XXIV .
Experiments and Observations on the inflammable Air breathed by various Animals .
By the Abbe Fontana , Director of the Cabinet of Natural History belonging to his Royal Highness the Grand Duke of Tuscany ; communicated by John Paradise , Esq. F. R. S. Read March 11 , 1779 .
PHILOSOPHERS believed , till lately , that inflammable air had the power of killing animals who breathed it .
Dr. PRIESTLEY , to whom we are much indebted for many discoveries and observations relative to inflammable air , made in consequence of Mr. CAVENDISH'S excellent paper on that subject , assures us , that inflammable air causes the death of animals as readily as fixed air , and that animals die convulsed in it .
The doctor adds , that water absorbed about one quarter of the inflammable air shaken in it , after which a mouse lived in it as long as it would have lived in an equal quantity of common air .
This air breathed by the mouse was still inflammable , though not so much as before .
Mr. SHEELE , who has made various important observations in chemistry , on the contrary asserts , that inflammable air not only does not kill the animals who breathe it , but that it is even good and innocent air .
He relates some experiments to which it seems that nothing can be opposed , and they appear to contradict Dr. PRIESTLEY'S observations .
Mr. SHEELE has breathed inflammable air contained in a bladder , without receiving any hurt .
Seeing then that the experiments of these celebrated persons contradicted each other , I began to suspect that they might possibly be all true ; and that their so contradictory effects might be owing to some circumstance not yet attended to .
In order to follow some method in my researches about a point so delicate , and which so nearly interests human life , I first of all thought of assuring myself , whether or no animals could breathe inflammable air with impunity , when the receivers that contained it were immersed in quicksilver .
To this end , I introduced inflammable air , extracted both from zinc and iron , by means of the vitriolic acid , into various tubes filled with quicksilver , in which the air entered pretty free from moisture .
I then introduced various birds into those tubes , and observed that they died in a few minutes time , but without any apparent sign of convulsions .
These experiments , having been often repeated , were constantly attended with the same event .
Being assured , beyond any doubt , that the inflammable air obtained from zinc or iron , and made to pass through quicksilver , was fatal to animals ; I next wished to observe , whether it retained the same properties when it had passed through water ; in which case the volatile sulphurous acid , or other vapour , is absorbed by the water ; but , on trying the experiments , I found that the birds died under these circumstances as under the others ( though not quite so soon ) showing likewise some signs of convulsion .
I introduced some of this same air that had passed through water into a glass tube full of quicksilver , by a method which makes the air lose all its moisture .
The birds died in it in the same manner as when the experiment was tried upon water .
In all these cases the air after the animals had died in it was still inflammable , nor did its exploding properties seem to have been at all diminished .
The inflammable air extracted from zinc , and that extracted from iron , is fatal to animals even after it has been shaken in water for a minute 's time , or something longer .
By shaking it a long time , it becomes in some measure respirable ; but then it is decomposed in a great measure , and becomes of another kind , although it still preserves the properties of being inflammable , but in a smaller degree , Not only birds but also quadrupeds die in inflammable air ( though not so soon ) and show some signs of being convulsed .
It seems very strange , that Mr. SHEELE could breathe inflammable air with impunity , when animals obliged to breathe it were killed in a very short time .
Admitting his experiments to be true , there remains nothing to be said , but that the inflammable air in which animals die does not occasion death because it is conveyed to the lungs , but because it affects some other organs of the animal body exposed to that air , and necessary to animal life .
It is not impossible to occasion death by affecting the very sensible nerves of the nose ; it being well known , that various liquors , as very concentrated volatile alkaly , &amp;c. if they are inspired through the nose , immediately affect the senses , and occasion death if they continue to act upon the pituitary membrane .
In order , therefore , to try whether inflammable air killed , only because it was inspired through the nose , I stopped very accurately the noses of various birds with soft wax , and in this manner I introduced them into receivers full of inflammable air extracted from zinc , and from iron , through water .
The birds died within a few seconds , that is , just as they did when their noses were unstopped .
Quadrupeds were tried after the same manner , and the event was the same .
Having in this manner exploded this new hypothesis , there remained one more , which seemed to suggest a probable reason ( since some reason there must be ) for Mr. SHEELE'S experiments being attended with results so different from those of other experimenters .
