~ .
XXVIII .
Account of the Airs extracted from different Kinds of Waters ; with Thoughts on the Salubrity of Air at different Places .
In a Letter from the Abbe Fontana , Director of the Cabinet of Natural History belonging to his Royal Highness the Grand Duke of Tuscany , to Joseph Priestley , LL. D. F. R. S. Read April 16 , 1779 .
ITAKE the liberty of sending you an account of some experiments which I made at Paris in the years 1777 and 1778 on the air extracted from various kinds of waters : some of the principal of which I thought proper to transcribe , that you might make use of them if you think that they are at all useful , and likewise lay them before the Royal Society .
I have extracted the air from the water of a well by means of common fire .
The water was then made to boil in a large mattress of tin , which had a long tube of the same metal , which being bent into two different directions was with its extremity immerged in a tub of cold water .
The mattress and its tube were entirely filled with water : the air which came out of it was received into three different vessels .
The air of the first vessel , by being shaken in water , was diminished a little ; the air of the second was diminished of half its bulk , or rather more ; and the air of the third vessel was diminished exceedingly .
The residuums of air that remained unabsorbed were more or less phlogisticated .
Another time I obtained almost entirely fixed air , excepting a little which remained unabsorbed by water , and was partly phlogisticated .
A third time the air of the water of a well , obtained as above , was made to pass through mercury into a tube anointed with oil of tartar , and it occasioned a crystallization just like that which the purest fixed air is used to do .
A fourth time I impregnated with this air a quantity of common water , which absorbed its own bulk of it , and became by these means acidulous , exactly like water with the purest fixed air .
This water turned the tincture of turnsole red , and precipitated the lime in lime water .
Another time a light was successively extinguished , and a bird died instantly in this air .
The water of the river Seine , filtrated through sand , as it is drunk at Paris , was treated in the same manner as the water of the well .
The air extracted from that water was half absorbed by water , when shaken in it ; the remainder , when treated with the taste of nitrous air , gave II 4 , II +1 ( a ) ; when the common atmospheric air treated with the same nitrous air gave II 4 , II + 8 .
It was therefore sensibly better than the atmospheric air , which , during three years of experiments made at Paris , I have constantly found to be inferior to the air of the Seine water , extracted as above .
Having repeated the experiment , I received the air into two different receivers .
The first of which , by being shaken in water , was diminished in the proportion of ten to seven ; and by the test of nitrous air gave II 14 , II + 1 , III + 1 , when the common air gave II 12 , II + 6 , III + 6 .
The second quantity of air was diminished in the proportion of three to one ; and when examined by the test of nitrous air gave II ~ 0 , III ~ 0 .
From whence it may be concluded , that the first air was better than the atmospheric air ; whereas the second was worse , and mixed with much fixed air .
Being in doubt whether the tin vessel employed in the experiment above mentioned might not alter the nature of the air , &amp;c. I made use of glass vessels .
Having therefore filled one of these vessels , having a long neck bent in two directions , with the Seine water , I ( a ) See p. 343 .
for an explanation of this measure .
obtained some air which seemed not sensibly diminished when shaken in water .
Having introduced one measure and 37 parts of this air into the tube used to try the diminutions , it gave with the nitrous air I+ 19 , I+ 48 , when the same quantity of nitrous and atmospheric air gave II + 26 , II + 6 : it is therefore certain , that the air extracted from Seine water is purer than common air .
Another time I extracted , in the same manner , and from the same water , the air ; one measure and 24 parts of which being introduced into the tube , &amp;c. and shaken , was reduced to one measure 31 parts , that is , one fifth of it was obsorbed .
Treated with the nitrous air it gave I 4 , when equal measures of common and nitrous air gave I~ 0 : it was therefore better than common air .
A third time I extracted the air , in the manner above mentioned , from the water of the river Seine , contained in three mattrasses : this air was about one twenty-eighth of the bulk of the water , and it gave with the test of nitrous air II 14 , II 9 , III 9 ; when the common air mixed with nitrous air , as usual , gave II 14 , II + 8 , III + 8 .
It is therefore clear , that the air extracted from the Seine water , by the action of fire in glass vessels , is much better than common air , or than the air which is extracted from the same water when boiled in tin vessels .
Another time I filled a glass retort , which had a long and doubly bent neck , with Seine water .
The water weighed about three pounds .
