XXV .
On the Variation of the Temperature of boiling Water .
By Sir George Shuckburgh , Baronet , F. R. and A. S. and Member of the Academy of Sciences and Belles Lettres at Lyon .
Read March 11 , 1779 .
THE heat of boiling water having for some years been used as one of the terms for graduating the scale of thermometers ; together with the particular attention the Society has lately given ( vide the Report of the Committee , Phil. Trans. vol. LXVII .
) to this branch of inquiry , and I may add the singular success with which this age and nation has introduced a mathematical precision , hitherto unheard of , into the construction of philosophical instruments , will render it unnecessary for me to say more in respect of the following experiments , than simply to lay them before the Royal Society .
That the heat of boiling water was variable , according to the pressure of the atmosphere , seems to have been known to FAHRENHEIT as early as the year 1724 ( a ) .
( a ) Vide Phil. Trans. No 385 .
wherein is proposed a curious project of determining the weight of the atmosphere by means of a thermometer alone , under the title of ` ` Barometri novi descriptio .
' ' A few years after this , Messieurs LE MONNIER and CASSINI ( Mem. de l'Acad .
des Sc. pour 1740 ) made some decisive observations , to show that this quantity was very considerable .
It was left , however , for Mr. DE LUC to make a much more complete series of experiments , which he has described and reduced into system in his Recherches sir la Variation de la Chaleur de l'Eau bouillante .
It remained only that these should be verified .
Towards the latter end of the year 1775 I had an opportunity of repeating these observations with a small pocket thermometer of about six inches long , made by Mr. NAIRNE ; an instrument , it must be confessed , not very accurate for such an examination , but with which I thought , however , I could observe to within a quarter of a degree ; my object at that time , amidst a variety of other philosophical pursuits , being to assure myself that the variation took place , rather than critically to examine the quantity of it .
I shall relate these observations , as the result of them upon my return to England led me to some more accurate .
Table of observations of the boiling-point , made in a journey over the Alps .
Heat of Heat of boilHeight of Place of obboiling ing water by Difference in the baroDiff .
servation .
water by Mr. DELUC'S 1/ 100 of total .
meter .
observat .
thermometer Inches .
ooo Bologna , 30.21 213.5 213.5 -0,0 0 Geneva , 28.60 210.4 210.9 -0,5 -16 Modane , 26.61 207.3 207.4 -0,1 2 Lannebourg , 25.75 205.1 205.9 -0,8 9 Mount Cenis , 24.03 201.2 202.6 -1,4 -11 Ditto , 23.91 201.1 202.4 -1,3 -10 Mean 9/ 100 = 1/ 11 The second column gives the height of the barometer at the time of observation ; the fourth , the heat of boiling water deduced from Mr. DE LUC'S rules , compared with the lowermost observation , or that under the greatest pressure ; the sixth gives the difference between the theory and the experiment in the motion of the boiling point in hundredth parts of the whole space described : from whence it might be concluded , that the motion or variation of the boiling point with a given variation in the pressure of the atmosphere was 9/ 100 or 1/ 11 greater than by the theory alluded to ( b ) .
But these were but gross experiments , and perhaps unworthy of such a competition .
They induced me , however , to make the following .
In the beginning of last year ( 1778 ) with the assistance of Mr. RAMSDEN , I procured a most excellent thermometer , every way adapted for this purpose .
It was about fourteen inches long , but the interval between freezing and boiling only 8 1/ 4 inches ( c ) , and though every degree was something less than the 1/ 10th of an inch , yet , by means of a semi-transparent piece of ivory , which applied itself close behind the glass tube , sliding up and down in a groove cut in the brass scale for that purpose , carrying a hair-line division , at the extremity of which was a vernier dividing each de(b ) The same instrument immersed in snow just melting at the top of Mount Cenis fell to 32~ , the point of freezing observed at the level of the sea .