When an animal is introduced into a vessel of inflammable air , its whole body is exposed to that air ; and it is not yet known by philosophers what disorders that fluid may occasion to the animal frame .
It is true that none are observed to be produced by other noxious kind of air ; but if it be considered , that the vapours of sulphur make a great impression upon frogs , even when those animals do not breathe them , but have their aspera arteria tied up , it will not seem impossible for the inflammable air , in some manner or other , to act upon the body of animals .
It may , perhaps , hinder the perspiration ; it may insinuate itself through the pores of the skin ; in short , its action upon the body seems probable till experiments evince the contrary .
I therefore endeavoured to force various four-footed animals to breathe the inflammable air through the mouth only , without immerging their whole bodies into it .
I chiefly used bladders tied to their mouths , but sometimes I also made use of tubes which entered immediately into the wind-pipe .
In both cases the animals died in a very short time : hence it became evident , not only that the inflammable air is pernicious to animal life , but that it does not act on the body of an animal ; for I kept some of them immerged in inflammable air , with the mouth only out of it , and did not perceive any effect hurtful to them .
It being in this manner ascertained , that the inflammable air could not be breathed by animals with impunity , it still remained to find out the cause of Mr. SHEELE'S mistake .
I began therefore to breathe the inflammable air contained in bladders , after the manner of Mr. SHEELE .
The inflammable air used in my experiments was extracted from zinc and from iron by the action of the vitriolic acid , and it was received into bladders that were dry in the inside , but a little moist on the outside .
The quantity of air contained in each bladder was about eighty cubic inches .
The air coming out of the mattress passed through about one inch of water before it went into the bladders .
At first I breathed the inflammable air with a kind of fear ; but finding that it occasioned no painful impression , I continued breathing it with courage as long as I could .
I breathed in a bladder filled with it eleven times , beginning after a natural expiration .
This air when taken out of the bladder , was still inflammable , and being tried with the test of nitrous air it gave II 28 , III + 20 .
Before I go farther I must explain the formula which I use to express the diminution of respirable air , or air of other kind , when mixed with nitrous air .
My method is as follows : I have a glass tube of about eighteen inches in length , and half an inch in diameter , closed at one end , and of a constant diameter throughout its whole length : this tube has a mark at every three inches , which marks or divisions I call measures , and every inch is divided into twenty equal parts ; so that every measure is divided into sixty portions , which I call parts .
Into this tube , by means of an instrument which measures always one constant quantity of air equal to one measure of the tube , I introduce two measures of respirable air and one measure of nitrous air , after which I measure the diminution ; then I introduce a second measure of nitrous air , and again measure the diminution .
The whole measures I express in Roman characters , and the parts of a measure I express in common numbers ; for instance , when I say II 16 and II + 10 , the first expression means , that after having introduced into the tube two measures of common air , and one measure of nitrous air , the space occupied by the mixture of these two airs was two measures 16 parts , or 60ths of a measure : and the second expression shows that , after having introduced another measure of nitrous air , the space occupied was two measures + 10 parts .
The reason and particulars of this method will be given hereafter in a paper expressly written upon the method of determining the degree of the salubrity of the air by means of nitrous and inflammable air .
Having introduced eight cubic inches of common air into the same bladder , I breathed it as long as I could ; beginning after a natural expiration as in the experiment above related .
I breathed it thirty-four times successively , and afterwards found it very much altered , so that it extinguished a light many times successively .
An animal introduced into a vessel of that air immediately gave signs of uneasiness : and the air being tried with the nitrous air gave II + 20 , III + 15 ; whereas , before it had been breathed , it gave with the same nitrous air II 15 , II + 18 .
This experiment shows , that the air which remained in the bladder in the first experiment was not so good as that breathed thirty-four times successively .
In order to make this experiment with more precision , I breathed eighty cubic inches of common air , introduced into the same bladder , only eleven times ; beginning after a natural expiration .
Then I examined this air with the nitrous air , and found that it gave II 13 , III + 28 .
Hence it is plain , that the mixture of inflammable and pulmonary air breathed eleven times is much inferior to common air breathed an equal number of times ; so that there can remain no doubt but that inflammable air is at least worse than common air .
