XIV .
Account of the Organs of Speech of the Orang ~ .
Outang .
By Peter Camper , M. D. late Professor of Anatomy , &amp;c. in the University of Groningen , and F. R. S. in a Letter to Sir John Pringle , F. R. S. Read January 7 , 1779 .
SIR , BEING lately informed by Dr. POEMMERING , whom on account of his singular industry and talents I have recommended to your favour , that you , as well as l'Abbe FONTANA and Dr. INGENHOUSZ , were surprised to hear from M. FEBRONI , the keeper of the Duke of Tuscany 's Museum , that I had discovered the true organical reason for which the Orang Outang , and several other apes and monkies , are unable to speak ; I take the liberty of addressing to you this anatomical essay upon the organ of speech of the Orang Outang and other monkies , in hopes you will judge it worthy to be read to the Royal Society ; in whose most valuable Transactions I should be very proud to see these observations ; the rather , as it is the first essay I have offered to that respectable body .
Klein-Lankum , near Franequer , Dec. 2 , 1778 .
It is this discovery ( of which I have already given a hint at the end of my Observations on the Rein-Deer ) which Professor ALLAMAND has inserted amongst his additions to the XVth volume of the Count DE BUFFON'S Not .
Hist. printed at Amsterdam 1771 , for S. H. SCHNEIDER , p. 55 , 56 .
Professor ALLAMAND has moreover added , in the same volume , p. 76 : M. le Prof. CAMPER a observe les organes de la voix de l'Orang ; il s'est convaincu qu'il etoit impossible , qu'il format des tons articules , comme les hommes en peuvent former , &amp;c. It is asserted by a great many travellers , that though the Orang Outang does not speak , he would be able to articulate if he chose it .
Several Naturalists seem to leave this question undetermined , from not having had the opportunity of dissecting this very uncommon animal ; others again overlook it , being deeply engaged in the researches of other parts .
My principal study in this essay will be to prove the absolute impossibility there is for the Orang and other monkies to speak .
~ 1 .
Being Professor of Natural Philosophy , Anatomy , Surgery , and Physic , in the University of Franeker in Friesland , I soon perceived the impossibility of understanding the most precious and valuable works of the immortal GALEN ( especially his anatomical works ) without dissecting monkies , to compare his exact descriptions with .
I got for that purpose , in the year 1754 , a Cynocephalus , and was charmed to find the exactness of almost all GALEN'S descriptions .
The organ of speech puzzled me , nevertheless , very much , and I was not able to explain his observations , so as to satisfy myself in this animal : I was obliged , therefore , for want of other apes , to delay my researches to another opportunity , which , however , I did not meet with till I came to Amsterdam , where I settled in the year 1755 .
I discovered , at the beginning of 1757 , in another Cynocephalus , that the basis of the os hyoides was very large and hollow ; and that a membranous bag , lying under the latissimi colli ( which touch one another in the middle of the neck in these animals ) went up into this bony cavity , having a communication with the inside of the larynx by a hole at the root of the epiglottis .
The structure of these and the Orang will be better understood by the four figures engraved after my own drawings for the anatomy of the Orang .
I intend to publish them with that of the Rhinoceros with the double horn , and the Rein-Deer .
In the Cynocephalus I found the whole organ of voice pretty much like that of dogs , except the pouch d , n , o , i , fig. 4 .
Examining the root of the epiglottis I found a hole i , p , fig. 3 .
being the real orifice of the bag d , i , o , n , fig. 4 .
As all this lies above the rima glottidis i , fig. 3 .
or i , h , fig. 4 .
I concluded , that the voice , having passed the glottis , entered this membranous bag , d , n , o , i , by which the neck swelled , and out of which the air was forced by the contraction of the latissimi colli .
I had often observed this swelling in some living apes , but now found out the reason of it , and was persuaded of the incapacity of this animal to modulate his voice so as to articulate words .
I then considered this remarkable passage of GALEN'S , de Usu Part .
Ed. Charter .
tom .