The air that came out of it lost a quarter of its bulk by being shaken in water ; and afterwards being tried with nitrous air it gave II 16 , II 16 , III 16 , when common and nitrous air gave II 12 , II + 12 .
This experiment being repeated , the air was diminished of one quarter by being shaken in water .
One measure 16 parts of this air introduced into the measuring tube gave II 32 , II 2 , when common air and the nitrous gave II 28 , II + 4 .
The water d'Arqeuil at Paris is considered as very pure .
I filled the tin vessel above mentioned with it , and received the air that came out of it into three vessels .
Being shaken in water , the first of them was diminished one fifth ; the second , three fourths ; and the third 15/ 16 by the operation in water .
A light burned with a flame , more luminous than in common air , in the first air after it had been shaken in water .
This air being tried with the nitrous air gave II 10 , II 10 , III 10 .
The second gave II 10 , II 17 , III 30 , when common and nitrous air gave II 2 , II + 14 , III + 14 .
The third air , before it was shaken in water , crystallized with the oil of tartar like fixed air .
An equal bulk of it was absorbed by water , which by this mixture became acidulous ; it precipitated the lime in lime water , extinguished a light several times , and killed an animal instantly .
It is therefore partly fixed air , and partly air which is not only better than common air , but likewise than that extracted from Seine water , even when this last has been boiled in glass vessels .
The experiments being repeated with the same water of Arqueil , but in glass vessels , the air obtained , after being shaken in water , was much better than that obtained from the same matter , when boiled in vessels of tin .
I have also extracted the air from distilled water in glass vessels , and having shaken one measure 32 parts of it in water , it was reduced to one measure 35 parts .
With the test of nitrous air it gave 1 6 , when equal parts of common and nitrous air gave 1 2 , which showed that it was better than common air .
I extracted the air again in the manner above described ; but it was not sensibly diminished when shaken in water .
Two measures 49 parts of it , with the test of nitrous air , gave I 2 , I+ 8 , when common air , &amp;c. gave I+ 1 , I+ 18 : It is therefore better than common air .
I extracted the air from a great quantity of distilled water in the usual manner , and found that it did not senV O L. LXIX .
Mmm sibly sibly diminish in water .
With nitrous air it gave II 14 , II 25 , II + 25 , when common and the same nitrous air gave II 14 , II + 10 , III + 10 ; consequently it was dephlogisticated air , viz. purer than the air of the Seine and Arqueil , which are much better than common air .
I had the curiosity to try , whether any difference would arise from boiling distilled water in a mattress of tin instead of glass vessels ; and found , that the first air was diminished one tenth by being shaken in water , and afterwards with the nitrous air gave II 13 , II 16 , III 18 , when common air gave II 12 , II + 8 ; which shows that it was dephlogisticated air , but not so good as that extracted from the same water when boiled in glass vessels .
The second quantity of air was not sensibly diminished in water , and with nitrous air gave II 13 , II 20 , III 30 ; that is , it was more dephlogisticated than the first .
The air extracted from distilled water is to that extracted from the water of the river Seine as 13 to 32 nearly ; whence distilled water does not give more air than one sixtieth of its bulk : but as the air extracted from the water of the Seine is half fixed air , it may be concluded , that the quantity of respirable air produced by both kinds of waters is nearly the same , and that they only differ a little in purity .
It is however true , that other ex1 periments periments have shown me that water in general absorbs about twice as much of dephlogisticated as of common air ; for which reason , I think , that the respirable air of Seine water is rather less than that of distilled water .
Accordingly I have found , that Seine water , after it has been boiled for a long time , absorbs in forty days about one fourteenth of its own bulk of dephlogisticated air , when in the same length of time it does not absorb more than one twenty-eighth of common air .
This seems to be an experiment of very great consequence , and is much worth notice ; especially as it discovers a new characteristic by which dephlogisticated air may be distinguished from common air ; and shows , that water absorbs a greater quantity of those kinds of air , which contain a less quantity of phlogiston .
It must however be observed , that it is impossible to determine exactly the quantity of air that is extracted from vessels filled with water , by means of fire ; because a portion of the air is absorbed by the water of the tub in the act of its coming forth .
It will certainly be more exact to receive the air in vessels immersed in quicksilver ; but then there are many other inconveniences to encounter .