Willing , however , to ascertain this matter still better , I tried to breathe it immediately through a large receiver , partly immersed in water , and swimming in it , so that the air within the receiver was of the same elasticity with the external air .
For this experiment I made use also of a glass tube bended in two different directions .
The air contained in the receiver was about 250 cubic inches .
In all the trials made in this manner , I was never able to breathe the inflammable air more than three times , and even at the second inspiration I felt a great oppression .
As these experiments can be depended upon , because they were often and at different times repeated , there seems to be reason enough to suspect , that the bladder might possibly alter the nature of inflammable air , and render it more fit for respiration , notwithstanding that the mere contact of the bladder seemed not sufficient to produce such an effect , which is irreconcilable with other facts : yet some reason must certainly exist sufficient to explain Mr. SHEELE'S experiments , which directly prove that the inflammable air contained in bladders can be breathed with impunity .
When I breathed this air according to Mr. SHEELE'S manner eleven times successively , I not only breathed it without any inconvenience , but observed that the first inspirations were even pleasing ; more so than when I breathed common air .
I felt a facility of dilating the breast , as if the air was as light as that at the top of high mountains .
I never felt a like sensation , even when I have breathed the purest dephlogisticated air .
I do not think that I was mistaken in these sensations , or gave a loose to imagination , because I was rather prejudiced against the inflammable air , after I had seen various animals immediately die in it , and I was rather fearful when I first began to breathe it : besides , this facility of breathing it , accompanied with a pleasing sensation , I have constantly observed in all my experiments upon this subject .
This pleasure , however , I paid very dear for in another experiment , in which I was near losing my life .
Having filled a bladder of the largest sort with about 350 cubic inches of inflammable air extracted from iron filings through water , which air was not at all diminished by the mixture of nitrous air ; I began to breathe it boldly ( owing to the encouragement received from the above related experiment ) , and resolved to breathe it as long as my strength would permit me , after having made a very violent expiration in order to evacuate the lungs of the atmospheric air .
Having made the first inspiration I felt a great oppression upon my lungs .
Towards the middle of the second inspiration I heard Mr. CAVALLO , who favoured me with his assistance in these experiments , say , that I was become very pale : by this time the objects appeared confused to my eyes .
Notwithstanding this , I made the third inspiration ; but now my strength failing , I lost my sight entirely , and fell upon my knees .
In this situation I breathed the air of the room , but my knees not being able to support me , I fell entirely upon the floor .
However , in a short time I came to myself , so as to be able to get up , &amp;c. ; but my respiration continued to be affected with difficulty and pain , as if I had a great weight upon the breast ; nor did I perfectly recover before the next day .
It must be observed , that during this experiment I kept my nose close stopped .
This same inflammable air contained in the bladder , which I had breathed three times , was examined in various manners , and was found to be as inflammable as before ; it exploded as usual , when mixed with dephlogisticated air , but after having been shaken in water for a short time , being tried with the nitrous air , it gave III 10 , IV 10 , whereas before it was not at all diminished .
At this time the common air , with the same nitrous air , gave II 14 , II + 10 .
Hence it appears , that the inflammable air , after being breathed , is rather better than before , because in that case it is a little diminished by the addition of nitrous air .
In order to ascertain whether this alteration was occasioned by the bladder or no , I made the following experiment , which , having been often repeated , was constantly attended with the same event .
I introduced into a bladder , which was sometimes moist and sometimes dry , a quantity of inflammable air , extracted as well from zinc as from iron , through water , and having kept it in that situation for some minutes , beating in the mean while the bladder , to keep the air in agitation , I afterwards took it out , and by the mixture of nitrous air ob3 served served , that it suffered no diminution , exactly as it suffered none before it had been put into the bladder .
Having ascertained , in this manner , that the bladders do not in any manner contribute to render the inflammable air extracted from metals better in its nature , there remained no other way of ascertaining Mr. SHEELE'S experiments , and of understanding why I had been able to breathe it eleven times , than by supposing that the air of the lungs , which can never be thoroughly emptied by being mixed with the inflammable air , alters it , &amp;c. It is well known , that in an ordinary expiration about thirtyfive cubic inches of air are expelled from the lungs .