( c ) It may possibly be suggested , that if this interval had been greater , viz. 20 , 30 , or 40 inches , I should have had a much larger scale and more convenient instrument ; but in this , as in most other mechanical contrivances , our progress beyond certain limits is prevented ; for if the perpendicular height of the column of quicksilver be much increased , the weight of it will be such as to distend the ball , and the instrument may differ from itself in a vertical and horizontal position by half a degree , as I have seen in a tube only fifteen inches long ; and if this circumstance be endeavoured to be corrected by making the bulb of the thermometer thicker , its sensibility will be proportionably diminished .
If my experience were to lead me to conclude any thing , I should consider a tube of a foot long as a maximum , and the bore of such a diameter as to admit a ball of a quarter or one fifth of an inch .
gree into ten ; with , moreover , a lens of an inch focus ; this apparatus being made moveable first by the hand , and more delicately by means of a micrometer screw , whose head was divided into twenty-five divisions , each equal to the fortieth of a degree ( for so truly cylindrical was the tube , which had been with care expressly selected from a great quantity of glass , that the divisions in the neighbourhood of the freezing point did not differ from those near the boiling point by so much as 1/ 40th of a degree , and this variation appeared in other parts of the tube strictly uniform , as was found by breaking the column of mercury ) ; by means I say of this apparatus I was enabled to read off any height of the thermometer to within 1/ 50th of a degree .
The vessel , in which the water was boiled , which was always spring water , was a cylindrical tin pot , 13 inches high and 4 1/ 4 inches wide , with a top something resembling that described in Mr. DE LUC'S work , contrived to carry off the steam without incommoding the observer , with a waste pipe for the superfluous water in boiling , which might otherwise fall upon the fire and extinguish it .
The ball of the thermometer was immersed to within 2 1/ 2 inches of the bottom of the vessel , and 10 1/ 2 inches below the surface of the water , so that as near as might be the whole column of mercury was exposed to the heat of boiling water , there being only 15~ or 20~ of the scale , equal about 1/ 50.0 part rising out of the water exposed to the temperature of the steam , which in one or two experiments was found to be 180~ or 190~ , so that the correction for this defect of heat would only amount to a very few hundredths of a degree , perhaps about , 04 or 05 , which , as the instrument was exposed to the same circumstances as near as might be in all the observations , I have taken no notice of .
I thought it necessary to say thus much respecting the precision of the instrument and the apparatus , and shall now relate the observations at length .
Table of the observations .
Barometer reducHeight of Boiling Mean Place of observation .
ed to the No the baroheat of point .
boiling meter .
Therm. at .
50~ .
point .
Inch .
Inch .
40ths .
100ths ooo 1 Summit of Snowdon in Car26,487 46 26,498 207 , 8 207,07 narvonshire , Aug. 15,1778 , 206,38 2 Top of Carn Cwm Gafr , 27,274 62 27,241 208,27 Aug. 16 , 1778 , 208,24 208,28 208,64 208,19 208,29 3 In the descent from ditto , 27,957 51 27,954 209,28 1/ 2 209,37 209,39 209,87 209,32 209,32 209,40 Table of observations continued Barometer reducHeight of Boiling Mean ed to the Place of Observations .
the baroheat of point .
boiling Number .
meter .
Therm. at .
50~ .
point .
Inch .
o Inch .
o 40ths .
o 100ths 4 Shuckburgh , Dec. 3 , 1778 , 28,360 44 28,377 210,17 1/ 2 210,20 1/ 2 210,50 210,20 1/ 2 210,21 1/ 2 5 Ditto , Oct. 23 , 1778 , 28,690 47 28,699 211 , 8 211,10 211,11 211,27 211,13 211,12 211,10 6 Ditto , Sept. 27 , 1778 , 28,910 54 28,898 211,19 1/ 2 211,20 1/ 2 211,24 1/ 2 211,50 211,17 1/ 2 211,14 1/ 2 7 Ditto , Nov. 7 , 1778 , 18,990 47 28,999 211,23 211,24 211,25 211,60 211,23 8 Llanberis , Carnarvonshire , 29,477 60 29,447 212,22 212,55 Aug. 13 , 1778 , 9 London , Jan. 27 , 1779 , 29,790 45 29,805 212,35 212,40 212,42 212,36 212,95 212,36 212,38 212,39 Table of Observations continued .