IV .
lib. 7 .
cap. XI .
p. 461 .
Foramen in utraque lingulae ( epiglottidis ) part unum effecit natura , et foramini ipsi part interna ventriculum supposuit non parvum .
In quem quum aer vias nactus amplas in animal ingreditur , rursusque exit , nihil in ventrem depellitur ; and what he , p. 466 .
further observes , fissuram potius , quam foramen esse .
When I compared this with the organ in the Cynocephali , fig. 3 , 4 .
I was at a loss how to explain GALEN ; for I could by no means apply those ventriculi , by which he seemed to have understood large capacities , to the small holes h , i , k , fig. 4 .
above the rima glottidis i , h , which , though much larger in the Cynocephali than in men , could not be applied to this very particular definition of no small bags , ventriculum non parvum .
In November 1758 I dissected another monkey , in which the membranous bag , d , n , o , was much larger , so as to occupy almost the whole fore part of the neck , under the latissimi colli .
In the Apella ( the 29th species of LINNAEUS , Syst. Not .
ed. XII .
p. 42 .
or simia caudata imberbis , cauda subprehensili , corpore fusco , pedibus nigris ) was no such a bag at all , nor any opening at the root of the epiglottis , which was entirely similar to that of dogs .
I cannot forbear to mention , that in this monkey the meatus , or the processus peritonaei , were closed as in men .
This I dissected in the year 1768 , when I was Professor in the University of Groningen .
Here I got the opportunity , the year following , of dissecting two papiones or sphinges of LINNAEUS , simiae semi caudatae ore vibrissato unguibus acuminatis , spec .
6 .
p. 35 .
a male and a female ; in which the epiglottis was likewise perforated , the os hyoides as in the former , but the pouch very small in comparison of the apes , who were very large .
As these parts are so apparent in a great many monkies , and likewise in the ape or Pithecos , I was very much surprised EUSTACHIUS did not discover them , especially as he had taken great pains to pursue the anatomical doctrine of GALEN , as appears in the XLIst plate , where he has given several figures of this organ .
I was no less surprised that ALBINUS and MARTINS did not find this bag ; and I wondered likewise very much , how Mr. D'AUBENTON , who has had the greatest opportunity of any anatomist , could pass over so striking a construction of this organ .
I do not mention RIOLANUS , FALLOPIUS , GORTER , SYLVIUS , BLASIUS , and some others , because they had fixed their attention upon quite different parts .
~ .
2 .
As GALEN not only dissected the Cebi , or the Cynocephalus , who are all of the tailed or caudati kind , but the Pithecos or ape without a tail ; and as the celebrated Dr. TYSON had found the organ of voice so similar to that of men in his Pigmy , I endeavoured to get one from the East Indies .
For this purpose I offered a good sum of money to my correspondents to have a wellpreserved Orang Outang , because none were to be met with in any collection of Natural History in Holland .
I soon got a female one in the year 1770 , by the kindness and generosity of Dr. HOFFMAN , physician at Batavia , formerly my pupil ; and the year 1771 another , by favour of Mr. HOPE , Director of the East India Company of Amsterdam , and Representative of his Most Serene Highness the Prince of Orange in the same Company , who was so good as to order not only a female , but a male one for my use ; but this last was unluckily lost , with the whole ship , betwixt Java and the Cape of Good Hope .
These and the succeeding years were very favourable to Naturalists ; for Professor ALLAMAND got a male Orang for the Museum of the University of Leyden ; Mr. VANDER MEULEN , a great admirer of natural history ( who has one of the finest collections at Amsterdam ) received one , and Mr. VOSMAER got two for the celebrated collection of the Prince of Orange , all females .
In the year 1777 , Dr. VAN HOEY ( a physician of great celebrity at the Hague , who has a very rich collection of natural curiosities ) got a male ( but a very young ) Orang .
Upon the whole , I had an opportunity of seeing seven Orangs , besides the living one , which was sent to his Highness the Prince of Orange .