In a very violent expiration , following a natural inspiration , the air expelled may amount to sixty cubic inches .
These forty inches of pulmonary air are mixed with the inflammable air , and are expelled from the lungs in proportion to the remaining air that is breathed after that the lungs have been thoroughly emptied .
In the expement above related , of the three inspirations I made into the inflammable air , it may be easily supposed , that twenty inches or more of pulmonary air were joined with the inflammable air , and entered into the bladder .
This pulmonary air , although it is itself partly phlogisticated , is however diminished by nitrous air ; and when it stands in the bladder it is nearly equal to 1/ 17th of the inflammable air of the bladder breathed three times ; hence this lost ten parts by the mixture of nitrous air .
This explanation , which it is necessary to adopt after having exploded all the other hypotheses , is very analogous to the above related experiment of the smaller bladder filled with inflammable air which was breathed eleven times successively .
This air was breathed after a natural expiration , so that there still remained in the lungs about seventy-five inches of common air .
These seventy-five inches of pulmonary air , together with the eighty inches of inflammable air , were mixed together during the eleven inspirations and expirations ; hence the air of the bladder was a mixture of nearly equal portions of inflammable and common air ; and , accordingly , when tried with the nitrous air , it was found to be much better ( though it had been breathed eleven times ) than the air of the large bladder breathed three times only , after the lungs had been emptied as much as possible .
All the other experiments that I have made in confirmation of this hypothesis seem universally to favour it .
If a Guinea pig is introduced into a receiver containing 400 cubic inches of inflammable air , or a small bird into only fifty inches of it , and they be left therein till they are dead , that air afterwards will not be sensibly diminished nished by nitrous air ; but if a much larger animal is introduced into the 400 inches of inflammable air , or a small animal into a few cubic inches of that air , then it will be found to be sensibly diminished by nitrous air ; and this diminution will be greater as the animal is larger in proportion to the quantity of inflammable air .
A larger animal imparts a greater quantity of its pulmonary air to the inflammable air ; and the inflammable air will be found joined to a quantity of pulmonary air , which is so much the less as the animal is smaller .
Mr. SHEELE says , he found that the inflammable air after being breathed some time entirely loses its inflammability ; from whence he concludes , that the lungs , instead of imparting some phlogiston to , imbibe it from , whatever substance it can be extracted .
Though all the direct experiments which show that a phlogistic principle is continually detached from the lungs , and joins itself to the common air , were wanting , still Mr. SHEELE'S consequence could not be drawn , because the experiment is not true .
With respect to my own experience I may safely say , that I have always found it inflammable in every circumstance , even after I had breathed it eleven times successively : and I have not only found it inflammable in the bladder , but I have fired it in the act of letA aa2 ting ting it out of my mouth .
In this manner a flame may be produced from the mouth , of various inches in length , and two or more inches in breadth .
But whence does that sensation of levity and facility of breathing the inflammable air , which I have described above , originate ?
At present I can only have recourse to a mere mechanical cause for a solution , for I do not observe in inflammable air any property that seems capable of altering the lungs upon a chemical principle ; neither have I observed any decomposition of air , or alteration of the fluids of the animal .
It has been observed , that inflammable air , after being breathed , comes out of the lungs with the same properties it had before .
It is also known , that inflammable air is not sensibly absorbed by water , at least after a short time .
The lungs , or more properly the pulmonary vesicles , are continually moistened with fluids ; but that air cannot be absorbed by them , except it be first decomposed .
Nothing else therefore remains to which we can have recourse for an explanation of the above mentioned sensations , but the well known levity of the inflammable air compared with common air .
And indeed the sensation I felt when I breathed that air , is like that of a very light fluid which does not oppress the lungs , and is hardly felt .
This explanation agrees exactly with some experiments I have made with common air rendered more light by fire .
This air I have found may be breathed much easier , although not for so long a time , as when it is more condensed .
It must be said , indeed , that this is occasioned by another particular cause , which has nothing to do with the case of the inflammable air , and which cannot be properly examined in this place .
After all , it still remains to be known , why inflammable air , which kills animals so soon , may be breathed without any oppression , when in a small quantity , viz. when it is mixed with common air ; and the following experiments , which are very analogous to those related above , will show that the question is not uninteresting .