Barometer reducHeight of Boiling Mean ed to the Place of observation .
the baroheat of point .
boiling Number .
meter .
Therm. at .
50~ point .
Inch .
o Inch .
o 40ths .
o 100ths 10 London , Jan. 28 , 1779 , 29,990 44 30,008 213 , 5 213 , 8 213,10 213 , 9 213,18 213,10 213,22 213 , 6 213 , 6 213,11 213,12 213 , 8 11 Ditto , June 10 , 1778 , 30,250 64 30,207 213,20 213,23 213,24 213,58 213,26 213,23 1/ 2 12 Ditto , Dec. 27 , 1778 , 30,468 43 30,489 214 , 5 214 , 9 214 , 6 214 , 2 214 , 5 214,15 214 , 7 214 , 7 214 , 5 13 Ditto , Dec. 24 , 1778 , 30,750 46 30,763 214,18 214,12 214,37 214,15 Table of observations continued .
Barome~ reducHeight of ~ Mean ed to the Place of observation .
the baroheat of point .
boiling Number .
meter .
Therm. at .
50~ .
point .
Inch .
o Inch .
o 40ths .
o 100ths 14 London , Dec. 25 , 1778 , 30,838 47 30,847 214,35 214,32 214,33 214,34 214,83 214,35 214,31 214,33 15 Ditto , at the Adelphi 30,948(d ) 47 30,957 214,35 Wharf , 3 1/ 2 feet above high 214,39 water , Dec. 26 , 1778 , 214,40 214,38 1/ 2 214 41 214,15 214,37 214,41 214,40 214,40 214,34 The numbers in the fifth column are the corrected heights of the barometer reduced to one and the same temperature , viz. 50~ , which was necessary in order to have the true proportion of the pressure of the atmosphere , whose influence seems to have so considerable a ( d ) This is the greatest height of the barometer that I have ever known , and , as far as I have been able to collect the highest point , that it has ever been seen to stand at in any country where observations have been made and recorded , since the first invention of this ingenious instrument .
share in the heat of boiling water .
Column the sixth shows the height the thermometer stood at in water boiling very fast in degrees and 40ths of a degree ; where it will be seen , that the observation was repeated , as the heat is given of every separate trial , which is , perhaps , the best criterion of the confidence that is to be placed in the mean result , shown in column the seventh expressed in hundredths of a degree .
Having collected this series of experiments , I was anxious to see how far they corresponded with Mr. DE LUC'S , and upon comparison of No 1 .
and No 15 .
I found that the decrease of the boiling heat was ~,47/ 100 greater than the rules admitted of from an alteration of the pressure of the atmosphere of 41/ 2 inches .
This difference led me into an examination of all my observations , to see how far they were consistent with themselves ; how far they disagreed from Mr. DE LUC'S ; and , lastly , what general conclusion might be drawn from them .
To avoid in some measure , or at least correct , the errors of observation , the mean of No 1 .
and No 2 .
the mean of ~ 0 .
and No 7 .
and of No 14 .
and No 15 .
was taken instead of either observation separately ; the first and third of these means as two extreme terms , and the second as an intermediate one : with these it was very easy by interpolation or proportion to deduce any other intermediate term , and consequently from the mean of six to examine all the fifteen observations .
Thus , on a comparison of No 1 .
and 2 .
with No 14 .
and 15 .
the mean motion of the boiling point in that interval for one inch of the barometer ( viz. when the mercury stands at 28,886 inches ) is = 1~,743 ; according to Mr. DE LUC this is 1~,65 .
By a similar comparison of No 1 .
and 2 .
with No 6 .
and 7 .
the mean motion of the boiling point in that interval ( viz. at 27,908 inches ) for one inch is = 1~,779 ; by Mr. DE LUC = 1~,73 .