All these resembled perfectly in shape and colour that of Mr. EDWARDS , which is still preserved in the British Museum .
Seven of those , I had seen , had no nails upon the great toes of the feet : it surprised me , therefore , to see them so distinctly represented by Professor ALLAMAND .
I took the liberty to inform him of it ; he corrected his description accordingly , p. 75 .
ib. in fine , which was easily done , as the sheets were not worked off at the press .
I wrote likewise to Dr. KOOYSTRA , physician to the London Infirmary , to inquire about the Orang in the British Museum .
The late Dr. MATY examined , at my request , the Orang with him ; and both declared , that not a single mark of a nail was to be found upon the large toes of that specimen , though Mr. EDWARDS had represented them on his 213th table so very large .
These two instances show us , how little we can depend upon figures , if not drawn with great exactness .
The want of these nails , and of the second phalanx of the large toes , is beyond any doubt a very remarkable character in this animal .
Nature , however , seems to be inconstant sometimes ; for , upon the great toe of the right foot of the Orang in Dr. VAN HOEY'S collection , there was a little nail and two phalanges .
The singular red , long hair , and the shortness of the neck , form another very peculiar property ; for in the living , as well as in all the rest , I have observed the shoulders to rise up to the ears ; the lower and upper jaws were much projected forwards , as I shall show in the anatomical description of the Orang .
The country they all came from was Borneo , from which island they are first sent over to Java , and so to Holland by the Cape of Good Hope .
The Orang Outangs described by TULPIUS and TYSON came from Angola , and had both black hair , and large nails upon the great toes .
I own the figures of these great men are very deficient in many respects : but , upon the whole , the animals are represented and described as very strong and muscular ; whereas all the Orangs from Borneo , I have seen , were the contrary , and had long and very lean arms and legs .
To conclude , it seems very probable , that Africa furnishes a peculiar sort of apes which are not the Pithecos of the ancients , though these are not uncommon in Angola .
The organs of voice of the Angolese Orang , dissected by TYSON , are very different from those of the Pithecos which I dissected 1777 .
This one had the os hyoides like all the papiones or sphinges , &amp;c. ; the epiglottis perforated as in fig. 3 .
and 4 .
and therefore different from GALEN'S description , and from TYSON'S , who makes no mention at all of the one , nor of the two bags which GALEN describes , and which I found in the real Orang of Borneo ; not only in one specimen , but in five , which I have dissected for that purpose .
To return to GALEN ; I am very apt to think that he dissected an Asiatic Orang , from whom he took his description of the ventricles a latere lingulae , at the sides of the epiglottis ; at least that he dissected such an organ , for the bones of the carpus do not entirely agree with his description , though he seems to have been very exact and nice in his dissections .
And indeed I wondered as often as I compared the structure of the carpus and tarsus of apes , monkies , and dogs , with GALEN'S osteological performances upon this subject : for though he describes but eight bones in the carpus , he mentions the ninth , which I have met with in all monkies , apes , and dogs , and likewise in the Orang .
The tenth is not easily seen , it being very much attached to the os naviculare .
These bones I shall give the explanation of in the anatomical description of the Orang .
In the Angolese Orang , Dr. TYSON met with the vermicular process of the intest .
coecum , which I found very considerable in the Asiatic ; but of which GALEN appears not to have had the least notion .
Mr. D'AUBENTON has given the description and figure of the same little gut in the Gibbon , a species approaching to that of the Orang , and likewise an inhabitant of Asia , but also unknown to GALEN .
~ 3 .
I shall now proceed to the organ of speech itself , and describe it as it appeared in the first Orang I dissected in October 1770 .
And for the clearer understanding I shall add some figures to it ; first , of the fore-part ; secondly , of the larynx from the inside of the pharynx ; and , lastly , of the inside of the larynx itself .
Fig. 2 .
N , O , P , represents the os hyoides ; N , O , the basis ; ~ the left cornu ; N , O , the little graniform bones .
Q , T , U , the thyroid cartilage ; V the aspera arteria .