I introduced 350 cubic inches of common air into a bladder , and after having made as strong an expiration as I could , I applied the neck of the bladder to my mouth , and breathed the air it contained forty times successively .
Afterwards , having taken the air out of the bladder , I found that it extinguished a light several times successively .
It formed various crystals with the oil of tartar , but after a very considerable time ; some of these crystals had the shape of needles , others were like flowers : being tried with the nitrous air , it gave II 18 , III + 18 .
This air , therefore , was very much phlogisticated , nor could I possibly have breathed it longer than I did , without out falling upon the ground , as I already felt my strength failing , and the objects appeared confused before my eyes .
Into ten cubic inches of this air I introduced a small bird , which , as soon as it began to breathe it , made various contorsions with its body , and seemed to suffer a great deal .
It died in ten minutes time ; whereas another little bird introduced into a like quantity , that is , into ten cubic inches of common air , lived in it fiftytwo minutes , nor did it show any sign of uneasiness before it had been in five minutes .
It remains to be accounted for , why the bird could breathe for five minutes longer in the air of the bladder than a man could .
It will be sufficient to consider , that when a man in this experiment has made the last expiration into the bladder , he is in a state of pain , and his lungs are loaden with a superfluous quantity of phlogiston , which is not communicated to the air of the bladder ; whereas nothing of this takes place with the bird , which , besides its being in vigour , has a quantity of common air in its lungs .
This seems confirmed by an experiment , which admits of no doubt .
Having breathed the air of the bladder as long as I could , I stopped the neck of the bladder with my finger , then breathed the common air several times ; and afterwards putting the neck of the same bladder to my mouth again , I breathed that very same air four times successively .
Now there is no doubt but that a bird could have breathed it much longer : the reason of which diversity seems to be the following , viz that a small bird is in want of a small quantity of air for every time it breathes , whereas a man is in want of a much greater quantity ; hence the air is rendered more easily noxious , and unfit for respiration .
From all which it may be concluded , that we are in want of a certain quantity of common air necessary for respiration , and for the support of life ; and that this air , after being inspired , comes out of the lungs less fit to be breathed a second time .
It has been observed , that the inflammable air cannot be breathed when the lungs are emptied of common air as much as possible ; but that it may be breathed when the lungs are in a natural state , in which state a quantity of common air , equal to about forty cubic inches , is known to exist in the lungs of an adult person .
This pulmonary air is not infected so far as to be incapable of being breathed various times , and of supporting life .
After having made a natural expiration I have with force expelled from my lungs about thirty inches of air into an empty bladder ; and this pulmonary air I have generally been able to breathe eight times successively , but never longer .
It is true , however , that I breathed it with some oppression , even from the beginning , which does not happen when the inflammable air contained in a bladder is breathed , the lungs being in a natural state .
And now it seems no longer difficult to give an answer to the question proposed above , and to account for the small difference observed in the breathing of the two different kinds of air in the bladders .
The inflammable air , when joined to a great quantity of common air , may be breathed safely , because there is a quantity of common air sufficient for various inspirations , and that the mixture of the two airs may be breathed till this common air is thoroughly infected .
But the inflammable air itself is not altered nor decomposed by the respiration .
Wherefore we must conclude , that the inflammable air is not such a kind of air as can by itself alone be directly useful for respiration .
It must rather be considered as if there was nothing of that air in the case of the bladder ; and indeed it is found by experience , that the pulmonary air itself may be breathed eight or nine times in an empty bladder .
The not being able to breathe it eleven times successively , as was done when there was inflammable air in the bladder , and the feeling an oppression in the first case and not in the second , must be entirely attributed to the want of thirty-five cubic inches of air expirated , which are necessary to give the lungs all the necessary expansion ; whereas , in the other case , the inflammable air serves to fill up space , and , together with the common air , contributes to fill the lungs ; so that the inflammable air , considered under these circumstances , and under this point of view , may be said to be useful for animal respiration .
This explanation seems most evidently demonstrated by the following experiment .
If thirty-five cubic inches of common air are introduced into the bladder , and this air be breathed when the lungs are in a natural state , it will be found , that one may breathe it for twenty times or longer ; whereas , when the bladder was empty , it could not be breathed more than nine times at most .
