see all these , he may pass over into the second class , and direct his instrument to some of those that were pointed out as objects for the very best telescopes , where , I suppose , he will soon find the want of superior power .
The fourth , fifth , and sixth classes contain double stars that are from 15 to 30~ , from 30~ to 1~ , and from 1~ to 2~ or more asunder .
Though these will hardly be of any service for the purpose of parallax , I thought it not amiss to give an account of such as I have observed ; they may , perhaps , answer another very important end , which also requires a great deal of accuracy , though not quite so much as the investigation of the parallax of the fixed stars .
I will just mention it , though foreign to my present purpose .
Several stars of the first magnitude have already been observed , and others suspected , to have a proper motion of their own : hence we may surmise , that our sun , with all its planets and comets , may also have a motion towards some particular part of the heavens , on account of a greater quantity of matter collected in a number of stars and their surrounding planets there situated , which may perhaps occasion a gravitation of our whole solar system towards it .
If this surmise should have any foundation , it will show itself in a series of some years ; as from that motion will arise another kind of hitherto unknown parallax * , the investigation of which may account for some part of the motions already observed in some of the principal stars ; and for the purpose of determining the direction and quantity of such a motion , accurate observations of the distance of stars that are near enough to be measured with a micrometer , and a very high power of * See the note in the rev .
Mr. MITCHELL'S paper on the Parallax of the Fixed Stars , Phil. Trans. vol. LVII .
p. 252 .
telescopes may be of considerable use , as they will undoubtedly give us the relative places of those stars to a much greater degree of accuracy than they can be had by transit instruments or sectors , and thereby much sooner enable us to discover any apparent change in their situation occasioned by this new kind of systematical parallax , if I may be allowed to use that expression , for signifying the change arising from the motion of the whole solar system .
I shall now endeavour to deliver a theory of the annual parallax of double stars , with the method of computing from thence what is generally called the parallax of the fixed stars , or of single stars of the first magnitude , such as are nearest to us .
It may be observed , that the principles upon which I have founded the following theory are of such a nature , that they cannot be strictly demonstrated , in consequence of which they are only proposed as postulata , which have so great a probability in their favour , that they will hardly be objected to by those who are in the least acquainted with the doctrine of chances .
GENERALPOSTULAT A. 1 .
Let the stars be supposed , one with another , to be about the size of the sun * .
2 .
Let the difference of their apparent magnitudes be owing to their different distances , so that a star of the second , third , * See Mr. MICHELL'S Inquiry into the probable Parallax and Magnitude of the Fixed Stars , Phil. Trans. vol. LVII .
p. 234 .
236 .
237 .
240 .
and Dr. HALLEY on the Number , Order , and Light , of the Fixed Stars , Phil. Trans. vol. XXXI .
or fourth magnitude is two , three , or four times as far off as one of the first * .
In fig. 7 .
let O be the whole diameter of the earth 's annual orbit ; and let a , b , c , be three stars situated in the ecliptic , in such a manner that they may be seen all in one line Oabc , when the earth is at O. Let the line Oabc be perpendicular to O , and draw PE parallel to cO .
Then , if Oa , ab , bc , are equal to each other , a will be a star of the first magnitude , b of the second , and c of the third .
Let us now suppose the angle OaE , or parallax of the whole orbit of the earth , to be 1~ of a degree : then we have PEa=OaE=1~ .
: and , because very small angles , having the same subtense O , may be taken to be in the inverse ratio of the lines Oa , Ob , Oc , &amp;c. we shall have ObE=1/ 2~ , OcE=1/ 4~ , &amp;c. ~ .
Now , when the earth is removed * The apparent magnitude is here taken in a stricter sense than is generally used ; and by it is rather meant the order into which the stars ought to be distinguished than that into which they are commonly divided : for as the order of the magnitudes is here to denote the different relative distances , we are to examine carefully the degree of light each star is accurately found to have : and considering then that light diminishes in the inverse ratio of the squares of the distances , we ought to class the stars accordingly .