It may be almost superfluous to mention , that the above related experiments are very useful in explaining the reason why some kinds of water have a peculiar sharp taste more than others ; and especially why some of them precipitate the lime in lime water , rendering it a calcareous earth , and change the tincture of turnsole into a red colour , as I have generally experienced with the well waters at Paris .
We may also explain from hence , why some kind of waters can dissolve iron , and keep it in dissolution without deposition ; whereas other kinds of water are incapable of doing it , at least do it much less than the purest distilled water .
This is soon discovered by boiling the water , which will then deposit the iron which before was dissolved .
It will be sufficient , for the present , to mention , that I have not only extracted from waters the different kinds of air they contained naturally , but have likewise made various experiments upon waters deprived of air , which , being exposed , have again imbibed the atmospherical air , as I hinted above .
I have determined the quantity and quality of those airs .
In general , I may say , that distilled water , deprived of air , imbibes again an equal quantity of air of the same kind as that it had lost , and that in less than sifty days .
Other kinds of water do the same , but with this difference , viz. that the air they absorb , after being boiled , is better than that they have lost ; and in this particular they come very near to the nature of distilled water itself .
If the waters deprived of air are exposed to common air held in receivers in contact with quicksilver , the air which remains unabsorbed is so much more phlogisticated as a less quantity of it remains in the receiver .
This experiment deserves consideration .
By means of pure water , especially distilled water , common air may be changed into dephlogisticated air , that is , into air much more salubrious than the best common air which we breathe ; and this , for what I know , is the only means of meliorating common air : for all the artificial methods ( great numbers of which I have tried ) have proved either useless or noxious , but never such as promised to be of any great utility to human kind .
Though I have long thought of applying those experiments to some use for the purposes of life , the want of time and a proper apparatus has hitherto hindered my doing any thing ; I now begin to be in hopes I shall be able to do something .
In the mean time I think it of some importance to have it known , that water not only possesses the property of diminishing the noxious part of tainted air , but has also the power , and that in a very high degree , of dephlogisticating common air ; which must certainly be one of the methods by which nature keeps the atmosphere in a state constantly fit to support animal life , it being certain , that the water in various circumstances must lose either a part or the whole of that air which it hath absorbed from the atmosphere .
It may with some reason be suspected , that in my experiments of extracting the air from water by the action of fire , the air might be considerably altered by the vapour of the water itself .
As this difficulty was of some force , I endeavoured to remove it in the following manner .
I introduced into a tube , through water , a quantity of common air of known goodness , and I caused the steam of water boiling in a mattress , from which the air had been previously extracted , to pass through it .
The heat of the steam sometimes made the water occupy above five times the space it did when cold ; yet the air so treated was not at all altered by it , as appeared by the test of nitrous air .
The event of the experiment , although repeated various times , was constantly the same .
I must observe , lastly , that having once caused the air of boiling water to pass into receivers filled with , and standing in , quicksilver , I found that the air was better than usual .
I have observed the same thing when I have caused the air to go through distilled water into receivers filled with it : which observation , if the event of the experiment is constantly the same , induces me to believe , that the air loses some of its good properties by going through water not very pure ; or , which seems to be rather more probable , that a quantity of air less good is , by the action of the vapours and the heat , extricated from that impure water , and is mixed with the air that comes out of the mattress ; from whence this air is debased .
I must not omit to mention a new character of equal importance with that which distinguishes the dephlogisticated from the common air .
This new character has been equally unknown , and deserves the attention of philosophers , because at the same time it discovers a new property of the atmospherical air , which I should never have suspected if experience had not offered it to me .
I have found , that common air shaken in water , instead of being diminished is sensibly increased in its bulk .
The increased space is in proportion to the time the air is shaken in water , and it begins to be sensible even from the beginning , that is , after a few seconds .
This augmentation I have sometimes brought to be one twelfth of the bulk of the air , and even more : it must , however , be confessed , that I met with great variety in the experiments of this kind made at different times .
After that the bulk of the air shaken in water is increased to a certain degree , it then begins to decrease continually ; and , in proportion to this decrease , the air becomes gradually less good .
When the experiment is tried in close vessels , the diminution nution cannot be observed ; but I shall reserve , for another opportunity , to speak of the laws and causes of those diminutions and augmentations , and the differences observed between common and other kinds of air , and when the experiments are tried in water , &amp;c. For the present I shall only mention , that if the dephlogisticated air be shaken in the tube , in the manner above mentioned , not only it does not increase its bulk , but it begins to diminish from the very beginning of the operation , and it continually loses more and more of its bulk , and with its bulk of its purity .