Z , X the right ventricle cut open ; R , S the left .
Y the hole leading into the bag .
The ventricles form here a kind of meatus , passing over the brim of the thyroid cartilage , under the os hyoides , towards the inside , where they form the fissures a , b , and a , i , fig. 5 .
I dissected this in the Anatomical Theatre of the University at Groningen in public .
In a second , which Mr. VOSMAER , the keeper of the Prince of Orange 's cabinet , was so kind as to grant me for dissection , I found both these ventricles the same in every respect as the others , except that these last were of equal size .
In the third , which I dissected at the house of Dr. VAN HOEY at the Hague , the 31 st of August , 1777 , the two ventricles were smaller but of equal size on both sides .
The animal was very young .
The doctor preserves this preparation in his museum .
In a fourth , which I preserve entire in my collection , but whose organ of voice I examined the 30th of No. vember last , I found both the ventricles united so as to form but one .
The 6th figure gives a sketch of it ; a , c , d , e , f , g , h , b , is the ventricle , having , nevertheless , the two meatus 's a and b , and showing evidently a kind of division in i ; g , h , making a smaller bag .
This bag descended downwards to the middle of the breast bone , and spread itself sidewards over the sternomasloideus , with appendices underneath the cucullares .
The latissimi colli adhered very much to the fore-part , but sidewards ; and under , from the muscles of the neck , they were easily separated by tearing gently , either with the top of the finger , or with the flat part of the handle of a dissecting knife .
As this Orang was much larger than the former ones , and consequently older , I dare not venture to determine , whether these ventricles or bags , which touch each other in the middle , grow together , so as to make but one bladder ; or whether this may be a variety : because in the Orang which was alive at the Hague , and the history of which I shall give by and by , there was likewise but one bag still larger than these , and proceeding far over the clavicles , backwards under the cucullares , and before down two-thirds of the breast bone .
This accidental union can probably make no essential variety ; for as these receptacles of air do not seem to serve for any modulation of voice , they will answer their proper purpose , whether united into one , or divided into two cavities .
We very often see the kidnies united at the lower ends across the spine in men , without its occasioning any disturbance in the secretion or animal economy .
~ 4 .
I must now give the history of the so much celebrated Orang which belonged to the Prince of Orange , and died in January 1777 .
This was a female ; when alive the head was always deep in the shoulders , and the animal seldom lifted it very high up .
The man who took care of her observed a great quantity of air under the skin of the neck on both sides , which ( being ignorant of these ventricles ) he took for a dangerous disorder , and the symptoms of approaching death .
I felt the neck myself in December 1776 , and discovered the bags to be much larger than any I had dissected .
I could remove the air easily with my hand from one side to the other , and divide it , as it were , into two parts .
The bags appeared sometimes very turgid , sometimes collapsed .
She died not long afterwards , and was soon cut to pieces by the order of Mr. VOSMAER , to be stuffed for the Museum of his Serene Highness the Prince of Orange ; but , as this cannot be done without preserving the face , a part of the skull , hands , and feet , it is very evident , that Mr. VOSMAER was obliged to cut off the head and the other extremities , and to destroy the most interesting parts for natural knowledge .
I was very sorry to hear the fate of this curious and uncommon creature , more especially as I had great reason to flatter myself with the dissection of the entire animal as soon as it was dead .
I need not remind any one of the particulars mentioned by Mr. FORSTER in the 2d volume of a Voyage round the World , p. 553 .
; nor of his rather too severe criticism upon the conduct of Mr. VOSMAER , the inspector of the Museum belonging to the hereditary Stadholder of the United Provinces .
Mr. VOSMAER had , without doubt , no onther intention but to preserve the fresh skin of this uncommon animal stuffed , for the cabinet of his benefactor , and not the least malevolent intention to prevent the dissection of the other parts not necessary for this purpose : for , when , by a special order of his Most Serene Highness the Prince of Orange , the remaining trunk was sent to me , I found the organ of voice not in the least hurt , and quite entire , as it is still to my great satisfaction .