An allowance ought also perhaps to be made for some loss that may happen to the light of very remote stars in its passage through immense tracts of space , most probably not quite destitute of some very subtle medium .
This conjecture is suggested to us by the colour of the very small telescopic stars , for I have generally found them red , or inclining to red ; which seems to indicate , that the more feeble and refrangible rays of the other colours are either stopped by the way , or at least diverted from their course by accidental deflections .
~ This proves what I have before remarked on the parallax of ~ Draconis ; for that star , ( admitting it to be a star of between the second and third magnitude , which ought to be ascertained by experiments , as mentioned in the note above ) by the postulata , will have its place assigned somewhere between b and c , and therefore its parallax will be between 1/ 2 and 1/ 3 of the parallax of a star of the first magnitude .
And if Dr. BRADLEY thought that he should have perceived a removed to E , we shall have PEb = EbO = 1/ 2~ , and PEa PEb = aEb = 1/ 2~ ; that is , the stars a , b , will appear to be 1/ 2~ distant .
We also have PEc = EcO = 1/ 3~ , and PEa PEc = aEc = 2/ 3~ ; that is , the stars a , c , will appear to be 2/ 3~ distant , when the earth is at E. Now , since we have bEP = 1/ 2~ , and cEP = 1/ 3~ , therefore bEP cEP = bEc = 1/ 2~ 1/ 3~ = 1/ 6~ ; that is , the stars b , c , will appear to be only 1/ 6~ removed from each other , when the earth is at E. From what has been said , we may gather the following general expression , to denote the parallax that will become visible in the change of distance between the two stars , by the removal of the earth from one extreme of its orbit to the other .
Let P express the total parallax of a fixed star of the first magnitude , M the magnitude of the largest of the two stars , m the magnitude of the smallest * , and p the partial parallax to be observed by the change in the distance of a double star ; then will p= m-M/ Mm P ; and p being found by observation will give us P= pMm/ m-M .
An example or two will explain this sufficiently .
Suppose a star of the first magnitude should have a small star of the twelfth magnitude near it ; then will the partial parallax parallax in ~ Draconis , if at most it had amounted to 2~ , it follows , ~ that the angle OaE may nearly amount to 4 or 5~ for any thing we can conclude to the contrary from those observations .
* As M and m are here taken to express the relative distances of the stars , in measures whereof the distance of the nearest star is taken as unity , those who think the postulata on which these estimations are built cannot be granted , may still use the following formulae , if instead of the magnitudes M , m , they put their own estimations of the relative distances of the stars , according to any other method whatever they may think it most eligible to adopt ; for the apparent magnitude of stars is here only proposed as the most probable means we have of forming any conjectures about their relative distances .
we are to expect to see be 12 x 1/ 12 1 P ; or 11/ 12ths of the total parallax of a fixed star of the first magnitude ; and if we should , by observation , find the partial parallax between two such stars to amount to 1~ , we shall have the total parallax P= 1x1x 12/ 12 1= 1~,0909 .
If the stars are of the third and twentyfourth magnitude , the partial parallax will be 24 3/ 3 x 24 = 21/ 72 P ; and if , by observation , p is found to be a tenth of a second , the whole parallax will come out,1 x3x 24/ 24 3= 0~,3428 .
It will be necessary to examine some different situations .
Suppose the stars , being still in the ecliptic , to appear in one line , when the earth is in any other part of its orbit between O and E ; then will the parallax still be expressed by the same algebraic form , and one of the maxima will still lie at O , the other at E ; but the whole effect will be divided into two parts , which will be in proportion to each other as radius sine to radius + sine of the stars distance from the nearest conjunction or opposition .
When the stars are any where out of the ecliptic situated so as to appear in one line Oabc at rectangles to O , the maximum of parallax will still be expressed by m M/ Mm P ; but there will arise another additional parallax in the conjuction and opposition , which will be to that which is found 90~ before or after the sun , as the sine ( S ) of the latitude of the stars seen at O is to radius ( R ) ; and the effect of this parallax will be divided into two parts ; half of it lying on one side of the large star , the other half on the other side of it .