This last mentioned property of the dephlogisticated air seems to show , that this is a fluid much different from common air , because it has its peculiar properties by which it differs from common air not from more to less only , but entirely ; as is shown by the property this fluid has of being absorbed by water ; whereas common air receives an increase of bulk and elasticity by being shaken in water .
All that I have been saying above , in order to give an idea of my method , and the words I use to express the diminutions made by the mixture of nitrous air and other kinds of respirable air , is not sufficient to obtain results constant and certain , so as to deduce any consequences from them .
Even after that all the elements are corrected , and all the causes of error hitherto unknown or neglected by the most diligent observers , are avoided ( which causes sensibly alter this kind of experiments ) it is absolutely necessary to follow always a constant and equal method , not only in the act of introducing the various kinds of air into the tube , but also after the mixing of the two kinds of air .
The least variation of circumstances causes very great variations in the results of the experiments , and these variations of circumstances are so minute that I never saw any of the persons that observed my experiments who could discover them , although apprised of my design .
The neglect alone of this uniformity of operation may occasion an error of from 20 to 50 parts and upwards in the experiment with common air ; but with dephlogisticated air the error is incomparably greater , so much that the same quality of air a moment after may decompose even a double quantity of nitrous air ; so that the purest common air would appear to be noxious , and phlogisticated air ; and the dephlogisticated air would appear less good , and even noxious : for , by the test of nitrous air , it might appear little different from a mixture of dephlogisticated and phlogisticated air .
I shall take another opportunity to speak of all the particulars relative to my method ; but for the present I must mention , that , after using all the cautions I am master of ; the greatest error in the diminutions is not greater than one sixtieth of the common air introduced in the tube : so that , after having made five or six experiments successively , the probable error is so small that it may be safely neglected .
But , if one chose to operate upon a quantity of air nine or ten times greater than that I commonly use , the error could not be 1000th part of the quantity of the air , which quantity would not be more than a few cubic inches .
In the description of my method I shall also mention the means by which I obtain nitrous air of a nearly equal and constant goodness , and in what manner I can refer my experiments to some constant standard .
For want of this method it is that we are not certain of the observations made about the salubrity of common air in different places , and that no tables of its changes have been made .
I have not the least hesitation in asserting , that the experiments made to ascertain the salubrity of the atmospherical air in various places , in different countries and situations , mentioned by several authors , are not to be depended upon ; because the method they used was far from being exact , the elements or ingredients for the experiment were unknown and uncertain , and the results very different from one another .
When all the errors are corrected it will be found , that the difference between the air of one country and that of another , at different times , is much less than what is commonly believed , and that the great differences found by various observers are owing to the fallacious effects of uncertain methods .
This I advance from experience : for when I was in the same error , I found very great differences between the results of the experiments of this nature which ought to have been similar ; which diversities I attributed to myself rather than to the method I then used .
At Paris I examined the air of different places at the same time , and especially of those situations where it was most probable to meet with infected air , because those places abounded with putrid substances and impure exhalations ; but the differences I observed were very small , and much less than what could have been suspected , for they hardly arrived to one fiftieth of the air in the tube .
Having taken the air of the hill called Mont Valerien at the height of about 500 feet above the level of Paris , and compared it with the air of Paris taken at the same time and treated alike ; I found the former to be hardly one thirtieth better than the latter .
In London I have observed almost the same .
The air of Islington and that of London suffered an equal diminution by the mixture of nitrous air ; yet the air of Islington is esteemed to be much better .
I have examined the air of London , taken at different heights ; ( for instance , in the street , at the second floor , and at the top of the adjoining houses ) and have found it to be of the same quality .
Having taken the air at the iron gallery of St. Paul 's cupola at the height of 313 feet above the ground , and likewise the air of the stone gallery which is 202 feet below the other ; and having compared these two quantities of air with that of the street adjoining ; I found , that there was scarce any sensible difference between them , although taken at such different heights .
In this experiment a circumstance is to be considered , which must have contributed to render the above mentioned differences more sensible ; this is , the agitation of the air of the cupola , for there was felt a pretty brisk wind upon it , which I observed to be stronger and stronger the higher I ascended ; whereas in the street , and indeed in all the streets I passed through , there was no sensible wind to be felt .
This experiment was made at four in the afternoon , the weather being clear .