Before I finish this paper it will be proper to mention another cause , which , perhaps , also contributes to render the inflammable air of the bladder less noxious : this is the levity of the inflammable air itself with respect to common air , which hinders the inflammable mixing with the common air .
The inflammable air swims continually upon the common air , just as aether swims upon water ; and the inflammable air swims still better than aether , because it is much lighter in comparison than aether .
Various experiments made upon volatile substances have convinced me of this truth .
If equal quanV O L. LXIX .
Bbb tities cated of common and inflammable air , or dephlogisticated and inflammable air , are put into a tube , and two birds are introduced in it , so that one of them may stand at the top , and the other at the lower part of the inverted jar ; it will be found , that the first mentioned of these birds not only will die considerably sooner than the other , but will show signs of uneasiness as soon as it is come to that place .
The inflammable air , therefore , when breathed together with a considerable quantity of common air , must always swim at the top of it , filling the cavity of the wind-pipe , &amp;c. while the common air occupies the lower place , and filling the smallest pulmonary vesicles is subservient to the ordinary functions of the lungs .
Here I put an end to my observations upon inflammable air considered with respect to respiration ; but I beg leave to add a few words respecting a property of the inflammable air , which , as far as I know , has been overlooked by the most diligent observers .
I mean here to speak of such inflammable air as is extracted from metals , by means of oil of vitriol , especially that extracted from iron and zinc .
The air of these metals when presented to the flame of a candle , not only burns with a whitish flame inclining to green ( as is well known ) ; but exhibits a kind of sparks or explosions which may be easily distinguished between the body of the flame by their vivid light .
These sparks , which are of a vivid colour , dart in every direction .
They might be easily taken for those sparks that are emitted from red-hot iron ; or they might be compared to very small grains of gunpowder , if these were inflamed successively , and without smoke ; or they might even be compared to charcoal that sparkles , but without any noise .
This phenomenon seems very interesting , as it respects the nature of the inflammable air itself .
What seems to me most singular is , that this appearance forms a distinctive character between the inflammable air of metals , and that extracted from animal or vegetable substances ; at least I may safely say , that I never found the inflammable air of animal or vegetable substances sparkle like that extracted from metals .
In several of the former kinds of air I could observe no sparkling at all ; in others the sparks were so few that they might be considered as nothing in comparison to the sparkling of the inflammable air from metals .
The inflammable air of metals itself , if left in contact with water for a long time , or shook in it till it becomes less inflammable , will in great measure lose its sparkling property , and at last loses it entirely , when it is become in a state of being hardly inflammable .
I have observed , that the inflammable air is the more difficult to be decomposed , by being shaken in water , as the number of the sparks it shows when burning is greater ; and according to this number of sparks , the inflammable air makes greater or weaker explosions when mixed with the dephlogisticated air ; so that it seems proved by expements , that the phlogistic principle is more fixed and in greater quantity combined with the inflammable air of metals , than with that of vegetable or animal substances .
I do not mean to deny the possibility of finding other species of inflammable air extracted from other substances besides metals which may explode like that extracted from metals ; but I only say , that in those cases the inflammable air will also sparkle more , and will be found less easy to be decomposed by water .
There are other substances that give the inflammable air in great quantity , and which cannot be considered as animal or vegetable substances , but come rather near the nature of metals ; as , for instance , the spathose iron , from which I extract a good deal of inflammable air by the action of fire only , applied to a mattress .
But the metal in this substance is not in its pure state , and it may be considered rather as a calx of iron than true iron .
Accordingly , this air can hardly sparkle at all ; it explodes more like the inflammable air of vegetable or animal bodies than that of metals , and it is easily decomposed in water .
This property of inflammable air of metals which I have discovered , throws great light upon the analysis of the decomposition of that air which I have made in two different ways .
The first is to fire it together with common or dephlogisticated air , in vessels filled with very pure quicksilver , and also in vessels filled with distilled water .
The second method is to decompose it by shaking it in pure distilled water .
In the first process a great number of experiments are required in order to obtain a sensible residuum ; besides , the igneous part is lost .
The second method requires an exceedingly long time , but it is the most complete ; for which reason I have used it for the decomposition of other kinds of air .