This latter parallax , moreover , will be compounded with the former , so that the distance of the stars in the conjunction and opposition will then be represented by the diagonal of a parallelogram , whereof the two semi-parallaxes are the sides ; a general expression for which will be ~m M/ 2Mm P2 x SS/ RR + 1 : for the stars will apparently describe two ellipses in the heavens , whose transverse axes will be to each other in the ratio of M to m ( fig. 8 .
) , and Aa , Bb , Cc , Dd , will be cotemporary situations .
Now , if bQ be drawn parallel to AC , and the parallelogram bqBQ completed , we shall have bQ = 1/ 2 CA 1/ 2 ca = 1/ 2 Cc = 1/ 2p , or semiparallax 90~ before or after the sun , and Bb may be resolved into , or is compounded of , bQ and bq ; but bq = 1/ 2 BD 1/ 2 bd = the semi-parallax in the conjunction or opposition .
We also have R : S : : bQ : bq = pS/ 2R ; therefore the distance Bb ( or Dd ) = ~p/ 22 + ~2 ; and by substituting the value of p into this expression we obtain ~m M/ 2Mm P2 x SS/ RR + 1 , as above .
When the stars are in the pole of the ecliptic , bq will become equal to bQ , and Bb will be.7071 Pm M/ M m. Hitherto we have supposed the stars to be all in one line Oabc ; let them now be at some distance , suppose 5~ from each other , and let them first be both in the ecliptic .
This case is resolvable into the first ; for imagine the star a , fig. 9 .
to stand at x , and in that situation the stars x , b , c , will be in one line , and their parallax expressed by m M/ Mm P. But the angle aEx may be taken to be equal to aOx ; and as the foregoing form gives us the angles xEb , xEc , we are to add aEx , or 5~ to xEb , and we shall have aEb .
In general , let the distance tance of the stars be d , and let the observed distance at E be D ; then will D=d+p , and therefore the whole parallax of the annual orbit will be expressed by DMm-dMm/ m-M=P .
Suppose the two stars now to differ only in latitude , one being in the ecliptic , the other , for instance , 5~ north , when seen at O. This case may also be resolved by the former ; for imagine the stars b , c , fig. 7 .
to be elevated at rectangles above the plane of the figure , so that aOb , or aOc , may make an angle of 5~ at O : then , instead of the lines Oabc , Ea , Eb , Ec , EP , imagine them all to be planes at rectangles to the figure ; and it will appear , that the parallax of the stars in longitude must be the same as if the small star had been without latitude .
And since the stars b , c , by the motion of the earth from O to E , will not change their latitude , we shall have the following construction for finding the distance of the stars ab , ac , at E , and from thence the parallax P. Let the triangle ab~ , fig. 10 .
represent the situation of the stars ; ab is the subtense of 5~ , that being the angle under which they are supposed to be seen at O. The quantity b~ by the former theorem is found m-M/ Mm P , which is the partial parallax that would have been seen by the earth 's moving from O to E , had both stars been in the ecliptic ; but on account of the difference in latitude it will now be represented by a~ , the hypothenuse of the triangle ab~ : therefore , in general , putting ab=d , and a~=D , we have ~DD-dd X Mm/ m-M = P. Hence D being taken by observation and d , M , and m , given , we obtain the total parallax .
If the situation of the stars differs in longitude as well as latitude , we may resolve this case by the following method .
Let the triangle ab~ , fig. 11 .
represent the situation of the stars , ab=d being their distance seen at O , a~=D their distance seen at E. That the change b~ which is produced by the earth 's motion will be truly expressed by m-M/ Mm P , may be proved as before , by supposing the star a to have been placed at ~ .