After having duly examined , dissected , and delineated the viscera of the breast and belly , I have put it in molasses , in a fine phial , in order to preserve so valuable a preparation , not only for my museum , but for natural knowledge in general .
There was no difference betwixt this organ and that I delineated in the 6th figure , but in extent .
The united ventricles covered the greatest part of the breast bone , and had several appendices , which insinuated themselves into all the interstices of the muscles of the neck and shoulders .
It had likewise two distinct meatus 's coming from the inside of the organ at the sides of the epiglottis , as in fig. 5 .
and passing between the os hyoides and thyroid cartilage .
A large and vermicular process was attached to the caecum ; but the intestines were very different on the inside from those of men .
The os femoris was kept in its socket only by a strong capsular ligament , there being no ligamentum teres .
I had not observed one in the Orang which I preserve , and whose feet I dissected , to compare them with GALEN and others .
~ 5 .
Having given the structure of the organ of voice in five different Orangs , and demonstrated their conformity in every other respect but the union I mentioned in some , I shall proceed now to the internal part of the organ , as it is described by GALEN .
Fig. 5 .
shows the inside of the organ , which is represented in fig. 2 .
consequently of the same Orang .
d , e , f , is the epiglottis or lingula .
g , h , k , l , the cricoid cartilage , divided in the middle , and expanded sidewards .
b , d , h , and g , i , f , the arytenoid cartilages .
i , a , and a , b , the holes or fissures at each side of the epiglottis ; b and i , the cords which form the rima glottidis .
All this answers exactly to the description given by GALEN .
The air which is forced by expiration out of the lungs , and passes with an accelerated velocity the rima glottidis , b , i , being stopped by the hollow epiglottis and the roof of the mouth , narrow nostrils , &amp;c. rushes into these ventricles Z , X and Q , R , S fig. 2 .
or into the united large ventricle a , b , d , e , f , g , fig. 6 .
These are , as GALEN rightly observes , seemingly within the animal ; for they are covered with the external integuments and the latissimi colli .
From thence , or out of these ventricles , the air gets out again by the same fissures a , i , a , b , fig. 5 .
through the mouth and nostrils , without entering into the lungs again , or , as he expresses it , without entering into the belly of the animal , rursusque exit , nihil in ventrem depellitur ; by venter is to be understood the inside of the body .
If this organ does not answer entirely to the description of GALEN , I do not know how to explain the quotation ; for there is no animal , as yet known , whose organ of speech is more applicable to it , at least none of the monkey kind , as I observed before .
It is hardly to be conceived , how Dr. TYSON should have overlooked all this , and have pronounced the organ of voice of his pigmy to be exactly like that of men , as he has done p. 51 .
; and yet , it is not impossible , when we consider that he has overlooked other and more striking differences in his essay .
Nor is it probable that GALEN should have overlooked the large vermicular process of the caecum and other things , if he had dissected the same kind of African Orang as TYSON did , unless he dissected the Organ of voice in the one , neglecting the intestines , and again the bones of the feet in another , as is often the case with anatomists , as I know by my own experience .
This , however , seems probable , that GALEN dissected more than one species of pithecos or apes without a tail , and that even that species was different from the Angolese pigmy and from the Orang of Borneo .
~ 6 .
Having dissected the whole organ of voice in the Orang , in apes , and several monkies , I have a right to conclude , that Orangs and apes are not made to modulate the voice like men : for the air passing by the rima glottidis is immediately lost in the ventricles or ventricle of the neck , as in apes and monkies , and must conseX 2 quently quently return from thence without any force and melody within the throat and mouth of these creatures : and this seems to me the most evident proof of the incapacity of Orangs , apes , and monkies , to utter any modulated voice , as indeed they never have been observed to do .
I have already mentioned in the anatomical description of the Rein Deer ( p. 55 .
of Mr. ALLAMAND'S addition to the XVth volume of the Count DE BUFFON ) the surprising analogy of its organ of voice with that of the Pitheci and Cercopitheci .