The quicksilver in the barometer at that time was 28,6 inches high , and FAHRENHEIT 's thermometer stood at 54~ .
After having related all these circumstances , it will be necessary to give the mean result of all the various experiments periments made upon each of those quantities of air treated after my method with the nitrous air .
The air of the street gave II 13 , II + 6 ; the air of the stone gallery , which was 202 feet high , gave II 14 , II + 5 ; and the air of the iron gallery , which was 313 feet high , gave II 14 , II + 5 .
The results of the two last experiments are exactly the same ; and that of the first is hardly at all different from them .
Mr. CAVALL O , who has shown the literary world his ability in examining nature , assisted me in those experiments , so that a mistake can hardly be suspected .
From this we clearly see , how little the experiments hitherto published , about the differences of common air , are to be depended upon .
In general I find , that the air changes from one time to another ; so that the differences between them are far greater than those of the airs of different countries , or different heights ; for instance , I have found that the air of London , in the months of September , October , and November , 1778 , when treated with the nitrous air , gave II 6 , II + 15 , which is a mean result of many experiments which differed very little from each other .
The 26th day of November last , I found the air for the first time much better , for it gave II 12 , II + 12 ; but the 14th of February last , the air gave II 18 , II + 7 ; from whence it appears , that the air of this 14th of February was better than it had been for six months before .
There can be no doubt of the accuracy of the experiments , because I compared the air taken at different times with that which I had first used in the month of September , and which I had preserved in dry glass bottles accurately stopped .
Now if the formulae expressed above are compared together , it will be found , that the difference between the first terms is of twelve parts , and that between the latter of seven ; that is , of one tenth and one twenty-fourth of the whole quantity of air : which are much greater differences than those mentioned above .
Notwithstanding this , I could not perceive any particular change of health , or facility of breathing , arising from those changes of the salubrity of the atmospherical air ; and I am informed , that no particular diseases appeared which could indicate any remarkable change of air .
Nature is not so partial as we commonly believe .
She has not only given us an air almost equally good every where and at every time , but has allowed us a certain latitude or a power of living and being in health in qualities of air which differ to a certain degree .
By this I do not mean to deny the existence of certain kinds of noxious air in some particular places ; but only say , that in general the air is good every where , and that the small differences are not to be feared so much as some people would make us believe .
Nor do I mean to speak here of those vapours and other bodies which are accidentally joined to the common air in particular places , but do not change its nature and intrinsical property .
This state of the air cannot be known by the test of nitrous air , and those vapours are to be considered in the same manner as we should consider so many particles of arsenic swimming in the atmosphere .
In this case it is the arsenic , and not the degenerated air , that would kill the animals who ventured to breathe it .
In this place , therefore , I do not mean to speak of those changes which do not immediately alter the nature of the air itself .
The other states of that fluid are of another kind , and they are not to be examined by means of nitrous or inflammable air ( the uses of which last , I shall show on another occasion ) .
The same thing may be said of those vapours or particles which may be good for respiration , and do not change the nature of the air .
Some vegetables , for instance , can diffuse through the air such exhalations as may be of real use to the animal oeconomy when they are breathed for a long time , or imbibed by the pores of the skin .
I remember to have often put various flowers , as roses , pinks , &amp;c. in vessels full of common air confined by quicksilver , where I left them for several hours ; after which time I found , that the air was not at all altered , but that various animals seemed to breathe it very well , notwitstanding that the flowers filled the greatest part of the vessels .
On the contrary , I have found , that the vapours arising from lime slacked in water , either do not alter the air at all , or very little ; though when breathed with the air they occasion the death of animals .
I would not have any body suppose , that I think it of little importance to know the goodness of the atmospherical air , and the changes it undergoes .
On the contrary , I believe it to be a very useful inquiry for mankind , because we do not yet know how far one kind of air more than another may contribute to a perfect state of health ; nor at what time small differences may become very considerable , when one continues to breathe the same kind of air for whole years , especially in some kind of diseases .
An exact method of examining the goodness of common air may even be useful to posterity , in order to ascertain whether our atmosphere degenerates in a length of time .
This curious inquiry , together with the method , &amp;c. are the production of this eighteenth century : and our descendants must have some gratitude for the philosophers who found out , as well as for those who improved it .
If our ancestors had known and transmitted it to us , we should , perhaps , at present be able to judge of one of the greatest changes of our globe , of a change which very nearly interests human life .