Now let the angle of position ba~ be taken by a micrometer * , or by any other method that may be thought sufficiently exact ; then , by solving the triangle ab~ , we shall have the longitudinal and latitudinal differences a~ and b~ of the two stars .
Put a~=x , b~=y , and it will be x+b~=aq , whence D=~x+m-M/ Mm P~ + yy ; and ~D2-y2 X M2m2-xMm/ m-M = P. If neither of the stars should be in the ecliptic , nor have the same longitude or latitude , the last theorem will still serve to calculate the total parallax whose maximum will lie in E. There will , moreover , arise another parallax , whose maximum will be in the conjunction and opposition , which will be divided , and lie on different sides of the large star ; but as we know the whole parallax to be exceedingly small , it will not be necessary to investigate every particular case of this kind ; for , by reason of the division of the parallax , which renders observations taken at any other time , except where it is greatest , very unfavourable , the forms would be of little use .
To finish this theory , I shall only add a general observation on the time and place where the maxima of parallax will happen .
* The position of a line passing through the two stars , with the parallel of declination of the largest of them , may be had by the micrometer I invented for this purpose in the year 1779 , of which a description has been given in a former paper ; whence , by spherical trigonometry , we easily deduce their position ba~ fig. 11 .
with regard to the ecliptic .
b* Fig. 3 .
Fig. 1 .
Fig. 2 .
a* Fig. 5 .
O Fig. 4 .
B q Qb CcaA d b Fig. 7 .
D b~ Fig. 11 .
a Fig. 10 .
aa O Fig. 12 .
South mp q West B nor c aA b Fig. 9 .
b~ ax ~q O t ~ A East s When two unequal stars are both in the ecliptic , or , not being in the ecliptic , have equal latitudes , north or south , and the largest star has most longitude , the maximum of the apparent distance will be when the sun 's longitude is 90~ more than the stars , or when observed in the morning ; and the minimum when the longitude of the sun is 90~ less than that of the star , or when observed in the evening .
When the small star has most longitude , the maximum and minimum , as well as the time of observation , will be the reverse of the former .
When the stars differ in latitudes , this makes no alteration in the place of the maximum or minimum , nor in the time of observation ; that is to say , it is immaterial whether the largest star has the least or the most latitude of the two stars .
XI .
On the Parallax of the Fixed Stars .
By Mr. Herschel , F. R. S. ; communicated by Sir Joseph Banks , Bart. P. R. S. Read December 6 , 1781 .
TO find the distance of the fixed stars has been a problem which many eminent astronomers have attempted to solve ; but about which , after all , we remain in a great measure still in the dark .
Various methods have been pursued without success , and the result of the finest observations has hardly given us more than a distant approximation , from which we may conclude , that the nearest of the fixed stars cannot be less than forty thousand diameters of the whole annual orbit of the earth distant from us .
Trigonometry , by whose powerful assistance the mathematician has boldly ascended into the planetary regions , and measured the diameters and orbits of the heavenly bodies , for want of a proper base , can here be but of little service ; for the whole diameter of the annual orbit of the earth is a mere point when compared to the immense distance of the stars .
Now , as it is not in our power to enlarge this base , we can only endeavour to improve the instruments by which we measure its parallax .
There are two things requisite for measuring extremely small angles with accuracy .
First , that the instrument we use for this purpose , be it quadrant , sector , or micrometer , should be divided and executed with sufficient exactness ; and , secondly , that the telescope , by which the observations are to be made , should have an adequate power and distinctness .
Upon the first head , the great improvements of mathematical instrument-makers have hardly left us any thing to desire : we can now measure seconds with almost as much facility and truth as former observers could measure minutes ; nor do I think it impossible to go still further , and divide instruments that would show thirds with sufficient accuracy .
It is in the latter , or optical part , we find the greatest difficulty .
To see a single second of a degree with precision requires a telescope of very great perfection ; therefore , supposing the mechanical part of an apparatus well executed , it will still be necessary to try how far the power of our telescope will enable us to ascertain with confidence the division or number of seconds it points out .