And , lastly , comparing the mean of No 6 .
and 7 .
with the mean of No 14 .
and 15 .
the mean motion of the boiling point in this interval ( viz. at 29,925 inches ) for one inch is = 1~,709 ; by Mr. DE LUC = 1~,59 .
It should follow then , that , within the limits of my experiments , the alteration or motion of the boiling point is greater ( e ) by 1/ 18 than from that gentleman 's observations , that the heat of boiling water is not directly in the simple ratio of the height of the barometer , nor yet is the progression so rapid as Mr. DE LUC observed it .
It may be somewhat satisfactory to see the observations collated and compared .
( e ) It is true , that my observations in Savoy give this difference + 1/ 11 those of Mr. LE MONNIER equal + 1/ 1~ ( Vide Recherches sir l'At .
~ 964 .
) ; and though , perhaps , neither the one nor the other are entirely unexceptionable , they tend , however , something to confirm , although alone they may be unable wholly to support , such a supposition .
Boiling Boiling pt .
Boiling point Height of point by by Mr. by interpolation from No No the baroobservaDE LUC'S Error .
1 , 2 , 6 , 7 , Error .
meter .
tion .
rules .
14 , and 15 .
Inch .
ooooo 1 26,498 207,07 208,54 + 0,47 207,18 + 0,11 2 27,241 208,64 208,84 + 0,20 208,52 0,12 3 27,954 209,87 210,03 + 0,16 209,80 0 , 7 4 28,377 210,50 210,81 + 0,31 210,56 + 0 , 6 5 28,699 211,27 211,34 + 0 , 7 211 , 11 0,16 6 28,898 211,50 211,67 + 0,17 211,47 0 , 3 7 28,999 211,60 211,85 + 0,25 211,64 + 0 , 4 8 29,447 212,55 212,74 + 0,19 212,42 0,13 9 29,805 212,95 213,15 + 0,20 213,03 + 0 , 8 10 30,008 213,22 213,47 + 0,25 213,49 + 0,27 11 30,207 213,58 213,79 + 0,21 213,71 + 0,13 12 30,489 214,15 214,23 + 0 , 8 214,19 + 0 , 4 13 30,763 214,37 214,66 + 0,29 214,65 + 0,28 14 30,847 214,83 214,79 0 , 4 214,79 0 , 4 15 30,957 214,96 214,96,0 214,96,0 I shall make no deductions from this comparison , but leave them to the leisure of the reader .
It will , however , probably be inquired , how the thermometer came to stand at 213~ in boiling water , when the barometer was about 30 inches , 212~ being the degree by which that heat is expressed on FAHRENHEIT'S scale ?
The answer is easy : it was an error in the making of the instrument , and , I believe , a pretty general one .
There was also a similar error of something more than one quarter of a degree in laying down the freezing point so that the fundamental interval between freezing and boiling , when the barometer stands at 29,8 inches ( the mean height at London ) was 180~,71 instead of 180~ ; by this means each division was in fact 1/ 260th part less than a degree : this small correction may therefore easily be applied , if thought necessary , but I have taken no notice of it .
I will now add a general table for the use of artists in making this instrument , both according to my own observations , and those of Mr. DE LUC , that the preference may be given as it shall be thought due ; not that it is a matter of any great consequence which is made use of under small variations of the atmosphere ; but even under these circumstances , I flatter myself , that the object of this paper will be sufficiently obvious to all who wish to verify a new theory , or aim at accuracy in these days of precision .
Height Correct .
Correct .
of the of the according barom .
boiling Diff. to Mr. DE Diff. point .
LUC .
oo 26,0 7,09 6,83 ,91,90 26,5 6,18 5,93 ,91,89 27,0 5,27 5,04 ,90,88 27,5 4,37 4,16 ,89,87 28,0 3,48 3,31 ,89,86 28,5 2,59 2,45 ,87,83 29,0 1,72 1,62 ,87,82 29,5 0,85 0,80 ,85,80 30,0 0,00 0,00 ,85,79 30,5 + 0,85 + 0,79 ,84,78 31,0 + 1,69 + 1,57