That of the Orang seems to have some analogy with that of frogs , whose voice , however , can be better modulated by their tongues .
I have given a description of them in the Memoirs of the Society of Rotterdam .
As I am afraid of having dwelt already too long on this subject , I shall here finish this essay ; but promise to send the Society an account of the very extraordinary organ of voice of the alouate or hurleur de Cayenne , the Simia Capucina of LINNAEUS , n. 30 .
p. 42 .
the organ and os hyoides of which , &amp;c. I dissected some time ago with all possible care and attention .
I am , &amp;c. EXPLANATIONOFTHEFIGURE S. Fig. 1 .
represents the pharynx of the Orang Ourang , from which the organs of voice , fig. 2 .
and 5 .
are delineated .
A , D , B , C , the tongue from behind .
D , B , C , M , the palatum molle , on the back part of which the uvula B , L is seen .
B , E , G , H , F , the pharynx , divided lengthways in the middle from E to G. K , M , J , the passage from the mouth into the oesophagus S , K , G , H. Within this is seen the epiglottis and the glottis shut by the arytenoid cartilages .
Fig. 2 .
is the same organ of voice from the fore-part N , O , P , the os hyoides ; N and O the little graniform bones ; P , the left cornu .
Q , T , U , the thyroid cartilage ; V the aspera arteria .
R , S , the left ventricle entire .
W the right , cur open to see the orifice of the duct Y from the bag .
Fig. 3 The back part of the tongue and the glottis of a monkey .
a , b , the epiglottis ; a , b , r , g , the root and back part of the tongue ; c , s , t , d , the oesophagus laid open .
u , the aspera arteria .
f , e , the capitella of the arytenoid cartilages .
e , the upper part or top of the little cartilage between the arytenoid cartilage and the epiglottis , which I have likewise met with in men , but less prominent .
i , f , the rima glottidis .
p , i , the hole at the root of the epiglottis .
Fig. 4 .
the inside of the larynx in profile .
a , b , c , d , the epiglottis ; e , the cartilage mentioned in fig. 3 .
f , h , the arytenoid cartilage ; f , g , the capitellums forming a kind of crooked hook .
i , m , the cord of the glottis .
i , k , h , the lateral sinus above the rima glottidis , forming a pretty large ventricle in these animals .
i , m , l , the cricoid cartilage .
d , n , o , the ventricle , into which the air , coming through the hole at the root of the epiglottis , enters .
Fig. 5 .
the same larynx , represented in fig. 1 .
opened , to see the inward parts .
a , the union of the cords forming the rima glottidis .
N BCZQP DT Y Fig:2 .
LUR Fig:1 .
M S FV EI K W X GH Fig:6 .
Fig:5 .
gr e fd ab b a gch cdib Fig:3 .
cn ~~ f ghkl m l o mn Fig:4 .
st A BC LDEM F ~:6 .
G ab HI h K c ~ g df a , b , a , i , the holes or orifices by which the air enters into the two ventricles R , S and Z , X , fig. 2 .
b , c , h , d , the right arytenoid cartilage , with its capitellum d. i , g , f , the left arytenoid cartilage .
f , e , d , the epiglottis .
g , h , k , l , the cricoid cartilage , divided and dilated .
k , m , n , l , the wind-pipe .
Fig. 6 .
the fore part of the Orang , which I preserve entire in my museum .
The skin of the neck and the latissimi colli are laid open , to show the ventricles , &amp;c. A , B , C , the lower jaw-bone ; A , D , A , E , the genio hyoides .
F , G , the cornua of the os hyoides .
H , I , the thyroid cartilage ; K , the cricoid .
L , M , the sub-maxillary glands .
a , c , d , e , f , g , h , b , the large bladder formed by the union of the two ventricles , of which i , f , is a mark .
a and b , the two meatus 's entering towards the inside of the larynx , betwixt the thyroid cartilage and the os hyoides .