If upon trial we find that our instrument will give us the same measure within the second , every time the experiment is repeated , we may pronounce it capable of measuring seconds ; if otherwise , it will remain to be examined , whether the fault lies in the mechanical or optical part .
Let us now suppose that the parallax of the fixed stars does not amount to a single second , yet still the case is by no means desperate ; and though the difficulty of measuring seconds will soon suggest to us what extraordinary powers and distinctness of the telescope , and accuracy of the micrometer , are required to measure thirds ; this ought by no means to discourage us in the attempt .
Could we measure angles , much smaller than seconds , might we not hope to find the parallax of some of the fixed stars at least to amount to several thirds ?
On the other hand , if it should appear , indeed , that even with such improved methods of measurement we could not reach the remote situation of such almost infinitely distant suns , we might still derive a valuable approximation towards truth from such repeated observations , even though they should not be attended with all the success we expected from them .
On this assurance , I endeavoured to take such a method for attempting the investigation of the parallax of the stars as to avail myself of the improvements I had already made , and was still in hopes of making , in my telescopes .
The next thing that was necessary to consider in this undertaking was , the manner of putting it into execution .
The method pointed out by GALILEO , and first attempted by HOOK , FLAMSTEAD , MOLINEUX , and BRADLEY , of taking distances of stars from the zenith that pass very near it , though it failed with regard to parallax , has been productive of the most noble discoveries of another nature .
At the same time it has given us a much juster idea of the immense distance of the stars , and furnished us with an approximation to the knowledge of their parallax that is much nearer the truth than we ever had before .
Dr. BRADLEY , in a letter to Dr. HALLEY on the subject of a new discovered motion of the fixed stars , says , ` ` I believe I may venture to say , that in either of the two stars last mentioned ( ~ Draconis and ~ Ursae majoris ) it ( the annual parallax ) does not amount to 2~ .
I am of opinion , that if it were 1~ I should have perceived it in the great number of observations that I made , especially upon ~ Draconis ; which agreeing with the hypothesis ( without allowing any thing for parallax ) nearly as well when the sun was in conjunction with , as in opposition to , this star , it seems very probable , that the parallax of it is not so great as one single second .
' ' Phil. Trans. n. 406 .
p. 637 .
Dec. 1728 .
As I do not know that any thing more decisive has been done upon the subject , it will not be amiss to see how far this method of finding the parallax has really been successful .
The instrument that was used upon this occasion was the same as the present zenith sectors , which can hardly be allowed sufficient to show an angle of one or even two seconds with accuracy ; yet , on account of the great number of observations , and above all the great sagacity of the observer , we will admit that if the parallax had amounted to two seconds he would have perceived it .
The star on which these observations were made is marked of the third magnitude in the catalogue of PTOLEMY ; in TYCHO BRAHE'S of the third ; in the Prince of HESSE'S of the third ; in HEVELIUS'S between the third and second ; in FLAMSTEAD'S of the second ; and now appears as a very bright star of the third , or small star of the second magnitude ; therefore its parallax is probably considerably less than that of a star of the first magnitude .
Several authors who have touched upon this subject seem to have overlooked this distinction ; and from Dr. BRADLEY'S account of the parallax of ~ Draconis , have concluded the parallax of the stars in general not to exceed 1~ ; but this appears to me by no means to follow from the doctor 's observations .
It is rather evident that , for aught we know to the contrary , the stars of the first magnitude may still have a parallax of several seconds ; and I believe this to be as accurate a result as that method is capable of giving , at least in latitudes where there is not a star of the first magnitude that passes directly through the zenith * .
In * DE LA LAND , in his excellent book of Astronomy , says , that the parallax of the fixed stars has been proved to be absolutely insensible ( Ast .
liv .
XVI .
~ 2782 .
) .
He reports the observations of TYCHO BRAHE , PICARD , HOOK , and FLAMSTEAD , and concludes ( ~ 2778 .
) from the discovery of the aberration by Dr. BRADLEY ( which it seems he also allows to be the most decisive upon the subject ) that now the question about parallax is resolved .
In giving us the opinion which In general , the method of zenith distances labours under the following considerable difficulties .
In the first place , all these distances , though they should not exceed a few degrees , are liable to refractions ; and I hope to be pardoned when I say that the real quantities of these refractions , and their differences , the doctor had of the result of his own observations with regard to the annual parallax , DE LA LAND only mentions ` ` M. BRADLEY pens que si elle ( la parallaxe ) eut ete seulement de 1~ il l'auroit appercue dans le grand nombre d'observations qu'il avoit faites , surtout de ~ du Dragon .
' ' But if we also take in those lines upon which Dr. BRADLEY seems to lay the greatest stress , viz. ` ` I believe I may venture to say , that in either of the two stars last mentioned it does not amount to two seconds ; ' ' and if we allow for the magnitude of the stars upon which the observations were made , I think I have fairly stated the full amount of all the actual proofs we have of the smallness of the annual parallax .
Now , since it has escaped the finest observations of BRADLEY , it is not likely that it should come up to the full quantity to which it might amount without being perceived ; and therefore the doctor might think it highly probable , ` ` that it is not so great as one single second ; ' ' and his opinion , as well as DE LA LANDE'S , who believes it to be absolutely insensible , are perfectly consistent with all the observations that have hitherto been made ; though the actual proofs , which are the subject of our present inquiry , do not extend so far .
Against the parallax of Sirius DE LA LAND ( ~ 2781 .
) mentions ` ` fortyfive meridian altitudes taken by Dr. BEVIS [ a ] , with the eight-feet mural quadrant of the Royal Observatory at Greenwich , none of which differed 3 or 4~ from the mean altitude .
' ' Now , if they differed 3 or 4~ from the mean , we may suppose they differed 6 or 8~ from each other ; and that observations , subject to so many causes of error as I shall presently enumerate , and which differed so much from each other , cannot give the least evidence either for or against a parallax , will need no proof .
Refraction alone , which is liable to such changes at the meridian altitude of Sirius , notwithstanding the most careful observations of the barometer and thermometer should be made to ascertain its quantity , would , with me , remain an unanswerable argument against the validity of such observations in a subject of this critical nicety .
[ a ] These observations were not made by Dr. BEVIS , but extracted from the registers of the Royal Observatory at my desire , and calculated by myself , and sent in a letter by Dr. BEVIS to Paris .
NEVIL MASKELYNE .
are very far from being perfectly known .
Secondly , the change of position of the earth 's axis arising from nutation , precession of the equinoxes , and other causes , is so far from being completely settled , that it would not be very easy to say what it exactly is at any given time .
In the third place , the aberration of light , though best known of all , may also be liable to some small errors , since the observations from which it was deduced laboured under all the foregoing difficulties .
I do not mean to say , that our theories of all these causes of error are defective ; on the contrary , I grant that we are for most astronomical purposes sufficiently furnished with excellent tables to correct our observations from the above mentioned errors .
But when we are upon so delicate a point as the parallax of the stars ; when we are investigating angles that may , perhaps , not amount to a single second , we must endeavour to keep clear of every possibility of being involved in uncertainties ; even the hundredth part of a second becomes a quantity to be taken into consideration .
I shall now deliver the method I have taken , and show that it is free from every error to which the former is liable , and is still capable of every improvement the telescope and mechanism of micrometers can furnish .
Let O ( fig. 1 .
) be two opposite points of the annual orbit , taken in the same plane with two stars a , b , of unequal magnitudes .
Let the angle aOb be observed when the earth is at O : and let the angle aEb be also observed when the earth is at E. From the difference of these angles , if any should be found , we may calculate the parallax of the stars , according to a theory that will be delivered hereafter .
These two stars , for reasons that will soon appear , ought to be as near each other as

